Usefulness of DNA viral load quantification for cytomegalovirus disease monitoring in renal and pancreas/renal transplant recipients

Clinical utility of viral load in management of cytomegalovirus infection after solid organ transplantation

The negative impact of cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection on transplant outcomes warrants efforts toward improving its prevention, diagnosis, and treatment. During the last 2 decades, significant breakthroughs in diagnostic virology have facilitated remarkable improvements in CMV disease management. During this period, CMV nucleic acid amplification testing (NAT) evolved to become one of the most commonly performed tests in clinical virology laboratories. NAT provides a means for rapid and sensitive diagnosis of CMV infection in transplant recipients. Viral quantification also introduced several principles of CMV disease management. Specifically, viral load has been utilized (i) for prognostication of CMV disease, (ii) to guide preemptive therapy, (iii) to assess the efficacy of antiviral treatment, (iv) to guide the duration of treatment, and (v) to indicate the risk of clinical relapse or antiviral drug resistance. However, there remain important limitations that require further optimization, including the interassay variability in viral load reporting, which has limited the generation of standardized viral load thresholds for various clinical indications. The recent introduction of an international reference standard should advance the major goal of uniform viral load reporting and interpretation. However, it has also become apparent that other aspects of NAT should be standardized, including sample selection, nucleic acid extraction, amplification, detection, and calibration, among others. This review article synthesizes the vast amount of information on CMV NAT and provides a timely review of the clinical utility of viral load testing in the management of CMV in solid organ transplant recipients. Current limitations are highlighted, and avenues for further research are suggested to optimize the clinical application of NAT in the management of CMV after transplantation.

Comparison of cytomegalovirus pp-65 antigenemia assay and plasma DNA correlation with the clinical outcome in transplant recipients

The relationship between quantitative antigenemia and plasma DNAemia was studied for monitoring cytomegalovirus (CMV) viremia in CMV infection (CMVI) or disease (CMVD), in 20 transplant recipients (13 CMD, seven CMVI). A total of 142 samples of blood were assayed for CMV-DNA and pp-65 antigenemia (CMV-Ag). A quantitative correlation between both markers was found (P < 0.0001). First CMV antigenemia as well as first plasma DNA viral load was similar in CMVI and CMVD (29 vs. 24 CMV-Ag+ cells/10(5) PMN; and 7445 vs. 12407 CMV-DNA copies/ml). The maximum antigenemia was higher in CMVD than in CMVI (146 +/- 87 vs. 61 +/- 54 +cells/10(5) PMN, P < 0.05), but the highest CMV plasma viral load was similar in both groups (62592 +/- 33000 vs. 42055 +/- 38600 copies/ml). In nine patients, maximum antigenemia coincided with highest plasma DNA viral load, but in 10 highest DNAemia occurred 6 days later. On the contrary, antigenemia declined faster than CMV-DNAnemia, after treatment.

Monitoring of cytomegalovirus infection in solid-organ transplant recipients by an ultrasensitive plasma PCR assay

Early and accurate monitoring of cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection in solid-organ transplant recipients is of major importance. We have assessed the potential benefit of an ultrasensitive plasma-based PCR assay for renal transplant recipients. The pp65 CMV antigen (pp65 Ag) assay using leukocytes was employed as a routine test for the monitoring of CMV in 23 transplant recipients. We compared the pp65 antigenemia with the CMV load quantified by an ultrasensitive PCR (US-PCR) with a limit of detection of 20 CMV DNA copies/ml of plasma. CMV infection was detected in 215 (67%) of 321 plasma samples by the US-PCR compared with 124 (39%) of 321 samples by the pp65 Ag assay. The US-PCR assay permitted the detection of CMV infection episodes following transplantation a median of 12 days earlier than the pp65 Ag assay. Moreover, during CMV infection episodes, DNA detection by the US-PCR was consistently positive, whereas false negative results were frequently observed with the pp65 Ag assay. We found a good correlation between the two assays, and the peak viral loads were significantly higher in patients with CMV-related complications (median, 5000 DNA copies/ml) than in those without symptoms (1160 DNA copies/ml) (P = 0.048). In addition, patients that did not require preemptive therapy based on the results of the pp65 assay had CMV loads significantly lower (median, 36 DNA copies/ml) than those that needed treatment (median, 4703 DNA copies/ml) (P < 0.001). These observations provided cutoff levels that could be applied in clinical practice. The ultrasensitive plasma-based PCR detected CMV infection episodes earlier and provided more consistent results than the pp65 Ag assay. This test could improve the monitoring of CMV infection or reactivation in renal transplant recipients.

Association of glycoprotein B and immediate early-1 genotypes with human leukocyte antigen alleles in renal transplant recipients with cytomegalovirus infection

BACKGROUND

Numerous risk factors for cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection or disease, or both, such as serostatus of donor and recipient, immunosuppressive regimen, or intensity of viral load, have been identified in renal transplant recipients. Additional parameters may be involved, notably, genetic variability of both host and virus, which could modulate the efficacy of the immune response.

METHODS

Active CMV infection was analyzed retrospectively in 634 renal transplant recipients, according to human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-A, HLA-B, and HLA-DR alleles; CMV serostatus; presentation of the disease; and variations in the coding sequences of glycoprotein (g) B and IE1 proteins.

RESULTS

Active infection occurred in 141 of 634 patients: seropositivity of the donor and the recipient were identified as risk factors. Patients carrying the HLA-A11, HLA-A32, or HLA-DR11 allele developed active infection more frequently, whereas none of the patients with the HLA-B16 or HLA-B55 allele was actively infected. Significant independent associations between some genotypes and particular HLA alleles were observed: gB1 was more frequent in the HLA-A24 or HLA-B7 context and underrepresented in patients with HLA-DR11; gB2 was more frequent in HLA-A32 or HLA-DR11 carriers; and an increased frequency of gB3 was observed in the HLA-A29 context. Considering the IE1-2 genotype, increased frequency was noted for HLA-A3 carriers, whereas this type was underrepresented for patients with the HLA-DR11 allele.

CONCLUSION

Data strongly suggest that differential presentation of polymorphic gB or IE peptides by HLA molecules or differential recognition by host CD8+ and CD4+ T lymphocytes, or both, should modulate immunologic response and then CMV pathogenesis in renal transplant patients.

Prospective validation of quantitative polymerase chain reaction for management of cytomegalovirus disease in solid-organ transplant patients

This study evaluates the utility of quantitative polymerase chain reaction (QPCR) to determine duration of treatment of transplant patients with human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) disease. Eighteen patients with HCMV disease were prospectively evaluated and followed for recurrence using a QPCR assay. We used plasma samples from which nucleic acid was extracted. Quantification was determined by using an internal standard that contained the same primer sequences as for HCMV. During treatment, weekly QPCR assays were performed. Patients were treated with HCMV immunoglobulin-G for a finite period, but intravenous ganciclovir was continued until less than 100 viral copies (vc) per mL was detectable. After cessation of therapy, patients were followed for 6 months with monthly clinical assessment and QPCR. No patient developed recurrence of HCMV at a mean follow-up of 16 months. This preliminary study suggests that the use of QPCR to assess viral load is useful in deciding the length of HCMV treatment with ganciclovir but requires further randomized validation.

Infections in recipients of kidney transplants

A review of infections in kidney transplant recipients is presented in this article, beginning with a discussion of the pretransplant infectious diseases evaluation and an overview of the timing of infectious posttransplant, and then focusing on individual types of infection.

Quantification of cytomegalovirus (CMV) viral load by the hybrid capture assay allows for early detection of CMV disease in lung transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

We prospectively compared the hybrid capture system (HCS) assay with conventional cell culture and shell vial assay for the detection of cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection and disease in the lung transplant population.

METHODS

Between January 1999 and February 2000, 34 lung transplant patients at Loyola University Medical Center, who were considered to be at risk for CMV disease, underwent surveillance testing for CMV cell culture, shell vial assay and HCS assay according to a pre-determined schedule. In addition, bronchoscopy with bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) and transbronchial biopsy were performed at regular intervals and for clinical indications. All BAL samples were sent for CMV cultures and biopsy specimens were analyzed for histopathologic evidence of CMV by immunoperoxidase staining using antibody to early immediate nuclear antigen.

RESULTS

Ten patients developed CMV disease/syndrome during the course of the study. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value and negative predictive value were >90% for the HCS assay. The sensitivity of the HCS assay (90%) was statistically significantly higher than the sensitivity of either the SV assay (40%) or the cell culture (50%). In addition, the HCS assay was able to detect CMV 50 +/- 67 days prior to clinical evidence of CMV disease and an average of 36 days prior to the other detection techniques.

CONCLUSION

The HCS assay is a sensitive diagnostic technique able to reliably detect CMV disease earlier than other diagnostic methods in the lung transplant population. Future studies may be able to evaluate whether pre-emptive anti-viral therapy targeted to specific viral loads using the HCS assay will be beneficial in preventing morbidity associated with CMV disease.

Evaluation of the Murex CMV DNA Hybrid Capture assay (version 2.0) for early diagnosis of cytomegalovirus infection in recipients of an allogeneic stem cell transplant

Early diagnosis of CMV infection based on sensitive diagnostic assays has helped to reduce CMV-related mortality after allogeneic stem cell transplantation (SCT). In this study, the commercialized Murex CMV DNA Hybrid Capture assay (version 2.0) (HCS) was prospectively compared to an in-house CMV-DNA PCR assay from whole blood in patients after allogeneic stem cell transplantation. Overall, a high concordance between HCS and PCR was documented (kappa = 0.686; n = 385). The HCS assay was found to be as sensitive as the PCR indicating active CMV infection at a median of 35 and 34 days after transplantation, respectively. None of the HCS-negative patients developed CMV-related symptoms (negative predictive value 100%). Declining CMV DNA load in the blood was found to be an indicator for effective antiviral therapy, whereas persistence of a high viral load was associated with fatal CMV disease. In conclusion, the Hybrid Capture CMV DNA assay (v 2.0) allows early diagnosis of CMV infection after allogeneic SCT and assessment of the efficacy of antiviral therapy.

Posttransplant microbiological surveillance

Posttransplant microbiological surveillance should be used when the likelihood of infection in a transplant recipient is high and the sensitivity and specificity of the test can provide a high positive or negative predictive value. Testing is also performed in some instances to monitor the patient's response to therapy. Examples of successful posttransplant microbiological surveillance include molecular detection of cytomegalovirus and Epstein-Barr virus and virus load determinations, as well as hepatitis B and C detection and virus load testing. Routine fungal and bacterial surveillance are generally not necessary, except for Candida colonization detection or vancomycin-resistant enterococcal detection in high-risk subgroups. The organ transplanted may also play a role in the type of routine surveillance recommended.

Evaluation of CMV viral load using TaqMan CMV quantitative PCR and comparison with CMV antigenemia in heart and lung transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

Quantitative assessment of cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection using the antigenemia test has been used to monitor CMV infection in heart and lung transplant patients enabling a preemptive treatment strategy. However, the method is labour intensive, samples have to be processed within a few hours and requires skilled interpretation. A comparative prospective evaluation of a real-time TaqMan CMV quantitative PCR (QPCR) with the CMV antigenemia was undertaken.

METHODS

A real-time quantitative TaqMan CMV PCR from EDTA bloods was developed. In this study 25 heart transplant and single-lung transplant patients were monitored posttransplantation by antigenemia and TaqMan CMV QPCR. CMV DNA extracted from EDTA blood was amplified by TaqMan QPCR using primers and probe designed from the CMV glycoprotein B (gB) gene. Quantification of the genome copies is extrapolated from a standard curve generated from amplification of quantified standards.

RESULTS

Antigenaemia levels and TaqMan CMV QPCR genome copies showed a linear correlation between the two assays (R=0.843, P=0.001). A clinically significant threshold of 50 CMV pp65 antigen positive polymorphonuclear leucocytes (PMNLs) per 200 000 cells previously reported was used to extrapolate an equivalent value of 40 000 (log 4.6) genome copies per ml of blood for the TaqMan CMV QPCR.

CONCLUSIONS

The TaqMan system enables a rapid high-throughput of samples. The TaqMan CMV QPCR can be used as an accurate and robust alternative to the antigenemia test to predict CMV disease and to monitor effectiveness of treatment.

CMV infection of liver transplant recipients: comparison of antigenemia and molecular biology assays

BACKGROUND

CMV is a major clinical problem in transplant recipients. Thus, it is important to use sensitive and specific diagnostic techniques to rapidly and accurately detect CMV infection and identify patients at risk of developing CMV disease. In the present study, CMV infection after liver transplantation was monitored retrospectively by two molecular biology assays - a quantitative PCR assay and a qualitative NASBA assay. The results were compared with those obtained by prospective pp65 antigenemia determinations.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

87 consecutive samples from 10 liver transplanted patients were tested for CMV by pp65 antigenemia, and CMV monitor and NASBA pp67 mRNA assay.

RESULTS

CMV infection was detected in all patients by antigenemia and CMV monitor, whereas NASBA assay identified only 8/10 patients with viremia. Furthermore, CMV infection was never detected earlier by molecular biology assays than by antigenemia. Only 5/10 patients with CMV infection developed CMV disease. Using a cut off value of 8 cells/50,000, antigenemia was found to be the assay that better identified patients at risk of developing CMV disease. However, the kinetics of the onset of infection detected by NASBA and CMV monitor seemed to have better identified patients at risk of developing CMV disease. Furthermore, before onset of disease, CMV pp67 mRNA was found to have similar or better negative and positive predictive values for the development of CMV disease.

CONCLUSIONS

The present data, suggests that the concomitant use of antigenemia and pp67 mRNA assay gives the best identification of patients at risk of developing CMV disease.

Detection of human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) pp67-mRNA and pp65 antigenemia in relation to development of clinical HCMV disease in renal transplant recipients

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the performance of the recently introduced method based on detection of human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) pp67 mRNA in blood by the nucleic acid sequence-based amplification (NucliSens), in comparison to semiquantitative detection of pp65 HCMV antigen in white blood cells, in relation to development of clinical HCMV disease.

METHODS

Thirty patients, recipients of renal transplants, were monitored prospectively for the presence of pp67 mRNA, the presence and level of pp65 antigenemia, IgG and IgM antibodies, and the development of clinical HCMV disease. A total of 148 samples were examined during the observation period.

RESULTS

Twenty-five samples were positive for pp67-mRNA and 45 samples contained at least one pp65 positive cell, with 68% agreement between the two assays. Both assays predicted correctly the development of clinical disease in five patients, giving a sensitivity of 100%. However, the specificity of the pp67-mRNA test was 72%, and of the pp65 antigenemia test from 20 to 64%, depending on the level of antigenemia chosen for cut-off. pp67-RNA appeared somewhat earlier than pp65 antigenemia, and responded earlier to treatment. Sero-conversion and appearance of IgM antibodies were of very little clinical value.

CONCLUSION

Both the pp67-mRNA and the pp65 antigenemia assay predicted correctly the development of clinical HCMV disease in renal transplant recipients. However, the specificity of both tests with respect to development of HCMV disease, especially the pp65 antigen test was moderate. Significantly positive tests not necessarily prove the development of clinical disease. Testing for pp67-mRNA may improve the diagnosis and management of HCMV disease in renal transplant patients.

Predictive value of quantitative PCR-based viral burden analysis for eight human herpesviruses in pediatric solid organ transplant patients

Human herpesviruses can cause significant morbidity and mortality in pediatric solid organ transplant recipients. It was hypothesized that viral burden quantification by polymerase chain reaction using an internal calibration standard could aid in distinguishing between viral disease and latency. Here we report the results of a 2-year prospective study of 27 pediatric solid organ (liver, kidney, or heart) transplant recipients in which multiple samples were analyzed for levels of all eight human herpesviruses by internal calibration standard-polymerase chain reaction. Herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2, varicella-zoster virus, and Kaposi's sarcoma-associated herpesvirus were not detected in any of these samples. Human herpesvirus types 6 and 7 were detected in half of the patients, but were present at low levels, similar to those found in reference populations. Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) and cytomegalovirus (CMV) were detected in 89% and 56% of the patients, respectively. Viral burden analysis suggested distinct patient populations for CMV, with a natural cutoff of 10,000 viral targets/ml blood strongly associated with disease. In some cases, a dramatic increase in CMV levels preceded clinical evidence of disease by several weeks. EBV viral burden was relatively high in the only patient presenting with an EBV syndrome. However, two other patients without evidence of EBV disease had single samples with high EBV burden. Rapid reduction in both EBV and CMV burden occurred with antiviral treatment. These data suggest that viral burden analysis using internal calibration standard-polymerase chain reaction for CMV, and possibly other herpesviruses, is an effective method for monitoring pediatric transplant patients for significant herpesvirus infection and response to therapy.

Prediction and diagnosis of cytomegalovirus disease in renal transplant recipients using qualitative and quantitative polymerase chain reaction

BACKGROUND

Preemptive antiviral therapy against cytomegalovirus (CMV) disease after transplantation requires information from suitable laboratory markers. We examined the use of qualitative and quantitative polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to monitor renal transplant recipients.

METHODS

A cohort of 77 renal transplant recipients was monitored using an in-house and a commercial (Amplicor; Roche Diagnostic, Basel, Switzerland) PCR on leukocytes and plasma. Quantitative plasma viral load was determined using a commercial PCR kit (CMV Monitor; Roche Diagnostic). Patients were analyzed according to their pretransplantation CMV serological status (R- or R+).

RESULTS

Seventeen patients developed CMV disease after transplantation. Qualitative leukocyte PCRs had the best overall sensitivity (54-69%) and specificity (75-87%) in identifying R- recipients with CMV disease before onset. The specificities of qualitative PCRs for R+ recipients were poor and, if used, could result in unnecessary preemptive treatment in up to 50% of patients. Symptomatic and asymptomatic R+, but not R-, recipients could be distinguished using a plasma viral load of 25,000 copies/ml. An increase in viral load of >0.7 log (fivefold) per week also distinguished between symptomatic and asymptomatic R+ recipients with high sensitivity (100%) and specificity (95%).

CONCLUSIONS

Qualitative leukocyte PCRs were the best assays to predict CMV disease for R- recipients who received R+ kidneys. None of the qualitative assays could be used to guide preemptive therapy of R+ recipients, but plasma viral load and its incremental rate could be used as diagnostic tools in R+ recipients.

Comparison of two commercial methods for measurement of cytomegalovirus load in blood samples after renal transplantation

A cohort of 77 renal transplant recipients was prospectively studied for comparison of two commercially available cytomegalovirus (CMV) load assays, i.e., the COBAS AMPLICOR CMV Monitor test (Amplicor), using plasma samples, and the Murex Hybrid Capture System (HCS), using whole blood. The manufacturer of the HCS assay changed the version of the test from 1.0 (HCS-1) to 2.0 (HCS-2) after the first 37 patients had been tested. Despite the differences in principle and type of specimen used, the Amplicor and HCS assays gave comparable results. The regression line correlating the HCS-1 assay to the Amplicor assay was similar to that correlating the HCS-2 assay to the Amplicor assay. The HCS results could be converted to Amplicor-equivalent units by using linear-regression equations [log(10) HCS-1 result = 0.49 (log(10) Amplicor result) + 2.58, and log(10) HCS-2 result = 0.61 (log(10) Amplicor result) + 2.18]. The HCS-2 assay appeared to have the lowest detection limit, followed by the Amplicor assay and then the HCS-1 assay. When a sliding scale of cutoff values in Amplicor-equivalent units (>1,000, >2,500, >6,000, >16,000, >40,000, and >100,000 copies/ml) was applied to diagnose CMV disease, similar patterns of sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) were observed with the Amplicor and HCS assays. A cutoff value of >40,000 copies/ml has a low sensitivity (Amplicor, 29.4%; HCS, 41.2%) but is specific (Amplicor, 96.7%; HCS, 93.3%) and can be used for the differential diagnosis of CMV disease (PPV, 71.4% [Amplicor] or 63. 6% [HCS]; NPV, 82.9% [Amplicor] or 84.8% [HCS]). A lower cutoff value of >1,000 copies/ml improves the sensitivity (Amplicor, 76.5%; HCS, 82.4%) and has a high NPV (Amplicor, 91.8%; HCS, 94.2%) but, due to the low PPV (Amplicor, 46.2%; HCS, 56%), is useful only for exclusion of CMV disease.

Highly altered V beta repertoire of T cells infiltrating long-term rejected kidney allografts

Chronic rejection represents a major cause of long-term kidney graft loss. T cells that are predominant in long-term rejected kidney allografts (35 +/- 10% of area infiltrate) may thus be instrumental in this phenomenon, which is likely to be dependent on the indirect pathway of allorecognition only. We have analyzed the variations in T cell repertoire usage of the V beta chain at the complementary determining region 3 (CDR3) level in 18 human kidney grafts lost due to chronic rejection. We observed a strongly biased intragraft TCR V beta usage for the majority of V beta families and also a very high percentage (55%) of V beta families exhibiting common and oligoclonal V beta-C beta rearrangements in the grafts of patients with chronic rejection associated with superimposed histologically acute lesions. Furthermore, V beta 8 and V beta 23 families exhibited common and oligoclonal V beta-J beta rearrangements in 4 of 18 patients (22%). Several CDR3 amino acid sequences were found for the common and oligoclonal V beta 8-J beta 1.4 rearrangement. Quantitative PCR showed that biased V beta transcripts were also overexpressed in chronically rejected kidneys with superimposed acute lesions. In contrast, T lymphocytes infiltrating rejected allografts with chronic rejection only showed an unaltered Gaussian-type CDR3 length distribution. This pattern suggests that late graft failure associated with histological lesions restricted to Banff-defined chronic rejection does not involve T cell-mediated injury. Thus, our observation suggests that a limited number of determinants stimulates the recipient immune system in long-term allograft failure. The possibility of a local response against viral or parenchymatous cell-derived determinants is discussed.

New strategies for prevention and therapy of cytomegalovirus infection and disease in solid-organ transplant recipients

In the past three decades since the inception of human organ transplantation, cytomegalovirus (CMV) has gained increasing clinical import because it is a common pathogen in the immunocompromised transplant recipient. Patients may suffer from severe manifestations of this infection along with the threat of potential fatality. Additionally, the dynamic evolution of immunosuppressive and antiviral agents has brought forth changes in the natural history of CMV infection and disease. Transplant physicians now face the daunting task of recognizing and managing the changing spectrum of CMV infection and its consequences in the organ recipient. For the microbiology laboratory, the emphasis has been geared toward the development of more sophisticated detection assays, including methods to detect emerging antiviral resistance. The discovery of novel antiviral chemotherapy is an important theme of clinical research. Investigations have also focused on preventative measures for CMV disease in the solid-organ transplant population. In all, while much has been achieved in the overall management of CMV infection, the current understanding of CMV pathogenesis and therapy still leaves much to be learned before success can be claimed.

Monitoring human cytomegalovirus viral load in peripheral blood leukocytes of renal transplant recipients by a simple limiting dilution-PCR assay

To assess the clinical relevance of a semi-quantitative measurement of human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) DNA in renal transplant recipients within the typical clinical context of a developing country where virtually 100% of both receptors and donors are seropositive for this virus, we have undertaken HCMV DNA quantification using a simple, semi-quantitative, limiting dilution polymerase chain reaction (PCR). We evaluated this assay prospectively in 52 renal transplant patients from whom a total of 495 serial blood samples were collected. The samples scored HCMV positive by qualitative PCR had the levels of HCMV DNA determined by end-point dilution-PCR. All patients were HCMV DNA positive during the monitoring period and a diagnosis of symptomatic infection was made for 4 of 52 patients. In symptomatic patients the geometric mean of the highest level of HCMV DNAemia was 152,000 copies per 10(6) leukocytes, while for the asymptomatic group this value was 12,050. Symptomatic patients showed high, protracted HCMV DNA levels, whereas asymptomatic patients demonstrated intermittent low or moderate levels. Using a cut-off value of 100,000 copies per 10(6) leukocytes, the limiting dilution assay had sensitivity of 100%, specificity of 92%, a positive predictive value of 43% and a negative predictive value of 100% for HCMV disease. In this patient group, there was universal HCMV infection but relatively infrequent symptomatic HCMV disease. The two patient groups were readily distinguished by monitoring with the limiting dilution assay, an extremely simple technology immediately applicable in any clinical laboratory with PCR capability.

Clinical utility of a quantitative polymerase chain reaction for diagnosis of cytomegalovirus disease in solid organ transplant patients

BACKGROUND

Accurate and rapid diagnosis of human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) disease in solid organ transplant patients remains a challenge. We evaluated the clinical utility of a quantitative polymerase chain reaction (QPCR) method to diagnose transplant patients with HCMV disease.

METHODS

A total of 429 plasma samples from 121 solid organ transplant patients were prospectively collected and evaluated for HCMV using a QPCR assay. To enhance the sensitivity of the QPCR assay, plasma samples were centrifuged in a manner designed to concentrate the virions before nucleic acid extraction. Quantitation was achieved by co-amplifying an internal quantitative standard (IS) that contained the same primer sequences as for HCMV. Polymerase chain reaction products were detected by hybridization to 96-well microtiter plates coated with either a HCMV- or an IS-specific probe.

RESULTS

A total of 103 patients had all samples negative by QPCR. None of the 103 patients developed HCMV disease during the study. In contrast, 18 patients showed at least 1 sample positive by the QPCR assay, but only 8 of these developed HCMV disease. The mean viral load value for patients without HCMV disease was 93 viral copies (vc) per ml of plasma (range: 35-325 vc/ml plasma) and for the 8 patients with HCMV disease was 67,686 vc/ml plasma (range: 167-1,325,000 vc/ml plasma) (P<0.001). Using a cut-off value of 100 vc/ml plasma and clinical diagnosis of HCMV disease, the QPCR assay showed a sensitivity of 100% and specificity of 99.1%.

CONCLUSION

HCMV viral load may be useful in the diagnosis of HCMV disease in solid organ transplant patients.

Use of molecular assays in diagnosis and monitoring of cytomegalovirus disease following renal transplantation

We compared two commercial molecular assays (the Murex Hybrid Capture CMV DNA assay [HCA], version 2, and the Roche Amplicor plasma PCR assay) with a standard shell vial assay in detecting and predicting cytomegalovirus (CMV) disease in a group of renal transplant patients and assessed the role of viral load measurements (using the HCA) in their management. The sensitivity of the HCA and Amplicor assay in terms of disease detection was 100%, compared to 71% for the shell vial assay. Both the HCA and the PCR assay detected all cases of disease, at medians of 11 and 12.5 days before the onset of symptoms, respectively. Significantly higher viral loads were detected in those patients with symptoms (7.9 x 10(5) copies/ml) than in patients without symptoms (7.9 x 10(4) copies/ml; P < 0.0001). There was also a trend towards higher viral loads in those patients with primary infections (7.8 x 10(5) copies/ml) than in those patients with reactivations of CMV disease or reinfections. Successful treatment with ganciclovir was associated with a >90% reduction in viral load. Both of these new assays are sensitive and easy to use. A comparison of accurate quantitation is also useful in monitoring responses to antiviral therapy.

Use of reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction with colorimetric plate hybridization to detect a cytomegalovirus late spliced mRNA in polymorphonuclear leukocytes from renal transplant patients

Human cytomegalovirus replication was evaluated in polymorphonuclear leukocytes from ten renal transplant recipients. Three new reverse transcription polymerase chain reactions with plate hybridization suitable for automation were developed for the detection of immediate-early spliced UL123 mRNA, early-late pp65 mRNA, and late spliced UL22 mRNA. The presence of UL22mRNA was found to be significantly associated with the occurrence of cytomegalovirus (CMV) disease.

A PCR based DNA hybridisation capture system for the detection of human cytomegalovirus. A comparative study with other identification methods

A simple, sensitive and specific colourimetric hybridisation method for the detection of HCMV DNA in clinical specimens is described. This method combines a PCR assay with a sensitive sandwich hybridisation assay. It relies on the use of a specific capture probe linked covalently to polystyrene microplates and a specific polybiotinylated detection probe. Amplified DNA fragments, sandwiched between these two probes, are detected by an enzymatic colour reaction. This PCR-based colourimetric hybridisation method was compared with other known HCMV detection methods. Clinical specimens (n = 145, corresponding to 106 patients) were tested by both a nested PCR assay and this colourimetric hybridisation method; and by either the culture method or the pp65 antigenaemia test depending on the type of sample used. The results showed that the PCR-based hybridisation method has a specificity similar to tissue culture, known as the conventional gold standard method, and could be used for the examination of the clinical specimens.

Evaluation of the AmpliSensor PCR and the SHARP signal detection system for the early prediction of symptomatic CMV infection in solid transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

Cytomegalovirus (CMV) is associated with high morbidity and mortality in transplant patients. Specific antiviral treatment at an early stage of CMV infection may effectively ameliorate, but not eliminate CMV disease in these patients. Presently, the pp65 antigenemia test on peripheral leukocytes is the method most widely used for predicting and monitoring transplant patients for active CMV infection. Nucleic acid amplification methods are less well defined since they lack standardisation.

OBJECTIVE

A seminested fluorometric PCR assay (AmpliSensor-CMV, BAG, Germany) and a one-step PCR with a signal-amplification step (SHARP, Abbott, Germany) specific for the fragments of the CMV UL 122 and UL 123 genes, respectively, were evaluated for the early diagnosis of CMV infection.

DESIGN

A total of 26 recipients of heterogeneous solid organs were monitored prospectively for a median of 99 days after transplantation. By testing 371 clinical samples parallel with the pp65-antigen assay and IgM and IgG EIA assays the sensitivity, specificity, correlation and quantitation potential of both PCRs was evaluated.

RESULTS

Eight out of 26 patients developed active CMV infection. A total of 48 samples of these patients exceeded a CMV-DNA load threshold of 15 genome equivalents/10(5) leukocytes (AmpliSensor-CMV) and 41 samples exceeded the critical cut-off for the SHARP system. The AmpliSensor PCR exceeded its threshold consistently before the clinical onset of CMV disease (median 8 days). There was very good agreement between symptomatic CMV infection in patients and AmpliSensor-PCR, SHARP PCR, and pp65-antigen results (kappa-coefficient > 0.900). IgM and IgG EIA showed moderate agreement (kappa-coefficient = 0.591 and 0.552, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Both PCRs and pp65 antigen assay correlated significantly better with CMV disease than serodiagnosis. The AmpliSensor PCR allowed more precisely than the SHARP system a quantitative determination of viral load and an early and reliable prediction of active CMV infection. The use of AmpliSensor PCR may improve the diagnosis and management of active CMV infection in organ transplant recipients.

Multicenter comparison of the digene hybrid capture CMV DNA assay (version 2.0), the pp65 antigenemia assay, and cell culture for detection of cytomegalovirus viremia

We compared the Digene Hybrid Capture CMV DNA Assay version 2.0, the pp65 antigenemia assay, traditional tube culture, and shell vial culture for the detection of cytomegalovirus (CMV) viremia in several patient populations at three centers. Of 561 blood specimens collected from 402 patients, complete clinical and laboratory data were available for 489. Using consensus definitions for true positives and true negatives, the sensitivities of the Hybrid Capture assay, antigenemia, shell vial, and tube culture were 95, 94, 43, and 46%, respectively. The specificities of the Hybrid Capture assay and antigenemia were 95 and 94%, respectively. At all three study sites, the detected level of CMV viremia was significantly higher with the Hybrid Capture assay or antigenemia than with shell vial and tube culture. In a group of 131 healthy nonimmunosuppressed volunteers, the Hybrid Capture assay demonstrated a specificity of over 99%. The Hybrid Capture assay is a standardized assay that is simple to perform and can utilize whole blood specimens that have been stored for up to 48 h. The high sensitivity and specificity of the Hybrid Capture assay along with its simplicity and flexibility make it a clinically useful assay for the detection of CMV viremia in immunocompromised or immunosuppressed patients. Further evaluation to determine its role in predicting CMV disease and for monitoring the therapeutic response to anti-CMV therapy is needed.

Determination of cytomegalovirus DNA load for monitoring of cytomegalovirus disease and antiviral treatment in solid organ transplant patients, comparing limiting-dilution PCR and hybrid capture assay with cytomegalovirus isolation

OBJECTIVE: To improve the identification of patients at risk of developing cytomegalovirus (CMV) disease. MATERIALS AND METHODS: In a prospective study of 50 kidney or liver transplant patients who developed fever, 133 EDTA blood samples were analyzed, using two tests to measure CMV DNA: a 10-fold limiting dilution of an extract of 2 million leukocytes for CMV PCR, and a CMV hybrid capture assay. Both tests were compared with virus isolation, using an equivalent amount of leukocytes as a base for all three tests. RESULTS: The limiting-dilution CMV PCR and the hybrid capture assay presented relatively similar changes of sensitivity and specificity at different CMV DNA concentrations. The kinetics of the positive and negative predictive values were also comparable. A higher CMV DNA load corresponded to an increased risk of developing CMV disease. Furthermore, an increase in the endpoint dilution of a positive CMV PCR also corresponded to more severe disease. After antiviral treatment, the CMV PCR decreased by at least 100-fold (2 log10) in 10 cases and by 10-fold (1 log10) in five cases. Thus, there was a decrease in 15 of 18 (83%) patients. Similarly, with the hybrid capture assay, the amount of CMV DNA decreased about 100-fold in five patients and decreased by about 0.5 genome equivalents in five cases, i.e. in 10 of 12 (83%) patients. CONCLUSION: Both methods proved clinically useful for detecting patients at risk of developing CMV disease and for monitoring antiviral treatment in solid organ transplant patients.

Cytomegalovirus and human herpesvirus 6 both cause viral disease after renal transplantation

BACKGROUND

Systemic viral disease after renal transplantation, especially after treatment with OKT3 or antithymocyte globulin, has usually been attributed to cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection. Identification of human herpesvirus 6 (HHV6) has raised the possibility that infection or reactivation of this virus may also occur in the same setting.

METHODS

We thus examined the incidence of CMV and HHV6 infection in a prospective blinded consecutive series of 30 renal and renal/pancreas transplant patients, 22 of whom received OKT3, antithymocyte globulin, or both.

RESULTS

Clinical diagnosis of a viral syndrome was made in 15 patients. Three patients with only HHV6 DNA in urine or serum had fever and abnormal liver function but not neutropenia. All five CMV-seronegative patients who received positive kidneys developed moderate to severe disease with fever and neutropenia but also had HHV6 DNA in urine or serum. Seven CMV-seropositive patients developed disease, mostly after OKT3/antithymocyte globulin, but six shed both CMV and HHV6 in urine or serum. The simultaneous detection of both HHV6 and CMV DNA in either urine or serum was the strongest predictor of disease (and also the severity of disease), with an odds ratio of 99.0 (95% confidence intervals 5.4-1814, P<0.002).

CONCLUSION

Most systemic viral disease after renal transplantation may be due to either coinfection or reactivation of CMV and HHV6 together. A wider understanding of risk factors for severe viral disease in this setting may come from testing for both viruses in all donors and patients in both clinical practice and clinical trials.

Randomized comparison of triple therapy and antithymocyte globulin induction treatment after simultaneous pancreas-kidney transplantation

BACKGROUND

The incidence of acute rejection is considered to be higher after simultaneous pancreas-kidney (SPK) transplantation as compared to renal transplant alone. Therefore, the majority of SPK transplant recipients commonly receive a combination of cyclosporine (CsA) or tracolimus, and azathioprine or mycophenolic mofetyl, corticosteroids and/or antilymphocyte preparations. This study was designed to compare two immunosuppressive protocols for the prevention of acute rejection in patients undergoing SPK transplantation. The primary end-point was the incidence of acute rejection during the first 12 months after transplantation

METHODS

Fifty patients with type-I insulin-dependent diabetes and chronic renal failure were randomized to receive a triple drug immunosuppressive regimen including CsA, azathioprine and corticosteroids (N = 25), or the quadruple sequential combination of rabbit antithymocyte globulin (ATG) given for 10 days, azathioprine, corticosteroids and delayed CsA (N = 25). Maintenance immunosuppression (CsA and azathioprine, without corticosteroids) was similar in both arms.

RESULTS

The average follow-up was 36 months in both groups (range 9 to 60 months). No patient was excluded from the study. Although the percentage of patients with adverse events was higher in the ATG group (80 vs. 40%, P < 0.01), none of them resulted in premature discontinuation of the drug. Patients receiving ATG experienced a lower incidence (36% vs. 76%, P < 0.01) and number (13 vs. 29, P < 0.05) of acute renal rejection episodes. However, no difference was observed in patient, pancreas and kidney survival rates between groups. No case of isolated pancreas rejection was observed.

CONCLUSIONS

The quadruple sequential combination ATG, azathioprine, corticosteroid and CsA significantly reduced the one year incidence of acute renal rejection after SPK transplantation, compared to a triple immunosuppressive regimen.

A polymorphism in the major immediate-early gene delineates groups among cytomegalovirus clinical isolates

Major immediate-early gene exon 4 sequences were determined at codons 161-241 and 254-397 in 25 cytomegalovirus clinical strains and compared with those of reference strains AD169 and Towne. The nucleotide sequences at codon 161-241 segregated into three groups which could be determined by restriction mapping of a 247-nucleotide amplified target. AD169 and Towne belonged to the same group. Clustered variations and group-specific amino-acid motifs found in the deduced peptide sequence of the two immediate-early (IE) exon 4 regions raised a question is to the effects of polymorphism on IE1 function and/or immunogenicity. On the basis of restriction analysis of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) products, virus isolates were also classified into four glycoprotein B (gB) genotypes. Strain distribution in IE1 and gB genotypes showed a lack of concordance of the two grouping methods, and no preferential association was observed between the clinical context or kind of specimen and IE1 or gB groups. These data lead up to further prospective studies which could provide important information on the implication of the MIE gene region in virus pathogenesis and indicate whether linkage unbalance exists in particular clinical contexts between IE1 and gB loci.

Quantitation of cytomegalovirus: methodologic aspects and clinical applications

Cytomegalovirus (CMV) is an important pathogen in transplant recipients and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-infected individuals. Major progress has been made in developing quantitative detection methods for CMV in recent years. Due to their high sensitivity, these assays can detect CMV early, and quantitation may be useful in predicting the patient's risk for disease and in monitoring the effect of antiviral therapy. This review discusses methodological aspects of currently used quantitative assays for CMV (i.e., viral culture techniques, antigen detection assays, DNA detection assays including PCR, branched-DNA assay, and the DNA hybrid capture assay) and addresses the correlation of systemic and site-specific CMV load and CMV disease in different populations of immunosuppressed patients as well as the response to antiviral treatment. To date, direct antigen detection and molecular techniques have largely replaced traditional culture-based techniques for CMV quantitation. In general, a high systemic CMV load is correlated with CMV disease. This correlation is strong in the HIV-infected population and in solid-organ transplant recipients but less clear in allogeneic marrow transplant recipients. Measuring the viral load at specific anatomic sites may be an alternative way to assess disease activity in situations where the systemic viral load correlates poorly with disease activity. A reduction of the systemic CMV load also correlates with a response to antiviral treatment, but more research is needed to evaluate the role of viral load as a surrogate marker for drug resistance. Due to the widespread use of quantitative CMV detection techniques to direct and monitor antiviral treatment, there is a great need for an assessment of the reproducibility of test results and better standardization of the assays.

Evaluation of Murex CMV DNA hybrid capture assay for detection and quantitation of cytomegalovirus infection in patients following allogeneic stem cell transplantation

Murex hybrid capture DNA assay (HCS) is a solution hybridization antibody capture assay for detection and quantitation of cytomegalovirus (CMV) DNA in leukocytes. To determine whether CMV HCS is sensitive enough to initiate and monitor antiviral therapy after allogeneic stem cell transplantation (SCT), 51 consecutive SCT recipients were prospectively screened for the appearance of CMV infection by HCS, PCR, and culture assays from blood samples. Preemptive antiviral therapy was initiated after the second positive PCR result in all patients, as previously reported, and HCS was not considered for clinical decision making. A total of 417 samples were analyzed. Of these, 21 samples were found to be positive by PCR and HCS, 88 samples were PCR positive but HCS negative, and 308 were negative by both assays. Concordance of results between PCR and HCS and between HCS and blood culture was observed in 78.9 and 95.9% of the samples assayed, respectively. PCR was found to be more sensitive than HCS, and HCS was more sensitive than the blood culture assay (P < 0.0001). Four patients with symptomatic CMV infection were PCR positive prior to the onset of CMV-related symptoms, whereas HCS detected CMV DNA in three patients prior to and one at onset of CMV disease. The numbers of genomes per milliliter of blood were higher in patients with symptomatic CMV infection than in those with asymptomatic CMV infection (P = 0.06). None of the HCS-negative patients developed CMV disease. Thus, all patients with CMV disease were correctly identified by HCS; however, the lower sensitivity limit of the HCS assay may still be insufficient to allow diagnosis of CMV infection early enough to prevent CMV disease in patients following allogeneic SCT.

Development of a method for direct quantification of cytomegalovirus antigenemia by flow cytometry

Cytomegalovirus (CMV) antigenemia was directly detected in polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNLs) from transplant recipients by using flow cytometry (FC). Two fixation and permeabilization methods and seven anti-CMV monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) were evaluated. 1C3, SL20, and NEA-9221 MAbs were more efficacious. The antigenemia detection threshold of FC was 0.05% positive PMNLs, and percentages correlated well with DNA viral load and the appearance of clinical symptoms.