Whole blood and Hextend: Bookends of modern tactical combat casualty care field resuscitation and starting point for multifunctional resuscitation fluid development

The Use of Large Animal Models in Trauma and Bleeding Studies

BACKGROUND

 Major trauma often results in significant bleeding and coagulopathy, posing a substantial clinical burden. To understand the underlying pathophysiology and to refine clinical strategies to overcome coagulopathy, preclinical large animal models are often used. This review scrutinizes the clinical relevance of large animal models in hemostasis research, emphasizing challenges in translating findings into clinical therapies.

METHODS

 We conducted a thorough search of PubMed and EMBASE databases from January 1, 2010, to December 31, 2022. We used specific keywords and inclusion/exclusion criteria centered on large animal models.

RESULTS

 Our review analyzed 84 pertinent articles, including four animal species: pigs, sheep, dogs, and nonhuman primates (NHPs). Eighty-five percent of the studies predominantly utilized porcine models. Meanwhile, sheep and dogs were less represented, making up only 2.5% of the total studies. Models with NHP were 10%. The most frequently used trauma models involved a combination of liver injury and femur fractures (eight studies), arterial hemorrhage (seven studies), and a combination of hemodilution and liver injury (seven studies). A wide array of coagulation parameters were employed to assess the efficacy of interventions in hemostasis and bleeding control.

CONCLUSIONS

 Recognizing the diverse strengths and weaknesses of large animal models is critical for trauma and hemorrhage research. Each model is unique and should be chosen based on how well it aligns with the specific scientific objectives of the study. By strategically considering each model's advantages and limitations, we can enhance our understanding of trauma and hemorrhage pathophysiology and further advance the development of effective treatments.

A Multifunctional, Low-Volume Resuscitation Cocktail Improves Vital Organ Blood Flow and Hemostasis in a Pig Model of Polytrauma with Traumatic Brain Injury

The resuscitation of polytrauma with hemorrhagic shock and traumatic brain injury (TBI) is a balance between permissive hypotension and maintaining vital organ perfusion. There is no current optimal solution. This study tested whether a multifunctional resuscitation cocktail supporting hemostasis and perfusion could mitigate blood loss while improving vital organ blood flow during prolonged limited resuscitation. Anesthetized Yorkshire swine were subjected to fluid percussion TBI, femur fracture, catheter hemorrhage, and aortic tear. Fluid resuscitation was started when lactate concentration reached 3–4 mmol/L. Animals were randomized to one of five groups. All groups received hydroxyethyl starch solution and vasopressin. Low- and high-dose fibrinogen (FBG) groups additionally received 100 and 200 mg/kg FBG, respectively. A third group received TXA and low-dose FBG. Two control groups received albumin, with one also including TXA. Animals were monitored for up to 6 h. Blood loss was decreased and vital organ blood flow was improved with low- and high-dose fibrinogen compared to albumin controls, but survival was not improved. There was no additional benefit of high- vs. low-dose FBG on blood loss or survival. TXA alone decreased blood loss but had no effect on survival, and combining TXA with FBG provided no additional benefit. Pooled analysis of all groups containing fibrinogen vs. albumin controls found improved survival, decreased blood loss, and improved vital organ blood flow with fibrinogen delivery. In conclusion, a low-volume resuscitation cocktail consisting of hydroxyethyl starch, vasopressin, and fibrinogen concentrate improved outcomes compare to controls during limited resuscitation of polytrauma.

Fresh frozen plasma attenuates lung injury in a novel model of prolonged hypotensive resuscitation

BACKGROUND

Hemorrhagic shock remains a leading cause of early death among severely injured in both civilian and military settings. As future military operations will require strategies allowing prolonged field care of the injured, we sought to develop an in vivo model of prolonged hypotensive resuscitation (PHR) and to evaluate the role of plasma-based resuscitation in this model. We hypothesized that resuscitation with fresh frozen plasma (FFP) would mitigate lung injury when compared with Hextend in a rodent model of PHR.

METHODS

Mice underwent laparotomy and hemorrhagic shock (mean arterial blood pressure, 35 ± 5 mm Hg × 90 minutes) followed by PHR with either FFP or Hextend to maintain a mean arterial blood pressure of 55 mm Hg to 60 mm Hg for 6 hours. Sham animals underwent cannulation only. At the end of 6 hours, animals were euthanized, and lung tissue harvested for measurement of histopathologic injury, inflammation and permeability using hematoxylin and eosin staining, myeloperoxidase immunofluorescence staining and Evans Blue dye. Pulmonary syndecan-1 immunostaining was assessed as an indicator of endothelial cell integrity.

RESULTS

All animals in the FFP, Hextend, and sham groups survived to the end of resuscitation. Resuscitation with FFP mitigated lung histopathologic injury compared with Hextend (histologic injury score of 4.38 ± 2.07 vs. 7.5 ± 0.93, scale of 0-9, p = 0.002) and was comparable to shams (histologic injury score of 4.0 ± 1.93, scale of 0-9, p = 0.99). Fresh frozen plasma also reduced lung inflammation (0.116 ± 0.044 vs. 0.308 ± 0.054 relative fluorescence of myeloperoxidase, p = 0.002) and restored pulmonary syndecan-1 (0.514 ± 0.061 vs. 0.059 ± 0.021, relative syndecan-1 fluorescence, p < 0.001) when compared with Hextend. Consistently, FFP mitigated lung hyperpermeability compared with Hextend (7.30 ± 1.34 μg vs. 14.91 ± 5.55 μg Evans blue/100 mg lung tissue, p = 0.005).

CONCLUSION

We have presented a novel model of PHR of military relevance to the prolonged field care environment. In this model, FFP maintains its pulmonary protective effects using a PHR strategy compared with Hextend, which supports the need for further development and implementation of plasma-based resuscitation in the forward environment.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Basic science.

Noninvasive Cerebral Perfusion and Oxygenation Monitoring Augment Prolonged Field Care in a Non-Human Primate Model of Decompensated Hemorrhage and Resuscitation

BACKGROUND

Decompensated hemorrhagic shock (DHS) is the leading cause of preventable death in combat casualties. "Golden hour" resuscitation effects on cerebral blood flow and perfusion following DHS in prolonged field care (PFC) are not well investigated. Using an established non-human primate model of DHS, we hypothesized noninvasive regional tissue oxygenation (rSO2) and Transcranial Doppler (TCD) would correlate to the invasive measurement of partial pressure of oxygen (PtO2) and mean arterial pressure (MAP) in guiding hypotensive resuscitation in a PFC setting.

METHODS

Ten rhesus macaques underwent DHS followed by a 2 h PFC phase (T0-T120), and subsequent 4 h hospital resuscitation phase (T120-T360). Invasive monitoring (PtO2, MAP) was compared against noninvasive monitoring systems (rSO2, TCD). Results were analyzed using t tests and one-way repeated measures ANOVA. Linear correlation was determined via Pearson r. Significance = P < 0.05.

RESULTS

MAP, PtO2, rSO2, and mean flow velocity (MFV) significantly decreased from baseline at T0. MAP and PtO2 were restored to baseline by T15, while rSO2 was delayed through T30. At T120, MFV returned to baseline, while the Pulsatility Index significantly elevated by T120 (1.50 ± 0.31). PtO2 versus rSO2 (R2 = 0.2099) and MAP versus MFV (R2 = 0.2891) shared very weak effect sizes, MAP versus rSO2 (R2 = 0.4636) displayed a low effect size, and PtO2 versus MFV displayed a moderate effect size (R2 = 0.5540).

CONCLUSIONS

Though noninvasive monitoring methods assessed here did not correlate strongly enough against invasive methods to warrant a surrogate in the field, they do effectively augment and direct resuscitation, while potentially serving as a substitute in the absence of invasive capabilities.

Minimally invasive preperitoneal balloon tamponade and abdominal aortic junctional tourniquet versus open packing for pelvic fracture-associated hemorrhage: Not all extrinsic compression is equal

BACKGROUND

Minimally invasive preperitoneal balloon tamponade (PPB) and abdominal aortic junctional tourniquets (AAJT) have been proposed as alternatives to open preperitoneal packing (OP) for the management of pelvic fracture-associated hemorrhage. We hypothesized that the PPB (SpaceMaker Pro) and AAJT would result in similar rates of survival and blood loss versus OP.

METHODS

Thirty-two swine underwent creation of a combined open-book pelvic fracture and major iliac vascular injuries. Animals were randomized to no intervention (n = 7), OP (n = 10), PPB (n = 9), or AAJT (n = 6) at a mean arterial pressure <40 mm Hg following initiation of uncontrolled hemorrhage. Survival (up to 60 minutes + 10 minutes after intervention reversal), hemodynamics, extraperitoneal pressures, blood loss, and associated complications were compared between groups.

RESULTS

Prior to injury, no difference was measured between groups for weight, hemodynamics, lactate, and hematocrit (all p > 0.05). The injury was uniformly lethal without intervention, with survival time (mean) of 5 minutes, peak preperitoneal pressure (PP) of 14 mm Hg, blood loss of 960 g, and peak lactate of 2.6 mmol/L. Survival time was 44 minutes with OP versus 60 minutes with PPB and AAJT (p < 0.01). Peak PP (mm Hg) was 19 with OP, 23 with PPB, and 23 with AAJT (p > 0.05). Blood loss (g) was 850 with OP, 930 with PPB, and 600 with AAJT (p > 0.05). Peak lactate (mmol/L) was 3.3 with OP, 4.3 with PPB, and 6.3 with AAJT (p < 0.01). Only 33% of AAJT animals survived intervention reversal versus 60% for OP and 67% for PPB (p < 0.01). Necropsy revealed bowel/bladder injury in 50% of AAJT subjects versus 0% in all other arms (p < 0.01).

CONCLUSION

Preperitoneal balloon tamponade is a safe and potentially effective alternative to OP for the management of lethal pelvic fracture-associated hemorrhage. Abdominal aortic junctional tourniquet offers a similar survival benefit to PPB but has concerning rates of ischemia-reperfusion and compressive abdominal organ injury.

Prehospital whole blood resuscitation prevents coagulopathy and improves acid-base status at hospital arrival in a nonhuman primate hemorrhagic shock model

BACKGROUND

Hemorrhage remains the primary cause of preventable death in civilian and military trauma. The Committee on Tactical Combat Casualty Care recommends prehospital (PH) resuscitation with whole blood (WB). However, 6% hetastarch in lactated electrolyte (HEX) and crystalloids are more commonly available and used for PH resuscitation in military and civilian environments, respectively. The mechanistic benefits of PH WB resuscitation have not been well studied and remain to be elucidated.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

The aim of this study was to evaluate the differences in simulated PH WB and HEX resuscitation, specifically with regards to coagulation, physiologic, and metabolic outcomes to better elucidate the mechanistic benefits of WB. In a randomized study, the physiologic, coagulation, and metabolic responses to simulated PH WB (n = 12) or HEX (n = 12) were evaluated in a nonhuman primate model of severe polytraumatic hemorrhagic shock.

RESULTS

Notable findings included 1) equivalence of shock reversal between simulated PH WB and HEX treatment groups as determined by hemodynamics and base deficit and 2) prevention of coagulopathy at simulated hospital arrival with initial WB resuscitation as determined by viscoelastic and plasmatic coagulation assays.

CONCLUSION

The major benefit of WB, as compared to HEX, in simulated PH resuscitation appears to be prevention of coagulopathy at hospital arrival. Both fluids effectively reversed shock in this model, implying that efficacious provision preload (cardiac output support and hence oxygen delivery) and coagulation proteins (prevention of coagulopathy) are mechanisms underlying WB's effectiveness in early resuscitation of hemorrhagic shock.

Efficacy of the perfluorocarbon dodecafluoropentane as an adjunct to pre-hospital resuscitation

BACKGROUND

Hemorrhage is the most common cause of preventable death in the pre-hospital phase in trauma, with a critical capability gap optimizing pre-hospital resuscitation in austere environments. One promising avenue is the concept of a multi-functional resuscitation fluid (MRF) that contains a blood product backbone with agents that promote clotting and enhance oxygen delivery. Oxygen therapeutics, such as hemoglobin based oxygen carriers(HBOCs) and perfluorocarbons(PFCs), may be a critical MRF component. Our purpose was to assess the efficacy of resuscitation with a PFC, dodecafluoropentane(DDFPe), compared to fresh whole blood(FWB).

METHODS AND FINDINGS

Forty-five swine(78±5kg) underwent splenectomy and controlled hemorrhage via femoral arterial catheter until shock physiology(lactate = 7.0) was achieved prior to randomization into the following groups: 1) Control-no intervention, 2)Hextend-500mL, 3)FFP-500mL, 4)FFP+DDFPe-500mL, 5)FWB-500mL. Animals were observed for an additional 180 minutes following randomization.

RESULTS

Baseline physiologic values did not statistically differ. At T = 60min, FWB had significantly decreased lactate(p = 0.001) and DDFPe was not statistically different from control. There was no statistical significance in tissue oxygenation(StO2) between groups at T = 60min. Survival was highest in the FWB and Hextend groups(30% at 180min). Kaplan-Meier analysis showed decreased survival of DDFPe+FFP in comparison to FWB(p<0.05) and was not significantly different from control or FFP. Four animals who received DDFPe died within 10 minutes of administration. This study was limited by a group receiving DDFPe alone, however this would not be feasible in this lethal swine model as DDFPe given its small volume.

CONCLUSION

DDFPe administration with FFP does not improve survival or enhance tissue oxygenation. However, given similar survival rates of Hextend and FWB, there is evidence that an ideal MRF should contain an element of volume expansion to enhance oxygen delivery.