Well-Defined Molybdenum Oxo Alkyl Complex Supported on Silica by Surface Organometallic Chemistry: A Highly Active Olefin Metathesis Precatalyst

Revisiting the Potential of Group VI Inorganic Precatalysts for the Ethenolysis of Fatty Acids through a Mechanochemical Approach

The utilization of biobased feedstocks to prepare useful compounds is a pivotal trend in current chemical research. Among a varied portfolio of naturally available starting materials, fatty acids are abundant, versatile substrates with multiple applications. In this context, the ethenolysis of unsaturated fatty acid esters such as methyl oleate is an atom-economical way to prepare functional C10 olefins with a biobased footprint. Despite the existence of a variety of metathesis catalysts for the latter process, there is a lack of readily available, efficient, and inexpensive catalytic systems based on earth-abundant metals (Mo, W) whose preparation does not require sophisticated syntheses and manipulations. Here, a systematic exploration of homogeneous and heterogeneous inorganic Mo, W (oxy)halides shows that MoOCl4, while inactive as a homogeneous species, forms active and selective silica-supported ethenolysis precatalysts able to reach equilibrium conversion of methyl oleate within a few minutes upon activation with SnMe4. Such heterogeneous MoOCl4-based precatalysts were easily accessed through mechanochemical solvent-free procedures and found to contain, upon characterization by elemental analysis and Raman spectroscopy, isolated (≡SiO)Mo(=O)Cl3 units or polymeric silica-supported [-O(≡SiO)nMoCl4-nO-]m (n = 1, 2) complexes depending on the molybdenum loading. The former isolated species exhibited a higher catalytic performance. The developed heterogeneous precatalysts could be applied to the ethenolysis of various substrates, including polyunsaturated fatty acid esters and industrial fatty acid methyl ester (FAME) mixtures from palm oil transesterification.

Well-defined diatomic catalysis for photosynthesis of C2H4 from CO2

Owing to the specific electronic-redistribution and spatial proximity, diatomic catalysts (DACs) have been identified as principal interest for efficient photoconversion of CO2 into C2H4. However, the predominant bottom-up strategy for DACs synthesis has critically constrained the development of highly ordered DACs due to the random distribution of heteronuclear atoms, which hinders the optimization of catalytic performance and the exploration of actual reaction mechanism. Here, an up-bottom ion-cutting architecture is proposed to fabricate the well-defined DACs, and the superior spatial proximity of CuAu diatomics (DAs) decorated TiO2 (CuAu-DAs-TiO2) is successfully constructed due to the compact heteroatomic spacing (2-3 Å). Owing to the profoundly low C-C coupling energy barrier of CuAu-DAs-TiO2, a considerable C2H4 production with superior sustainability is achieved. Our discovery inspires a novel up-bottom strategy for the fabrication of well-defined DACs to motivate optimization of catalytic performance and distinct deduction of heteroatom synergistically catalytic mechanism.

Single-Site Carbon-Supported Metal-Oxo Complexes in Heterogeneous Catalysis: Structure, Reactivity, and Mechanism

When early transition metal complexes are molecularly grafted onto catalyst supports, well-defined, surface-bound species are created, which are highly active and selective single-site heterogeneous catalysts (SSHCs) for diverse chemical transformations. In this minireview, we analyze and summarize a less conventional type of SSHC in which molybdenum dioxo species are grafted onto unusual carbon-unsaturated scaffolds, such as activated carbon, reduced graphene oxide, and carbon nanohorns. The choice of earth-abundant, low-toxicity, versatile metal constituents, and various carbon supports illustrates "catalyst by design" principles and yields insights into new catalytic systems of both academic and technological interest. Here, we summarize experimental and computational investigations of the bonding, electronic structure, reaction scope, and mechanistic pathways of these unusual catalysts.

Surface and Interface Coordination Chemistry Learned from Model Heterogeneous Metal Nanocatalysts: From Atomically Dispersed Catalysts to Atomically Precise Clusters

The surface and interface coordination structures of heterogeneous metal catalysts are crucial to their catalytic performance. However, the complicated surface and interface structures of heterogeneous catalysts make it challenging to identify the molecular-level structure of their active sites and thus precisely control their performance. To address this challenge, atomically dispersed metal catalysts (ADMCs) and ligand-protected atomically precise metal clusters (APMCs) have been emerging as two important classes of model heterogeneous catalysts in recent years, helping to build bridge between homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysis. This review illustrates how the surface and interface coordination chemistry of these two types of model catalysts determines the catalytic performance from multiple dimensions. The section of ADMCs starts with the local coordination structure of metal sites at the metal-support interface, and then focuses on the effects of coordinating atoms, including their basicity and hardness/softness. Studies are also summarized to discuss the cooperativity achieved by dual metal sites and remote effects. In the section of APMCs, the roles of surface ligands and supports in determining the catalytic activity, selectivity, and stability of APMCs are illustrated. Finally, some personal perspectives on the further development of surface coordination and interface chemistry for model heterogeneous metal catalysts are presented.

Atomic-Scale View of Redox Induced Changes for Monolayer MoOx on α-TiO2(110) with Chemical-State Sensitivity

Supported molybdenum oxide (MoOx) plays an important role in catalytic transformations from alcohol dehydrogenation to transesterification. During these reactions, molybdenum and oxygen surface species undergo structural and chemical changes. A detailed, chemical-state specific, atomic-scale structural analysis of the catalyst under redox conditions is important for improving catalytic properties. In this study, a monolayer of Mo grown on α-TiO2(110) by atomic-layer deposition is analyzed by X-ray standing wave (XSW) excited X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). The chemical shifts for Mo 2p3/2 and O 1s peaks are used to distinguish Mo6+ from Mo4+ and surface O from bulk O. Excitation of XPS by XSW allows pinpointing the location of these surface species relative to the underlying substrate lattice. Measured 3D composite atomic density maps for the oxidized and reduced interfaces compare well with our density functional theory models and collectively create a unique view of the redox-driven dynamics for this complex catalytic structure.

Tuning metathesis performance of molybdenum oxide-based catalyst by silica support acidity modulation and high temperature pretreatment

Molybdenum oxide-based catalysts containing 5 wt. % of Mo obtained by simple impregnation of silica mesoporous support were studied in olefin metathesis reaction at 50 °C. Effect of support modification...

Synthesis and Structure-Activity Characterization of a Single-Site MoO2 Catalytic Center Anchored on Reduced Graphene Oxide

Molecularly derived single-site heterogeneous catalysts can bridge the understanding and performance gaps between conventional homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysis, guiding the rational design of next-generation catalysts. While impressive advances have been made with well-defined oxide supports, the structural complexity of other supports and the nature of the grafted surface species present an intriguing challenge. In this study, single-site Mo(═O)₂ species grafted onto reduced graphene oxide (rGO/MoO₂) are characterized by XPS, DRIFTS, powder XRD, N₂ physisorption, NH₃-TPD, aqueous contact angle, active site poisoning assay, Mo EXAFS, model compound single-crystal XRD, DFT, and catalytic performance. NH₃-TPD reveals that the anchored MoO₂ moiety is not strongly acidic, while Mo 3d_5/2 XPS assigns the oxidation state as Mo(VI), and XRD shows little rGO periodicity change on MoO₂ grafting. Contact angle analysis shows that MoO₂ grafting consumes rGO surface polar groups, yielding a more hydrophobic surface. The rGO/MoO₂ DRIFTS assigns features at 959 and 927 cm^-1 to the symmetric and antisymmetric Mo═O stretching modes, respectively, of an isolated cis-(O═Mo═O) moiety, in agreement with DFT computation. Moreover, the Mo EXAFS rGO/MoO₂ structural data are consistent with isolated (C-O)₂-Mo(═O)₂ species having two Mo═O bonds and two Mo-O bonds at distances of 1.69(3) and 1.90(3) Å, respectively. rGO/MoO₂ is also more active than the previously reported AC/MoO₂ catalyst, with reductive carbonyl coupling TOFs approaching 1.81 × 10³ h^-1. rGO/MoO₂ is environmentally robust and multiply recyclable with 69 ± 2% of the Mo sites catalytically significant. Overall, rGO/MoO₂ is a structurally well-defined and versatile single-site Mo(VI) dioxo heterogeneous catalytic system.

Effect of Lewis Acids on the Catalyst Activity for Alkene Metathesis, Z-/E- Selectivity and Stability of Tungsten Oxo Alkylidenes

Lewis acids increase the catalytic activity of classical heterogeneous catalysts and molecular d0 tungsten oxo alkylidenes in a variety of olefin metathesis processes. The formation of labile adducts between the metal complex and the Lewis acid has been observed experimentally and suggested to be involved in the catalyst activity increase. In this contribution, DFT (M06) calculations have been performed to determine the role of Lewis acids on catalyst activity, Z-/E- selectivity and stability by comparing three W(E)(CHR)(2,5-dimethylpyrrolide)(O-2,6-dimesithylphenoxide) (E = oxo, imido or oxo-Lewis acid adduct) alkylidenes. Results show that the formation of the alkylidene—Lewis acid adducts influences the reactivity of tungsten oxo alkylidenes due to both steric and electronic effects. The addition of the Lewis acid on the E group increases its bulkiness and this decreases catalyst Z-selectivity. Moreover, the interaction between the oxo ligand and the Lewis acid decreases the donating ability of the former toward the metal. This is important when the oxo group has either a ligand in trans or in the same plane that is competing for the same metal d orbitals. Therefore, the weakening of oxo donating ability facilitates the cycloaddition and cycloreversion steps and it stabilizes the productive trigonal bipyramid metallacyclobutane isomer. The two factors increase the catalytic activity of the complex. The electron donating tuneability by the coordination of the Lewis acid also applies to catalyst deactivation and particularly the key β-hydride elimination step. In this process, the transition states show a ligand in pseudo trans to the oxo. Therefore, the presence of the Lewis acid decreases the Gibbs energy barrier significantly. Overall, the optimization of the E group donating ability in each step of the reaction makes tungsten oxo alkylidenes more reactive and this applies both for the catalytic activity and catalyst deactivation.

Room-Temperature Metathesis of Ethylene with 2-Butene to Propene Over MoOx-Based Catalysts: Mixed Oxides as Perspective Support Materials

We investigated the effect of supports based on ZrO2, TiO2, Al2O3, and SiO2 on the rate of propene formation in the metathesis of ethylene with 2-butene at 50 °C over Mo-containing catalysts possessing highly dispersed MoOx. Large improvements in this rate were achieved when using supports composed of mixed oxides (ZrO2–SiO2, ZrO2–PO4, TiO2–SiO2; Al2O3–SiO2) rather than of individual oxides (ZrO2, TiO2, Al2O3, SiO2). Although previous literature studies dealing with the metathesis reaction over Al2O3- or SiO2-suppported catalysts at higher temperatures suggest the importance of redox or acidic properties of supported MoOx species for catalyst activity, we were not able to establish any general direct correlation in this regard. Contrarily, the rate of propene formation can be significantly enhanced when promoting supports with an oxide promoter. We suggest that the created support lattice defects may facilitate the transformation of MoOx to Mo carbenes under reaction conditions or improve the intrinsic activity of the latter.

Graphic Abstract

Olefin metathesis: what have we learned about homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysts from surface organometallic chemistry?

Since its early days, olefin metathesis has been in the focus of scientific discussions and technology development. While heterogeneous olefin metathesis catalysts based on supported group 6 metal oxides have been used for decades in the petrochemical industry, detailed mechanistic studies and the development of molecular organometallic chemistry have led to the development of robust and widely used homogeneous catalysts based on well-defined alkylidenes that have found applications for the synthesis of fine and bulk chemicals and are also used in the polymer industry. The development of the chemistry of high-oxidation group 5-7 alkylidenes and the use of surface organometallic chemistry (SOMC) principles unlocked the preparation of so-called well-defined supported olefin metathesis catalysts. The high activity and stability (often superior to their molecular analogues) and molecular-level characterisation of these systems, that were first reported in 2001, opened the possibility for the first direct structure-activity relationships for supported metathesis catalysts. This review describes first the history of SOMC in the field of olefin metathesis, and then focuses on what has happened since 2007, the date of our last comprehensive reviews in this field.

Meziane K, Kaddouri A, Nguyen HP, Taoufik M. Well-defined surface tungstenocarbyne complex through the reaction of [W(CtBu)(CH2tBu)3] with CeO2: a highly stable precatalyst for NOx reduction with NH3

A highly-efficient NH₃-SCR single site catalyst W(CtBu)(CH₂tBu)₃/CeO_2–200, was prepared by surface organometallic chemistry approach. This catalyst showed high catalytic activity and stability with a broad operational temperature window.

Silica-supported Nb(iii)–CH3 species can act as an efficient catalyst for the non-oxidative coupling of methane

The Nb(iii)–CH₃ catalyst lowers the energetic span of the whole catalytic cycle over its Ta and V analogues.

The Comparison between Single Atom Catalysis and Surface Organometallic Catalysis

Single atom catalysis (SAC) is a recent discipline of heterogeneous catalysis for which a single atom on a surface is able to carry out various catalytic reactions. A kind of revolution in heterogeneous catalysis by metals for which it was assumed that specific sites or defects of a nanoparticle were necessary to activate substrates in catalytic reactions. In another extreme of the spectrum, surface organometallic chemistry (SOMC), and, by extension, surface organometallic catalysis (SOMCat), have demonstrated that single atoms on a surface, but this time with specific ligands, could lead to a more predictive approach in heterogeneous catalysis. The predictive character of SOMCat was just the result of intuitive mechanisms derived from the elementary steps of molecular chemistry. This review article will compare the aspects of single atom catalysis and surface organometallic catalysis by considering several specific catalytic reactions, some of which exist for both fields, whereas others might see mutual overlap in the future. After a definition of both domains, a detailed approach of the methods, mostly modeling and spectroscopy, will be followed by a detailed analysis of catalytic reactions: hydrogenation, dehydrogenation, hydrogenolysis, oxidative dehydrogenation, alkane and cycloalkane metathesis, methane activation, metathetic oxidation, CO₂ activation to cyclic carbonates, imine metathesis, and selective catalytic reduction (SCR) reactions. A prospective resulting from present knowledge is showing the emergence of a new discipline from the overlap between the two areas.

Molybdenum-Incorporated Mesoporous Silica: Surface Engineering toward Enhanced Metal-Support Interactions and Efficient Hydrogenation

In heterogeneous catalysis, strong metal-support interactions are highly desired to improve catalytic turnover on metal catalysts. Herein, molybdenum is uniformly incorporated into mesoporous silica (KIT-6) to accomplish strong interactions with iridium catalysts, and consequently, active and selective hydrogenation of carbonyl compounds. Mo-incorporated KIT-6 (Mo-KIT-6) affords electronic interactions to improve the proportion of metallic Ir⁰ species, avoiding the easy surface oxidation of ultrafine metals in silica mesocavities. Owing to the effective H₂ activation and subsequent hydrogenation on metallic Ir⁰ sites, optimal Ir/Mo-KIT-6 with a high Ir⁰/Ir^δ+ ratio delivers prominent performance in the hydrogenation of amides to amines and α,β-unsaturated aldehydes to unsaturated alcohols. As for N-acetylmorpholine hydrogenation, the Ir/Mo-KIT-6 catalyst achieves efficient turnover toward N-ethylmorpholine with high selectivity (>99%) and exhibits activity that relies on the engineered chemical state of Ir sites. Such promotion is further proved to be universal in cinnamaldehyde hydrogenation. This work will provide new opportunities for catalyst design through surface/interface engineering.

Surface organometallic chemistry in heterogeneous catalysis

Surface organometallic chemistry has been reviewed with a special focus on environmentally relevant transformations (C–H activation, CO₂conversion, oxidation).

Innovative Sol-Gel Routes for the Bottom-Up Preparation of Heterogeneous Catalysts

Heterogeneous catalysts can be prepared by different methods offering various levels of control on the final properties of the solid. In this account, we exemplify bottom-up preparation routes that are based on the sol-gel chemistry and allow to tailor some decisive properties of solid catalysts. First, an emulsion templating strategy is shown to lead to macrocellular self-standing monoliths with a macroscopic 3D structure. The latter can be used as catalyst or catalyst supports in flow chemistry, without requiring any subsequent shaping step. Second, the aerosol-assisted sol-gel process allows for the one-step and continuous production of porous mixed oxides. Tailored textural properties can be obtained together with an excellent control on composition and homogeneity. Third, the application of non-hydrolytic sol-gel routes, in the absence of water, leads to mixed oxides with outstanding textural properties and with peculiar surface chemistry. In all cases, the resulting catalytic performance can be correlated with the specificities of the preparation routes presented. This is exemplified in catalytic reactions in the fields of biomass conversion, petro chemistry, enantioselective organic synthesis, and air pollution mitigation.

MoO2 Formed on Mesoporous Graphene Oxide: Efficient and Stable Catalyst for Epoxidation of Olefins

A novel mesoporous MoO2 composite supported on graphene oxide (m-MoO2/GO) has been designed and applied as an efficient epoxidation catalyst. The m-MoO2/GO composite was characterised by X-ray diffraction, Raman spectroscopy, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, Brunauer–Emmet–Teller surface area analysis, field emission scanning electron microscopy, and transmission electron microscopy. Compared with pure mesoporous MoO2 (m-MoO2) and amorphous MoO2-graphene oxide (a-MoO2/GO), m-MoO2/GO exhibits the best catalytic activity. The conversion and selectivity for cyclooctene are both over 99 % in 6 h. Remarkably, the mesoporous structure in m-MoO2/GO which derives from SiO2 nanospheres endows the catalyst better catalytic performance for long chain olefins: the conversion of methyl oleate can be as high as 82 %. Such a robust catalyst can be easily recycled and reused five times without significant loss of catalytic activity. This novel catalyst is promising in the synthesis of epoxides with a long carbon chain or large ring size.

Single site silica supported tetramethyl niobium by the SOMC strategy: synthesis, characterization and structure–activity relationship in the ethylene oligomerization reaction

Facile synthesis of two SOMC-based niobium methyl complexes which showed different selectivity in ethylene oligomerization.

Well-defined silica supported bipodal molybdenum oxo alkyl complexes: a model of the active sites of industrial olefin metathesis catalysts

A novel well-defined supported bipodal molybdenum alkyl oxo species for “modelling MoO₃/SiO₂ industrial catalysts” that efficiently catalyzes olefin metathesis has been unveiled.