Crystal structure of an assembly intermediate of respiratory Complex II

An evolving view of complex II-noncanonical complexes, megacomplexes, respiration, signaling, and beyond

Mitochondrial complex II is traditionally studied for its participation in two key respiratory processes: the electron transport chain and the Krebs cycle. There is now a rich body of literature explaining how complex II contributes to respiration. However, more recent research shows that not all of the pathologies associated with altered complex II activity clearly correlate with this respiratory role. Complex II activity has now been shown to be necessary for a range of biological processes peripherally related to respiration, including metabolic control, inflammation, and cell fate. Integration of findings from multiple types of studies suggests that complex II both participates in respiration and controls multiple succinate-dependent signal transduction pathways. Thus, the emerging view is that the true biological function of complex II is well beyond respiration. This review uses a semichronological approach to highlight major paradigm shifts that occurred over time. Special emphasis is given to the more recently identified functions of complex II and its subunits because these findings have infused new directions into an established field.

How an assembly factor enhances covalent FAD attachment to the flavoprotein subunit of complex II

The membrane-bound complex II family of proteins is composed of enzymes that catalyze succinate and fumarate interconversion coupled with reduction or oxidation of quinones within the membrane domain. The majority of complex II enzymes are protein heterotetramers with the different subunits harboring a variety of redox centers. These redox centers are used to transfer electrons between the site of succinate-fumarate oxidation/reduction and the membrane domain harboring the quinone. A covalently bound FAD cofactor is present in the flavoprotein subunit, and the covalent flavin linkage is absolutely required to enable the enzyme to oxidize succinate. Assembly of the covalent flavin linkage in eukaryotic cells and many bacteria requires additional protein assembly factors. Here, we provide mechanistic details for how the assembly factors work to enhance covalent flavinylation. Both prokaryotic SdhE and mammalian SDHAF2 enhance FAD binding to their respective apoprotein of complex II. These assembly factors also increase the affinity for dicarboxylates to the apoprotein-noncovalent FAD complex and stabilize the preassembly complex. These findings are corroborated by previous investigations of the roles of SdhE in enhancing covalent flavinylation in both bacterial succinate dehydrogenase and fumarate reductase flavoprotein subunits and of SDHAF2 in performing the same function for the human mitochondrial succinate dehydrogenase flavoprotein. In conclusion, we provide further insight into assembly factor involvement in building complex II flavoprotein subunit active site required for succinate oxidation.

Structural Insight into Evolution of the Quinone Binding Site in Complex II

The Complex II family encompasses membrane bound succinate:quinones reductases and quinol:fumarate reductases that catalyze interconversion of succinate and fumarate coupled with reduction and oxidation of quinone. These enzymes are found in all biological genres and share a modular structure where a highly conserved soluble domain is bound to a membrane-spanning domain that is represented by distinct variations. The current classification of the complex II family members is based on the number of subunits and co-factors in the membrane anchor (types A-F). This classification also provides insights into possible evolutionary paths and suggests that some of the complex II enzymes (types A-C) co-evolved as the whole assembly. Origin of complex II types D and F may have arisen from independent events of de novo association of the conserved soluble domain with a new anchor. Here we analyze a recent structure of Mycobacterium smegmatis Sdh2, a complex II enzyme with two transmembrane subunits and two heme b molecules. This analysis supports an earlier hypothesis suggesting that mitochondrial complex II (type C) with a single heme b may have evolved as an assembled unit from an ancestor similar to M. smegmatis Sdh2.

Bioenergetics and Reactive Nitrogen Species in Bacteria

The production of reactive nitrogen species (RNS) by the innate immune system is part of the host's defense against invading pathogenic bacteria. In this review, we summarize recent studies on the molecular basis of the effects of nitric oxide and peroxynitrite on microbial respiration and energy conservation. We discuss possible molecular mechanisms underlying RNS resistance in bacteria mediated by unique respiratory oxygen reductases, the mycobacterial bcc-aa3 supercomplex, and bd-type cytochromes. A complete picture of the impact of RNS on microbial bioenergetics is not yet available. However, this research area is developing very rapidly, and the knowledge gained should help us develop new methods of treating infectious diseases.

YgfY Contributes to Stress Tolerance in Shewanella oneidensis Neither as an Antitoxin Nor as a Flavinylation Factor of Succinate Dehydrogenase

YgfY(SdhE/CptB) is highly conserved while has controversial functions in bacteria. It works as an antitoxin and composes a type IV toxin-antitoxin system with YgfX(CptA) typically in Escherichia coli, while functions as an flavinylation factor of succinate dehydrogenase and fumarate reductase typically in Serratia sp. In this study, we report the contribution of YgfY in Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 to tolerance of low temperature and nitrite. YgfY deficiency causes several growth defects of S. oneidensis MR-1 at low temperature, while YgfX do not cause a growth defect or morphological change of S. oneidensis MR1-1 and E. coli. YgfY do not interact with FtsZ and MreB nor with YgfX examined by bacterial two-hybrid assay. YgfY effect on growth under low temperature is not attributed to succinate dehydrogenase (SDH) because a mutant without SDH grows comparably with the wild-type strain in the presence of succinate. The ygfY mutant shows impaired tolerance to nitrite. Transcription of nitrite reductase and most ribosome proteins is significantly decreased in the ygfY mutant, which is consistent with the phenotypes detected above. Effects of YgfY on growth and nitrite tolerance are closely related to the RGXXE motif in YgfY. In summary, this study demonstrates pleiotropic impacts of YgfY in S. oneidensis MR-1, and sheds a light on the physiological versatility of YgfY in bacteria.

Mitochondrial complex II and reactive oxygen species in disease and therapy

Increasing evidence points to the respiratory Complex II (CII) as a source and modulator of reactive oxygen species (ROS). Both functional loss of CII as well as its pharmacological inhibition can lead to ROS generation in cells, with a relevant impact on the development of pathophysiological conditions, i.e. cancer and neurodegenerative diseases. While the basic framework of CII involvement in ROS production has been defined, the fine details still await clarification. It is important to resolve these aspects to fully understand the role of CII in pathology and to explore its therapeutic potential in cancer and other diseases.

Architecture of the mycobacterial succinate dehydrogenase with a membrane-embedded Rieske FeS cluster

Targeting energy metabolism in Mycobacterium tuberculosis has emerged as a new paradigm in antituberculosis drug discovery. Succinate dehydrogenase is considered the regulator of respiration in M. tuberculosis. Mycobacteria contains two different succinate dehydrogenase enzymes designated Sdh1 and Sdh2. Sdh1 has recently been identified as a new class of succinate dehydrogenase. In this study, we have determined M. smegmatis Sdh1 structures alone and in the presence of ubiquinone-1, revealing that Sdh1 has a novel electron transfer pathway and a unique substrate-binding site. These data show that the structure of M. tuberculosis Sdh1 is significantly different by comparison with the human counterpart making a good antituberculosis drug target.

Complex II, also known as succinate dehydrogenase (SQR) or fumarate reductase (QFR), is an enzyme involved in both the Krebs cycle and oxidative phosphorylation. Mycobacterial Sdh1 has recently been identified as a new class of respiratory complex II (type F) but with an unknown electron transfer mechanism. Here, using cryoelectron microscopy, we have determined the structure of Mycobacterium smegmatis Sdh1 in the presence and absence of the substrate, ubiquinone-1, at 2.53-Å and 2.88-Å resolution, respectively. Sdh1 comprises three subunits, two that are water soluble, SdhA and SdhB, and one that is membrane spanning, SdhC. Within these subunits we identified a quinone-binding site and a rarely observed Rieske-type [2Fe-2S] cluster, the latter being embedded in the transmembrane region. A mutant, where two His ligands of the Rieske-type [2Fe-2S] were changed to alanine, abolished the quinone reduction activity of the Sdh1. Our structures allow the proposal of an electron transfer pathway that connects the substrate-binding and quinone-binding sites. Given the unique features of Sdh1 and its essential role in Mycobacteria, these structures will facilitate antituberculosis drug discovery efforts that specifically target this complex.

Modulation of mitochondrial site-specific hydrogen peroxide efflux by exogenous stressors

Oxygen (O₂) deprivation and metals are common environmental stressors and their exposure to aquatic organisms can induce oxidative stress by disrupting cellular reactive oxygen species (ROS) homeostasis. Mitochondria are a major source of ROS in the cell wherein a dozen sites located on enzymes of the electron transport system (ETS) and substrate oxidation produce superoxide anion radicals (O₂˙‾) or hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂). Sites located on ETS enzymes can generate ROS by forward electron transfer (FET) and reverse electron transfer (RET) reactions; however, knowledge of how exogenous stressors modulate site-specific ROS production is limited. We investigated the effects of anoxia-reoxygenation and cadmium (Cd) on H₂O₂ emission in fish liver mitochondria oxidizing glutamate-malate, succinate or palmitoylcarnitine-malate. We find that anoxia-reoxygenation attenuates H₂O₂ emission while the effect of Cd depends on the substrate, with monotonic responses for glutamate-malate and palmitoylcarnitine-malate, and a biphasic response for succinate. Anoxia-reoxygenation exerts a substrate-dependent inhibition of mitochondrial respiration which is more severe with palmitoylcarnitine-malate compared with succinate or glutamate-malate. Additionally, specific mitochondrial ROS-emitting sites were sequestered using blockers of electron transfer and the effects of anoxia-reoxygenation and Cd on H₂O₂ emission were evaluated. Here, we find that site-specific H₂O₂ emission capacities depend on the substrate and the direction of electron flow. Moreover, anoxia-reoxygenation alters site-specific H₂O₂ emission rates during succinate and glutamate-malate oxidation whereas Cd imposes monotonic or biphasic H₂O₂ emission responses depending on the substrate and site. Contrary to our expectation, anoxia-reoxygenation blunts the effect of Cd. These results suggest that the effect of exogenous stressors on mitochondrial oxidant production is governed by their impact on energy conversion reactions and mitochondrial redox poise. Moreover, direct increased ROS production seemingly does not explain the increased adverse effects associated with combined exposure of aquatic organisms to Cd and low dissolved oxygen levels.

N5 Is the New C4a: Biochemical Functionalization of Reduced Flavins at the N5 Position

For three decades the C4a-position of reduced flavins was the known site for covalency within flavoenzymes. The reactivity of this position of the reduced isoalloxazine ring with the dioxygen ground-state triplet established the C4a as a site capable of one-electron chemistry. Within the last two decades new types of reduced flavin reactivity have been documented. These studies reveal that the N5 position is also a protean site of reactivity, that is capable of nucleophilic attack to form covalent bonds with substrates. In addition, though the precise mechanism of dioxygen reactivity is yet to be definitively demonstrated, it is clear that the N5 position is directly involved in substrate oxygenation in some enzymes. In this review we document the lineage of discoveries that identified five unique modes of N5 reactivity that collectively illustrate the versatility of this position of the reduced isoalloxazine ring.

The roles of SDHAF2 and dicarboxylate in covalent flavinylation of SDHA, the human complex II flavoprotein

Mitochondrial complex II, also known as succinate dehydrogenase (SDH), is an integral-membrane heterotetramer (SDHABCD) that links two essential energy-producing processes, the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle and oxidative phosphorylation. A significant amount of information is available on the structure and function of mature complex II from a range of organisms. However, there is a gap in our understanding of how the enzyme assembles into a functional complex, and disease-associated complex II insufficiency may result from incorrect function of the mature enzyme or from assembly defects. Here, we investigate the assembly of human complex II by combining a biochemical reconstructionist approach with structural studies. We report an X-ray structure of human SDHA and its dedicated assembly factor SDHAF2. Importantly, we also identify a small molecule dicarboxylate that acts as an essential cofactor in this process and works in synergy with SDHAF2 to properly orient the flavin and capping domains of SDHA. This reorganizes the active site, which is located at the interface of these domains, and adjusts the pK_a of SDHA^R451 so that covalent attachment of the flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) cofactor is supported. We analyze the impact of disease-associated SDHA mutations on assembly and identify four distinct conformational forms of the complex II flavoprotein that we assign to roles in assembly and catalysis.

Cryo-EM structure of trimeric Mycobacterium smegmatis succinate dehydrogenase with a membrane-anchor SdhF

Diheme-containing succinate:menaquinone oxidoreductases (Sdh) are widespread in Gram-positive bacteria but little is known about the catalytic mechanisms they employ for succinate oxidation by menaquinone. Here, we present the 2.8 Å cryo-electron microscopy structure of a Mycobacterium smegmatis Sdh, which forms a trimer. We identified the membrane-anchored SdhF as a subunit of the complex. The 3 kDa SdhF forms a single transmembrane helix and this helix plays a role in blocking the canonically proximal quinone-binding site. We also identified two distal quinone-binding sites with bound quinones. One distal binding site is formed by neighboring subunits of the complex. Our structure further reveals the electron/proton transfer pathway for succinate oxidation by menaquinone. Moreover, this study provides further structural insights into the physiological significance of a trimeric respiratory complex II. The structure of the menaquinone binding site could provide a framework for the development of Sdh-selective anti-mycobacterial drugs.

Diheme-containing succinate:menaquinone oxidoreductases (Sdh) are members of the complex II superfamily. Here, the authors present the 2.8 Å cryo-EM structure of Mycobacterium smegmatis Sdh2, which reveals membrane-anchored SdhF as a component of the complex and they discuss the electron/proton transfer pathway in the Sdh2 trimer.

Mutational analysis of the flavinylation and binding motifs in two protein targets of the flavin transferase ApbE

Many flavoproteins belonging to three domain types contain an FMN residue linked through a phosphoester bond to a threonine or serine residue found in a conserved seven-residue motif. The flavinylation reaction is catalyzed by a specific enzyme, ApbE, which uses FAD as a substrate. To determine the structural requirements of the flavinylation reaction, we examined the effects of single substitutions in the flavinylation motif of Klebsiella pneumoniae cytoplasmic fumarate reductase on its modification by its own ApbE in recombinant Escherichia coli cells. The replacement of the flavin acceptor threonine with alanine completely abolished the modification reaction, whereas the replacements of conserved aspartate and serine had only minor effects. Effects of other substitutions, including replacing the acceptor threonine with serine, (a 10–55% decrease in the flavinylation degree) pinpointed important glycine and alanine residues and suggested an excessive capacity of the ApbE-based flavinylation system in vivo. Consistent with this deduction, drastic replacements of conserved leucine and threonine residues in the binding pocket that accommodates FMN residue still allowed appreciable flavinylation of the NqrC subunit of Vibrio harveyi Na+-translocating NADH:quinone oxidoreductase, despite a profound weakening of the isoalloxazine ring binding and an increase in its exposure to solvent.

The assembly of succinate dehydrogenase: a key enzyme in bioenergetics

Succinate dehydrogenase (SDH) also known as complex II or succinate:quinone oxidoreductase is an enzyme involved in both oxidative phosphorylation and tricarboxylic acid cycle; the processes that generate energy. SDH is a multi-subunit enzyme which requires a series of proteins for its proper assembly at several steps. This enzyme has medical significance as there is a broad range of human diseases from cancers to neurodegeneration related to SDH malfunction. Some of these disorders have recently been linked to defective assembly factors, reinvigorating further research in this area. Apart from that this enzyme has agricultural importance as many fungicides have been/will be designed targeting specifically this enzyme in plant fungal pathogens. In addition, we speculate it might be possible to design novel fungicides specifically targeting fungal assembly factors. Considering the medical and agricultural implications of SDH, the aim of this review is an overview of the SDH assembly factors and critical analysis of controversial issues around them.

A Mechanism of Modulating the Direction of Flagellar Rotation in Bacteria by Fumarate and Fumarate Reductase

Fumarate, an electron acceptor in anaerobic respiration of Escherichia coli, has an additional function of assisting the flagellar motor to shift from counterclockwise to clockwise rotation, with a consequent modulation of the bacterial swimming behavior. Fumarate transmits its effect to the motor via the fumarate reductase complex (FrdABCD), shown to bind to FliG-one of the motor's switch proteins. How binding of the FrdABCD respiratory enzyme to FliG enhances clockwise rotation and how fumarate is involved in this activity have remained puzzling. Here we show that the FrdA subunit in the presence of fumarate is sufficient for binding to FliG and for clockwise enhancement. We further demonstrate by in vitro binding assays and super-resolution microscopy in vivo that the mechanism by which fumarate-occupied FrdA enhances clockwise rotation involves its preferential binding to the clockwise state of FliG (FliG_cw). Continuum electrostatics combined with docking analysis and conformational sampling endorsed the experimental conclusions and suggested that the FrdA-FliG_cw interaction is driven by the positive electrostatic potential generated by FrdA and the negatively charged areas of FliG. They further demonstrated that fumarate changes FrdA's conformation to one that can bind to FliG_cw. These findings also show that the reason for the failure of the succinate dehydrogenase flavoprotein SdhA (an almost-identical analog of FrdA shown to bind to FliG equally well) to enhance clockwise rotation is that it has no binding preference for FliG_cw. We suggest that this mechanism is physiologically important as it can modulate the magnitude of ΔG⁰ between the clockwise and counterclockwise states of the motor to tune the motor to the growth conditions of the bacteria.

Maturation of the respiratory complex II flavoprotein

Respiratory complexes are complicated multi-subunit cofactor-containing machines that allow cells to harvest energy from the environment. Maturation of these complexes requires protein folding, cofactor insertion, and assembly of multiple subunits into a final, functional complex. Because the intermediate states in complex maturation are transitory, these processes are poorly understood. This review gives an overview of the process of maturation in respiratory complex II with a focus on recent structural studies on intermediates formed during covalent flavinylation of the catalytic subunit, SDHA. Covalent flavinylation has an evolutionary significance because variants of complex II enzymes with the covalent ligand removed by mutagenesis cannot oxidize succinate, but can still perform the reverse reaction and reduce fumarate. Since succinate oxidation is a key step of aerobic respiration, the covalent bond of complex II appears to be important for aerobic life.

Flavin transferase: the maturation factor of flavin-containing oxidoreductases

Flavins, cofactors of many enzymes, are often covalently linked to these enzymes; for instance, flavin adenine mononucleotide (FMN) can form a covalent bond through either its phosphate or isoalloxazine group. The prevailing view had long been that all types of covalent attachment of flavins occur as autocatalytic reactions; however, in 2013, the first flavin transferase was identified, which catalyzes phosphoester bond formation between FMN and Na⁺-translocating NADH:quinone oxidoreductase in certain bacteria. Later studies have indicated that this post-translational modification is widespread in prokaryotes and is even found in some eukaryotes. Flavin transferase can occur as a separate ∼40 kDa protein or as a domain within the target protein and recognizes a degenerate DgxtsAT/S motif in various target proteins. The purpose of this review was to summarize the progress already achieved by studies of the structure, mechanism, and specificity of flavin transferase and to encourage future research on this topic. Interestingly, the flavin transferase gene (apbE) is found in many bacteria that have no known target protein, suggesting the presence of yet unknown flavinylation targets.

The unassembled flavoprotein subunits of human and bacterial complex II have impaired catalytic activity and generate only minor amounts of ROS

Complex II (SdhABCD) is a membrane-bound component of mitochondrial and bacterial electron transport chains, as well as of the TCA cycle. In this capacity, it catalyzes the reversible oxidation of succinate. SdhABCD contains the SDHA protein harboring a covalently bound FAD redox center and the iron-sulfur protein SDHB, containing three distinct iron-sulfur centers. When assembly of this complex is compromised, the flavoprotein SDHA may accumulate in the mitochondrial matrix or bacterial cytoplasm. Whether the unassembled SDHA has any catalytic activity, for example in succinate oxidation, fumarate reduction, reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation, or other off-pathway reactions, is not known. Therefore, here we investigated whether unassembled Escherichia coli SdhA flavoprotein, its homolog fumarate reductase (FrdA), and the human SDHA protein have succinate oxidase or fumarate reductase activity and can produce ROS. Using recombinant expression in E. coli, we found that the free flavoproteins from these divergent biological sources have inherently low catalytic activity and generate little ROS. These results suggest that the iron-sulfur protein SDHB in complex II is necessary for robust catalytic activity. Our findings are consistent with those reported for single-subunit flavoprotein homologs that are not associated with iron-sulfur or heme partner proteins.

Crystal structure of bacterial succinate:quinone oxidoreductase flavoprotein SdhA in complex with its assembly factor SdhE

Succinate:quinone oxidoreductase (SQR) functions in energy metabolism, coupling the tricarboxylic acid cycle and electron transport chain in bacteria and mitochondria. The biogenesis of flavinylated SdhA, the catalytic subunit of SQR, is assisted by a highly conserved assembly factor termed SdhE in bacteria via an unknown mechanism. By using X-ray crystallography, we have solved the structure of Escherichia coli SdhE in complex with SdhA to 2.15-Å resolution. Our structure shows that SdhE makes a direct interaction with the flavin adenine dinucleotide-linked residue His45 in SdhA and maintains the capping domain of SdhA in an "open" conformation. This displaces the catalytic residues of the succinate dehydrogenase active site by as much as 9.0 Å compared with SdhA in the assembled SQR complex. These data suggest that bacterial SdhE proteins, and their mitochondrial homologs, are assembly chaperones that constrain the conformation of SdhA to facilitate efficient flavinylation while regulating succinate dehydrogenase activity for productive biogenesis of SQR.