Mechanistic investigations of a ribozyme derived from the Tetrahymena group I intron: insights into catalysis and the second step of self-splicing

Analysis of catalytic RNA structure and function by nucleotide analog interference mapping

Nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) is a quick and efficient method to define concurrently, yet singly, the importance of specific functional groups at particular nucleotide residues to the structure and function of an RNA. NAIM can be utilized on virtually any RNA with an assayable function. The method hinges on the ability to successfully incorporate, within an RNA transcript, various 5'-O-(1-thio)nucleoside analogs randomly via in vitro transcription. This could be achieved by using wild-type or Y639F mutant T7 RNA polymerase, thereby creating a pool of analog doped RNAs. The pool when subjected to a selection step to separate the active transcripts from the inactive ones leads to the identification of functional groups that are crucial for RNA activity. The technique can be used to study ribozyme structure and function via monitoring of cleavage or ligation reactions, define functional groups critical for RNA folding, RNA-RNA interactions, and RNA interactions with proteins, metals, or other small molecules. All major classes of catalytic RNAs have been probed by NAIM. This is a generalized approach that should provide the scientific community with the tools to better understand RNA structure-activity relationships.

Structure-function analysis from the outside in: long-range tertiary contacts in RNA exhibit distinct catalytic roles

The conserved catalytic core of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme is encircled by peripheral elements. We have conducted a detailed structure-function study of the five long-range tertiary contacts that fasten these distal elements together. Mutational ablation of each of the tertiary contacts destabilizes the folded ribozyme, indicating a role of the peripheral elements in overall stability. Once folded, three of the five tertiary contact mutants exhibit defects in overall catalysis that range from 20- to 100-fold. These and the subsequent results indicate that the structural ring of peripheral elements does not act as a unitary element; rather, individual connections have distinct roles as further revealed by kinetic and thermodynamic dissection of the individual reaction steps. Ablation of P14 or the metal ion core/metal ion core receptor (MC/MCR) destabilizes docking of the substrate-containing P1 helix into tertiary interactions with the ribozyme's conserved core. In contrast, ablation of the L9/P5 contact weakens binding of the guanosine nucleophile by slowing its association, without affecting P1 docking. The P13 and tetraloop/tetraloop receptor (TL/TLR) mutations had little functional effect and small, local structural changes, as revealed by hydroxyl radical footprinting, whereas the P14, MC/MCR, and L9/P5 mutants show structural changes distal from the mutation site. These changes extended into regions of the catalytic core involved in docking or guanosine binding. Thus, distinct allosteric pathways couple the long-range tertiary contacts to functional sites within the conserved core. This modular functional specialization may represent a fundamental strategy in RNA structure-function interrelationships.

The Azoarcus group I intron ribozyme misfolds and is accelerated for refolding by ATP-dependent RNA chaperone proteins

Structured RNAs traverse complex energy landscapes that include valleys representing misfolded intermediates. In Neurospora crassa and Saccharomyces cerevisiae, efficient splicing of mitochondrial group I and II introns requires the DEAD box proteins CYT-19 and Mss116p, respectively, which promote folding transitions and function as general RNA chaperones. To test the generality of RNA misfolding and the activities of DEAD box proteins in vitro, here we measure native folding of a small group I intron ribozyme from the bacterium Azoarcus by monitoring its catalytic activity. To develop this assay, we first measure cleavage of an oligonucleotide substrate by the prefolded ribozyme. Substrate cleavage is rate-limited by binding and is readily reversible, with an internal equilibrium near unity, such that the amount of product observed is less than the amount of native ribozyme. We use this assay to show that approximately half of the ribozyme folds readily to the native state, whereas the other half forms an intermediate that transitions slowly to the native state. This folding transition is accelerated by urea and increased temperature and slowed by increased Mg(2+) concentration, suggesting that the intermediate is misfolded and must undergo transient unfolding during refolding to the native state. CYT-19 and Mss116p accelerate refolding in an ATP-dependent manner, presumably by disrupting structure in the intermediate. These results highlight the tendency of RNAs to misfold, underscore the roles of CYT-19 and Mss116p as general RNA chaperones, and identify a refolding transition for further dissection of the roles of DEAD box proteins in RNA folding.

Tightening of active site interactions en route to the transition state revealed by single-atom substitution in the guanosine-binding site of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme

Protein enzymes establish intricate networks of interactions to bind and position substrates and catalytic groups within active sites, enabling stabilization of the chemical transition state. Crystal structures of several RNA enzymes also suggest extensive interaction networks, despite RNA's structural limitations, but there is little information on the functional and the energetic properties of these inferred networks. We used double mutant cycles and presteady-state kinetic analyses to probe the putative interaction between the exocyclic amino group of the guanosine nucleophile and the N7 atom of residue G264 of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme. As expected, the results supported the presence of this interaction, but remarkably, the energetic penalty for introducing a CH group at the 7-position of residue G264 accumulates as the reaction proceeds toward the chemical transition state to a total of 6.2 kcal/mol. Functional tests of neighboring interactions revealed that the presence of the CH group compromises multiple contacts within the interaction network that encompass the reactive elements, apparently forcing the nucleophile to bind and attack from an altered, suboptimal orientation. The energetic consequences of this indirect disruption of neighboring interactions as the reaction proceeds demonstrate that linkage between binding interactions and catalysis hinges critically on the precise structural integrity of a network of interacting groups.

A rearrangement of the guanosine-binding site establishes an extended network of functional interactions in the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme active site

Protein enzymes appear to use extensive packing and hydrogen bonding interactions to precisely position catalytic groups within active sites. Because of their inherent backbone flexibility and limited side chain repertoire, RNA enzymes face additional challenges relative to proteins in precisely positioning substrates and catalytic groups. Here, we use the group I ribozyme to probe the existence, establishment, and functional consequences of an extended network of interactions in an RNA active site. The group I ribozyme catalyzes a site-specific attack of guanosine on an oligonucleotide substrate. We previously determined that the hydrogen bond between the exocyclic amino group of guanosine and the 2'-hydroxyl group at position A261 of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme contributes to overall catalysis. We now use functional data, aided by double mutant cycles, to probe this hydrogen bond in the individual reaction steps of the catalytic cycle. Our results indicate that this hydrogen bond is not formed upon guanosine binding to the ribozyme but instead forms at a later stage of the catalytic cycle. Formation of this hydrogen bond is correlated with other structural rearrangements in the ribozyme's active site that are promoted by docking of the oligonucleotide substrate into the ribozyme's active site, and disruption of this interaction has deleterious consequences for the chemical transformation within the ternary complex. These results, combined with earlier results, provide insight into the nature of the multiple conformational steps used by the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme to achieve its active structure and reveal an intricate, extended network of interactions that is used to establish catalytic interactions within this RNA's active site.

Coordination of two sequential ester-transfer reactions: exogenous guanosine binding promotes the subsequent omegaG binding to a group I intron

Self-splicing of group I introns is accomplished by two sequential ester-transfer reactions mediated by sequential binding of two different guanosine ligands, but it is yet unclear how the binding is coordinated at a single G-binding site. Using a three-piece trans-splicing system derived from the Candida intron, we studied the effect of the prior GTP binding on the later ωG binding by assaying the ribozyme activity in the second reaction. We showed that adding GTP simultaneously with and prior to the esterified ωG in a substrate strongly accelerated the second reaction, suggesting that the early binding of GTP facilitates the subsequent binding of ωG. GTP-mediated facilitation requires C2 amino and C6 carbonyl groups on the Watson–Crick edge of the base but not the phosphate or sugar groups, suggesting that the base triple interactions between GTP and the binding site are important for the subsequent ωG binding. Strikingly, GTP binding loosens a few local structures of the ribozyme including that adjacent to the base triple, providing structural basis for a rapid exchange of ωG for bound GTP.

Tetrahymena thermophila and Candida albicans group I intron-derived ribozymes can catalyze the trans-excision-splicing reaction

Group I intron-derived ribozymes can catalyze a variety of non-native reactions. For the trans-excision-splicing (TES) reaction, an intron-derived ribozyme from the opportunistic pathogen Pneumocystis carinii catalyzes the excision of a predefined region from within an RNA substrate with subsequent ligation of the flanking regions. To establish TES as a general ribozyme-mediated reaction, intron-derived ribozymes from Tetrahymena thermophila and Candida albicans, which are similar to but not the same as that from Pneumocystis, were investigated for their propensity to catalyze the TES reaction. We now report that the Tetrahymena and Candida ribozymes can catalyze the excision of a single nucleotide from within their ribozyme-specific substrates. Under the conditions studied, the Tetrahymena and Candida ribozymes, however, catalyze the TES reaction with lower yields and rates [Tetrahymena (k(obs)) = 0.14/min and Candida (k(obs)) = 0.34/min] than the Pneumocystis ribozyme (k(obs) = 3.2/min). The lower yields are likely partially due to the fact that the Tetrahymena and Candida catalyze additional reactions, separate from TES. The differences in rates are likely partially due to the individual ribozymes ability to effectively bind their 3' terminal guanosines as intramolecular nucleophiles. Nevertheless, our results demonstrate that group I intron-derived ribozymes are inherently able to catalyze the TES reaction.

The 2'-hydroxyl group of the guanosine nucleophile donates a functionally important hydrogen bond in the tetrahymena ribozyme reaction

In the first step of self-splicing, group I introns utilize an exogenous guanosine nucleophile to attack the 5'-splice site. Removal of the 2'-hydroxyl of this guanosine results in a 10 (6)-fold loss in activity, indicating that this functional group plays a critical role in catalysis. Biochemical and structural data have shown that this hydroxyl group provides a ligand for one of the catalytic metal ions at the active site. However, whether this hydroxyl group also engages in hydrogen-bonding interactions remains unclear, as attempts to elaborate its function further usually disrupt the interactions with the catalytic metal ion. To address the possibility that this 2'-hydroxyl contributes to catalysis by donating a hydrogen bond, we have used an atomic mutation cycle to probe the functional importance of the guanosine 2'-hydroxyl hydrogen atom. This analysis indicates that, beyond its role as a ligand for a catalytic metal ion, the guanosine 2'-hydroxyl group donates a hydrogen bond in both the ground state and the transition state, thereby contributing to cofactor recognition and catalysis by the intron. Our findings continue an emerging theme in group I intron catalysis: the oxygen atoms at the reaction center form multidentate interactions that function as a cooperative network. The ability to delineate such networks represents a key step in dissecting the complex relationship between RNA structure and catalysis.

Kinetic characterization of the first step of the ribozyme-catalyzed trans excision-splicing reaction

Group I introns catalyze the self-splicing reaction, and their derived ribozymes are frequently used as model systems for the study of RNA folding and catalysis, as well as for the development of non-native catalytic reactions. Utilizing a group I intron-derived ribozyme from Pneumocystis carinii, we previously reported a non-native reaction termed trans excision-splicing (TES). In this reaction, an internal segment of RNA is excised from an RNA substrate, resulting in the covalent reattachment of the flanking regions. TES proceeds through two consecutive phosphotransesterification reactions, which are similar to the reaction steps of self-splicing. One key difference is that TES utilizes the 3'-terminal guanosine of the ribozyme as the first-step nucleophile, whereas self-splicing utilizes an exogenous guanosine. To further aid in our understanding of ribozyme reactions, a kinetic framework for the first reaction step (substrate cleavage) was established. The results demonstrate that the substrate binds to the ribozyme at a rate expected for simple helix formation. In addition, the rate constant for the first step of the TES reaction is more than one order of magnitude lower than the analogous step in self-splicing. Results also suggest that a conformational change, likely similar to that in self-splicing, exists between the two reaction steps of TES. Finally, multiple turnover is curtailed because dissociation of the cleavage product is slower than the rate of chemistry.

A relaxed active site after exon ligation by the group I intron

During RNA maturation, the group I intron promotes two sequential phosphorotransfer reactions resulting in exon ligation and intron release. Here, we report the crystal structure of the intron in complex with spliced exons and two additional structures that examine the role of active-site metal ions during the second step of RNA splicing. These structures reveal a relaxed active site, in which direct metal coordination by the exons is lost after ligation, while other tertiary interactions are retained between the exon and the intron. Consistent with these structural observations, kinetic and thermodynamic measurements show that the scissile phosphate makes direct contact with metals in the ground state before exon ligation and in the transition state, but not after exon ligation. Despite no direct exonic interactions and even in the absence of the scissile phosphate, two metal ions remain bound within the active site. Together, these data suggest that release of the ligated exons from the intron is preceded by a change in substrate-metal coordination before tertiary hydrogen bonding contacts to the exons are broken.

Synthesis and biochemical application of 2'-O-methyl-3'-thioguanosine as a probe to explore group I intron catalysis

Oligonucleotides containing 3'-S-phosphorothiolate linkages provide valuable analogues for exploring the catalytic mechanisms of enzymes and ribozymes, both to identify catalytic metal ions and to probe hydrogen-bonding interactions. Here, we have synthesized 2'-O-methyl-3'-thioguanosine to test a possible hydrogen-bonding interaction in the Tetrahymena ribozyme reaction. We developed an efficient method for the synthesis of 2'-O-methyl-3'-thioguanosine phosphoramidite in eight steps starting from 2'-O-methyl-N(2)-(isobutyryl) guanosine with 10.4% overall yield. Following incorporation into oligonucleotides using solid-phase synthesis, we used this new analogue to investigate whether the 3'-oxygen of the guanosine cofactor in the Tetrahymena ribozyme reaction serves as an acceptor for the hydrogen bond donated by the adjacent 2'-hydroxyl group. We show that regardless of whether the guanosine cofactor bears a 3'-oxygen or 3'-sulfur leaving group, replacing the adjacent 2'-hydroxyl group with a 2'-methoxy group incurs the same energetic penalty, providing evidence against an interaction. These results indicate that the hydrogen bond donated by the guanosine 2'-hydroxyl group contributes to catalytic function in a manner distinct from the U(-1) 2'-hydroxyl group.

A Pneumocystis carinii group I intron-derived ribozyme utilizes an endogenous guanosine as the first reaction step nucleophile in the trans excision-splicing reaction

In the trans excision-splicing reaction, a Pneumocystis carinii group I intron-derived ribozyme binds an RNA substrate, excises a specific internal segment, and ligates the flanking regions back together. This reaction can occur both in vitro and in vivo. In this report, the first of the two reaction steps was analyzed to distinguish between two reaction mechanisms: ribozyme-mediated hydrolysis and nucleotide-dependent intramolecular transesterification. We found that the 3'-terminal nucleotide of the ribozyme is the first-reaction step nucleophile. In addition, the 3'-half of the RNA substrate becomes covalently attached to the 3'-terminal nucleotide of the ribozyme during the reaction, both in vitro and in vivo. Results also show that the identity of the 3'-terminal nucleotide influences the rate of the intramolecular transesterification reaction, with guanosine being more effective than adenosine. Finally, expected products of the hydrolysis mechanism do not form during the reaction. These results are consistent with only the intramolecular transesterification mechanism. Unexpectedly, we also found that ribozyme constructs become truncated in vivo, probably through intramolecular 3'-hydrolysis (self-activation), to create functional 3'-terminal nucleotides.

Probing the role of a secondary structure element at the 5'- and 3'-splice sites in group I intron self-splicing: the tetrahymena L-16 ScaI ribozyme reveals a new role of the G.U pair in self-splicing

Several ribozyme constructs have been used to dissect aspects of the group I self-splicing reaction. The Tetrahymena L-21 ScaI ribozyme, the best studied of these intron analogues, catalyzes a reaction analogous to the first step of self-splicing, in which a 5'-splice site analogue (S) and guanosine (G) are converted into a 5'-exon analogue (P) and GA. This ribozyme preserves the active site but lacks a short 5'-terminal segment (called the IGS extension herein) that forms dynamic helices, called the P1 extension and P10 helix. The P1 extension forms at the 5'-splice site in the first step of self-splicing, and P10 forms at the 3'-splice site in the second step of self-splicing. To dissect the contributions from the IGS extension and the helices it forms, we have investigated the effects of each of these elements at each reaction step. These experiments were performed with the L-16 ScaI ribozyme, which retains the IGS extension, and with 5'- and 3'-splice site analogues that differ in their ability to form the helices. The presence of the IGS extension strengthens binding of P by 40-fold, even when no new base pairs are formed. This large effect was especially surprising, as binding of S is essentially unaffected for S analogues that do not form additional base pairs with the IGS extension. Analysis of a U.U pair immediately 3' to the cleavage site suggests that a previously identified deleterious effect from a dangling U residue on the L-21 ScaI ribozyme arises from a fortuitous active site interaction and has implications for RNA tertiary structure specificity. Comparisons of the affinities of 5'-splice site analogues that form only a subset of base pairs reveal that inclusion of the conserved G.U base pair at the cleavage site of group I introns destabilizes the P1 extension >100-fold relative to the stability of a helix with all Watson-Crick base pairs. Previous structural data with model duplexes and the recent intron structures suggest that this effect can be attributed to partial unstacking of the P1 extension at the G.U step. These results suggest a previously unrecognized role of the G.U wobble pair in self-splicing: breaking cooperativity in base pair formation between P1 and the P1 extensions. This effect may facilitate replacement of the P1 extension with P10 after the first chemical step of self-splicing and release of the ligated exons after the second step of self-splicing.

Structural Evidence for a Two-Metal-Ion Mechanism of Group I Intron Splicing

We report the 3.4 angstrom crystal structure of a catalytically active group I intron splicing intermediate containing the complete intron, both exons, the scissile phosphate, and all of the functional groups implicated in catalytic metal ion coordination, including the 2'-OH of the terminal guanosine. This structure suggests that, like protein phosphoryltransferases, an RNA phosphoryltransferase can use a two-metal-ion mechanism. Two Mg2+ ions are positioned 3.9 angstroms apart and are directly coordinated by all six of the biochemically predicted ligands. The evolutionary convergence of RNA and protein active sites on the same inorganic architecture highlights the intrinsic chemical capacity of the two-metal-ion catalytic mechanism for phosphoryl transfer.

Theoretical study of the o-OH participation in catechol ester ammonolysis

The possible catalytic effect of the vicinal hydroxyl group during the ammonolysis of acetylcatechol has been studied by first principle calculations. A very efficient intramolecular catalysis was found to occur when the catechol ester o-OH group is deprotonated: the activation energy of the ammonolysis decreases by 24 kcal mol(-1) as compared to that of acetylphenol ammonolysis. Using this value, the o-oxyanion-catalysed intramolecular ammonolysis was estimated to be orders of magnitude faster than the ammonolysis of acetylphenol or nonionised acetylcatechol. The analogy with the aminolysis of peptidyl-tRNA that occurs during protein biosynthesis implies several orders of magnitude acceleration due to complete or partial deprotonation of its 3'-terminal adenosine 2'-OH providing a mechanistic possibility for general acid-base catalysis by the ribosome.

Crystal structure of a group I intron splicing intermediate

A recently reported crystal structure of an intact bacterial group I self-splicing intron in complex with both its exons provided the first molecular view into the mechanism of RNA splicing. This intron structure, which was trapped in the state prior to the exon ligation reaction, also reveals the architecture of a complex RNA fold. The majority of the intron is contained within three internally stacked, but sequence discontinuous, helical domains. Here the tertiary hydrogen bonding and stacking interactions between the domains, and the single-stranded joiner segments that bridge between them, are fully described. Features of the structure include: (1) A pseudoknot belt that circumscribes the molecule at its longitudinal midpoint; (2) two tetraloop-tetraloop receptor motifs at the peripheral edges of the structure; (3) an extensive minor groove triplex between the paired and joiner segments, P6-J6/6a and P3-J3/4, which provides the major interaction interface between the intron's two primary domains (P4-P6 and P3-P9.0); (4) a six-nucleotide J8/7 single stranded element that adopts a mu-shaped structure and twists through the active site, making critical contacts to all three helical domains; and (5) an extensive base stacking architecture that realizes 90% of all possible stacking interactions. The intron structure was validated by hydroxyl radical footprinting, where strong correlation was observed between experimental and predicted solvent accessibility. Models of the pre-first and pre-second steps of intron splicing are proposed with full-sized tRNA exons. They suggest that the tRNA undergoes substantial angular motion relative to the intron between the two steps of splicing.

A base triple in the Tetrahymena group I core affects the reaction equilibrium via a threshold effect

Previous work on group I introns has suggested that a central base triple might be more important for the first rather than the second step of self-splicing, leading to a model in which the base triple undergoes a conformational change during self-splicing. Here, we use the well-characterized L-21 ScaI ribozyme derived from the Tetrahymena group I intron to probe the effects of base-triple disruption on individual reaction steps. Consistent with previous results, reaction of a ternary complex mimicking the first chemical step in self-splicing is slowed by mutations in this base triple, whereas reaction of a ternary complex mimicking the second step of self-splicing is not. Paradoxically, mechanistic dissection of the base-triple disruption mutants indicates that active site binding is weakened uniformly for the 5'-splice site and the 5'-exon analog, mimics for the species bound in the first and second step of self-splicing. Nevertheless, the 5'-exon analog remains bound at the active site, whereas the 5'-splice site analog does not. This differential effect arises despite the uniform destabilization, because the wild-type ribozyme binds the 5'-exon analog more strongly in the active site than in the 5'-splice site analog. Thus, binding into the active site constitutes an additional barrier to reaction of the 5'-splice site analog, but not the 5'-exon analog, resulting in a reduced reaction rate constant for the first step analog, but not the second step analog. This threshold model explains the self-splicing observations without the need to invoke a conformational change involving the base triple, and underscores the importance of quantitative dissection for the interpretation of effects from mutations.

Architecture and folding mechanism of the Azoarcus Group I Pre-tRNA

Self-splicing RNAs must evolve to function in their specific exon context. The conformation of a group I pre-tRNA(ile) from the bacterium Azoarcus was probed by ribonuclease T(1) and hydroxyl radical cleavage, and by native gel electrophoresis. Biochemical data and three-dimensional models of the pre-tRNA showed that the tRNA is folded, and that the tRNA and intron sequences form separate tertiary domains. Models of the active site before steps 1 and 2 of the splicing reaction predict that exchange of the external G-cofactor and the 3'-terminal G is accomplished by a slight conformational change in P9.0 of the Azoarcus group I intron. Kinetic assays showed that the pre-tRNA folds in minutes, much more slowly than the intron alone. The dependence of the folding kinetics on Mg(2+) and the concentration of urea, and RNase T(1) experiments showed that formation of native pre-tRNA is delayed by misfolding of P3-P9, including mispairing between residues in P9 and the tRNA. Thus, although the intron and tRNA sequences form separate domains in the native pre-tRNA, their folding is coupled via metastable non-native base-pairs. This could help prevent premature processing of the 5' and 3' ends of unspliced pre-tRNA.

A modular, bifunctional RNA that integrates itself into a target RNA

Nature often combines independent functional domains to achieve complex function, but this approach has not been extensively explored with artificial enzymes. Here, a group I ribozyme, which can act as an endoribonuclease, was partnered with the R3C ribozyme, which catalyzes the ligation of RNA molecules. The conjoined ribozymes have the potential to perform successive RNA cleavage and joining reactions, resulting in their mutual integration into a target RNA substrate. When simply joined together, however, the ribozymes were unable to achieve this outcome because of inefficient transfer of the substrate between the two catalytic subunits. In vitro evolution was used to optimize the behavior of the conjoined ribozymes, resulting in bifunctional molecules with substantially improved integration activity. The ligase subunit of these molecules was unchanged, whereas the group I subunit acquired several mutations, mostly in peripheral regions. The generation and study of this bifunctional assembly helps shed light on the evolution of modular enzymes and the obstacles that must be overcome in bringing together independent functional domains. These molecules also may be useful as tools for the insertional mutagenesis of target mRNAs.

Catechol as a nucleophilic catalyst of peptide bond formation

The aminolysis of a mildly activated aminoacid ester, benzyloxycarbonyl-L-phenylalanine cyanomethyl ester, by glycine esters in the presence of catechol has been studied as a model of catalysis by RNA cis-vicinal-diol systems in protein biosynthesis. Catechol accelerated the aminolysis, especially in the presence of bases, probably by nucleophilic catalysis.

Enhancing RNA repair efficiency by combining trans-splicing ribozymes that recognize different accessible sites on a target RNA

Recent reports have demonstrated that trans-splicing ribozymes can be employed to repair mutant RNAs. One key factor that influences RNA repair efficiency is the accessibility of the substrate RNA for ribozyme binding, which is complicated by the fact that RNAs may assume multiple conformations and have proteins bound to them in vivo. Here we describe a strategy to map accessible sites on sickle beta-globin (beta(s)-globin) transcripts in vitro and in vivo and to use this information to enhance RNA repair efficiency. Two sites upstream of the sickle mutation were identified as accessible in some fraction of the beta-globin RNA by mapping with a ribozyme library and the accessibility of those sites was assessed by in vitro cleavage analyses. Ribozymes targeting either site could only convert a certain fraction of the beta(s)-globin RNA to product but not drive the reaction to completion. However, cleavage and splicing reactions were driven further toward completion when the two ribozymes were both added to the reactions, suggesting that the substrate RNA is present in multiple conformations in vitro. These two ribozymes were each able to repair beta(s)-globin transcripts in erythrocyte precursors derived from peripheral blood from individuals with sickle cell disease. Moreover, the relative accessibility of the targeted sites in vivo is as predicted by mapping and in vitro analyses. These results demonstrate that this novel RNA mapping strategy represents an effective means to determine the accessible regions of target RNAs and that combinations of trans-splicing ribozymes can be employed to enhance RNA repair efficiency of clinically relevant transcripts such as beta(s)-globin RNA.

Template-directed interference footprinting for RNA based on inosine-specific cleavage

We report here the development of a Template-directed Interference (TDI) footprinting assay for RNA. The TDI nucleotide analogue inosine (I) lacks the exocyclic amine of G and is a suitable probe for the role of this group in RNA structure and function. Using an I-specific cleavage protocol we identified three functionally significant G residues in the Tetrahymena ribozyme. These residues are proximal to the active site of the folded intron and likely contribute to the positioning of substrates at the catalytic core.

In vitro selection of functional nucleic acids

In vitro selection allows rare functional RNA or DNA molecules to be isolated from pools of over 10(15) different sequences. This approach has been used to identify RNA and DNA ligands for numerous small molecules, and recent three-dimensional structure solutions have revealed the basis for ligand recognition in several cases. By selecting high-affinity and -specificity nucleic acid ligands for proteins, promising new therapeutic and diagnostic reagents have been identified. Selection experiments have also been carried out to identify ribozymes that catalyze a variety of chemical transformations, including RNA cleavage, ligation, and synthesis, as well as alkylation and acyl-transfer reactions and N-glycosidic and peptide bond formation. The existence of such RNA enzymes supports the notion that ribozymes could have directed a primitive metabolism before the evolution of protein synthesis. New in vitro protein selection techniques should allow for a direct comparison of the frequency of ligand binding and catalytic structures in pools of random sequence polynucleotides versus polypeptides.

Ribozyme chemogenetics

In this review I will outline several chemogenetic approaches used to determine the chemical basis of large ribozyme function and structure. The term chemogenetics was first used to describe site-specific functional group modification experiments in the analysis of DNA-protein interactions. Within the past few years equivalent experiments have been performed on large catalytic RNAs using both single-site substitution and interference mapping techniques with nucleotide analogues. While functional group mutagenesis is an important aspect of a chemogenetic approach, chemical correlates to genetic revertants and suppressors must also be realized for the genetic analogy to be intellectually valid and experimentally useful. Several examples of functional group revertants and suppressors have now been obtained within the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme. These experiments define an ensemble of tertiary hydrogen bonds that have made it possible to construct a detailed model of the ribozyme catalytic core. The model includes a functionally important monovalent metal ion binding site, a wobble-wobble receptor motif for helix-helix packing interactions, and a minor groove triple helix.

Nucleotide analog interference mapping

Single-atom substitution experiments provide atomic resolution biochemical information concerning RNA structure and function. Traditionally, these experiments are performed using chimeric RNAs generated by reassembly of full-length RNA from a synthetic substituted oligonucleotide and a truncated RNA transcript. Unfortunately, this technique is limited by the technical difficulty of assembling and measuring the effect of each singly substituted molecule in a given RNA. Here we review an alternate method for rapidly screening the effect of chemical group substitutions on RNA function. Nucleotide analog interference mapping is a chemogenetic approach that utilizes a series 5'-O-(1-thio)-nucleoside analog triphosphates to simultaneously, yet individually, probe the contribution of a functional group at every nucleotide position in an RNA molecule. A population of randomly substituted RNAs is prepared by including phosphorothioate-tagged nucleotide analogs in an in vitro transcription reaction. The active molecules in the RNA population are selected by an activity assay, and the location of the analog substitution detrimental to activity is identified by cleavage at the phosphorothioate tag with iodine and resolution of the cleavage fragments by gel electrophoresis. This method, which is as easy as RNA sequencing, is applicable to any RNA that can be transcribed in vitro and has an assayable function. Here we describe protocols for the synthesis of phosphorothioate-tagged analogs and their incorporation into RNA transcripts. The incorporation properties and unique biochemical signatures of each individual analog are discussed.

A hydrogen-bonding triad stabilizes the chemical transition state of a group I ribozyme

BACKGROUND

The group I intron is an RNA enzyme capable of efficiently catalyzing phosphoryl-transfer reactions. Functional groups that stabilize the chemical transition state of the cleavage reaction have been identified, but they are all located within either the 5'-exon (P1) helix or the guanosine cofactor, which are the substrates of the reaction. Functional groups within the ribozyme active site are also expected to assist in transition-state stabilization, and their role must be explored to understand the chemical basis of group I intron catalysis.

RESULTS

Using nucleotide analog interference mapping and site-specific functional group substitution experiments, we demonstrate that the 2'-OH at A207, a highly conserved nucleotide in the ribozyme active site, specifically stabilizes the chemical transition state by approximately 2 kcal mol-1. The A207 2'-OH only makes its contribution when the U(-1) 2'-OH immediately adjacent to the scissile phosphate is present, suggesting that the 2'-OHs of A207 and U(-1) interact during the chemical step.

CONCLUSIONS

These data support a model in which the 3'-oxyanion leaving group of the transesterification reaction is stabilized by a hydrogen-bonding triad consisting of the 2'-OH groups of U(-1) and A207 and the exocyclic amine of G22. Because all three nucleotides occur within highly conserved non-canonical base pairings, this stabilization mechanism is likely to occur throughout group I introns. Although this mechanism utilizes functional groups distinctive of RNA enzymes, it is analogous to the transition states of some protein enzymes that perform similar phosphoryl-transfer reactions.

The Therapeutic Potential of Ribozymes

Ribozymes are catalytic RNA molecules that recognize their target RNA in a highly sequence-specific manner. They can therefore be used to inhibit deleterious gene expression (by cleavage of the target mRNA) or even repair mutant cellular RNAs. Targets such as the mRNAs of oncogenes (resulting from base mutations or chromosome translocations, eg, ras or bcr-abl) and viral genomes and transcripts (human immunodeficiency virus–type 1 [HIV-1]) are ideal targets for such sequence-specific agents. The aim of this review is therefore to introduce the different classes of ribozymes, highlighting some of the chemistry of the reactions they catalyze, to address the specific inhibition of genes by ribozymes, the problems yet to be resolved, and how new developments in the field give hope to the future for ribozymes in the therapeutic field.

The Therapeutic Potential of Ribozymes

Ribozymes are catalytic RNA molecules that recognize their target RNA in a highly sequence-specific manner. They can therefore be used to inhibit deleterious gene expression (by cleavage of the target mRNA) or even repair mutant cellular RNAs. Targets such as the mRNAs of oncogenes (resulting from base mutations or chromosome translocations, eg, ras or bcr-abl) and viral genomes and transcripts (human immunodeficiency virus–type 1 [HIV-1]) are ideal targets for such sequence-specific agents. The aim of this review is therefore to introduce the different classes of ribozymes, highlighting some of the chemistry of the reactions they catalyze, to address the specific inhibition of genes by ribozymes, the problems yet to be resolved, and how new developments in the field give hope to the future for ribozymes in the therapeutic field.

Complementary sets of noncanonical base pairs mediate RNA helix packing in the group I intron active site

Helix packing is critical for RNA tertiary structure formation, although the rules for helix-helix association within structured RNAs are largely unknown. Docking of the substrate helix into the active site of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme provides a model system to study this question. Using a novel chemogenetic method to analyze RNA structure in atomic detail, we report that complementary sets of noncanonical base pairs (a G.U wobble pair and two consecutively stacked sheared A.A pairs) create an RNA helix packing motif that is essential for 5'-splice site selection in the group I intron. This is likely to be a general motif for helix-helix interaction within the tertiary structures of many large RNAs.

pH dependence of self-splicing by the group IA2 intron in a pre-mRNA derived from the nrdB gene of bacteriophage T4

The nrdB gene of bacteriophage T4 contains a group IA2 intron. We have investigated the kinetics of self-splicing by a shortened variant of nrdB pre-mRNA in the presence of the co-substrates guanosine and 2'-amino-2'-deoxyguanosine. The pH dependence of the first transesterification step displayed parallel linear correlations for the two different co-substrates up to pH 7, above which the reaction with guanosine levels off to become pH independent. The plot for the 30-fold slower reaction with 2'-aminoguanosine is linear up to pH 8-8.5 and then levels off. The linear correlations with slopes close to unity suggest that a deprotonation event accelerates the transesterification reaction and that a change in rate limiting step occurs at a first order rate constant of approximately 1 min-1(i.e. for our system k cat/ K m approximately 10(5) M-1 min-1). The pH dependence of observed rate constants in different divalent metal ion mixtures, where the 2'-aminoguanosine-dependent reaction is enhanced 6- and 35-fold compared with that in magnesium, strongly supports this conclusion. This is, to our knowledge, the first report on an intact self-splicing group I intron where use of different co-substrates and divalent metal ions shows that a deprotonation enhances the rate and verifies that the transitions occurring during splicing of group I introns are all part of a common reaction sequence.

Crystals by design: a strategy for crystallization of a ribozyme derived from the Tetrahymena group I intron

Recently, the 2.8 A crystal structure of one domain of the self-splicing Tetrahymena group I intron was reported. Although it revealed much about RNA tertiary interactions, it contained only half of the active site. We have now designed a series of larger molecules that contain about 70% of the intron and all of the catalytic core. These RNAs were efficient in cleavage of a substrate RNA, consisting of the approximately 100 nucleotides from the 5' end of the intron, at a site corresponding to the 5' splice site. A sparse matrix was designed specifically for large RNAs and used to screen for preliminary crystallization conditions. Of the six RNAs initially tested, five were crystallized in this initial trial. Two of these crystals were further examined. The first diffracted X-rays to only approximately 16 A resolution, even when the crystal were very large. The second diffracted as high as 3.5 A, but the crystals were twinned and therefore unusable for structural studies. Site-specific mutagenesis was performed on the latter RNA to disrupt interactions that might have been responsible for the twinning. One of these mutant RNAs produced large, single, diffraction-quality crystals. The crystals belong to the tetragonal space group P42212 and have large unit cell dimensions, a=b=178 A and c=199 A. Thus, by variation of both sequence elements and crystallization conditions, crystals of a 247 nucleotide catalytic RNA were obtained.

The New World of ribozymes

The number of RNA molecules that have novel catalytic activities has dramatically increased during the past two years. This ribozymic boom is not due to the discovery of additional examples of natural ribozymes but rather to the development of artificial ribozymes isolated by in vitro selection and evolution techniques. The structural and functional complexities of these artificial ribozymes, however, do not match those of the larger natural ribozymes. The understanding of both RNA structure and catalysis performed by natural and artificial ribozymes paves the way for the creation of RNA molecules that are able to efficiently catalyze more complex reactions.

Kinetic mechanism of the hairpin ribozyme. Identification and characterization of two nonexchangeable conformations

To investigate the relationship between RNA folding and ribozyme catalysis, we have carried out a detailed kinetic analysis of four structural derivatives of the hairpin ribozyme. Optimal and suboptimal (wild-type) substrate sequences were studied in conjunction with stabilization of helix 4, which supports formation of the catalytic core. Pre-steady-state and steady-state kinetic studies strongly support a model in which each of the ribozyme variants partitions between two major conformations leading to active and inactive ribozyme. substrate complexes. Reaction rates for cleavage, ligation, and substrate binding to both ribozyme conformations were determined. Ligation rates (3 min-1) were typically 15-fold greater than cleavage rates (0.2 min-1), demonstrating that the hairpin ribozyme is an efficient RNA ligase. On the other hand, substrate binding is very rapid (kon = 4 x 10(8) M-1 min-1), and the ribozyme. substrate complex is very stable (KD < 25 pM; koff < 0.01 min-1). Stabilization of helix 4 increases the proportion of RNA molecules folded into the active conformation, and enhances substrate association and ligation rates. These effects can be explained by stabilization of the catalytic core of the ribozyme. Rigorous consideration of conformational isomers and their intrinsic kinetic properties was necessary for development of a kinetic scheme for the ribozyme-catalyzed reaction.

Defining the chemical groups essential for Tetrahymena group I intron function by nucleotide analog interference mapping

Improved atomic resolution biochemical methods are needed to identify the chemical groups within an RNA that are essential to its activity. As a step toward this goal, we report the use of 5'-O-(1-thio)inosine monophosphate (IMP alphaS) in a nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) assay that makes it possible to simultaneously, yet individually, determine the contribution of almost every N2 exocyclic amine of G within a large RNA. Using IMP alphaS, we identified the exocyclic amines that are essential for 5' or 3' exon ligation by the Tetrahymena group I intron. We report that the amino groups of three phylogenetically conserved guanosines (G111, G112, and G303) are important for 3' exon ligation. The amine of G22, as well as the amines of the other four guanosines within the P1 helix, are essential for ligation of the 5' exon. Previous work has shown that point mutation of either G22 or G303 to an adenosine (A) substantially reduces activity. Like inosine, adenosine lacks an N2 amino group. Interference rescue of the G22A and G303A point mutations was detected at the site of mutation by NAIM using 5'-O-(1-thio)diaminopurine riboside monophosphate (DMP alphaS), an adenosine analog that has an N2 exocyclic amine. The G22A point mutant could also be rescued by incorporation of DMP alphaS at A24. By analogy to genetics, there are interference phenotypes comparable to loss of function, reversion, and suppression. This method can be readily extended to other nucleotide analogs for the analysis of chemical groups essential to a variety of RNA and DNA activities.

Mechanistic aspects of enzymatic catalysis: lessons from comparison of RNA and protein enzymes

A classic approach in biology, both organismal and cellular, is to compare morphologies in order to glean structural and functional commonalities. The comparative approach has also proven valuable on a molecular level. For example, phylogenetic comparisons of RNA sequences have led to determination of conserved secondary and even tertiary structures, and comparisons of protein structures have led to classifications of families of protein folds. Here we take this approach in a mechanistic direction, comparing protein and RNA enzymes. The aim of comparing RNA and protein enzymes is to learn about fundamental physical and chemical principles of biological catalysis. The more recently discovered RNA enzymes, or ribozymes, provide a distinct perspective on long-standing questions of biological catalysis. The differences described in this review have taught us about the aspects of RNA and proteins that are distinct, whereas the common features have helped us to understand the aspects that are fundamental to biological catalysis. This has allowed the framework that was put forth by Jencks for protein catalysts over 20 years ago (1) to be extended to RNA enzymes, generalized, and strengthened.