Experimental Endoscopic Angular Domains of Transnasal and Transoral Routes to the Craniovertebral Junction: Light and Shade

A Three-Step Submandibular Retropharyngeal Approach to the Craniovertebral Junction: Is Less Always More?

Background: Accessing the craniovertebral junction poses unique challenges due to its anatomical complexity and proximity to critical structures, such as the cord-brainstem junction, great vessels of the neck, cranial nerves, oropharynx, and rhinopharynx. Among the approaches that have been developed over the years, the submandibular retropharyngeal approach offers good antero-lateral access without the need of transgressing mucosal layers. In its traditional form, however, this approach involves multiple sequential steps and requires intricate dissection, extensive retraction, and meticulous maneuvering, which can increase operative time and produce approach-related morbidity. Methods: With this paper, we propose a simplified technique for a submandibular retropharyngeal approach involving only three surgical steps. The advantages and limitations of this technique are illustrated through three surgical cases of neoplastic and degenerative craniovertebral junction pathologies. Results: In two out of the three cases, our technique allowed for a wide exposure of the lesions that could be resected totally or sub-totally with good outcome. In one case with involvement of the clivus and the occipital condyle, the exposure was inadequate; a biopsy was obtained, and the lesion was subsequently resected via and endoscopic transmucosal approach. Conclusions: Our technique represents a significant simplification of the traditional submandibular retropharyngeal approach; with appropriate indication, it permits a fast, safe, and adequate exposure of craniovertebral junction pathologies.

Craniovertebral Junction Surgical Approaches: State of Art

Surgical approaches directed toward craniovertebral junction (CVJ) can be addressed to the ventral, dorsal, and lateral aspects through a variety of 360° surgical corridors Herein, we report features, advantages, and limits of the updated technical support in CVJ surgery in clinical setting and dissection laboratories enriched by our preliminary surgical results of the simultaneous application of O-arm intraoperative neuronavigation and imaging system along with the 3D-4K EX in TOA for the treatment of CVJ pathologies.In the past 4 years, eight patients harboring CVJ compressive pathologies underwent one-step combined anterior neurosurgical decompression and posterior instrumentation and fusion technique with the aid of exoscope and O-arm. In our equipped Cranio-Vertebral Junction Laboratory, we use fresh cadavers (and injected "head and neck" specimens) whose policy, protocols, and logistics have already been elucidated in previous works. Five fresh-frozen adult specimens were dissected adopting an FLA. In these specimens, a TOA was also performed, as well as a neuronavigation-assisted comparison between transoral and transnasal explorable distances.A complete decompression along with stable instrumentation and fusion of the CVJ was accomplished in all the cases at the maximum follow-up (mean: 25.3 months). In two cases, the O-arm navigation allowed the identification of residual compression that was not clearly visible using the microscope alone. In four cases, it was not possible to navigate C1 lateral masses and C2 isthmi due to the angled projection unfitting with the neuronavigation optical system, so misleading the surgeon and strongly suggesting changing surgical strategy intraoperatively. In another case (case 4), it was possible to navigate and perform both C1 lateral masses and C2 isthmi screwing, but the screw placement was suboptimal at the immediate postoperative radiological assessment. In this case, the hardware displacement occurred 2 months later requiring reoperation.

Os odontoideum associated with a retro-odontoid cyst treated with posterior C1-C3 fixation: A case report and literature review

Background

Os odontoideum is a rare abnormality of the upper cervical spine, and os odontoideum associated with a retro-odontoid cyst has been described as a marker of local instability.

Case description

This paper reports a case of a 52-year-old female patient who was diagnosed with os odontoideum associated with a retro-odontoid cyst. The patient underwent posterior C1-C3 fixation without surgical removal of the cyst. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) two days later revealed that the retro-odontoid cyst was still present and that there were no significant changes to it when compared with the preoperative MRI.

Conclusion

Retro-odontoid cysts associated with unstable os odontoideum can lead to symptomatic spinal cord compression. Posterior C1-C3 fixation can restore atlantoaxial stability by allowing the gradual resorption of the cyst and ensuring spinal cord decompression. Fixation can also avoid the surgical risk associated with a high-riding vertebral artery.

Combined Transoral Exoscope and OARM-Assisted Approach for Craniovertebral Junction Surgery. New Trends in an Old-Fashioned Approach

BACKGROUND

The introduction of recent innovations in the field of intraoperative imaging and neuronavigation, such as the O-arm StealthStation, allows for obtaining crucial intraoperative data by performing safer and controlled surgical procedures. As part of the improvement of surgical visual magnification and wide expansion of surgical corridors, the 3D 4 K exoscope (EX) has nowadays become an interesting and useful tool. The transoral approach (TOA) is the historical gold-standard direct microsurgical route to ventral craniovertebral junction (CVJ).

METHODS

We herein report our experience, consisting of ten cases via TOA concerning the simultaneous application of an O-arm with a StealthStation navigation system (Medtronic, Memphis, TN) and an imaging system, along with the 3D 4 K exoscopes in the TOA, for the treatment of CVJ pathologies.

RESULTS

No intraoperative neurophysiological changes or postoperative infections occurred, but neurological improvement was evident in all the patients. A complete decompression and a stable instrumentation and fusion of the CVJ were accomplished in all cases at the maximum follow-up time.

CONCLUSIONS

With EX, the role of the surgeon becomes self-sufficient with better individual surgical freedom compared to endoscopic surgery and excellent 3D vision and magnification. O-arms offer absolutely reliable intraoperative support for more-effective CVJ decompression. Nevertheless, with O-arm-assisted neuronavigation, it can be difficult to navigate C1 lateral masses and C2 isthmi, and converting 3D into 2D real-time navigation can be quite complicated. Finally, the combination of an EX with an O-arm appears more time-consuming compared to the old-fashion one.

Multidisciplinary approach to the craniovertebral junction. Historical insights, current and future perspectives in the neurosurgical and otorhinolaryngological alliance

Historically considered as a nobody’s land, craniovertebral junction (CVJ) surgery or specialty recently gained high consideration as symbol of challenging surgery as well as selective top level qualifying surgery. The alliance between Neurosurgeons and Otorhinolaringologists has become stronger in the time. CVJ has unique anatomical bone and neurovascular structures architecture. It not only separates from the subaxial cervical spine but it also provides a special cranial flexion, extension, and axial rotation pattern. Stability is provided by a complex combination of osseous and ligamentous supports which allows a large degree of motion. The perfect knowledge of CVJ anatomy and physiology allows to better understand surgical procedures of the occiput, atlas and axis and the specific diseases that affect the region. Although many years passed since the beginning of this pioneering surgery, managing lesions situated in the anterior aspect of the CVJ still remains a challenging neurosurgical problem. Many studies are available in the literature so far aiming to examine the microsurgical anatomy of both the anterior and posterior extradural and intradural aspects of the CVJ as well as the differences in all the possible surgical exposures obtained by 360° approach philosophy. Herein we provide a short but quite complete at glance tour across the personal experience and publications and the more recent literature available in order to highlight where this alliance between Neurosurgeon and Otorhinolaringologist is mandatory, strongly advisable or unnecessary.

A 360° Approach to the Craniovertebral Junction in a Cadaveric Laboratory Setting: Historical Insights, Current, and Future Perspectives in a Comparative Study

BACKGROUND

We herein outline the experience matured in our equipped Cranio-Vertebral Junction Laboratory for anatomic dissection.

METHODS

An extreme lateral approach (ELA) was performed on 4 fresh cadavers and submandibular approach was performed on 5. An endoscope and navigation-assisted far lateral approach (FLA) was performed in 5 injected specimens. In these specimens, a transoral approach was also performed, as well as a neuronavigation-assisted comparison between transoral and transnasal explorable distances.

RESULTS

As calculated with neuronavigation, statistically significant differences both in the explored craniocaudal (P = 0.003) and lateral (P = 0.008) distances were observed between the transoral approach and endoscopic endonasal approach. In FLA, neuronavigation facilitated identification and partial removal of the occipital condyle; in one case, during endoscopic intradural exploration, tearing of the emerging roots of the 11th cranial nerve occurred. In ELA, the site where the accessory nerve pierces into the sternocleidomastoid muscle was found at a distance from the tip of the mastoid between 3 and 4 cm.

CONCLUSIONS

During dissections, as in the clinical setting, endoscope and image guidance give the surgeon a constant orientation, increasing the accuracy and the safety of the approach. Nonetheless, the encumbrance of the endoscope could represent a limit in deep and narrow corridors as those running across the craniovertebral junction, especially in "oblique" FLA and ELA, in which the surgical target is often hidden by a delicate tangle of nerves and vessels. Its use appears more suitable and safer in "straight" approaches as transoral and transnasal in which there are no neurovascular structures interposed.

Combined transoral exoscope and OArm-assisted approach for craniovertebral junction surgery: Light and shadows in single-center experience with improving technologies

Background

The introduction of recent innovations in the field of intraoperative imaging and neuronavigation, such as OArm Stealth Station, allows to obtain crucial intraoperative data by performing safer and controlled surgical procedures. As part of the improvement of surgical visual magnification and wide expansion of surgical corridors, the 3D-4K exoscope (EX) represents nowadays an interesting and useful tool. Transoral approach (TOA) represents the historical gold standard direct microsurgical route to ventral craniovertebral junction (CVJ).

Methods

We herein report a preliminary experience on 6 cases of 33 patients operated by TOA concerning the simultaneous application of OArm with Stealth Navigation system (Medtronic, Memphis, TN) and imaging system along with the 3D-4K EXs in TOA for the treatment of CVJ pathologies.

Results

Neither intraoperative neurophysiological changes nor postoperative infections occurred, but a neurological improvement was evident in all the patients. A complete decompression along with stable instrumentation and fusion of the CVJ was accomplished in all cases at the maximum follow-up (mean: 16.8 months).

Conclusions

With EX, the role of surgeon become self-sufficient with a better individual surgical freedom compared to endoscopic surgery and excellent 3D vision and magnification. OArm allows an absolutely reliable intraoperative support for a more effective CVJ decompression. Nevertheless, with OArm-assisted neuronavigation, it can be difficult to navigate C1 lateral masses and C2 isthmi, and to convert 3D into 2D real-time navigation, it can become quite complicate. Finally, the association of EX and OArm appears more time consuming compared to the old fashion one.

Navigation-Guided Measurement of the Inferior Limit Through the Endonasal Route to the Craniovertebral Junction

BACKGROUND

The endoscopic endonasal approach (EEA) has been accepted as an alternative option for diseases at the craniovertebral junction. However, the inferior destination through the endoscopic endonasal approach is anatomically higher than that of the transoral approach. Therefore, preoperative assessment of accessibility is mandatory for appropriate selection of indication. Using a navigation system, we examined the inferior limit through the endonasal route and evaluated the relationships between surrounding anatomicl structures and the lowest point.

METHODS

This study included patients who underwent endoscopic transsphenoidal surgery for intrasellar lesions at our hospital (N = 23). At the start of surgery, the lowest point (target point [TP]) was marked with a straight probe under guidance of the navigation system. We measured 4 parameters on preoperative computed tomography: nasal length, hard palate length, anterior-posterior diameter of the nasopharynx, and nasopalatine angle. Patients were classified into groups depending on whether the TP was at or above (group A) or below (group B) the hard palatine line.

RESULTS

TPs were above the hard palatine line in 15 patients (group A) and below the hard palatine line in 8 patients (group B). No TPs reached the nasopalatine line. Nasal length (P = 0.03) and nasopalatine angle (P = 0.01) were larger in group B than in group A. There were no significant differences in anterior-posterior diameter of the nasopharynx or hard palate length.

CONCLUSIONS

The hard palatine line is a reliable parameter for assessing the inferior limit of the endoscopic endonasal approach. Nostril size affects accessibility with surgical instruments.

Step-up Establishment of Neurosurgical Laboratory Starting with Limited Resources-Tips and Tricks

BACKGROUND

Neurosurgical diseases have a devastating impact on society. It is estimated that approximately 14 million essential neurosurgical cases develop worldwide annually, of which more than 80% arise in low- and middle-income countries. Neurosurgical cadaveric dissection remains largely unexploited as a learning tool for the training of surgeons in developing countries, often because of the assumed high costs.

METHODS

The minimum requirements to establish a neurosurgical cadaver laboratory are the availability of minimally equipped environment to perform dissection, respecting safety requirements, fitting surgical instruments, anatomic samples, and materials to be used for preservation and preparation of anatomical specimens. Moving from these basic foundations, we established our Neurosurgical Dissection Laboratory at Fondazione Policlinico Universitario A. Gemelli IRCCS in Rome, Italy. The laboratory is located at the Institute of Public Health Section of Legal Medicine of University.

RESULTS

After reviewing relevant literature and discussing our experience, we provide advice for setting up a neurosurgical dissection cadaver laboratory with specific focus on suitable location identification, surgical equipment procurement, fresh cadaver and frozen specimen acquisition, and preparation and description of a step-up strategy to progressively enrich the laboratory.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study demonstrates the feasibility of establishing a neurosurgical cadaver dissection laboratory for training and research purposes even in presence of limited resources. The introduction of cost-effective guidelines and targeted funding could represent an added value to target the unmet neurosurgical disease need by promoting development of local neurosurgical expertise with the aim of providing health coverage for the treatment of common neurosurgical pathologies in developing countries.

Refinement of the Transoral Approach to Craniovertebral Junction Malformations

BACKGROUND

The transoral approach provides the most direct surgical corridor for treatment of congenital bony abnormalities that exert irreducible ventral compression of the cervicomedullary junction. In this paper, based on our experience with the transoral approach over the past three decades, we briefly describe the surgical strategies and the operative nuances that allow effective decompression of the craniovertebral junction (CVJ) while minimizing postoperative morbidity.

METHODS

The surgical strategy is dictated by the type and severity of the malformation. Fibre-optic nasotracheal intubation obviates the necessity of preoperative tracheostomy, and avoidance of a soft-palate incision significantly reduces oropharyngeal morbidity. When feasible, the atlas-sparing technique minimizes postoperative instability. The transoral transatlas approach is generally required in patients with severe basilar invagination and allows wider exposure of the anterior CVJ at the price of a higher incidence of postoperative instability.

CONCLUSION

The transoral approach is extremely effective in providing excellent decompression of the anterior cervicomedullary junction in patients with fixed malformations. Tailoring the approach to the peculiar anatomy of each malformation reduces iatrogenic instability and minimizes postoperative complications.

Endonasal and Transoral Approaches to the Craniovertebral Junction: A Quantitative Anatomical Study

BACKGROUND

The endoscopic endonasal approach has recently been added to the surgical armamentarium to access the anterior craniovertebral junction (CVJ). Comparative analyses with the transoral approach are scarce. The aim of this study was to provide a quantitative anatomical analysis of both approaches.

METHODS

In four specimens the endoscopic endonasal approach (before and after sphenoidectomy) and the transoral approach (without and with a soft palate split) were performed. ApproachViewer-part of GTx-UHN (Guided Therapeutics software, developed at University Health Network, Toronto, ON, Canada)-was used to quantify and visualize the working volume, as well as the exposed area, of each surgical approach. Different modalities (crossing and non-crossing) were used to quantify the exposure of the deep surface, providing an indirect quantitative value of the 'surgical freedom'. The lowest point exposed by the endonasal approaches was compared with that predicted by preoperative radiological lines. Non-parametric Welch analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used for statistical analyses.

RESULTS

The working volume was significantly larger and the distance to the target was shorter with the transoral approaches than with the endonasal approaches. Clival exposure was better with the endonasal approaches than with the non-crossing transoral approach without a soft palate split; areas below C1 were better exposed with the transoral routes. The nasoaxial line best predicted surgical exposure with the endonasal approaches.

CONCLUSION

Endoscopic endonasal and transoral approaches to the anterior CVJ provide optimal exposure of different areas that overlap at the level of C1 when no anatomical anomalies are present. A split of the soft palate is not necessary during the transoral approach if it is combined with an endoscopic endonasal approach.

Full-endoscopic Uniportal Odontoidectomy and Decompression of the Anterior Cervicomedullary Junction Using the Retropharyngeal Approach

STUDY DESIGN

A study of a series of consecutive full-endoscopic uniportal decompressions of the anterior craniocervical junction with retropharyngeal approach.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the direct anterior decompression of the craniocervical junction in patients with bulbomedullary compression using a full-endoscopic uniportal technique via an anterolateral retropharyngeal approach.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Acute or progressive myelopathy may necessitate direct anterior decompression of the craniocervical junction and odontoidectomy. Different techniques with individual advantages and disadvantages can be used. In addition to the gold standard - the transoral approach - there is increasing experience with the endoscopic transnasal technique. Other alternative procedures are also being developed.

METHODS

Between 2013 and 2016, eight patients with basilar impression, retrodental pannus, or retrodental infection were operated in the full-endoscopic uniportal technique with a retropharyngeal approach. Anterior decompression of the bulbomedullary junction with odontoidectomy was performed. All patients additionally underwent posterior stabilization. Imaging and clinical data were collected in follow-up examinations for 1 year.

RESULTS

The bulbomedullary junction was adequately decompressed. No problems due to swelling of pharyngeal soft tissue occurred. One patient required revision due to secondary bleeding. No other complications were observed. All patients had a good clinical outcome with stable regression of the myelopathy symptoms and/or healing of the infection. The imaging follow-up showed sufficient decompression of bone and soft tissue in all cases. No evidence was found of increasing instability or failure of posterior fusion.

CONCLUSION

In the operated patients, the full-endoscopic uniportal surgical technique with anterior retropharyngeal approach was found to be a sufficient and minimally invasive method with the known advantages of an endoscopic procedure under continuous irrigation. It should not be viewed only as competition for other surgical techniques - due to its individual technical parameters, it can also be considered to be an alternative or complementary procedure.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4.

Transoral Versus Transnasal Approach for Craniovertebral Junction Pathologies: Never Say Never

OBJECTIVE

For many years, the microsurgical transoral approach (TOA) has been accepted as the "gold standard" for the surgical treatment of a variety of congenital, developmental, and acquired pathologies affecting the craniovertebral junction. In the present study, we try to investigate both experimental and clinical fronts of such a challenging surgery, starting from the updated literature experience. TOA is actually presented as an "old-fashioned" surgical technique dealing with possible bacterial contamination, the need of postoperative nose gastric tube feeding for a week, the possible nasopharyngeal incompetence, and the postoperative tongue swelling. Otherwise, the endoscopic endonasal approach (EEA) appears strongly supported by the modern literature as the true "minimally invasive" procedure.

METHODS

Our clinical experience deals with 23 anterior procedures in paediatric and adult patients (17 TOA and 6 EEA). We further report on our experimental cadaver laboratory study of 12 subjects.

RESULTS

All the patients of TOA group but one were discharged after posterior procedures within two weeks and improved or remained unchanged after surgery and during the follow-up. No mayor complications occurred in TOA group. In EEA group two patients died for cerebrospinal fluid infection, for disease progression and for heart attack.

CONCLUSION

Our and other available data suggest that no clear superiority of EEA over endoscopic TOA can be assessed so far; on the other hand, EEA can produce complications similar to TOA in craniovertebral junction surgery.

Walk the Line. The Surgical Highways to the Craniovertebral Junction in Endoscopic Approaches: A Historical Perspective

BACKGROUND

We compiled a comprehensive literature review on the anatomic and clinical results of endoscopic approaches to the craniocervical junction (CVJ) to better contribute to identify the best strategy.

METHODS

An updated literature review was performed in the PubMed, OVID, and Google Scholar medical databases, using the terms "Craniovertebral junction," "Transoral approach," "Transnasal approach," "Transcervical approach," "Endoscopic endonasal approach," "Endoscopic transoral approach," "Endoscopic transcervical approach." Clinical series, anatomic studies, and comparative studies were reviewed.

RESULTS

Pure endonasal and cervical endoscopic approaches still have some disadvantages, including the learning curve and the deeper surgical field. Endoscopically assisted transoral surgery with 30° endoscopes represents an emerging option to standard microsurgical techniques for transoral approaches to the anterior CVJ. This approach should be considered as complementary rather than an alternative to the traditional microsurgical transoral-transpharyngeal approach.

CONCLUSIONS

The transoral approach with sparing of the soft palate still remains the gold standard compared with the pure transnasal and transcervical approaches because of the wider working channel provided by the former technique. The transnasal endoscopic approach alone appears to be superior when the CVJ lesion exceeds the upper limit of the inferior third of the clivus.

Direct and Oblique Approaches to the Craniovertebral Junction: Nuances of Microsurgical and Endoscope-Assisted Techniques Along with a Review of the Literature

PURPOSE

The aim of this review is to provide an update of the technical nuances of microsurgical and endoscopic-assisted approaches to the craniovertebral junction (transnasal, transoral, and transcervical), and to report on the available clinical results in order to identify the best strategy.

METHODS

A nonsystematic update of the reviews and reporting on the anatomical and clinical results of endoscopic-assisted and microsurgical approaches to the craniovertebral junction (CVJ) was performed.

RESULTS

Pure endonasal and cervical endoscopic approaches still have some disadvantages, including their steep learning curves and their deeper surgical fields. Endoscopically assisted transoral surgery with 30° endoscopes represents an emerging option compared with standard microsurgical techniques for transoral approaches to the anterior CVJ. This approach should be considered as complementary to, rather than as an alternative to the traditional transoral-transpharyngeal approach.

CONCLUSIONS

The transoral (microsurgical or video-assisted) approach with sparing of the soft palate still remains the gold standard compared with the "pure" transnasal and transcervical approaches, due to the wider working channel provided by the former technique. The transnasal endoscopic approach alone appears to be superior when the CVJ lesion exceeds the upper limit of the inferior third of the clivus. Of particular interest is the evidence that advances in reduction techniques can avoid the ventral approach.

Craniovertebral Junction Transanasal and Transoral Approaches: Reconstruct the Surgical Pathways with Soft or Hard Tissue Endocopic Lines? This Is the Question

A variety of pathological conditions may affect the clivus and the craniovertebral junction (CVJ). These include congenital disorders, chronic inflammation, neoplasms, infections, and posttraumatic conditions that could all result in CVJ compression and myelopathy Endoscopic-assisted procedures have been further developed for CVJ decompression and they have now become conventional approaches. The aims of the present study were:(1) to compare "radiological" and "surgical" nasoaxial lines (NAxLs); (2) to introduce an analogous radiological line as a predictor of the superior extension of the transoral approach (palatine inferior dental arch line (PIA); (3) to compare the "radiological" nasopalatine line (NPL) with the "surgical" NPL (SNPL) and surgical PIA (SPIA); (4) to compare "our" SNPL with the NAxL; and (5) to find possible radiological reference points to predict, preoperatively, the maximal extent of superior dissection for the transoral approach (SPIA).

Endoscopic endonasal resection of the odontoid process: clinical outcomes in 34 adults

OBJECTIVE Treatment of odontoid disease from a ventral corridor has consisted of a transoral approach. More recently, the endoscopic endonasal approach (EEA) has been used to access odontoid pathology. METHODS A retrospective review was conducted of patients who underwent an EEA for odontoid pathology from 2004 to 2013. During our analysis, the mean follow-up duration was 42.6 months (range 1-80 months). Patient outcomes, complications, and postoperative swallowing function were assessed either by clinic visit or phone contact. RESULTS Thirty-four patients underwent an EEA for symptomatic odontoid pathology. The most common pathology treated was basilar invagination (n = 17). Other pathologies included odontoid fractures, os odontoideum, and metastatic carcinoma. The mean patient age was 71.5 years. Thirty-one patients underwent a posterior fusion. All 34 patients experienced stability or improvement in symptoms and all had successful radiographic decompression. The overall complication rate was 76%. Nearly all of these complications were transient (86%) and the overall complication rate excluding mild transient dysphagia was only 44%. Twenty-one patients (62%) suffered from transient postoperative dysphagia: 15 cases were mild, transient subjective dysphagia (6 of whom had documented preoperative dysphagia), whereas 6 other patients required tube feedings for decreased oral intake, malnutrition, and dysphagia in the perioperative setting (5 of these patients had documented preoperative dysphagia). Sixteen patients had documented preoperative dysphagia and 6 of these had lower cranial nerve dysfunction. Postoperatively, 6 (37.5%) of 16 patients with preoperative dysphagia and 4 (67%) of 6 with lower cranial nerve dysfunction had significant dysphagia/respiratory complications. Eighteen patients had no documented preoperative dysphagia and only 2 had significant postoperative dysphagia/respiratory complications (11%). The rates of these complications in patients without preoperative dysphagia were lower than in those with any preoperative dysphagia (p = 0.07) and especially those with preexisting lower cranial neuropathies (p = 0.007). Dysphagia was also significantly more common in patients who underwent occipitocervical fixation (19/26, 73%) than in patients who underwent cervical fusion alone or no fusion (2/8, 25%; p = 0.02). All patients with perioperative dysphagia had improved at follow-up and all patients were tolerating oral diets. No patient suffered from velopalatal insufficiency. Two patients had intraoperative CSF leaks. One of these patients underwent a negative exploratory surgery for a questionable postoperative CSF leak. One patient developed infection in the resection bed requiring debridement and antibiotics. One patient died 8 days following surgery from an unknown cause. The 90-day perioperative mortality rate was 2.9%. CONCLUSIONS A completely EEA can be performed for compressive odontoid disease in all cases of neoplastic, degenerative, or invaginative atlantoaxial disease with satisfactory outcomes and low morbidity. Transient perioperative dysphagia and respiratory complications are common, usually as an exacerbation and reflection of underlying disease or occipitocervical fusion rather than the EEA, emphasizing the importance of avoiding transoral surgery.

Endoscopic approach to the upper cervical spine and clivus: an anatomical study of the upper limits of the transoral corridor

BACKGROUND

Recent advances in endoscopic techniques have allowed minimally invasive approaches to the cranio-vertebral junction (CVJ) through the oropharynx (ETA) in addition to the transnasal approach (EEA). These minimally invasive endoscopic techniques allow for increased surgical exposure using no visible incisions, with a potential less morbidity. The ability to know preoperatively the limit of the ETA is vital for the surgical planning in order to better address CVJ pathology. The aim of the present study is to determine the anatomical limits of endoscopic dissection of the skull base and upper cervical spine through the transoral corridor and the superior limit reached by adopting this approach.

METHODS

Six fresh-frozen adult cadaver heads were dissected adopting ETA preserving the hard and soft palate. The most superior extent of the exposure was dissected. Post-operative CT scans were performed to confirm the superior extent.

RESULTS

The superior most limit of dissection corresponded to the sphenoid-occipital junction, where the basilar portion of the occipital bone joins with the sphenoid bone's body. This ranged from 12.7 to 18.9 mm above the line of the hard palate. This was achieved without having to transgress any of the palatine structures.

CONCLUSIONS

The sphenoid-occipital junction represents the rostral limit of endoscopic transoral approach to the lower skull base and CVJ area. This approach is limited superiorly by the orientation of the hard palate and mouth aperture and lower dentition due to the linear nature of the endoscope. Using the endoscope for this approach can allow for a more superior exposure than the traditional open transoral approach.

Endoscopic Endonasal Approach for Craniovertebral Junction Pathologic Conditions: Myth and Truth in Clinical Series and Personal Experience

OBJECTIVE

For many years, the microsurgical transoral approach has been accepted as the gold standard for anterior decompressions of the craniovertebral junction (CVJ). The introduction of the endoscopic endonasal approach (EEA) has gained wide recognition and overwhelming support in recent years, including for diseases of the CVJ. The aim of this study was to critically analyze and discuss all cases of CVJ diseases approached by means of an EEA so far reported in the literature, including our institutional experience consisting of 6 consecutive patients.

METHODS

Six consecutive patients affected by CVJ disease underwent an EEA. Three patients had a tumor (2 chordomas and 1 myeloma) and 3 had impressio basilaris.

RESULTS

Five patients had an uncomplicated postoperative course and 1 developed an intraoperative cerebrospinal fluid leak and subsequent meningitis and died 5 weeks after surgery. A total of 107 patients (including our 6) affected by CVJ disease and treated with EEA have been reported so far. Among these patients, cerebrospinal fluid leak was reported in 13 (12.4%), transient velopharyngeal incompetence in 6 (5.6%), postoperative epistaxis in 2 (1.86%), and respiratory dysfunction requiring a tracheostomy in 2 (1.86%). In our extended institutional series of more than 20 consecutive anterior decompressions for CVJ diseases (including transoral and transnasal microsurgical approaches), the only fatal complication was associated with EEA.

CONCLUSIONS

On the basis of the reviewed literature and our personal experience, the reported increased safety of the EEA needs to be reassessed and discussed.