Aggression and personality: association with amino acids and monoamine metabolites

Biomarkers in aggression

Aggressive behavior exerts an enormous impact on society remaining among the main causes of worldwide premature death. Effective primary interventions, relying on predictive models of aggression that show adequate sensitivity and specificity are currently lacking. One strategy to increase the accuracy and precision of prediction would be to include biological data in the predictive models. Clearly, to be included in such models, biological markers should be reliably associated with the specific trait under study (i.e., diagnostic biomarkers). Aggression, however, is phenotypically highly heterogeneous, an element that has hindered the identification of reliable biomarkers. However, current research is trying to overcome these challenges by focusing on more homogenous aggression subtypes and/or by studying large sample size of aggressive individuals. Further advance is coming by bioinformatics approaches that are allowing the integration of inter-species biological data as well as the development of predictive algorithms able to discriminate subjects on the basis of the propensity toward aggressive behavior. In this review we first present a brief summary of the available evidence on neuroimaging of aggression. We will then treat extensively the data on genetic determinants, including those from hypothesis-free genome-wide association studies (GWAS) and candidate gene studies. Transcriptomic and neurochemical biomarkers will then be reviewed, and we will dedicate a section on the role of metabolomics in aggression. Finally, we will discuss how biomarkers can inform the development of new pharmacological tools as well as increase the efficacy of preventive strategies.

Revisiting the serotonin-aggression relation in humans: a meta-analysis

The inverse relation between serotonin and human aggression is often portrayed as "reliable," "strong," and "well established" despite decades of conflicting reports and widely recognized methodological limitations. In this systematic review and meta-analysis, we evaluate the evidence for and against the serotonin deficiency hypothesis of human aggression across 4 methods of assessing serotonin: (a) cerebrospinal fluid levels of 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid (CSF 5-HIAA), (b) acute tryptophan depletion, (c) pharmacological challenge, and (d) endocrine challenge. Results across 175 independent samples and over 6,500 total participants were heterogeneous, but, in aggregate, revealed a small, inverse correlation between serotonin functioning and aggression, anger, and hostility (r = -.12). Pharmacological challenge studies had the largest mean weighted effect size (r = -.21), and CSF 5-HIAA studies had the smallest (r = -.06). Potential methodological and demographic moderators largely failed to account for variability in study outcomes. Notable exceptions included year of publication (effect sizes tended to diminish with time) and self- versus other-reported aggression (other-reported aggression was positively correlated to serotonin functioning). We discuss 4 possible explanations for the pattern of findings: unreliable measures, ambient correlational noise, an unidentified higher order interaction, and a selective serotonergic effect. Finally, we provide 4 recommendations for bringing much needed clarity to this important area of research: acknowledge contradictory findings and avoid selective reporting practices; focus on improving the reliability and validity of serotonin and aggression measures; test for interactions involving personality and/or environmental moderators; and revise the serotonin deficiency hypothesis to account for serotonin's functional complexity.

Cerebrospinal fluid 5-hydroxyindolacetic acid correlates directly with negative affective intensity, but not affective lability, in human subjects

Centrally acting monoamines have long been thought to be associated with component traits of behavior and emotion and are potential biological mediators of psychopathology. In this study we tested the hypothesis that centrally acting monoamines would be associated with measures of affective instability (i.e. affective intensity and affective lability) in healthy and personality disordered human subjects. In total, 57 adult subjects including 19 psychiatrically healthy volunteers and 38 personality disordered individuals were assessed for affective instability with the affective intensity measure (AIM) and the Affective Lability Scale (ALS). Samples of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) were collected for assay of 5-hydroxyindoleacitic acid (5-HIAA), homovanillic acid (HVA) and 3-methoxy-4-hydroxy-phenylglycol (MHPG). CSF 5-HIAA concentration correlated directly with overall AIM score and, specifically, with the AIM Negative Intensity score, in all subjects and in personality disordered subjects. This result was not affected but the addition of aggression scores or life history of mood disorder to the model. Neither CSF HVA nor MHPG were found to uniquely correlate with either AIM or ALS measure. Higher Affective Intensity scores, Negative Intensity scores, specifically, are directly correlated with higher basal levels of CSF 5-HIAA. This relationship was independent of aggression, life history of mood disorder and general personality traits.

CSF 5-HIAA and exposure to and expression of interpersonal violence in suicide attempters

BACKGROUND

Serotonin is implicated in impaired impulse control, aggression and suicidal behaviour. Low cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) concentrations of the serotonin metabolite 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid (5-HIAA) have been found in violent suicide attempters, suicide victims and in violent offenders. CSF 5-HIAA concentrations have both genetic and environmental determinants. Childhood trauma may have an effect on central monoamine function as an adult.

AIM

The aim of this study was to assess the relationship of CSF 5-HIAA and the exposure to and the expression of violence in childhood and during adult life measured with the Karolinska Interpersonal Violence Scale (KIVS).

METHOD

42 medication free suicide attempters underwent lumbar puncture and were assessed with the Karolinska Interpersonal Violence Scale (KIVS) to assess history of childhood exposure to violence and lifetime expressed violent behaviour.

RESULTS

In women, but not in men, CSF 5-HIAA showed a significant negative correlation to exposure to violence during childhood. Furthermore, suicide attempters with low CSF 5-HIAA were more prone to commit violent acts as an adult if exposed to violence as a child compared to suicide attempters with high CSF 5-HIAA. In the non-traumatized group, CSF 5-HIAA showed a significant negative correlation to expressed violent behaviour in childhood.

CONCLUSIONS

Although central serotonergic function has important genetic determinants, exposure to childhood trauma may also affect serotonergic function. Low serotonergic function may facilitate impaired aggression control in traumatized suicide attempters.

The neurochemistry of human aggression

Various data from scientific research studies conducted over the past three decades suggest that central neurotransmitters play a key role in the modulation of aggression in all mammalian species, including humans. Specific neurotransmitter systems involved in mammalian aggression include serotonin, dopamine, norepinephrine, GABA, and neuropeptides such as vasopressin and oxytocin. Neurotransmitters not only help to execute basic behavioral components but also serve to modulate these preexisting behavioral states by amplifying or reducing their effects. This chapter reviews the currently available data to present a contemporary view of how central neurotransmitters influence the vulnerability for aggressive behavior and/or initiation of aggressive behavior in social situations. Data reviewed in this chapter include emoiric information from neurochemical, pharmaco-challenge, molecular genetic and neuroimaging studies.

Zolmitriptan and human aggression: interaction with alcohol

RATIONALE

The serotonin 1(B/D) (5-HT1(B/D)) receptor has shown potential as a target for decreasing aggression. The 5-HT1(B/D) agonist zolmitriptan's ability to reduce aggressive behavior in humans and its interaction with the well-known aggression-enhancing drug alcohol were examined.

OBJECTIVES

Our objective was to investigate zolmitriptan's potential to modify human aggression in a laboratory paradigm across a range of alcohol doses. Alcohol has been consistently associated with aggression and violence, thus we hoped to expand current understanding of alcohol's role in aggressive behavior via manipulation of the serotonin (5-HT) system.

METHODS

Eleven social drinkers, seven male, were recruited to participate in a research study lasting 3-4 weeks. Aggression was measured using the point-subtraction aggression paradigm (PSAP), a laboratory model widely used in human aggression studies. Subjects were administered 5-mg zolmitriptan and placebo capsules along with alcohol doses of 0.0, 0.4 and 0.8 g/kg in a within-subject, counterbalanced dosing design. Data were analyzed as the ratio of aggressive/monetary-earning responses, to account for possible changes in overall motor function due to alcohol.

RESULTS

There was a significant alcohol by zolmitriptan interaction on the aggressive/monetary response ratio. Specifically, compared to placebo, zolmitriptan decreased the aggressive/monetary ratio at the 0.4- and 0.8-g/kg alcohol doses.

CONCLUSIONS

A 5-mg dose of zolmitriptan effectively reduced alcohol-related aggression in an acute dosing protocol, demonstrating an interaction of 5-HT and alcohol in human aggressive behavior.

Neuroendocrine and subjective responses to pharmacological challenge with citalopram: a controlled study in male and female ecstasy/MDMA users

Despite evidence that +/-3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine (MDMA; 'ecstasy') causes persistent alterations to the serotonergic system of animals, evidence for long-term neurological effects of ecstasy/MDMA in humans remains equivocal. The current study assessed serotonin functioning of nine male and 11 female recreational ecstasy polydrug users by measuring neuroendocrine (prolactin, cortisol) responses to pharmacological challenge with the selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor citalopram, compared with nine male and five female cannabis polydrug users and 11 male and 11 female non-drug using controls. A single-blind, randomised, placebo-controlled design was used. Subjective responses, other substance use, mood, personality traits and demographic variables were measured to control for potentially confounding variables. There were no significant differences between ecstasy polydrug users, cannabis polydrug users and non-drug using controls in neuroendocrine or subjective responses to serotonergic challenge, and there were no sex by drug group interactions. There was no relationship between extent of ecstasy use and neuroendocrine functioning, alone or in combination with potential confounding variables. Subjective responses to the pharmacological challenge (nausea, tremor, dry mouth), novelty seeking and lifetime dose of alcohol were the only variables that contributed to one or more of the neuroendocrine outcome variables. These data do not support the premise that recreational ecstasy/MDMA use results in measurable impairment of serotonergic control of endocrine activity.

Sex, aggression and impulse control: an integrative account

There is evidence that the male sex and a personality style characterized by low self-control/high impulsivity and a propensity for negative emotionality increase the risk for impulsive aggressive, antisocial and criminal behavior. This article aims at identifying neurobiological factors underlying this association. It is concluded that the neurobiological correlates of impulsive aggression act through their effects on the ability to modulate impulsive expression more generally, and that sex-related differences in the neurobiological correlates of impulse control and emotion regulation mediate sex differences in direct aggression. A model is proposed that relates impulse control and its neurobiological correlates to sex differences in direct aggression.

Plasma serotonin levels in young violent offenders: Aggressive responding and personality correlates

70 young male violent offenders and 30 normal controls in Hunan, China were interviewed and assessed by the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI), Point Subtraction Aggression Paradigm (PSAP) and plasma serotonin (5-HT) level. Compared to the normal controls, the violent offenders had significantly higher plasma 5-HT levels; higher scores on the MMPI subscale Pd (P < 0.01), Pa (P < 0.05); and higher PSAP-B responding and lower PSAP-C responding (P < 0.05). There was a positive correlation between the MMPI Pd score and the PSAP B response, but no significant correlation was found between Pd score and plasma 5-HT level, or between PSAP B response and plasma 5-HT level. Our data suggest that the young violent offenders are more aggressive than the normal control. But this study did not demonstrate that the plasma 5-HT level had a correlation with the PSAP aggressive response. The relationship between the aggressiveness and impulsivity in the violent behavior needs further study.

The relation of free plasma tryptophan to anger, hostility, and aggression in a nonpatient sample of adult men and women

BACKGROUND

Dysregulation of central nervous system serotonergic (5-HT) activity is implicated in behavioral states and psychological traits associated with depression and aggression, with some studies suggesting possible gender-related differences.

PURPOSE

This study examined the relation of free plasma tryptophan (TRP) to aggression and depression in a sample of 138 nonsmoking adults recruited from the general community. It was hypothesized that TRP would be associated with anger, hostility, and aggression.

METHODS

To minimize effects of diurnal variation and menstrual cycle, fasting blood samples were collected in the morning, and, for women, during the follicular phase of the menstrual cycle. Participants were administered questionnaires following blood draw. Plasma TRP was determined by high performance liquid chromatography.

RESULTS

In women, but not men, higher levels of TRP were associated with trait hostility, propensity for anger, a tendency to express anger outwardly, and an antagonistic interpersonal style. For men and women, greater severity of depressive symptoms, anger, and the verbal expression of anger were associated with higher TRP. These associations were independent of age, body mass index, fasting albumin, and race and ethnicity.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that in women, but not men, higher plasma levels of TRP, the precursor to 5-HT, are associated with anger-hostility-aggression and that these associations are independent of various potential confounds. Implications of these observations to studies employing acute TRP depletion studies are discussed.

Links between temperamental dimensions and brain monoamines in the rat

In 27 female Wistar rats, the authors obtained composite scores on harm avoidance and novelty seeking, as well as 57 measures of monoamines and metabolites from 10 different brain regions. A multivariate regression method was used to discover associations between individual differences in temperament and neurochemistry. Harm-avoidant subjects had low levels of striatal dopamine and high levels of cortical norepinephrine and amygdaloid 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid. High novelty-seeking scores were linked to low levels of brainstem serotonin and dopamine and to low levels of 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid in amygdala and accumbens. Moreover, rats scoring high on novelty seeking had higher-than-average levels of norepinephrine in the thalamus and amygdala and of serotonin in the amygdala.

Norepinephrine function in personality disorder: plasma free MHPG correlates inversely with life history of aggression

OBJECTIVE

Clinical and pre-clinical data suggest the possibility of a facilitory role for norepinephrine (NE) in impulsive-aggressive behavior. While clinical studies have focused on putative central measures of NE activity, few studies have been published using peripheral measures. In this study, the relationship between plasma free NE metabolite, plasma free 3-methoxy-4-hydroxyphenylglycol (pMHPG), and impulsive aggression was explored in subjects with personality disorder.

METHODS

Subjects were 30 male subjects with personality disorder in whom basal plasma free MHPG concentrations were obtained. Aggression was assessed using the Life History of Aggression (LHA) assessment and the Buss-Durkee Aggression scales; impulsivity was assessed using the Barratt Impulsiveness and the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire Impulsivity scales.

RESULTS

A significant inverse correlation was found between LHA-Aggression and pMHPG in these subjects. Correlations with other behavioral measures were not statistically significant. pMHPG was significantly lower among subjects with borderline personality disorder but not significantly lower after controlling for LHA-Aggression scores.

CONCLUSION

These data suggest that pMHPG is inversely correlated with life history of aggression in subjects with personality disorder and that central and/or peripheral NE may play a role in modulating aggressive behavior in these subjects.

The neuropsychopharmacology of criminality and aggression

Although the idea that aggression has biological components is not a new one, recent research in genetics, neuropsychopharmacology, and neuroimaging has helped clarify the biological contributions to aggression. Studies to date have focused on serotonergic function and impulsive aggression. Reduced levels of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid (5-HIAA) are associated with impulsive aggression. Pharmacochallenge studies have found decreased serotonergic responsiveness associated with impulsive aggression. Neuroimaging studies suggest a role for the prefrontal cortex, along with other regions of the brain, in the expression of aggression. Serotonin is not the only aspect of brain function implicated in impulsive aggression, and further work is being done on other neurotransmitters and neuropeptides.

Serotonin und Persönlichkeit

Zusammenfassung: Es werden kurz drei wichtige Persönlichkeitstheorien vorgestellt, die die Beteiligung des serotonergen Neurotransmittersystems an der Ausprägung dispositioneller Merkmale auf der Ebene von Temperamentseigenschaften konstatieren. Der vorliegende Beitrag fasst die zentralen Befunde zusammen. Zunächst wird jedoch beschrieben, über welche Charakteristika das serotonerge Neurotransmittersystem verfügt, und welche Schwierigkeiten sich hinsichtlich der Messung von Indikatoren serotonerger Aktivität bzw. Ansprechbarkeit ergeben. Basierend auf einigen ausgewählten Befunden aus dem Bereich der biologischen Psychiatrie wird dann dargestellt, dass sich serotonerge Auffälligkeiten klinischer Populationen durchaus in den Bereich der gesunden Persönlichkeit übertragen lassen. Konkreter wird gezeigt, dass sich Personen mit erhöhter Ausprägung auf den Dimensionen Depressivität, Aggressivität und Impulsivität über eine geringe Ansprechbarkeit des serotonergen Systems im Zuge des so genannten Neurotransmitter-Challenge-Tests charakterisieren lassen. Implikationen für ein Verständnis der zugrundeliegenden Mechanismen interindividueller Differenzen und Implikationen für ggfs. veränderte diagnostische Methoden werden diskutiert.

Plasma tryptophan and trait aggression

Many studies have reported correlations between measures of aggression and indices of serotonergic function, but most have studied patient or offender populations and relatively few have investigated plasma concentrations of the serotonin precursor tryptophan. This study investigates the relationship between plasma concentrations of tryptophan and trait hostility, depression and anxiety in male healthy volunteers. Sixty-seven healthy male volunteers gave blood samples and completed trait questionnaires. Plasma tryptophan was positively correlated with the Buss-Durkee Hostility Inventory Total score and Motor Aggression subscale, but not with the Attitudinal Hostility subscale or with trait anxiety or depression. In conclusion, there is evidence for an association between high concentrations of plasma tryptophan and aggressive behaviour in men, presumably mediated by some aspect of central serotonergic function, which seems unlikely to be explained by high trait anxiety or depression.

CSF 5-HIAA correlates with neuroticism in depressed patients

BACKGROUND

To examine for relationships between neurotransmitters and personality.

METHOD

27 depressed patients had cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) monoamine metabolites measured and completed the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire (EPQ).

RESULT

CSF concentrations of the serotonin metabolite 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid (5-HIAA) correlated significantly with EPQ neuroticism scores.

CONCLUSION

Central serotonin may play a role in neuroticism, a personality dimension predisposing to depression.

LIMITATION

The positive correlation may partly reflect collinear relationships between both variables and anxiety/depression.

Correlations between plasma-neuropeptides and temperament dimensions differ between suicidal patients and healthy controls

BACKGROUND

Decreased plasma levels of plasma-neuropeptide Y (NPY) and plasma-corticotropin releasing hormone (CRH), and increased levels of plasma delta-sleep inducing peptide (DSIP) in suicide attempters with mood disorders have previously been observed. This study was performed in order to further understand the clinical relevance of these findings.

METHODS

Examination of correlates between temperament dimensions (Karolinska Scales of Personality (KSP), the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire together with the IVE- impulsiveness scale (EPQI), and the Marke-Nyman Temperament (MNT)) and NPY, CRH and DSIP and serum-cortisol in the dexamethasone suppression test (DST) in 38 suicidal patients and matched controls.

RESULTS

NPY correlated significantly and positively with psychasthenia, irritability, and stability and significantly and negatively with validity in patients, but significantly and negatively with muscular tension, psychasthenia, verbal aggression and irritability in controls. DSIP correlated significantly and positively with impulsiveness (EPQI) in controls. CRH correlated negatively with lie in controls. Cortisol correlated significantly and positively with validity, extraversion and verbal aggression and significantly and negatively with inhibition of aggression in controls.

CONCLUSION

NPY may be related to stress tolerance. DSIP seems to be associated with impulsivity/antisocial traits.

LIMITATIONS

Non-suicidal patients were not included in the examination.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The state of depression or stress seems to influence the correlations studied.

Neurotransmitters and suicidal behavior. The evidence from cerebrospinal fluid studies

Studies of neurotransmitter metabolites in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) were initially focused on depressive illness. Although several studies have demonstrated low concentrations of the serotonin metabolite, 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid (5-HIAA), and the dopamine metabolite, homovanillic acid (HVA), in depressed patients, these early studies may have been biased by concomitant administration of antidepressant drugs (which tend to lower CSF 5-HIAA), amount of CSF drawn (there is a concentration gradient for both metabolites), and selection of control subjects. Once these methodological details are controlled for, the differences between depressed patients and controls are unimpressive. However, there is a remarkably consistent association between low concentrations of CSF 5-HIAA and suicidal behavior, as evidenced by over 20 studies. The association is not confined to depressive illness but has also been found in schizophrenia, personality disorder, and certain impulse control disorders (but, interestingly, not in bipolar disorder). A low concentration of CSF 5-HIAA in a suicide attempter is associated with a substantial increase in short-term suicide risk. CSF studies in violent criminals, and in nonhuman primates, suggest that aggression dyscontrol may partly explain the association between suicide and serotonin, which is of considerable theoretical interest. CSF 5-HIAA determinations may also be helpful in the clinical assessment of suicide risk.

Assessment of life history of aggression: development and psychometric characteristics

The Life History of Aggression (LHA) assessment was administered to up to 252 subjects. In addition to a total LHA score, subscale scores for Aggression, Social Consequences and Antisocial Behavior, and Self-directed Aggression were calculated. Test-retest stability, interrater agreement, and internal consistency reliability were excellent both for the LHA Total score and the LHA Aggression subscore. There were moderately strong correlations between these scores and both self-reports of aggressive tendency (Buss-Durkee Hostility Inventory: n = 214) and recent overt aggression (Overt Aggression Scale-Modified for Out-patients: n = 61). LHA Total scores were highest among subjects with Antisocial or Borderline Personality Disorder. These results support the use of the LHA assessment, and especially the LHA Aggression subscore, as a measure of life history of aggressive behavior.

Serotonin function in human subjects: intercorrelations among central 5-HT indices and aggressiveness

Three central indices of serotonin (5-HT) system activity in human subjects were examined to: (a) estimate intercorrelations among 5-HT indices and (b) compare correlations of these indices with a measure of assaultiveness (Buss-Durkee 'Assault') in personality-disordered individuals. Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid (5-HIAA) concentration and prolactin responses to m-chlorophenylpiperazine (m-CPP) m-CPP (PRL[m-CPP]) and fenfluramine (PRL[FEN]), served as indices of pre-, post- and 'net'-synaptic central 5-HT activity, respectively. PRL[D,L-FEN] responses were inversely related to CSF 5-HIAA concentration and positively correlated with PRL[m-CPP] responses. Both PRL[D,L-FEN] and PRL[m-CPP] response data correlated equally, and inversely, with BD Buss-Durkee Assault when the same subjects were examined. Basal CSF 5-HIAA concentration did not correlate with Buss-Durkee 'Assault'. PRL responses to challenge probes which involve activation of 5-HT post-synaptic receptors may correlate better than a basal measure of pre-synaptic 5-HT function with a tendency to assaultive behavior in non-criminally aggressive personality-disordered individuals.

Genetics of aggressive and violent behavior

This article develops the topic of the genetics of aggressive and violent behavior from three directions. Firstly, evidence from twin, family, and adoption studies will establish the case for the importance of genetically transmitted factors in the genesis of aggressivity from childhood through adulthood. Secondly, evidence from adoption studies will be presented to show that some environmental conditions interact with genetic factors in such a way as to suggest that the development of aggressivity requires that both genetic and environmental factors be present. Thirdly, additional and direct evidence of genetic factors in aggressivity is presented from the perspective of molecular genetics, where underlying biochemical mechanisms associated with aggressivity have been found to be caused by specific genes in animal models with confirmation of similar physiologic mechanisms in humans.

Biological and psychopharmacological aspects of impulse-control disorders

Over the past decades extensive research has been performed on the presumed relationship between neurotransmitter functionality in the central nervous system and psychopathological states. Originally, in the mid-sixties it was hypothesized that depressive states may be associated with disorders in brain noradrenalin and/or serotonin (5-hydroxytryptamine; 5-HT) metabolism or function resulting in the socalled monoamine hypothesis of depression. Subsequent investigations revealed that altered 5-HT metabolism is not related to mood disorder per se, but to components of the depressive syndrome and more specifically to increased anxiety and/or signs of dysregulated aggression, including violent suicidal attempts. Concerning aggression and other types of disruptive or impulsive behavior, research on their neurobiological determinants has been focussed mainly on indicators of central 5-HT function.