The electronic structure of FeV-cofactor in vanadium-dependent nitrogenase

Analyses of the electronic structures of FeFe-cofactors compared with those of FeMo- and FeV-cofactors and their P-clusters

The electronic structures of FeFe-cofactors (FeFe-cos) in resting and turnover states, together with their PN clusters from iron-only nitrogenases, have been calculated using the bond valence method, and their crystallographic data were reported recently and deposited in the Protein Data Bank (PDB codes: 8BOQ and 8OIE). The calculated results have also been compared with those of their homologous Mo- and V-nitrogenases. For FeFe-cos in the resting state, Fe1/2/4/5/6/7/8 atoms are prone to Fe3+, while the Fe3 atom shows different degrees of mixed valences. The results support that the Fe8 atom at the terminal positions of FeFe-cos possesses the same oxidation states as the Mo3+/V3+ atoms of FeMo-/FeV-cos. In the turnover state, the overall oxidation state of FeFe-co is slightly reduced than those in the resting species, and its electronic configuration is rearranged after the substitution of S2B with OH, compatible with those found in CO-bound FeV-co. Moreover, the calculations give the formal oxidation states of 6Fe2+-2Fe3+ for the electronic structures of PN clusters in Fe-nitrogenases. By the comparison of Mo-, V- and Fe-nitrogenases, the overall oxidation levels of 7Fe atoms (Fe1-Fe7) for both FeFe- and FeMo-cos in resting states are found to be higher than that of FeV-co. For the PN clusters in MoFe-, VFe- and FeFe-proteins, they all exhibit a strong reductive character.

The energetics of N2 reduction by vanadium containing nitrogenase

The main class of nitrogenases has a molybdenum in its cofactor. A mechanism for Mo-nitrogenase has recently been described. In the present study, another class of nitrogenases has been studied, the one with a vanadium instead of a molybdenum in its cofactor. It is generally believed that these classes use the same general mechanism to activate nitrogen. The same methodology has been used here as the one used for Mo-nitrogenase. N2 activation is known to occur after four reductions in the catalytic cycle, in the E4 state. The main features of the mechanism for Mo-nitrogenase found in the previous study are an activation process in four steps prior to catalysis, the release of a sulfide during the activation steps and the formation of H2 from two hydrides in E4, just before N2 is activated. The same features have been found here for V-nitrogenase. A difference is that five steps are needed in the activation process, which explains why the ground state of V-nitrogenase is a triplet (even number) and the one for Mo-nitrogenase is a quartet (odd number). The reason an additional step is needed for V-nitrogenase is that V3+ can be reduced to V2+, in contrast to the case for Mo3+ in Mo-nitrogenase. The fact that V3+ is Jahn-Teller active has important consequences. N2H2 is formed in E4 with reasonably small barriers.

Protonation of Homocitrate and the E1 State of Fe-Nitrogenase Studied by QM/MM Calculations

Nitrogenase is the only enzyme that can cleave the strong triple bond in N2, making nitrogen available for biological life. There are three isozymes of nitrogenase, differing in the composition of the active site, viz., Mo, V, and Fe-nitrogenase. Recently, the first crystal structure of Fe-nitrogenase was presented. We have performed the first combined quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical (QM/MM) study of Fe-nitrogenase. We show with QM/MM and quantum-refinement calculations that the homocitrate ligand is most likely protonated on the alcohol oxygen in the resting E0 state. The most stable broken-symmetry (BS) states are the same as for Mo-nitrogenase, i.e., the three Noodleman BS7-type states (with a surplus of β spin on the eighth Fe ion), which maximize the number of nearby antiferromagnetically coupled Fe-Fe pairs. For the E1 state, we find that protonation of the S2B μ2 belt sulfide ion is most favorable, 14-117 kJ/mol more stable than structures with a Fe-bound hydride ion (the best has a hydride ion on the Fe2 ion) calculated with four different density-functional theory methods. This is similar to what was found for Mo-nitrogenase, but it does not explain the recent EPR observation that the E1 state of Fe-nitrogenase should contain a photolyzable hydride ion. For the E1 state, many BS states are close in energy, and the preferred BS state differs depending on the position of the extra proton and which density functional is used.

Computational Study on the Influence of Mo/V Centers on the Electronic Structure and Hydrazine Reduction Capability of [MFe3S4]3+/2+ Complexes

[MFe3S4] cubanes have for some time been of interest for their ability to mimic the electronic and geometric structure of the active site of nitrogenase, the enzyme responsible for fixing N2 to NH3. Nitrogenase naturally occurs in three forms, with the major difference being that the metal ion present in the cofactor active site is either molybdenum (FeMoco), vanadium (FeVco), or iron. The molybdenum and vanadium versions of these cofactors are more closely studied, owing to their larger abundance and rate of catalysis. In this study, we compare free energy profiles and electronic properties of the Mo/V cubanes at various stages during the reduction of N2H4 to NH3. Our findings highlight the differences in how the complexes facilitate the reaction, in particular, vanadium's comparatively weaker ability to interact with the Fe/S network and stabilize reducing electrons prior to N-N bond cleavage, which may have implications when considering the lower efficiency of the vanadium-dependent nitrogenase.

The Fe Protein Cycle Associated with Nitrogenase Catalysis Requires the Hydrolysis of Two ATP for Each Single Electron Transfer Event

A central feature of the current understanding of dinitrogen (N₂) reduction by the enzyme nitrogenase is the proposed coupling of the hydrolysis of two ATP, forming two ADP and two Pi, to the transfer of one electron from the Fe protein component to the MoFe protein component, where substrates are reduced. A redox-active [4Fe-4S] cluster associated with the Fe protein is the agent of electron delivery, and it is well known to have a capacity to cycle between a one-electron-reduced [4Fe-4S]¹⁺ state and an oxidized [4Fe-4S]²⁺ state. Recently, however, it has been shown that certain reducing agents can be used to further reduce the Fe protein [4Fe-4S] cluster to a super-reduced, all-ferrous [4Fe-4S]⁰ state that can be either diamagnetic (S = 0) or paramagnetic (S = 4). It has been proposed that the super-reduced state might fundamentally alter the existing model for nitrogenase energy utilization by the transfer of two electrons per Fe protein cycle linked to hydrolysis of only two ATP molecules. Here, we measure the number of ATP consumed for each electron transfer under steady-state catalysis while the Fe protein cluster is in the [4Fe-4S]¹⁺ state and when it is in the [4Fe-4S]⁰ state. Both oxidation states of the Fe protein are found to operate by hydrolyzing two ATP for each single-electron transfer event. Thus, regardless of its initial redox state, the Fe protein transfers only one electron at a time to the MoFe protein in a process that requires the hydrolysis of two ATP.

Overview of physiological, biochemical, and regulatory aspects of nitrogen fixation in Azotobacter vinelandii

Understanding how Nature accomplishes the reduction of inert nitrogen gas to form metabolically tractable ammonia at ambient temperature and pressure has challenged scientists for more than a century. Such an understanding is a key aspect toward accomplishing the transfer of the genetic determinants of biological nitrogen fixation to crop plants as well as for the development of improved synthetic catalysts based on the biological mechanism. Over the past 30 years, the free-living nitrogen-fixing bacterium Azotobacter vinelandii emerged as a preferred model organism for mechanistic, structural, genetic, and physiological studies aimed at understanding biological nitrogen fixation. This review provides a contemporary overview of these studies and places them within the context of their historical development.

Can the E1 state in nitrogenase tell if there is an activation process prior to catalysis?

Model calculations have been performed for the singly reduced ground state of Mo-nitrogenase, usually termed E₁. Contradictory conclusions have been reached in two recent experimental studies. In a study based on EPR, it was concluded that there is a bridging hydride in E₁, while in an X-ray study it was concluded that there is no hydride in E₁. Therefore, the EPR study implies that there is an oxidation of the cofactor going from E₀ to E₁, the X-ray study implies a reduction. DFT methods have here been used, which have previously been benchmarked on a set of redox enzymes that led to the conclusion that the accuracy is about 3 kcal mol^-1 in all cases, even for redox transitions. The methodology should therefore be adequate for resolving the question of the hydride presence in E₁. As a comparison, calculations are performed on both Mo- and V-nitrogenase with the same conclusion. The conclusion from the calculations has far reaching consequences for the mechanism of nitrogenase.

Tale of Three Molecular Nitrides: Mononuclear Vanadium (V) and (IV) Nitrides As Well As a Mixed-Valence Trivanadium Nitride Having a V3N4 Double-Diamond Core

Transmetallation of [VCl₃(THF)₃] and [TlTp^tBu,Me] afforded [(Tp^tBu,Me)VCl₂] (1, Tp^tBu,Me = hydro-tris(3-tert-butyl-5-methylpyrazol-1-yl)borate), which was reduced with KC₈ to form a C_3v symmetric V^II complex, [(Tp^tBu,Me)VCl] (2). Complex 1 has a high-spin (S = 1) ground state and displays rhombic high-frequency and -field electron paramagnetic resonance (HFEPR) spectra, while complex 2 has an S = 3/2 ⁴A₂ ground state observable by conventional EPR spectroscopy. Complex 1 reacts with NaN₃ to form the V^V nitride-azide complex [(Tp^tBu,Me)V≡N(N₃)] (3). A likely V^III azide intermediate en route to 3, [(Tp^tBu,Me)VCl(N₃)] (4), was isolated by reacting 1 with N₃SiMe₃. Complex 4 is thermally stable but reacts with NaN₃ to form 3, implying a bis-azide intermediate, [(Tp^tBu,Me)V(N₃)₂] (A), leading to 3. Reduction of 3 with KC₈ furnishes a trinuclear and mixed-valent nitride, [{(Tp^tBu,Me)V}₂(μ₄-VN₄)] (5), conforming to a Robin-Day class I description. Complex 5 features a central vanadium ion supported only by bridging nitride ligands. Contrary to 1, complex 2 reacts with NaN₃ to produce an azide-bridged dimer, [{(Tp^tBu,Me)V}₂(1,3-μ₂-N₃)₂] (6), with two antiferromagnetically coupled high-spin V^II ions. Complex 5 could be independently produced along with [(κ₂-Tp^tBu,Me)₂V] upon photolysis of 6 in arene solvents. The putative {V^IV≡N} intermediate, [(Tp^tBu,Me)V≡N] (B), was intercepted by photolyzing 6 in a coordinating solvent, such as tetrahydrofuran (THF), yielding [(Tp^tBu,Me)V≡N(THF)] (B-THF). In arene solvents, B-THF expels THF to afford 5 and [(κ₂-Tp^tBu,Me)₂V]. A more stable adduct (B-OPPh₃) was prepared by reacting B-THF with OPPh₃. These adducts of B are the first neutral and mononuclear V^IV nitride complexes to be isolated.

The Conversion of Carbon Monoxide and Carbon Dioxide by Nitrogenases

Nitrogenases are the only known family of enzymes that catalyze the reduction of molecular nitrogen (N2 ) to ammonia (NH3 ). The N2 reduction drives biological nitrogen fixation and the global nitrogen cycle. Besides the conversion of N2 , nitrogenases catalyze a whole range of other reductions, including the reduction of the small gaseous substrates carbon monoxide (CO) and carbon dioxide (CO2 ) to hydrocarbons. However, it remains an open question whether these 'side reactivities' play a role under environmental conditions. Nonetheless, these reactivities and particularly the formation of hydrocarbons have spurred the interest in nitrogenases for biotechnological applications. There are three different isozymes of nitrogenase: the molybdenum and the alternative vanadium and iron-only nitrogenase. The isozymes differ in their metal content, structure, and substrate-dependent activity, despite their homology. This minireview focuses on the conversion of CO and CO2 to methane and higher hydrocarbons and aims to specify the differences in activity between the three nitrogenase isozymes.

The One-Electron Reduced Active-Site FeFe-Cofactor of Fe-Nitrogenase Contains a Hydride Bound to a Formally Oxidized Metal-Ion Core

The nitrogenase active-site cofactor must accumulate 4e^-/4H⁺ (E₄(4H) state) before N₂ can bind and be reduced. Earlier studies demonstrated that this E₄(4H) state stores the reducing-equivalents as two hydrides, with the cofactor metal-ion core formally at its resting-state redox level. This led to the understanding that N₂ binding is mechanistically coupled to reductive-elimination of the two hydrides that produce H₂. The state having acquired 2e^-/2H⁺ (E₂(2H)) correspondingly contains one hydride with a resting-state core redox level. How the cofactor accommodates addition of the first e^-/H⁺ (E₁(H) state) is unknown. The Fe-nitrogenase FeFe-cofactor was used to address this question because it is EPR-active in the E₁(H) state, unlike the FeMo-cofactor of Mo-nitrogenase, thus allowing characterization by EPR spectroscopy. The freeze-trapped E₁(H) state of Fe-nitrogenase shows an S = 1/2 EPR spectrum with g = [1.965, 1.928, 1.779]. This state is photoactive, and under 12 K cryogenic intracavity, 450 nm photolysis converts to a new and likewise photoactive S = 1/2 state (denoted E₁(H)*) with g = [2.009, 1.950, 1.860], which results in a photostationary state, with E₁(H)* relaxing to E₁(H) at temperatures above 145 K. An H/D kinetic isotope effect of 2.4 accompanies the 12 K E₁(H)/E₁(H)* photointerconversion. These observations indicate that the addition of the first e^-/H⁺ to the FeFe-cofactor of Fe-nitrogenase produces an Fe-bound hydride, not a sulfur-bound proton. As a result, the cluster metal-ion core is formally one-electron oxidized relative to the resting state. It is proposed that this behavior applies to all three nitrogenase isozymes.

AnfO controls fidelity of nitrogenase FeFe protein maturation by preventing misincorporation of FeV ‐cofactor

Azotobacter vinelandii produces three genetically distinct, but structurally and mechanistically similar nitrogenase isozymes designated as Mo‐dependent, V‐dependent, or Fe‐only based on the heterometal contained within their associated active site cofactors. These catalytic cofactors, which provide the site for N₂ binding and reduction, are, respectively, designated as FeMo‐cofactor, FeV‐cofactor, and FeFe‐cofactor. Fe‐only nitrogenase is a poor catalyst for N₂ fixation, when compared to the Mo‐dependent and V‐dependent nitrogenases and is only produced when neither Mo nor V is available. Under conditions favoring the production of Fe‐only nitrogenase a gene product designated AnfO preserves the fidelity of Fe‐only nitrogenase by preventing the misincorporation of FeV‐cofactor, which results in the accumulation of a hybrid enzyme that cannot reduce N₂. These results are interpreted to indicate that AnfO controls the fidelity of Fe‐only nitrogenase maturation during the physiological transition from conditions that favor V‐dependent nitrogenase utilization to Fe‐only nitrogenase utilization to support diazotrophic growth.

Carbon Monoxide Binding to the Iron-Molybdenum Cofactor of Nitrogenase: a Detailed Quantum Mechanics/Molecular Mechanics Investigation

Carbon monoxide (CO) is a well-known inhibitor of nitrogenase activity. Under turnover conditions, CO binds to FeMoco, the active site of Mo nitrogenase. Time-resolved IR measurements suggest an initial terminal CO at 1904 cm^-1 that converts to a bridging CO at 1715 cm^-1, and an X-ray structure shows that CO can displace one of the bridging belt sulfides of FeMoco. However, the CO-binding redox state(s) of FeMoco (E_n) and the role of the protein environment in stabilizing specific CO-bound intermediates remain elusive. In this work, we carry out an in-depth analysis of the CO-FeMoco interaction based on quantum chemical calculations addressing different aspects of the electronic structure. (1) The local electronic structure of the Fe-CO bond is studied through diamagnetically substituted FeMoco. (2) A cluster model of FeMoco within a polarizable continuum illustrates how CO binding may affect the spin-coupling between the metal centers. (3) A QM/MM model incorporates the explicit influence of the amino acid residues surrounding FeMoco in the MoFe protein. The QM/MM model predicts both a terminal and a bridging CO in the E₁ redox state. The scaled calculated CO frequencies (1922 and 1716 cm^-1, respectively) are in good agreement with the experimentally observed IR bands supporting CO binding to the E₁ state. Alternatively, an E₂ state QM/MM model, which has the same atomic structure as the CO-bound X-ray structure, features a semi-bridging CO with a scaled calculated frequency (1718 cm^-1) similar to the bridging CO in the E₁ model.

Specificity of NifEN and VnfEN for the Assembly of Nitrogenase Active Site Cofactors in Azotobacter vinelandii

The nitrogen-fixing microbe Azotobacter vinelandii has the ability to produce three genetically distinct, but mechanistically similar, components that catalyze nitrogen fixation. For two of these components, the Mo-dependent and V-dependent components, their corresponding metal-containing active site cofactors, designated FeMo-cofactor and FeV-cofactor, respectively, are preformed on separate molecular scaffolds designated NifEN and VnfEN, respectively. From prior studies, and the present work, it is now established that neither of these scaffolds can replace the other with respect to their in vivo cofactor assembly functions. Namely, a strain inactivated for NifEN cannot produce active Mo-dependent nitrogenase nor can a strain inactivated for VnfEN produce an active V-dependent nitrogenase. It is therefore proposed that metal specificities for FeMo-cofactor and FeV-cofactor formation are supplied by their respective assembly scaffolds. In the case of the third, Fe-only component, its associated active site cofactor, designated FeFe-cofactor, requires neither the NifEN nor VnfEN assembly scaffold for its formation. Furthermore, there are no other genes present in A. vinelandii that encode proteins having primary structure similarity to either NifEN or VnfEN. It is therefore concluded that FeFe-cofactor assembly is completed within its cognate catalytic protein partner without the aid of an intermediate assembly site. IMPORTANCE Biological nitrogen fixation is a complex process involving the nitrogenases. The biosynthesis of an active nitrogenase involves a large number of genes and the coordinated function of their products. Understanding the details of the assembly and activation of the different nitrogen fixation components, in particular the simplest one known so far, the Fe-only nitrogenase, would contribute to the goal of transferring the necessary genetic elements of bacterial nitrogen fixation to cereal crops to endow them with the capacity for self-fertilization. In this work, we show that there is no need for a scaffold complex for the assembly of the FeFe-cofactor, which provides the active site for Fe-only nitrogenase. These results are in agreement with previously reported genetic reconstruction experiments using a non-nitrogen-fixing microbe. In aggregate, these findings provide a high degree of confidence that the Fe-only system represents the simplest and, therefore, most attractive target for mobilizing nitrogen fixation into plants.

Exploring the Role of the Central Carbide of the Nitrogenase Active-Site FeMo-cofactor through Targeted 13C Labeling and ENDOR Spectroscopy

Mo-dependent nitrogenase is a major contributor to global biological N₂ reduction, which sustains life on Earth. Its multi-metallic active-site FeMo-cofactor (Fe₇MoS₉C-homocitrate) contains a carbide (C^4-) centered within a trigonal prismatic CFe₆ core resembling the structural motif of the iron carbide, cementite. The role of the carbide in FeMo-cofactor binding and activation of substrates and inhibitors is unknown. To explore this role, the carbide has been in effect selectively enriched with ¹³C, which enables its detailed examination by ENDOR/ESEEM spectroscopies. ¹³C-carbide ENDOR of the S = 3/2 resting state (E₀) is remarkable, with an extremely small isotropic hyperfine coupling constant, ^Ca = +0.86 MHz. Turnover under high CO partial pressure generates the S = 1/2 hi-CO state, with two CO molecules bound to FeMo-cofactor. This conversion surprisingly leaves the small magnitude of the ¹³C carbide isotropic hyperfine-coupling constant essentially unchanged, ^Ca = -1.30 MHz. This indicates that both the E₀ and hi-CO states exhibit an exchange-coupling scheme with nearly cancelling contributions to ^Ca from three spin-up and three spin-down carbide-bound Fe ions. In contrast, the anisotropic hyperfine coupling constant undergoes a symmetry change upon conversion of E₀ to hi-CO that may be associated with bonding and coordination changes at Fe ions. In combination with the negligible difference between CFe₆ core structures of E₀ and hi-CO, these results suggest that in CO-inhibited hi-CO the dominant role of the FeMo-cofactor carbide is to maintain the core structure, rather than to facilitate inhibitor binding through changes in Fe-carbide covalency or stretching/breaking of carbide-Fe bonds.