Total cytokine immunoassay: a more accurate method of cytokine measurement?

The Tolerance Model of Non-Inflammatory Immune Competence in Acute Pediatric Malnutrition: Origins, Evidence, Test of Fitness and Growth Potential

The tolerance model rests on the thesis of a physiologically regulated, albeit unsustainable, systemic attempt to adapt to the catabolic challenge posed by acute prepubescent malnutrition even in its severe forms. The model centers on the immunological component of the attempt, positing reorientation toward a non-inflammatory form of competence in place of the classic paradigm of immunological attrition and exhaustion. The foundation of the model was laid in 1990, and sixteen years later it was articulated formally on the basis of a body of evidence centered on T cell cytokines and interventions with cytokine and hormonal mediators. The benefit originally suggested was a reduced risk of autoimmune pathologies consequent to the catabolic release of self-antigens, hence the designation highlighting immune tolerance. Herein, the emergence of the tolerance model is traced from its roots in the recognition that acute malnutrition elicits an endocrine-based systemic adaptive attempt. Thereafter, the growth of the evidence base supporting the model is outlined, and its potential to shed new light on existing information is tested by application to the findings of a published clinical study of acutely malnourished children. Finally, some knowledge gaps pertinent to the model are identified and its potential for growth consonant with evolving perceptions of immunobiology is illustrated.

Elevated Bioactivity of the Tolerogenic Cytokines, Interleukin-10 and Transforming Growth Factor-β, in the Blood of Acutely Malnourished Weanling Mice

The main objective of this investigation was to determine the influence of acute deficits of protein and energy on the blood levels of interleukin-10 (IL-10) and transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β), physiologically the main anti-inflammatory and tolerogenic cytokines. In four 14-day experiments, male and female C57BL/6J mice, initially 19 days old, consumed a complete purified diet either ad libitum or in restricted daily quantities, or had free access to an isocaloric purified low-protein diet. A zero-time control group (19 days old) was included. In the first two experiments, serum IL-10 levels were assessed by sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and bioassay. The mean serum IL-10 bioactivities were higher (P ≤ 0.05) in both malnourished groups (low-protein and restricted intake: 15.8 and 12.2 ng/ml, respectively) than in the zero-time and age-matched control groups (6.3 and 7.3 ng/ml, respectively), whereas serum IL-10 immunoactivity was high only in the restricted intake group (e.g., second experiment: 17.0 pg/ml vs. 5.4, 3.7, and 3.1 pg/ml in the zero-time control, age-matched control and low-protein group, respectively). The third and fourth experiments centered on plasma TGF-β immunoactivity (sandwich ELISA) and bioactivity, respectively. The ELISA revealed a high mean plasma TGF-β1 level (P < 0.05) in the low-protein group only, but TGF-β bioactivity (β1 isoform, although 15% β2 in the restricted intake group) was high in both malnourished groups (8.7 and 9.3 ng/ml in the low-protein and restricted groups, respectively) relative to the age-matched control group (0.5 ng/ml). Thus, metabolically distinct weanling systems mimicking marasmus and incipient kwashiorkor both exhibit a blood cytokine profile that points to a tolerogenic microenvironment within immune response compartments. A model emerges in which malnutrition-associated immune competence, at least in advanced weight loss, centers on cytokine-mediated peripheral tolerance that reduces the risk of catabolically induced autoimmune disease, but this is at the cost of attenuated responsiveness to infectious agents.

Evidence that periodontal treatment improves biomarkers and CVD outcomes

AIM

The aim of this review was to critically appraise the evidence on the impact of periodontal treatment of cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) biomarkers and outcomes.

METHODS

A systematic search was performed in Cinhal, Cochrane, Embase and Medline for relevant articles up to July 2012. Duplicate screening and reference hand searching were performed. Data were then summarized and evidence graded in tables.

RESULTS

The search resulted in: (a) no evidence on the effects of periodontal therapy on subclinical atherosclerosis, serum levels of CD40 ligand, serum amyloid A and monocyte chemoattractant protein-1, (b) limited evidence on the effects of periodontal therapy on arterial blood pressure, leucocyte counts, fibrinogen, tissue necrosis factor-α, sE-selectin, von Willebrand factors, d-dimers, matrix metalloproteinases, oxidative stress and CVD events, and (c) moderate evidence suggesting a negligible effect of periodontal therapy in reducing interleukin-6 and lipids levels, whilst a positive effect in reducing serum C-reactive protein levels and improving endothelial function.

CONCLUSIONS

Periodontal therapy triggers a short-term inflammatory response followed by (a) a progressive and consistent reduction of systemic inflammation and (b) an improvement in endothelial function. There is however limited evidence that these acute and chronic changes will either increase or reduce CVD burden of individuals suffering from periodontitis in the long term.

Evidence that periodontal treatment improves biomarkers and CVD outcomes

AIM

The aim of this review was to critically appraise the evidence on the impact of periodontal treatment of cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) biomarkers and outcomes.

METHODS

A systematic search was performed in Cinhal, Cochrane, Embase and Medline for relevant articles up to July 2012. Duplicate screening and reference hand searching were performed. Data were then summarized and evidence graded in tables.

RESULTS

The search resulted in: (a) no evidence on the effects of periodontal therapy on subclinical atherosclerosis, serum levels of CD40 ligand, serum amyloid A and monocyte chemoattractant protein-1, (b) limited evidence on the effects of periodontal therapy on arterial blood pressure, leucocyte counts, fibrinogen, tissue necrosis factor-a, sE-selectin, von Willebrand factors, d-dimers, matrix metalloproteinases, oxidative stress and CVD events, and (c) moderate evidence suggesting a negligible effect of periodontal therapy in reducing interleukin-6 and lipids levels, whilst a positive effect in reducing serum C-reactive protein levels and improving endothelial function.

CONCLUSIONS

Periodontal therapy triggers a short-term inflammatory response followed by (a) a progressive and consistent reduction of systemic inflammation and (b) an improvement in endothelial function. There is however limited evidence that these acute and chronic changes will either increase or reduce CVD burden of individuals suffering from periodontitis in the long term.

Cytokines as biomarkers in rheumatoid arthritis

RA is a complex disease that develops as a series of events often referred to as disease continuum. RA would benefit from novel biomarker development for diagnosis where new biomarkers are still needed (even if progresses have been made with the inclusion of ACPA into the ACR/EULAR 2010 diagnostic criteria) and for prognostic notably in at risk of evolution patients with autoantibody-positive arthralgia. Risk biomarkers for rapid evolution or cardiovascular complications are also highly desirable. Monitoring biomarkers would be useful in predicting relapse. Finally, predictive biomarkers for therapy outcome would allow tailoring therapy to the individual. Increasing numbers of cytokines have been involved in RA pathology. Many have the potential as biomarkers in RA especially as their clinical utility is already established in other diseases and could be easily transferable to rheumatology. We will review the current knowledge's relation to cytokine used as biomarker in RA. However, given the complexity and heterogeneous nature of RA, it is unlikely that a single cytokine may provide sufficient discrimination; therefore multiple biomarker signatures may represent more realistic approach for the future of personalised medicine in RA.

[Kidney injury and multiple trauma: outcome, course and treatment algorithm. An organ-specific evaluation of 835 patients from the trauma register of the DGU]

BACKGROUND

The relevance of renal trauma in severely injured patients within a large collective has not yet been thoroughly reviewed. This study aimed at assessing the prevalence of renal trauma in relation to the outcome and the currently established method of treatment.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Altogether data of 35,664 patients of the TraumaRegister of the German Society of Trauma Surgery (DGU) (1996-2007) were interpreted retrospectively. All patients with an injury severity score (ISS) ≥16, direct admission to a trauma center and an age of ≥16 years were included. All patients with abdominal trauma (AIS(Abdomen) ≥2) were compared with patients with abdominal and renal trauma (AIS(Kidney) ≥2).

RESULTS

A total of 18,416 patients fulfilled the inclusion criteria of which 6,218 (34.1%) had abdominal injuries. Of these patients with abdominal injury 835 (13.3%) additionally showed a kidney injury (AIS(Abdomen) ≥2, AIS(Kidney) 2-5) and were analyzed according to the classification of the American Association for the Surgery of Trauma (AAST) organ-severity-score. AAST kidney: II°: 45.5%, III°: 31.1%, IV°: 15.6%, V°: 7.8%. Patients with leading kidney injury (grade IV and V) thereby showed a significant increase in mortality (IV: 32.3% and V: 40.0%) and an increase in the need for surgical intervention (IV: 61.5 and V: 81.5%). With an increasing grade of renal injury, however, the ISS is also increased but mortality was not increased over the expected mortality rate (RISC score) due to the additional renal injury. Dialysis rate in the surviving patients showed an increased rate depending on the degree of the kidney injury (II: 5.5%, III: 7.6%, IV: 18.8%, V: 8.3%).

CONCLUSION

The results presented here show the prevalence and the outcome of kidney injury in a large collective within the TraumaRegister of the DGU for the first time. Based on the current literature and the findings a treatment algorithm has been developed.

Abdominal vascular trauma in 760 severely injured patients

PURPOSE

The relevance of abdominal vascular injuries in polytraumatic patients within a large collective has not yet been thoroughly analyzed. This study aimed at assessing the prevalence of traumatic injuries in relation to outcome and currently established treatment options.

METHODS

51,425 patients from the Trauma Registry of the German Society of Trauma Surgery (TR DGU) (1993-2009) were analyzed retrospectively. All patients who had an Injury Severity Score (ISS) of ≥16, were directly admitted to a trauma center and subsequently received treatment for at least three days, were ≥16 years old, and had an abdominal injury (AISabdomen ≥2) were included. Patients with abdominal trauma (AISabdomen ≥2) were compared with patients with additional vascular trauma (AISvascular 2-5).

RESULTS

10,530 (20.5 %) of the 51,425 patients had documented abdominal injury. 760 (7.2 %) of the patients with abdominal injury additionally showed abdominal vascular injury (AISabdomen ≥2, AISvascular 2-5) and were analyzed based on the classification of the American Association for the Surgery of Trauma (AAST) organ severity score (AAST vascular injury grade: II, 2.4 %; III, 2.7 %; IV, 1.8 %; V, 0.2 %. Patients with high-grade abdominal vascular injury (grades IV and V) showed a significant increase in mortality (IV, 44.6 %; V, 60 %) and consequently a decrease in the need for surgical intervention (IV, 67.4 %; V, 64 %).

CONCLUSIONS

The results presented here show the prevalence and outcome of abdominal vascular injuries in a large collective within the TR DGU for the first time. Based on the current literature and these findings, a treatment algorithm has been developed.

Efficient clearance of early apoptotic cells by human macrophages requires M2c polarization and MerTK induction

Mer tyrosine kinase (MerTK) is a major macrophage apoptotic cell (AC) receptor. Its functional impairment promotes autoimmunity and atherosclerosis, whereas overexpression correlates with poor prognosis in cancer. However, little is known about mechanisms regulating MerTK expression in humans. We found that MerTK expression is heterogenous among macrophage subsets, being mostly restricted to anti-inflammatory M2c (CD14(+)CD16(+)CD163(+)CD204(+)CD206(+)CD209(-)) cells, differentiated by M-CSF or glucocorticoids. Small numbers of MerTK(+) "M2c-like" cells are also detectable among circulating CD14(bright)CD16(+) monocytes. MerTK expression levels adapt to changing immunologic environment, being suppressed in M1 and M2a macrophages and in dendritic cells. Remarkably, although glucocorticoid-induced differentiation is IL-10 independent, M-CSF-driven M2c polarization and related MerTK upregulation require IL-10. However, neither IL-10 alone nor TGF-β are sufficient to fully differentiate M2c (CD16(+)CD163(+)MerTK(+)) macrophages. M-CSF and IL-10, both released by T lymphocytes, may thus be required together to promote regulatory T cell-mediated induction of anti-inflammatory monocytes-macrophages. MerTK enables M2c macrophages to clear early ACs more efficiently than other macrophage subsets, and it mediates AC clearance by CD14(bright)CD16(+) monocytes. Moreover, M2c cells release Gas6, which in turn amplifies IL-10 secretion via MerTK. IL-10-dependent induction of the Gas6/MerTK pathway may, therefore, constitute a positive loop for M2c macrophage homeostasis and a critical checkpoint for maintenance of anti-inflammatory conditions. Our findings give new insight into human macrophage polarization and favor a central role for MerTK in regulation of macrophage functions. Eliciting M2c polarization can have therapeutic utility for diseases such as lupus, in which a defective AC clearance contributes to initiate and perpetuate the pathological process.

[Significance of liver trauma for the incidence of sepsis, multiple organ failure and lethality of severely injured patients. An organ-specific evaluation of 24,771 patients from the trauma register of the DGU]

BACKGROUND

The prognosis of multiple injured patients is mainly limited by initial severe hemorrhage causing hemorrhagic shock, subsequent sepsis and multiple organ failure (MOF). Although mechanisms of altered microcirculation, cytokine release etc. have been intensively investigated, little is known about the relevance of severe liver trauma as an independent predictive outcome factor in these patients. This study aimed to clarify the impact of severe liver trauma in one of the largest trauma databases.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The study was based on data from the German trauma register within the German Society for Trauma Surgery (DGU) and 24,711 patients from 113 hospitals were collected for retrospective analysis between 1993 and 2005. Patients with an injury severity score (ISS) >16, no isolated head injury and primary admission to a trauma center were included. Data were allocated according to the injury pattern into I liver group (severe damage of the liver, AIS>3 and AIS abdomen <3), II Abdomen group (severe abdominal trauma AIS>3, AIS liver <3) and III Control group (liver and/or abdominal trauma AIS<3, other trauma AIS>3).

RESULTS

Out of 24,771 multiple injured patients from 113 trauma centers, 321 individuals were identified which matched the criteria of the liver group. Another 574 patients were allocated to the abdomen group while the majority of patients formed the trauma group (9574). Severe injury of the liver is associated with excessive demands for volume resuscitation and induces a significantly increased risk for sepsis and MOF compared to both other groups (sepsis 19.9% vs 11%; MOF 32.7% vs 16.6%). Furthermore, deleterious outcome is more frequent associated with patients with severe liver trauma (lethality 34.9%) compared to severe abdominal trauma (12%) and the control group (19.5%).

CONCLUSIONS

Severe liver trauma is an independent predictor for severe hemorrhage with a substantial increased risk of sepsis, MOF and trauma-related death. While conservative treatment of patients with severe liver trauma but no hemorrhage is effective, patients with hemodynamic instability seem to form a subgroup where contemporary treatment modalities are not yet sufficient.

Blood serum interferon-gamma bioactivity is low in weanling mice subjected to acute deficits of energy or both protein and energy

The main objective of the present study was to determine the influence of acute deficits of protein and energy on the blood serum level of interferon-gamma, a signature type 1 polarising inflammatory cytokine. In two 14 d experiments, male and female C57BL/6J mice, initial age 19 d, consumed a complete purified diet ad libitum or in restricted daily quantities, or had free access to an isoenergetic purified low-protein diet. A zero-time control group (age 19 d) was included in the second experiment. Serum interferon-gamma was assessed in both experiments by sandwich ELISA and, in the second experiment, also by a bioassay based on inhibition of proliferation by WEHI-279 B lymphoma cells. The immunoassay detected interferon-gamma inconsistently in all groups (range 0-14 pg/ml; detection limits 1 x 5 and 0 x 7 pg/ml in experiments 1 and 2, respectively). By contrast, interferon-gamma bioactivity was found in all animals of each group (means 339, 499, 124 and 200 pg/ml in zero-time controls, age-matched controls, low-protein and restricted intake groups, respectively; detection limit, 12 pg/ml), and the mean serum bioactivity of each malnourished group was low compared with the age-matched control (P <or=0 x 05). The present study defines the physiological serum interferon-gamma bioactivity of the adolescent mouse. Moreover, to the extent achievable by way of the blood, the results reflect the influence of metabolically diverse forms of acute malnutrition on the polarising type 1 cytokine profile within lymphoid microenvironments wherein immune responses arise. Therefore, the results suggest a mechanism underlying the cell-mediated inflammatory incompetence that characterises acute, prepubescent malnutrition.

What is new in cytokine research related to trauma/critical care

Cytokines are low molecular weight proteins whose production can be modified by various insults. They have the potential to modify cellular responses to these insults. Recent years have seen a plethora of research in cytokine biology in trauma and critical care.

Interleukin-10 concentration determined by sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay is unrepresentative of bioactivity in murine blood

Two experiments were performed, each using six male and six female C57BL/6J mice collectively ranging from 4 wk to 17 mo of age. Blood was obtained following CO2 anesthesia, and the IL-10 concentration of each serum sample was determined both by sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and by bioassay. In the first experiment, mean serum IL-10 immunoactivity was 9.3 pg/ml while the mean bioactivity was 700 times greater, i.e., 6.5 ng/ml. However, the bioassay required sample dilution, which might have released bound cytokine that the ELISA could also detect. In the second experiment, therefore, the ELISA was applied to samples diluted to 20% as for the bioassay. Nevertheless, the immunoassay continued to detect only a small fraction of the serum IL-10 identified by the bioassay (mean values: 32.4 pg/ml vs. 2.6 ng/ml). Although currently the preferred method, the sandwich ELISA is inappropriate for quantification of blood IL-10 concentrations. Moreover, studies of the actions of IL-10 are needed at the concentrations revealed in the blood by bioassay and currently considered supraphysiological.

Cytometric bead assay of cytokines in sepsis: A clinical evaluation

BACKGROUND

The clinical relevancy of an attractive new multiparametric method, cytometric beads assay (CBA), was evaluated for the monitoring of cytokines in sepsis.

METHODS

A total of 52 samples (26 patients) were simultaneously tested by CBA and chemiluminescence (IL-6, IL-8, IL-1beta, and TNFalpha) or ELISA (IL-10, IL-12 p40, IL-12 p70, and soluble TNFalpha-RI).

RESULTS

CBA standard curves were linear from 20-5,000 ng/L except for IL-1beta (40-5,000 ng/L). IL-6 and IL-8 were detected in 41 and 48 samples (44-5,000 ng/L and 22-5,000 ng/L), respectively, and out of range in six samples. IL-10 and IL-1beta were detected in 14 and 15 samples (21-1,548 ng/L and 29-582 ng/L), respectively. TNFalpha was rarely detected, and IL-12 p70 was never detected. Accuracy and repeatability were good (CV for IL-6 was 2.1-8.7%; for IL-8 3.7-5.3%; for IL-10 2.5-9.1%; for IL-12 5.2-6.5%; for IL-1 beta 4-12%; and for TNFalpha 3-19.3%). Reproducibility of four standard curves and 20 samples (-1.1 to +1.03%) was excellent between tests done at two- to six-week intervals. CBA values were correlated (r2 > 0.89; P < 0.001) with our reference methods, but were lower on CBA (TNFalpha 45% +/- 8; IL-6 49% +/- 7), probably due to interactions with patients' serum, as confirmed by spiking diluted standards in one patient's serum with end stage renal failure and high levels of TNF soluble receptor (i.e., TNFalpha levels 34 and 21%).

CONCLUSIONS

Finally, these results suggest that IL-6, IL-8, IL-1beta, and Il-10 are clinically promising for sepsis evaluation. However, sensitivity of TNFalpha has to be improved and IL-12 p70 should be replaced with more relevant parameters such as TNF-R, procalcitonin, or neopterin.

Cytokine signatures in atherosclerotic claudicants

BACKGROUND

Iron accumulation and inflammation may affect atherosclerosis. This study intended to define a cytokine signature in atherosclerotic claudicants and to determine whether reduction in serum ferritin by phlebotomy influenced this pattern.

METHODS

Ninety-one subjects with peripheral vascular disease (PVD; mean age, 67 years) were recruited from the VA Cooperative Iron and Atherosclerosis Study (FeAST) testing the hypothesis that ferritin reduction to 25 ng/ml may ameliorate atherosclerosis. Cytokines TNF-a, IL-2, IL-6, and IL-10 were analyzed by enzyme amplified sensitivity assay (EASIA). Fasting iron and cholesterol panels, complete blood count, C-reactive protein (CRP), uric acid, fibrinogen, glucose, and hemoglobin A1c levels were also quantified. Values were compared with "healthy" controls (n = 21; mean age, 56 years). After randomization of PVD to phlebotomy (intervention group [IG], n = 44) or control (nonintervention group [NG], n = 47), analyses were compared at 6 and 12 months using t test, Wilcoxon rank sum test, chi-square, and robust MM regression.

FINDINGS

Age, glucose, and hemoglobin A1c were higher in PVD compared with healthy controls (P < 0.01), whereas serum iron (P < 0.01) and percentage of transferrin saturation (P < 0.05) were lower. Tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha; P < 0.05), IL-6 (P < 0.01), and CRP (P < 0.05) levels were higher in the PVD group, whereas IL-10 was lower (P < 0.01). At 6 months post phlebotomy, ferritin levels were reduced (P < 0.01), although ferritin levels were reduced less in smokers. IL-6 and fibrinogen, CRP and ferritin levels correlated positively. At 6 and 12 months, subjects with TNF-alpha (n= 15) and IL-6 (n = 10) levels in the upper 25th percentile were reduced by phlebotomy.

INTERPRETATION

An inflammatory cytokine signature exists in atherosclerosis. Elevated levels of TNF-alpha and IL-6, reportedly associated with recurrent and future myocardial infarction, were reduced by phlebotomy. The utility of the iron/inflammatory hypotheses will ultimately relate to clinical outcomes obtained prospectively by the FeAST trial.