Percutaneous epiphysiodesis of the lower extremity: a comparison of single- versus double-portal techniques

Microwave Ablation of the Pig Growth Plate: Proof of Concept for Minimally Invasive Epiphysiodesis

BACKGROUND

Different surgical methods for epiphysiodesis of limb length discrepancy (LLD) have been described. Although these methods are variably effective, they are associated with morbidity (pain and limp) and potential complications. Microwave ablation is a less-invasive opportunity to halt growth by selectively destroying the growth plate via thermal energy to treat LLD in children.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

In this proof-of-concept study using an in vivo pig model, we asked: (1) What is the durability of response 2 to 4 months after microwave ablation of the tibial growth plate as measured by length and angulation of the tibia via a CT scan? (2) Was articular cartilage maintained as measured by standard histologic staining for articular cartilage viability?

METHODS

To develop an in vivo protocol for microwave ablation, we placed microwave antennas adjacent to the proximal tibia growth plate in the cadaveric hindlimbs of 18 3-month-old pigs. To determine the suitable time, we varied ablation from 90 to 270 seconds at 65-W power settings. After sectioning the tibia, we visually assessed for discoloration (implying growth plate destruction) that included the central growth plate but did not encroach into the epiphysis in a manner that could disrupt the articular surface. Using this information, we then performed microwave ablation on three live female pigs (3.5 to 4 months old) to evaluate physiologic changes and durability of response. A postprocedure MRI was performed to ensure the intervention led to spatial growth plate alterations similar to that seen in cadavers. This was followed by serial CT, which was used to assess the potential effect on local bone and growth until the animals were euthanized 2 to 4 months after the procedure. We analyzed LLD, angular deformity, and bony deformity using CT scans of both tibias. The visibility of articular cartilage was compared with that of the contralateral tibia via standard histologic staining, and growth rates of the proximal tibial growth plate were compared via fluorochrome labeling.

RESULTS

Eighteen cadaveric specimens showed ablation zones across the growth plate without visual damage to the articular surface. The three live pigs did not exhibit changes in gait or require notable pain medication after the procedure. Each animal demonstrated growth plate destruction, expected limb shortening (0.8, 1.2, and 1.5 cm), and bony cavitation around the growth plate. Slight valgus bone angulation (4º, 5º, and 12º) compared with the control tibia was noted. No qualitatively observable articular cartilage damage was encountered from the histologic comparison with the contralateral tibia for articular cartilage thickness and cellular morphology.

CONCLUSION

A microwave antenna placed into a pig's proximal tibia growth plate can slow the growth of the tibia without apparent pain and alteration of gait and function.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Further investigation and refinement of our animal model is ongoing and includes shorter ablation times and comparison of dynamic ablation (moving the antennae during the ablation) as well as static ablation of the tibia from a medial and lateral portal. These refinements and planned comparison with standard mechanical growth arrest in our pig model may lead to a similar approach to ablate growth plates in children with LLD.

Are percutaneous epiphysiodesis and Phemister technique effective in the treatment of leg-length discrepancy? A systematic review

Epiphysiodesis is considered the preferred treatment for children predicted to have leg length discrepancies (LLDs) 2-5 cm at maturity. The aim of this study was to systematically review the existing literature on the effectiveness of permanent epiphysiodesis for LLD treatment, and secondarily to address the reported complications of permanent epiphysiodesis techniques. This systematic review was performed according to PRISMA guidelines. We searched MEDLINE (PubMed), Embase, Cochrane Library, Web of Science and Scopus for studies on skeletally immature patients with LLD treated with permanent epiphysiodesis. The extracted outcome categories were effectiveness of epiphysiodesis (LLD measurements pre/post-operatively, successful/unsuccessful), physeal fusion/arrest, and complications that were graded on severity. Forty-nine studies (3051 patients) were included, 1550 underwent Phemister/modified Phemister epiphysiodesis and 1501 percutaneous epiphysiodesis (PE). Total successful permanent epiphysiodesis surgeries (16 studies) were 73.7% (516/700). Only 13 out of 23 studies had a mean final LLD of less than 1.5 cm. In total, 17.5% (513/2936) of complications were reported. 57 angular deformities were reported (1.9%). Phemister technique had higher percentage of complications (39%) than PE (19.1%) in total, but when failure to achieve adequate reduction in LLD was not included, complication rates for both were close to 14%. However, severe complications were 10.2% for Phemister group and 5.1% for PE. The high complication rates and the relative low success rate call for optimization of the timing and the applied techniques when treating LLD with permanent epiphysiodesis. Phemister technique was found to have higher percentage of severe complications than PE. Registration: PROSPERO (CRD42023435177).

Angular deformities after percutaneous epiphysiodesis for leg length discrepancy

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to systematically analyze the presence of secondary angular deformities after percutaneous epiphysiodesis based on long-standing radiographs, and to see if the occurrence and magnitude of angular deformities after percutaneous epiphysiodesis correlated with the amount of remaining growth at the time of surgery.

METHODS

From a local Health Register consisting of patients investigated using the Moseley Straight-Line Graph, we identified 269 patients who had undergone percutaneous epiphysiodesis from 2002 until 2020. Radiographic analysis included the measurement of mechanical axis and joint orientation angles on long-standing anterior-posterior radiographs. Remaining growth was analyzed based on the Menelaus method.

RESULTS

One hundred and forty epiphysiodeses (71 femurs and 69 tibiae) in 88 patients (39 girls and 49 boys) could be included in the study. Mean age at surgery was 13.2 (10-16.8) years, and mean skeletal age at surgery was 13.0 (9.8-15.7) years. A change of the MA (Mechanical axis) ≥10 mm was found in eight patients (9%). Secondary frontal plane deformities after percutaneous epiphysiodesis correlated significantly with the remaining growth at the time of surgery (p = 0.003).

CONCLUSION

We found a high rate of secondary angular deformities after percutaneous epiphysiodesis, and the magnitude of the deformities correlated with the amount of remaining growth at the time of surgery. A modification of the original surgical method for percutaneous epiphysiodesis to also include ablation of central parts of the growth plate might be considered. Patients should be enrolled in a systematic follow-up scheme which allows for the early detection of possible angular deformities.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

level III study.

The single portal percutaneous epiphysiodesis technique for treatment of leg length inequality stops growth as expected

One technique for distal femur and proximal tibia epiphysiodesis to treat leg length inequality is a single-incision percutaneous technique using reamers and curettes. The purpose of this study is to demonstrate the efficacy and reliability of this technique by quantifying the growth arrest produced from this method. Patients who underwent distal femur and proximal tibia epiphysiodesis with a single-incision percutaneous technique were retrospectively reviewed. Using scanogram data, derivative formulas of both the multiplier and arithmetic methods were used to predict bone length after physeal arrest at maturity. Patients included had at least 2-year follow-up after surgery. Predicted bone lengths were then compared to actual bone lengths obtained via scanogram at final follow-up. A total of 46 patients were included in the study (27 males; 19 females). Average age at surgery was: males 14.5 years, females 12.4 years. Surgery was performed on 40 distal femurs and 25 proximal tibias. Postoperative femurs demonstrated an actual mean length of 44.75 cm. Predicted femur bone lengths utilizing the multiplier and arithmetic methods were 45.08 and 44.08 cm, respectively. Postoperative tibias demonstrated an actual mean length of 38.12 cm. Predicted tibia lengths utilizing the multiplier and arithmetic method were 38.30 and 38.02 cm. No significance was found between actual and predicted bone lengths for both tibias and femurs. This study demonstrates that a single-incision percutaneous epiphysiodesis technique reliably arrests the growth as expected. Surgeons can confidently and accurately employ this technique to successfully treat leg length inequality.

Update on guided growth concepts around the knee in children

Guided growth is part of the surgical armamentarium for limb-length discrepancy or axial deformity. It is an old concept, with several apparently conflicting techniques that are in fact usually complementary. Depending on whether the aim is to slow or arrest growth, to treat length discrepancy or axial deviation, techniques differ and the choice is partly determined by the indication. It is thus essential to know the technical details for each: temporary or definitive, complete or asymmetric, with or without implant. Considerations of fashion and personal habits may outweigh basic principles, and it is important to go back to the princeps descriptions: the Phemister, Bowen, Blount, Métaizeau and Stevens techniques and others all have their surgical specificities Apart from surgery itself, he indication and choice of technique depend on the patient's age and whether the abnormality to be treated is isolated or part of a wider syndrome, all of this being included in a precise strategy based on planning calculations that are indispensable ahead of any surgery. Guided growth can also be implemented elsewhere than in the limbs: wrist, ankle, or even hip; and it is beginning to be possible to correct sagittal and rotational deformities. All of this is furthermore achievable using emerging techniques that are less invasive, are reversible, and show equal efficacy.

Long-term follow-up after bilateral percutaneous epiphysiodesis around the knee to reduce excessive predicted final height

CONTEXT

Percutaneous epiphysiodesis (PE) around the knee to reduce predicted excessive final height. Studies until now included small numbers of patients and short follow-up periods.

OBJECTIVE AND DESIGN

This Dutch multicentre, long-term, retrospective, follow-up study aimed to assess adult height (AH), complications, knee function and patient satisfaction after PE. The primary hypothesis was that PE around the knee in constitutionally tall boys and girls is an effective treatment for reducing final height with low complication rates and a high level of patient satisfaction.

PARTICIPANTS

77 treated adolescents and 60 comparisons.

INTERVENTION

Percutaneous epiphysiodesis.

OUTCOME

AH, complications, knee function, satisfaction.

RESULTS

In the PE-treated group, final height was 7.0 cm (±6.3 cm) lower than predicted in boys and 5.9 cm (±3.7 cm) lower than predicted in girls. Short-term complications in file search were seen in 5.1% (three infections, one temporary nerve injury), one requiring reoperation. Long-term complications in file search were seen in 2.6% (axis deformity 1.3%, prominent head of fibula 1.3%). No significant difference in knee function was found between treated cases and comparisons. Satisfaction was high in both the comparison and PE groups; most patients in the PE group recommended PE as the treatment for close relatives with tall stature.

CONCLUSION

PE is safe and effective in children with predicted excessive AH. There was no difference in patient satisfaction between the PE and comparison group. Careful and detailed counselling is needed before embarking on treatment.

Effectiveness of different minimally invasive epiphysiodesis techniques in the management of pediatric leg length discrepancies: a systematic review protocol

REVIEW QUESTION/OBJECTIVE

The objective of this review is to synthesize the best available evidence on the use of percutaneous epiphysiodesis for the management of pediatric leg length discrepancies (LLDs). The effectiveness of four different percutaneous epiphysiodesis techniques will be compared, including transphyseal screws (percutaneous epiphysiodesis using transphyseal screws), physeal drilling and curettage, physeal stapling and guided growth with eight-Plates.Specific review questions to be addressed include.

The role of guided growth as it relates to limb lengthening

For decades, the classic indication for limb lengthening has been reserved for anisomelia that was expected to reach or exceed 5 cm at maturity. Epiphysiodesis was reserved for discrepancies in the 2-5 cm range. With the increasing sophistication of fixators, including rail, hexapod, and hybrid, complex deformities may be corrected simultaneously while moderate to extreme lengthening is achieved. More recently, iterations of telescoping intramedullary rods have further strengthened our armamentarium. Meanwhile, permanent epiphysiodesis techniques, both open and percutaneous, have yielded to more versatile and reversible tethering of one (angle) or both (length) sides of a physis. While the techniques of guided growth and callotasis seem to be diametrically opposed, they may be used in a tandem or complementary fashion, for the benefit of the patient. If treatment is undertaken during skeletal growth, one must be aware that issues remain regarding the accurate assessment of skeletal maturity and prediction of the ultimate outcome. Therefore, there is potential for over- or undercorrection. Reversible and serial guided growth now enable the surgeon to commence intervention at a comparatively young age, for the purpose of optimizing limb alignment and reducing the ultimate discrepancy. Frame application may be delayed or, in some cases, avoided altogether. With the limb properly aligned at the outset of lengthening, elective use of a telescoping intramedullary nail may now be favored over a frame accordingly.

Thermal epiphysiodesis performed with radio frequency in a porcine model

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Current techniques for epiphysiodesis involve opening of cortical windows; use of staples, screws, and tension devices; and fusion with curettes or drills. Complications may have serious consequences. There is a need for a more reliable, precise, and less traumatic procedure that overcomes the known complications from existing techniques. We analyzed a new epiphysiodesis technique using radio-frequency ablation (RFA) in a porcine model.

METHODS

Six 35-kg and two 25-kg immature pigs were used. 1 hind leg of each animal was randomly selected and the proximal tibia growth plate was ablated laterally and medially. The contralateral leg was used as a control. MR images were obtained immediately after the ablation and 12 weeks later for 6 animals, and 24 weeks later for the other 2 animals. CT was done for the 2 animals that were followed for 24 weeks for proof of bone bridges.

RESULTS

Both tibias were equal in length initially. At the 12-week follow-up, there was an average leg length discrepancy of 3.9 mm (95% CI: 3.0-4.8), and at 24 weeks the difference was 8.4 mm and 7.5 mm. No damage to the adjacent tissue was found. Bone bridges and physeal closure were found after 24 weeks. The pigs showed no discomfort after the intervention.

INTERPRETATION

We found RFA to be feasible for epiphysiodesis in a pig model. The method is minimally invasive and recovery may be quick compared to conventional methods. We recommend that the method should be tested in larger-scale safety studies before clinical application.

Percutaneous epiphysiodesis in the proximal tibia by a single-portal approach: evaluation by radiostereometric analysis

PURPOSE

We modified the method for tibial epiphysiodesis by solely using a lateral approach to the physis. From this small-incision approach, the lateral as well as the medial part of the tibial physis were ablated. The aim of our study was to see if this operative technique might be as effective as a bilateral approach, and reduce the operation time and usage time of the image intensifier. The epiphysiodeses were monitored by radiostereometric analysis (RSA), which is a well-established method for the analysis of micro movements and has been used to monitor percutaneous epiphysiodesis with the bilateral approach. There are no reports in the literature comparing single- with double-portal approaches for percutaneous epiphysiodesis evaluated by RSA.

METHODS

Twenty children were treated by percutaneous epiphysiodesis for leg length discrepancies ranging from 15 to 70 mm, comprising 14 boys and 6 girls with a mean age of 13 (11-15) years. The timing of epiphysiodesis was determined by using Moseley's straight-line graph and Paley's multiplier method. For the tibial epiphysiodesis, ten patients were operated with a single surgical approach from the lateral side (Group I) and ten patients were operated with a surgical approach from both the medial and the lateral sides (Group II). The percutaneous epiphysiodesis was monitored by RSA, a method which allows analysis of the three-dimensional dynamics of the epiphysis relative to the metaphysics. RSA examinations were performed postoperatively and after 6 weeks, 12 weeks, and 6 months.

RESULTS

From 0 to 6 weeks after epiphysiodesis, the mean longitudinal growth across the operated physis in the tibia in Group I was 0.26 (0.01-0.6) mm. In Group II, the mean growth for the first 6 weeks after surgery was 0.17 (0.01-0.5) mm. During the time period from 6 weeks to 12 weeks after surgery, there was a mean growth of 0.06 (0.00-0.18) mm in Group I and 0.03 (0.00-0.2) mm in Group II. The mean growth from 0 to 6 weeks after epiphysiodesis for all patients was 0.22 mm, which corresponds to 30 % of the normal growth rate. From 6 to 12 weeks, the mean growth for all patients was 0.046 mm, i.e., 6 % of the normal growth rate. From 12 weeks to 24 weeks, no significant growth across the operated physis was observed in neither Group I nor Group II. The mean surgical time was 26 (21-30) min in Group I and 43 (35-48) min in Group II. This difference was statistically significant (p = 0.006). The mean time for use of the image intensifier during surgery was 202 (191-236) s in Group I and 229 (185-289) s in Group II (p = 0.013).

CONCLUSIONS

In our study, a single-portal technique from the lateral side for percutaneous epiphysiodesis of the proximal tibia was as effective as the double-portal technique. Actual growth arrest appeared within 12 weeks after surgery. A single-portal technique for epiphysiodesis of the tibia is a safe technique, with less surgical time and less time for image intensification compared to the double-portal technique.

Negative correlation between extent of physeal ablation after percutaneous permanent physiodesis and postoperative growth: volume computer tomography and radiostereometric analysis of 37 physes in 27 patients

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Percutaneous physiodesis in the knee region is a well-established method for treating leg-length inequality. Longitudinal growth in the physis is believed to stop almost immediately after the operation. The extent of physis ablation required has never been investigated by any kind of tomography in humans. Using radiostereometric analysis (RSA), we determined when definite growth arrest occurred after surgery. We also studied the correlation between the extent of physis ablation and postoperative growth. Finally, we assessed any bone bridging across the physis.

METHODS

6, 12, and 30 weeks after surgery, we used RSA to measure longitudinal growth in 27 patients (37 physes) with a mean age of 13 years. CT scanning of the knee region was performed 12 weeks after surgery to measure the percentage of the ablated physis and to determine the distribution of bone bridges across the physis.

RESULTS

RSA showed that growth rate was reduced to less than half of the expected rate after 6 weeks. During the next 6 weeks, the growth ceased completely. CT scans revealed a large variation in the extent of ablated physes (17-69%). In the ablated areas, tissues of various densities were mixed with mature bone. Bridges were found both laterally and medially across the physes in all of the patients. There was a negative correlation between the extent of ablation and total postoperative growth (rho = -0.37, p = 0.03).

INTERPRETATION

Growth across the physis is effectively stopped by percutaneous physiodesis. RSA is well-suited for observation of this phenomenon. Volume CT scanning can be used to detect bone bridges that cross the physis and to calculate the extent of physis ablation.

The accuracy of current methods in determining the timing of epiphysiodesis

We compared the accuracy of the growth remaining method of assessing leg-length discrepancy (LLD) with the straight-line graph method, the multiplier method and their variants. We retrospectively reviewed the records of 44 patients treated by percutaneous epiphysiodesis for LLD. All were followed up until maturity. We used the modified Green–Anderson growth-remaining method (Method 1) to plan the timing of epiphysiodesis. Then we presumed that the other four methods described below were used pre-operatively for calculating the timing of epiphysiodesis. We then assumed that these four methods were used pre-operatively. Method 2 was the original Green–Anderson growth-remaining method; Method 3, Paley’s multiplier method using bone age; Method 4, Paley’s multiplier method using chronological age; and Method 5, Moseley’s straight-line graph method. We compared ‘Expected LLD at maturity with surgery’ with ‘Final LLD at maturity with surgery’ for each method. Statistical analysis revealed that ‘Expected LLD at maturity with surgery’ was significantly different from ‘Final LLD at maturity with surgery’. Method 2 was the most accurate. There was a significant correlation between ‘Expected LLD at maturity with surgery’ and ‘Final LLD at maturity with surgery’, the greatest correlation being with Method 2. Generally all the methods generated an overcorrected value. No method generates the precise ‘Expected LLD at maturity with surgery’. It is essential that an analysis of the pattern of growth is taken into account when predicting final LLD. As many additional data as possible are required.

Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2013;95-B:993–1000.

Guided growth for the treatment of moderate leg-length discrepancy

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness and complication rate of guided growth for the treatment of patients with a moderate leg-length discrepancy. The authors retrospectively reviewed all patients treated with guided growth for a moderate leg-length discrepancy at their institution between October 2004 and December 2010. Thirty-four patients met the inclusion criteria from an initial cohort of 105 patients. All patients were followed until screw removal or maturity occurred. Nine patients had a developmental leg-length discrepancy, and 25 had a congenital leg-length discrepancy. Average age was 12.6 years (range, 7-16 years). Average leg-length discrepancies, as measured on standing long-leg radiographs from the top of the pelvis, the top of the femoral heads, and the center of the ankle to the top of the femoral heads, were 22, 19, and 17 mm, respectively. Average discrepancies at screw removal or maturity were 13, 10, and 11 mm, respectively. Twenty of 33 patients had a leg-length discrepancy of less than 1 cm at maturity or screw removal. The leg-length discrepancy change in patients who underwent guided growth of the tibia was minimal. Leg-length discrepancies in patients who underwent guided growth of the femur or both the femur and the tibia changed by an average of 10 mm. One patient had a mechanical axis change greater than 1 zone, and 1 patient required treatment for angular deformity after being treated for a leg-length discrepancy. Guided growth is a safe and effective technique for treating moderate leg-length discrepancies.

Endoscopically aided physeal bar takedown and guided growth for the treatment of angular limb deformity

The treatment of physeal arrest after infection remains a challenge. This report describes localized endoscopic epiphysiolysis combined with guided growth in the treatment of partial physeal arrest and limb deformity in an infant after infection. Over a year's time, the valgus was corrected and the plate was removed. The patient returned to full activity. Physeal arrest may occur at anytime after physeal trauma, highlighting the importance of long-term follow-up. Endoscopic physeal bar takedown combined with guided growth of the distal femur can be an effective option for the treatment.

Surgical epiphysiodesis indications and techniques: update

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To present a summary of epiphysiodesis indications and to report most recent advances in the field, along with their clinical relevance.

RECENT FINDINGS

Percutaneous epiphysiodesis using transphyseal screws (PETS) and guided growth using eight plates represent the most recent techniques used for hemiepiphysiodesis.

SUMMARY

PETS and guided growth have yielded very good results and low rates of complications and are the current standard for the management of angular deformities of the lower extremities in children. Permanent percutaneous epiphysiodesis remains the preferred method for the treatment of limb length discrepancies.