Surgical aspects of intestinal injury due to pelvic radiotherapy

Concurrent Chemoradiation Affects the Clinical Outcome of Small Bowel Complications Following Pelvic Irradiation: Prospective Observational Study from a Regional Cancer Center

Background

To appraise the spectrum of small bowel complications following pelvic irradiation and to assess the clinical outcome and factors associated with adverse clinical outcome in these patients.

Methods

This descriptive clinical study was done for three years in a tertiary care center in South India. Patients managed for post-irradiation small bowel complications, irrespective of the indication for radiotherapy, were studied. Patients with associated non-gastrointestinal radiation toxicity, radiation proctitis, and radiation colitis were excluded. The parameters assessed were the range of small bowel complications, a comparison of operative and non-operative management, morbidity and mortality, the severity of complications in relation to the dose of radiotherapy, and various factors influencing the clinical outcome.

Results

A total of 50 patients were studied. Stricture and perforation peritonitis were the most common presentation (n=25; 50%). A majority of the patients (n=37; 74%) presented after six months following radiotherapy. Post-operative mortality was 16% (n=5). Age, body mass index (BMI), previous surgery, operative intervention, primary or adjuvant radiotherapy, concurrent chemoradiotherapy (CCRT), and various radiation protocols were not associated with adverse clinical outcomes with respect to overall mortality, the requirement of surgery, and operative mortality. However patients who were operated and those who received CCRT had a significantly longer mean intensive care unit (ICU) stay (3.51 days vs. 0.68 days; p = 0.0001) as well as overall mean hospital stay (14.87 days vs. 5.58 days; p = 0.001) and an insignificant mortality rate (16% vs. 15%; p = 0.4085).

Conclusion

The present study observed that the patients who were operated and those who received CCRT had significantly longer hospitalization and relatively higher mortality. Considering the fact that many of the patients who develop post-irradiation complications may not report back to the same center, the incidence of small bowel complications could be higher in reality, which ascertains the necessity for more precision in the radiation technique and operative care in developing countries.

The surgical management of radiation proctopathy

BACKGROUND

There is sparse evidence guiding the optimum surgical management of patients with radiation proctopathy (RP). The purpose of this review is to analyse all the literature on the surgical management of RP in order to guide physicians and surgeons as to when and what surgery should be employed for these patients.

METHODS

A literature search of PubMed, EMBASE, MEDLINE, Ovid, and Cochrane Library using the MeSH terms "radiation proctopathy", "proctitis", "surgical management", and related terms as keywords was performed. The review included all articles that reported on the surgical management of patients with radiation proctopathy. All relevant articles were cross-referenced for further articles and any unavailable online were retrieved from hard-copy archive libraries. Eighteen studies including one prospective cohort study, fifteen retrospective cohort studies, and three small case series are included.

CONCLUSION

Surgery is indicated for patients with RP for rectal obstruction, perforation, fistulae, or a failure of medical measures to control the symptoms of RP. Surgery centres mainly on diversion version resection. Diversion alone does not remove the damaged tissue leaving the patient at risk of continued complications including bleeding, perforation, occlusion, and abscess formation; however, major resectional surgery carries higher risks. Morbidity and mortality vary 0-44% and 0-11% for diversion only versus 0-100% and 0-14% for resectional surgery. There is no universally agreed surgical first-line approach. The data supports both resection with defunctioning stoma or diversion only as reasonable first-line surgical options for patients requiring surgery for RP.

Surgical experience with small bowel damage secondary to pelvic radiotherapy

BACKGROUND

Patients undergoing pelvic radiotherapy are at risk of developing radiation enteritis. This study reviewed patients with radiation enteritis referred to a specialist colorectal unit.

METHODS

Patients referred with radiation enteritis secondary to pelvic radiotherapy (July 2001 to July 2005) were analysed regarding: indication, duration, dosage/fractionation of radiotherapy, nutritional/biochemical assessment, investigation, surgery, histopathology, and hospital stay.

RESULTS

Eleven patients underwent pelvic radiotherapy. The median interval between radiotherapy and referral was 17 months. The majority were nutritionally deficient at presentation (haemoglobin < 12 g/l: 91%; magnesium < 0.75 mmol/l: 64%; albumin < 35 g/l: 91%). Eight (73%) patients had either a BMI < 20 or weight loss of >10% within 3 months prior to referral. Radiation enteritis was diagnosed by preoperative radiology, laparotomy and at histopathology. All patients underwent surgery (resection/ilesotomy/bypass) and median post-operative stay was 24 days.

CONCLUSIONS

Radiation enteritis is associated with prolonged symptoms. Majority of patients are undernourished and despite nutritional support a high morbidity is noted.

Operative and long term results after surgery for chronic radiation enteritis

BACKGROUND

About one third of patients with chronic radiation enteritis will need to be operated on during follow-up. Morbidity and life expectancy after resection and conservative surgical management for chronic radiation enteritis have not been well documented.

METHODS

From 1984 to 1994, 109 patients were operated on with a mean follow-up of 40 months (range 1 to 293). Postoperative mortality, early and late morbidity, long-term survival were studied in patients after resection (n = 65) and after conservative surgical management (n = 42), and in patients after planned or emergency procedure. Existence of possible risk factors for reoperation after a first surgical procedure was analyzed.

RESULTS

Five (5%) patients died in the postoperative course. Operative mortality was significantly higher when the procedure was performed as an emergency (P <0.05). Although not statistically significant, mortality was higher in the resection group (5% versus 0%). Thirty-three (30%) patients experienced postoperative complications including anastomotic leak in 11. Morbidity was not statistically related to the nature of the treatment (ie, conservative versus resection) or to the indication (emergency versus elective). During follow-up, reoperation was required in 40% of the patients, because of recurrence of digestive symptoms suggestive of chronic radiation enteritis; the reoperation rate was higher in the patients of the conservative group (50% versus 34%). Overall survival, after a mean follow-up of 40 months in patients without cancer recurrence was 85% at 1 year and 69% at 5 years after surgery, respectively. Overall survival was influenced by the nature of the treatment with 51% and 71% 5-year survival after conservative and resection treatment, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite high initial mortality and morbidity rates, life expectancy in patients with chronic radiation enteritis without recurrence of their previous neoplastic disease was good. Resection seems to provide a smaller reoperation rate and a better 5-year survival, but a higher postoperative mortality.

Aggressive initial surgery for chronic radiation enteritis: long-term results of resection vs non-resection in 44 consecutive cases

OBJECTIVE

One third of patients with chronic radiation enteritis will require surgery. There is, however, no consensus on the best surgical strategy. The long-term results of intestinal resection vs a `conservative' procedure, including stoma, bypass, and/or adhesiolysis, were reviewed with special reference to reoperation rates and the ultimate need for long-term parenteral nutrition.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Forty-four patients operated for chronic radiation enteritis were divided into two groups: Group I resection (n = 21) and Group II conservative (n = 23). Twenty patients had received preoperative total parenteral nutrition, 16 (76%) in the resection group vs four (17%) in the conservative group (P < 0.001). In the resection group, intestinal resection was combined with a stoma in six patients. In the conservative group, 10 patients underwent adhesiolysis, five a bypass procedure, and eight diverting stoma.

RESULTS

Post-operative mortality was similar in both groups (9.5% vs 8.5%). Mean follow up was 53 and 55 months for Group I and Group II, respectively. The reoperation rate was significantly lower in Group I: 9 (47%) vs 19 (86%), P < 0.01. Although not significant, the ultimate need for long-term parenteral nutrition rate was lower in Group I than in Group II: 6 (32%) vs 10 (48%).

CONCLUSION

Resection resulted in better treatment outcomes than `conservative' surgery for chronic radiation enteritis.

The incidence and clinical consequences of treatment-related bowel injury

OBJECTIVE

To assess the frequency and clinical features of treatment-induced bowel injury in rectal carcinoma patients receiving perioperative external beam radiotherapy (EBRT). The frequency of and factors associated with treatment-induced intestinal injury have previously not been well quantified for rectal cancer patients. Postoperative adjuvant chemoirradiation is recommended for Stage II and III rectal cancers, making such data of significant interest.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

The records of 386 consecutive patients undergoing radiotherapy with or without chemotherapy (CT) for rectal carcinoma between 1981-90 were reviewed. Eight-two patients were excluded for receiving nontherapeutic EBRT or modalities other than EBRT.

RESULTS

Symptomatic acute treatment-related enteritis (within 30 days of EBRT +/- CT) was diagnosed in 13 patients, 3 of whom developed chronic bowel injury. Chronic treatment-related enteritis was identified in 18 patients and reoperation was required in 17 (5% of the 304 patients with complete follow-up). Chronic proctitis was documented in 38 patients, including 3 patients with small bowel injury. The probability of developing treatment-induced bowel injury at 5 years following treatment was 19%. Variables associated with an increased risk of bowel injury using multivariate analysis were transanal excision (p = 0.002), escalating radiation dose (p = 0.005), and increasing age (p = 0.01). Twenty of the affected patients required operative treatment, and 2 deaths resulted from treatment-induced enteritis.

CONCLUSION

Patients with rectal carcinoma treated with EBRT +/- CT have the risk of developing treatment-induced bowel injury. The pelvic radiation dose should be limited to < or = 5040 cGy unless small bowel can be displaced. Reperitonealization of the pelvis, or other surgical methods of excluding the small intestine should be used whenever possible.

Effect of radiotherapy on anorectal function in patients with cervical cancer

PURPOSE

The acute and long-term effects of pelvic radiation on defecation were studied.

METHOD

Anorectal function was assessed based on manometry and subjective symptoms in 31 patients with cervical cancer treated by radiotherapy alone. Sixteen of 31 patients were examined periodically before, during, and after radiotherapy (early group). Fifteen others were examined more than six months after completion of radiotherapy (late group).

RESULTS

One-third of patients in both groups had symptoms, mainly diarrhea and increased stool frequency. Patients in the late group also suffered from disturbed gas-stool discrimination, urgency, a sense of residual stool, and soiling. Anal canal resting pressure was significantly higher after radiotherapy (47 +/- 15.5 mmHg) than before radiotherapy (36.3 +/- 12.5 mmHg; P < 0.05). The maximum tolerable volume decreased with radiation, from 163.3 +/- 45 before to 119.2 +/- 41.4 ml during, 112.7 +/- 36.6 ml immediately after, and 94.6 +/- 34.4 ml in the late group (P < 0.01). Rectal compliance also decreased over time and was lower in the early group (before, 5.7 +/- 1.3 ml/mmHg; P < 0.01; during, 4.6 +/- 2.2 ml/mmHg, P < 0.01; after, 3.7 +/- 1.4 ml/mmHg; P < 0.05) than the late group (2.1 +/- 1.5 ml/mmHg) and lower before than after in the early group (P < 0.01). Although rectal pressure initiating continuous desire to defecate did not change, the maximum tolerable pressure was significantly higher in the late group (81 +/- 19.5 mmHg) than during (59 +/- 16.8 mmHg) or after (59.9 +/- 16.9 mmHg) radiotherapy in the early group (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Radiation reduces the capacity of the rectal reservoir, even in asymptomatic patients. These changes develop during radiotherapy and progress over time.

Effect of rectal dilation in fecal incontinence with low rectal compliance. Report of a case

PURPOSE

This study was undertaken to determine the effect of rectal dilation in a patient with urge-type fecal incontinence and frequent bowel movements associated with low rectal compliance and capacity.

METHOD

Daily rectal balloon dilation was performed for a period of four weeks.

RESULTS

The patient regained complete fecal continence with one to two daily bowel movements. Rectal compliance, capacity, and cross-sectional area increased by 37 to 136 percent. Nine months later the patient was still without symptoms.

CONCLUSION

Rectal balloon dilation may be a therapeutic alternative in selected patients.

Chronic effects of pelvic radiation therapy on anorectal function

PURPOSE

The long-term effect of 4,500 cGy of preoperative radiation on anorectal function has not been prospectively evaluated.

METHODS

Anal manometry was performed on 20 patients with rectal carcinoma before and four weeks after receiving 4,500 cGy of external radiotherapy. Four patients underwent proctectomies, three died, and three refused follow-up. Ten patients were available for long-term follow-up and underwent anal manometry at 14 to 42 (average, 35.5) months after initial radiotherapy.

RESULTS

No significant difference in mean maximum squeeze or resting pressures was found after radiation therapy. The sphincter profile and minimum sensory threshold were unchanged. The rectoanal inhibitory reflex was present in all patients. Nine patients reported normal anal function. One patient who was incontinent before treatment remained incontinent.

CONCLUSION

Preoperative radiation therapy has a minimal chronic effect on anorectal function. Incontinence after sphincter-saving operations for rectal cancer should not be attributed to preoperative radiation therapy.

Early effect of external beam radiation therapy on the anal sphincter: a study using anal manometry and transrectal ultrasound

The early of pelvic irradiation on the anal sphincter has not been previously investigated. This study prospectively evaluated the acute effect of preoperative radiation on anal function. Twenty patients with rectal carcinoma received 4,500 cGy of preoperative external beam radiation. The field of radiation included the sphincter in 10 patients and was delivered above the anorectal ring in 10 patients. Anal manometry and transrectal ultrasound were performed before and four weeks after radiotherapy. No significant difference in mean maximal squeeze or resting pressure was found after radiation therapy. An increase in mean minimal sensory threshold was significant. Histologic examination revealed minimal radiation changes at the distal margin in 8 of 10 patients who underwent low anterior resection and in 1 of 3 patients who underwent abdominoperineal resection. We conclude that preoperative radiation therapy has minimal immediate effect on the anal sphincter and is not a major contributing factor to postoperative incontinence in patients after sphincter-saving operations for rectal cancer.

The prognostic importance of site and type of radiation-induced bowel injury in patients requiring surgical management

A multivariate analysis was performed to determine the outcome, and factors prognostic for outcome, in 57 patients requiring surgical intervention for radiation bowel injury. The actuarial 2- and 5-year cause-specific survival (CSS) was 76 and 74%, respectively, with a median follow-up of 62 months for the survivors. The median time from surgery to death from complications was 4 months. Identified sites of injury were both large and small bowel. The types of injury were defined as stricture, perforation, inflammation, and fistula. At surgery 9 patients had more than one site, and 15 patients had more than one type of injury. Cox proportional hazards regression models relating survival to individual patient characteristics were constructed using surgical procedure, radiation-surgery interval, age, stage, radiotherapy technique and dose, and the individual sites and types of injuries. Only the site of injury was found to be of prognostic significance for CSS (P less than 0.03). However, when the site and type of injury were recoded as single or multiple, Cox regression analysis found both the site (P = 0.008) and the type (P = 0.02) of injury to be statistically significant for CSS (favoring single sites and types). Stepwise multivariate regression analysis found type of injury to be insignificant when site of injury was already in the model. Ileal damage was associated with the lowest CSS of any single site of injury (56%) and also appeared to be responsible for the poor CSS of those with multiple sites of injury (46%).

Late radiation injury of the colon and rectum. Surgical management and outcome

After a median latency of 2 years, the initial late colorectal radiation injuries in 182 patients were: stricture (37 percent), minor lesions (36 percent), rectovaginal fistula (22 percent), and gangrene or other fistulas (5 percent). Due to progression, new colorectal injuries, primarily stricture (55 percent) and fistula (42 percent), occurred in 68 patients (37 percent). Resection provided the best results. However, the resectability rate was low (46 percent) and resection was primarily performed in patients with a circumscript well-defined stricture of the proximal rectum or sigmoid colon with an anastomotic leakage rate of 5 percent. The prevailing management of 78 patients with fistula or stricture with synchronous fistula was defunctioning colostomy, primarily end-sigmoidostomy, providing fair results in half of the patients. Stomal complications occurred in 15 percent. The radiation-induced colorectal mortality was 8 percent. Colorectal fistula and associated radiation injuries of the urinary tract, and especially of the small bowel, were the major determinants of fatal outcome, yielding an overall radiation-induced mortality of 25 percent. After a median observation time of 13 years, half of the patients were alive at follow-up; 56 percent of these had a fair outcome whereas the remaining patients continued to have mild symptoms responding to conservative measures (34 percent) or disabling symptoms (10 percent).

Chronic radiation enteritis: a community hospital experience

A retrospective study was undertaken to evaluate the operative management of patients with chronic radiation enteropathy. Thirty-eight affected patients from 1974 to 1986 were reviewed. Patients with recurrent cancer responsible for symptoms were excluded. Seventy-one percent of patients presented with bowel obstruction. Twenty-one patients were treated with bowel resection, while 17 were treated with a bypass procedure or diverting ostomy alone. Overall morbidity was 45%, and postoperative mortality was 16%. Patients in the bypass group were significantly older than those in the resection group (70.3 vs. 55.5 years, P = .024), suggesting that age may have been a determinant of the procedure performed. In our study there was no difference in outcome based on preexisting vascular disease, tumor site, type of procedure performed, or radiation dose. We conclude that resection is the procedure of choice in cases of chronic radiation enteritis requiring surgery except in cases with dense adhesions when enteroenterostomal bypass is a viable alternative.

Surgical therapy of radiation-induced lesions of the colon and rectum

Thirty-six operations for late sequelae of radiotherapy were carried out in 31 patients from 1971 to 1986. The most frequent indications for surgery were stricture (58 percent) and fistula (29 percent). In the first 8 year period from 1971 through 1978, 13 of 14 operations were diversions (colostomy or by-pass). From 1979 through 1986, a more aggressive approach prevailed. Only 32 percent of the operations were diversions. This more aggressive strategy was accompanied by a decrease of the postoperative mortality rate from 21 percent through 1978 to 0 in the later period. The overall complication rate was 23 percent. Complications were relatively more frequent after two-layer sutured or stapled anastomoses and after resection or fistula closure without temporary colostomy. We conclude that in radiation-induced colonic and rectal lesions, diversion should be performed in patients with unproved cure of disease or tumor persistence. Resection and fistula closure can be carried out safely, and a temporary colostomy is strongly recommended.

Long-term prognosis of patients with severe radiation enteritis

One hundred thirty-six patients (median age 59 years) presented with intestinal complications of previous radiotherapy. Seventy-eight had bleeding or stricture and 58 had perforation or fistula. One hundred twenty-four patients survived for more than 3 months and were followed for a median of 4.5 years. Sixty-eight patients were free of symptoms, whereas 16 experienced operation-related complications. Twelve patients had continuing symptoms of radiation enteritis, and new radiation-induced complications developed in 28. Sixteen of 51 patients with perforation or fistula had new complications compared with 12 of 73 patients with bleeding of stricture (p = 0.05). Overall, 57 patients died during the study. Thirteen died from radiation-induced complications and 27, from recurrent malignancy. Radiation deaths occurred in the postoperative period but had no impact on long-term survival. Life expectancy was poorer in patients presenting with perforation or fistula compared with bleeding or stricture, the main reason being significantly more recurrences among patients with fistulas (p less than 0.05).

Surgical treatment of intestinal radiation injury

A review of 43 consecutive patients requiring operation for serious intestinal radiation injury was undertaken to elucidate the efficacy of surgical treatment. The most common site of radiation injury was the rectum (19 cases), followed by the small bowel (13 cases), the colon (7 cases), and the combination of these (4 cases). The overall operative mortality was 14%; morbidity, 47%; and the postoperative symptom-free period, 18 +/- 30 months. Colostomy (N = 20) carried the lowest risk of mortality, 0%, as compared with resection (N = 17) and bypass procedure (N = 6), which were accompanied by the mortalities of 24% and 33%, respectively. During the follow-up (3-13 years) 12 patients (28%) died of recurrent cancer and 9 patients (21%) of persistent radiation injury, which yielded an overall mortality of 65% after resection and 50% and 65% after bypass and colostomy procedures, respectively. Continuing radiation damage led to 15 late reoperations. Ten of these were performed after colostomy, four after resection, and one after bypass. We conclude that colostomy cannot be regarded as a preferred operative method, because it does not prevent the progression of radiation injury and because it is, for this reason, associated with a higher late-complication rate. A more radical surgery is recommended but with the limitation that the operative method must be adapted to the operative finding.

Natural history and surgical management of radiation enteritis

Radiation enteritis is an increasing problem. The effect of ionizing radiation is due to a direct effect on proliferating cells and due to a progressive obliterative vasculitis. Predisposing factors include the dose of radiation, combination with chemotherapy, previous operations and vascular disease. Management is related to the stage of disease at presentation, and tailored to the clinical problem. Surgical management must take into account the poor healing associated with irradiated intestine.

Medical management of radiation enteritis--an algorithmic guide

An algorithmic guide to the differential diagnosis and management of late radiation enteritis is proposed. The proposition is based on physiological principles and clinical experience rather than on published reports. Too few patients with late radiation enteritis are seen in most oncology centres for a large prospective trial of the algorithm to be set up, but we hope it will stimulate further investigation.

Late results of mucosal proctectomy and colo-anal sleeve anastomosis for chronic irradiation rectal injury

Ten patients with severe chronic irradiation injury to the rectum were treated by mucosal proctectomy and colo-anal sleeve anastomosis. The indications were: recurrent rectal bleeding (five), stricture (three), fistula (one) and intractable pain (one). Overall follow-up has ranged from 8 to 77 months (mean 40 months). In the present survivors (n = 7) the follow-up ranges from 18 to 77 months (mean 52 months). Six patients have been followed up for more than 3 years and four for more than 5 years. There was no operative mortality. Three anastomotic strictures occurred but the protecting stoma could be closed in all but one patient. Continence was acceptable although urgency and frequency of defaecation were troublesome symptoms. The operation is recommended for life-threatening, haemorrhagic chronic irradiation injury to the rectum.

Function of the anal sphincters after chronic radiation injury

Anorectal manometry was done in 10 men with chronic radiation proctitis and symptoms of urgency, frequency, and occasional incontinence of faeces. They were compared with 10 asymptomatic age and sex-matched controls. The maximum resting anal canal pressure and the physiological sphincter length were significantly lower (p less than 0.01) in the irradiated group. The rectosphincteric reflex was absent in one patient and showed abnormalities of recovery in four others, who had received radiotherapy. The squeeze pressure of the external sphincter was not significantly different. These results indicate that dysfunction of the internal anal sphincter may contribute to patients' anorectal symptoms after pelvic radiotherapy. Histological evidence suggests that damage to the myenteric plexus is mainly responsible. The manometric function of the external sphincter remains relatively unaffected.

Anorectal function following colo-anal sleeve anastomosis for chronic radiation injury to the rectum

Anorectal manometry and electrophysiological studies of the pelvic floor were performed in eight patients who had undergone anterior resection of the rectum with mucosal proctectomy and colo-anal sleeve anastomosis for radiation rectal injury. There is a severe reduction in the compliance of the neorectum and in the maximal tolerable volume. Maximum basal anal canal pressure and physiological sphincter length are also significantly reduced although the 'squeeze' pressure of the external anal sphincter and the latency of the pudendo-anal reflex were unaffected. Four patients had an absent rectosphincteric reflex, four patients involuntarily expelled the test balloon at the maximal tolerable volume during a proctometrogram and four patients demonstrated increased EMG activity of the pelvic floor on straining and on rectal distension. These abnormalities help to explain many of the patients' symptoms. Histological abnormalities of the myenteric plexus were a prominent feature in all the excised specimens and may be responsible for some of the functional abnormalities.

Correlation of clinical and manometric abnormalities of rectal function following chronic radiation injury

Continuous fluid-inflation proctometrograms were performed in men with the symptoms of chronic radiation proctitis and in age and sex-matched control subjects (n = 10). Rectal volumes and compliance were measured. There was a significant reduction in the rectal volumes at sensory threshold, constant sensation and maximal tolerance and in rectal compliance (P less than 0.01). Comparable pressure measurements did not demonstrate significant differences. The maximum tolerable volume, symptomatic and sigmoidoscopic scoring correlated to rectal compliance (r = 0.77, -0.8, -0.73; P less than 0.01, less than 0.01, less than 0.02, respectively). Reduction in volume and compliance is often not obvious radiologically. Histological evidence suggests that smooth muscle hypertrophy and myenteric plexus damage are contributory.