The effect of periodic disturbances and carrying capacity on the significance of selection and drift in complex bacterial communities

The cost of adaptability: resource availability constrains functional stability under pulsed disturbances

Global change exposes ecosystems to changes in the frequency, magnitude, and concomitancy of disturbances, which impact the composition and functioning of these systems. Here, we experimentally evaluate the effects of salinity disturbances and eutrophication on bacterial communities from coastal ecosystems. The functional stability of these communities is critically important for maintaining water quality, productivity, and ecosystem services, such as fishery yields. Microbial functional stability can be maintained via resistance and resilience, which are reflected in genomic traits such as genome size and codon usage bias and may be linked to metabolic costs. However, little is known about the mechanisms that select these traits under varying nutrient regimes. To study the impact of pulsed disturbances on community assembly and functioning depending on metabolic costs, we performed a 41-day pulse disturbance experiment across two levels of resource availability. Our setup triggered stochastic community re-assembly processes in all treatments. In contrast, we observed consistent and resource availability-dependent patterns of superordinate community functioning and structural patterns, such as functional resistance in response to disturbances, genomic trait distributions, and species diversity. Predicted genomic traits reflected the selection for taxa possessing resistant- and resilience-related traits, particularly under high nutrient availability. Our findings are a step toward unraveling the compositional and genomic underpinnings of functional resistance in microbial communities after exposure to consecutive pulse disturbances. Our work demonstrates how resource availability alleviates metabolic constraints on resistance and resilience, and this has important consequences for predicting water quality and ecosystem productivity of environments exposed to global change.

IMPORTANCE

Understanding the communities' responses to disturbances is a prerequisite to predicting ecosystem dynamics and, thus, highly relevant considering global change. Microbial communities play key roles in numerous ecosystem functions and services, and the large diversity, rapid growth, and phenotypic plasticity of microorganisms are thought to allow high resistance and resilience. While potential metabolic costs associated with adaptations to fluctuating environments have been debated, little evidence supports trade-offs between resource availability, resistance, and resilience. Here, we experimentally assessed the compositional and functional responses of an aquatic microbial model community to disturbances and systematically manipulated resource availability. Our results demonstrate that the capacity to tolerate environmental fluctuations is constrained by resource availability and reflected in the selection of genomic traits.

Does soil history decline in influencing the structure of bacterial communities of Brassica napus host plants across different growth stages?

Soil history has been shown to condition future rhizosphere microbial communities. However, previous experiments have also illustrated that mature, adult plants can "re-write," or mask, different soil histories through host plant-soil community feedbacks. This leaves a knowledge gap concerning how soil history influences bacterial community structure across different growth stages. Thus, here we tested the hypothesis that previously established soil histories will decrease in influencing the structure of Brassica napus bacterial communities over the growing season. We used an on-going agricultural field experiment to establish three different soil histories, plots of monocrop canola (B. napus), or rotations of wheat-canola, or pea-barley-canola. During the following season, we repeatedly sampled the surrounding bulk soil, rhizosphere, and roots of the B. napus hosts at different growth stages-the initial seeding conditions, seedling, rosette, bolting, and flower-from all three soil history plots. We compared composition and diversity of the B. napus soil bacterial communities, as estimated using 16S rRNA gene metabarcoding, to identify any changes associated with soil history and growth stages. We found that soil history remained significant across each growth stage in structuring the bacterial bulk soil and rhizosphere communities, but not the bacterial root communities. This suggests that the host plant's capacity to "re-write" different soil histories may be quite limited as key components that constitute the soil history's identity remain present, such that the previously established soil history continues to impact the bacterial rhizosphere communities, but not the root communities. For agriculture, this highlights how previously established soil histories persist and may have important long-term consequences on future plant-microbe communities, including bacteria.

Resistance of aerobic granular sludge microbiomes to periodic loss of biomass

Granular sludge is a biofilm process used for wastewater treatment which is currently being implemented worldwide. It is important to understand how disturbances affect the microbial community and performance of reactors. Here, two acetate-fed replicate reactors were inoculated with acclimatized sludge and the reactor performance, and the granular sludge microbial community succession were studied for 149 days. During this time, the microbial community was challenged by periodically removing half of the reactor biomass, subsequently increasing the food-to-microorganism (F/M) ratio. Diversity analysis together with null models show that overall, the microbial communities were resistant to the disturbances, observing some minor effects on polyphosphate-accumulating and denitrifying microbial communities and their associated reactor functions. Community turnover was driven by drift and random granule loss, and stochasticity was the governing ecological process for community assembly. These results evidence the aerobic granular sludge process as a robust system for wastewater treatment.

The impact of phage treatment on bacterial community structure is minor compared to antibiotics

Phage treatment is suggested as an alternative to antibiotics; however, there is limited knowledge of how phage treatment impacts resident bacterial community structure. When phages induce bacterial lysis, resources become available to the resident community. Therefore, the density of the target bacterium is essential to consider when investigating the effect of phage treatment. This has never been studied. Thus, we invaded microcosms containing a lake-derived community with Flavobacterium columnare strain Fc7 at no, low or high densities, and treated them with either the bacteriophage FCL-2, the antibiotic Penicillin or kept them untreated (3 × 3 factorial design). The communities were sampled over the course of one week, and bacterial community composition and density were examined by 16S rDNA amplicon sequencing and flow cytometry. We show that phage treatment had minor impacts on the resident community when the host F. columnare Fc7 of the phage was present, as it caused no significant differences in bacterial density α- and β-diversity, successional patterns, and community assembly. However, a significant change was observed in community composition when the phage host was absent, mainly driven by a substantial increase in Aquirufa. In contrast, antibiotics induced significant changes in all community characteristics investigated. The most crucial finding was a bloom of γ-proteobacteria and a shift from selection to ecological drift dominating community assembly. This study investigated whether the amount of a bacterial host impacted the effect of phage treatment on community structure. We conclude that phage treatment did not significantly affect the diversity or composition of the bacterial communities when the phage host was present, but introduced changes when the host was absent. In contrast, antibiotic treatment was highly disturbing to community structure. Moreover, higher amounts of the bacterial host of the phage increased the contribution of stochastic community assembly and resulted in a feast-famine like response in bacterial density in all treatment groups. This finding emphasises that the invader density used in bacterial invasion studies impacts the experimental reproducibility. Overall, this study supports that phage treatment is substantially less disturbing to bacterial communities than antibiotic treatments.

Aquaculture rearing systems induce no legacy effects in Atlantic cod larvae or their rearing water bacterial communities

The microbial rearing quality influences the survival of marine larvae. Microbially matured water treatment systems (MMS) provide a more favourable rearing water microbiome than flow-through systems (FTS). It has previously been hypothesised, but not investigated, that initial rearing in MMS leaves a protective legacy effect in Atlantic cod larvae (Gadus morhua). We tested this hypothesis through a crossover 2 × 2 factorial experiment varying the rearing water treatment system (MMS vs FTS) and the microbial carrying capacity (+ /- added organic matter). At 9 days post-hatching, we switched the rearing water treatment system. By comparing switched and unswitched rearing tanks, we evaluated if legacy effects had been established in the larvae or their surrounding rearing water bacterial community. We analysed the bacterial communities with flow cytometry and 16S rRNA gene sequencing. We found no evidence that the initial rearing condition left a legacy effect in the communities by evaluating the bacterial community diversity and structure. Instead, the present rearing condition was the most important driver for differences in the rearing water microbiota. Furthermore, we found that MMS with high microbial carrying capacity appeared to seed a stable bacterial community to the rearing tanks. This finding highlights the importance of keeping a similar carrying capacity between the inlet and rearing water. Moreover, we reject the hypothesis that the initial rearing condition leaves a protective legacy effect in larvae, as the larval survival and robustness were linked to the present rearing condition. In conclusion, our results highlight the importance of maintaining a beneficial microbial rearing environment from hatching and throughout the larval rearing period.

Disentangling the Mechanisms Shaping the Prokaryotic Communities in a Eutrophic Bay

Eutrophication occurring in coastal bays is prominent in impacting local ecosystem structure and functioning. To understand how coastal bay ecosystem function responds to eutrophication, comprehending the ecological processes associated with microbial community assembly is critical. However, quantifying the contribution of ecological processes to the assembly of prokaryotic communities is still limited in eutrophic waters. Moreover, the influence of these ecological processes on microbial interactions is poorly understood. Here, we examined the assembly processes and co-occurrence patterns of prokaryotic communities in a eutrophic bay using 156 surface seawater samples collected over 12 months. The variation of prokaryotic community compositions (PCCs) could be mainly explained by environmental factors, of which temperature was the most important. Under high environmental heterogeneity conditions in low-temperature seasons, heterogeneous selection was the major assembly process, resulting in high β-diversity and more tightly connected co-occurrence networks. When environmental heterogeneity decreased in high-temperature seasons, drift took over, leading to decline in β-diversity and network associations. Microeukaryotes were found to be important biological factors affecting PCCs. Our results first disentangled the contribution of drift and microbial interactions to the large unexplained variation of prokaryotic communities in eutrophic waters. Furthermore, a new conceptual model linking microbial interactions to ecological processes was proposed under different environmental heterogeneity. Overall, our study sheds new light on the relationship between assembly processes and co-occurrence of prokaryotic communities in eutrophic waters. IMPORTANCE A growing number of studies have examined roles of microbial community assembly in modulating community composition. However, the relationships between community assembly and microbial interactions are not fully understood and rarely tested, especially in eutrophic waters. In this study, we built a conceptual model that links seasonal microbial interactions to ecological processes, which has not been reported before. The model showed that heterogeneous selection plays an important role in driving community assembly during low-temperature seasons, resulting in higher β-diversity and more tightly connected networks. In contrast, drift became a dominant force during high-temperature seasons, leading to declines in the β-diversity and network associations. This model could function as a new framework to predict how prokaryotic communities respond to intensified eutrophication induced by climate change in coastal environment.

Robust bacterial co-occurence community structures are independent of r- and K-selection history

Selection for bacteria which are K-strategists instead of r-strategists has been shown to improve fish health and survival in aquaculture. We considered an experiment where microcosms were inoculated with natural seawater and the selection regime was switched from K-selection (by continuous feeding) to r-selection (by pulse feeding) and vice versa. We found the networks of significant co-occurrences to contain clusters of taxonomically related bacteria having positive associations. Comparing this with the time dynamics, we found that the clusters most likely were results of similar niche preferences of the involved bacteria. In particular, the distinction between r- or K-strategists was evident. Each selection regime seemed to give rise to a specific pattern, to which the community converges regardless of its prehistory. Furthermore, the results proved robust to parameter choices in the analysis, such as the filtering threshold, level of random noise, replacing absolute abundances with relative abundances, and the choice of similarity measure. Even though our data and approaches cannot directly predict ecological interactions, our approach provides insights on how the selection regime affects the composition of the microbial community, providing a basis for aquaculture experiments targeted at eliminating opportunistic fish pathogens.