Enzyme Kinetics in Liquid Crystalline Mesophases: Size Matters, But Also Topology

Soft Materials with Time-Programmed Changes in Physical Properties through Lyotropic Phase Transitions Induced by pH-Changing Reactions

We present the development of time-programmable functional soft materials. The materials undergo reversible phase transitions between lyotropic phases with different topologies and symmetries, which in turn have very different physical properties: viscosity, diffusion, and optical transparency. Here, this behavior is achieved by combining pH-responsive lyotropic phases made from the lipid monoolein doped with 10% oleic acid, with chemical reactions that have well-defined controllable kinetics: autocatalytic urea-urease and methyl formate hydrolysis, which increase and decrease pH, respectively. In this case, we use small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and optical imaging to show temporally controlled transitions between the cloudy hexagonal phase, which is a two-dimensional (2D) array of cylindrical inverse micelles, and the transparent, highly viscous three-dimensional (3D) bicontinuous cubic phases. By combining these into a single reaction mixture where the pH increases and then decreases again, we can induce a sequential transformation cycle from hexagonal to cubic and back to hexagonal over several hours. The sample therefore changes from cloudy to transparent and back again as a proof-of-concept demonstration for a wider range of soft materials with time-programmable changes in physical properties.

Development of Redox-Active Lyotropic Lipid Cubic Phases for Biosensing Platforms

Enzyme-based electrochemical biosensors play an important role in point-of-care diagnostics for personalized medicine. For such devices, lipid cubic phases (LCP) represent an attractive method to immobilize enzymes onto conductive surfaces with no need for chemical linking. However, research has been held back by the lack of effective strategies to stably co-immobilize enzymes with a redox shuttle that enhances the electrical connection between the enzyme redox center and the electrode. In this study, we show that a monoolein (MO) LCP system doped with an amphiphilic redox mediator (ferrocenylmethyl)dodecyldimethylammonium bromide (Fc12) can be used for enzyme immobilization to generate an effective biosensing platform. Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) showed that MO LCP can incorporate Fc12 while maintaining the Pn3m symmetry morphology. Cyclic voltammograms of Fc12/MO showed quasi-reversible behavior, which implied that Fc12 was able to freely diffuse in the lipid membrane of LCP with a diffusion coefficient of 1.9 ± 0.2 × 10-8 cm2 s-1 at room temperature. Glucose oxidase (GOx) was then chosen as a model enzyme and incorporated into 0.2%Fc12/MO to evaluate the activity of the platform. GOx hosted in 0.2%Fc12/MO followed Michaelis-Menten kinetics toward glucose with a KM and Imax of 8.9 ± 0.5 mM and 1.4 ± 0.2 μA, respectively, and a linearity range of 2-17 mM glucose. Our results therefore demonstrate that GOx immobilized onto 0.2% Fc12/MO is a suitable platform for the electrochemical detection of glucose.

Expanding the Enzymatic Polymerization Landscape by Lipid Mesophase Soft Nanoconfinement

Soft nanoconfinement can increase chemical reactivity in nature and has therefore led to considerable interest in transferring this universal feature to artificial biological systems. However, little is known about the underlying principles of soft nanoconfinement responsible for the enhancement of biochemical reactions. Herein we demonstrate how enzymatic polymerization can be expanded, optimized, and engineered when carried out under soft nanoconfinement mediated by lipidic mesophases. By systematically varying the water content in the mesophase and thus the diameter of the confined water nanochannels, we show higher efficiency, turnover rate, and degrees of polymerization as compared to the bulk aqueous solution, all controlled by soft nanoconfinement effects. Furthermore, we exploit the unique properties of unfreezing soft nanoconfined water to perform the first enzymatic polymerization at -20 °C in pure aqueous media. These results underpin lipidic mesophases as a versatile host system for chemical reactions and promote them as an original and unexplored platform for enzymatic polymerization.

A novel droplet-based approach to study phase transformations in lyotropic liquid crystalline systems

HYPOTHESIS

Lyotropic liquid crystals (LLC) and their phase transformations in response to stimuli have gathered much interest for controlled and 'on-demand' drug applications. Bulk methods of preparation impose limitations on studying the transformations, especially induced by compositional changes, such as enzymatic changes to lipid structure. Here we hypothesise that controlled microfluidic production and coalescence of dissimilar aqueous and lipid droplets emulsified in a third mutually immiscible liquid will provide a new approach to the spatio-temporal study of structure formation in lyotropic liquid crystalline materials.

EXPERIMENTS

Separate lipid and aqueous droplets, dispersed in a fluorocarbon oil were generated using a microfluidic format. The chip, prepared as a hybrid polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) and glass microfluidic device, was constructed to enable in-situ acquisition of time-resolved synchrotron small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and crossed polarised light microscopy of the coalesced droplets to determine the structures present during aging.

FINDINGS

Janus-like droplets formed upon coalesce, with distinct lipid and aqueous portions with a gradient between the two sides of the merged droplet. SAXS and polarised light microscopy revealed a progression of mesophases as the lipid portion was hydrated by the aqueous portion via the diffusion limited interface which separated the portions. Thus demonstrating, on a droplet scale, a new approach for studying the phase transformation kinetics and identification of non-equilibrium phase in droplet-based lyotropic liquid systems.

Cryogenic activity and stability of benzaldehyde lyase enzyme in lipidic mesophases-nanoconfined water

Phytantriol-based lipidic mesophases (LMs) are introduced as a platform for cryoenzymology, which relies on the presence of liquid water in LMs at subzero temperatures. After incorporation into LMs, the model enzyme Benzaldehyde lyase (BAL) shows high cryogenic stability and activity. In contrast, BAL in bulk solution undergoes significant secondary structural transitions caused by low temperatures (cold denaturation), demonstrating the potential of this approach to enable in meso cryoenzymology.

Designing cryo-enzymatic reactions in subzero liquid water by lipidic mesophase nanoconfinement

Cryo-enzymology provides the possibility to develop unconventional biological reactions and detect intermediates in ultrafast enzymatic catalysis processes, but also illuminates the understanding of life principles in extremely cold environments. The scarcity of biological or biomimetic host systems that provide liquid water at subzero temperatures inhibits the prosperity of cryo-enzymology. Here we introduce cryo-enzymatic reactions in subzero water nanoconfined within lipid mesophases formed by conventional lipids. We show that the enzymatic reactions that ensue outperform the homologue catalytic processes run at standard temperatures. We use phytantriol-based lipidic mesophases (LMPs), within which water remains in the liquid state down to -120 °C, and combine crystallization and dynamic studies of the confined water to provide a fundamental understanding of the physical status of water at subzero temperatures, which sets the stage for cryo-enzymatic reactions in these environments. In the model horseradish peroxidase oxidization, the cation free-radical product is stabilized in LMPs at -20 °C, in contrast to the fast-consuming reactions at temperatures above 0 °C. Furthermore, the LMP system also supports the cascade reaction and lipase reaction at subzero temperatures, at which enzymatic reactions with both hydrophilic and hydrophobic substrates are successfully carried out. Our designed LMP system opens access to the nature of confined water in the biomimetic environment and provides a platform for low-temperature biomacromolecule reconstitution and the cryogenic control of enzymatic reactions in bionanotechnology.

Controlling the Kinetics of an Enzymatic Reaction through Enzyme or Substrate Confinement into Lipid Mesophases with Tunable Structural Parameters

Lipid liquid crystalline mesophases, resulting from the self-assembly of polymorphic lipids in water, have been widely explored as biocompatible drug delivery systems. In this respect, non-lamellar structures are particularly attractive: they are characterized by complex 3D architectures, with the coexistence of hydrophobic and hydrophilic regions that can conveniently host drugs of different polarities. The fine tunability of the structural parameters is nontrivial, but of paramount relevance, in order to control the diffusive properties of encapsulated active principles and, ultimately, their pharmacokinetics and release. In this work, we investigate the reaction kinetics of p-nitrophenyl phosphate conversion into p-nitrophenol, catalysed by the enzyme Alkaline Phosphatase, upon alternative confinement of the substrate and of the enzyme into liquid crystalline mesophases of phytantriol/H₂O containing variable amounts of an additive, sucrose stearate, able to swell the mesophase. A structural investigation through Small-Angle X-ray Scattering, revealed the possibility to finely control the structure/size of the mesophases with the amount of the included additive. A UV-vis spectroscopy study highlighted that the enzymatic reaction kinetics could be controlled by tuning the structural parameters of the mesophase, opening new perspectives for the exploitation of non-lamellar mesophases for confinement and controlled release of therapeutics.

Lipid-based mesophases as matrices for nanoscale reactions

Lipidic mesophases are versatile bioorganic materials that have been effectively employed as nanoscale matrices for membrane protein crystallization, drug delivery and as food emulsifiers over the last 30 years. In this review, the focus is upon studies that have employed non-lamellar lipid mesophases as matrices for organic, inorganic and enzymatic reactions. The ability of lipidic mesophases to incorporate hydrophilic, amphiphilic and hydrophobic molecules, together with the high interfacial area of the lipidic cubic and inverse hexagonal phases has been exploited in heterogeneous catalysis as well as for enzyme immobilization. The unique nanostructure of these mesophases is the driving force behind their ability to act as templates for synthesis, resulting in the creation of highly ordered polymeric and inorganic materials with complex geometries.

Peculiar hydrogen bonding behaviour of water molecules inside the aqueous nanochannels of lyotropic liquid crystals

The hydrogen bonding abilities of the LLC water molecules and their effects on intramolecular hydrogen bonds of the target probe molecules.

Encapsulation of Aspartic Protease in Nonlamellar Lipid Liquid Crystalline Phases

Encapsulation of proteins within lipid inverse bicontinuous cubic phases (Q₂) has been widely studied for many applications, such as protein crystallization or drug delivery of proteins for food and pharmaceutical purposes. However, the use of the lipid sponge (L₃) phase for encapsulation of proteins has not yet been well explored. Here, we have employed a lipid system that forms highly swollen sponge phases to entrap aspartic protease (34 kDa), an enzyme used for food processing, e.g., to control the cheese-ripening process. Small-angle x-ray scattering showed that although the L₃ phase was maintained at low enzyme concentrations (≤15 mg/mL), higher concentration induces a transition to more curved structures, i.e., transition from L₃ to inverse bicontinuous cubic (Q₂) phase. The Raman spectroscopy data showed minor conformational changes assigned to the lipid molecules that confirm the lipid-protein interactions. However, the peaks assigned to the protein showed that the structure was not significantly affected. This was consistent with the higher activity presented by the encapsulated aspartic protease compared to the free enzyme stored at the same temperature. Finally, the encapsulation efficiency of aspartic protease in lipid sponge-like nanoparticles was 81% as examined by size-exclusion chromatography. Based on these results, we discuss the large potential of lipid sponge phases as carriers for proteins.

Supramolecular chirality and crystallization from biocatalytic self-assembly in lipidic cubic mesophases

Biocatalytic self-assembly in a nanoconfined environment is widely used in nature to construct complex structures that endow special characteristics to life. There is tremendous interest in mimicking such bottom-up processes to fabricate functional materials. In this study, we have investigated a novel biomimetic scaffold based on lipidic cubic mesophases (LCMs), which provide a special nanoconfined environment for biocatalytic self-assembly and subsequent formation of organic crystals. (R)-Benzoin generated in situ from benzaldehyde in a reaction catalyzed by the enzyme benzaldehyde lyase (BAL) exhibits - when confined within LCMs - enhanced chirality compared to (R)-benzoin in solution or (R)-benzoin-doped LCMs. We infer that a metastable state is formed under kinetic control that displays enhanced supramolecular chirality. As they age, these metastable structures can further grow into thermodynamically stable crystals. The biomimetic, nanoconfined environment provided by the LCMs plays a key role in the development of supramolecular chirality and subsequent crystallization.

Large PAMAM Dendron Induces Formation of Unusual P4332 Mesophase in Monoolein/Water Systems

Compact macromolecular dendrons have previously been shown to induce the formation of discontinuous inverse micellar assemblies with Fd3 m symmetry in monoolein/water systems. Here, we demonstrate that a large PAMAM dendron (G5: fifth generation) induces the formation of a very unusual mesophase with P4₃32 symmetry. This mesophase had previously been observed in monoolein/water systems only on addition of cytochrome c. The P4₃32 mesophase can be considered an intermediate phase between the bicontinuous Ia3 d and discontinuous micellar mesophases. We present a detailed investigation of the phase behavior of monoolein/water as a function of G5 concentration and temperature. Addition of 1% G5 in 85/15 monoolein/water system induces a transition from the L_α to Ia3 d phase. Further increase in G5 concentration to above 2% induces the formation of the P4₃32 phase. In contrast to this, incorporation of lower generation PAMAM dendrons (G2-G4) in monoolein/water yields a qualitatively different phase diagram with the formation of the reverse micellar Fd3 m phase. PAMAM dendrons of all generations, G2-G5, bear terminal amine groups that interact with the monoolein headgroup. The compact molecular architecture of the dendrons and these attractive interactions induce bending of the monoolein bilayer structure. For smaller dendrons, G2-G4, this results in the formation of the Fd3 m phase. However, the large size of the G5 dendron precludes this and a rare intermediate phase between the Ia3 d and discontinuous micellar phase, and the P4₃32 mesophase forms instead.

Lyotropic liquid crystal engineering moving beyond binary compositional space - ordered nanostructured amphiphile self-assembly materials by design

Ordered amphiphile self-assembly materials with a tunable three-dimensional (3D) nanostructure are of fundamental interest, and crucial for progressing several biological and biomedical applications, including in meso membrane protein crystallization, as drug and medical contrast agent delivery vehicles, and as biosensors and biofuel cells. In binary systems consisting of an amphiphile and a solvent, the ability to tune the 3D cubic phase nanostructure, lipid bilayer properties and the lipid mesophase is limited. A move beyond the binary compositional space is therefore required for efficient engineering of the required material properties. In this critical review, the phase transitions upon encapsulation of more than 130 amphiphilic and soluble additives into the bicontinuous lipidic cubic phase under excess hydration are summarized. The data are interpreted using geometric considerations, interfacial curvature, electrostatic interactions, partition coefficients and miscibility of the alkyl chains. The obtained lyotropic liquid crystal engineering design rules can be used to enhance the formulation of self-assembly materials and provides a large library of these materials for use in biomedical applications (242 references).

Lipidic Mesophases as Novel Nanoreactor Scaffolds for Organocatalysts: Heterogeneously Catalyzed Asymmetric Aldol Reactions in Confined Water

The unique molecular architecture of lipidic cubic phases (LCPs) and their cubosome dispersions comprise a well-defined, curved bilayer that spans the entire three-dimensional (3-D) material space, encompassing a network of two periodic, curved, and nonintersecting 3-D aqueous channels. The ensuing large lipid/water interfacial area makes these biomaterials an interesting matrix for the lateral immobilization of organocatalysts to catalyze organic reactions in confined water. Herein, we report for the first time the design, synthesis, assembly, and characterization of catalytically active LCPs and cubosomes and demonstrate their applicability as self-assembled, biomimetic, and recyclable nanoreactor scaffolds. Small-angle X-ray scattering, cryo-transmission electron microscopy, and dynamic light scattering were applied for the characterization of the mesophases. These mesophases can be recycled and enable efficient catalytic activity as well as modulation of the diastereo- and enantioselectivity for the aldol reaction of several benzaldehyde derivatives and cyclohexanone in water.

Influence of Surface Charge of the Nanostructures on the Biocatalytic Activity

The physicochemical properties of abiotic nanostructures determine the structure and function of biological counterparts in biotic-abiotic nanohybrids. A comprehensive understanding of the interfacial interactions and the predictive capability of their structure and function is paramount for virtually all fields of bionanotechnology. In this study, using plasmonic nanostructures as a model abiotic system, we investigate the effect of the surface charge of nanostructures on the biocatalytic reaction kinetics of a bound enzyme. We found that the surface charge of nanostructures profoundly influences the structure, orientation, and activity of the bound enzyme. Furthermore, the interactions of the enzyme with nanoparticles result in stable conjugates that retain their functionality at elevated temperatures, unlike their free counterparts that lose their secondary structure and biocatalytic activity.

Non-lamellar lipid assembly at interfaces: controlling layer structure by responsive nanogel particles

Biological membranes do not only occur as planar bilayer structures, but depending on the lipid composition, can also curve into intriguing three-dimensional structures. In order to fully understand the biological implications as well as to reveal the full potential for applications, e.g. for drug delivery and other biomedical devices, of such structures, well-defined model systems are required. Here, we discuss the formation of lipid non-lamellar liquid crystalline (LC) surface layers spin-coated from the constituting lipids followed by hydration of the lipid layer. We demonstrate that hybrid lipid polymer films can be formed with different properties compared with the neat lipid LC layers. The nanostructure and morphologies of the lipid films formed reflect those in the bulk. Most notably, mixed lipid layers, which are composed of glycerol monooleate and diglycerol monooleate with poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) nanogels, can form films of reverse cubic phases that are capable of responding to temperature stimulus. Owing to the presence of the nanogel particles, changing the temperature not only regulates the hydration of the cubic phase lipid films, but also the lateral organization of the lipid domains within the lipid self-assembled film. This opens up the possibility for new nanostructured materials based on lipid-polymer responsive layers.

Direct demonstration of lipid phosphorylation in the lipid bilayer of the biomimetic bicontinuous cubic phase using the confined enzyme lipid A phosphoethanolamine transferase

Retention of amphiphilic protein activity within the lipid bilayer membrane of the nanostructured biomimetic bicontinuous cubic phase is crucial for applications utilizing these hybrid protein-lipid self-assembly materials, such as in meso membrane protein crystallization and drug delivery. Previous work, mainly on soluble and membrane-associated enzymes, has shown that enzyme activity may be modified when immobilized, including membrane bound enzymes. The effect on activity may be even greater for amphiphilic enzymes with a large hydrophilic domain, such as the Neisserial enzyme lipid A phosphoethanolamine transferase (EptA). Encapsulation within the biomimetic but non-endogenous lipid bilayer membrane environment may modify the enzyme conformation, while confinement of the large hydrophilic domain with the nanoscale water channels of a continuous lipid bilayer structure may prevent full function of this enzyme. Herein we show that NmEptA remains active despite encapsulation within a nanostructured bicontinuous cubic phase. Full transfer of the phosphoethanolamine (PEA) group from a 1,2-dioleoyl-glycero-phosphoethanolamine (DOPE) doped lipid to monoolein (MO), which makes up the bicontinuous cubic phase, is shown. The reaction was found to be non-specific to the alkyl chain identity. The observed rate of enzyme activity is similar to other membrane bound enzymes, with complete transfer of the PEA group occurring in vitro, under the conditions studied, over a 24 hour timescale.

Dynamics of different steps of the photopyrolytic cycle of an eminent anticancer drug topotecan inside biocompatible lyotropic liquid crystalline systems

Dynamics of different steps of photopyrolytic processes of an eminent anticancer drug topotecan have been investigated inside different lyotropic liquid crystalline systems.

Mesoporous self-assembled nanoparticles of biotransesterified cyclodextrins and nonlamellar lipids as carriers of water-insoluble substances

Soft mesoporous hierarchically structured particles were created by the self-assembly of an amphiphilic deep cavitand cyclodextrin βCD-nC₁₀ (degree of substitution n = 7.3), with a nanocavity grafted by multiple alkyl (C₁₀) chains on the secondary face of the βCD macrocycle through enzymatic biotransesterification, and the nonlamellar lipid monoolein (MO). The effect of the non-ionic dispersing agent polysorbate 80 (P80) on the liquid crystalline organization of the nanocarriers and their stability was studied in the context of vesicle-to-cubosome transition. The coexistence of small vesicular and nanosponge membrane objects with bigger nanoparticles with inner multicompartment cubic lattice structures was established as a typical feature of the employed dispersion process. The cryogenic transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM) images and small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) structural analyses revealed the dependence of the internal organization of the self-assembled nanoparticles on the presence of embedded βCD-nC₁₀ deep cavitands in the lipid bilayers. The obtained results indicated that the incorporated amphiphilic βCD-nC₁₀ building blocks stabilize the cubic lattice packing in the lipid membrane particles, which displayed structural features beyond the traditional CD nanosponges. UV-Vis spectroscopy was employed to characterize the nanoencapsulation of a model hydrophobic dimethylphenylazo-naphthol guest compound (Oil red) in the created nanocarriers. In perspective, these dual porosity carriers should be suitable for co-encapsulation and sustained delivery of peptide, protein or siRNA biopharmaceuticals together with small molecular weight drug compounds or imaging agents.

Lyotropic Liquid Crystalline Cubic Phases as Versatile Host Matrices for Membrane-Bound Enzymes

Lyotropic liquid crystalline cubic mesophases can function as host matrices for enzymes because of their biomimetic structural characteristics, optical transparency, and capability to coexist with water. This study demonstrates that the in meso immobilized membrane-bound enzyme d-fructose dehydrogenase (FDH) preserves its full activity, follows ideal Michaelis-Menten kinetics, and shows improved stability compared to its behavior in solution. Even after 5 days, the immobilized FDH retained its full activity in meso, whereas a model hydrophilic enzyme, horseradish peroxidase, maintained only 21% of its original activity. We reason that the lipidic bilayers in the three-dimensional structures of cubic mesophases provide an ideal environment for the reconstitution of a membrane-bound enzyme. The preserved activity, long-term stability, and reusability demonstrate that these hybrid nanomaterials are ideal matrices for biosensing and biocatalytic fuel cell applications.

Topological Influence of Lyotropic Liquid Crystalline Systems on Excited-State Proton Transfer Dynamics

In the present work, we have investigated the excited-state proton transfer (ESPT) dynamics inside lipid-based reverse hexagonal (HII), gyroid Ia3d, and diamond Pn3m LLC phases. Polarized light microscopy (PLM) and small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) techniques have been employed for the characterization of LLC systems. Time-resolved fluorescence results reveal the retarded ESPT dynamics inside liquid crystalline systems compared to bulk water, and it follows the order HII < Ia3d < Pn3m < H2O. The slower solvation, hampered "Grotthuss" proton transfer process, and most importantly, topological influence, of the LLC systems are believed to be mainly responsible for the slower and different extent of ESPT dynamics. Interestingly, recombination dynamics is found to be faster with respect to bulk water and it follows the order H2O < Pn3m < Ia3d < HII. Faster recombination dynamics arises due to lower dielectric constant and different channel diameters of these LLC systems. However, the dissociation dynamics is found to be slower than bulk water and it follows the order HII < Ia3d < Pn3m < H2O. Differences in critical packing parameter of LLC systems are believed to be the governing factors for the slower dissociation dynamics in these liquid crystalline systems.

Understanding the Mechanism of Enzyme-Induced Formation of Lyotropic Liquid Crystalline Nanoparticles

Liquid crystalline nanoparticles have shown great potential for application in fields of drug delivery and agriculture. However, optimized approaches to generating these dispersions have long been sought after. This study focused on understanding the mechanism of formation of cubosomes during the recently reported enzymatic approach and extending the approach to alternative lipid types other than phytantriol. The chain length of digestible lipids was found to influence the effectiveness of triglycerides in disrupting the equilibrium cubic phase structure to form the emulsion precursor. In general, a greater hydrophobicity of the triglyceride required a lower concentration to inhibit liquid crystal structure formation. Selachyl alcohol was also examined due to its nondigestible trait and ability to form the inverted hexagonal phase. Digestion of its precursor emulsion formed hexosomes analogous to the phytantriol-based systems. Finally, the assumption that fatty acids liberated during digestion needed to partition out of the nondigestible lipids for the re-formation of the phase structure was found to be untrue. Their ionization state, however, did have an effect on the resulting nanostructure, and this unique property could potentially provide a useful attribute for oral drug delivery systems.