Cholesterol-Induced Lipophobic Interaction between Transmembrane Helices Using Ensemble and Single-Molecule Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer

Lipid Bilayer Strengthens the Cooperative Network of a Membrane-Integral Enzyme

Lipid bilayer provides a two-dimensional hydrophobic solvent milieu for membrane proteins in cells. Although the native bilayer is widely recognized as an optimal environment for folding and function of membrane proteins, the underlying physical basis remains elusive. Here, employing the intramembrane protease GlpG of Escherichia coli as a model, we elucidate how the bilayer stabilizes a membrane protein and engages the protein's residue interaction network compared to the nonnative hydrophobic medium, micelles. We find that the bilayer enhances GlpG stability by promoting residue burial in the protein interior compared to micelles. Strikingly, while the cooperative residue interactions cluster into multiple distinct regions in micelles, the whole packed regions of the protein act as a single cooperative unit in the bilayer. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulation indicates that lipids less efficiently solvate GlpG than detergents. Thus, the bilayerinduced enhancement of stability and cooperativity likely stems from the dominant intraprotein interactions outcompeting the weak lipid solvation. Our findings reveal a foundational mechanism in the folding, function, and quality control of membrane proteins. The enhanced cooperativity benefits function facilitating propagation of local structural perturbation across the membrane. However, the same phenomenon can render the proteins' conformational integrity vulnerable to missense mutations causing conformational diseases1,2.

Thermodynamic analysis of the GASright transmembrane motif supports energetic model of dimerization

The GASright motif, best known as the fold of the glycophorin A transmembrane dimer, is one of the most common dimerization motifs in membrane proteins, characterized by its hallmark GxxxG-like sequence motifs (GxxxG, AxxxG, GxxxS, and similar). Structurally, GASright displays a right-handed crossing angle and short interhelical distance. Contact between the helical backbones favors the formation of networks of weak hydrogen bonds between Cα-H carbon donors and carbonyl acceptors on opposing helices (Cα-H···O=C). To understand the factors that modulate the stability of GASright, we previously presented a computational and experimental structure-based analysis of 26 predicted dimers. We found that the contributions of van der Waals packing and Cα-H hydrogen bonding to stability, as inferred from the structural models, correlated well with relative dimerization propensities estimated experimentally with the in vivo assay TOXCAT. Here we test this model with a quantitative thermodynamic analysis. We used Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) to determine the free energy of dimerization of a representative subset of seven of the 26 original TOXCAT dimers using FRET. To overcome the technical issue arising from limited sampling of the dimerization isotherm, we introduced a globally fitting strategy across a set of constructs comprising a wide range of stabilities. This strategy yielded precise thermodynamic data that show strikingly good agreement between the original propensities and ΔG° of association in detergent, suggesting that TOXCAT is a thermodynamically driven process. From the correlation between TOXCAT and thermodynamic stability, the predicted free energy for all the 26 GASright dimers was calculated. These energies correlate with the in silico ΔE scores of dimerization that were computed on the basis of their predicted structure. These findings corroborate our original model with quantitative thermodynamic evidence, strengthening the hypothesis that van der Waals and Cα-H hydrogen bond interactions are the key modulators of GASright stability.

Biophysical Approaches for the Characterization of Protein-Metabolite Interactions

With an estimate of hundred thousands of protein molecules per cell and the number of metabolites several orders of magnitude higher, protein-metabolite interactions are omnipresent. In vitro analyses are one of the main pillars on the way to establish a solid understanding of how these interactions contribute to maintaining cellular homeostasis. A repertoire of biophysical techniques is available by which protein-metabolite interactions can be quantitatively characterized in terms of affinity, specificity, and kinetics in a broad variety of solution environments. Several of those provide information on local or global conformational changes of the protein partner in response to ligand binding. This review chapter gives an overview of the state-of-the-art biophysical toolbox for the study of protein-metabolite interactions. It briefly introduces basic principles, highlights recent examples from the literature, and pinpoints promising future directions.

Effects of Gly Residue and Cholesterol on the GXXXG-Mediated Parallel Association of Transmembrane Helices: A Single-Pair FRET Study

Small residue-mediated interhelical packing is ubiquitous in helical membrane proteins: however, the lipid dependence of its stability remains unclear. We previously demonstrated that the introduction of a GXXXG sequence in the middle of de novo-designed (AALALAA)₃ helices (AALALAA AGLALGA AALALAA) facilitated their dimerization, which was abolished by cholesterol. Here single-pair FRET measurements revealed that a longer GXXXGXXXG segment (AALALAA A GLALGA AAGALAA) promoted helix dimerization in POPC/cholesterol bilayers, but not without cholesterol. The predicted dimer structures and degrees of helix packing suggested that helix dimers with small (∼10°) and large (∼55°) crossing angles were only stabilized in POPC and POPC/cholesterol membranes, respectively. A steric hindrance in the dimer interface and the large flexibility of helices prevented the formation of stable dimers. Therefore, amino acid sequences and lipid compositions distinctively constrain stable dimer structures in membranes.

Elucidation of Complex Dynamic Intermolecular Interactions in Membranes

Biomembranes composed of various proteins and lipids play important roles in cellular functions, such as signal transduction and substance transport. In addition, some bioactive peptides and pathogenic proteins target membrane proteins and lipids to exert their effects. Therefore, an understanding of dynamic and complex intermolecular interactions among these membrane constituents is needed to elucidate their mechanisms. This review summarizes the major research carried out in the author's laboratory on how lipids and their inhomogeneous distributions regulate the structures and functions of antimicrobial peptides and Alzheimer's amyloid β-protein. Also, how to detect transmembrane helix-helix and membrane protein-protein interactions and how they are modulated by lipids are discussed.

Regulation of EGFR activation and signaling by lipids on the plasma membrane

Lipids on the plasma membrane are not only components of the membrane biophysical structures but also regulators of receptor functions. Recently, the critical roles of lipid-protein interactions have been intensively highlighted. Epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) is one of the most extensively studied receptors exhibiting various lipid interactions, including interactions with phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylserine, phosphatidylinositol phosphate, cholesterol, gangliosides, and palmitate. Here, we review recent findings on how direct interaction with these lipids regulates EGFR activation and signaling, providing unprecedented insight into the comprehensive roles of various lipids in the control of EGFR functions. Finally, the current limitations in investigating lipid-protein interactions and novel technologies to potentially overcome these limitations are discussed.

All-Atom Molecular Dynamics Elucidating Molecular Mechanisms of Single-Transmembrane Model Peptide Dimerization in a Lipid Bilayer

Protein-protein interactions between transmembrane helices are essential elements for membrane protein structures and functions. To understand the effects of peptide sequences and lipid compositions on these interactions, single-molecule experiments using model systems comprising artificial peptides and membranes have been extensively performed. However, their dynamic behavior at the atomic level remains largely unclear. In this study, we applied the all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) method to simulate the interactions of single-transmembrane helical peptide dimers in membrane environments, which has previously been analyzed by single-molecule experiments. The simulations were performed with two peptides (Ala- and Leu-based artificially designed peptides, termed "host peptide", and the host peptide added with the GXXXG motif, termed "GXXXG peptide"), two membranes (pure-POPC and POPC mixed with 30% cholesterols), and two dimer directions (parallel and antiparallel), consistent with those in the previous experiment. As a result, the MD simulations with parallel dimers reproduced the experimentally observed tendency that introducing cholesterols weakened the interactions in the GXXXG dimer and facilitated those in the host dimer. Our simulation suggested that the host dimer formed hydrogen bonds but the GXXXG dimer did not. However, some discrepancies were also observed between the experiments and simulations. Limitations in the space and time scales of simulations restrict the large-scale undulation and peristaltic motions of the membranes, resulting in differences in lateral pressure profiles. This effect could cause a discrepancy in the rotation angles of helices against the membrane normal.

FRET detects lateral interaction between transmembrane domain of EGF receptor and ganglioside GM3 in lipid bilayers

Ganglioside GM3 in the plasma membranes suppresses cell growth by preventing the autophosphorylation of the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR). Biological studies have suggested that GM3 interacts with the transmembrane segment of EGFR. Further biophysical experiments are particularly important for quantitative evaluation of the peptide-glycolipid interplay in bilayer membranes using a simple reconstituted system. To examine these interactions in this way, we synthesized the transmembrane segment of EGFR bearing a nitrobenzoxadiazole fluorophore (NBD-TM) at the N-terminus. The affinity between EGFR and GM3 was evaluated based on Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) between NBD-TM and ATTO594-labeled GM3 in bilayers where their non-specific interaction due to lateral proximity was subtracted by using NBD-labeled phospholipid. This method for selectively detecting the specific lipid-peptide interactions in model lipid bilayers disclosed that the lateral interaction between GM3 and the transmembrane segment of EGFR plays a certain role in disturbing the formation of active EGFR dimers.

Single-Molecular Förster Resonance Energy Transfer Measurement on Structures and Interactions of Biomolecules

Single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer (smFRET) inherits the strategy of measurement from the effective "spectroscopic ruler" FRET and can be utilized to observe molecular behaviors with relatively high throughput at nanometer scale. The simplicity in principle and configuration of smFRET make it easy to apply and couple with other technologies to comprehensively understand single-molecule dynamics in various application scenarios. Despite its widespread application, smFRET is continuously developing and novel studies based on the advanced platforms have been done. Here, we summarize some representative examples of smFRET research of recent years to exhibit the versatility and note typical strategies to further improve the performance of smFRET measurement on different biomolecules.

Thermodynamic and kinetic stabilities of transmembrane helix bundles as revealed by single-pair FRET analysis: Effects of the number of membrane-spanning segments and cholesterol

The tertiary structures and conformational dynamics of transmembrane (TM) helical proteins are maintained by the interhelical interaction network in membranes, although it is complicated to analyze the underlying driving forces because the amino acid sequences can involve multiple and various types of interactions. To obtain insights into basal and common effects of the number of membrane-spanning segments and membrane cholesterol, we measured stabilities of helix bundles composed of simple TM helices (AALALAA)₃ (1TM) and (AALALAA)₃-G₅-(AALALAA)₃ (2TM). Association-dissociation dynamics for 1TM-1TM, 1TM-2TM, and 2TM-2TM pairs were monitored to compare stabilities of 2-, 3-, and 4-helical bundles, respectively, with single-pair fluorescence resonance energy transfer (sp-FRET) in liposome membranes. Both thermodynamic and kinetic stabilities of the helix bundles increased with a greater number of membrane-spanning segments in POPC. The presence of 30 mol% cholesterol strongly enhanced the formation of 1TM-1TM and 1TM-2TM bundles (~ - 9 kJ mol^-1), whereas it only weakly stabilized the 2TM-2TM bundle (~ - 3 kJ mol^-1). Fourier transform infrared-polarized attenuated total reflection (ATR-FTIR) spectroscopy revealed an ~30° tilt of the helix axis relative to bilayer normal for the 1TM-2TM pair in the presence of cholesterol, suggesting the formation of a tilted helix bundle to release high lateral pressure at the center of cholesterol-containing membranes. These results demonstrate that the number of membrane-spanning segments affects the stability and structure of the helix bundle, and their cholesterol-dependences. Such information is useful to understand the basics of folding and assembly of multispanning TM proteins.

Packing of apolar side chains enables accurate design of highly stable membrane proteins

The features that stabilize the structures of membrane proteins remain poorly understood. Polar interactions contribute modestly, and the hydrophobic effect contributes little to the energetics of apolar side-chain packing in membranes. Disruption of steric packing can destabilize the native folds of membrane proteins, but is packing alone sufficient to drive folding in lipids? If so, then membrane proteins stabilized by this feature should be readily designed and structurally characterized-yet this has not been achieved. Through simulation of the natural protein phospholamban and redesign of variants, we define a steric packing code underlying its assembly. Synthetic membrane proteins designed using this code and stabilized entirely by apolar side chains conform to the intended fold. Although highly stable, the steric complementarity required for their folding is surprisingly stringent. Structural informatics shows that the designed packing motif recurs across the proteome, emphasizing a prominent role for precise apolar packing in membrane protein folding, stabilization, and evolution.

Live-cell imaging of membrane proteins by a coiled-coil labeling method-Principles and applications

In situ investigations in living cell membranes are important to elucidate the dynamic behaviors of membrane proteins in complex biomembrane environments. Protein-specific labeling is a key technique for the detection of a target protein by fluorescence imaging. The use of post-translational labeling methods using a genetically encodable tag and synthetic probes targeting the tag offer a smaller label size, labeling with synthetic fluorophores, and precise control of the labeling ratio in multicolor labeling compared with conventional genetic fusions with fluorescent proteins. This review focuses on tag-probe labeling studies for live-cell analysis of membrane proteins based on heterodimeric peptide pairs that form coiled-coil structures. The robust and simple peptide-peptide interaction enables not only labeling of membrane proteins by noncovalent interactions, but also covalent crosslinking and acyl transfer reactions guided by coiled-coil assembly. A number of studies have demonstrated that membrane protein behaviors in live cells, such as internalization of receptors and the oligomeric states of various membrane proteins (G-protein-coupled receptors, epidermal growth factor receptors, influenza A M2 channel, and glycopholin A), can be precisely analyzed using coiled-coil labeling, indicating the potential of this labeling method in membrane protein research.

[Fluorescent Peptide Tools for Studying the Self-association of Membrane Proteins]

Detecting the behaviors of proteins in membranes is often challenging; we need to develop new methods to better understand the mechanisms involved. We have developed two types of peptide-based experimental systems that can detect the self-association of proteins in bilayer environments: 1) a single-pair fluorescence detection system for studying the self-association of transmembrane helices in model membranes; and 2) live-cell fluorescence labeling and analysis of the oligomeric state of membrane proteins using a coiled-coil labeling method. By using these methods, we show that membrane cholesterol significantly affects the self-association of transmembrane helices.

A model-free method for measuring dimerization free energies of CLC-ec1 in lipid bilayers

The thermodynamic reasons why membrane proteins form stable complexes inside the hydrophobic lipid bilayer remain poorly understood. This is largely because of a lack of membrane-protein systems amenable for equilibrium studies and a limited number of methods for measuring these reactions. Recently, we reported the equilibrium dimerization of the CLC-ec1 Cl^-/H⁺ transporter in lipid bilayers (Chadda et al. 2016. eLife https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.17438), which provided a new type of model system for studying protein association in membranes. The measurement was conducted using the subunit-capture approach, involving passive dilution of the protein in large multilamellar vesicles, followed by single-molecule photobleaching analysis of the Poisson distribution describing protein encapsulation into extruded liposomes. To estimate the fraction of dimers (F_Dimer ) as a function of protein density, the photobleaching distributions for the nonreactive, ideal monomer and dimer species must be known so that random co-capture probabilities can be accounted for. Previously, this was done by simulating the Poisson process of protein reconstitution into a known size distribution of liposomes composed of Escherichia coli polar lipids (EPLs). In the present study, we investigate the dependency of F_Dimer and ΔG° on the modeling through a comparison of different liposome size distributions (EPL versus 2:1 POPE/POPG). The results show that the estimated F_Dimer values are comparable, except at higher densities when liposomes become saturated with protein. We then develop empirical controls to directly measure the photobleaching distributions of the nonreactive monomer (CLC-ec1 I201W/I422W) and ideal dimer (WT CLC-ec1 cross-linked by glutaraldehyde or CLC-ec1 R230C/L249C cross-linked by a disulfide bond). The measured equilibrium constants do not depend on the correction method used, indicating the robustness of the subunit-capture approach. This strategy therefore presents a model-free way to quantify protein dimerization in lipid bilayers, offering a simplified strategy in the ongoing effort to characterize equilibrium membrane-protein reactions in membranes.

Selective amine labeling of cell surface proteins guided by coiled-coil assembly

Covalent labeling of target proteins in living cells is useful for both fluorescence live-cell imaging and the subsequent biochemical analyses of the proteins. Here, we report an efficient method for the amine labeling of membrane proteins on the cell surface, guided by a noncovalent coiled-coil interaction. A carboxyl sulfosuccinimidyl ester introduced at the C-terminus of the coiled-coil probe reacted with target proteins under mild labeling conditions ([probe] = 150 nM, pH 7.4, 25°C) for 20 min. Various fluorescent moieties with different hydrophobicities are available for covalent labeling with high signal/background labeling ratios. Using this method, oligomeric states of glycophorin A (GpA) were compared in mammalian CHO-K1 cells and sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) micelles. In the cell membranes, no significant self-association of GpA was detected, whereas SDS-PAGE suggested partial dimerization of the proteins. Membrane cholesterol was found to be an important factor that suppressed the dimerization of GpA. Thus, the covalent functionality enables direct comparison of the oligomeric state of membrane proteins under various conditions. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Biopolymers (Pept Sci) 106: 484-490, 2016.

GXXXG-Mediated Parallel and Antiparallel Dimerization of Transmembrane Helices and Its Inhibition by Cholesterol: Single-Pair FRET and 2D IR Studies

Small-residue-mediated interhelical packings are ubiquitously found in helical membrane proteins, although their interaction dynamics and lipid dependence remain mostly uncharacterized. We used a single-pair FRET technique to examine the effect of a GXXXG motif on the association of de novo designed (AALALAA)₃ helices in liposomes. Dimerization occurred with sub-second lifetimes, which was abolished by cholesterol. Utilizing the nearly instantaneous time-resolution of 2D IR spectroscopy, parallel and antiparallel helix associations were identified by vibrational couplings across helices at their interface. Taken together, the data illustrate that the GXXXG motif controls helix packing but still allows for a dynamic and lipid-regulated oligomeric state.

Lipid perturbation by membrane proteins and the lipophobic effect

Understanding how membrane proteins interact with their environment is fundamental to the understanding of their structure, function and interactions. We have performed coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations on a series of membrane proteins in a membrane environment to examine the perturbations of the lipids by the presence of protein. We analyze these perturbations in terms of elastic membrane deformations and local lipid protein interactions. However these two factors are insufficient to describe the variety of effects that we observe and the changes caused by membranes proteins to the structure and dynamics of their lipid environment. Other factors that change the conformation available to lipid molecules are evident and are able to modify lipid structure far from the protein surface, and thus mediate long-range interactions between membrane proteins. We suggest that these multiple modifications to lipid behavior are responsible, at the molecular level, for the lipophobic effect we have proposed to account for our observations of membrane protein organization.

Unfolding and refolding of a protein by cholesterol and cyclodextrin: a single molecule study

Cholesterol induced unfolding of a globular protein, human serum albumin (HSA), and β-cyclodextrin induced refolding of the unfolded protein is demonstrated in this study.