Identification of Carbonyl Modes of P700 and P700+ by in situ Chlorophyll Labeling in Photosystem I†

Tryptophan as a probe of photosystem I electron transfer reactions: a UV resonance Raman study

Photosystem I (PSI) is one of the two membrane-associated reaction centers involved in oxygenic photosynthesis. In photosynthesis, solar energy is converted to chemical energy in the form of a transmembrane charge separation. PSI oxidizes cytochrome c(6) or plastocyanin and reduces ferredoxin. In cyanobacterial PSI, there are 10 tryptophan residues with indole side chains located less than 10 A from the electron transfer cofactors. In this study, we apply pump-probe difference UV resonance Raman (UVRR) spectroscopy to acquire the spectrum of aromatic amino acids in cyanobacterial PSI. This UVRR technique allows the use of the tryptophan vibrational spectrum as a reporter for structural changes, which are linked to PSI electron transfer reactions. Our results show that photo-oxidation of the chlorophyll a/a' heterodimer, P(700), causes shifts in the vibrational frequencies of two or more tryptophan residues. Similar perturbations of tryptophan are observed when P(700) is chemically oxidized. The observed spectral frequencies suggest that the perturbed tryptophan side chains are only weakly or not hydrogen bonded and are located in an environment in which there is steric repulsion. The direction of the spectral shifts is consistent with an oxidation-induced increase in dielectric constant or a change in hydrogen bonding. To explain our results, the perturbation of tryptophan residues must be linked to a PSI conformational change, which is, in turn, driven by P(700) oxidation.

Calculation of the vibrational properties of chlorophyll a in solution

Chlorophyll a (Chl-a) is at the heart of solar energy capture and conversion in plants. Because of this, Chl-a has been the subject of innumerable studies. Recently, we have been able to use quantum mechanical methods to calculate the vibrational properties of neutral and oxidized Chl-a in the gas phase [Wang, R.; Parameswaran, S.; Hastings, G. Vib. Spectrosc. 2007, 44, 357-368]. The calculated vibrational properties do not agree with experiment, however. One factor ignored in our calculations was how solvents could impact the vibrational properties. Here we calculate the vibrational properties of Chl-a and Chl-a+ in several solvents that span a wide range of dielectric constant. The calculated and experimental (Chl-a+-Chl-a) infrared difference spectra now show a remarkable similarity. However, the composition of the calculated vibrational modes are very different from that suggested from experiment. We therefore use our calculated data to make new suggestions as to the origin of the bands in experimental (Chl-a+-Chl-a) FTIR difference spectra. We indicate why bands in experimental spectra may have been misassigned. We also point to other experimental data that support our new band assignments. Assignment of bands in (Chl-a+-Chl-a) FTIR difference spectra were first made nearly 20 years ago. These assignments have formed the basis for evaluating all "cation minus neutral" FTIR difference spectra obtained for all photosynthetic systems since then. All of these experimental FTIR difference spectra should be re-examined in light of our new assignments.

Light-induced dynamics in photosystem I electron transfer

Protein dynamics are likely to play important, regulatory roles in many aspects of photosynthetic electron transfer, but a detailed description of these coupled protein conformational changes has been unavailable. In oxygenic photosynthesis, photosystem I catalyzes the light-driven oxidation of plastocyanin or cytochrome c and the reduction of ferredoxin. A chlorophyll (chl) a/a' heterodimer, P(700), is the secondary electron donor, and the two P(700) chl, are designated P(A) and P(B). We used specific chl isotopic labeling and reaction-induced Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy to assign chl keto vibrational bands to P(A) and P(B). In the cyanobacterium, Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803, the chl keto carbon was labeled from (13)C-labeled glutamate, and the chl keto oxygen was labeled from (18)O(2). These isotope-based assignments provide new information concerning the structure of P(A)(+), which is found to give rise to two chl keto vibrational bands, with frequencies at 1653 and 1687 cm(-1). In contrast, P(A) gives rise to one chl keto band at 1638 cm(-1). The observation of two P(A)(+) keto frequencies is consistent with a protein relaxation-induced distribution in P(A)(+) hydrogen bonding. These results suggest a light-induced conformational change in photosystem I, which may regulate the oxidation of soluble electron donors and other electron-transfer reactions. This study provides unique information concerning the role of protein dynamics in oxygenic photosynthesis.

FTIR difference spectroscopy in combination with isotope labeling for identification of the carbonyl modes of P700 and P700+ in photosystem I

Room temperature, light induced (P700(+)-P700) Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) difference spectra have been obtained using photosystem I (PS I) particles from Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 that are unlabeled, uniformly (2)H labeled, and uniformly (15)N labeled. Spectra were also obtained for PS I particles that had been extensively washed and incubated in D(2)O. Previously, we have found that extensive washing and incubation of PS I samples in D(2)O does not alter the (P700(+)-P700) FTIR difference spectrum, even with approximately 50% proton exchange. This indicates that the P700 binding site is inaccessible to solvent water. Upon uniform (2)H labeling of PS I, however, the (P700(+)-P700) FTIR difference spectra are considerably altered. From spectra obtained using PS I particles grown in D(2)O and H(2)O, a ((1)H-(2)H) isotope edited double difference spectrum was constructed, and it is shown that all difference bands associated with ester/keto carbonyl modes of the chlorophylls of P700 and P700(+) downshift 4-5/1-3 cm(-1) upon (2)H labeling, respectively. It is also shown that the ester and keto carbonyl modes of the chlorophylls of P700 need not be heterogeneously distributed in frequency. Finally, we find no evidence for the presence of a cysteine mode in our difference spectra. The spectrum obtained using (2)H labeled PS I particles indicates that a negative difference band at 1698 cm(-1) is associated with at least two species. The observed (15)N and (2)H induced band shifts strongly support the idea that the two species are the 13(1) keto carbonyl modes of both chlorophylls of P700. We also show that a negative difference band at approximately 1639 cm(-1) is somewhat modified in intensity, but unaltered in frequency, upon (2)H labeling. This indicates that this band is not associated with a strongly hydrogen bonded keto carbonyl mode of one of the chlorophylls of P700.

Attenuated total reflection Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy of redox transitions in photosynthetic reaction centers: comparison of perfusion- and light-induced difference spectra

Chemically induced Fourier transform infrared difference spectra associated with redox transitions of several primary electron donors and acceptors in photosynthetic reaction centers (RCs) have been compared with the light-induced FTIR difference spectra involving the same cofactors. The RCs are deposited on an attenuated total reflection (ATR) prism and form a film that is enclosed in a flow cell. Redox transitions in the film of RCs can be repetitively induced either by perfusion of buffers poised at different redox potentials or by illumination. The perfusion-induced ATR-FTIR difference spectra for the oxidation of the primary electron donor P in the RCs of the purple bacteria Rb. sphaeroides and Rp. viridis and P700 in the photosystem 1 of Synechocystis 6803, as well as the Q(A)/Q(A) transition of the quinone acceptor (Q(A)) in Rb. sphaeroides RCs are reported for the first time. They are compared with the light-induced ATR-FTIR difference spectra P+Q(A)/PQ(A) for the RCs of Rb. sphaeroides and P700+/P700 for photosystem 1. It is shown that the perfusion-induced and light-induced ATR-FTIR difference spectra recorded on the same RC film display identical signal to noise ratios when they are measured under comparable conditions. The ATR-FTIR difference spectra are very similar to the equivalent FTIR difference spectra previously recorded upon photochemical or electrochemical excitation of these RCs in the more conventional transmission mode. The ATR-FTIR technique requires a smaller amount of sample compared with transmission FTIR and allows precise control of the aqueous environment of the RC films.

Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy of primary electron donors in type I photosynthetic reaction centers

The vibrational properties of the primary electron donors (P) of type I photosynthetic reaction centers, as investigated by Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) difference spectroscopy in the last 15 years, are briefly reviewed. The results obtained on the microenvironment of the chlorophyll molecules in P700 of photosystem I and of the bacteriochlorophyll molecules in P840 of the green bacteria (Chlorobium) and in P798 of heliobacteria are presented and discussed with special attention to the bonding interactions with the protein of the carbonyl groups and of the central Mg atom of the pigments. The observation of broad electronic transitions in the mid-IR for the cationic state of all the primary donors investigated provides evidence for charge repartition over two (B)Chl molecules. In the green sulfur bacteria and the heliobacteria, the assignments proposed for the carbonyl groups of P and P(+) are still very tentative. In contrast, the axial ligands of P700 in photosystem I have been identified and the vibrational properties of the chlorophyll (Chl) molecules involved in P700, P700(+), and (3)P700 are well described in terms of two molecules, denoted P(1) and P(2), with very different hydrogen bonding patterns. While P(1) has hydrogen bonds to both the 9-keto and the 10a-ester C=O groups and bears all the triplet character in (3)P700, the carbonyl groups of P(2) are free from hydrogen bonding. The positive charge in P700(+) is shared between the two Chl molecules with a ratio ranging from 1:1 to 2:1, in favor of P(2), depending on the temperature and the species. The localization of the triplet in (3)P700 and of the unpaired electron in P700(+) deduced from FTIR spectroscopy is in sharp contrast with that resulting from the analysis of the magnetic resonance experiments. However, the FTIR results are in excellent agreement with the most recent structural model derived from X-ray crystallography of photosystem I at 2.5 A resolution that reveals the hydrogen bonds to the carbonyl groups of the Chl in P700 as well as the histidine ligands of the central Mg atoms predicted from the FTIR data.