Dehydrobenzoyl Cations: Distonic Ions with Dual Free Radical and Acylium Ion Reactivity

Sequential radical and cationic reactivity at separated sites within one molecule in solution

Distonic radical cations (DRCs) with spatially separated charge and radical sites are expected to show both radical and cationic reactivity at different sites within one molecule. However, such "dual" reactivity has rarely been observed in the condensed phase. Herein we report the isolation of crystalline 1λ2,3λ2-1-phosphonia-3-phosphinyl-cyclohex-4-enes 2a,b˙+, which can be considered delocalized DRCs and were completely characterized by crystallographic, spectroscopic, and computational methods. These DRCs contain a radical and cationic site with seven and six valence electrons, respectively, which are both stabilized via conjugation, yet remain spatially separated. They exhibit reactivity that differs from that of conventional radical cations (CRCs); specifically they show sequential radical and cationic reactivity at separated sites within one molecule in solution.

An N-Heterocyclic-Carbene-Derived Distonic Radical Cation

We present the discovery of a novel radical cation formed through one-electron oxidation of an N-heterocyclic carbene-carbodiimide (NHC-CDI) zwitterionic adduct. This compound possesses a distonic electronic structure (spatially separate spin and charge regions) and displays persistence under ambient conditions. We demonstrate its application in a redox-flow battery exhibiting minimal voltage hysteresis, a flat voltage plateau, high Coulombic efficiency, and no performance decay for at least 100 cycles. The chemical tunability of NHCs and CDIs suggests that this approach could provide a general entry to redox-active NHC-CDI adducts and their persistent radical ions for various applications.

Mass Spectrometry of Cyclopentadienylideneketene: Differentiation of Isomeric Ion Structures by Means of Ion/Molecule Reactions

The nature of the m/z 104 ions formed by loss of CO2 or Ph-O-NCO from the molecular ions of phthalic anhydride, N-phenoxyphthalimide, and N-phenoxyisophthalimide was investigated by means of ion/molecule reactions with acetone. This allows a clear-cut differentiation of the so-obtained ions from the isomeric molecular ions of cyclopentadienylideneketene. The different intrinsic chemical reactivities of ionized cyclopentadienylideneketene and its distonoid isomer towards neutral acetone were investigated on a large-scale hybrid mass spectrometer and confirmed by density functional theory calculations.

Recognizing alpha-, beta- or gamma-substitution in pyridines by mass spectrometry

A general mass spectrometric method able to recognize the site of substitution of monosubstituted pyridines is described. The method requires that the molecule under investigation forms, upon ionization and dissociation, the respective alpha-, beta- or gamma- pyridinium ion of m/z 78. Pyridinium ions are stable and common fragments of ionized and protonated pyridines and are found to function as appropriate structurally diagnostic fragment ions. They can be identified by their characteristic and nearly identical collision-induced dissociation behavior and distinguished by the combined use of two structurally diagnostic ion/molecule reactions with acetonitrile and 2-methyl-1,3-dioxolane. alpha-, beta- or gamma-substitution in pyridines can, therefore, be securely recognized via an MS-only method based on structurally diagnostic ions and by the inspection of a single molecule (no need for intracomparisons within the whole set of isomers).

Intrinsic Gas-Phase Reactivity of Ionized 6-(Oxomethylene)cyclohexa-2,4-dienone: Evidence Pointing to Its Neutral α-Oxoketene Counterpart as a Proper Precursor of Various Benzopyran-4-ones and Analogues

Despite its unique structure and potential use as an important building block in organic synthesis, the title alpha-oxoketene 1 has been formed mostly under very special conditions as a short-lived species. The reactivity of 1 is, therefore, nearly unexplored. In great contrast, it seemed that its ionized gaseous form 1*+ is stable and easily accessible. In this study, we used multiple-stage pentaquadrupole mass spectrometry to probe the formation of gaseous 1*+ and explore its stability and intrinsic reactivity. With water and methanol, gaseous 1*+ was found to react similarly to solvated 1, which indicates that there is a close parallel between their reactivities. Gaseous 1*+ was also found to react promptly via polar [3 + 2] cycloadditons with various dienophiles including alkenes, alkynes, isocyanates, ketones and esters, thus forming a series of benzopyran-4-ones (flavones, 4-chromanones, 4-chromenones, benzo[1,3]dioxin-4-ones, and analogues) that are common structural units in many natural products. The present availability of 1 at room temperature and the gas-phase findings reported herein for gaseous 1*+ indicate that solvated 1 should undergo many [4 + 2] cycloadditions and functions as a versatile precursor of a variety of biologically active molecules.

Distonoid ions

By Yates, Bouma, and Radom's definition, distonic radical ions are those formally arising by ionization of diradicals or zwitterionic molecules (including ylides). These ions differ, therefore, from conventional radical ions by displaying the charge site and unpaired electron site (spin) localized mandatorily on separate atoms or group of atoms; that is, these sites are separated in all of their major resonance forms. Many conventional radical ions with a major resonance form in which charge and spin sites reside formally on the same atom or group of atoms display, however, high degree of discretionary (non-mandatory) charge-spin separation. By analogy with the metal/metalloid terminology, we propose that these distonic-like radical ions be classified as distonoid ions. Radical ions would, therefore, be divided into three sub-classes: conventional, distonic, and distonoid ions. B3LYP/6-311 + G(d,p) calculations for a proof-of-principle set of radical cations are used to demonstrate the existence of many types of distonoid ions with a high degree of discretionary charge-spin separation. Reliable calculations are indispensable for probing distonoid ions, since an ion that was expected to be distonoid (by the analysis of its resonance forms) is shown by the calculations to display a characteristic conventional-ion electronic distribution. Similarly to many distonic radical ions, and in sharp contrast to a conventional radical ion (ionized 1,4-dioxane), the gas-phase intrinsic bimolecular reactivity with selective neutrals of a representative distonoid ion, ionized 2-methylene 1,3-dioxolane, is found to include dual ion-radical type reactions.

Meerwein reaction of phosphonium ions with epoxides and thioepoxides in the gas phase

Phosphonium ions are shown to undergo a gas-phase Meerwein reaction in which epoxides (or thioepoxides) undergo three-to-five-membered ring expansion to yield dioxaphospholanium (or oxathiophospholanium) ion products. When the association reaction is followed by collision-induced dissociation (CID), the oxirane (or thiirane) is eliminated, making this ion molecule reaction/CID sequence a good method of net oxygen-by-sulfur replacement in the phosphonium ions. This replacement results in a characteristic mass shift of 16 units and provides evidence for the cyclic nature of the gas-phase Meerwein product ions, while improving selectivity for phosphonium ion detection. This reaction sequence also constitutes a gas-phase route to convert phosphonium ions into their sulfur analogs. Phosphonium and related ions are important targets since they are commonly and readily formed in mass spectrometric analysis upon dissociative electron ionization of organophosphorous esters. The Meerwein reaction should provide a new and very useful method of recognizing compounds that yield these ions, which includes a number of chemical warfare agents. The Meerwein reaction proceeds by phosphonium ion addition to the sulfur or oxygen center, followed by intramolecular nucleophilic attack with ring expansion to yield the 1,3,2-dioxaphospholanium or 1,3,2-oxathiophospholanium ion. Product ion structures were investigated by CID tandem mass spectrometry (MS(2)) experiments and corroborated by DFT/HF calculations.

Ionic Transacetalization with Acylium Ions: A Class-Selective and Structurally Diagnostic Reaction for Cyclic Acetals Performed under Unique Electrospray and Atmospheric Pressure Chemical Ionization In-Source Ion−Molecule Reaction Conditions

Ionic transacetalization of cyclic acetals with the gaseous (CH3)2NCO+ acylium ion has been performed under unique in-source ion-molecule reaction (in-source IMR) conditions of electrospray (ESI) and atmospheric pressure chemical ionization (APCI). In-source IMR under ESI and APCI greatly expands the range of neutral molecules that can be brought to the gas phase to react by ionic transacetalization, a general, class-selective and structurally diagnostic reaction for cyclic acetals (Moraes, L. A. B.; Gozzo, F. C.; Vainiotalo, P.; Eberlin, M. N. J. Org. Chem. 1997, 62, 5096). Heavier, more polar, and less volatile cyclic acetals than those previously employed in quadrupole collision cells are shown to react efficiently by ionic transacetalization under the ESI and APCI in-source IMR conditions. Tetramethylurea (TMU) acts as an efficient dopant, being co-injected with the acetal in either benzene, toluene, methanol, or water/methanol solutions. Under APCI or ESI, the basic TMU dopant is protonated preferentially, and the labile protonated TMU then undergoes dissociation to (CH3)2NCO+, the least acidic and the most transacetalization-reactive acylium ion so far tested. Under the relatively high-pressure, low-energy collision conditions set to favor associative reactions, (CH3)2NCO+ reacts competitively both with TMU to form acylated TMU and with the acetal via ionic transacetalization to form the respective cyclic ionic acetals. Spectrum subtraction removes the ionic products of the dopant (TMU) self-reactions, thus providing clean ion-molecule reaction product ion mass spectra, which are used for the selective, structurally diagnostic detection of cyclic acetals. Information on ring substituents comes from characteristic mass shifts resulting from aldehyde/ketone by acylium ion replacement. Enhanced selectivity in structural characterization or chemical recognition for cyclic acetal monitoring is gained by performing on-line collision-induced dissociation via tandem mass spectrometric experiments. Most cyclic ionic acetals dissociate exclusively or nearly exclusively to re-form the reactant (CH3)2NCO+ acylium ion whereas the presence of additional functional groups with increased structural complexity tends to favor other specific but likewise selective dissociation channels.

Reactions of gaseous acylium ions with 1,3-dienes: further evidence for polar [4 + 2+] Diels-Alder cycloaddition

A novel reaction of acylium and thioacylium ions, polar [4 + 2(+)] Diels-Alder cycloaddition with 1,3-dienes and O-heterodienes, has been systematically investigated in the gas phase (Eberlin MN, Cooks RG. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1993; 115: 9226). This polar cycloaddition, yet without precedent in solution, likely forms cyclic 2,5-dihydropyrylium ions. Here we report the reactions of gaseous acylium ions [(CH(3))(2)N-C(+)=O, Ph-C(+)=O, (CH(3))(2)N-C(+)=S, CH(3)-C(+)=O, CH(3)CH(2)-C(+)=O, and CH(2)=CH-C(+)=O] with several 1-oxy-substituted 1,3-dienes of the general formula RO-CH=CH-C(R(1))=CH(2), which were performed to collect further evidence for cycloaddition. In reactions with 1-methoxy and 1-(trimethylsilyloxy)-1,3-butadiene, adducts are formed to a great extent, but upon collision activation they mainly undergo structurally unspecific retro-addition dissociation. In reactions with Danishefsky's diene (trans-1-methoxy-3-(trimethylsilyloxy)-1,3-butadiene), adducts are also formed to great extents, but retro-addition is no longer their major dissociation; the ions dissociate instead mainly to a common fragment, the methoxyacryl cation of m/z 85. This fragment ion is most likely formed with the intermediacy of the acyclic adduct, which isomerizes prior to dissociation by a trimethylsilyl cation shift. Theoretical calculations predict that meta cycloadducts bearing 1-methoxy and 1-trimethylsilyloxy substituents are unstable, undergoing barrierless ring opening induced by the charge-stabilizing effect of the 1-oxy substituents. In contrast, for the reactions with 1-acetoxy-1,3-butadiene, both the experimental results and theoretical calculations point to the formation of intrinsically stable cycloadducts, but the intact cycloadducts are either not observed or observed in low abundances. Both the isomeric ortho and meta cycloadducts are likely formed, but the nascent ions dissociate to great extents owing to excess internal energy. The ortho cycloadducts dissociate by ketene loss; the meta cycloadducts undergo intramolecular proton transfer to the acetoxy group followed by dissociation by acetic acid loss to yield aromatic pyrylium ions. Either or both of these dissociations, ketene and/or acetic acid loss, dominate over the otherwise favored retro-Diels-Alder alternative. The pyrylium ion products therefore constitute compelling evidence for polar [4 + 2(+)] cycloaddition since their formation can only be rationalized with the intermediacy of cyclic adducts.

Ketalization of phosphonium ions by 1,4-dioxane: selective detection of the chemical warfare agent simulant DMMP in mixtures using ion/molecule reactions

Phosphonium ions CH(3)P(O)OCH(3)(+) (93 Th) and CH(3)OP(O)OCH(3)(+) (109 Th) react with 1,4-dioxane to form unique cyclic ketalization products, 1,3,2-dioxaphospholanium ions. By contrast, a variety of other types of ions having multiple bonds, including the acylium ions CH(3)CO(+) (43 Th), CH(3)OCO(+) (59 Th), (CH(3))(2)NCO(+) (72 Th), and PhCO(+) (105 Th), the iminium ion H(2)C[double bond]NHC(2)H(5)(+) (58 Th) and the carbosulfonium ion H(2)C[double bond]SC(2)H(5)(+) (75 Th) do not react with 1,4-dioxane under the same conditions. The characteristic ketalization reaction can also be observed when CH(3)P(OH)(OCH(3))(2)(+), viz. protonated dimethyl methylphosphonate (DMMP), collides with 1,4-dioxane, as a result of fragmentation to yield the reactive phosphonium ion CH(3)P(O)OCH(3)(+) (93 Th). This novel ion/molecule reaction is highly selective to phosphonium ions and can be applied to identify DMMP selectively in the presence of ketone, ester, and amide compounds using a neutral gain MS/MS scan. This method of DMMP analysis can be applied to aqueous solutions using electrospray ionization; it shows a detection limit in the low ppb range and a linear response over the range 10 to 500 ppb.

Mono and double polar [4 + 2(+)] Diels-Alder cycloaddition of acylium ions with O-heterodienes

Gas-phase reactions of acylium ions with alpha,beta-unsaturated carbonyl compounds were investigated using pentaquadrupole multiple-stage mass spectrometry. With acrolein and metacrolein, CH(3)-C(+)(double bond)O, CH(2)(double bond)CH-C(+)(double bond)O, C(6)H(5)-C(+)(double bond)O, and (CH(3))(2)N-C(+)(double bond)O react to variable extents by mono and double polar [4 + 2(+)] Diels-Alder cycloaddition. With ethyl vinyl ketone, CH(3)-C(+)(double bond)O reacts exclusively by proton transfer and C(6)H(5)-C(+)(double bond)O forms only the mono cycloadduct whereas CH(2)(double bond)CH-C(+)(double bond)O and (CH(3))(2)N-C(+)(double bond)O reacts to great extents by mono and double cycloaddition. The positively charged acylium ions are activated O-heterodienophiles, and mono cycloaddition occurs readily across their C(+)(double bond)O bonds to form resonance-stabilized 1,3-dioxinylium ions which, upon collisional activation, dissociate predominantly by retro-addition. The mono cycloadducts are also dienophiles activated by resonance-stabilized and chemically inert 1,3-dioxonium ion groups, hence they undergo a second cycloaddition across their polarized C(double bond)C ring double bonds. (18)O labeling and characteristic dissociations displayed by the double cycloadducts indicate the site and regioselectivity of double cycloaddition, which are corroborated by Becke3LYP/6-311++G(d,p) calculations. Most double cycloadducts dissociate by the loss of a RCO(2)COR(1) molecule and by a pathway that reforms the acylium ion directly. The double cycloadduct of the thioacylium ion (CH(3))(2)N-C(+)(double bond)S with acrolein dissociates to (CH(3))(2)N-C(+)(double bond)O in a sulfur-by-oxygen replacement process intermediated by the cyclic monoadduct. The double cycloaddition can be viewed as a charge-remote type of polar [4 + 2(+)] Diels-Alder cycloaddition reaction.

Mass spectrometric studies of organic ion/molecule reactions

In the past 25 years, a tremendous amount of work has been published on the ion/molecule reactions of organic species. This review provides an overview of the areas where gas phase ion chemistry has made a contribution to our understanding of fundamental organic reaction processes. It is clear that the gas phase work can provide insights into subtle features of reaction mechanisms that could not be addressed by conventional condensed phase methods. The study of ion/molecule reactions has already had a major impact on the way that organic chemists think about reaction mechanisms and interpret substituent effects. Moreover, it has heightened our awareness of the importance of solvation effects and how they can alter not only absolute rates but also relative rates, leading in some cases to complete reversals in reactivity patterns. A large body of work could not be included in this review due to space limitations. For example, the study of thermochemistry in the gas phase (i.e., acidities, basicities, bond strengths, binding energies, etc.) has provided a wealth of data that has been exceptionally useful in interpreting organic reaction mechanisms. This has spilled over into the study of organometallic systems, and several groups are making major headway in using mass spectrometry to probe the stability and reactivity of transition metal species. Finally, work involving chemical ionization has provided abundant information on gas phase reaction mechanisms. The future appears to be very promising for the study of gas phase organic reaction mechanisms. In particular, the emergence of new ionization techniques and more powerful mass analyzers will allow chemists to explore a wider range of species. Although still at an early stage, the gas phase study of biochemical transformations offers great promise and has been facilitated by electrospray and matrix assisted laser desorption ionization methods. In addition, these techniques provide a means for introducing important, metal-centered catalytic species into the gas phase and exploring the details of their reactivity. Finally, mass spectrometry continues to play a major role in the study of atmospheric ion chemistry and is providing important kinetic as well as mechanistic data.

Ketalization of gaseous acylium ions

A novel reaction of gaseous acylium ions: ketalization with diols and analogs, has been systematically studied via pentaquadrupole MS2 and MS3 experiments and ab initio calculations. A variety of alpha,beta-diols and their amino, thiol, ether, and thioether analogs have been tested for reactivity, mechanism evaluation, site selectivity, and for the effects of alpha- and beta-interfunctional separation. As for condensed-phase ketalization of neutral carbonyl compounds followed by hydrolysis, gaseous acylium ions are chemically deactivated in the form of cyclic ionic ketals by ketalization, and are efficiently released via on-line collision-induced dissociation. Ketalization of acylium ions is shown to identify and structurally characterize alpha,beta-diols and their analogs, and to distinguish regioisomers. Diastereomers can also be distinguished, as illustrated for cis and trans 1,2-diaminocyclohexane. The MS2 and MS3 data together with 18O-labeling and ab initio calculations establish for acylium ion ketalization a mechanism of anchimeric assistance with participation of the neighboring acyl group.

Transacetalization with gaseous carboxonium and carbosulfonium ions

Primary carboxonium (H2C=O+-R) and carbosulfonium (H2C=S+-R) ions (R = CH3, C2H5, Ph) and the prototype five-membered cyclic carboxonium ion are found to react in the gas phase with cyclic acetals and ketals by transacetalization to form the respective O-alkyl-1,3-dioxolanium and S-alkyl-1,3-oxathiolanium ions. The reaction, which competes mainly with proton transfer and hydride abstraction, initiates by O-alkylation and proceeds by ring opening and recyclization via intramolecular displacement of the carbonyl compound previously protected in its ketal form. As indicated by product ion mass spectra, and confirmed by competitive reactions, carbosulfonium ions are, by transacetalization, much more reactive than carboxonium ions. For acyclic secondary and tertiary carboxonium ions bearing acidic alpha-hydrogens, little or no transacetalization occurs and proton transfer dominates. This structurally related reactivity distinguishes primary from both secondary and tertiary ions, as exemplified for the two structural isomers H2C=O+-C2H5 and CH3C(H)=O+-CH3. The prototype five- and six-membered cyclic carboxonium ions react mainly by proton transfer and adduct formation, but the five-membered ring ion also reacts by transacetalization to a medium extent. Upon CID, the transacetalization products of the primary ions often dissociate by loss of formaldehyde, and a +44 u neutral gain/-30 u neutral loss MS3 scan is shown to efficiently detect reactive carboxonium and carbosulfonium ions. Transacetalization with either carboxonium or carbosulfonium ions provides a route to 1,3-oxathiolanes and analogs alkylated selectively either at the sulfur or oxygen atom.

Acyclic distonic acylium ions: dual free radical and acylium ion reactivity in a single molecule

Three gaseous acyclic distonic acylium ions: *CH2-CH2-C+=O, *CH2-CH2-CH2-C+=O, and *CH2=C(CH2)-C+=O, are found to display dual free radical and acylium ion reactivity; with appropriate neutrals, they react selectively either as free radicals with inert charge sites, or (and more pronouncedly) as acylium ions with inert radical sites. The free radical reactivity of the ions is demonstrated via the Kenttamaa reaction: CH3S* abstraction with the spin trap dimethyl disulfide; their ion reactivity by two reactions most characteristic of acylium ions: transacetalization with 2-methyl-1,3-dioxolane and the gas-phase Meerwein reaction, that is, expansion of the three-membered epoxide ring of epichlorohydrin to the five-membered 1,3-dioxolanylium ion ring. In "one-pot" reactions with gaseous mixtures of epichlorohydrin and dimethyl disulfide, the ions react selectively at either site, but more readily at the acylium charge site, to form the two mono-derivatized ions. Further reaction at either the remaining free radical or acylium charge site forms a single bi-derivatized ion as the final product. Becke3LYP/6-31G(d) calculations predict the reactions at the acylium charge sites of the three distonic ions to be highly exothermic, and both the "hot" transacetalization and epoxide ring expansion products of *CH2-CH2-CH2-C+=O to dissociate rapidly by H2C=CH2 loss in overall exothermic processes. The calculations also predict highly spatially separate odd spin and charge sites for the novel cyclic distonic ketal ions formed by the reactions at the acylium charge sites.

Double transacetalization of diacylium ions

A novel gas-phase reaction of diacylium ions of the O=C=X(+)=C=O type (X = N, CH) is reported: double transacetalization with cyclic acetals or ketals. The reaction is exothermic and highly efficient, and forms members of a new class of highly charged-delocalized ions: cyclic ionic diketals. Pentaquadrupole double- and triple-stage mass spectrometric (MS(2) and MS(3)) experiments reveal the high double transacetalization reactivity of O=C=N(+)=C=O and O=C=CH(+)=C=O, whereas the synthesis of differently substituted cyclic ionic diketals is performed in MS(3) experiments via sequential mono- and double transacetalization of O=C=N(+)=C=O and O=C=CH(+)=C=O with different acetals. With cyclic acetals, the acylium-thioacylium ion O=C=N(+)=C=S reacts promptly and selectively by mono-transacetalization at its acylium site, but the free thiacylium site of its cyclic ionic ketal is nearly unreactive by double transacetalization. Therefore, only the acylium site of O=C=N(+)=C=S can be efficiently protected by transacetalization. Low-energy MS(3) collision-induced dissociation of the cyclic ionic diketals of O=C=N(+)=C=O and O=C=CH(+)=C=O sequentially frees each of the protected acylium site to form the mono-derivatized ion, and then the fully deprotected diacylium ion.