DNA strand specificity in promoter recognition by RNA polymerase

Towards a rational approach to promoter engineering: understanding the complexity of transcription initiation in prokaryotes

Promoter sequences are important genetic control elements. Through their interaction with RNA polymerase they determine transcription strength and specificity, thereby regulating the first step in gene expression. Consequently, they can be targeted as elements to control predictability and tuneability of a genetic circuit, which is essential in applications such as the development of robust microbial cell factories. This review considers the promoter elements implicated in the three stages of transcription initiation, detailing the complex interplay of sequence-specific interactions that are involved, and highlighting that DNA sequence features beyond the core promoter elements work in a combinatorial manner to determine transcriptional strength. In particular, we emphasize that, aside from promoter recognition, transcription initiation is also defined by the kinetics of open complex formation and promoter escape, which are also known to be highly sequence specific. Significantly, we focus on how insights into these interactions can be manipulated to lay the foundation for a more rational approach to promoter engineering.

The activity of a single-stranded promoter of plasmid ColIb-P9 depends on its secondary structure

The leading region of the conjugal bacterial plasmid ColIb-P9 contains three dispersed repeats of a 328 bp sequence homologous to Frpo, a sequence from plasmid F that acts as a promoter in single-stranded DNA. One of these sequences, ssi3, inactive in the double-stranded form, promoted in vitro transcription exclusively from the single strand that is transferred during conjugation. Promoter activity was dependent on the presence of RNA polymerase holoenzyme containing sigma 70. Transcription initiated from the position predicted from folding the single-stranded DNA to form a pseudo double-stranded hairpin structure containing recognizable -35 and -10 promoter elements. Footprinting of RNA polymerase holoenzyme on single-stranded ssi3 DNA was consistent with this suggestion. Mutagenesis of the putative -35 region inactivated the promoter, but random mutations in the -10 region had little effect. The putative -10 region is a poor match to the consensus sequence and contains mismatched bases. Elimination of these mismatches invariably destroyed single-strand promoter activity. These observations reveal the crucial contribution of the unpaired bases in the -10 region in potentiating the formation of the productive open complex with RNA polymerase.

Differential melting of the transcription start site associated with changes in RNA polymerase-promoter contacts in initiating transcription complexes

Formaldehyde cross-linking was used in a kinetic analysis of RNA polymerase-lacUV5 promoter interactions in open complexes (RP(o)). RP(o) quenched from 37 degrees C to 14 degrees C isomerised to a closed, competitor resistant, complex (RP(LT)). We observed that contacts of the beta' and sigma subunits with the positions -3, -5 of the non-template DNA strand disappeared very quickly during the first 30 seconds after the temperature downshift. The re-annealing of the DNA downstream of the transcription start site takes place in the same time scale. However re-annealing of the upstream part of the transcription bubble was slower and completed within five minutes. The results support a two-step model of promoter melting and suggest that conformational changes in the RNA polymerase occur concurrently with the melting around the transcription start site.

Analysis of core promoter sequences located downstream from the TATA element in the hsp70 promoter from Drosophila melanogaster

TFIID recognizes multiple sequence elements in the hsp70 promoter of Drosophila. Here, we investigate the function of sequences downstream from the TATA element. A mutation in the initiator was identified that caused an eightfold reduction in binding of TFIID and a fourfold reduction in transcription in vitro. Another mutation in the +24 to +29 region was somewhat less inhibitory, but a mutation in the +14 to +19 region had essentially no effect. The normal promoter and the mutants in the initiator and the +24 to +29 region were transformed into flies by P element-mediated transformation. The initiator mutation reduced expression an average of twofold in adult flies, whereas the mutation in the +24 to +29 region had essentially no effect. In contrast, a promoter combining the two mutations was expressed an average of sixfold less than the wild type. The results suggest that the initiator and the +24 to +29 region could serve overlapping functions in vivo. Protein-DNA cross-linking was used to identify which subunits of TFIID contact the +24 to +29 region and the initiator. No specific subunits were found to cross-link to the +24 to +29 region. In contrast, the initiator cross-linked exclusively to dTAF230. Remarkably, dTAF230 cross-links approximately 10 times more efficiently to the nontranscribed strand than to the transcribed strand at the initiator.

Crystal structure of a sigma 70 subunit fragment from E. coli RNA polymerase

The 2.6 A crystal structure of a fragment of the sigma 70 promoter specificity subunit of E. coli RNA polymerase is described. Residues involved in core RNA polymerase binding lie on one face of the structure. On the opposite face, aligned along one helix, are exposed residues that interact with the -10 consensus promoter element (the Pribnow box), including four aromatic residues involved in promoter melting. The structure suggests one way in which DNA interactions may be inhibited in the absence of RNA polymerase and provides a framework for the interpretation of a large number of genetic and biochemical analyses.

Conformational changes in E. coli RNA polymerase during promoter recognition

We analysed complexes formed during recognition of the lacUV5 promoter by E. coli RNA polymerase using formaldehyde as a DNA-protein and protein-protein cross-linking reagent. Most of the cross-linked complexes specific for the open complex (RPO) contain the beta' subunit of RNA polymerase cross-linked with promoter DNA in the regions: -50 to -49; -5 to -10; + 5 to +8 and +18 to +21. The protein-protein cross-linking pattern of contacting subunits is the same for the RNA polymerase in solution and in RPO: there are strong sigma-beta' and beta-beta' interactions. In contrast, only beta-beta' cross-links were detected in the closed (RPC) and intermediate (RPI) complexes. In presence of lac repressor before or after formation of the RPO cross-linking pattern is similar with that of RPI (RPC) complex.

Identification of a nucleic acid-binding region within the largest subunit of Drosophila melanogaster RNA polymerase II

The largest and the second-largest subunit of the multisubunit eukaryotic RNA polymerases are involved in interaction with the DNA template and the nascent RNA chain. Using Southwestern DNA-binding techniques and nitrocellulose filter binding assays of bacterially expressed fusion proteins, we have identified a region of the largest, 215-kDa, subunit of Drosophila RNA polymerase II that has the potential to bind nucleic acids nonspecifically. This nucleic acid-binding region is located between amino acid residues 309-384 and is highly conserved within the largest subunits of eukaryotic and bacterial RNA polymerases. A homology to a region of the DNA-binding cleft of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I involved in binding of the newly synthesized DNA duplex provides indirect evidence that the nucleic acid-binding region of the largest subunit participates in interaction with double-stranded nucleic acids during transcription. The nonspecific DNA-binding behavior of the region is similar to that observed for the native enzyme in nitrocellulose filter binding assays and that of the separated largest subunit in Southwestern assays. A high content of basic amino acid residues is consistent with the electrostatic nature of nonspecific DNA binding by RNA polymerases.

Analysis of multiple forms of nuclear factor I in human and murine cell lines

Nuclear factor I (NFI) is a group of related site-specific DNA-binding proteins that function in adenovirus DNA replication and cellular RNA metabolism. We have measured both the levels and forms of NFI that interact with a well-characterized 26-base-pair NFI-binding site. Five different NFI-DNA complexes were seen in HeLa nuclear extracts by using a gel mobility shift (GMS) assay. In addition, at least six forms of NFI were shown to cross-link directly to DNA by using a UV cross-linking assay. The distinct GMS complexes detected were composed of different subspecies of NFI polypeptides as assayed by UV cross-linking. Different murine cell lines possessed varying levels and forms of NFI binding activity, as judged by nitrocellulose filter binding and GMS assays. The growth state of NIH 3T3 cells affected both the types of NFI-DNA complexes seen in a GMS assay and the forms of the protein detected by UV cross-linking.

Analysis of multiple forms of nuclear factor I in human and murine cell lines

Nuclear factor I (NFI) is a group of related site-specific DNA-binding proteins that function in adenovirus DNA replication and cellular RNA metabolism. We have measured both the levels and forms of NFI that interact with a well-characterized 26-base-pair NFI-binding site. Five different NFI-DNA complexes were seen in HeLa nuclear extracts by using a gel mobility shift (GMS) assay. In addition, at least six forms of NFI were shown to cross-link directly to DNA by using a UV cross-linking assay. The distinct GMS complexes detected were composed of different subspecies of NFI polypeptides as assayed by UV cross-linking. Different murine cell lines possessed varying levels and forms of NFI binding activity, as judged by nitrocellulose filter binding and GMS assays. The growth state of NIH 3T3 cells affected both the types of NFI-DNA complexes seen in a GMS assay and the forms of the protein detected by UV cross-linking.

Chemical and photochemical probing of DNA complexes

An overview of the chemical and photochemical probes which over the past ten years have been used in studies of DNA/ligand complexes and of non-B-form DNA conformations is presented with emphasis on the chemical reactions of the probes with DNA and on their present 'use-profile'. The chemical probes include: dimethyl sulfate, ethyl nitroso urea, diethyl pyrocarbonate, osmium tetroxide, permanganate, aldehydes, methidiumpropyl-EDTA-Fell (MPE), phenanthroline metal complexes and EDTA/FeII. The photochemical probes that have been used include: psoralens, UVB, acridines and uranyl salts. The biological systems analysed by use of these probes are reviewed by tabulation.

DNA-binding properties of an adenovirus 289R E1A protein

An adenovirus 2 289 amino acid (289R) E1A protein purified from Escherichia coli has been shown to interact with DNA by two independent methods. UV-crosslinking of complexes containing unmodified, uniformly 32P-labelled DNA and purified E1A protein induced efficient labelling of the protein with covalently attached oligonucleotides, indicating that the E1A protein itself contacts DNA. Discrete nucleoprotein species were also observed when E1A protein--DNA complexes were analysed by gel electrophoresis. Although the 289R E1A protein exhibited no significant binding to single-stranded DNA or to RNA, no evidence for its sequence-specific binding to double-stranded DNA was obtained with either assay. Identification of the sites of covalent attachment of 32P-labelled oligonucleotides by partial proteolysis of the crosslinked E1A protein indicated that the interaction of this protein with DNA is mediated via domain(s) in the C-terminal half of the protein. Such previously unrecognized DNA-binding activity is likely to contribute to the regulatory activities of this important adenoviral protein.

Structural and functional differences between the two intrinsic zinc ions of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

DNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RPase) from Escherichia coli contains 2 mol of intrinsic Zn(II)/mol of core enzyme (alpha 2 beta beta'). In techniques analogous to those employed with the Zn(II) metalloenzyme aspartate transcarbamoylase [Hunt, J. B., Neece, S. H., Schachman, H. K., & Ginsberg, A. (1984) J. Biol. Chem. 259, 14793-14803], we show that titration of core or holoRPase with 10 or 16 equiv, respectively, of the sulfhydryl reagent p-(hydroxymercuri)benzenesulfonate (PMPS) results in the facile release of 1 mol of Zn(II) [B-site Zn(II)] in a reaction totally reversible with the addition of excess thiol provided no metal chelator is present. If ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) is present, reversal of the PMPS-enzyme complex results in formation of a Zn1 RPase [A-site Zn(II)]. This enzyme retains full transcriptional activity relative to Zn2 RPase on both calf thymus (nonspecific) and T7 (sigma-dependent, specific) DNA templates. If the core enzyme-PMPS complex is incubated with a large excess of another metal such as Cd(II) followed by thiol treatment, a hybrid ZnACdB RPase is formed. Direct treatment of the enzyme with excess Cd(II) also gives rise to a hybrid ZnACdB RPase. Transcription by these enzymes is also comparable to that of the starting Zn2 enzyme. Isolation of in vivo synthesized Co2 RPase and Cd2 RPase and treatment of either enzyme with PMPS/EDTA results in formation of a CoA and CdA enzyme, respectively. Co(II)A and Cd(II)A enzymes show 123 and 76%, respectively, of the elongation rates on T7 DNA observed for the Zn(II) enzyme. Visible absorption spectroscopy of the Co2 enzyme exhibits four d-d transition bands positioned at 760 (epsilon = 800), 710 (epsilon = 900), 602 (epsilon = 1500), and 484 (epsilon = 4000) nm. In addition, two charge-transfer bands are found at 350 (epsilon = 9600) and 370 (epsilon = 9500) nm. Only the Co(II) ion bound at site A is associated with this unique set of intense d-d transitions. The positions and intensities of both the visible and charge-transfer bands of Co(II)A RPase approximate those shown by Co(II)-substituted metalloenzyme sites where the ligands are four S rather than mixed S,N or S,O sites.

Functionally important site in the vicinity of the amino-terminus of the Escherichia coli RNA polymerase beta subunit

We have analyzed the interaction of monoclonal antibodies against Escherichia coli RNA polymerase with products of its limited proteolysis. Two major proteolytic fragments of molecular masses 107 and 43 kDa originate as a result of a single cleavage in the vicinity of the 980th amino acid residue. Anti-beta subunit monoclonal antibody PYN-2 inhibiting RNA polymerase activity at the stage of RNA elongation reacts with an epitope located between the amino-terminus and the 50th amino acid residue of the beta subunit. DNA sequencing has shown that the RNA polymerase mutation rpoB22 converts the Gln(1111) codon of the beta subunit gene into the amber codon. An epitope for the monoclonal antibody PYN-6 was located between the major site of proteolytic cleavage and Gln(1111) of the beta subunit.

Topography of transcription: path of the leading end of nascent RNA through the Escherichia coli transcription complex

A cleavable dinucleotide photoaffinity reagent was prepared and used to map the path of the leading end of the RNA transcript across the surface of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase/T7 DNA transcription complexes. By using 5'-(4-azidophenacylthio)phosphoryladenylyl(3'-5')uridine, transcription was specifically initiated at the A1 promoter of bacteriophage T7 D111 or D123 DNA. Transcription complexes containing radiolabeled RNA chains of various lengths (4-116 nucleotides) were prepared, and the 5' end of the RNA transcript was then covalently attached to the nearby polymerase subunits or DNA by irradiation with UV light. The photoaffinity-labeled enzyme subunits and DNA were separated, the radiolabeled RNAs were cleaved from each, and the lengths and sequences of RNA attached to each component were determined. The leading end of RNA chains up to 12 bases long was found to label the DNA and the beta and beta' subunits of RNA polymerase, with more than 90% of the label going to the DNA. When the RNA transcript reached 12 bases in length, the 5' end diverged from the DNA and only the beta and beta' enzyme subunits were labeled thereafter. These two subunits were heavily labeled by RNA chains 12 to as many as 94 bases long. No significant labeling of the alpha subunit occurred. The sigma subunit was not labeled by RNAs longer than the trinucleotide.

Interaction of nucleic acids with the DNA-dependent RNA polymerases of Drosophila

The interaction between the three Drosophila DNA-dependent RNA polymerases (EC 2.7.7.6) and the DNA template or the RNA product was investigated by photochemical cross-linking and binding studies, using RNA polymerase subunits immobilized on nitro-cellulose filters. It can be shown that the two largest subunits are responsible for the binding of the enzymes to both template and newly-synthesized RNA.

Chemical modifications of the sigma subunit of the E. coli RNA polymerase

The function of arginine, cysteine and carboxylic amino acid (glutamic and aspartic) residues of sigma was studied using chemical modification by group specific reagents. Following modification of 3 arginine residues with phenylglyoxal or 3 cysteine residues with N-ethylmaleimide (NEM) sigma activity was lost. Analysis of the kinetic data for inactivation indicated that one arginine or cysteine residue is essential for sigma activity. At low NEM concentration alkylation was limited to a non-critical cysteine which was identified as cysteine-132. Modification of arginine or cysteine residues had no observable effect on the binding of the inactivated sigma to the core polymerase. Modification of aspartic and/or glutamic acid residues with the water-soluble carbodiimides 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylamino-propyl) carbodiimide hydrochloride (EDC) or 1-cyclohexyl-3-(2-morpholinoethyl) carbodiimide metho-p-toluene sulfonate (CMC) resulted in loss of sigma activity. The inactivation data indicated that one carboxylic amino acid residue is essential for sigma activity. Sigma modified with EDC, CMC or EDC in the presence of glycine was inactive in supporting promoter binding and initiation by core polymerase. Reaction with EDC plus (3H)glycine resulted in the incorporation of glycine into sigma. The (3H)glycine-sigma was unable to form a stable holoenzyme complex.

A rapid mixing-photocrosslinking technique to study the dynamics of nucleic acid-protein interactions

A rapid mixing-photocrosslinking technique has been developed to investigate the kinetics of protein-nucleic acid interactions. With this technique, binding of nucleic acid to protein is first synchronized by rapid mixing in a stopped-flow apparatus. The intermediates formed at different stages of the binding process are then "frozen" by photocrosslinking with a 10-microseconds uv light pulse at various times after mixing. By analyzing structural changes of these intermediates as a function of time, one can obtain the information concerning the dynamic aspects of the interaction. This technique may also be applied to other macromolecular interactions in biological systems.

Laser crosslinking of E. coli RNA polymerase and T7 DNA

The first photochemical crosslinking of a protein to a nucleic acid using laser excitation is reported. A single, 120 mJ, 20 ns pulse at 248 nm crosslinks about 10% of bound E. coli RNA polymerase to T7 DNA under the conditions studied. The crosslinking yield depends on mercaptoethanol concentration, and is a linear function of laser intensity. The protein subunits crosslinked to DNA are beta, beta' and sigma.