Negative Electron Transfer Collision-Induced Dissociation of G-Quadruplexes: Uncovering the Guanine Radical Anion Loss Pathway

G-quadruplex (G4) DNA can form highly stable secondary structures in the presence of metal cations, and research has shown its potential as a transcriptional regulator for oncogenes in the human genome. In order to explore the interactions of DNA with metal cations using mass spectrometry, employing complementary fragmentation methods can enhance structural information. This study explores the use of ion-ion reactions for sequential negative electron transfer collision-induced dissociation (nET-CID) as a complement to traditional ion-trap CID (IT-CID). The resulting nET-CID data for G4 anions with and without metal cations show an increase in fragment ion type diversity and yield of structurally informative ions relative to IT-CID. The nET-CID yields greater sequence coverage by virtue of fragmentation at the 3'-side of thymine residues, which is lacking with IT-CID. Potassium adductions to backbone fragments in IT-CID and nET-CID spectra were nearly identical. Of note is a prominent fragment resulting from a loss of a 149 Da anion seen in nET-CID of large, G-rich sequences, proposed to be radical anion guanine loss. Neutral loss of neutral guanine (151 Da) and deprotonated nucleobase loss (150 Da) have been previously reported, but this is the first report of radical anion guanine loss (149 Da). Confirmation of the identity of the 149 Da anion results from the examination of the homonucleobase sequence 5'-GGGGGGGG-3'. Loss of a charged adenine radical anion at much lower relative abundance was also noted for the sequence 5'-AAAAAAAA-3'. DFT modeling indicates that the loss of a nucleobase as a radical anion from odd-electron nucleic acid anions is a thermodynamically favorable fragmentation pathway for G.

Competitive Radical Migrations and Ribose Ring Cleavage in Adenosine and 2'-Deoxyadenosine Cation Radicals

We report a combined experimental and computational study of adenosine cation radicals that were protonated at adenine and furnished with a radical handle in the form of an acetoxyl radical, •CH2COO, that was attached to ribose 5'-O. Radicals were generated by collision-induced dissociation (CID) and characterized by tandem mass spectrometry and UV-vis photodissociation action spectroscopy. The acetoxyl radical was used to probe the kinetics of intramolecular hydrogen transfer from the ribose ring positions that were specifically labeled with deuterium at C1', C2', C3', C4', C5', and in the exchangeable hydroxyl groups. Hydrogen transfer was found to chiefly involve 3'-H with minor contributions by 5'-H and 2'-H, while 4'-H was nonreactive. The hydrogen transfer rates were affected by deuterium isotope effects. Hydrogen transfer triggered ribose ring cleavage by consecutive dissociations of the C4'-O and C1'-C2' bonds, resulting in expulsion of a C6H9O4 radical and forming a 9-formyladenine ion. Rice-Ramsperger-Kassel-Marcus (RRKM) and transition-state theory (TST) calculations of unimolecular constants were carried out using the effective CCSD(T)/6-311++G(3d,2p) and M06-2X/aug-cc-pVTZ potential energy surfaces for major isomerizations and dissociations. The kinetic analysis showed that hydrogen transfer to the acetoxyl radical was the rate-determining step, whereas the following ring-opening reactions in ribose radicals were fast. Using DFT-computed energies, a comparison was made between the thermochemistry of radical reactions in adenosine and 2'-deoxyadenosine cation radicals. The 2'-deoxyribose ring showed lower TS energies for both the rate-determining 3'-H transfer and ring cleavage reactions.

Do d(GCGAAGC) Cations Retain the Hairpin Structure in the Gas Phase? A Cyclic Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry and Density Functional Theory Computational Study

d(GCGAAGC) is the smallest oligonucleotide with a well-defined hairpin structure in solution. We report a study of multiply protonated d(GCGAAGC) and its sequence-scrambled isomers, d(CGAAGCG), d(GCGAACG), and d(CGGAAGC), that were produced by electrospray ionization with the goal of investigating their gas-phase structures and dissociations. Cyclic ion mobility measurements revealed that dications of d(GCGAAGC) as well as the scrambled-sequence ions were mixtures of protomers and/or conformers that had collision cross sections (CCS) within a 439-481 Å2 range. Multiple ion conformers were obtained by electrospray under native conditions as well as from aqueous methanol. Arrival time distribution profiles were characteristic of individual isomeric heptanucleotides. Extensive Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics (BOMD) and density functional theory (DFT) calculations of d(GCGAAGC)2+ isomers indicated that hairpin structures were high-energy isomers of more compact distorted conformers. Protonation caused a break up of the C2···G6 pair that was associated with the formation of strong hydrogen bonds in zwitterionic phosphate anion-nucleobase cation motifs that predominated in low energy ions. Multiple components were also obtained for d(GCGAAGC)3+ trications under native and denaturing electrospray conditions. The calculated trication structures showed disruption of the G···C pairs in low energy zwitterions. A hairpin trication was calculated to be a high energy isomer. d(GCGAAGC)4+ tetracations were produced and separated by c-IMS as two major isomers. All low energy d(GCGAAGC)4+ ions obtained by DFT geometry optimizations were zwitterions in which all five purine bases were protonated, and the ion charge was balanced by a phosphate anion. Tetracations of the scrambled sequences were each formed as one dominant isomer. The CCS calculated with the MobCal-MPI method were found to closely match experimental values. Collision-induced dissociation (CID) spectra of multiply charged heptanucleotides showed nucleobase loss and backbone cleavages occurring chiefly at the terminal nucleosides. Electron-transfer-CID tandem mass spectra were used to investigate dissociations of different charge and spin states of charge-reduced heptanucleotide cation radicals.

Tracking Isomerizations of High-Energy Adenine Cation Radicals by UV-Vis Action Spectroscopy and Cyclic Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry

We report experimental and computational studies of protonated adenine C-8 σ-radicals that are presumed yet elusive reactive intermediates of oxidative damage to nucleic acids. The radicals were generated in the gas phase by the collision-induced dissociation of C-8-Br and C-8-I bonds in protonated 8-bromo- and 8-iodoadenine as well as by 8-bromo- and 8-iodo-9-methyladenine. Protonation by electrospray of 8-bromo- and 8-iodoadenine was shown by cyclic-ion mobility mass spectrometry (c-IMS) to form the N-1-H, N-9-H and N-3-H, N-7-H protomers in 85:15 and 81:19 ratios, respectively, in accordance with the equilibrium populations of these protomers in water-solvated ions that were calculated by density functional theory (DFT). Protonation of 8-halogenated 9-methyladenines yielded single N-1-H protomers, which was consistent with their thermodynamic stability. The radicals produced from the 8-bromo and 8-iodo adenine cations were characterized by UV-vis photodissociation action spectroscopy (UVPD) and c-IMS. UVPD revealed the formation of C-8 σ-radicals along with N-3-H, N-7-H-adenine π-radicals that arose as secondary products by hydrogen atom migrations. The isomers were identified by matching their action spectra against the calculated vibronic absorption spectra. Deuterium isotope effects were found to slow the isomerization and increase the population of C-8 σ-radicals. The adenine cation radicals were separated by c-IMS and identified by their collision cross sections, which were measured relative to the canonical N-9-H adenine cation radical that was cogenerated in situ as an internal standard. Ab initio CCSD(T)/CBS calculations of isomer energies showed that the adenine C-8 σ-radicals were local energy minima with relative energies at 76-79 kJ mol^-1 above that of the canonical adenine cation radical. Rice-Ramsperger-Kassel-Marcus calculations of unimolecular rate constants for hydrogen and deuterium migrations resulting in exergonic isomerizations showed kinetic shifts of 10-17 kJ mol^-1, stabilizing the C-8 σ-radicals. C-8 σ-radicals derived from N-1-protonated 9-methyladenine were also thermodynamically unstable and readily isomerized upon formation.

The DNA Radical Code. Resolution of Identity in Dissociations of Trinucleotide Codon Cation Radicals in the Gas Phase

Sixty DNA trinucleotide cation radicals covering a large part of the genetic code alphabet were generated by electron transfer in the gas phase, and their chemistry was studied by collision-induced dissociation tandem mass spectrometry and theoretical calculations. The major dissociations involved loss of nucleobase molecules and radicals, backbone cleavage, and cross-ring fragmentations that depended on the nature and position of the nucleobases. Mass identity in dissociations of symmetrical trinucleotide cation radicals of the (XXX+2H)^+• and (XYX+2H)^+• type was resolved by specific ¹⁵N labeling. The specific features of trinucleotide cation radical dissociations involved the dominant formation of d₂⁺ ions, hydrogen atom migrations accompanying the formation of (w₂+H)^+•, (w₂+2H)⁺, and (d₂+2H)⁺ sequence ions, and cross-ring cleavages in the 3'- and 5'-deoxyribose moieties that depended on the nucleobase type and its position in the ion. Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics (BOMD) and density functional theory calculations were used to obtain structures and energies of several cation-radical protomers and conformers for (AAA+2H)^+•, (CCC+2H)^+•, (GGG+2H)^+•, (ACA+2H)^+•, and (CAA+2H)^+• that were representative of the different types of backbone dissociations. The ion electronic structure, protonation and radical sites, and hydrogen bonding were used to propose reaction mechanisms for the dissociations.

UV-vis spectroscopy of gas-phase ions

Photodissociation action spectroscopy has made a great progress in expanding investigations of gas-phase ion structures. This review deals with aspects of gas-phase ion electronic excitations that result in wavelength-dependent dissociation and light emission via fluorescence, chiefly covering the ultraviolet and visible regions of the spectrum. The principles are briefly outlined and a few examples of instrumentation are presented. The main thrust of the review is to collect and selectively present applications of UV-vis action spectroscopy to studies of stable gas-phase ion structures and combinations of spectroscopy with ion mobility, collision-induced dissociation, and ion-ion reactions leading to the generation of reactive intermediates and electronic energy transfer.

Resolution of Identity in Gas-Phase Dissociations of Mono- and Diprotonated DNA Trinucleotide Codons by 15N-Labeling and Computational Structure Analysis

Dissociations of DNA trinucleotide codons as gas-phase singly and doubly protonated ions were studied by tandem mass spectrometry using ¹⁵N-labeling to resolve identity in the nucleobase loss and backbone cleavages. The monocations showed different distributions of nucleobase loss from the 5'-, middle, and 3'-positions depending on the nucleobase, favoring cytosine over guanine, adenine, and thymine in an ensemble-averaged 62:27:11:<1 ratio. The distribution for the loss of the 5'-, middle, and 3'-nucleobase was 49:18:33, favoring the 5'-nucleobase, but also depending on its nature. The formation of sequence w₂⁺ ions was unambiguously established for all codon mono- and dications. Structures of low-Gibbs-energy protomers and conformers of dAAA⁺, dGGG⁺, dCCC⁺, dTTT⁺, dACA⁺, and dATC⁺ were established by Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics and density functional theory calculations. Monocations containing guanine favored classical structures protonated at guanine N7. Structures containing adenine and cytosine produced classical nucleobase-protonated isomers as well as zwitterions in which two protonated bases were combined with a phosphate anion. Protonation at thymine was disfavored. Low threshold energies for nucleobase loss allowed extensive proton migration to occur prior to dissociation. Loss of the nucleobase from monocations was assisted by neighboring group participation in nucleophilic addition or proton abstraction, as well as allosteric proton migrations remote from the reaction center. The optimized structures of diprotonated isomers for dAAA²⁺ and dACA²⁺ revealed combinations of classical and zwitterionic structures. The threshold and transition-state energies for nucleobase-ion loss from dications were low, resulting in facile dissociations involving cytosine, guanine, and adenine.

Radical Cascade Dissociation Pathways to Unusual Nucleobase Cation Radicals

We report unusual dissociations of protonated RNA nucleosides tagged with radical initiator groups at ribose 5'-O and furnished with a 2',3'-O-isopropylidene protecting group. The ions undergo collision-induced radical cascade dissociations starting at the radical initiator that break down the dioxolane ring and trigger the formation of nucleobase cations and cation radicals. The adenine cation radical that was formed by radical cascade dissociations was identified by MS⁵ UV-vis photodissociation action spectroscopy to be a higher-energy N-3-H tautomer of the canonical ionized nucleobase. The guanine cation radical was formed by radical cascade dissociations as the N-7-H tautomer. In contrast to adenosine and guanosine, radical cascade dissociations of the tagged ribocytidine ion produced protonated cytosine, whereas tagged ribothymidine showed yet different dissociations resulting in predominant thymine loss. Reaction mechanisms were suggested for the cascade dissociations that were based on Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics and density functional theory calculations that were used to map the relevant parts of the potential energy surfaces for adenosine, guanosine, and cytidine radical ions. The reported radical cascade dissociations represent a new, nonredox approach to nucleobase and nucleoside cation radicals that has the potential of being expanded to the generation of various oligonucleotide cation radicals.

Noncanonical Isomers of Nucleoside Cation Radicals: An Ab Initio Study of the Dark Matter of DNA Ionization

Cation radicals of DNA nucleosides, 2'-deoxyadenosine, 2'-deoxyguanosine, 2'-deoxycytidine, and 2'-deoxythymidine, can exist in standard canonical forms or as noncanonical isomers in which the charge is introduced by protonation of the nucleobase, whereas the radical predominantly resides in the deoxyribose moiety. Density functional theory as well as correlated ab initio calculations with coupled clusters (CCSD(T)) that were extrapolated to the complete basis set limit showed that noncanonical nucleoside ion isomers were thermodynamically more stable than their canonical forms in both the gas phase and as water-solvated ions. This indicated the possibility of exothermic conversion of canonical to noncanonical forms. The noncanonical isomers were calculated to have very low adiabatic ion-electron recombination energies (RE_ad) for the lowest-energy isomers 2'-deoxy-(N-3H)adenos-1'-yl (4.74 eV), 2'-deoxy-(N-7H)guanos-1'-yl (4.66 eV), 2'-deoxy-(N-3H)cytid-1'-yl (5.12 eV), and 2'-deoxy-5-methylene-(O-2H)uridine (5.24 eV). These were substantially lower than the RE_ad value calculated for the canonical 2'-deoxyadenosine, 2'-deoxy guanosine, 2'-deoxy cytidine, and 2'-deoxy thymidine cation radicals, which were 7.82, 7.46, 8.14, and 8.20 eV, respectively, for the lowest-energy ion conformers of each type. Charge and spin distributions in noncovalent cation-radical dA⊂dT and dG⊂dC nucleoside pairs and dAT, dCT, dTC, and dGC dinucleotides were analyzed to elucidate the electronic structure of the cation radicals. Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics trajectory calculations of the dinucleotides and nucleoside pairs indicated rapid exothermic proton transfer from noncanonical T^+· to A in both dAT^+· and dA⊂dT^+·, leading to charge and radical separation. Noncanonical T^+· in dCT^+· and dTC^+· initiated rapid proton transfer to cytosine, whereas the canonical dCT^+· dinucleotide ion retained the cation radical structure without isomerization. No spontaneous proton transfer was found in dGC^+· and dG⊂dC^+· containing canonical neutral and noncanonical ionized deoxycytidine.

Flying DNA Cation Radicals in the Gas Phase: Generation and Action Spectroscopy of Canonical and Noncanonical Nucleobase Forms

Gas-phase chemistry of cation radicals related to ionized nucleic acids has enjoyed significant recent progress thanks to the development of new methods for cation radical generation, ion spectroscopy, and reactivity studies. Oxidative methods based on intramolecular electron transfer in transition-metal complexes have been used to generate nucleobase and nucleoside cation radicals. Reductive methods relying on intermolecular electron transfer in gas-phase ion-ion reactions have been utilized to generate a number of di- and tetranucleotide cation radicals, as well as charge-tagged nucleoside radicals. The generated cation radicals have been studied by infrared and UV-visible action spectroscopy and ab initio and density functional theory calculations, providing optimized structures, harmonic frequencies, and excited-state analysis. This has led to the discovery of stable noncanonical nucleobase cation radicals of unusual electronic properties and extremely low ion-electron recombination energies. Intramolecular proton-transfer reactions in cation radical oligonucleotides and Watson-Crick nucleoside pairs have been studied experimentally, and their mechanisms have been elucidated by theory. Whereas the range of applications of the oxidative methods is currently limited to nucleobases and readily oxidizable guanosine, the reductive methods can be scaled up to generate large oligonucleotide cation radicals including double-strand DNA. Challenges in the experimental and computational approach to DNA cation radicals are discussed.