Sequence of the junction in adenovirus 2-SV40 hybrids: examples of illegitimate recombination

Mechanistic toxicology in light of genetic compensation

Mechanistic toxicology seeks to identify the molecular and cellular mechanisms by which toxicants exert their deleterious effects. One powerful approach is to generate mutations in genes that respond to a particular toxicant, and then test how such mutations change the effects of the toxicant. CRISPR is a rapid and versatile approach to generate mutations in cultured cells and in animal models. Many studies use CRISPR to generate short insertions or deletions in a target gene and then assume that the resulting mutation, such as a premature termination codon, causes a loss of functional protein. However, recent studies demonstrate that this assumption is flawed. Cells can compensate for short insertion and deletion mutations, leading toxicologists to draw erroneous conclusions from mutant studies. In this review, we will discuss mechanisms by which a mutation in one gene may be rescued by compensatory activity. We will discuss how CRISPR insertion and deletion mutations are susceptible to compensation by transcriptional adaptation, alternative splicing, and rescue by maternally derived gene products. We will review evidence that measuring levels of messenger RNA transcribed from a mutated gene is an unreliable indicator of the severity of the mutation. Finally, we provide guidelines for using CRISPR to generate mutations that avoid compensation.

Applying genomic and bioinformatic resources to human adenovirus genomes for use in vaccine development and for applications in vector development for gene delivery

Technological advances and increasingly cost-effect methodologies in DNA sequencing and computational analysis are providing genome and proteome data for human adenovirus research. Applying these tools, data and derived knowledge to the development of vaccines against these pathogens will provide effective prophylactics. The same data and approaches can be applied to vector development for gene delivery in gene therapy and vaccine delivery protocols. Examination of several field strain genomes and their analyses provide examples of data that are available using these approaches. An example of the development of HAdV-B3 both as a vaccine and also as a vector is presented.

Comparison of filler DNA at immune, nonimmune, and oncogenic rearrangements suggests multiple mechanisms of formation

Extra nucleotides (termed filler DNA) are commonly found at the junctions of genetic rearrangements in mammalian cells. The filler DNA at immune system rearrangements, which are called N regions, are generated at VDJ joints primarily by terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase. However, the origin of filler DNA at genetic rearrangements in nonlymphoid cells is uncertain. In an analysis of more than 200 junctions that arose by circularization of transfected linear DNA (D. B. Roth and J. H. Wilson, Mol. Cell. Biol. 6:4295-4304, 1986), we found 18 junctions with extra nucleotides exactly at the point of circularization. Analysis of these 18 junctions indicated that nonlymphoid cells could add extra nucleotides to the ends of duplex DNA. The characteristics of the extra nucleotides at these junctions and at 31 other rearrangement junctions from nonlymphoid cells were quite similar, suggesting that many genetic rearrangements may pass through a stage with free DNA ends. A comparison of the filler DNA at these 49 nonimmune system rearrangements with 97 N regions derived from immune system rearrangements suggested that lymphoid and nonlymphoid cells use different mechanisms for insertion of filler DNA, as expected from the absence of detectable terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase in cells from nonlymphoid tissues. The filler DNAs at a smaller group of 22 translocations associated with cancer had features in common with both immune and nonimmune system rearrangements and therefore may represent a mixture of these two processes. Mechanisms that might account for the presence of filler DNA in nonlymphoid cells are discussed.

Comparison of filler DNA at immune, nonimmune, and oncogenic rearrangements suggests multiple mechanisms of formation

Extra nucleotides (termed filler DNA) are commonly found at the junctions of genetic rearrangements in mammalian cells. The filler DNA at immune system rearrangements, which are called N regions, are generated at VDJ joints primarily by terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase. However, the origin of filler DNA at genetic rearrangements in nonlymphoid cells is uncertain. In an analysis of more than 200 junctions that arose by circularization of transfected linear DNA (D. B. Roth and J. H. Wilson, Mol. Cell. Biol. 6:4295-4304, 1986), we found 18 junctions with extra nucleotides exactly at the point of circularization. Analysis of these 18 junctions indicated that nonlymphoid cells could add extra nucleotides to the ends of duplex DNA. The characteristics of the extra nucleotides at these junctions and at 31 other rearrangement junctions from nonlymphoid cells were quite similar, suggesting that many genetic rearrangements may pass through a stage with free DNA ends. A comparison of the filler DNA at these 49 nonimmune system rearrangements with 97 N regions derived from immune system rearrangements suggested that lymphoid and nonlymphoid cells use different mechanisms for insertion of filler DNA, as expected from the absence of detectable terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase in cells from nonlymphoid tissues. The filler DNAs at a smaller group of 22 translocations associated with cancer had features in common with both immune and nonimmune system rearrangements and therefore may represent a mixture of these two processes. Mechanisms that might account for the presence of filler DNA in nonlymphoid cells are discussed.

Compilation of DNA strand exchange sites for non-homologous recombination in somatic cells

DNA sequences of 496 somatic cell illegitimate crossing over regions were compiled and analyzed. Sites for non-homologous recombination on linear DNAs transfected into mammalian cells (Transfected Linear DNAs; TLD) were analyzed separately from the remaining illegitimate recombination regions (IRR). Trinucleotides that are preferentially cleaved by rat liver topoisomerase I in vitro (CAT, CTY, GTY, RAT where R = purine, Y = pyrimidine) were present in the 10 base pair (bp) vicinity of the cross-over sites in 92% of IRR and 93% of TLD. Multiple repeats of these trinucleotides have been observed in 39% of IRR and 38% of TLD. Runs of five or more contiguous purines (or pyrimidines on the complementary strand) were found in 26% of IRR and 14% of TLD. Adenine-Thymine rich regions of five or more bases were found in 14% of IRR and 21% of TLD. Alternating purine-pyrimidine tracks longer than four nucleotides in length were found in 11% of IRR, though only in 4% of TLD. I discuss the possible biological significance of these findings and present an appendix containing the sequences in the 10 bp vicinity of the non-homologous recombination sites analyzed.

Mechanisms of nonhomologous recombination in mammalian cells

The primary mechanism of nonhomologous recombination in transfected DNA involves breakage followed by end joining. To probe the joining step in more detail, linear simian virus 40 genomes with mismatched ends were transfected into cultured monkey cells, and individual viable recombinants were analyzed. The transfected genomes carried mismatched ends as a result of cleavage with two restriction enzymes, the recognition sites of which are located in the intron of the gene encoding the T antigen. Because the T antigen gene was split by this cleavage, the transfected genomes were inert until activated by cell-mediated end joining. Clonal descendants of the original recombinants were isolated from 122 plaques and were grouped into four classes based on the electrophoretic mobility of the junction fragment. The structures of representative junctions were determined by nucleotide sequencing. The spectrum of nonhomologous junctions analyzed here along with a large number of previously reported junctions suggest that there are two mechanisms for the linkage of DNA molecules: (i) direct ligation of ends and (ii) repair synthesis primed by terminal homologies of a few nucleotides. A paired-priming model of nonhomologous recombination is discussed.

Analysis of homologous recombination in cultured mammalian cells in transient expression and stable transformation assays

Recombination between plasmid molecules, each containing a nonoverlapping deletion mutation in the hamster adenine phosphoribosyltransferase gene, was measured after coinjection into rat cells. Using these two plasmids, as linear or circular molecules, the recombination efficiency was measured soon after injection in a transient expression assay or after selection for stable transformants. The transient assay revealed that linear molecules were a better substrate for recombination, with double strand breaks within the region of homology stimulating recombination more than breaks outside the region of homology. A 20 to 70-fold increase in the efficiency of recombination was observed when two linear molecules were coinjected as compared to two circular molecules. Linear molecules were found to not only stimulate recombination but also to facilitate stable integration of the recombinant molecule into the host genome.

Mechanisms of nonhomologous recombination in mammalian cells

The primary mechanism of nonhomologous recombination in transfected DNA involves breakage followed by end joining. To probe the joining step in more detail, linear simian virus 40 genomes with mismatched ends were transfected into cultured monkey cells, and individual viable recombinants were analyzed. The transfected genomes carried mismatched ends as a result of cleavage with two restriction enzymes, the recognition sites of which are located in the intron of the gene encoding the T antigen. Because the T antigen gene was split by this cleavage, the transfected genomes were inert until activated by cell-mediated end joining. Clonal descendants of the original recombinants were isolated from 122 plaques and were grouped into four classes based on the electrophoretic mobility of the junction fragment. The structures of representative junctions were determined by nucleotide sequencing. The spectrum of nonhomologous junctions analyzed here along with a large number of previously reported junctions suggest that there are two mechanisms for the linkage of DNA molecules: (i) direct ligation of ends and (ii) repair synthesis primed by terminal homologies of a few nucleotides. A paired-priming model of nonhomologous recombination is discussed.

DNA sequence studies of simian virus 40 chromosomal excision and integration in rat cells

Cell fusion between simian CV1 cells and the simian virus 40-transformed rat cell line 14B, which contains a single copy of integrated simian virus 40 DNA, results in chromosomal excision of viral DNA. A heterogeneous population of circular molecules containing both viral and cellular DNA is detected in the replicating pool. We present the DNA sequences across six novel junctions created by these excision events and use this information to define the parental genomic sequences involved in this form of "illegitimate" recombination. The data were analyzed to discover whether any common structural feature(s) could be detected at these sites. In each case a redundancy of either two or three base-pairs was found at the precise points of cross-over in both parental DNA molecules. The cross-over points were further distinguished by the presence of at least one copy of the sequence 5'Pyr-T-T3' in either of the homologous sequences that define the cross-over points. Additional stretches of homology are found extending from the homologous cross-over points. To explore the possibility that the selection of the cross-over sites is determined by the free energy of base-pairing, we have used the program of Zuker & Stiegler (1981) to form model heteroduplexes between single-stranded parental DNA molecules. In some cases model heteroduplexes were formed that paired the cross-over points, although these structures were of dubious thermodynamic stability. We therefore conclude that, while the redundancies at the cross-over points must play some role in these processes, other factors aside from simple base-pairing across replicating structures must also be involved. In order to expand our analysis of the recombination events that accompany transformation of rat cells by simian virus 40, we determined the DNA sequences across one of the sites on the rat genome that served as the target for the integration event that engendered the 14B line. Our analysis of this DNA showed that: (1) viral and chromosomal DNA share three base-pairs of homology at the site of cross-over; (2) the cross-over site in the rat genome is adjacent to the trinucleotide 5'Pyr-T-T3'; and (3) the homology shared by the virus and chromosome does not resemble the homology reported at another integration locus, but is similar in that it is flanked on one side by alternating purine and pyrimidine nucleotides.

The nucleotide sequence at the recombination/integration sites of the hybrid viruses Ad2+ND3 and Ad2+ND5

The nucleotide sequence at the recombination/integration sites of the adenovirus 2-simian virus 40 hybrid viruses, Ad2+ND3 and Ad2+ND5, is reported. These viruses were obtained by passages through human cells and fail to express the SV40-related proteins. The lack of expression of SV40-related proteins has been explained on the basis of the nucleotide sequence at the recombination sites. Ad2+ND3 has the entire reading frame for the SV40 T antigen removed up to the translation termination codon. The recombination event in Ad2+ND5 was found to occur in the leader region 11 nucleotides upstream from the splice junction, thus totally eliminating the naturally occurring splice site, which might have lead to defective processing of the mRNA. Alternatively, because of the large deletion, this virus is incapable of making similar hybrid proteins as in Ad2+ND1, Ad2+ND2, and Ad2+ND4, which share the N-terminal sequence of the 16-kDa glycoprotein of the wild-type virus. Thus, either one or both of these events may explain the lack of synthesis of the SV40 T antigen specific protein. Ad2+ND3 and Ad2+ND5 share the sequences at the right junction which suggests their origin from a common precursor. Also, the recombination was found to result in the disruption of the poly (A) addition signal of the adenovirus 2 early region III transcripts. All of the junction sequences were found to be rich in A:T base pairs.

A pattern of partially homologous recombination in mouse L cells

Herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase gene and pBR322 DNA (in large excess to the thymidine kinase gene) were introduced into mouse L cells by calcium phosphate DNA-mediated gene transfer. DNA fragments encompassing six junctions between the exogenous DNAs have been cloned and their nucleotide sequences determined. Analysis of these sequences has shown that stretches of partial homology involving from 20-50 base pairs are present near the points at which joining occurs between the donor molecules. The structure of the junction sequences suggests that the recombination event involves the alignment of the two donor DNA molecules at partially homologous regions followed by staggered cutting and joining. One donor molecule is always cut in the region of partial homology, while the second is cut at some distance that is a small multiple of 13.5 +/- 0.5 base pairs away (at 0, 14, 27, 39, 41, and 54 base pairs). In the three junctions where the second cut is far from the region of homology, a 17- to 19-base-pair segment of DNA separates the donor sequences. In all cases the origin of this "filler" DNA appears to be oligonucleotides derived from pBR322.

Quantitation of a simian virus 40 nonhomologous recombination pathway

We describe an infectious-center in situ plaque hybridization procedure which quantitates simian virus 40 (SV40) nonhomologous recombination in terms of the number of recombinant-producing cells in the DNA transfected cell population. Using this assay to measure the efficiency of recombination with SV40 DNA in permissive monkey BSC-1 cells, we found that: (i) over a range of DNA concentrations, polyomavirus DNA (which is partially homologous to SV40 DNA) cannot be distinguished from nonhomologous phi X174 RF1 DNA with respect to its ability to recombine with SV40 DNA; (ii) at defined DNA concentrations, polyomavirus and phi X174 RF1 DNA compete with each other for recombination with SV40 DNA; (iii) virtually all segments of the phi X174 genome recombine, apparently at random, with SV40 DNA; (iv) the frequency of recombinant-producing cells, among the successfully transfected (virion-producing) cells, depends upon the input SV40 DNA concentration in the transfection solution; and (v) replication-defective SV40 mutant DNAs compete with wild-type SV40 DNA for recombination with phi X174 RF1 DNA. From these observations, we conclude that the efficiency of recombination with SV40, in the system under study, is unaffected by nucleotide sequence homology and that a limiting stage in the recombination pathway occurs before SV40 DNA replication. Comparison of the dependency of recombination on initial SV40 DNA concentration with the dependency on initial phi X174 RF1 DNA concentration indicates that SV40 DNA sequences are a controlling factor in the nonhomologous recombination pathway.

The adenovirus type 2-simian virus 40 hybrid virus Ad2+ND4 requires deletion variants to grow in monkey cells

The Ad2+ND4 virus is an adenovirus type 2 (Ad2)-simian virus 40 (SV40) recombination. The Ad2 genome of this recombinant has a rearrangement within early region 3; Ad2 DNA sequences between map positions 81.3 and 85.5 have been deleted, and the SV40 DNA sequences between map positions 0.11 and 0.626 have been inserted into the deletion in an 81.3-0.626 orientation. Nonhybrid Ad2 is defective in monkey cells; however, the Ad2+ND4 virus can replicate in monkey cells due to the expression of the SV40-enhancing function encoded by the DNA insert. Stocks of the Ad2+ND4 hybrid were produced in primary monkey cells by using the progeny of a three-step plaque purification procedure and were considered to be homogeneous populations of Ad2+ND4 virions because they induced plaques in primary monkey cells by first-order kinetics. By studying the kinetics of plaque induction in continuous lines (BSC-1 and CV-1) of monkey cells, we have found that stocks (prepared with virions before and after plaque purification) of Ad2+ND4 are actually heterogeneous populations of Ad2+ND4 virions and Ad2+ND4 deletion variants that lack SV40 and frequently Ad2 DNA sequences at the left Ad2-SV40 junction. Due to the defectiveness of the Ad2+ND4 virus, the production of progeny in BSC-1 and CV-1 cells requires complementation between the Ad2+ND4 genome and the genome of an Ad2+ND4 deletion variant. Since the deletion variants that have been obtained from Ad2+ND4 stocks do not express the SV40-enhancing function in that they cannot produce progeny in monkey cells, we conclude that they are providing an Ad2 component that is essential for the production of Ad2+ND4 progeny. These data imply that the Ad2+ND4 virus is incapable of replicating in singly infected primary monkey cells without generating deletion variants that are missing various amounts of DNA around the left Ad2-SV40 junction in the hybrid genome. As the deletion variants that arise from the Ad2+ND4 virus are created by nonhomologous DNA recombination, the generation of deletion variants in monkey cells infected with Ad2+ND4 may be a useful model for studying this process.