Mitigation of Physical Aging with Mixed Matrix Membranes Based on Cross-Linked PIM-1 Fillers and PIM-1

Hydroxyl-functionalized microporous polymer membranes with tunable para position substituent benzaldehydes for gas separation

We report hydroxyl-functionalized microporous polymers with tunable benzaldehyde groups for gas separation membranes. These polymers were synthesized via acid-catalyzed Friedel-Crafts polycondensation. The tunability in d-spacing and fractional free volume of these polymers depends on the para position substituents (-H, -F, -Cl, and -Br) of the benzaldehyde. Specifically, the size and polarity of the para position substituent influence the polymer chain-packing structure. Consequently, the hydroxyl-functionalized microporous polymer membrane with a larger para position substituent in the benzaldehyde group exhibited improved gas permeability. This improvement is due to enhanced gas diffusivity resulting from the inefficient polymer chain-packing structure. Furthermore, these membranes demonstrated enhanced CO2 plasticization resistance, attributable to the rigid, contorted polymer structure and the hydrogen bonding interactions between hydroxyl groups. This study provides insights into the relationship between the polymer chain-packing structure, tunable para position substituents, and molecular transport.

Metal-Organic-Frameworks Based Mixed-Matrix Membranes for CO2 Separation: An Applicable-Conceptual Approach

A promising class of porous crystalline materials, metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), have recently emerged as a potential material in fabricating mixed matrix membranes (MMMs) for gas separation applications. Their unique chemistry and structural versatility offer substantial advantages over conventional fillers. This review gives an in-depth exploration of MOF chemistry, focusing on strategies to manipulate their adsorption behavior to enhance separation properties. We scrutinize the impact of various MOF-based MMM components, including polymer matrix, MOFs fillers and polymer/filler interface, on the overall gas separation performance. This involves a detailed analysis of key parameters associated with MMM preparation. Additionally, we offer a comprehensive overview of the determining factors in MOF-based MMM development for gas separation, including MOF structure, synthesis, and chemistry. Moreover, the most advances in modification strategies of MOF for CO2 separation, such as a wide variety of hybrid MOFs will be outlined, which opens the door to an improved CO2 separation process. Finally, the gas transport mechanisms of MMMs are thoroughly discussed to understand the factors affecting the gas permeation through the polymer matrix, MOFs and interface between them.

Morphological Study before and after Thermal Treatment of Polymer-Polymer Mixed-Matrix Membranes for Gas Separations

A good integration of the polymer materials that form a mixed-matrix membrane (MMM) for gas separation is essential to reaching interesting permselective properties. In this work, a porous polymer network (PPN), obtained by combining triptycene and trifluoroacetophenone, has been used as a filler, which was blended with two o-hydroxypolyamides (HPAs) that act as polymer matrices. These polymer matrices have been thermally treated to induce a thermal rearrangement (TR) of the HPAs to polybenzoxazoles (β-TR-PBOs) through a solid-state reaction. For its structural study, various techniques have been proposed that allow us to undertake a morphological investigation into the integration of these materials. To access the internal structure of the MMMs, three different methods were used: a polishing process for the material surface, the partial dissolution of the polymer matrix, or argon plasma etching. The argon plasma technique has not only revealed its potential to visualize the internal structure of these materials; it has also been proven to allow for the transformation of their permselective properties. Force modulation and phase contrast in lift-mode techniques, along with the topographic images obtained via the tapping mode using a scanning probe microscope (SPM), have allowed us to study the distribution of the filler particles and the interaction of the polymer and the filler. The morphological information obtained via SPM, along with that of other more commonly used techniques (SEM, TGA, DSC, FTIR, WASX, gas adsorption, and permeability measurements), has allowed us to postulate the most probable structural configuration in this type of system.

A Microporous Poly(Arylene Ether) Platform for Membrane-Based Gas Separation

Membrane-based gas separations are crucial for an energy-efficient future. However, it is difficult to develop membrane materials that are high-performing, scalable, and processable. Microporous organic polymers (MOPs) combine benefits for gas sieving and solution processability. Herein, we report membrane performance for a new family of microporous poly(arylene ether)s (PAEs) synthesized via Pd-catalyzed C-O coupling reactions. The scaffold of these microporous polymers consists of rigid three-dimensional triptycene and stereocontorted spirobifluorene, endowing these polymers with micropore dimensions attractive for gas separations. This robust PAE synthesis method allows for the facile incorporation of functionalities and branched linkers for control of permeation and mechanical properties. A solution-processable branched polymer was formed into a submicron film and characterized for permeance and selectivity, revealing lab data that rivals property sets of commercially available membranes already optimized for much thinner configurations. Moreover, the branching motif endows these materials with outstanding plasticization resistance, and their microporous structure and stability enables benefits from competitive sorption, increasing CO2 /CH4 and (H2 S+CO2 )/CH4 selectivity in mixture tests as predicted by the dual-mode sorption model. The structural tunability, stability, and ease-of-processing suggest that this new platform of microporous polymers provides generalizable design strategies to form MOPs at scale for demanding gas separations in industry.

An integrated life cycle assessment and techno-economic analysis: Evaluation on the production of polymers of intrinsic microporosity (PIM-1) and UiO-66-NH2 as membrane materials

Material synthesis requires an enormous amount of organic solvents which leads to huge environmental burdens. Being so, the necessity to utilize non-toxic chemicals is of growing interest in the global market. Harnessing a green fabrication strategy could be a sustainable remedy. Herein, life cycle assessment (LCA) and techno-economic assessment (TEA) using a cradle-to-gate approach to select the green synthesis route for the production of main components in mixed matrix membranes such as polymer and fillers were studied. Five representative synthesis routes of polymers of intrinsic microporosity (PIM-1) and fillers such as UiO-66-NH2 (UiO: University of Oslo) were conducted. Our findings revealed that the tetrachloroterephthalonitrile (TCTPN) synthesized PIM-1 using a novel approach (e.g., P5-Novel synthesis) and solvent-free synthesized UiO-66-NH2 (e.g., U5-Solvent-free) demonstrated the least environmental impact and are most economically feasible. The environmental burden and cost of PIM-1 synthesized by P5-Novel synthesis route decreased by 50 % and 15 %, respectively, while that of UiO-66-NH2 produced via U5-Solvent-free route reduced by 89 % and 52 %, respectively. Additionally, solvent reduction was found to have an apparent effect on cost-saving, whereby the production cost declined 13 % with a 30 % solvent reduction. Alleviation of environmental burdens could also be found through recovering solvents or substituting with a greener alternative (e.g., water). The fundamentals gained on the environmental impacts and economic feasibility of PIM-1 and UiO-66-NH2 production from this LCA-TEA study may provide a preliminary evaluation for the development of green and sustainable materials.

Sorption-Induced Fiber Optic Plasmonic Gas Sensing via Small Grazing Angle of Incidence

Sensing technologies based on plasmonic nanomaterials are of interest for various chemical, biological, environmental, and medical applications. In this work, an incorporation strategy of colloidal plasmonic nanoparticles (pNPs) in microporous polymer for realizing distinct sorption-induced plasmonic sensing is reported. This approach is demonstrated by introducing tin-doped indium oxide pNPs into a polymer of intrinsic microporosity (PIM-1). The composite film (pNPs-polymer) provides distinct and tunable optical features on the fiber optic (FO) platform that can be used as a signal transducer for gas sensing (e.g., CO2 ) under atmospheric conditions. The resulting pNPs-polymer composite demonstrates high sensitivity response on FO in the evanescent field configuration, provided by the dramatic response of modes above the total-internal-reflection angle. Furthermore, by varying the pNPs content in the polymer matrix, the optical behavior of the pNPs-polymer composite film can be tuned to affect the operational wavelength by over several hundred nanometers and the sensitivity of the sensor in the near-infrared range. It is also shown that the pNPs-polymer composite film exhibits remarkable stability over a period of more than 10 months by mitigating the physical aging issue of the polymer.

Pillared Carbon Membranes Derived from Cardo Polymers

Carbon molecular sieve membranes (CMSMs) were prepared by carbonizing the high free volume polyimide BTDA-BAF that is obtained from the reaction of benzophenone-3,3',4,4'-tetracarboxylic dianhydride (BTDA) and 9,9-bis(4-aminophenyl) fluorene (BAF). The bulky cardo groups prevented a tight packing and rotation of the chains that leads to high permeabilities of their CMSMs. The incorporation of metal-organic polyhedra 18 (MOP-18, a copper-based MOP) in the BTDA-BAF polymer before pyrolysis at 550 °C prevented the collapse of the pores and the aging of the CMSMs. It was found that upon decomposition of MOP-18, a distribution of copper nanoparticles minimized the collapse of the graphitic sheets that formed the micropores and mesopores in the CMSM. The pillared CMSMs displayed CO2 and CH4 permeabilities of 12,729 and 659 Barrer, respectively, with a CO2/CH4 selectivity of 19.3 after 3 weeks of aging. The permselectivity properties of these membranes was determined to be at the 2019 Robeson upper bound. In contrast, the CMSMs from pure BTDA-BAF aged three times faster than the CMSMs from MOP-18/BTDA-BAF and exhibited lower CO2 and CH4 permeabilities of 5337 and 573 Barrer, respectively, with a CO2/CH4 selectivity of 9.3. The non-pillared CMSMs performed below the upper bound.

The Difference in Performance and Compatibility between Crystalline and Amorphous Fillers in Mixed Matrix Membranes for Gas Separation (MMMs)

An increasing number of high-performing gas separation membranes is reported almost on a daily basis, yet only a few of them have reached commercialisation while the rest are still considered pure research outcomes. This is often attributable to a rapid change in the performance of these separation systems over a relatively short time. A common approach to address this issue is the development of mixed matrix membranes (MMMs). These hybrid systems typically utilise either crystalline or amorphous additives, so-called fillers, which are incorporated into polymeric membranes at different loadings, with the aim to improve and stabilise the final gas separation performance. After a general introduction to the most relevant models to describe the transport properties in MMMs, this review intends to investigate and discuss the main advantages and disadvantages derived from the inclusion of fillers of different morphologies. Particular emphasis will be given to the study of the compatibility at the interface between the filler and the matrix created by the two different classes of additives, the inorganic and crystalline fillers vs. their organic and amorphous counterparts. It will conclude with a brief summary of the main findings.

Methanol Vapor Retards Aging of PIM-1 Thin Film Composite Membranes in Storage

Physical aging of glassy polymers leads to a decrease in permeability over time when they are used in membranes. This hinders the industrial application of high free volume polymers, such as the archetypal polymer of intrinsic microporosity PIM-1, for membrane gas separation. In thin film composite (TFC) membranes, aging is much more rapid than in thicker self-standing membranes, as rearrangement within the thin active layer is relatively fast. Liquid alcohol treatment, which swells the membrane, is often used in the laboratory to rejuvenate aged self-standing membranes, but this is not easily applied on an industrial scale and is not suitable to refresh TFC membranes because of the risk of membrane delamination. In this work, it is demonstrated that a simple method of storage in an atmosphere of methanol vapor effectively retards physical aging of PIM-1 TFC membranes. The same method can also be utilized to refresh aged PIM-1 TFC membranes, and one-week methanol vapor storage is sufficient to recover most of the original CO₂ permeance.

PIM-1/Holey Graphene Oxide Mixed Matrix Membranes for Gas Separation: Unveiling the Role of Holes

PIM-1/holey graphene oxide (GO) mixed matrix membranes (MMMs) have been prepared and their gas separation performance for CO₂/CH₄ mixtures assessed. Nanopores have been created in the basal plane of gas-impermeable GO by chemical etching reactions, and the resulting holey flakes have been further chemically functionalized, either with octadecylamine (ODA) or with PIM-1 moieties, to aid their dispersion in PIM-1. It is found that nanopores barely promote gas transport through the graphene-like nanofiller for fresh membranes (tested right after preparation); however, the prepared hybrid PIM-1/holey GO membranes exhibit higher CO₂ permeability and CO₂/CH₄ selectivity than the pure polymer membrane 150 days after preparation and 13 and 15% higher CO₂ permeability for filler contents of 0.1% of octadecylamine-functionalized holey GO and 1% of (PIM-1)-functionalized holey GO, respectively. The most significant improvement is observed for the mitigation of physical aging, as MMMs using 10% of (PIM-1)-functionalized holey GO nanofillers are capable of maintaining up to 70% of their initial CO₂ permeability after 150 days, whereas only 53% is kept for pure PIM-1 after the same period. The gas permeability of the nanofiller has been rationalized with the aid of the Maxwell-Wagner-Sillars equation.

Superglassy Polymers to Treat Natural Gas by Hybrid Membrane/Amine Processes: Can Fillers Help?

Superglassy polymers have emerged as potential membrane materials for several gas separation applications, including acid gas removal from natural gas. Despite the superior performance shown at laboratory scale, their use at industrial scale is hampered by their large drop in gas permeability over time due to physical aging. Several strategies are proposed in the literature to prevent loss of performance, the incorporation of fillers being a successful approach. In this work, we provide a comprehensive economic study on the application of superglassy membranes in a hybrid membrane/amine process for natural gas sweetening. The hybrid process is compared with the more traditional stand-alone amine-absorption technique for a range of membrane gas separation properties (CO2 permeance and CO2/CH4 selectivity), and recommendations for long-term membrane performance are made. These recommendations can drive future research on producing mixed matrix membranes (MMMs) of superglassy polymers with anti-aging properties (i.e., target permeance and selectivity is maintained over time), as thin film nanocomposite membranes (TFNs). For the selected natural gas composition of 28% of acid gas content (8% CO2 and 20% H2S), we have found that a CO2 permeance of 200 GPU and a CO2/CH4 selectivity of 16 is an optimal target.

Boosting gas separation performance and suppressing the physical aging of polymers of intrinsic microporosity (PIM-1) by nanomaterial blending

In recent decades, polymers of intrinsic microporosity (PIMs), especially the firstly introduced PIM-1, have been actively explored for various membrane-based separation purposes and widely recognized as the next generation membrane materials of choice for gas separation due to their ultra-permeable characteristics. Unfortunately, the polymers suffer substantially the negative impacts of physical aging, a phenomenon that is primarily noticeable in high free volume polymers. The phenomenon occurs at the molecular level, which leads to changes in the physical properties, and consequently the separation performance and membrane durability. This review discusses the strategies that have been employed to manage the physical aging issue, with a focus on the approach of blending with nanomaterials to give mixed matrix membranes. A detailed discussion is provided on the types of materials used, their inherent properties, the effects on gas separation performance, and their benefits in the suppression of the aging problem.