Subclinical Rhythmic EEG Discharge of Adult (SREDA) in a Child With Generalized Epilepsy and Literature Review of SREDA in Children:

Four Atypical Cases of Subclinical Rhythmic Electroencephalogram Discharge of Adults: Case Series and Review

SUMMARY

Subclinical rhythmic EEG discharge of adults is an uncommon variant that represents a diagnostic challenge in the clinical practice because it can be mistaken for an electrographic seizure. We present a case series of four patients who underwent EEG because of suspicious events or an unclear medical history of epilepsy. In all cases, the EEG revealed atypical features including focal and asymmetric distribution, presentation during NREM and REM sleep, rhythmic activity in the delta range with a notched appearance and blocked by eyes opening.

Normal variants and artifacts: Importance in EEG interpretation

Overinterpretation of EEG is an important contributor to the misdiagnosis of epilepsy. For the EEG to have a high diagnostic value and high specificity, it is critical to recognize waveforms that can be mistaken for abnormal patterns. This article describes artifacts, normal rhythms, and normal patterns that are prone to being misinterpreted as abnormal. Artifacts are potentials generated outside the brain. They are divided into physiologic and extraphysiologic. Physiologic artifacts arise from the body and include EMG, eyes, various movements, EKG, pulse, and sweat. Some physiologic artifacts can be useful for interpretation such as EMG and eye movements. Extraphysiologic artifacts arise from outside the body, and in turn can be divided into the environments (electrodes, equipment, and cellphones) and devices within the body (pacemakers and neurostimulators). Normal rhythms can be divided into awake patterns (alpha rhythm and its variants, mu rhythm, lambda waves, posterior slow waves of youth, HV-induced slowing, photic driving, and photomyogenic response) and sleep patterns (POSTS, vertex waves, spindles, K complexes, sleep-related hypersynchrony, and frontal arousal rhythm). Breach can affect both awake and sleep rhythms. Normal variants or variants of uncertain clinical significance include variants that may have been considered abnormal in the early days of EEG but are now considered normal. These include wicket spikes and wicket rhythms (the most common normal pattern overread as epileptiform), small sharp spikes (aka benign epileptiform transients of sleep), rhythmic midtemporal theta of drowsiness (aka psychomotor variant), Cigánek rhythm (aka midline theta), 6 Hz phantom spike-wave, 14 and 6 Hz positive spikes, subclinical rhythmic epileptiform discharges of adults (SREDA), slow-fused transients, occipital spikes of blindness, and temporal slowing of the elderly. Correctly identifying artifacts and normal patterns can help avoid overinterpretation and misdiagnosis. This is an educational review paper addressing a learning objective of the International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) curriculum.

Critically ill benign EEG variants: Is there such a thing?

Despite growing use of critical care electroencephalography (ccEEG) to detect seizures and status epilepticus in the intensive care unit (ICU), integrating ccEEG findings with traditionally described benign EEG variants (BEVs) is a relatively new concept. BEV-like waveforms are now increasingly encountered in the ICU, and have also been explicitly included in proposed definitions of brief potentially ictal rhythmic discharges (BIRDs) in the ICU, bringing to the fore the question of if and which EEG patterns in critically ill patients can be safely deemed "benign". Though well-characterized as benign in healthy outpatients at low pre-test risk for neurologic disease, the significance of BEVs in the ICU remains largely unknown. Simultaneously, there has been mounting evidence to suggest that certain BEVs can arise from heterogeneous intracranial sources, including some pathologic generators. We conducted an extensive literature review on all known BEVs to assess what is known of BEVs in the ICU. Here we discuss critically ill BEVs and how to interpret them.

SREDA: A Rare but Confusing Benign EEG Variant

INTRODUCTION

Subclinical rhythmic EEG discharges in adults (SREDA) is a very rare benign EEG pattern. The electrophysiological features and atypical variants of SREDA has wide spectrum and they are poorly known. It resembles ictal discharges, and overinterpretation of SREDA may lead to misdiagnosis of epilepsy. Herein, we aimed to report patients with SREDA to identify the frequency and characterized clinical, demographic, electrophysiological features.

METHODS

We reviewed 22,234 EEG reports that are reported by the same experienced clinical neurophysiologists, between 2012 and 2018. The EEGs with SREDA were reevaluated blindly by three clinical neurophysiologists. The demographic, clinical characteristics, and neuroimaging features of the patients were reviewed.

RESULTS

Subclinical rhythmic EEG discharges in adults was present in 14 EEG records (0.06%), in nine patients. The mean age of patients was 52.1 ± 17.7 (range, 21-71) years. The patients had been diagnosed with several neurologic diseases, including cerebrovascular disease, epilepsy, psychogenic nonepileptic seizures, mental retardation, Alzheimer disease, and transient global amnesia. One patient had unilateral lesion, in whom SREDA had appeared on contralateral side of the lesion, whereas other patients with normal or nonlateralized lesions had SREDA bilaterally and symmetrical. This variant had been misdiagnosed as an ictal discharge in previous EEGs in three patients.

CONCLUSIONS

This study indicates that SREDA is difficult to associate with any specific condition. The pathophysiology of SREDA can not be explained by a single mechanism. Even if it is mostly observed in older adults, it is also observed in young adults in this study. It is important to differentiate SREDA from ictal discharge to prevent misdiagnosis of epilepsy especially in nonepileptic paroxysmal events.

Atypical SREDA During Wakefulness, NREM and REM Sleep in a Young Teenager: A Diagnostic Challenge

Subclinical rhythmic electrographic discharges of adult (SREDA) is a rare variant considered to be normal in EEG. It consists of sharp-contoured or sinusoidal waveforms in the theta frequency range (usually 5-7 Hz), occurring in a widespread distribution, often maximal over the parietotemporal regions. SREDA is usually bilateral but could be unilateral (atypical SREDA). Compared with true ictal activities, SREDA has little change in frequency, morphology, and distribution. It has been described in adults and is extremely rare in children/adolescents. There are only 5 cases published in children. We report a case of atypical SREDA in a child that may have occurred in wakefulness, non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep, and REM sleep. This finding was initially misdiagnosed as epilepsy. Inpatient video-EEG demonstrated that during periods of SREDA in quiet wakefulness the patient did not have any signs or symptoms with the SREDA pattern; SREDA abated whenever the patient was alerted or if he spontaneously initiated some activities. SREDA with same morphology was noted in NREM and REM sleep. The patient had no true epileptogenic abnormalities and hence antiepileptic medication was discontinued and stopped uneventfully. This case illustrates the importance of recognizing this rare variant, avoiding a misdiagnosis of epilepsy as it occurred in our case.