Functional groups required for the stability of yeast RNA triphosphatase in vitro and in vivo

Crystal structures of the RNA triphosphatase from Trypanosoma cruzi provide insights into how it recognizes the 5'-end of the RNA substrate

RNA triphosphatase catalyzes the first step in mRNA cap formation, hydrolysis of the terminal phosphate from the nascent mRNA transcript. The RNA triphosphatase from the protozoan parasite Trypanosoma cruzi, TcCet1, belongs to the family of triphosphate tunnel metalloenzymes (TTMs). TcCet1 is a promising antiprotozoal drug target because the mechanism and structure of the protozoan RNA triphosphatases are completely different from those of the RNA triphosphatases found in mammalian and arthropod hosts. Here, we report several crystal structures of the catalytically active form of TcCet1 complexed with a divalent cation and an inorganic tripolyphosphate in the active-site tunnel at 2.20-2.51 Å resolutions. The structures revealed that the overall structure, the architecture of the tunnel, and the arrangement of the metal-binding site in TcCet1 are similar to those in other TTM proteins. On the basis of the position of three sulfate ions that cocrystallized on the positively charged surface of the protein and results obtained from mutational analysis, we identified an RNA-binding site in TcCet1. We conclude that the 5'-end of the triphosphate RNA substrate enters the active-site tunnel directionally. The structural information reported here provides valuable insight into designing inhibitors that could specifically block the entry of the triphosphate RNA substrate into the TTM-type RNA triphosphatases of T. cruzi and related pathogens.

Nanomolar Inhibitors of Trypanosoma brucei RNA Triphosphatase

Eukaryal taxa differ with respect to the structure and mechanism of the RNA triphosphatase (RTPase) component of the mRNA capping apparatus. Protozoa, fungi, and certain DNA viruses have a metal-dependent RTPase that belongs to the triphosphate tunnel metalloenzyme (TTM) superfamily. Because the structures, active sites, and chemical mechanisms of the TTM-type RTPases differ from those of mammalian RTPases, the TTM RTPases are potential targets for antiprotozoal, antifungal, and antiviral drug discovery. Here, we employed RNA interference (RNAi) knockdown methods to show that Trypanosoma brucei RTPase Cet1 (TbCet1) is necessary for proliferation of procyclic cells in culture. We then conducted a high-throughput biochemical screen for small-molecule inhibitors of the phosphohydrolase activity of TbCet1. We identified several classes of chemicals-including chlorogenic acids, phenolic glycopyranosides, flavonoids, and other phenolics-that inhibit TbCet1 with nanomolar to low-micromolar 50% inhibitory concentrations (IC50s). We confirmed the activity of these compounds, and tested various analogs thereof, by direct manual assays of TbCet1 phosphohydrolase activity. The most potent nanomolar inhibitors included tetracaffeoylquinic acid, 5-galloylgalloylquinic acid, pentagalloylglucose, rosmarinic acid, and miquelianin. TbCet1 inhibitors were less active (or inactive) against the orthologous TTM-type RTPases of mimivirus, baculovirus, and budding yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae). Our results affirm that a TTM RTPase is subject to potent inhibition by small molecules, with the caveat that parallel screens against TTM RTPases from multiple different pathogens may be required to fully probe the chemical space of TTM inhibition.

IMPORTANCE

The stark differences between the structure and mechanism of the RNA triphosphatase (RTPase) component of the mRNA capping apparatus in pathogenic protozoa, fungi, and viruses and those of their metazoan hosts highlight RTPase as a target for anti-infective drug discovery. Protozoan, fungal, and DNA virus RTPases belong to the triphosphate tunnel metalloenzyme family. This study shows that a protozoan RTPase, TbCet1 from Trypanosoma brucei, is essential for growth of the parasite in culture and identifies, via in vitro screening of chemical libraries, several classes of potent small-molecule inhibitors of TbCet1 phosphohydrolase activity.

Enzymology of RNA cap synthesis

The 5' guanine-N7 methyl cap is unique to cellular and viral messenger RNA (mRNA) and is the first co-transcriptional modification of mRNA. The mRNA cap plays a pivotal role in mRNA biogenesis and stability, and is essential for efficient splicing, mRNA export, and translation. Capping occurs by a series of three enzymatic reactions that results in formation of N7-methyl guanosine linked through a 5'-5' inverted triphosphate bridge to the first nucleotide of a nascent transcript. Capping of cellular mRNA occurs co-transcriptionally and in vivo requires that the capping apparatus be physically associated with the RNA polymerase II elongation complex. Certain capped mRNAs undergo further methylation to generate distinct cap structures. Although mRNA capping is conserved among viruses and eukaryotes, some viruses have adopted strategies for capping mRNA that are distinct from the cellular mRNA capping pathway.

Nucleotide analogs and molecular modeling studies reveal key interactions involved in substrate recognition by the yeast RNA triphosphatase

RNA triphosphatases (RTPases) are involved in the addition of the distinctive cap structure found at the 5′ ends of eukaryotic mRNAs. Fungi, protozoa and some DNA viruses possess an RTPase that belongs to the triphosphate tunnel metalloenzyme family of enzymes that can also hydrolyze nucleoside triphosphates. Previous crystallization studies revealed that the phosphohydrolase catalytic core is located in a hydrophilic tunnel composed of antiparallel β-strands. However, all past efforts to obtain structural information on the interaction between RTPases and their substrates were unsuccessful. In the present study, we used computational molecular docking to model the binding of a nucleotide substrate into the yeast RTPase active site. In order to confirm the docking model and to gain additional insights into the molecular determinants involved in substrate recognition, we also evaluated both the phosphohydrolysis and the inhibitory potential of an important number of nucleotide analogs. Our study highlights the importance of specific amino acids for the binding of the sugar, base and triphosphate moieties of the nucleotide substrate, and reveals both the structural flexibility and complexity of the active site. These data illustrate the functional features required for the interaction of an RTPase with a ligand and pave the way to the use of nucleotide analogs as potential inhibitors of RTPases of pathogenic importance.

High-throughput assays for yeast RNA 5' triphosphatase (Cet1p)

The 5' cap on eukaryotic messenger RNA (mRNA) is critical for the stabilization, processing, nuclear transport, and translation of the transcript. Before capping can occur, the gamma-phosphate from the 5' end of newly synthesized RNA must be removed. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, this reaction is catalyzed by Cet1p, an RNA triphosphatase. Because Cet1p is both essential for fungal growth and sufficiently different from its human counterpart in terms of three-dimensional structure and catalytic mechanism, it represents an unexplored target for antifungal drug discovery. To this end, we characterized the steady-state kinetics of Cet1p using both synthetic RNA oligos and nucleoside triphosphates. Nucleotide triphosphatase activity was measured in a scintillation proximity assay (SPA)-based high-throughput screen using [gamma-(33)P]biotin-11 GTP as substrate (GTP-SPA); the format is sensitive, accurate, robust, and compatible with automation. A charcoal absorption method was used to measure the release of free inorganic phosphate from an RNA substrate; the method was adapted to fit a 96-well plate format. The performance of the GTP-SPA and RNA assays was tested against a panel of commercially available compounds and found to be comparable. The charcoal absorption method run in the 96-well plate format has general utility for any phosphatase using nucleotides, nucleic acids, or proteins as substrate.

Divalent metal requirements for catalysis and stability of the RNA triphosphatase from Trypanosoma cruzi

RNA triphosphatases act in the first step of the mRNA capping process, removing the gamma-phosphoryl group from the 5' end of nascent RNA. A metal-dependent catalysis is found in the enzymes from trypanosomes and several other lower eukaryotes. This contrasts with the cysteine-dependent activity of the corresponding enzymes of mammals, a difference that points to these enzymes as potential targets for drug design. This work describes the identification, expression, purification, enzyme kinetics, and the role of divalent metal in the ATPase activity of the RNA triphosphatase from Trypanosoma cruzi, the agent of Chagas' disease, and compares it with the previously characterized enzyme from Trypanosoma brucei. Sequence similarity of the T. cruzi enzyme with the RNA triphosphatase of Saccharomyces cerevisiae indicates that a tunnel domain containing the divalent metal forms its active site. Based on enzyme kinetics, circular dichroism, and intrinsic fluorescence analysis, a kinetic mechanism for the ATPase activity of the T. cruzi tunnel triphosphatase is proposed. A single metal is sufficient to interact with the enzyme through the formation of a productive MnATP-enzyme complex, while free ATP inhibits activity. Manganese is also required for the tunnel stability of the T. cruzi enzyme, while the T. brucei homologue remains stable in the absence of metal, as shown for other triphosphatases. These findings may be useful to devise specific triphosphatase inhibitors to the T. cruzi enzyme.

Investigating the role of metal ions in the catalytic mechanism of the yeast RNA triphosphatase

The Saccharomyces cerevisiae RNA triphosphatase (Cet1) requires the presence of metal ion cofactors to catalyze its phosphohydrolase activity, the first step in the formation of the 5'-terminal cap structure of mRNAs. We have used endogenous tryptophan fluorescence studies to elucidate both the nature and the role(s) of the metal ions in the Cet1-mediated phosphohydrolase reaction. The association of Mg2+, Mn2+, and Co2+ ions with the enzyme resulted in a decrease in the intensity of the tryptophan emission spectrum. This decrease was then used to determine the apparent dissociation constants for these ions. Subsequent dual ligand titration experiments demonstrated that the metal ions bind to a common site, for which they compete. The kinetics of real-time metal ion binding to the Cet1 protein were also investigated, and the effects on RNA and nucleotide binding were evaluated. To provide additional insight into the relationship between Cet1 structure and metal ion binding, we correlated the effect of ion binding on protein structure using both circular dichroism and guanidium hydrochloride-induced denaturation as structural indicators. Our data indicate that binding of RNA, nucleotides, and metal ion cofactors does not lead to significant structural modifications of the Cet1 architecture. This suggests a model in which Cet1 possesses a preformed active site, and where major domain rearrangements are not required to form an active catalytic site. Finally, denaturation studies demonstrate that the metal ion cofactors can act by stabilizing the ground state binding of the phosphohydrolase substrate.

Chlorella virus RNA triphosphatase. Mutational analysis and mechanism of inhibition by tripolyphosphate

Chlorella virus RNA triphosphatase (cvRtp1) is the smallest member of a family of metal-dependent phosphohydrolases that includes the RNA triphosphatases of fungi, protozoa, poxviruses, and baculoviruses. The primary structure of cvRtp1 is more similar to that of the yeast RNA triphosphatase Cet1 than it is to the RNA triphosphatases of other DNA viruses. To evaluate the higher order structural similarities between cvRtp1 and the fungal enzymes, we performed an alanine scan of individual residues of cvRtp1 that were predicted, on the basis of the crystal structure of Cet1, to be located at or near the active site. Twelve residues (Glu(24), Glu(26), Asp(64), Arg(76), Lys(90), Glu(112), Arg(127), Lys(129), Arg(131), Asp(142), Glu(163), and Glu(165)) were deemed essential for catalysis by cvRtp1, insofar as their replacement by alanine reduced phosphohydrolase activity to <5% of the wild-type value. Structure-activity relationships were elucidated by introducing conservative substitutions at the essential positions. The mutational results suggest that the active site of cvRtp1 is likely to adopt a tunnel fold like that of Cet1 and that a similar constellation of side chains within the tunnel is responsible for metal binding and reaction chemistry. Nonetheless, there are several discordant mutational effects in cvRtp1 versus Cet1, which suggest that different members of the phosphohydrolase family vary in their reliance on certain residues within the active site tunnel. We found that tripolyphosphate and pyrophosphate were potent competitive inhibitors of cvRtp1 (K(i) = 0.6 microm tripolyphosphate and 2.4 microm pyrophosphate, respectively), whereas phosphate had little effect. cvRtp1 displayed a weak intrinsic tripolyphosphatase activity (3% of its ATPase activity) but was unable to hydrolyze pyrophosphate.