The fundamental and second harmonic of the photopic flicker electroretinogram: temporal frequency-dependent abnormalities in retinitis pigmentosa

New criteria for evaluation of electroretinogram in patients with retinitis pigmentosa

BACKGROUND

Electroretinogram (ERG) plays an essential role in the diagnosis of retinal disease. Choosing appropriate methods could extract valuable information from ERG. In this study, a new criterion based on time-frequency domain analysis was proposed to investigate the retina in retinitis pigmentosa (RP) patients.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The total number of 16 eyes from eight RP patients and 20 eyes from age-matched healthy subjects were assessed. The signals included photopic and scotopic ERGs. Continuous wavelet transform was applied to ERGs. Dominant frequencies were extracted, and the contours related to these dominant frequencies were selected. As a new criterion, the areas related to dominant frequency contours were considered a feature to differentiate the RP and normal groups. To better evaluate the proposed criterion results, the time-domain analysis characteristics of ERG were also considered.

RESULTS

The results showed an increase in implicit time and reduced amplitude in RP patients (P < 0.05). A significant decrease of dominant frequencies and increasing their occurrence time were seen in ERG of RP patients. Also, in RP patients, the third dominant frequency was disappeared from the three main frequencies observed in photopic ERGs of normal subjects. The area criterion showed a significant decrease in RP groups (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

RP can cause changes in the time and time-frequency components of the ERG. The area index could represent a new view of the characteristics of the ERG in the time-frequency domain. This criterion can help the ophthalmologist to have a better evaluation of retinal disease.

Macular Impairment in Fabry Disease: A Morpho-functional Assessment by Swept-Source OCT Angiography and Focal Electroretinography

Purpose

Fabry disease (FD) is a multiorgan X-linked condition characterized by a deficiency of the lysosomal enzyme alpha-galactosidase A, resulting in a progressive intralysosomal deposit of globotriaosylceramide. The aim of this study was to evaluate the macular ultrastructure of the vascular network using optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) and to evaluate macular function using focal electroretinography (fERG) in Fabry patients (FPs).

Methods

A total of 20 FPs (38 eyes, mean age 57 ± 2.12 SD, range of 27-80 years) and 17 healthy controls (27 eyes, mean age 45 years ± 20.50 SD, range of 24-65 years) were enrolled in the study. Color fundus photography, swept-source optical coherence tomography (SS-OCT), OCTA and fERG were performed in all subjects. The OCTA foveal avascular zone (FAZ), vasculature structure, superficial and deep retinal plexus densities (images of 4.5 × 4.5 mm) and fERG amplitudes were measured. Group differences were statistically assessed by Student's t-test and ANOVA.

Results

In the FP group, the FAZ areas of the superficial and deep plexuses were enlarged (P = 0.036, t = 2.138; P < 0.001, t = -3.889, respectively), the vessel density was increased in the superficial plexus, and the fERG amplitude was reduced (P < 0.001, t = -10.647) compared with those in healthy controls. No significant correlations were found between the structural and functional data.

Conclusions

OCTA vascular abnormalities and reduced fERG amplitudes indicate subclinical signs of microangiopathy with early retinal dysfunction in FPs. This study highlights the relevance of OCTA imaging analysis in the identification of abnormal macular vasculature as an ocular hallmark of FD.

Visual Cortical Plasticity in Retinitis Pigmentosa

Purpose

Retinitis pigmentosa is a family of genetic diseases inducing progressive photoreceptor degeneration. There is no cure for retinitis pigmentosa, but prospective therapeutic strategies are aimed at restoring or substituting retinal input. Yet, it is unclear whether the visual cortex of retinitis pigmentosa patients retains plasticity to react to the restored visual input.

Methods

To investigate short-term visual cortical plasticity in retinitis pigmentosa, we tested the effect of short-term (2 hours) monocular deprivation on sensory ocular dominance (measured with binocular rivalry) in a group of 14 patients diagnosed with retinitis pigmentosa with a central visual field sparing greater than 20° in diameter.

Results

After deprivation most patients showed a perceptual shift in ocular dominance in favor of the deprived eye (P < 0.001), as did control subjects, indicating a level of visual cortical plasticity in the normal range. The deprivation effect correlated negatively with visual acuity (r = −0.63, P = 0.015), and with the amplitude of the central 18° focal electroretinogram (r = −0.68, P = 0.015) of the deprived eye, revealing that in retinitis pigmentosa stronger visual impairment is associated with higher plasticity.

Conclusions

Our results provide a new tool to assess the ability of retinitis pigmentosa patients to adapt to altered visual inputs, and suggest that in retinitis pigmentosa the adult brain has sufficient short-term plasticity to benefit from prospective therapies.

Central Retina Functional Damage in Usher Syndrome Type 2: 22 Years of Focal Macular ERG Analysis in a Patient Population From Central and Southern Italy

Purpose

Recent studies show that patients with Usher syndrome type 2 (USH2) have abnormal cone structure and density in the central retina. This occurs in the presence of normal acuity, opening the quest for additional sensitive functional measures of central cone function in USH. We tested here whether focal macular cone electroretinogram (fERG) could be such a tool.

Methods

This retrospective study of central cone function loss was based on data from 47 patients with USH2 from the Ophthalmology Department of the Policlinico Gemelli/Catholic University in Rome. The analysis focused on the decrease of the fERG, obtained in response to a 41-Hz sinusoidal modulation of a uniform field presented to the central 18°, generated by red light-emitting diodes (LEDs) and superimposed on an equiluminant steady adapting background. fERG decrease was compared with the decrease of best-corrected visual acuity and Goldmann kinetic perimetry V4E field.

Results

fERG follow-up data document a severe and precocious loss of central cone function in USH2 patients, preceding losses in other measures of cone function. fERG is already reduced to 40% of control at the beginning of the second decade of life, and by 25 years of age, all USH2 patients have fERGs less than 30% of control values.

Conclusions

fERG represents a sensitive tool to evaluate central cone function in USH2, anticipating the decline of other central cone function measures, such as visual acuity and Goldmann perimetry.

Time and frequency components of ERG responses in retinitis pigmentosa

PURPOSE

To evaluate the effects of retinitis pigmentosa (RP) on time, frequency, and time-frequency components of Xenon flash ERG signals using Fourier and wavelet transforms.

METHODS

Xenon flash ERG was done in 18 eyes of nine RP patients and 20 normal eyes. After examining latency and amplitude, Fourier and wavelet transforms were performed using MATLAB software. Then, we extracted the mode frequency from the Fourier transform and main frequencies and their occurrence time from the wavelet transform. Finally, mean differences were analyzed using statistical tests.

RESULTS

The results indicated increased latency and reduced ERG wave amplitude, no significant inter-group difference in the average mode frequency, and significant reduction in main signal frequencies and their increased occurrence times. Also one or two of the three main frequencies had disappeared in more advanced cases.

CONCLUSION

Retinitis pigmentosa can induce changes in ERG time and time-frequency components. Impacted areas can be identified more accurately by wavelet transform and converting scales to frequencies.

Metabolic and functional changes in retinitis pigmentosa: comparing retinal vessel oximetry to full-field electroretinography, electrooculogram and multifocal electroretinography

PURPOSE

To determine a relationship between the retinal vessel saturation alterations and the residual retinal function measured by means of full-field electroretinography (full-field ERG), electrooculogram (EOG) and multifocal electroretinography (mfERG) in patients with retinitis pigmentosa (RP).

METHODS

Retinal vessel oximetry (RO), full-field ERG, EOG and mfERG were performed on 43 eyes of 22 patients suffering from RP and were compared to those of 26 eyes of 13 healthy controls. The oxygen saturation in the first and second branch retinal arterioles (A-SO2 ) and venules (V-SO2 ) was measured, and their difference (A-V SO2 ) was calculated. Full-field ERG amplitudes, EOG parameters and averaged mfERG response amplitudes (within central 3°, between 3° and 8°, 8° and 15°, 15° and 24°) were evaluated in relation to the RO measurements.

RESULTS

V-SO2 correlated negatively with the full-field ERG and EOG values, with increasing functional damage the V-SO2 was higher. The RP group was well distinguished from the controls when the RO measurements were correlated to the averaged N1 (baseline to trough), but also to the N1P1 (trough-to-peak) mfERG response amplitudes. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve of V-SO2 , compared to those of N1 and N1P1 mfERG response averages (15-24°), presented a high differential margin between RP and controls (p < 0.001), shown by an area under the ROC curve of 0.912 (95% CI: 0.840-0.984).

CONCLUSION

Retinal vessel saturation showed a significant relation to full-field ERG, EOG and mfERG. Thus, retinal vessel oximetry could potentially complement electrophysiological tests in monitoring disease progression in patients with RP.

NGF eye-drops topical administration in patients with retinitis pigmentosa, a pilot study

Background

Preclinical trials have shown beneficial effects of nerve growth factor (NGF) administration on visual function in animal models of retinitis pigmentosa (RP). The aim of this pilot study was to explore the potential efficacy of short term NGF eye drops treatment in patients affected by RP.

Methods

The trial consisted in 10 days daily administration of murine NGF as eye-drops for a total dose of 1 mg NGF/pt. Eight RP patients at an advanced stage of the disease were included in the trial. To monitor safety and potential adverse effects subjects underwent standard clinical measures and were requested to report any general or topic alterations following NGF assumption. Retinal function was assessed at baseline and after treatment by best-corrected visual acuity measurement (BCVA), macular focal electroretinogram (fERG) recording and Goldmann visual field testing.

Results

A transient tolerable local corneal irritation was the only adverse effect reported. fERG and BCVA remained within the limits determined by test–retest analysis of a large cohort of RP patients. Three patients reported a subjective feeling of improved visual performance. This was associated to a temporary enlargement of the visual field in all three patients and to improved fERG in two of the three.

Conclusions

Short-term administration of NGF eye-drops caused neither significant adverse effects nor visual function losses in the tested RP patients. A minority of patients experienced an improvement of visual performance as shown by Goldmann visual field and fERG. This study supports the safety and possible efficacy of NGF eye-drops administration in RP patients.

Trial registration: EudraCT n. 2008-004561-26

Peripapillary retinal vessel diameter correlates with mfERG alterations in retinitis pigmentosa

PURPOSE

To investigate relationship between the peripapillary retinal vessel diameter and the residual retinal function, measured by mfERG, in patients with retinitis pigmentosa (RP).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A cross-sectional study based on 23 patients with RP (43 eyes) and 20 controls (40 eyes) was performed. Retinal vessel diameters were measured using a computer-based program of the retinal vessel analyser (RVA; IMEDOS Systems UG, Jena, Germany). We evaluated the mean diameter in all four major retinal arterioles (D-A) and venules (D-V) within 1.0-1.5 optic disc diameters from the disc margin. The data were compared with the N1 amplitudes (measured from the baseline to the trough of the first negative wave), with the N1P1 amplitudes (measured from the trough of the first negative wave to the peak of the first positive wave) of the mfERG overall response and with the mfERG responses averaged in zones [zone 1 (0°-3°), zone 2 (3°-8°), zone 3 (8°-15°) and zone 4 (15°-24°)].

RESULTS

Mean (±SD) D-A and D-V were narrower in patients with RP [84.86 μm (±13.37 μm) and 103.35 μm (±13.65 μm), respectively] when compared to controls [92.81 μm (±11.49 μm) and 117.67 μm (±11.93 μm), respectively; the p-values between groups were p = 0.003 for D-A and p < 0.001 for D-V, linear mixed-effects model]. The RP group revealed clear differences compared to the controls: D-A and D-V became narrower with reduced mfERG responses. D-V correlated significantly with the overall mfERG N1 amplitudes (p = 0.013) and with N1P1 amplitudes (p = 0.016). D-V correlated with the mfERG amplitudes averaged in zones: (zone 2, 3 and 4; p ≤ 0.040) and N1P1 mfERG amplitudes (zones 1, 2, 3 and 4; p ≤ 0.013).

CONCLUSIONS

Peripapillary retinal vessel diameter is reduced in RP proportionally to functional alterations.

A new interpretation of components in the ERG signals to sine wave luminance stimuli at different temporal frequencies and contrasts

Full-field electroretinograms were recorded from five normal human subjects using white light (mean luminance: 250 cd/m2) sine wave stimuli at different frequencies and contrasts. In agreement with previous studies, we found that the amplitude of the fundamental component displayed a dip at about 12 Hz, coinciding with a maximum in the second harmonic component, indicating frequency doubling of the responses. By including measurements at different contrasts, we were able to recognize two (sine-like and transient) response components. We found that the waveform of the transient response was relatively frequency independent. An algorithm to separate the two components was developed. The interaction between these two components can explain the frequency-doubled responses around 12 Hz. The sine-like component is more linear and prominent in the low-frequency region, whereas the transient seems to be more nonlinear and prominent in the high-frequency region.

Visually evoked hemodynamical response and assessment of neurovascular coupling in the optic nerve and retina

The retina and optic nerve are both optically accessible parts of the central nervous system. They represent, therefore, highly valuable tissues for studies of the intrinsic physiological mechanism postulated more than 100 years ago by Roy and Sherrington, by which neural activity is coupled to blood flow and metabolism. This article describes a series of animal and human studies that explored the changes in hemodynamics and oxygenation in the retina and optic nerve in response to increased neural activity, as well as the mechanisms underlying these changes. It starts with a brief review of techniques used to assess changes in neural activity, hemodynamics, metabolism and tissue concentration of various potential mediators and modulators of the coupling. We then review: (a) the characteristics of the flicker-induced hemodynamical response in different regions of the eye, starting with the optic nerve, the region predominantly studied; (b) the effect of varying the stimulus parameters, such as modulation depth, frequency, luminance, color ratio, area of stimulation, site of measurement and others, on this response; (c) data on activity-induced intrinsic reflectance and functional magnetic resonance imaging signals from the optic nerve and retina. The data undeniably demonstrate that visual stimulation is a powerful modulator of retinal and optic nerve blood flow. Exploring the relationship between vasoactivity and metabolic changes on one side and corresponding neural activity changes on the other confirms the existence of a neurovascular/neurometabolic coupling in the neural tissue of the eye fundus and reveals that the mechanism underlying this coupling is complex and multi-factorial. The importance of fully exploiting the potential of the activity-induced vascular changes in the assessment of the pathophysiology of ocular diseases motivated studies aimed at identifying potential mediators and modulators of the functional hyperemia, as well as conditions susceptible to alter this physiological response. Altered hemodynamical responses to flicker were indeed observed during a number of physiological and pharmacological interventions and in a number of clinical conditions, such as essential systemic hypertension, diabetes, ocular hypertension and early open-angle glaucoma. The article concludes with a discussion of key questions that remain to be elucidated to increase our understanding of the physiology of ocular functional hyperemia and establish the importance of assessing the neurovascular coupling in the diagnosis and management of optic nerve and retinal diseases.

Remodeling of second-order neurons in the retina of rd/rd mutant mice

This is a brief review of data obtained by analyzing the morphology and the physiology of the retinas in rd/rd and normal, wt mice, aged 10-90 days. Second-order neurons of the rd/rd show abnormalities that start with the anomalous development of rod bipolar cells around P10 and culminate with the atrophy of dendrites in cone bipolar cells, mostly evident at P90. Horizontal cells remodel considerably. Cone-mediated ERGs, (recorded between 13 and 16 days of age) have reduced a-wave and b-wave amplitudes and longer b-wave latency and duration. B-wave abnormalities indicate specific postreceptoral dysfunction. Morphological and ERG changes in rd/rd retinas are consistent with substantial inner retinal remodeling associated to photoreceptor degeneration.

Analysis of photoreceptor function and inner retinal activity in juvenile X-linked retinoschisis

Thirteen retinoschisis males with genotyped XLRS1 gene mutations were examined by electroretinogram (ERG) techniques to determine photoreceptor involvement and ON-pathway and OFF-pathway sites of dysfunction. Parameters R(max) and logS determined by fitting the mathematical model of the activation phase of phototransduction to the scotopic and photopic a-wave responses, were not significantly different from normal. However, the XLRS photopic a-wave amplitudes were significantly lower than normal across all intensities, consistent with defective signaling in the OFF pathway. Long flash (150 ms) ON-OFF photopic responses showed reduced b-wave amplitude but normal d-wave amplitude, giving a reduced b/d ratio of <1.32 Hz photopic flicker ERG fundamental frequency responses showed reduced amplitude and delayed phase, consistent with abnormal signaling by both the ON- and OFF-pathway components. These results indicate that the XLRS1 protein appears not to affect photoreceptor function directly for most XLRS males, and that ERG signaling abnormalities occur in both the ON- and OFF-pathway components that originate in the proximal retina.

Targeted disruption of Müller cell metabolism induces photoreceptor dysmorphogenesis

Within the retina, the Müller cells and photoreceptors are in close physical proximity and are metabolically coupled. It is unknown, however, whether Müller cells affect photoreceptor differentiation and outer segment membrane assembly. The objective of this study was to determine whether targeted disruption of Müller cell metabolism would induce photoreceptor dysmorphogenesis. Intact isolated Xenopus laevis embryonic eyes were cultured in medium with or without Müller cell-specific inhibitors (i.e., alpha-aminoadipic acid and fluorocitrate). To assess Müller cell injury, the gross retinal morphology was examined along with immunocytochemical assessment of Müller cell-specific protein expression patterns. The steady-state levels of opsin were quantified to determine whether the Müller cell inhibitors negatively affected photoreceptor protein synthesis. Müller and photoreceptor cell ultrastructure was scrutinized and the organization of the outer segment membranes was graded. In control retinas, there was no swelling of Müller cell cytoplasm. Glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP) was undetectable, whereas glutamine synthetase was abundant. The steady-state level of opsin was high and photoreceptors elaborated properly folded outer segments. Exposure to both Müller cell-specific inhibitors induced swelling of Müller cell endfeet, cytoplasmic paling and alterations of Müller cell-specific protein expression patterns. The steady-state level of opsin in retinas exposed to alpha-aminoadipic acid was unchanged compared with control eyes, whereas, in eyes exposed to fluorocitrate, opsin levels were slightly reduced. The most significant finding was that targeted disruption of Müller cell metabolism adversely affected photoreceptor outer segment membrane assembly, causing dysmorphogenesis of nascent outer segments. These results suggest that the termination signal(s) necessary for proper outer segment folding were disrupted by targeted inhibition of Müller cells and support the hypothesis that Müller cells interact with photoreceptors through mechanisms that may regulate, at least in part, the assembly of photoreceptor outer segment membranes.