Analysis of somatic mutations in kappa transgenes

Promoter Proximity Defines Mutation Window for VH and VΚ Genes Rearranged to Different J Genes

Somatic hypermutation induced by activation-induced deaminase (AID) occurs at high densities between the Ig V gene promoter and intronic enhancer, which encompasses DNA encoding the rearranged V gene exon and J intron. It has been proposed that proximity between the promoter and enhancer defines the boundaries of mutation in V regions. However, depending on the J gene used, the distance between the promoter and enhancer is quite variable and may result in differential targeting around the V gene. To examine the effect of distance in mutation accumulation, we sequenced 320 clones containing different endogenous rearranged V genes in the IgH and Igκ loci from Peyer's patch B cells of mice. Clones were grouped by their use of different J genes. Distances between the V gene and enhancer ranged from ∼2.3 kb of intron DNA for rearrangements using J1, ∼2.0 kb for rearrangements using J2, ∼1.6 kb for rearrangements using J3 (H) or 4 (κ), and 1.1 kb for rearrangements using J4 (H) or 5 (κ). Strikingly, >90% of intron mutations occurred within 1 kb downstream of the J gene for both H and κ clones, regardless of which J gene was used. Thus, there is no evidence that the intron sequence or enhancer plays a role in determining the extent of mutation. The results indicate that V region intron mutations are targeted by their proximity to the promoter, suggesting they result from AID interactions with RNA polymerase II over a 1-kb region.

JH6 downstream intronic sequence is dispensable for RNA polymerase II accumulation and somatic hypermutation of the variable gene in Ramos cells

Activation-induced deaminase (AID) introduces nucleotide substitutions within the variable region of immunoglobulin genes to promote antibody diversity. This activity, which is limited to 1.5 kb downstream of the variable gene promoter, mutates both the coding exon and downstream intronic sequences. We recently reported that RNA polymerase II accumulates in these regions during transcription in mice. This build-up directly correlates with the area that is accessible to AID, and manipulation of RNA polymerase II levels alters the mutation frequency. To address whether the intronic DNA sequence by itself can regulate RNA polymerase II accumulation and promote mutagenesis, we deleted 613 bp of DNA downstream of the J_H6 intron in the human Ramos B cell line. The loss of this sequence did not alter polymerase abundance or mutagenesis in the variable gene, suggesting that most of the intronic sequence is dispensable for somatic hypermutation.

The 7-valent pneumococcal conjugate vaccine elicits cross-functional opsonophagocytic killing responses to Streptococcus pneumoniae serotype 6D in children

Background

We investigated the immune response to serogroup 6 with the opsonophagocytic killing assay (OPKA) in children aged 12–23 months of age after immunization with the 7-valent pneumococcal conjugate vaccine (PCV7) containing serotype 6B.

Methods

Blood samples were obtained from 59 children who had blood sampling for medical examination. Immunization status against PCV7 was confirmed by immunization records and samples were categorized according to immunization status into a booster, primary, or control group. The OPKA was performed for serotypes 6A, 6B, 6C, and 6D.

Results

Subjects with no previous PCV7 immunization history showed opsonic activity for serogroup 6 in 5-30% (according to serotype). In subjects vaccinated with a 3-dose primary series, 81% showed opsonic activity for serotypes 6B and 6D, and 29% showed opsonic activity for serotypes 6A and 6C. Among subjects vaccinated with a booster dose, all subjects had opsonic activity against serotype 6B. Subjects in the booster group with opsonic activity against serotypes 6A, 6C, and 6D were 100%, 78%, and 89%, respectively.

Conclusions

In subjects aged 12–23 months, an immune response is elicited after a primary series of immunizations with PCV7 for serotypes 6B and 6D, and a booster dose enhances a cross reactive immune response against serotypes 6A, 6C and 6D.

AID and Apobec3G haphazard deamination and mutational diversity

Activation-induced deoxycytidine deaminase (AID) and Apobec 3G (Apo3G) cause mutational diversity by initiating mutations on regions of single-stranded (ss) DNA. Expressed in B cells, AID deaminates C → U in actively transcribed immunoglobulin (Ig) variable and switch regions to initiate the somatic hypermutation (SHM) and class switch recombination (CSR) that are essential for antibody diversity. Apo3G expressed in T cells catalyzes C deaminations on reverse transcribed cDNA causing HIV-1 retroviral inactivation. When operating properly, AID- and Apo3G-initiated mutations boost human fitness. Yet, both enzymes are potentially powerful somatic cell "mutators". Loss of regulated expression and proper genome targeting can cause human cancer. Here, we review well-established biological roles of AID and Apo3G. We provide a synopsis of AID partnering proteins during SHM and CSR, and describe how an Apo2 crystal structure provides "surrogate" insight for AID and Apo3G biochemical behavior. However, large gaps remain in our understanding of how dC deaminases search ssDNA to identify trinucleotide motifs to deaminate. We discuss two recent methods to analyze ssDNA scanning and deamination. Apo3G scanning and deamination is visualized in real-time using single-molecule FRET, and AID deamination efficiencies are determined with a random walk analysis. AID and Apo3G encounter many candidate deamination sites while scanning ssDNA. Generating mutational diversity is a principal aim of AID and an important ancillary property of Apo3G. Success seems likely to involve hit and miss deamination motif targeting, biased strongly toward miss.

Nonimmunoglobulin target loci of activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) share unique features with immunoglobulin genes

Activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) is required for both somatic hypermutation and class-switch recombination in activated B cells. AID is also known to target nonimmunoglobulin genes and introduce mutations or chromosomal translocations, eventually causing tumors. To identify as-yet-unknown AID targets, we screened early AID-induced DNA breaks by using two independent genome-wide approaches. Along with known AID targets, this screen identified a set of unique genes (SNHG3, MALAT1, BCL7A, and CUX1) and confirmed that these loci accumulated mutations as frequently as Ig locus after AID activation. Moreover, these genes share three important characteristics with the Ig gene: translocations in tumors, repetitive sequences, and the epigenetic modification of chromatin by H3K4 trimethylation in the vicinity of cleavage sites.

Error-prone DNA repair activity during somatic hypermutation in shark B lymphocytes

Sharks are representatives of the earliest vertebrates that possess an immune system utilizing V(D)J recombination to generate Ag receptors. Their Ab repertoire diversity is based in part on a somatic hypermutation process that introduces adjacent nucleotide substitutions of 2-5 bp. We have isolated mutant nonfunctional Ig rearrangements and intronic flank sequences to characterize the nonselected, intrinsic properties of this phenomenon; changes unique to shark were observed. Duplications and deletions were associated with N additions, suggesting participation of a DNA polymerase with some degree of template independence during the repair of DNA breaks initiated by activation-induced cytidine deaminase. Other mutations were consistent with some in vitro activities of mammalian translesion DNA polymerase η: tandem base substitutions, strand slippage, and small insertions/deletions. The nature of substitution patterns shows that DNA lesions at shark Ig genes recruit DNA repair factors with a species-specific repertoire of activities. We speculate that the tandem mutations are introduced by direct sequential misinsertions and that, in shark B cells, the mispairs tend to be extended rather than proofread. Despite extensive changes undergone by some mutants, the physical range of mutational activity remained restricted to VDJ and within the first 2-kb portion of the 6.8-kb J-C intron, perhaps a self-regulating aspect of activation-induced cytidine deaminase action that is conserved in evolution.

A target selection of somatic hypermutations is regulated similarly between T and B cells upon activation-induced cytidine deaminase expression

Activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) is essential for somatic hypermutations (SHM) and class switch recombination. Overexpression of AID in non-B cells can induce SHM in artificial constructs inserted in various loci in the genome. AID overexpression was thus proposed to introduce mutations in a wide variety of genes with little specificity. We previously showed that AID transgenic mice developed T cell lymphomas in which the variable region beta genes of the T cell receptor and c-myc were mutated as frequently as SHM in activated B cells. To understand the target specificity of SHM in AID-expressing T lymphomas, we sequenced six oncogenes (c-myc, pim1, p53, atm, tgfbr-2, and k-ras) and two genes (cd4 and cd5) that are actively transcribed in T lymphomas. SHM was found only in c-myc, pim1, cd4, and cd5, which share the E47 binding motif in the enhancer/promoter. The rest that are not mutated in B cells were not mutated in AID-induced T lymphomas either, although they are transcribed in T and B cells. Comparison of several features of SHM, including selection of targets and mutation distribution, suggests that the regulatory mechanism of SHM is similar between T and B cells. SHM base specificities in the CD4 and CD5 genes were biased to AT, indicating that the preference of target bases of the mutations generated by overexpression of AID is not always GC bases but variable between target genes.

Somatic mutation hotspots correlate with DNA polymerase eta error spectrum

Mutational spectra analysis of 15 immunoglobulin genes suggested that consensus motifs RGYW and WA were universal descriptors of somatic hypermutation. Highly mutable sites, "hotspots", that matched WA were preferentially found in one DNA strand and RGYW hotspots were found in both strands. Analysis of base-substitution hotspots in DNA polymerase error spectra showed that 33 of 36 hotspots in the human polymerase eta spectrum conformed to the WA consensus. This and four other characteristics of polymerase eta substitution specificity suggest that errors introduced by this enzyme during synthesis of the nontranscribed DNA strand in variable regions may contribute to strand-specific somatic hypermutagenesis of immunoglobulin genes at A-T base pairs.

Targeting and subsequent selection of somatic hypermutations in the human V kappa repertoire

The number and distribution of nucleotide substitutions in human VkappaJkappa genes were examined using a PCR technique that analyzed nonproductive and productive rearrangements amplified from genomic DNA of individual B cells. The results indicate that the mutational mechanism introduces replacement (R) mutations comparably throughout the length of the VkappaJkappa rearrangement, but tends to target specific triplets. Moreover, hotspots of mutational activity were identified in complementarity determining regions (CDR). A marked increase in the frequency of R mutations in CDR was noted when productive were compared to nonproductive rearrangements, indicating that these were selected into the expressed repertoire. Of note, amino acids encoded by codons adjacent to hotspots of mutation were also positively selected implying that similar regions were targeted for hypermutation and subsequent selection. In contrast to the distribution of CDR mutations, R mutations in the framework (FR) regions tended to be eliminated from productive VkappaJkappa rearrangements, implying that the somatic hypermutational machinery frequently introduced amino acid changes that were deleterious to the structural integrity of the kappa chain protein. The difference in the ratio of R to silent mutations in CDR and FR in the expressed repertoire, therefore, reflects the summation of positive selection of R mutations in the CDR and the elimination of R mutations in the FR. The data indicate that the balance between targeted mutation of VkappaJkappa rearrangements and subsequent selection and elimination governs the pattern of mutations manifest within the expressed kappa repertoire.

Predicting Regional Mutability in Antibody V Genes Based Solely on Di- and Trinucleotide Sequence Composition

Somatic mutations are not distributed randomly throughout Ab V region genes. A sequence-specific target bias is revealed by a defined hierarchy of mutability among di- and trinucleotide sequences located within Ig intronic DNA. Here we report that the di- and trinucleotide mutability preference pattern is shared by mouse intronic JH and Jκ clusters and by human VH genes, suggesting that a common mutation mechanism exists for all Ig V genes of both species. Using di- and trinucleotide target preferences, we performed a comprehensive analysis of human and murine germline V genes to predict regional mutabilities. Heavy chain genes of both species exhibit indistinguishable patterns in which complementarity-determining region 1 (CDR1), CDR2, and framework region 3 (FR3) are predicted to be more mutable than FR1 and FR2. This prediction is borne out by empirical mutation data from nonproductively rearranged human VH genes. Analysis of light chain genes in both species also revealed a common, but unexpected, pattern in which FR2 is predicted to be highly mutable. While our analyses of nonfunctional Ig genes accurately predicts regional mutation preferences in VH genes, observed relative mutability differences between regions are more extreme than expected. This cannot be readily accounted for by nascent mRNA secondary structure or by a supplemental gene conversion mechanism that might favor nucleotide replacements in CDR. Collectively, our data support the concept of a common mutation mechanism for heavy and light chain genes of mice and humans with regional bias that is qualitatively, but not quantitatively, accounted for by short nucleotide sequence composition.

A hypermutable insert in an immunoglobulin transgene contains hotspots of somatic mutation and sequences predicting highly stable structures in the RNA transcript

Immunoglobulin (Ig) genes expressed in mature B lymphocytes can undergo somatic hypermutation upon cell interaction with antigen and T cells. The mutation mechanism had previously been shown to depend upon transcription initiation, suggesting that a mutator factor was loaded on an RNA polymerase initiating at the promoter and causing mutations during elongation (Peters, A., and U. Storb. 1996. Immunity. 4:57-65). To further elucidate this process we have created an artificial substrate consisting of alternating EcoRV and PvuII restriction enzyme sites (EPS) located within the variable (V) region of an Ig transgene. This substrate can easily be assayed for the presence of mutations in DNA from transgenic lymphocytes by amplifying the EPS insert and determining by restriction enzyme digestion whether any of the restriction sites have been altered. Surprisingly, the EPS insert was mutated many times more frequently than the flanking Ig sequences. In addition there were striking differences in mutability of the different nucleotides within the restriction sites. The data favor a model of somatic hypermutation where the fine specificity of the mutations is determined by nucleotide sequence preferences of a mutator factor, and where the general site of mutagenesis is determined by the pausing of the RNA polymerase due to secondary structures within the nascent RNA.

Somatic Hypermutation of an Artificial Test Substrate Within an Igκ Transgene

We have characterized a novel substrate for somatic hypermutation, confirming that non-Ig sequences can be targeted for mutation and demonstrating that this substrate allows for the rapid assay for mutations. An artificial sequence containing alternating EcoRV and PvuII sites (EPS) was inserted into the Vκ167 transgene, which is known to be a target for mutation. To assay for somatic hypermutation, the EPS is amplified using flanking transgene primers, and the PCR product is subsequently digested with either EcoRV or PvuII. A mutation is seen as the appearance of a larger fragment, indicating a base change in a restriction enzyme site. The original transgene, Vκ167/EPS, showed evidence of a low level of mutation in both splenic hybridomas and Peyer’s patch-derived or immunized splenic B220+ cells with high peanut agglutinin levels. Two derivative lines of Vκ167/EPS were made, Vκ167/POX and Vκ167/PEPS. While none of the Vκ167/POX transgenic lines demonstrated mutation, the Vκ167/PEPS transgene was highly mutated in B220+ splenic B cells with high peanut agglutinin levels at a frequency similar to that of endogenous Ig genes. An analysis of splenic RNA from the unimmunized transgenic mice indicated that the levels of stable message in splenic B cells could not be correlated with the mutation seen in GC B cells. The mutable Vκ167/PEPS transgenic line is a unique tool to study somatic hypermutation in vivo.

Cis-acting sequences that affect somatic hypermutation of Ig genes

We review our studies on the mechanism of somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes. Most experiments were carried out using Ig transgenes. We showed in these experiments that all required cis-acting elements are present within the 10-16 kb of a transgene. Only the Ig variable region and its proximate flanks are mutated, not the constant region. Several Ig gene enhancers are permissive for somatic mutation. Association of the enhancer with its natural Ig promoter is not necessary. However, the mutation process seems specific for Ig genes. No mutations were found in housekeeping genes from cells with high levels of somatic hypermutation of their Ig genes. The Ig enhancers may provide the Ig gene specificity. An exception may be the BCL6 gene, which was mutated in human but not in mouse B cells. Transcription of a region is required for its mutability. When the transcriptional promoter located upstream of the variable region is duplicated upstream of the constant region, this region also becomes mutable. This suggests a model in which a mutator factor associates with the RNA polymerase at the promoter, travels with the polymerase during elongation, and causes mutations during polymerase pausing. The DNA repair systems, nucleotide excision repair and DNA mismatch repair, are not required. Our recent data with an artificial substrate of somatic mutation suggest that pausing may be due to secondary structure of the DNA or nascent RNA, and the specific mutations to preferences of the mutator factor.

Insertion of 2 kb of bacteriophage DNA between an immunoglobulin promoter and leader exon stops somatic hypermutation in a kappa transgene

Somatic hypermutation in rearranged immunoglobulin variable genes occurs in a 2kb region of DNA that is delimited on the 5' side by the promoter and on the 3' side by intron DNA. To identify sequence features that activate the mutation mechanism, we increased the distance between the promoter and the leader region to test whether the spacing of these elements was important. The promoter was separated from the leader sequence by inserting a 2 kb fragment of noncoding bacteriophage lambda DNA between the TATA box and ATG initiator codon in a kappa transgene. Mice from three founder lines were immunized, RNA and DNA were isolated from spleen and Peyer's patch B cells, and transcription of the transgene was confirmed. The frequency of mutation in endogenous heavy chain genes was high, indicating that some B cells underwent hypermutation. However, no hypermutation was found in the transgenic bacteriophage or variable region sequences. Hypermutation did occur in another kappa transgene that had a deletion of the VJ coding sequence, showing that the basic construct is functional and that the VJ exon is not necessary for the mutation mechanism. It is likely that the bacteriophage sequence is a potential substrate for mutation because other heterologous sequences have been shown to undergo mutation if placed downstream of the leader exon. The results suggest that the promoter should be contiguous with the leader exon for the mutation mechanism to function.

Evaluation of the role of the 3'alpha heavy chain enhancer [3'alpha E(hs1,2)] in Vh gene somatic hypermutation

Previous work on the cis-acting elements that control heavy chain variable region (VH) gene somatic hypermutation has indicated the presence of an as yet unidentified element(s) 3' of the intron enhancer that is necessary for high rate mutation. Examination of cis-acting elements involved in kappa light chain V gene hypermutation has demonstrated a requirement for both the intronic and 3' kappa enhancers in this process. To examine whether the 3'alpha heavy chain enhancer [3'alpha E(hs1,2)] is required for somatic hypermutation of VH genes, we generated two types of transgenic mice. One type was generated using a construct containing a VH promoter, a rearranged VDJ, the heavy chain intronic enhancer, and the murine heavy chain 3'alpha E(hs1,2). The transgenes in the second lines were similar to the transgenes in the first with the addition of a second complete matrix attachment region (MAR) 3' of the heavy chain intronic enhancer, and splice acceptor and polyadenylation sites between the two enhancers. Analysis of both transgenes revealed levels of mutation at least 10-fold lower than endogenous VH genes. These data suggest that the 3'alpha E(hs1,2) does not play a role analogous to the 3' kappa enhancer in the regulation of the hypermutation process. Moreover, in one of the transgenes, the presence of the 3'alpha E(hs1,2) resulted in a lack of transcription in vivo, suggesting a negative regulatory role for this enhancer in certain contexts.

The molecular basis of somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes

Somatic hypermutation amplifies the variable region repertoire of immunoglobulin genes. Recent experimental evidence has thrown light on various molecular models of somatic hypermutation. A link between somatic hypermutation and transcription coupled DNA repair is shaping up.

Somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes is linked to transcription initiation

To identify DNA sequences that target the somatic hypermutation process, the immunoglobulin gene promoter located upstream of the variable (V) region was duplicated upstream of the constant (C) region of a kappa transgene. Normally, kappa genes are somatically mutated only in the VJ region, but not in the C region. In B cell hybridomas from mice with this kappa transgene (P5'C), both the VJ region and the C region, but not the region between them, were mutated at similar frequencies, suggesting that the mutation mechanism is related to transcription. The downstream promoter was not occluded by transcripts from the upstream promoter. In fact, the levels of transcripts originating from the two promoters were similar, supporting a mutation model based on initiation of transcripts. Several "hot-spots" of somatic mutation were noted, further demonstrating that this transgene has the hallmarks of somatic mutation of endogenous immunoglobulin genes. A model linking somatic mutation to transcription-coupled DNA repair is proposed.

Reciprocal homologous recombination in or near antibody VDJ genes

To determine if rearranged heavy chain variable (VDJ) genes can recombine with each other by crossing over of DNA strands, we constructed a transgene that contained a promoter, VDJ gene, reporter gene to detect crossover events, intron enhancer, matrix attachment region, and constant gene for IgM (C mu). Following immunization of transgenic mice, hybrid molecules were isolated from B cell DNA which contained the transgene recombined with the endogenous IgH locus. Reciprocal products of crossovers were detected by plasmid rescue and PCR amplification, and they were sequenced. Recombination occurred somewhere within 147 bp of homology that contained the JH4 gene segment and 3' flanking DNA. The recombined transgenes had a 20-fold increase in mutation in the VDJ region compared to nonrecombined transgenes, which indicates that DNA sequences 3' of the C mu gene in the endogenous IgH locus are necessary for full activity of the mutator mechanism. The recovery of recombinants between VDJ transgenes and endogenous VDJ genes raises the possibility that reciprocal recombination may somatically diversify rearranged genes between maternal and paternal alleles.

A lambda 1 transgene under the control of a heavy chain promoter and enhancer does not undergo somatic hypermutation

To identify cis-acting elements responsible for targeting somatic hypermutation to immunoglobulin variable regions, we generated transgenic mice which carry a rearranged lambda 1 gene regulated by the heavy chain intron enhancer, E mu, and the heavy chain promoter PH186.2 from the VH186.2 variable region. C57BL/6 x SJL founders were bred with C57BL/6 mice to establish a line carrying a single copy of the transgene. Somatic hypermutation was studied by generating hybridoma cell lines from mice immunized with the hapten (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) coupled to chicken gamma globulin. The immune response in this transgenic line was dominated by the endogenous VH186.2 heavy chain variable region and the transgenic lambda 1 light chain, and the transgene was actively expressed in all hybridomas analyzed. In this work we show that the transgenic V lambda 1 regions do not undergo hypermutation, despite high levels of expression, while the expressed heavy chain V regions accumulate mutations at a rate typical of the NP response in C57BL/6 mice. Thus, within the same B cell, the PH186.2 promoter in connection with E mu drives efficient expression of both a VH and a V lambda region, but only the VH is a target for somatic hypermutation. Our observations show that cis-acting sequences that activate immunoglobulin gene transcription are not sufficient to target somatic hypermutation.

Mapping the upstream boundary of somatic mutations in rearranged immunoglobulin transgenes and endogenous genes

Mammalian B-cell specific somatic hypermutation contributes to affinity maturation of the antibody response. This mutator activity is highly focused on rearranged immunoglobulin variable regions, but the underlying mechanism remains to be elucidated. In an effort to gain insights into the mechanism of somatic hypermutation, the precise distribution and frequency of mutations upstream of murine immunoglobulin genes was determined by examining the same variable gene segments when mutated in different B-cell lines. Immunoglobulin sequences analysed included kappa light chain transgenes bearing mutated V kappa 24 variable regions, and the endogenous V kappa gene isolated from myeloma MOPC167, which also exhibits mutations in the variable region. In addition, mutated endogenous VH1 gene segments of the S107 heavy chain variable gene family were also examined. For both VH1 and V kappa 24, somatic mutations were generally not found upstream of the leader intron, even in genes which exhibited a high mutation frequency in the variable region itself. The 5' somatic mutation boundary identified in immunoglobulin transgenes overlaps the boundary observed in endogenous genes, suggesting that both share cis-elements required for defining the mutable domain. Furthermore, the location of this 5' boundary appears not to change when these immunoglobulin genes are examined in different cell lines. These data may be indicative of a defined start site for immunoglobulin mutator activity.

Generating the antibody repertoire in rabbit

We describe a model for B cell development and generation of the antibody repertoire in rabbits. In this model, B cells develop early in ontogeny, migrate to GALT, and undergo the first round of diversification by a somatic gene conversion-like process and by somatic mutation. We designate the repertoire developed by this mechanism as the primary antibody repertoire and it is this repertoire that makes the rabbit immunocompetent. We invoke GALT as the site for development of the primary repertoire because (1) surgical removal of GALT from neonatal rabbits results in highly immunocompromised animals, (2) in germfree rabbits essentially no lymphoid development occurs in GALT and the rabbits are immunoincompetent, and (3) the follicular development of rabbit GALT is highly similar to that of the chicken bursa, the site in which the primary antibody repertoire develops by somatic gene conversion in chicken. We suggest that once the primary antibody repertoire is formed, it is maintained by self-renewing CD5+ B cells and is expanded to a secondary antibody repertoire after the B cells encounter antigen.

Affinity maturation leads to differential expression of multiple copies of a kappa light-chain transgene

Transgenic animals containing rearranged heavy or light chains are used to study the process of hypermutation, which characterizes the maturation of the antibody response. LK6 mice contain five copies of a transgene coding for a light chain produced in response to the hapten 2-phenyloxazolone. We have selected hybridomas from secondary responses that express the transgene as the only light chain. Some of these hybridomas contain transgene copies carrying mutations known to improve antibody affinity. We have analysed the expression of the five transgene copies in those hybridomas. We report here that the somatic hypermutation process can affect the successful expression of antibody light-chain transgenes. When mutations that improve the antibody affinity appear in one transgene copy, antigenic selection favours cells that downregulate the other copies at multiple levels of gene expression, including examples where nonsense mutations correlate with a drop in messenger RNA level.

Hypermutation is observed only in antibody H chain V region transgenes that have recombined with endogenous immunoglobulin H DNA: implications for the location of cis-acting elements required for somatic mutation

Mice with transgenes containing an antibody H chain V region (VHDJH) gene were used in an analysis of the cis-acting elements required for hypermutation of immunoglobulin (Ig) V genes. These transgenes can somatically recombine with endogenous IgH DNA, leading to the formation of functional heavy (H) chains partially encoded by the transgenic VHDJH. The transgenomes in the five different lines of mice analyzed contain as little as 150 bp, and as much as 2.8 kb of natural DNA flanking the 5' side of the VH and either 1.5 or 2.3 kb (including the intronic enhancer and 5' matrix attachment region [MAR]) flanking the 3' side of VH. Hybridomas were constructed from immunized transgenic mice, and transgenes present in these hybridomas that had or had not recombined to form functional H chain loci were sequenced. The data obtained show that: (a) the recombined transgenes contain hypermutated VH genes; and (b) among such transgenes, even those containing only 150 bp of natural VH 5' flanking sequence and several kilobases of 5' plasmid vector sequence display a frequency, distribution, and type of mutation characteristic of conventional IgH loci. The data also indicate that transgenic VHDJH genes that have not recombined with endogenous IgH DNA are not substrates for hypermutation, even if they are flanked by 2.8 kb of natural 5' DNA, and 2.3 kb of natural 3' DNA, including the JH2-JH4 region, a MAR, and the intronic enhancer. Collectively, the data suggest that sequences 5' of the VH promoter are dispensable, a VH promoter and the intronic IgH enhancer region are not sufficient, and a region(s) within or 3' of the IgH constant region locus is requisite, for hypermutation of Ig VH transgenes.

Molecular evolution of the human immunoglobulin E response: high incidence of shared mutations and clonal relatedness among epsilon VH5 transcripts from three unrelated patients with atopic dermatitis

We have analyzed the nucleotide sequences of 19 epsilon VH5 transcripts derived from in vivo isotype switched peripheral blood B cells of three patients with atopic dermatitis. Comparison with the patients' own germline VH5 gene segments revealed that the epsilon transcripts were derived from both functional members of the human VH5 gene family and harbored numerous somatic mutations (range 5-36 per VH5 gene). In two patients, we detected clonally related but diverged transcripts, permitting the construction of a genealogical tree in one patient. We observed a high proportion of shared silent (S) and replacement (R) mutations among epsilon VH5 sequences derived from all three individuals, even among transcripts descending from the two different germline VH5 gene segments. A remarkably high number of these mutations is shared with previously reported VH5 genes encoding antibodies with defined specificities. The shared S mutations, and likely a fraction of the R mutations, appear to mark preferential sites ("hot spots") of somatic hypermutations in human VH5 genes. The distribution of R and S mutations over complementarity determining region and framework regions in the majority of VH regions deviated from that characteristic of antigen-driven immune response. We hypothesize that the V regions of immunoglobulin E-bearing B cells have accumulated "selectively neutral" mutations over extended periods of clonal expansion, resulting in unusual R/S ratios. We propose that the molecular characteristics of the epsilon VH regions in atopic dermatitis may be representative of antigens that recurrently or chronically stimulate the immune system.

Somatic hypermutagenesis in immunoglobulin genes. II. Influence of neighbouring base sequences on mutagenesis

A new approach for the analysis of hotspots of mutations is described. It is based on the classification of hotspot site sequences. Using this approach, the consensuses RGYW and TAA of hotspot sites were revealed in the V gene. Correlation between somatic mutations and these consensuses is investigated by the statistical weight method in 323 somatic substitutions in 14 V genes. Assuming the absence of any correlation, the probability of observing such data in the sample would be very low (0.0003). These results support the idea that emergence of somatic mutation is significantly influenced by neighbouring base sequences. This idea was also supported by the analysis of 296 somatic mutations in flanking sequences of V genes. It is supposed that this influence is an important feature of somatic hypermutagenesis.

Analysis of a T cell receptor gene as a target of the somatic hypermutation mechanism

In an effort to identify cis-acting elements required for targeting of the somatic hypermutation process in mice, we examined whether a T cell receptor (TCR) transgene under the control of the immunoglobulin (Ig) heavy (H) chain intron enhancer would be mutated in antigen-stimulated B cells. Hybridomas were established from splenic B cells of mice carrying two copies of the TCR transgene after hyperimmunization with phosphorylcholine keyhole limpet hemocyanin. Northern analysis revealed that all of the transgene-containing hybridomas expressed the TCR mRNA. Multiple somatic point mutations were found in seven of eight endogenous Ig VH genes examined. In contrast, 29 of 32 TCR genes examined contained no mutations. One potential mutation was seen in each of the three other TCR genes. Our data indicate that although the TCR transgene is expressed in B cells, it is not efficiently targeted by the mutator mechanism. Furthermore, the presence of an Ig H chain enhancer is itself not sufficient for targeting of the somatic hypermutation mechanism.

Mutation in a reporter gene depends on proximity to and transcription of immunoglobulin variable transgenes

Somatic mutation in immunoglobulin genes is localized to a 2-kilobase region of DNA surrounding and including rearranged variable (V), diversity, and joining (J) gene segments encoding heavy and light chains. To examine the structural basis for targeted mutation, we developed an assay to score mutation on plasmid substrates by using a reporter gene: a bacterial gene encoding an amber-suppressor tRNA molecule was placed 3' of a rearranged kappa VJ gene within the boundaries of mutation. The reporter gene is exquisitely suited for mutational analysis because it is only 200 base pairs (bp), which should not greatly disrupt structure of the immunoglobulin locus, and gene function depends on secondary structure, which means mutation can be scored in many different nucleotide positions. The plasmid was used to make transgenic mice, which were then immunized. The shuttle vector was retrieved by plasmid rescue into an indicator strain of Escherichia coli that contained an amber mutation in its beta-galactosidase gene. Integrity of the tRNA molecule was monitored by colony color, which permitted many transformants to be screened visually. Mutations were not seen in DNA from a transfected B-cell line grown in vitro or in DNA from nonlymphoid tissue of transgenic mice, indicating that the reporter gene was stable during cell division and DNA manipulations. However, when the transgenic mice were immunized, DNA from splenic B cells contained point mutations in the reporter gene at a frequency of 10(-3) per transformant. Sequence analysis of 17 mutated transgenes revealed that the mutations were 1- and 2-bp deletions in the tRNA gene, and one plasmid had an additional 2-bp deletion in the V gene. In contrast, previous studies have shown that mutations in endogenous VJ genes are predominantly nucleotide substitutions and have only 6% deletions. Two other plasmid constructs were analyzed in transgenic lines: no mutations were found when the tRNA gene was placed distal to the VJ gene, and no mutations were seen when the immunoglobulin promoter was deleted. Although we lack direct evidence that the deletions in the tRNA gene are caused by the same mechanism that acts on VJ genes, we have shown that mutations in this assay occur in a manner consistent with immunoglobulin-specific mutation in that they are found in splenic B cells and not in tail tissue, depend on position next to the VJ gene, and require transcription of the VJ gene.

Instability of immunoglobulin genes in S107 cell line

Somatic mutation occurs frequently in rearranged and expressed immunoglobulin variable region genes in vivo. In contrast, V region hypermutation seldom occurs in antibody-forming cells in culture. The S107 mouse myeloma cell line is one of the few cell lines that has been observed to generate V region mutations frequently and spontaneously in vitro. Detailed examination reveals that both the S107 tumor and the cell line derived from it contain and express a duplicated heavy-chain gene. In culture, only one of the two heavy-chain genes undergoes both V and C region mutation, and variants with complex phenotypes and genotypes arise as a result of mutation and segregation of these duplicated genes.

Boundaries of somatic mutation in rearranged immunoglobulin genes: 5' boundary is near the promoter, and 3' boundary is approximately 1 kb from V(D)J gene

To investigate why somatic mutations are spatially restricted to a region around the rearranged V(D)J immunoglobulin gene, we compared the distribution of mutations flanking murine V gene segments that had rearranged next to either proximal or distal J gene segments. 124 nucleotide substitutions, nine deletions, and two insertions were identified in 32,481 bp of DNA flanking the coding regions from 17 heavy and kappa light chain genes. Most of the mutations occurred within a 2-kb region centered around the V(D)J gene, regardless of which J gene segment was used, suggesting that the structural information for mutation is located in sequences around and within the V(D)J gene, and not in sequences downstream of the J gene segments. The majority of mutations were found within 300 bp of DNA flanking the 5' side of the V(D)J gene and 850 bp flanking the 3' side at a frequency of 0.8%, which was similar to the frequency in the coding region. The frequency of flanking mutations decreased as a function of distance from the gene. There was no evidence for hot spots in that every mutation was unique and occurred at a different position. No mutations were found upstream of the promoter region, suggesting that the promoter delimits a 5' boundary, which provides strong evidence that transcription is necessary to generate mutation. The 3' boundary was approximately 1 kb from the V(D)J gene and was not associated with a DNA sequence motif. Occasional mutations were located in the nuclear matrix association and enhancer regions. The pattern of substitutions suggests that there is discrimination between the two DNA strands during mutation, in that the four bases were mutated with different frequencies on each strand. The high frequency of mutations in the 3' flanking region and the uniqueness of each mutation argues against templated gene conversion as a mechanism for generating somatic diversity in murine V(D)J genes. Rather, the data support a model for random point mutations where the mechanism is linked to the transcriptional state of the gene.