DEVELOPMENT OF NONINVASIVE AND QUANTITATIVE METHODOLOGIES FOR THE ASSESSMENT OF CHRONIC ULCERS AND SCARS IN HUMANS

Ultrasound measurement of traumatic scar and skin thickness: a scoping review of evidence across the translational pipeline of research-to-practice

OBJECTIVES

To identify the ultrasound methods used in the literature to measure traumatic scar thickness, and map gaps in the translation of these methods using evidence across the research-to-practice pipeline.

DESIGN

Scoping review.

DATA SOURCES

Electronic database searches of Ovid MEDLINE, Embase, Cumulative Index of Nursing and Allied Health Literature and Web of Science. Grey literature searches were conducted in Google. Searches were conducted from inception (date last searched 27 May 2022).

DATA EXTRACTION

Records using brightness mode (B-mode) ultrasound to measure scar and skin thickness across the research-to-practice pipeline of evidence were included. Data were extracted from included records pertaining to: methods used; reliability and measurement error; clinical, health service, implementation and feasibility outcomes; factors influencing measurement methods; strengths and limitations; and use of measurement guidelines and/or frameworks.

RESULTS

Of the 9309 records identified, 118 were analysed (n=82 articles, n=36 abstracts) encompassing 5213 participants. Reporting of methods used was poor. B-mode, including high-frequency (ie, >20 MHz) ultrasound was the most common type of ultrasound used (n=72 records; 61% of records), and measurement of the combined epidermal and dermal thickness (n=28; 24%) was more commonly measured than the epidermis or dermis alone (n=7, 6%). Reliability of ultrasound measurement was poorly reported (n=14; 12%). The scar characteristics most commonly reported to be measured were epidermal oedema, dermal fibrosis and hair follicle density. Most records analysed (n=115; 97%) pertained to the early stages of the research-to-practice pipeline, as part of research initiatives.

CONCLUSIONS

The lack of evaluation of measurement initiatives in routine clinical practice was identified as an evidence gap. Diverse methods used in the literature identified the need for greater standardisation of ultrasound thickness measurements. Findings have been used to develop nine methodological considerations for practitioners to guide methods and reporting.

Skin endothelial cell and microcirculation function study in recurred keloids patients after keloid surgery and radiotherapy

BACKGROUND

Keloid is a type of benign tumor of the skin with abnormal proliferation of fibrous tissue. We sought to observe the changes in skin microcirculation and endothelial cell function around the recurred keloid and explore the skin microcirculation characters in recurred keloid patients.

METHODS

Six patients with recurred keloid were treated with keloid surgery and radiotherapy for the second time. Microcirculation of recurred keloids and their surrounding normal skin tissue was observed with laser Doppler flowmeter before operation. Expression of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), CD31, and HIF-1α were identified by several assay.

RESULTS

The local blood flow of group RN was enhanced. The average strength of group N is 0.87. The average strength of group RN is 2.08. The expression of VEGF, CD31, and hypoxia inducible factor-1α (HIF-1α) protein in the keloid-recurred skin (RN) group was higher than the normal skin group via immunohistochemistry (IHC) and Western blotting analysis. The relative expression of VEGF and CD31 mRNA was significantly increased in RN group samples (P < .05).

CONCLUSIONS

There are significant differences in the expression of VEGF, CD31, and HIF-1α in the recurred keloid skin after radiotherapy and normal skin. They may be used as potential biomarkers and targets for future research on keloid recurrence.

Effectiveness of Microcurrent Therapy for Treating Pressure Ulcers in Older People: A Double-Blind, Controlled, Randomized Clinical Trial

The aim of this study was to assess the effectiveness of microcurrent therapy for healing pressure ulcers in aged people. A multicentric, randomized clinical trial was designed with a sham stimulation control. The experimental group received an intervention following a standardized protocol for curing ulcers combined with 10 h of microcurrent therapy daily for 25 days. The sham group received the same curing protocol plus a sham microcurrent stimulation. The studied healing-related variables were the Pressure Ulcer Scale for Healing (PUSH) and the surface, depth, grade, and number of ulcers that healed completely. Three evaluations were conducted: pre-intervention (T1), 14 days following the start of the intervention (T2), and 1 day after the intervention was completed (T3). In total, 30 participants met the inclusion criteria (n = 15 in each group). The improvement in the PUSH at T2 and T3 was 16.8% (CI95% 0.5-33.1) and 25.3% (CI95% 7.6-43.0) greater in the experimental group versus the sham control, respectively. The reduction in the wound area at T2 and T3 was 20.1% (CI95% 5.2-35.0) and 28.6% (CI95% 11.9-45.3) greater in the experimental group versus the control, respectively. Microcurrent therapy improves the healing of pressure ulcers in older adults, both quantitatively and qualitatively.

Relative perfusion index: An objective, quantitative and noninvasive method for evaluating the severity of keloids

BACKGROUND

Keloids are the result of abnormal wound healing, and they differ from the normal skin of the patient in the level of blood perfusion and the degrees of inflammation, hypoxia, regeneration of vessels, and expression of sensory receptors. However, there is no objective assessment method to accurately characterize the severity of keloids.

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the perfusion levels of keloids and the expression levels of various internal cytokines, including hypoxia-induced factor-1α (HIF-1α), vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), interleukin-17 (IL-17), HT_2A receptor subtype (5-HT_2A R), and H1R, in keloids and nonadjacent normal skin and to propose a laser speckle contrast imaging (LSCI)-based relative perfusion index (RPI), through which keloids can be divided into five grades to objectively characterize their severity.

METHODS

This population-based cross-sectional study included 70 untreated keloid patients who each had only one keloid on the chest. LSCI was used to measure the area of each patient's keloid ( K area ${K}_{\mathrm{area}}$ ) and the perfusion level of each patient's keloid ( K perfusion ${K}_{\mathrm{perfusion}}$ ) and normal skin ( N perfusion ${N}_{\mathrm{perfusion}}$ ). The Vancouver Scar Scale (VSS) and Visual Analog Scale (VAS) for pain and pruritus were also used to assess each keloid. Immunohistochemistry and Western blot were used to detect the expression levels of various internal cytokines in keloids and normal skin. We compared the perfusion and expression levels of intrinsic cytokines between keloids and normal skin. We established the RPI to grade the severity of keloids and applied different methods to test the utility of the RPI.

RESULTS

The mean perfusion level of keloids was significantly higher than that of normal skin (p < 0.001). The expression levels of HIF-1α, VEGF, IL-17, 5-HT_2A R, and H1R in keloids were significantly higher than those in normal skin (p < 0.05). RPI was defined as: [ ( K perfusion - N perfusion ) × 0.03 + K area × 0.001 ] . $[({K}_{\mathrm{perfusion}}-{N}_{\mathrm{perfusion}})\times 0.03+{K}_{\mathrm{area}}\times 0.001].$ The severity of keloids could be divided into five grades based on RPI. The RPI had a higher correlation with the pain-VAS, pruritus-VAS, and the expression levels of internal cytokines in keloids than blood perfusion levels and the VSS. T-SNE (t-distributed stochastic neighbor embedding) was also used to verify the clinical discriminatory abilities of this RPI model.

CONCLUSIONS

The proposed RPI based on LSCI showed the highest accuracy, unlike the VSS and assessment of perfusion, and can be utilized as a reliable, objective, quantitative, and noninvasive tool to evaluate the severity of keloids.

Point-of-Care Ultrasound as a Tool to Assess Wound Size and Tissue Regeneration after Skin Grafting

Chronic wounds can be difficult to heal and are often accompanied by pain and discomfort. Multiple skin substitutes or cellularized/tissue-based skin products have been used in an attempt to facilitate closure of complex wounds. Allografts from cadaveric sources have been a viable option in achieving such closure. However, early assessment of graft incorporation has been difficult clinically, often with delayed evidence of failure. Visual cues to assess graft integrity have been limited and remain largely superficial at the skin surface. Furthermore, currently used optical imaging techniques can penetrate only a few millimeters deep into tissue. Ultrasound (US) imaging offers a potential solution to address this limitation. This work evaluates the use of US to monitor wound healing and allograft integration. We used a commercially available dual-mode (US and photoacoustic) scanner operating only in US mode. We compared the reported wound size from the clinic with the size measured using US in 45 patients. Two patients from this cohort received an allogenic skin graft and underwent multiple US scans over a 110-d period. All data were processed by two independent analysts; one of them was blinded to the study. We measured change in US intensity and wound contraction as a function of time. Our results revealed a strong correlation (R² = 0.81, p < 0.0001) between clinically and US-measured wound sizes. Wound contraction >91% was seen in both patients after skin grafting. An inverse relationship between wound size and US intensity (R² = 0.77, p < 0 .0001) indicated that the echogenicity of the wound bed increases as healthy cells infiltrate the allograft matrix, regenerating and leading to healthy tissue and re-epithelization. This work indicates that US can be used to measure wound size and visualize tissue regeneration during the healing process.

Transplanted Antler Stem Cells Stimulated Regenerative Healing of Radiation-induced Cutaneous Wounds in Rats

Radiation-induced cutaneous injury is the main side effect of radiotherapy. The injury is difficult to cure and the pathogenesis is complex. Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) serve as a promising candidate for cell-based therapy for the treatment of cutaneous wounds. The aim of the present study was to investigate whether antler stem cells (AnSCs) have better therapeutic effects on radiation-induced cutaneous injury than currently available ones. In this study, a rat model of cutaneous wound injury from Sr-90 radiation was used. AnSCs (1 × 10⁶/500 μl) were injected through the tail vein on the first day of irradiation. Our results showed that compared to the control group, AnSC-treated rats exhibited a delayed onset (14 days versus 7 days), shorter recovery time (51 days versus 84 days), faster healing rate (100% versus 70% on day 71), and higher healing quality with more cutaneous appendages regenerated (21:10:7/per given area compared to those of rat and human MSCs, respectively). More importantly, AnSCs promoted much higher quality of healing compared to other types of stem cells, with negligible scar formation. AnSC lineage tracing results showed that the injected-dye-stained AnSCs were substantially engrafted in the wound healing tissue, indicating that the therapeutic effects of AnSCs on wound healing at least partially through direct participation in the wound healing. Expression profiling of the wound-healing-related genes in the healing tissue of AnSC group more resembled a fetal wound healing. Revealing the mechanism underlying this higher quality of wound healing by using AnSC treatment would help to devise more effective cell-based therapeutics for radiation-induced wound healing in clinics.

Imaging human skin autograft integration with optical coherence tomography

Background

Skin autografting is a common clinical procedure for reconstructive surgery. Despite its widespread use, very few studies have been conducted to non-invasively evaluate and monitor the vascular and structural features of skin grafts. This study, therefore, aims to demonstrate the potential of optical coherence tomography (OCT) alongside OCT-based angiography (OCTA) to non-invasively image and monitor human skin graft health and integration over time.

Methods

An in-house-built clinical prototype OCT system was used to acquire OCT/OCTA images from patients who underwent split-thickness skin graft surgery following severe burn damage to the skin. The OCT imaging was carried out at multiple locations over multiple time points with a field of view of ~9 mm × 9 mm and a penetration depth of ~1.5 mm. In addition to obtaining high-resolution qualitative images, we also quantitatively measured and compared specific structural and vascular parameters, such as identifiable layer thickness and corresponding vascular area density and diameter.

Results

Two patients (patient #1 and #2) were enrolled for this preliminary study. Vascular and structural features were successfully imaged and measured in the graft tissue and integration layer immediately beneath at different time points. Revascularization, healing, and integration were monitored with patient-specific details. Results of the quantitative image analysis from patient #1 indicated that integration layer thickness 16-day post-surgery was significantly less (~50%) than that of 7-day post-surgery. Additionally, with patient #2, significant growth (~20%) was seen with the vascular area density of both the graft and corresponding integration layer beneath between 6 and 14 days post-surgery.

Conclusions

Our preliminary studies show that OCT/OCTA has clinical potential to image and measure numerous features of human skin graft health and integration in the days and weeks following split-thickness surgery. For the first time, we demonstrate the applicability of non-invasive imaging technology for novel clinical uses that could eventually aid in the betterment of surgical practices and clinical outcomes.

Heterogeneous Features of Keloids Assessed by Laser Speckle Contrast Imaging: A Cross-Sectional Study

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Keloids are described as benign dermal fibroproliferative lesions, and vascularization may play a significant role in their pathogenesis. In this study, laser speckle contrast imaging (LSCI) was used to assess perfusion within keloids and surrounding skin, and perfusion of keloids at different stages was compared.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 59 patients with 110 untreated keloids on the anterior chest were enrolled in this study. Different keloid stages (progressive, stable, and regressive) were defined according to patients' descriptions of whether keloids became larger, stable, or smaller during the previous year. Vancouver Scar Scale (VSS) was assessed by a plastic surgeon, and patient reports on pain and itching were documented. LSCI was used to evaluate blood perfusion of keloids (K), skin adjacent to keloids (A), and nonadjacent skin (N). The mean perfusion of these regions was determined, and ratios (K/N, A/N) were calculated.

RESULTS

A heterogeneous perfusion map was observed among the keloid groups, as well as within each keloid. A positive correlation was found between keloid perfusion and VSS. There were 62 (56.4%) keloids in the progressive stage, 33 (30.0%) keloids in the stable stage, and 15 (13.6%) keloids in the regressive stage. The mean K/N ratios in the progressive, stable, and regressive stages were 2.3 ± 0.5, 1.8 ± 0.3, and 1.5 ± 0.5, respectively. The mean A/N ratios were 1.2 ± 0.4, 1.2 ± 0.2, and 1.0 ± 0.5, respectively. Within each keloid, significantly higher perfusion was noted in the keloid and adjacent skin compared with nonadjacent skin.

CONCLUSION

These results indicate that LSCI is a promising technique for evaluating keloid blood perfusion and distinguishing heterogeneous keloids. Lasers Surg. Med. © 2020 Wiley Periodicals LLC.

Quantitative Assessment of Keloids Using Ultrasound Shear Wave Elastography

This study was aimed at investigating the value of shear wave elastography (SWE) in quantitative evaluation of keloids. A total of 87 patients with 139 keloids were enrolled. Vancouver scar scale (VSS) scores were recorded. Thickness and blood flow grade were evaluated using high-frequency ultrasound. Skin stiffness (mean speed of shear wave, C_mean) was evaluated using SWE in both transverse and longitudinal sections. All measurements were performed in both keloids and site-matched unaffected skin (normal controls). The reliability of measurements was evaluated using intra- and inter-class correlation coefficients by two observers. Inter- and intra-observer repeatability was excellent (correlation coefficient > 0.99, p < 0.01). The SWE results revealed a significant increase in C_mean in keloids (p < 0.001) compared with the normal controls. C_mean in the longitudinal section was greater than that in the transverse section for keloids (p < 0.001). C_mean was highly positively correlated with VSS score (r = 0.904, p < 0.001), moderately positively correlated with thickness (r = 0.490, p < 0.001) and less positively correlated with blood flow (r = 0.231, p < 0.01). This non-invasive, tolerable and convenient imaging technique could be an effective tool for objectively evaluating keloid stiffness in the future, thus laying a foundation for the treatment and evaluation of keloids.

Experimental models and methods for cutaneous wound healing assessment

Wound healing studies are intricate, mainly because of the multifaceted nature of the wound environment and the complexity of the healing process, which integrates a variety of cells and repair phases, including inflammation, proliferation, reepithelialization and remodelling. There are a variety of possible preclinical models, such as in mice, rabbits and pigs, which can be used to mimic acute or impaired for example, diabetic and nutrition-related wounds. These can be induced by many different techniques, with excision or incision being the most common. After determining a suitable model for a study, investigators need to select appropriate and reproducible methods that will allow the monitoring of the wound progression over time. The assessment can be performed by non-invasive protocols such as wound tracing, photographic documentation (including image analysis), biophysical techniques and/or by invasive protocols that will require wound biopsies. In this article, we provide an overview of some of the most often needed and used: (a) preclinical/animal models including incisional, excisional, burn and impaired wounds; (b) methods to evaluate the healing progression such as wound healing rate, wound analysis by image, biophysical assessment, histopathological, immunological and biochemical assays. The aim is to help researchers during the design and execution of their wound healing studies.

Clinical Significance of Diabetic Dermatopathy

Diabetic dermopathy is a cutaneous manifestation commonly seen in diabetes patients and was initially described by Melin in 1964. These lesions are well-demarcated, hyperpigmented macules or papules with atrophic depression and were commonly sighted on shins of the tibia with bilateral asymmetrical distribution and rarely seen on arms, thighs and abdomen. The incidence of DD ranges from 0.2 to 55%. It has been frequently associated with microangiopathic complications of diabetes such as nephropathy, retinopathy and polyneuropathy. Although the exact mechanism of occurrence is unknown, it may be related to impaired wound healing due to decreased blood flow, local thermal trauma or local subcutaneous nerve degeneration. Diagnosis is made by clinical examination and the differential diagnosis includes stasis dermatitis, early lesion of necrobiosis lipoidica and purpuric dermatitis. Prevention of dermopathy lesions includes optimized glucose control. No active treatment is recommended or proven effective and DD is known to resolve on its own as time passes. Modified collagen and high glycerine-based lotion have shown marked improvement in skin color changes due to diabetic dermopathy. Diabetic dermopathy is known to have a strong association with microangiopathic complications; the presence of such lesions must raise strong suspicion and prompt investigation for severe underlying pathology. Enhanced scrutinized glycemic control in diabetic dermatopathy patients can even lead to abatement in further progression to microvascular complications and improved long-term patient outcomes.

Linking microvascular collapse to tissue hypoxia in a multiscale model of pressure ulcer initiation

Pressure ulcers are devastating injuries that disproportionately affect the older adult population. The initiating factor of pressure ulcers is local ischemia, or lack of perfusion at the microvascular level, following tissue compression against bony prominences. In turn, lack of blood flow leads to a drop in oxygen concentration, i.e, hypoxia, that ultimately leads to cell death, tissue necrosis, and disruption of tissue continuity. Despite our qualitative understanding of the initiating mechanisms of pressure ulcers, we are lacking quantitative knowledge of the relationship between applied pressure, skin mechanical properties as well as structure, and tissue hypoxia. This gap in our understanding is, at least in part, due to the limitations of current imaging technologies that cannot simultaneously image the microvascular architecture, while quantifying tissue deformation. We overcome this limitation in our work by combining realistic microvascular geometries with appropriate mechanical constitutive models into a microscale finite element model of the skin. By solving boundary value problems on a representative volume element via the finite element method, we can predict blood volume fractions in response to physiological skin loading conditions (i.e., shear and compression). We then use blood volume fraction as a homogenized variable to couple tissue-level skin mechanics to an oxygen diffusion model. With our model, we find that moderate levels of pressure applied to the outer skin surface lead to oxygen concentration contours indicative of tissue hypoxia. For instance, we show that applying a pressure of 60 kPa at the skin surface leads to a decrease in oxygen partial pressure from a physiological value of 65 mmHg to a hypoxic level of 31 mmHg. Additionally, we explore the sensitivity of local oxygen concentration to skin thickness and tissue stiffness, two age-related skin parameters. We find that, for a given pressure, oxygen concentration decreases with decreasing skin thickness and skin stiffness. Future work will include rigorous calibration and validation of this model, which may render our work an important tool toward developing better prevention and treatment tools for pressure ulcers specifically targeted toward the older adult patient population.

High-Frequency Ultrasound: Obtaining Optimal Images and the Effect of Image Artifacts on Image Quality

Objective: High-frequency ultrasound (HFUS) images are being researched for use in the prevention, detection, and monitoring of pressure injuries in patients at risk. This seminal longitudinal study in mechanically ventilated adults describes image quality, the incidence of image artifacts, and their effect on image quality in critically ill subjects. Approach: Mechanically ventilated subjects from three adult intensive care units were enrolled, and multiple sacral images from each subject were obtained daily. Using a subset of best image per patient per day, artifacts were grouped, and their effect on image quality was statistically evaluated. Results: Of a total of 1761 images collected from 137 subjects, 8% were rated as poor. In the subset, 70% had good quality ratings. Four groups of artifacts were identified as follows: "bubbles," "texture problems," "layer nondifferentiation," and "reduced area for evaluation." Artifacts from at least one group were found in 83% of images. Bubbles were most frequently seen, but artifacts with adverse effect on image quality were "layer nondifferentiation," "texture problems," and "reduced area for evaluation." Innovation: HFUS image evaluation is still in the development phase with respect to tissue injury use. Artifacts are generally omnipresent. Quickly recognizing artifacts that most significantly affect image quality during scanning will result in higher quality images for research and clinical applications. Conclusion: Good quality images were achievable in study units; although frequent artifacts were present in images, in general, they did not interfere with evaluation. Artifacts related to "layer nondifferentiation" was the greatest predictor of poor image quality, prompting operators to immediately rescan the area.

High frequency ultrasound sacral images in the critically ill: Tissue characteristics versus visual evaluation

PURPOSE

High frequency ultrasound (HFUS) systems may identify tissue injury. We compared HFUS tissue characteristics (dermal thickness and dermal density) with visual image examination.

METHODS

Longitudinal study in critically ill mechanically ventilated adults, from three ICUs (Surgical Trauma, Medical Respiratory, Neuroscience) enrolled within 24hours of airway intubation. Sacral HFUS images were obtained daily for up to seven days. Expert evaluation of the best image per day was completed and compared to HFUS generated tissue characteristics (dermal thickness and dermal density).

RESULTS

Of the113 subjects with 1614 comparisons analysed, 73.2% to 84% were normal, and 6.3% to 11.8% of the comparisons had injury present but no change was noted in the injury observed. There were no significant differences in one-day comparisons among type of injury and mean dermal thickness (p=0.6645) or dermal median intensity (adjusted p=0.06-0.17). All other day-to-day comparisons were similarly non-significant.

CONCLUSIONS

We found no association among dermal density, dermal thickness and visual examination of changes in sacral HFUS images for any day-to-day comparison. The use of sacral HFUS as a screening tool for the development of tissue injury is in its infancy. Additional comparative studies should be conducted to identify its future clinical usefulness.

Hypertrophic Burn Scar Research: From Quantitative Assessment to Designing Clinical Sequential Multiple Assignment Randomized Trials

This article explores the current options for the quantitative assessment of hypertrophic burn scars. It also introduces a novel type of randomized, controlled trial, which relies on heterogeneity of the subject population to improve the predictive value of personalized treatment strategies.

High-Frequency Ultrasound: Description of Sacral Tissue Characteristics in Healthy Adults

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to describe selected sacral tissue characteristics in a convenience sample of healthy volunteer subjects.

DESIGN

Descriptive.

SAMPLE AND SETTING

Fifty healthy volunteers in a clinical learning center in a school of nursing.

METHODS

Sacral scans were obtained using a 20-MHz ultrasound scanning system in 3 positions: prone and 60° and 90° side-lying from the back. The images were analyzed by software in the ultrasound program using quantitative parameters of dermal thickness and density (dermal median intensity and derived number of low-echogenic pixels to total pixels [LEP:TP] ratio).

RESULTS

In general, average values were as follows: dermal thickness between 2.32 and 2.65 mm; median pixel intensity between 102 and 112; and the LEP:TP ratio between 0.39 and 0.56. There were significant differences in sacral tissue characteristics between measures of thickness and dermal density (median intensity and LEP:TP ratio) by subject side-lying position (60° and 90°) versus prone position, with all P values less than .0001.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, the ranges were consistent across measures of thickness and dermal density except for systematic differences between side-lying and prone positions. When comparing thickness, median intensity, or LEP:TP ratio, it is important to report subject position. To best recognize tissue inflammation indicative of pressure injuries before surface changes are seen, it is useful to understand healthy high-frequency ultrasound sacral tissue characteristics. It is anticipated that quantitative assessment of dermal thickness, density, and LEP:TP ratio could help identify individuals with incipient pressure injury.

A systematic review of objective burn scar measurements

BACKGROUND

Problematic scarring remains a challenging aspect to address in the treatment of burns and can significantly affect the quality of life of the burn survivor. At present, there are few treatments available in the clinic to control adverse scarring, but experimental pharmacological anti-scarring strategies are now beginning to emerge. Their comparative success must be based on objective measurements of scarring, yet currently the clinical assessment of scars is not carried out systematically and is mostly based on subjective review of patients. However, several techniques and devices are being introduced that allow objective analysis of the burn scar. The aim of this article is to evaluate various objective measurement tools currently available and recommend a useful panel that is suitable for use in clinical trials of anti-scarring therapies.

METHODS

A systematic literature search was done using the Web of Science, PubMed and Cochrane databases. The identified devices were then classified and grouped according to the parameters they measured. The tools were then compared and assessed in terms of inter- and intra-rater reproducibility, ease of use and cost.

RESULTS

After duplicates were removed, 5062 articles were obtained in the search. After further screening, 157 articles which utilised objective burn scar measurement systems or tools were obtained. The scar measurement devices can be broadly classified into those measuring colour, metric variables, texture, biomechanical properties and pathophysiological disturbances.

CONCLUSIONS

Objective scar measurement tools allow the accurate and reproducible evaluation of scars, which is important for both clinical and scientific use. However, studies to evaluate their relative performance and merits of these tools are scarce, and there remain factors, such as itch and pain, which cannot be measured objectively. On reviewing the available evidence, a panel of devices for objective scar measurement is recommended consisting of the 3D cameras (Eykona/Lifeviz/Vectra H1) for surface area and volume, DSM II colorimeter for colour, Dermascan high-frequency ultrasound for scar thickness and Cutometer for skin elasticity and pliability.

Measurement of diabetic wounds with optical coherence tomography-based air-jet indentation system and a material testing system

OBJECTIVE

Material testing system is a conventional but destructive method for measuring the biomechanical properties of wound tissues in basic research. The recently developed optical coherence tomography-based air-jet indentation system is a non-destructive method for measuring these properties of soft tissues in a non-contact manner. The aim of the study was to examine the correlation between the biomechanical properties of wound tissues measured by the two systems.

METHOD

Young male Sprague-Dawley rats with streptozotocin-induced diabetic were wounded by a 6 mm biopsy punch on their hind limbs. The biomechanical properties of wound tissues were assessed with the two systems on post-wounding days 3, 7, 10, 14, and 21. Wound sections were stained with picro-sirius red for analysis on the collagen fibres. Data obtained on the different days were charted to obtain the change in biomechanical properties across the time points, and then pooled to examine the correlation between measurements made by the two devices. Qualitative analysis to determine any correlation between indentation stiffness measured by the air-jet indentation system and the orientation of collagen fibres.

RESULTS

The indentation stiffness is significantly negatively correlated to the maximum load, maximum tensile stress, and Young's modulus by the material testing system (all p<0.05). The orientation of collagen changes with the indentation stiffness over time.

CONCLUSION

Our findings support the use of optical coherence tomography-based air-jet indentation system to evaluate the biomechanical properties of wounds in a non-contact manner. It is a potential clinical device to examine the biomechanical properties of chronic wounds in vivo in a repeatable manner.

Noninvasive imaging technologies for cutaneous wound assessment: A review

The ability to phenotype wounds for the purposes of assessing severity, healing potential and treatment is an important function of evidence-based medicine. A variety of optical technologies are currently in development for noninvasive wound assessment. To varying extents, these optical technologies have the potential to supplement traditional clinical wound evaluation and research, by providing detailed information regarding skin components imperceptible to visual inspection. These assessments are achieved through quantitative optical analysis of tissue characteristics including blood flow, collagen remodeling, hemoglobin content, inflammation, temperature, vascular structure, and water content. Technologies that have, to this date, been applied to wound assessment include: near infrared imaging, thermal imaging, optical coherence tomography, orthogonal polarization spectral imaging, fluorescence imaging, laser Doppler imaging, microscopy, spatial frequency domain imaging, photoacoustic detection, and spectral/hyperspectral imaging. We present a review of the technologies in use or development for these purposes with three aims: (1) providing basic explanations of imaging technology concepts, (2) reviewing the wound imaging literature, and (3) providing insight into areas for further application and exploration. Noninvasive imaging is a promising advancement in wound assessment and all technologies require further validation.

Use of high frequency ultrasound to detect changes in skin integrity: An image evaluation validation procedure

OBJECTIVES

High frequency ultrasound (HFUS) scanning may be used for prevention, detection and monitoring of pressure ulcers in patients at risk and is amenable for portable, bedside use by a variety of clinicians. Limited data are available about the criteria to determine an ideal image or measures of tissue changes representative of tissue injury. We developed and evaluated criteria for overall image quality and measures of tissue integrity.

METHODS

In 40 mechanically ventilated adults in 3 ICUs, 241 HFUS sacral images were evaluated for agreement using criteria for overall image quality and tissue changes (dermal, hypodermal layer thickness and layer density).

RESULTS

HFUS sacral images (N=241) were evaluated in three analyses and showed poor agreement in all three analyses using the specific criteria for global quality, however when criteria were collapsed agreement was good to substantial. Evaluator agreement for layer thickness and layer density was also good.

CONCLUSIONS

A global rating is adequate for identifying good images. Agreement for measurements of layer thickness and density were also good and may be useful to identify early changes in tissue integrity leading to tissue injury. Additional data are needed concerning the association of changes in layer thickness and layer density to eventual tissue injury.

Imaging of collagen deposition disorders using optical coherence tomography

BACKGROUND

Collagen deposition disorders such as hypertrophic scars, keloids and scleroderma can be associated with significant stigma and embarrassment. These disorders often constitute considerable impairment to quality of life, with treatment posing to be a substantial challenge. Optical coherence tomography (OCT) provides a non-invasive, easily applicable bedside optical imaging method for assessment of the skin. It is hypothesized that OCT imaging may be useful in assessing fibrosis to avoid additional biopsies that could potentially worsen the scarring.

METHOD

Thirty-three patients with ordinary scars, hypertrophic scars, keloid scarring, lichen sclerosus et atrophicus and localized or systemic scleroderma were recruited for this pilot study. Affected tissue and adjacent healthy skin were scanned using OCT and digitally photographed. Density measurements were performed in ImageJ on OCT images from scleroderma patients, both systemic and morphea (10 patients), keloid patients (10 patients) and healthy skin adjacent to keloids (10 patients).

RESULTS

OCT images of scarring diseases showed varying degrees of disruption to the skin architecture. OCT characteristics were identified for each lesion type. Hypertrophic scars displayed an increased vascularity and signal-rich bands correlating to excessive collagen deposition. Keloids depicted a disarray of hyper-reflective areas primarily located in the upper dermis. Additionally, the dermis displayed a heterogeneous morphology without indications of any vascular supply or lymphatic network. In contrast to keloids, scleroderma displayed a more cohesive backscattering indicating a difference in density of collagen or other dermal structures. OCT images demonstrated no significant differences between mean density measurements in OCT images of scleroderma, keloid and healthy skin (P = 0.07).

CONCLUSION

The OCT imaging appears to identify different scarring mechanisms, and therefore be of potential use in the assessment of outcomes following non-invasive therapy of e.g. early or progressive lesions.

Skin blood flow abnormalities in diabetic dermopathy

BACKGROUND

Diabetic dermopathy is the most common specific cutaneous finding in diabetes.

OBJECTIVE

Using laser Doppler technology, we tested the hypothesis that diabetic dermopathy arises from abnormal local skin blood flow.

METHODS

We measured cutaneous blood flow in patients with type 1 diabetes without dermopathy and compared values with those in a control group of patients with type 1 diabetes without diabetic dermopathy and in a nondiabetic group. We measured at 3 separate sites on the pretibial area on the legs of each participant, at dermopathy lesions, and at a number of standard sites on the upper and lower extremities.

RESULTS

We studied 25 patients with diabetes and diabetic dermopathy, average age 51 ± 2 years, mean duration of diabetes 28 ± 3 years. In all, 58 patients with type 1 diabetes without diabetic dermopathy served as control patients, average age 41 ± 2 years, mean duration of diabetes 23 ± 2 years. There were 67 nondiabetic control subjects, average age 47 ± 3 years. The patients with diabetic dermopathy showed a marked reduction in skin blood flow at 35°C at normal-appearing skin areas on the pretibial surface of the legs (1.1 ± 0.1 mL/min/100 g) compared with 1.7 ± 0.1 mL/min/100 g (P = .01) in the type 1 diabetic control group and 2.1 ± 0.3 mL/min/100 g (P < .01) in the nondiabetic group. The dermopathy lesions themselves showed markedly higher blood flow: 2.5 ± 0.3 mL/min/100 g.

LIMITATIONS

Our diabetic dermopathy patients were somewhat older than the control type 1 diabetes subjects, but were of comparable age to the nondiabetic subjects.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that patients susceptible to diabetic dermopathy have a functional abnormality in blood flow leading to this scarring process.

Noninvasive assessment of diabetic foot ulcers with diffuse photon density wave methodology: pilot human study

A pilot human study is conducted to evaluate the potential of using diffuse photon density wave (DPDW) methodology at near-infrared (NIR) wavelengths (685 to 830 nm) to monitor changes in tissue hemoglobin concentration in diabetic foot ulcers. Hemoglobin concentration is measured by DPDW in 12 human wounds for a period ranging from 10 to 61 weeks. In all wounds that healed completely, gradual decreases in optical absorption coefficient, oxygenated hemoglobin concentration, and total hemoglobin concentration are observed between the first and last measurements. In nonhealing wounds, the rates of change of these properties are nearly zero or slightly positive, and a statistically significant difference (p<0.05) is observed in the rates of change between healing and nonhealing wounds. Differences in the variability of DPDW measurements over time are observed between healing and nonhealing wounds, and this variance may also be a useful indicator of nonhealing wounds. Our results demonstrate that DPDW methodology with a frequency domain NIR device can differentiate healing from nonhealing diabetic foot ulcers, and indicate that it may have clinical utility in the evaluation of wound healing potential.

Photoplanimetric evaluation and impedance measurement of split-thickness skin grafts: a new model for objective wound-healing assessment in clinical trials

PURPOSE

The objective assessment of wound healing is a challenging task especially in the context of clinical trials. Because the clinical evaluation of wounds and the wound-healing quality is often influenced by the subjective view of the physician, there is great need for a reliable, quantitative and objective wound model that would help to obtain statistically useful data. Here, we present a wound model and non-invasive analysis techniques to evaluate human wound healing. The model described was used in a clinical trial on 167 patients treated with a new wound therapeutic agent.

METHODS

The study was conducted on 167 patients receiving split-thickness mesh grafts (1 : 1.5 and 0.1 mm) after reconstructive procedures. The re-epithelialization of the mesh holes and the leakage of wound serum served as the main parameters of wound healing. The quantitative evaluation of the epithelialization rate was performed by photoplanimetry and impedance measurement. These data were correlated with the clinical wound assessment of two independent physicians.

RESULTS

The study showed that computer-aided photoplanimetry, in combination with impedance measurement, is a feasible and very useful method to evaluate the re-epithelialization rate of mesh skin grafts.

CONCLUSION

The model described is a viable method to evaluate human wound healing in clinical trials.

Scarring occurs at a critical depth of skin injury: precise measurement in a graduated dermal scratch in human volunteers

BACKGROUND

The association between scarring and the depth of dermal injury or burn is clinically recognized but not quantified. The authors tested the hypothesis that there is a critical depth beyond which a fibrous scar develops.

METHODS

A novel jig produced a wound that was deep dermal at one end and superficial dermal at the other. Pilot studies in cadaveric and ex vivo breast skin confirmed the depth of injury. Healthy volunteers had a standardized dermal wound made on the lateral aspect of the hip. Digital photography recorded the surface appearance of wound healing and scar development. High-frequency ultrasound demonstrated the depth of the healing wound and subsequent scar in vivo.

RESULTS

One hundred thirteen human subjects participated in the clinical study. Mean length of follow up was 28.6 +/- 13.2 weeks. The deep dermal end of the wound healed with a visible scar and the superficial end had no visible residual mark after week 18. The initial length of injury was 51.3 +/- 0.6 mm, which reduced to a scar of 34.9 +/- 1.0 mm at 36 weeks (corresponding areas were 196.6 +/- 7.5 mm and 92.7 +/- 9.4 mm). High-frequency ultrasound analysis showed a gradual reduction in scar thickness at the deep end and no detectable scar at the shallow end. The transition point between scar and no scar marked the threshold depth for scarring. This was calculated as 0.56 +/- 0.03 mm, or 33.1 percent of normal hip skin thickness.

CONCLUSIONS

The dermal scratch provides a well-tolerated, standardized, and reproducible wound model for investigating the healing response to dermal injury of different depths. There is a threshold depth of dermal injury at which scarring develops.

Characterization strategies for the functional assessment of the cutaneous lesion

Assessment of wound healing is a complex task, especially when the lesion is associated to significant (full thickness) loss of the skin. The clinical observation, essentially subjective and highly dependent on the observer's experience, creates difficulties in the comparison of results. Scoring scales were introduced in the clinical practice to create comparable semi-quantitative data and promote better management of resources, but its usefulness in a clinical perspective is still limited. New non-invasive biometric methodologies, although infrequently used, have opened new possibilities. While complementing the clinical observation and contributing to therapeutic decisions and prognosis, they may also help to look further into the pathophysiological mechanisms of scarring drugs rehabilitation. Following previous work in this arena, the authors review, the state-of-the-art of cutaneous wound healing clinical and biometric follow up, proposing a diagnosis correlation for the most relevant descriptors found in both strategies in order to fully characterise the different stages of the healing process.

Manifestations of cutaneous diabetic microangiopathy

The etiologies of a variety of skin conditions associated with diabetes have not been fully explained. One possible etiological factor is diabetic microangiopathy, which is known to affect the eyes and kidneys in patients with diabetes. There are many mechanisms by which diabetes may cause microangiopathy. These include excess sorbitol formation, increased glycation end products, oxidative damage, and protein kinase C overactivity. All of these processes occur in the skin, and the existence of a cutaneous diabetic microangiopathy has been well demonstrated. These microangiopathic changes are associated with abnormalities of skin perfusion. Because the skin plays a thermoregulatory role, there is significant capillary redundancy in normal skin. In diabetic patients, loss of capillaries is associated with a decrease in perfusion reserve. This lost reserve is demonstrable under stressed conditions, such as thermal stimulation. The associated failure of microvascular perfusion to meet the requirements of skin metabolism may result in diverse skin lesions in patients with diabetes. Many skin conditions peculiar to diabetes are fairly rare. Necrobiosis lipoidica diabeticorum (NLD) and diabetic bullae occur very infrequently as compared with diabetic retinopathy and nephropathy. Conversely, there is a correlation between diabetic microvascular disease and NLD. This correlation also exists with more common skin conditions, such as diabetic dermopathy. This relationship suggests that diabetic microangiopathy may contribute to these conditions even if it is not primarily causal. Clinically, the major significance of diabetic cutaneous microangiopathy is seen in skin ulceration which is very common and has a major impact on diabetic patients. Many factors contribute to the development of diabetic foot ulcers. Neuropathy, decreased large vessel perfusion, increased susceptibility to infection, and altered biomechanics all play a role, but there is no doubt that inadequate small blood vessel perfusion is a major cause of the inability to heal small wounds that eventually results in ulcer formation. The accessibility of skin capillaries makes cutaneous diabetic microangiopathy an attractive model for research on the evolution of microvascular disease in diabetic patients.

Objective assessment of burn scar vascularity, erythema, pliability, thickness, and planimetry

BACKGROUND

There is currently a lack of objective methods to assess scars.

OBJECTIVES

The objectives of this study were to (1) determine the pattern of scar formation up to 24 months after a burn, compare clinical and photographic scar assessment, and determine what percentage of scars became hypertrophic after a major trauma and (2) replace each clinical parameter of a clinical scar scale by objective measurements.

METHODS

Scars from 62 patients were evaluated from the acute phase up to 24 months after the burn, using photographs and clinical assessment during visits. Photographic planimetry helped estimate the percentage of scars that became hypertrophic. Thereafter, 69 patients had scars evaluated using clinical assessment and several instruments to evaluate pigmentation, erythema, pliability, thickness, and perfusion. The sensitivity and specificity of each instrument were determined regarding their ability to correlate with the parameters of hypertrophic and nonhypertrophic scars. Analysis of variance and Tukey's test were used in statistical analysis, with p<.05 indicating significance.

RESULTS

Increased scar hypertrophy occurred between 6 and 12 months after the burn, and less than 30% of scars were hypertrophic at 18 to 24 months. Objective assessment of pliability and erythema, but not pigmentation, correlated significantly with clinical evaluation of hypertrophy. Hypertrophic scars had significantly higher perfusion than nonhypertrophic scars. A new scar rating system is proposed, based on the sensitivity and specificity of each instrument, to correlate with hypertrophic and nonhypertrophic scars.

CONCLUSIONS

Objective rating systems using reliable instruments can be used to replace subjective scar assessment. Larger multicenter prospective studies should test this new scale in scars due to other mechanisms of injury.

Real-time monitoring of keratin 5 expression during burn re-epithelialization1

BACKGROUND

Keratin is a major protein produced during epithelialization following burn injury and is a useful marker for assessing wound healing. Transgenic mice expressing enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) driven by the keratin 5 (K5) promoter (K5GFP mice) were used to monitor keratin expression, and thus, re-epithelialization of burn wounds.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

K5GFP transgenic mice were created using conventional techniques, with PCR and Southern blot confirmation of transgene incorporation, followed by selection of the line with the most intense and consistent basal epithelial EGFP expression. Epi-fluorescent microscopy of 24 K5GFP mouse flanks and 10 negative littermate controls was used to characterize EGFP intensity, before wounding and serially for 30 days after administration of a standardized burn wound and excision. Biopsy sections of K5GFP and negative control mice were stained with K5 antibody and imaged with confocal microscopy to characterize the distribution of EGFP and K5 at baseline and after injury and to examine the correlation between K5 expression and EGFP expression during healing.

RESULTS

Green fluorescence intensity increased at the advancing wound margin of burned K5GFP mice, reaching a maximum between days 12 and 15 post-burn and then decreasing as healing completed. K5 and EGFP expression increased in parallel in burned K5GFP mice as demonstrated by confocal microscopy.

CONCLUSION

EGFP expression correlated with K5 expression during wound healing and therefore serves as a good marker of re-epithelialization. This transgenic model allows noninvasive, real-time assessment of in vivo K5 expression and will be useful in the study of wound healing.

Extracellular matrix metabolites as potential biomarkers of disease activity in wound fluid: lessons learned from other inflammatory diseases?

The new era of pharmacogenetics has identified a potential for individuals to receive customized treatments for a variety of disease states. For such individualized treatments to fulfil their potential, it will be essential for clinicians to be able to monitor disease activity, ideally in a rapid, noninvasive fashion. The accessibility of the skin offers much potential to develop noninvasive tests of metabolic and disease activity for clinical use. Impaired human wound healing in the skin is a chronic inflammatory disorder in which the development of such tests has considerable potential, aiding clinical decision making and monitoring responses to treatment. This review article discusses how studies in other human diseases have highlighted potential biochemical markers (biomarkers) of disease activity in secreted biofluids, as aids to determining disease and metabolic activity within tissues. Using, as examples, lessons learned in the study of disease activity and prognosis of other chronic inflammatory conditions, such as osteoarthritis and periodontal disease, this review highlights the potential of dermal extracellular matrix (ECM) components (collagens, proteoglycans, hyaluronan and glycoproteins) for such uses. The limitations of currently utilized techniques and the concept that analysis of ECM components in wound fluid may represent useful biomarkers of disease activity are also discussed.

Impact of in vivo glycation of LDL on platelet aggregation and monocyte chemotaxis in diabetic Psammomys obesus

Psammomys obesus (sand rat) is an appropriate model to highlight the development of hyperinsulinemia, insulin resistance, obesity, and diabetes. This animal species, with genetically predetermined diabetes, acquires non-insulin dependent diabetes mellitus when exposed to energy-rich diets. In the present study, we explored the possibility that glycation of LDL may occur in diabetes-prone P. obesus and affect platelet and macrophage functions. The glycation of LDL, isolated from diabetic animals, was significantly (P < 0.05) higher (40%) than that of control animals. The incubation of platelets with glycated LDL enhanced the reactivity of platelets by 32-44% depending on the aggregating agents (thrombin, collagen, ADP). Furthermore, LDL derived from diabetic rats were chemotactic for normal monocytes and stimulated the incorporation of [14C]oleate into cellular cholesteryl esters. The enhancement of platelet aggregation and cholesterol esterification in monocytes may contribute toward the accelerated development of atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease in diabetic P. obesus animals. This study also illustrates the relevance of studying atherosclerosis in the P. obesus animal model, as it shows an increased tendency to develop diet-induced diabetes, which is associated with cardiovascular disorders.

Reproducibility of repeated measurements on post-burn scars with Dermascan C

The present study investigated the reproducibility of measurements with the Dermascan C on post-burn scars. Intra- and inter-rater reproducibility and test-retest reliability with a one week time lapse were examined on 40 post-burn scars of 6 volunteering burn patients by means of intra-class- correlation coefficients (ICC) and standard error of measurements (SEM). Results showed good to excellent values for ICC in all the three conditions. On the basis of these results, we concluded that the instrument provides reliable information and can be used in comparative clinical trials that examine therapeutic strategies on healing scars.