TOLERANCE TO MUSCULOSKELETAL ALLOGRAFTS WITH TRANSIENT LYMPHOCYTE CHIMERISM IN MINIATURE SWINE1

A novel allogeneic acellular matrix scaffold for porcine cartilage regeneration

BACKGROUND

Cartilage defects are common sports injuries without significant treatment. Articular cartilage with inferior regenerative potential resulted in the poor formation of hyaline cartilage in defects. Acellular matrix scaffolds provide a microenvironment and biochemical properties similar to those of native tissues and are widely used for tissue regeneration. Therefore, we aimed to design a novel acellular cartilage matrix scaffold (ACS) for cartilage regeneration and hyaline-like cartilage formation.

METHODS

Four types of cartilage injury models, including full-thickness cartilage defects (6.5 and 8.5 mm in diameter and 2.5 mm in depth) and osteochondral defects (6.5 and 8.5 mm in diameter and 5 mm in depth), were constructed in the trochlear groove of the right femurs of pigs (n = 32, female, 25-40 kg). The pigs were divided into 8 groups (4 in each group) based on post-surgery treatment differences. was assessed by macroscopic appearance, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), micro-computed tomography (micro-CT), and histologic and immunohistochemistry tests.

RESULTS

At 6 months, the ACS-implanted group exhibited better defect filling and a greater number of chondrocyte-like cells in the defect area than the blank groups. MRI and micro-CT imaging evaluations revealed that ACS implantation was an effective treatment for cartilage regeneration. The immunohistochemistry results suggested that more hyaline-like cartilage was generated in the defects of the ACS-implanted group.

CONCLUSIONS

ACS implantation promoted cartilage repair in full-thickness cartilage defects and osteochondral defects with increased hyaline-like cartilage formation at the 6-month follow-up.

Simultaneous transplantation of hematopoietic stem cells and a vascularized composite allograft leads to tolerance

BACKGROUND

We have previously demonstrated that tolerance to a vascularized composite allograft (VCA) can be achieved after the establishment of mixed chimerism. We test the hypothesis that tolerance to a VCA in our dog leukocyte antigen-matched canine model is not dependent on the previous establishment of mixed chimerism and can be induced coincident with hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT).

METHODS

Eight dog leukocyte antigen-matched, minor antigen mismatched dogs received 200 cGy of radiation and a VCA transplant. Four dogs received donor bone marrow at the time of VCA transplantation (group 1), whereas a second group of four dogs did not (group 2). All recipients received a limited course of postgrafting immunosuppression. All dogs that received HCT and VCA were given donor, third-party, and autologous skin grafts.

RESULTS

All group 1 recipients were tolerant to their VCA (>62 weeks). Three of the four dogs in group 2 rejected their VCA transplants after the cessation of immunosuppression. Biopsies obtained from the muscle and skin of VCA from group 1 showed few infiltrating cells compared with extensive infiltrates in biopsies of VCA from group 2. Compared with autologous skin and muscle, elevated levels of CD3+ FoxP3+ T-regulatory cells were found in the skin and muscle obtained from the VCA of HCT recipients. All group 1 animals were tolerant to their donor skin graft and promptly rejected the third-party skin grafts.

CONCLUSION

These data demonstrated that donor-specific tolerance to all components of the VCA can be established through simultaneous nonmyeloablative allogeneic HCT and VCA transplantation protocol.

Induction of tolerance of vascularized composite allografts

Vascularized composite allotransplantation has become established as a clinical specialty since the first successful hand transplant was performed in 1998. Data now available indicate that hand and face transplants offer patients good functional outcomes and significant improvements in quality of life. Despite the debilitating nature of the injuries treated by such transplants, the defects are generally not life threatening, making it difficult for physicians to recommend life-long immunosuppression that can itself have grave consequences. One potential solution to this dilemma is the induction of immunologic tolerance of the tissue transplants because tolerance would eliminate the need for such immunosuppression. Transplant tolerance may also prevent chronic rejection, a significant source of late graft loss after organ transplantation.Induction of mixed hematopoietic chimerism is a robust approach to establishing such transplant tolerance, which recently led to the first clinical application of a tolerance induction protocol for kidney transplantation. In this manuscript, we review the current status of VCA and of research directed toward bringing a tolerance approach to the VCA field. We also discuss the potential clinical significance of these studies and outline the remaining obstacles to introduction of a tolerance induction protocol to clinical practice in hand or face transplantation.

Chimerism-based experimental models for tolerance induction in vascularized composite allografts: Cleveland clinic research experience

The preclinical experimental models of vascularized composite allografts (VCAs) have been rapidly developed for the assessment of immunomodulatory protocols for clinical application. Recently, researchers have focused on immunomodulatory protocols which overcome the immunologic barrier between the allogeneic donor and recipient and may lead to tolerance induction. In order to test the feasibility of chimerism induction, experimental VCAs have been performed in different models including rodents, large animals, and nonhuman primates. These models differ in the complexity of transplanted tissue and in their responses to immunomodulatory protocols. In most applications, VCA contains multiple-tissue components; however, each individual component of CTA possesses unique immunologic characteristics that ultimately contribute to the chimerism induction and successful outcome of the VCA. Heterogenic character and complexity of tissue components in different VCA models determine the quality and robustness of donor-specific chimerism. As introduced in experimental studies, variable immunomodulatory options have been studied to achieve tolerance to VCA in rodents and large animal models allowing for widespread application in clinic. In this paper, based on our own experience, we have analyzed the current knowledge of tolerance-inducing strategies via chimerism induction in VCA experimental models in the context of immunomodulatory protocols and VCA complexity and their relevance and applicability to clinical practice.

Immunologic aspects and rejection in solid organ versus reconstructive transplantation

The immunosuppressive medications developed over the past 3 decades have paved the way for solid organ transplantation to become the treatment of choice for end-stage organ failure. At the end of the century, composite tissue transplantation in humans was performed with success using the same immunosuppressive medications and therapeutic principles. A decade later, experience from >100 cases of reconstructive transplantation have increased the knowledge, changed the view, and affected the therapeutic principles in this novel field. We herein portray the evolution of this novel type of transplant with particular reference to immunologic aspects, particularly differences between reconstructive and solid organ transplantation.

Animal models for cartilage regeneration and repair

Articular cartilage injury and degeneration are leading causes of disability. Animal studies are critically important to developing effective treatments for cartilage injuries. This review focuses on the use of animal models for the study of the repair and regeneration of focal cartilage defects. Animals commonly used in cartilage repair studies include murine, lapine, canine, caprine, porcine, and equine models. There are advantages and disadvantages to each model. Small animal rodent and lapine models are cost effective, easy to house, and useful for pilot and proof-of-concept studies. The availability of transgenic and knockout mice provide opportunities for mechanistic in vivo study. Athymic mice and rats are additionally useful for evaluating the cartilage repair potential of human cells and tissues. Their small joint size, thin cartilage, and greater potential for intrinsic healing than humans, however, limit the translational value of small animal models. Large animal models with thicker articular cartilage permit study of both partial thickness and full thickness chondral repair, as well as osteochondral repair. Joint size and cartilage thickness for canine, caprine, and mini-pig models remain significantly smaller than that of humans. The repair and regeneration of chondral and osteochondral defects of size and volume comparable to that of clinically significant human lesions can be reliably studied primarily in equine models. While larger animals may more closely approximate the human clinical situation, they carry greater logistical, financial, and ethical considerations. A multifactorial analysis of each animal model should be carried out when planning in vivo studies. Ultimately, the scientific goals of the study will be critical in determining the appropriate animal model.

Cryopreservation and the age of the allotransplant

For centuries, reconstructive surgeons have restored form and function with autografts. These techniques are highly effective, but they are associated invariably with donor site morbidity. To avoid this, surgeons have long dreamed of using cadaveric sources for reconstructive material. However, allografts have two major limitations: rejection and limited donor tissue. In order to limit rejection, the allograft must be rendered more tolerable to the host or the host must be rendered more tolerant of the allograft. Both strategies have been used with considerable success in recent years. As understanding of the human immune response increases, clinical immunosuppressive regimens will undoubtedly become less morbid, and the indications for allotransplantation will broaden. This will place an even greater burden on the already small donor pool. One way to relieve this burden would be through the development of strategies for the long-term preservation of donated tissues and organs. Cryopreservation has been used clinically for decades, and recent advances in the field have allowed the preservation of an ever widening array of tissues and organs. As cold storage has been shown to reduce the antigenicity of parts, cryopreservation may actually serve to improve the survival rate of transplanted parts, as well as increase their availability. As the era of autotransplantation gives way to the age of allotransplantation, cryopreservation will play an increasingly important role.

Science of composite tissue allotransplantation

The science of composite tissue allotransplantation (CTA) is rooted in progressive thinking by surgeons, fueled by innovative solutions, and aided by understanding the immunology of tolerance and rejection. These three factors have allowed CTA to progress from science fiction to science fact. Research using preclinical animal models has allowed an understanding of the antigenicity of complex tissue transplants and mechanisms to promote graft acceptance. As a result, translation to the clinic has shown that CTA is a viable treatment option well on the way of becoming a standard of care for those who have lost extremities and suffered large tissue defects. The field of CTA has been progressing exponentially over the past decade. Transplantation of hands, larynx, vascularized knee, trachea, face, and abdominal wall has been performed. Several important observations have emerged from translation to the clinic. Although it was predicted that rejection would pose a major limitation, this has not proven true. In fact, steroid-sparing protocols for immunosuppression that have been successfully used in renal transplantation are sufficient to prevent rejection of limbs. Although skin is highly antigenic when transplanted alone in animal models, when part of a CTA, it has not proven to be. Chronic rejection has not been conclusively demonstrated in hand transplant recipients and is difficult to induce in rodent models of CTA. This review focuses on the science of CTA, provides a snapshot of where we are in the clinic, and discusses prospects for the future to make the procedures even more widely available.

Composite tissue transplantation: a rapidly advancing field

Composite tissue allotransplantation (CTA) is emerging as a potential treatment for complex tissue defects. It is currently being performed with increasing frequency in the clinic. The feasibility of the procedure has been confirmed through 30 hand transplantation, 3 facial reconstructions, and vascularized knee, esophageal, and tracheal allografts. A major drawback for CTA is the requirement for lifelong immunosuppression. The toxicity of these agents has limited the widespread application of CTA. Methods to reduce or eliminate the requirement for immunosuppression and promote CTA acceptance would represent a significant step forward in the field. Multiple studies suggest that mixed chimerism established by bone marrow transplantation promotes tolerance resulting in allograft acceptance. This overview focuses on the history and the exponentially expanding applications of the new frontier in CTA transplantation: immunology associated with CTA; preclinical animal models of CTA; clinical experience with CTA; and advances in mixed chimerism-induced tolerance in CTA. Additionally, some important hurdles that must be overcome in using bone marrow chimerism to induce tolerance to CTA are also discussed.

Chimerism and bone marrow based therapies in transplantation

Composite tissue allotransplantation holds a great potential for providing increased knowledge of anatomy and microsurgical experience for life-enhancing reconstructions. Many transplant cases around the world have made this a clinical reality at the present time. Composite tissue allotransplants contain multiple tissue types, including bone, muscle, vessels, nerves, skin, and immune cells and bear a huge antigenic load. Although immunosuppressive drugs are applied successfully to prevent allograft rejection, their side effects pose a barrier to worldwide use. Bone marrow therapy in many tolerance induction protocols, therefore, provides a guide to reaching the target of permanent immunotolerance. Multiple studies suggest that bone marrow is immunomodulatory and may facilitate allograft acceptance. In this review, bone marrow based therapy protocols of clinical and experimental models are presented in two major categories: solid organ and composite tissue transplantation.

Immunologic approaches to composite tissue allograft

This article discusses the immunologic principles and the most promising immunologic approaches for composite tissue allograft tolerance. We have previously reviewed some of the pharmacologic approaches for composite tissue allo-transplantation. In this review, we will summarize the range of options that may address the challenge of transplantation in reconstructive surgery.

Hand transplantation: the state-of-the-art

The feasibility of hand transplantation has been demonstrated, both surgically and immunologically. Levels of immunosuppression comparable to regimens used in solid organ transplantation are proving sufficient to prevent graft loss. Many patients have achieved discriminative sensibility and recovery of intrinsic muscle function. In addition to restoration of function, hand transplantation offers considerable psychological benefits. The recipient's pre-operative psychological status, his motivation and his compliance with the intense rehabilitation programme are key issues. While the induction of graft specific tolerance represents a hope for the future, immunosuppression currently remains necessary and carries significant risks. Hand transplantation should, therefore, only be considered a therapeutic option for a carefully selected group of patients.

Composite tissue allograft extends a helping hand to transplant immunologists

The first successful human hand transplantation, performed on September 1998, has translated the scope of 'composite tissue allotransplantation' from research concepts into clinical practice. Beyond microsurgical problems that have been overcome several years ago, the main obstacle that still prevents the generalization of composite tissue allotransplantation is immunologic. This review, which summarizes the evidence obtained both from experimental animal models and from the first recipients of a hand transplant, is focused on the two immunological characteristics of composite allografts that set them apart from other solid organ allografts: (i) they contain skin tissue that elicits a strong immune response; and (ii) they contain lymphoid tissues (such as bone marrow and lymph nodes) that have the potential both to attack the recipient, and also to down-modulate the host immune response and induce tolerance. While on one hand, the composite tissue allografts raise new challenges to transplant immunologists, on the other they provide answers to questions that have remained unresolved for a long time. In this sense, composite tissue allografts extend a helping hand to transplant immunologists.

Long-Term Acceptance of Renal Allografts following Prenatal Inoculation with Adult Bone Marrow

BACKGROUND

The aim was to investigate if intravascular in utero injection of adult bone marrow into swine fetuses could lead to macrochimerism and tolerance to the donor.

METHODS

Outbred Yorkshire sows and boars screening negative for MHC allele SLA of MGH miniature swine were bred. A laparotomy was performed on the sows at 50 days gestation to expose the uterus. Bone marrow harvested from SLA miniature swine was T-cell depleted and injected intravascularly into seventeen fetuses. Flow cytometry was performed to detect donor cells (chimerism) in the peripheral blood after birth. Mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) assays were used to assess the response to donor MHC. Previously frozen skin grafts from the bone marrow donor were placed on the offspring from the first litter. Donor-matched renal transplant from SLA donors were performed on chimeric swine, with and without a short 12-day course of cyclosporine, and one nonchimeric littermate.

RESULTS

Nine inoculated offspring demonstrated donor cell chimerism in the peripheral blood and lymphohematopoietic tissues. All animals with detectable chimerism within the first three weeks were consistently nonreactive to donor MHC in vitro. Animals challenged with donor skin grafts displayed prolonged graft survival without producing antidonor antibodies. All chimeric animals accepted donor-matched kidney allografts, even one without cyclosporine. The kidney in the nonchimeric littermate rejected by day 21.

CONCLUSIONS

Transplantation of allogeneic adult bone marrow into immunocompetent fetal recipients resulted in chimerism. In utero inoculation led to operational tolerance to the donor's major histocompatibility antigens and long-term acceptance to organ allografts.

Detection of chimerism following vascularized bone allotransplantation by polymerase chain reaction using a Y-chromosome specific primer

Chimerism following allogeneic organ transplantation is a phenomenon known to occur and be associated with development of immunologic tolerance in allotransplantation. However, little is known about graft cell migration following vascularized bone allografting. In this study, chimerism was assessed following vascularized tibia transplantation from male DA or PVG donors to female PVG rat recipients using a semi-quantitative polymerase chain reaction for the Y-chromosome. FK-506 (Tacrolimus) was administered after transplantation for immunosuppression. All immunosuppresssed PVG rat recipients of PVG bone grafts showed a high level of chimerism (1%) in the thymus, spleen, liver and cervical lymph nodes at 18 weeks post-transplant. Donor cells were also detected in the contralateral tibia and humerus. In non-immunosuppressed PVG rat recipients of DA bone grafts, donor cells were detected in the spleen in three of five rats within 2 weeks post-transplant. In these animals the bone grafts were severely rejected. In immunosuppressed PVG rat recipients of DA bone grafts, two of five, four of eight and eight of 10 rats showed low level chimerism (0.1%) in peripheral blood at 1, 12, and 18 weeks post-transplant. Six rats showed a high level of chimerism in the spleen and thymus. Histological studies revealed no rejection findings through 18 weeks post-transplant. Our results indicate that chimerism, or the presence of graft cells in host tissue, may occur in the face of acute rejection and be demonstrable following vascularized isograft and allograft living bone transplantation when chronic immunosuppression is maintained. Graft vascular patency during the short-term likely allows cellular migration, even in the face of acute rejection. Long-term survival and proliferation of graft marrow elements in host tissue may be possible with adequate immunosuppression.

Split tolerance to a composite tissue allograft in a swine model

BACKGROUND

The antigenicity of skin is a major obstacle to expanding human composite tissue transplantation. For example, multiple rejection episodes of the skin have been noted in clinical hand transplant patients. We have previously demonstrated tolerance to vascularized musculoskeletal allografts in major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-matched miniature swine treated with 12 days of cyclosporine. This regimen did not reproducibly lead to tolerance to subsequent frozen donor skin grafts. However, such skin grafts did not have a primary vascular supply. The aim of this study was to determine if tolerance to limb allografts with a vascularized skin component could be achieved with MHC matching and a 12-day course of immunosuppression.

METHODS

Hind limb grafts harvested with a 100 cm(2) cutaneous paddle were transplanted heterotopically into six MHC-matched, minor antigen-mismatched miniature swine. All animals received a 12-day course of cyclosporine. One control animal was not immunosuppressed. Grafts were evaluated with biweekly biopsies and tissue viability determined by histologic analysis. To test for sensitization, frozen donor skin grafts were applied to all animals that survived to postoperative day 100.

RESULTS

All treated animals (n=6) were tolerant to their musculoskeletal allografts at the time of necropsy (>100 days) regardless of the status of the epidermis. One animal demonstrated tolerance to the skin for more than 180 days. The other five animals demonstrated prolonged survival of the epidermal portion of the graft. The control animal rejected the graft epidermis at 10 days postoperatively. Frozen donor skin grafts demonstrated accelerated rejection (<10 days) in three of the animals and led to simultaneous rejection of both the epidermis of the allograft and the skin graft in the long-term tolerant animal. The rejection of the skin grafts did not break tolerance to the musculoskeletal portion in any of the animals.

CONCLUSIONS

All animals exhibited indefinite survival of the musculoskeletal portion of their allografts but only prolonged survival of the epidermis. The loss of the graft skin appears to be the result of an isolated immune reaction to the skin, and, in particular, the epidermis. This observation is further substantiated by the accelerated rejection of secondarily placed frozen donor skin grafts.

Lack of donor hyporesponsiveness and donor chimerism after clinical transplantation of the hand

BACKGROUND

Composite tissue allografts offer great potential in reconstructive surgery. However, the risks of immunosuppression and graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) after transplantation of vascularized bone in these grafts are significant. Transplantation of vascularized bone also may confer donor hematopoietic chimerism and, potentially, tolerance. We have followed two hand transplant recipients for more than 1 year to determine the level of chimerism and possible donor-specific tolerance, in addition to possible GVHD.

METHODS

We performed kinetic studies on peripheral blood of two subjects after hand transplantation that included portions of the radius and ulna. We evaluated donor-specific reactivity, chimerism, and antibody production.

RESULTS

Donor-specific tolerance did not develop clinically or in mixed lymphocyte reaction. The first subject recovered an excellent in vitro response to phytohemagglutinin, donor and third-party alloantigen, and by month 4 and at month 12 also recovered the ability to respond to Epstein-Barr virus. The second subject also demonstrated good in vitro proliferative responses, which were attenuated by immunosuppression. No phenotypic changes in mature hematopoietic lineages were detected by four-color flow cytometry other than those expected in response to immunosuppression. Donor chimerism was not detectable using four-color flow cytometry. Microchimerism (approximately 1:75,000 cells) was observed at the level of detection in some of the early posttransplantation specimens and was undetectable thereafter.

CONCLUSIONS

In this particular transplantation and immunosuppressive regimen, the composite tissue allograft with vascularized bone marrow did not provide the immunologic benefit of tolerance induction nor cause GVHD.

Recipient bone marrow engraftment in donor tissue after long-term tolerance to a composite tissue allograft

BACKGROUND

An important component of a composite tissue limb allograft (CTA) is the vascularized bone marrow and bone marrow stroma, which when transplanted could create immediate marrow space and engraftment. We have previously demonstrated that tolerance to musculoskeletal allografts can be achieved with a 12-day course of cyclosporine without the presence of long-term peripheral donor cell chimerism. The objective of this study was to determine the fate of the donor bone marrow after transplantation of a limb allograft in a miniature swine model.

METHODS

CTAs from donor swine were heterotopically transplanted into six MHC-matched, minor-antigen-mismatched recipients, and a 12-day course of cyclosporine was given. Previous animals transplanted without cyclosporine rejected their grafts in less than 42 days. A non-MHC-linked marker, pig allelic antigen (PAA), was used to distinguish host and donor cells. Three PAA- animals received PAA+ CTAs, and three PAA+ animals received PAA- CTAs. Bone marrow was harvested from the donor limb grafts and the recipient and analyzed by flow cytometry and histology. Thymus, spleen, and mesenteric lymph nodes were also harvested from the recipient swine and evaluated for the presence of donor cells by flow cytometry.

RESULTS

All animals receiving cyclosporine demonstrated permanent tolerance to their allografts. Donor bone marrow cells were present in all grafts at the time of transplantation and during the immediate postoperative period. By 48 weeks, donor cells were no longer detectable within the marrow space of the allograft. In long-term animals host bone marrow cells replaced donor cells in the graft marrow space. No evidence of donor cell engraftment was found in recipient animals.

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrates that in long-term tolerant recipients of musculoskeletal allografts there is no evidence of persistent donor bone marrow cells in the hematopoietic tissues of the graft or the host. Rather, the recipient's bone marrow cells and lymphocytes repopulate the donor marrow space of the graft.