Vaccination of macaques with SIV conserved envelope peptides suppressed infection and prevented disease progression and transmission

Protection against lethal simian immunodeficiency virus SIVsmmPBj14 disease by a recombinant Semliki Forest virus gp160 vaccine and by a gp120 subunit vaccine

Infection of pigtail macaques with SIVsmmPBj14, biological clone 3 (SIV-PBj14-bc13), produces an acute and usually fatal shock-like syndrome 7 to 14 days after infection. We used this simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) model as a rapid and rigorous challenge to evaluate the efficacy of two SIV Env vaccine strategies. Groups of four pigtail macaques were immunized four times over a 25-week span with either a recombinant Semliki Forest virus expressing the SIV-PBj14 Env gp160 (SFV-SIVgp160) or purified recombinant SIV-PBj14 gp120 (rgp120) in SBN-1 adjuvant. Antibody titers to SIV Env developed in all immunized animals (mean peak titers prior to challenge, 1:1,700 for SFV-SIV gp 160 and 1:10,500 for rgp120), but neither neutralizing antibodies nor SIV-specific T-cell proliferative responses were detectable in any of the vaccinees. All macaques were challenged with a 100% infectious, 75% fatal dose of SIV-PBj14-bc13 at week 26. Three of four control animals died of acute SIV-PBj14 syndrome on days 12 and 13. By contrast, all four SFV-SIVgp160-immunized animals and three of the four rgp120-immunized animals were protected from lethal disease. While all virus-challenged animals became infected, symptoms of the SIV-PBj14 syndrome were more severe in controls than in vaccinees. Mean virus titers in plasma at 13 days postchallenge were approximately 10-fold lower in vaccinated than control animals. However, there was no apparent correlation between survival and levels of peripheral blood mononuclear cell-associated culturable virus, provirus load, or any antiviral immunologic parameter examined. The results indicate that while immunization with SFV-SIVgp160 and rgp120 did not protect against virus infection, these Env vaccines did lower the virus load in plasma and protect against the lethal SIV-PBj14 challenge.

The simian immunodeficiency virus transmembrane protein is poorly immunogenic in inactivated virus vaccine

The transmembrane proteins (TMP) of immunodeficiency lentiviruses are primary candidates for inclusion in AIDS vaccines, the design and testing of which is facilitated by the SIV-macaque infection model. Antibody responses to linear determinants in the SIVmac TMP were investigated in rhesus macaques either infected with the SIVmac J5 molecular clone or vaccinated with partially purified, formalin-inactivated SIVmac. Infected animals were shown to recognise predominantly four regions in the external domain and three regions in the internal domain of the TMP defined by a series of nominally 20mer overlapping peptides. In contrast SIV vaccinates had extremely restricted and weak antibody responses to the TMP, indicating a selective loss of immunogenicity of this component in the vaccine.

Fine analysis of humoral antibody response to envelope glycoprotein of SIV in infected and vaccinated macaques

To characterize the serological response to SIV envelope, induced by vaccination with different envelope immunogens or by SIV infection, plasma samples from 11 cynomolgus macaques infected with simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) and from 16 macaques vaccinated with three different recombinant envelope proteins were analyzed by (1) ELISA, using a variety of antigens including overlapping peptides encompassing the entire sequence of the envelope protein of SIV, and (2) competition assays, using neutralizing monoclonal antibodies to SIV gp120. Seven regions of SIV envelope were predicted to be antigenic. Peptides representing four of these, in the second and third variable regions (V2 and V3) and the fourth constant (C4) region of gp120 and the Gnann region of gp41, were recognized by the majority of sera from infected and vaccinated animals. Additional antigenic regions were identified in the first and fourth variable domains (V1 and V4) and the carboxy terminus (C5) of gp120 and in three additional regions of gp41. Most infected and vaccinated animals made antibodies that competed with the binding of the three conformational MAbs. Among the vaccinated groups, antibodies induced by vaccination with precursor glycoproteins (gp140 or gp160) recognized several additional gp120 epitopes when compared with antibodies induced by external glycoprotein gp130. Sera from infected animals showed a more restricted gp120 response (17 of 46 peptides recognized) compared to animals vaccinated with precursor glycoproteins (31 peptides recognized). The converse was true for antibodies to gp41. Sera from animals vaccinated with recombinant gp140, produced in insect cells, were the only group that failed to compete with the binding of conformational MAbs. Finally, the development of antibodies to specific epitopes of gp120 and gp41 revealed differences between long-term survivors and nonsurvivors, implying that responses to specific epitopes may be important in conferring resistance to disease progression.

HIV-1 envelope-elicited neutralizing antibody titres correlate with protection and virus load in chimpanzees

In an attempt to compare the protective effect of vaccination with two forms of envelope antigens, and to define immunological correlates of protection against HIV infection, chimpanzees were vaccinated with either recombinant gp160 or gp120. Homologous HIV challenge was performed 3 weeks after the fourth immunization. The animal with the highest level of serum neutralizing antibodies (gp160 immunogen) was protected against HIV infection. All other chimpanzees became infected, but displayed various levels of infected PBMCs. The postchallenge data gave rise to the following conclusions: (1) protection correlated with the level of the serological immune response, but not with the nature of immunogen (gp120 versus gp160); (2) the virus-neutralizing titre at day of challenge correlated with protection from infection; (3) the relative magnitude of the lymphoproliferative T-cell response at day of challenge did not correlate with any protective effect; (4) the peak numbers of virus-infected PBMCs in vaccinated animals were lower than those observed in control animals, and this effect was correlated with the intensity of the antibody response at day of challenge. This raises the possibility that a beneficial effect of HIV vaccination may be achieved in a situation where sterile immunity is not consistently obtained.

Passively transferred antibodies directed against conserved regions of SIV envelope protect macaques from SIV infection

Inactivated plasma collected from either SIV-infected or peptide-vaccinated macaques was transferred into 17 naive rhesus monkeys. Two additional macaques received normal plasma and served as controls. Following transfer all 19 monkeys were inoculated with SIV. While the controls became infected and were virus-isolation-positive, 3 of 6 recipients of SIV peptide vaccine plasma and 9 of 11 recipients of SIV-infected monkey plasma were protected. None of the 12 protected animals became virus-isolation-positive or seroconverted within 100 days of follow-up. One, however was SIV-PCR-positive. All 12 protected animals were rechallenged 100 days after the initial inoculation; 8 became infected and yielded virus as expected, but 4 remained uninfected. One of the latter was the SIV-PCR-positive monkey mentioned above, suggesting that cryptic SIV infection may be of significance in immunological protection. The results demonstrate that envelope anti-peptide antibodies have similar protective potential in vivo as antibodies directed to the whole virus. In vitro neutralization competition assays performed with sera from vaccinated macaques in the presence of the free peptides suggest that of the four conserved envelope peptides of the vaccine, the two originating from gp41 rather than the two from gp120 are responsible for inducing the neutralizing anti-syncytial activity.