Submental intubation versus tracheostomy

Clinical evaluation of submental intubation as an alternative airway management technique in midface osteotomy

BACKGROUND

The conventional endonasal intubation would not allow precise intra-operative assessment of the changes to the nasolabial soft tissue complex. Submental intubation allows accurate measurement of nasolabial soft tissue complex with no interference with the occlusion.

METHODOLOGY

A clinical prospective study was carried on 20 patients visiting the Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery department diagnosed of dentofacial deformity requiring orthognathic surgery. The patient were intubated by the submental route of anaesthesia. Intraoperatively time taken to perform intubation and bleeding during the surgery was noted. Post-operatively infection, presence or absence of any complications were noted along with the measurement of scar by Vancouver scar scale.

RESULTS

Out of 20 patients 17 patients required only maxillary osteotomies whereas 3 patients required bimaxillary osteotomy. The mean time taken for intubation was 5.68 ± 1.257 minutes. In all the cases the scar was measured as minimum. 2 patients showed infection at the site of submental intubation after 7th day while after 14th day there was no infection present. No other complication was noted. 19 out of 20 cases showed no interference during the procedure whereas in 1 case mild interference during mandibular movement.

CONCLUSION

The submental intubation is a very good alternative to nasotracheal intubation in the patients undergoing bimaxillary surgeries or maxillary surgeries. Submental intubation can be chosen whenever possible, as it is easy, takes little time and follow-up is simple, does not result in bleeding or other complications and more importantly does not result in any unaesthetic scar after 3rd month follow up.

Submental tracheal intubation in oromaxillofacial surgery

BACKGROUND

Oromaxillofacial surgical procedures present a unique set of problems both for the surgeon and for the anesthesist. Achieving dental occlusion is one of the fundamental aims of most oromaxillofacial procedures. Oral intubation precludes this surgical prerequisite of checking dental occlusion. Having the tube in the field of surgery is often disturbing for the surgeon too, especially in the patient for whom skull base surgery is planned. Nasotracheal intubation is usually contraindicated in the presence of nasal bone fractures seen either in isolation or as a component of Le Fort fractures. We utilized submental endotracheal intubation in such situations and the experience has been very satisfying.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The technique has been used in 20 patients with maxillofacial injuries and those requiring Le Fort I approach with or without maxillary swing for skull base tumors. Initial oral intubation is done with a flexo-metallic tube. A small 1.5 cm incision is given in the submental region and a blunt tunnel is created in the floor of the mouth staying close to the lingual surface of mandible and a small opening is made in the mucosa. The tracheal end of tube is stabilized with Magil's forceps, and the proximal end is brought out through submental incision by using a blunt hemostat taking care not to injure the pilot balloon. At the end of procedure extubation is done through submental location only.

RESULTS

The technique of submental intubation was used in a series of twenty patients from January 2005 to date. There were fifteen male patients and five female patients with a mean age of twenty seven years (range 10 to 52). Seven patients had Le Fort I osteotomy as part of the approach for skull base surgery. Twelve patients had midfacial fractures at the Le Fort II level, of which 8 patients in addition had naso-ethomoidal fractures and 10 patients an associated fracture mandible. Twelve patients were extubated in the theatre. Eight patients had delayed extubation in the post-operative ward between 1 and 3 days postoperatively.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, the submental intubation technique has proved to be a simple solution for many a difficult problem one would encounter during oromaxillofacial surgical procedures. It provides a safe and reliable route for the endotracheal tube during intubation while staying clear of the surgical field and permitting the checking of the dental occlusion, all without causing any significant morbidity for the patient. Its usefulness both in the emergency setting and for elective procedures has been proved. The simplicity of the technique with no specialized equipment or technical expertise required makes it especially advantageous. This technique therefore, when used in appropriate cases, allows both the surgeon and the anesthetist deliver a better quality of patient care.

Submental intubation in panfacial injuries: our experience

Panfacial fractures present a unique set of problems to the anaesthesiologist and surgeon. Airway management in panfacial fractures is still a challenge to the anaesthesiologist as all modalities available such as orotracheal intubation, nasotracheal intubation, tracheostomy, etc., have their own advantages and disadvantages. When all the conventional modalities to secure airway seem unsuitable then submental route offers an excellent alternative to manage airway in such patients. Here we describe our experience with submental intubation technique in 10 patients with panfacial injuries over a period of two years.

Submental endotracheal intubation in concurrent orthognathic surgery: A technical note

INTRODUCTION

Achieving the necessary occlusion for orthognathic surgery is not possible with conventional oral intubation since the tube interferes with the occluding teeth. Sometimes nasotracheal intubation is impossible due to developmental malformations requiring repair. Also, the oral or nasotracheal tube may interfere with the operation or may be damaged during the procedure. In 1986, Hernandez Altemir described a method of submental endotracheal intubation. His intentions were to avoid tracheostomy in maxillofacial trauma cases where short-term intermaxillary fixation was required.

PATIENTS

Between January 2000 and May 2003, 13 patients were operated on, using submental intubation. Eight of these (three females and five males) had surgery for orthognathic malformations.

METHODS

The Hernandez Altemir technique was modified to ease the procedure: a sterile nylon guiding tube and the '222 rule' incision were introduced. Eight cases with concurrent complex orthognathic surgery, using this modified technique are reported in this paper.

RESULTS

There were no operative or postoperative complications related to the procedure.

CONCLUSION

The technique is easy to use, rapid and free of complications compared to 'alternative' intubation methods (tracheostomy, retromolar location of tube, etc.). Submental scarring is acceptable. It is recommended for orthognathic procedures in selected cases.

Submental intubation for cancrum oris: a case report

Cancrum oris (Noma) is a devastating gangrenous disease that leads to severe tissue destruction in the face. We describe the anesthetic management of a 12-year-old girl with cancrum oris sequelae in a Rural Secondary level Hospital in Central India (Padhar Hospital). She presented with a large defect in her upper lip on the left side that extended into the columella and the floor of the left nostril. She was scheduled to undergo reconstructive surgery and the surgeons planned to use an Abbé flap based on the lower lip. For this, access to both the mouth and the nose was required. We considered a tracheostomy but decided to attempt the submental route for orotracheal intubation. Following intravenous induction the patient's trachea was intubated with a cuffed oral tracheal tube. This was passed through the submental incision and then reconnected. The surgery proceeded uneventfully and the patient was extubated before transfer. She made a satisfactory recovery and the submental scar healed without complication or scarring. We describe briefly the features of cancrum oris and review the technique of submental intubation (described in adults with midfacial trauma). The use of submental intubation in children and for cancrum oris sequelae has not been previously reported.

Modifizierte submentale endotracheale Intubation bei kieferorthop�dischen Eingriffen

BACKGROUND

In 1986 Altemir described a method of submental endotracheal intubation in order to avoid tracheostomy in maxillofacial trauma cases where short-term intermaxillary fixation was required. His method has become widely established for airway maintenance in midfacial fractures.

CASE

We present a 21-year-old male patient with cleft lip and palate on the left side. The patient underwent Le Fort I maxillary osteotomy. Nasal intubation was impossible due to nasal malformation. In this case we used submental endotracheal intubation for airway maintenance. We introduced new methods: a sterile nylon guiding tube and our new "2-2-2 rule" incision to make the procedure easier.

RESULTS

The occlusion could be checked easily. There were no complications during and after the operation. The submental wound healed nicely.

DISCUSSION

The described case shows that the technique is easy to use compared to "alternative" intubation methods. Submental scarring is acceptable. We recommend the technique for orthognathic use.