“I Didn’t Know He Was Dying”: Missed Opportunities for Making End-of-Life Care Decisions for Older Family Members

Preference and Influencing Factors of Advance Care Planning for Chinese Elderly Patients With Chronic Diseases: A Mixed-Methods Approach

The incidence of chronic diseases among elderly patients increases annually with the accelerating aging process in China. Complications arising from the progression of these diseases may affect the ability of the aged to communicate and make decisions about future medical and personal care. This study aimed to investigate acceptance and influencing factors of advance care planning for community-dwelling elderly patients with chronic diseases in the Republic of China. Using a convergent parallel mixed-methods design, 471 elderly Chinese nationals older than 60 years with chronic diseases were recruited using convenience sampling. Quantitative data collection used Chinese versions of the Elderly Death Attitude Scale, Modified Barthel Index Rating Scale, and the Advance Care Planning Acceptance Questionnaire, followed by 14 patients drawn from the quantitative phase. Interviews were thematically analyzed. The results showed that attitude to death and quality of life were key predictors of advance care planning implementation preference, whereas family support and past medical experience were significant factors. The study highlighted the importance of conducting regular education about death, paying attention to quality of life, providing family support, and discussing past medical experience in order to implement advance care planning for elderly patients with chronic diseases in China.

Bereaved families' experiences of end-of-life decision making for general medicine patients

BACKGROUND

Family involvement in decision making for hospitalised patients is associated with improved end-of-life care. Yet, these discussions can be challenging for physicians and families and associated with distress, confusion and conflict. There is a need to understand how best to support families involved in decisions regarding the transition from active to palliative treatment in hospital settings.

AIM

To explore bereaved families' experiences of end-of-life decision making for general medicine patients.

DESIGN

A qualitative exploratory study framed by social constructionism using semistructured interviews and thematic analysis.

SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS

The general medicine units of one large public hospital in Melbourne, Australia. We recruited 28 bereaved family members of patients who had received end-of-life care.

FINDINGS

Patients and families depended on physicians to explain clinical complexity and treatment beneficence; however, trust in medical judgement was mediated by participant's own interpretations of clinical progress. Families sought to be respected as advocates and experienced distress if physicians disregarded their perspectives and insight concerning patient preferences. Ideally, families supported patients to express their preferences to physicians. Otherwise, families contextualised treatment decisions through their knowledge of patient's values and quality of life. Families often felt burdened by or excluded from medical decision making and experienced distress and confusion regarding their rights to request or refuse treatment.

CONCLUSION

Our study highlights how families contribute to decision making to ensure end-of-life care treatments reflect patient preferences. Physicians can ease families' distress around treatment withdrawal by providing a meaningful explanation of complex clinical issues, clarifying decision-making roles and acknowledge families' desire to protect and advocate for their loved one.

Challenges of older adults when a loved one was dying: Implications for nursing practice

AIMS

To explore the challenge of losing a loved one who was hospitalized at end of life and identify approaches deemed most helpful by older adult family members to resolve this challenge.

BACKGROUND

Nurses will be caring for a growing number of terminally ill older adults and their families. Research specific to older adults to address their needs when a loved one is dying is necessary to promote quality family-oriented care.

METHODS

A qualitative descriptive exploratory study was conducted with a purposive sample of 15 older adult family members during July-August 2015. Methods for data collection and analysis included story theory inquiry and theory-guided content analysis.

RESULTS

The dimensions of the challenge of losing a loved one include: moving from painful holding on to poignant letting go, uneasiness that permeates everyday living and precious memories, patterns of disconnect that breed discontent, and pervasive ambiguity that permeates perspectives about remaining time. Active engagement enabling exceptional care for loved ones, appreciating the rhythmic flow of everyday connecting and separating to get by, and embracing reality as situated in one's lifelong journey are the approaches to resolve this challenge.

CONCLUSIONS

Knowing a loved one was well cared for through nurses' compassionate caring was most important to older adults. Further research to address the self-care strategies of older adults as a loved one is dying is necessary. This study's nursing implications has the potential to enhance the quality of family-oriented care at end of life in diverse healthcare settings.

End-of-life care in intellectual disability: a retrospective cross-sectional study

Background

Adults with intellectual disability (ID) experience inequality in access to healthcare that is considered to extend to end-of-life care. Their experiences of healthcare at the end of life and how these compare with the general population are unknown.

Aim

To describe the end-of-life care outcomes for adults with ID living in residential care in the UK using the VOICES-SF questionnaire and compare these with the general population.

Design

Nationwide population-based postbereavement survey.

Participants

38 ID care providers took part in the study. The supported over 13 000 people with ID. Over the 18-month period of data collection, 222 deaths were reported. The survey was completed, by care staff, for 157 (70.7%) of those deaths.

Results

Decedents had complex health, functional and behavioural needs. Death was unanticipated in a high proportion of cases. Quality of care provided across care settings was generally well rated. However, hospital care and care provided at the time of was less well rated, particularly in comparison with the general population. Respondents reported low levels of involvement in care and awareness of approaching death among adults with ID, and lower than in the general population.

Conclusions

Access to end-of-life care for adults with ID may be constrained by a failure to identify approaching the end of life. The high proportion of unexpected deaths in this population warrants further study. There is a need to increase and support the involvement of adults with ID to be active partners in planning care at the end of their lives.

Information Framing Reduces Initial Negative Attitudes in Cancer Patients' Decisions About Hospice Care

BACKGROUND

Negative attitudes toward hospice care might prevent patients with cancer from discussing and choosing hospice as they approach end of life. When making a decision, people often naturally focus on either expected benefits or the avoidance of harm. Behavioral research has demonstrated that framing information in an incongruent manner with patients' underlying motivational focus reduces their negative attitudes toward a disliked option.

OBJECTIVE

Our study tests this communication technique with cancer patients, aiming to reduce negative attitudes toward a potentially beneficial but often-disliked option, that is, hospice care.

METHODS

Patients (n = 42) with active cancer of different types and/or stages completed a paper survey. Participants read a vignette about a patient with advanced cancer and a limited prognosis. In the vignette, the physician's advice to enroll in a hospice program was randomized, creating a congruent message or an incongruent message with patients' underlying motivational focus (e.g., a congruent message for someone most interested in benefits focuses on the benefits of hospice, whereas an incongruent message for this patient focuses on avoiding harm). Patients' attitudes toward hospice were measured before and after receiving the physician's advice.

RESULTS

Regression analyses indicated that information framing significantly influenced patients with strong initial negative attitudes. Patients were more likely to reduce intensity of their initial negative attitude about hospice when receiving an incongruent message (b = -0.23; P < 0.01) than a congruent one (b = -0.13; P = 0.08).

CONCLUSION

This finding suggests a new theory-driven approach to conversations with cancer patients who may harbor negative reactions toward hospice care.