Studies on the minimal lengths required for DNA primers to be extended by the Tetrahymena telomerase: implications for primer positioning by the enzyme

DNA-binding determinants and cellular thresholds for human telomerase repeat addition processivity

The reverse transcriptase telomerase adds telomeric repeats to chromosome ends. Purified human telomerase catalyzes processive repeat synthesis, which could restore the full ~100 nucleotides of (T2AG3)n lost from replicated chromosome ends as a single elongation event. Processivity inhibition is proposed to be a basis of human disease, but the impacts of different levels of processivity on telomere maintenance have not been examined. Here, we delineate side chains in the telomerase active-site cavity important for repeat addition processivity, determine how they contribute to duplex and single-stranded DNA handling, and test the cellular consequences of partial or complete loss of repeat addition processivity for telomere maintenance. Biochemical findings oblige a new model for DNA and RNA handling dynamics in processive repeat synthesis. Biological analyses implicate repeat addition processivity as essential for telomerase function. However, telomeres can be maintained by telomerases with lower than wild-type processivity. Furthermore, telomerases with low processivity dramatically elongate telomeres when overexpressed. These studies reveal distinct consequences of changes in telomerase repeat addition processivity and expression level on telomere elongation and length maintenance.

Telomerase Mechanism of Telomere Synthesis

Telomerase is the essential reverse transcriptase required for linear chromosome maintenance in most eukaryotes. Telomerase supplements the tandem array of simple-sequence repeats at chromosome ends to compensate for the DNA erosion inherent in genome replication. The template for telomerase reverse transcriptase is within the RNA subunit of the ribonucleoprotein complex, which in cells contains additional telomerase holoenzyme proteins that assemble the active ribonucleoprotein and promote its function at telomeres. Telomerase is distinct among polymerases in its reiterative reuse of an internal template. The template is precisely defined, processively copied, and regenerated by release of single-stranded product DNA. New specificities of nucleic acid handling that underlie the catalytic cycle of repeat synthesis derive from both active site specialization and new motif elaborations in protein and RNA subunits. Studies of telomerase provide unique insights into cellular requirements for genome stability, tissue renewal, and tumorigenesis as well as new perspectives on dynamic ribonucleoprotein machines.

P. berghei telomerase subunit TERT is essential for parasite survival

Telomeres define the ends of chromosomes protecting eukaryotic cells from chromosome instability and eventual cell death. The complex regulation of telomeres involves various proteins including telomerase, which is a specialized ribonucleoprotein responsible for telomere maintenance. Telomeres of chromosomes of malaria parasites are kept at a constant length during blood stage proliferation. The 7-bp telomere repeat sequence is universal across different Plasmodium species (GGGTTT/CA), though the average telomere length varies. The catalytic subunit of telomerase, telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT), is present in all sequenced Plasmodium species and is approximately three times larger than other eukaryotic TERTs. The Plasmodium RNA component of TERT has recently been identified in silico. A strategy to delete the gene encoding TERT via double cross-over (DXO) homologous recombination was undertaken to study the telomerase function in P. berghei. Expression of both TERT and the RNA component (TR) in P. berghei blood stages was analysed by Western blotting and Northern analysis. Average telomere length was measured in several Plasmodium species using Telomere Restriction Fragment (TRF) analysis. TERT and TR were detected in blood stages and an average telomere length of ∼950 bp established. Deletion of the tert gene was performed using standard transfection methodologies and we show the presence of tert⁻ mutants in the transfected parasite populations. Cloning of tert- mutants has been attempted multiple times without success. Thorough analysis of the transfected parasite populations and the parasite obtained from extensive parasite cloning from these populations provide evidence for a so called delayed death phenotype as observed in different organisms lacking TERT. The findings indicate that TERT is essential for P. berghei cell survival. The study extends our current knowledge on telomere biology in malaria parasites and validates further investigations to identify telomerase inhibitors to induce parasite cell death.

Tracing the path of DNA substrates in active Tetrahymena telomerase holoenzyme complexes: mapping of DNA contact sites in the RNA subunit

Telomerase, the enzyme that extends single-stranded telomeric DNA, consists of an RNA subunit (TER) including a short template sequence, a catalytic protein (TERT) and accessory proteins. We used site-specific UV cross-linking to map the binding sites for DNA primers in TER within active Tetrahymena telomerase holoenzyme complexes. The mapping was performed at single-nucleotide resolution by a novel technique based on RNase H digestion of RNA–DNA hybrids made with overlapping complementary oligodeoxynucleotides. These data allowed tracing of the DNA path through the telomerase complexes from the template to the TERT binding element (TBE) region of TER. TBE is known to bind TERT and to be involved in the template 5′-boundary definition. Based on these findings, we propose that upstream sequences of each growing telomeric DNA chain are involved in regulation of its growth arrest at the 5′-end of the RNA template. The upstream DNA–TBE interaction may also function as an anchor for the subsequent realignment of the 3′-end of the DNA with the 3′-end of the template to enable initiation of synthesis of a new telomeric repeat.

Telomerase: structure, functions, and activity regulation

Telomerase is the enzyme responsible for maintenance of the length of telomeres by addition of guanine-rich repetitive sequences. Telomerase activity is exhibited in gametes and stem and tumor cells. In human somatic cells proliferation potential is strictly limited and senescence follows approximately 50-70 cell divisions. In most tumor cells, on the contrary, replication potential is unlimited. The key role in this process of the system of the telomere length maintenance with involvement of telomerase is still poorly studied. No doubt, DNA polymerase is not capable to completely copy DNA at the very ends of chromosomes; therefore, approximately 50 nucleotides are lost during each cell cycle, which results in gradual telomere length shortening. Critically short telomeres cause senescence, following crisis, and cell death. However, in tumor cells the system of telomere length maintenance is activated. Besides catalytic telomere elongation, independent telomerase functions can be also involved in cell cycle regulation. Inhibition of the telomerase catalytic function and resulting cessation of telomere length maintenance will help in restriction of tumor cell replication potential. On the other hand, formation of temporarily active enzyme via its intracellular activation or due to stimulation of expression of telomerase components will result in telomerase activation and telomere elongation that can be used for correction of degenerative changes. Data on telomerase structure and function are summarized in this review, and they are compared for evolutionarily remote organisms. Problems of telomerase activity measurement and modulation by enzyme inhibitors or activators are considered as well.

Mapping of DNA binding sites in the Tetrahymena telomerase holoenzyme proteins by UV cross-linking and mass spectrometry

The Tetrahymena telomerase holoenzyme consists of a major catalytic protein [telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT)], an RNA subunit, and accessory proteins. We used site-specific UV cross-linking and mass spectrometry to map interactions between the holoenzyme and the telomeric DNA. In one series of experiments, an oligodeoxyribonucleotide containing a 5-iododeoxyuridine residue or 4-thio-deoxythymidine residue was cross-linked to the telomerase by irradiation with UV light-emitting diodes. The DNA was extended by the cross-linked enzyme with a radioactively labeled or unlabeled nucleotide. The complexes were subsequently resolved by SDS-PAGE. Proteins were isolated from strips in the unlabeled gels corresponding to bands observed in the radioactive gels. Mass spectrometric analysis of these proteins revealed a major cross-linking site in TERT. Serendipitous cleavage of TERT near amino acid 254 indicated that this site maps within the N-terminal cleavage product, which includes primarily the telomerase essential N-terminal (TEN) domain. Moreover, the absence of this N-terminal segment in TERT was found to cause a reduction in DNA binding by the telomerase and/or its activity to undetectable levels. In other experiments, similar unresolved cross-linked complexes were digested with trypsin, two exonucleases, and alkaline phosphatase. Tandem mass spectrometry was then used to search for peptides linked to the residual deoxyribonucleoside. Using this approach, we identified the phenylalanine residue F351 in the accessory protein p45 as a minor DNA cross-linking site. Our study constitutes the first direct mapping of DNA interaction sites in telomerase holoenzyme complexes. This mapping represents a significant contribution to the understanding of the mechanism of telomere extension by telomerase.

A modified model for translocation events of processive nucleotide and repeat additions by the recombinant telomerase

Telomerase is a unique reverse transcriptase that extends the single-stranded 3' overhangs of telomeres by copying a short template sequence within the integral RNA component of the enzyme. It shows processive nucleotide and repeat addition activities, which are realized via two types of movements: translocation of the DNA:RNA hybrid away from the active site following each nucleotide addition and translocation of the 3' end of the DNA primer relative to the RNA template after each round of repeat synthesis. Here, a model is presented to describe these two types of translocation events by the recombinant Tetrahymena telomerase, via the modification of the model that has been proposed recently. Using the present model, the dynamics of the dissociation of the DNA primer from the telomerase and the dynamics of the disruption of the DNA:RNA hybrid and then repositioning of the product 3' end to the beginning of the template are studied quantitatively. Their effects on the repeat addition processivity are theoretically studied. The theoretical results are in agreement with the available experimental data.

InTERTpreting telomerase structure and function

The Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine was recently awarded to Elizabeth Blackburn, Carol Greider and Jack Szostak for their pioneering studies on chromosome termini (telomeres) and their discovery of telomerase, the enzyme that synthesizes telomeres. Telomerase is a unique cellular reverse transcriptase that contains an integral RNA subunit, the telomerase RNA and a catalytic protein subunit, the telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT), as well as several species-specific accessory proteins. Telomerase is essential for genome stability and is associated with a broad spectrum of human diseases including various forms of cancer, bone marrow failure and pulmonary fibrosis. A better understanding of telomerase structure and function will shed important insights into how this enzyme contributes to human disease. To this end, a series of high-resolution structural studies have provided critical information on TERT architecture and may ultimately elucidate novel targets for therapeutic intervention. In this review, we discuss the current knowledge of TERT structure and function, revealed through the detailed analysis of TERT from model organisms. To emphasize the physiological importance of telomeres and telomerase, we also present a general discussion of the human diseases associated with telomerase dysfunction.

Multiple mechanisms for elongation processivity within the reconstituted tetrahymena telomerase holoenzyme

To maintain telomeres, telomerase evolved a unique biochemical activity: the use of a single-stranded RNA template for the synthesis of single-stranded DNA repeats. High repeat addition processivity (RAP) of the Tetrahymena telomerase holoenzyme requires association of the catalytic core with the telomere adaptor subcomplex (TASC) and an RPA1-related subunit (p82 or Teb1). Here, we used DNA binding and holoenzyme reconstitution assays to investigate the mechanism by which Teb1 and TASC confer high RAP. We show that TASC association with the recombinant telomerase catalytic core increases enzyme activity. Subsequent association of the Teb1 C-terminal domain with TASC confers the capacity for high RAP even though the Teb1 C-terminal domain does not provide a high-affinity DNA interaction site. Efficient RAP also requires suppression of nascent product folding mediated by the central Teb1 DNA-binding domains (DBDs). These sequence-specific high-affinity DBDs of Teb1 can be functionally substituted by the analogous DBDs of Tetrahymena Rpa1 to suppress nascent product folding but only if the Rpa1 high-affinity DBDs are physically tethered into holoenzyme context though the Teb1 C-terminal domain. Overall, our findings reveal multiple mechanisms and multiple surfaces of protein-DNA and protein-protein interaction that give rise to elongation processivity in the synthesis of a single-stranded nucleic acid product.

The telomerase-specific T motif is a restrictive determinant of repetitive reverse transcription by human telomerase

The central hallmark of telomerases is repetitive copying of a short, defined sequence within its integral RNA subunit. We sought to identify structural determinants of this unique activity in the catalytic protein subunit telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT) of telomerase. Residues within the highly conserved telomerase-specific T motif of human TERT were mutationally probed, leading to variant telomerases with increased repeat extension rates and wild-type processivity. The extension rate increases were independent of template sequence composition and only moderately correlated to telomerase RNA (TR) binding. Importantly, analysis of substrate primer elongation showed that the extension rate increases primarily resulted from increases in the repeat (type II) translocation rate. Our findings indicate a participatory role for the T motif in repeat translocation, an obligatory event for repetitive telomeric DNA synthesis. Thus, the T motif serves as a restrictive determinant of repetitive reverse transcription.

Multiple DNA-binding sites in Tetrahymena telomerase

Telomerase is a ribonucleoprotein enzyme that maintains chromosome ends through de novo addition of telomeric DNA. The ability of telomerase to interact with its DNA substrate at sites outside its catalytic centre ('anchor sites') is important for its unique ability to undergo repeat addition processivity. We have developed a direct and quantitative equilibrium primer-binding assay to measure DNA-binding affinities of regions of the catalytic protein subunit of recombinant Tetrahymena telomerase (TERT). There are specific telomeric DNA-binding sites in at least four regions of TERT (the TEN, RBD, RT and C-terminal domains). Together, these sites contribute to specific and high-affinity DNA binding, with a K(d) of approximately 8 nM. Both the K(m) and K(d) increased in a stepwise manner as the primer length was reduced; thus recombinant Tetrahymena telomerase, like the endogenous enzyme, contains multiple anchor sites. The N-terminal TEN domain, which has previously been implicated in DNA binding, shows only low affinity binding. However, there appears to be cooperativity between the TEN and RNA-binding domains. Our data suggest that different DNA-binding sites are used by the enzyme during different stages of the addition cycle.

High-resolution physical and functional mapping of the template adjacent DNA binding site in catalytically active telomerase

Telomerase is a cellular reverse transcriptase, which utilizes an integral RNA template to extend single-stranded telomeric DNA. We used site-specific photocrosslinking to map interactions between DNA primers and the catalytic protein subunit (tTERT) of Tetrahymena thermophila telomerase in functional enzyme complexes. Our assays reveal contact of the single-stranded DNA adjacent to the primer-template hybrid and tTERT residue W187 at the periphery of the N-terminal domain. This contact was detected in complexes with three different registers of template in the active site, suggesting that it is maintained throughout synthesis of a complete telomeric repeat. Substitution of nearby residue Q168, but not W187, alters the K(m) for primer elongation, implying that it plays a role in the DNA recognition. These findings are the first to directly demonstrate the physical location of TERT-DNA contacts in catalytically active telomerase and to identify amino acid determinants of DNA binding affinity. Our data also suggest a movement of the TERT active site relative to the template-adjacent single-stranded DNA binding site within a cycle of repeat synthesis.

Characterization of physical and functional anchor site interactions in human telomerase

Telomerase is a ribonucleoprotein reverse transcriptase (RT) that processively synthesizes telomeric repeats onto the ends of linear chromosomes to maintain genomic stability. It has been proposed that the N terminus of the telomerase protein subunit, telomerase RT (TERT), contains an anchor site that forms stable interactions with DNA to prevent enzyme-DNA dissociation during translocation and to promote realignment events that accompany each round of telomere synthesis. However, it is not known whether human TERT (hTERT) can directly interact with DNA in the absence of the telomerase RNA subunit. Here we use a novel primer binding assay to establish that hTERT forms stable and specific contacts with telomeric DNA in the absence of the human telomerase RNA component (hTR). We show that hTERT-mediated primer binding can be functionally uncoupled from telomerase-mediated primer extension. Our results demonstrate that the first 350 amino acids of hTERT have a critical role in regulating the strength and specificity of protein-DNA interactions, providing additional evidence that the TERT N terminus contains an anchor site. Furthermore, we establish that the RT domain of hTERT mediates important protein-DNA interactions. Collectively, these data suggest that hTERT contains distinct anchor regions that cooperate to help regulate telomerase-mediated DNA recognition and elongation.

The structure and function of telomerase reverse transcriptase

The structure and integrity of telomeres are essential for genome stability. Telomere dysregulation can lead to cell death, cell senescence, or abnormal cell proliferation. The maintenance of telomere repeats in most eukaryotic organisms requires telomerase, which consists of a reverse transcriptase (RT) and an RNA template that dictates the synthesis of the G-rich strand of telomere terminal repeats. Structurally, telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT) contains unique and variable N- and C-terminal extensions that flank a central RT-like domain. The enzymology of telomerase includes features that are both similar to and distinct from those characteristic of other RTs. Two distinguishing features of TERT are its stable association with the telomerase RNA and its ability to repetitively reverse transcribe the template segment of RNA. Here we discuss TERT structure and function; its regulation by RNA-DNA, TERT-DNA, TERT-RNA, TERT-TERT interactions, and TERT-associated proteins; and the relationship between telomerase enzymology and telomere maintenance.

The biogenesis and regulation of telomerase holoenzymes

Chromosome stability requires a dynamic balance of DNA loss and gain in each terminal tract of telomeric repeats. Repeat addition by a specialized reverse transcriptase, telomerase, has an important role in maintaining this equilibrium. Insights that have been gained into the cellular pathways for biogenesis and regulation of telomerase ribonucleoproteins raise new questions, particularly concerning the dynamic nature of this unique polymerase.

Real-time telomeric repeat amplification protocol using the duplex scorpion and two reverse primers system: the high sensitive and accurate method for quantification of telomerase activity

BACKGROUND

Real-time quantitative TRAP assays for detection of telomerase activity have been recently developed to eliminate complex post-PCR procedures. However, all of them use the conventional TRAP assay that possesses an unpredictable cascade of events in PCR amplification caused by stagger annealing, which may affect the accuracy of quantitation.

METHODS

A novel RTQ-TRAP method was developed by combining the duplex scorpion with modified TP-TRAP assay that has high fidelity PCR amplification of the telomerase product (DS/TP-TRAP). The synthesized oligonucleotide that represents telomerase products is used to set up a standard curve.

RESULTS

The DS/TP-TRAP method gives the standard curve a dynamic range of 6 orders of magnitude (R(2)=0.9992). It optimizes PCR amplification efficiency and determines telomerase activity in a lower threshold cycle number (Ct value). The method is both accurate and reproducible to measure telomerase activity in human tumor cell lines, and linearity from 1 to 1000 cells could be obtained (R(2)=0.9926). For tumor samples, the results determined by the DS/TP-TRAP assay are comparable to the data obtained with the conventional TRAP method.

CONCLUSIONS

The DS/TP-TRAP assay provides a high sensitive and accurate method for real-time quantitative detection of telomerase activity. It is thus a potential robust tool for application in cancer molecular diagnostics.

A physical and functional constituent of telomerase anchor site

Telomerase is a ribonucleoprotein reverse transcriptase responsible for the maintenance of one strand of the telomere terminal repeats. It consists minimally of a catalytic protein component (TERT) and an RNA subunit that provides the template. Compared with prototypical reverse transcriptases, telomerase is unique in possessing a DNA binding domain (anchor site) that is distinct from the catalytic site. Yeast TERT mutants bearing deletion or point mutations in an N-terminal domain (known as N-GQ) were found to be selectively impaired in extending primers that form short hybrids with telomerase RNA. The mutants also suffered a significant loss of repeat addition processivity but displayed an enhancement in nucleotide addition processivity. Furthermore, the mutants manifested altered primer utilization properties for oligonucleotides containing non-telomeric residues in the 5'-region. Cross-linking studies indicate that the N-GQ domain physically contacts the 5'-region of the DNA substrate in the context of a telomerase-telomere complex. Together, these results implicate the N-GQ domain of TERT as a physical and functional constituent of the telomerase anchor site. Coupled with previous genetic analysis, our data confirm that anchor site interaction is indeed important for telomerase function in vivo.

An anchor site-type defect in human telomerase that disrupts telomere length maintenance and cellular immortalization

Telomerase-mediated telomeric DNA synthesis is important for eukaryotic cell immortality. Telomerase adds tracts of short telomeric repeats to DNA substrates using a unique repeat addition form of processivity. It has been proposed that repeat addition processivity is partly regulated by a telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT)-dependent anchor site; however, anchor site-mediating residues have not been identified in any TERT. We report the characterization of an N-terminal human TERT (hTERT) RNA interaction domain 1 (RID1) mutation that caused telomerase activity defects consistent with disruption of a template-proximal anchor site, including reduced processivity on short telomeric primers and reduced activity on substrates with nontelomeric 5' sequences, but not on primers with nontelomeric G-rich 5' sequences. This mutation was located within a subregion of RID1 previously implicated in biological telomerase functions unrelated to catalytic activity (N-DAT domain). Other N-DAT and C-terminal DAT (C-DAT) mutants and a C-terminally tagged hTERT-HA variant were defective in elongating short telomeric primers, and catalytic phenotypes of DAT variants were partially or completely rescued by increasing concentrations of DNA primers. These observations imply that RID1 and the hTERT C terminus contribute to telomerase's affinity for its substrate, and that RID1 may form part of the human telomerase anchor site.

Effects of single-stranded DNA binding proteins on primer extension by telomerase

We present a biochemical analysis of the effects of three single-stranded DNA binding proteins on extension of oligonucleotide primers by the Tetrahymena telomerase. One of them, a human protein designated translin, which was shown to specifically bind the G-rich Tetrahymena and human telomeric repeats, slightly stimulated the primer extension reactions at molar ratios of translin/primer of <1:2. At higher molar ratios, it inhibited the reactions by up to 80%. The inhibition was caused by binding of translin to the primers, rather than by a direct interaction of this protein with telomerase. A second protein, the general human single-stranded DNA binding protein Replication Protein A (RPA), similarly affected the primer extension by telomerase, even though its mode of binding to DNA differs from that of translin. A third protein, the E. coli single-stranded DNA binding protein (SSB), whose binding to DNA is highly cooperative, caused more substantial stimulation and inhibition at the lower and the higher molar ratios of SSB/primer, respectively. Both telomere-specific and general single-stranded DNA binding proteins are found in living cells in telomeric complexes. Based on our data, we propose that these proteins may exert either stimulatory or inhibitory effects on intracellular telomerases, depending on their local concentrations.

Human telomerase catalyzes nucleolytic primer cleavage

Telomerase is a reverse transcriptase that uses an integral RNA molecule to add de novo G-rich repeats onto telomeric DNA, or onto nontelomeric DNA generated during chromosome fragmentation and breakage events. A telomerase-mediated DNA substrate cleavage activity has been reported in ciliates and yeasts. Nucleolytic cleavage may serve a proofreading function, enhance processivity or ensure that nontemplate telomerase RNA sequences are not copied into DNA. We identified and characterized a human telomerase-mediated nucleolytic cleavage activity using enzyme reconstituted in a rabbit reticulocyte lysate in vitro transcription/translation system and native enzyme extracted from cells. We found that telomerase catalyzed the removal of nucleotides from DNA substrates including those that can form a mismatch with the RNA template or that contain nontelomeric sequences located 3' to a telomeric sequence. Unlike Tetrahymena telomerase, human telomerase catalyzed the removal of more than one nucleotide (up to 13) from telomeric primers. DNA substrates predicted to align at the 3'-end of the RNA template were not cleaved, consistent with cleavage being dictated by the template 5'-end. We also found some differences in the nuclease activity between RRL-reconstituted human telomerase and native enzyme.

Yeast telomerase is capable of limited repeat addition processivity

Telomerase is a ribonucleoprotein reverse transcriptase responsible for the maintenance of one strand of telomere terminal repeats. Telomerase-mediated sequence addition is dictated by a short 'template' region of the RNA component. Despite the short template segment, telomerases from many organisms have been shown to mediate the synthesis of long extension products. This synthesis presumably depends on two types of translocation events: simultaneous translocation of the RNA-DNA duplex relative to the active site after each nucleotide incorporation (type I or nucleotide addition processivity), and translocation of the RNA relative to the DNA product after each round of repeat synthesis (type II or repeat addition processivity). In contrast, telomerases from yeasts have been shown to synthesize mostly short products, implying a defect in one or both types of translocation. In this report, we analyzed the processivity of yeast telomerase in vitro, and identified two position-specific elongation barriers within the 5' region of the RNA template that can account for the synthesis of incomplete first round products. These barriers respond differently to variations in nucleotide concentration, primer sequence and mutations in the catalytic protein subunit, consistent with their having distinct mechanistic bases. In addition, by using optimal primers and high concentrations of dGTP, we were able to detect significant type II translocation by the yeast enzyme. Thus, the difference between the elongation property of yeast and other telomerases appears to be quantitative rather than qualitative. Our results suggest that yeast may be a useful system for investigating the physiologic significance of repeat addition processivity.