Comparison of the binding of the human papillomavirus type 16 and cottontail rabbit papillomavirus E7 proteins to the retinoblastoma gene product

The Mus musculus Papillomavirus Type 1 E7 Protein Binds to the Retinoblastoma Tumor Suppressor: Implications for Viral Pathogenesis

The species specificity of papillomaviruses has been a significant roadblock for performing in vivo pathogenesis studies in common model organisms. The Mus musculus papillomavirus type 1 (MmuPV1) causes cutaneous papillomas that can progress to squamous cell carcinomas in laboratory mice. The papillomavirus E6 and E7 genes encode proteins that establish and maintain a cellular milieu that allows for viral genome synthesis and viral progeny synthesis in growth-arrested, terminally differentiated keratinocytes. The E6 and E7 proteins provide this activity by binding to and functionally reprogramming key cellular regulatory proteins. The MmuPV1 E7 protein lacks the canonical LXCXE motif that mediates the binding of multiple viral oncoproteins to the cellular retinoblastoma tumor suppressor protein, RB1. Our proteomic experiments, however, revealed that MmuPV1 E7 still interacts with RB1. We show that MmuPV1 E7 interacts through its C terminus with the C-terminal domain of RB1. Binding of MmuPV1 E7 to RB1 did not cause significant activation of E2F-regulated cellular genes. MmuPV1 E7 expression was shown to be essential for papilloma formation. Experimental infection of mice with MmuPV1 expressing an E7 mutant that is defective for binding to RB1 caused delayed onset, lower incidence, and smaller sizes of papillomas. Our results demonstrate that the MmuPV1 E7 gene is essential and that targeting noncanonical activities of RB1, which are independent of RB1's ability to modulate the expression of E2F-regulated genes, contribute to papillomavirus-mediated pathogenesis. IMPORTANCE Papillomavirus infections cause a variety of epithelial hyperplastic lesions, or warts. While most warts are benign, some papillomaviruses cause lesions that can progress to squamous cell carcinomas, and approximately 5% of all human cancers are caused by human papillomavirus (HPV) infections. The papillomavirus E6 and E7 proteins are thought to function to reprogram host epithelial cells to enable viral genome replication in terminally differentiated, normally growth-arrested cells. E6 and E7 lack enzymatic activities and function by interacting and functionally altering host cell regulatory proteins. Many cellular proteins that can interact with E6 and E7 have been identified, but the biological relevance of these interactions for viral pathogenesis has not been determined. This is because papillomaviruses are species specific and do not infect heterologous hosts. Here, we use a recently established mouse papillomavirus (MmuPV1) model to investigate the role of the E7 protein in viral pathogenesis. We show that MmuPV1 E7 is necessary for papilloma formation. The retinoblastoma tumor suppressor protein (RB1) is targeted by many papillomaviral E7 proteins, including cancer-associated HPVs. We show that MmuPV1 E7 can bind RB1 and that infection with a mutant MmuPV1 virus that expresses an RB1 binding-defective E7 mutant caused smaller and fewer papillomas that arise with delayed kinetics.

Loss of Retinoblastoma Protein, But Not p53, Is Associated With the Presence of Papillomaviral DNA in Feline Viral Plaques, Bowenoid In Situ Carcinomas, and Squamous Cell Carcinomas

Although papillomaviral (PV) DNA is frequently present in feline cutaneous squamous cell carcinomas (SCCs), a causative association cannot be proven. Oncogenic human PVs cause neoplastic transformation by inhibiting retinoblastoma (pRb) and p53 activity. Therefore, absence of pRb and p53 immunostaining, along with increased p16 immunostaining, indicates a PV cause in some human SCCs. If PVs cause cutaneous feline SCCs, it was hypothesized that a similar immunohistochemistry profile, along with PV DNA, would be detectable. This was investigated using 5 feline viral plaques, 10 Bowenoid in situ carcinomas, 19 SCCs from ultraviolet-exposed (UV-exposed) skin, and 11 SCCs from UV-protected skin. Papillomaviral DNA was amplified by polymerase chain reaction from 30 of 45 lesions. Reduced pRb immunostaining was present in 26 of 45; increased p16 immunostaining was in 30; and p53 immunostaining was in 19. Both reduced pRb immunostaining and increased p16 immunostaining were more frequent in lesions containing PV DNA. In contrast, no association was observed between p53 immunostaining and the presence of PV DNA. SCCs from UV-protected skin more frequently contained PV DNA, reduced pRb, and increased p16 than UV-exposed SCCs. UV exposure was not associated with p53 immunostaining within the SCCs. These results suggest that feline PVs alter cell regulation by degrading pRb. Unlike oncogenic human PVs, there was no evidence that feline PVs degrade p53. These results provide further evidence that PVs may cause feline cutaneous SCCs, especially those in UV-protected skin, and they suggest a possible mechanism of this oncogenic action.

Papillomavirus-Associated Cutaneous Neoplasia in Mammals

For humans, strong evidence indicates that some mucosal papillomavirus (PV) types cause genital and oral neoplasia, and weaker evidence suggests that some cutaneous PVs may cause cutaneous squamous cell carcinomas (SCC). For nonhuman species, strong evidence supports a causal role of PVs in the development of feline and equine sarcoids. Likewise, PVs are believed to cause cutaneous SCCs in rabbits, western barred bandicoots, and some rodents. Furthermore, some evidence suggests that PVs may influence the development of both feline and canine cutaneous SCCs. This review discusses the evidence that PVs cause human cutaneous SCCs and the proposed mechanisms for this action. It then reviews preneoplastic and neoplastic skin diseases that are associated with PV infection in nonhuman mammals.

The E7 protein of the cottontail rabbit papillomavirus immortalizes normal rabbit keratinocytes and reduces pRb levels, while E6 cooperates in immortalization but neither degrades p53 nor binds E6AP

Human papillomaviruses (HPVs) cause cervical cancer and are associated with the development of non-melanoma skin cancer. A suitable animal model for papillomavirus-associated skin carcinogenesis is the infection of domestic rabbits with the cottontail rabbit papillomavirus (CRPV). As the immortalizing activity of CRPV genes in the natural target cells remains unknown, we investigated the properties of CRPV E6 and E7 in rabbit keratinocytes (RK) and their influence on the cell cycle. Interestingly, CRPV E7 immortalized RK after a cellular crisis but showed no such activity in human keratinocytes. Co-expressed CRPV E6 prevented cellular crisis. The HPV16 or CRPV E7 protein reduced rabbit pRb levels thereby causing rabbit p19(ARF) induction and accumulation of p53 without affecting cellular proliferation. Both CRPV E6 proteins failed to degrade rabbit p53 in vitro or to bind E6AP; however, p53 was still inducible by mitomycin C. In summary, CRPV E7 immortalizes rabbit keratinocytes in a species-specific manner and E6 contributes to immortalization without directly affecting p53.

Association of cottontail rabbit papillomavirus E6 oncoproteins with the hDlg/SAP97 tumor suppressor

Papillomaviruses are small DNA viruses that infect epithelial tissues and cause warts. Human papillomavirus (HPV) infection is the primary risk factor for the development of cervical cancer. The E6 and E7 oncogenes are the only genes consistently expressed in HPV-positive cervical cancer cells. Cottontail rabbit papillomavirus (CRPV) induces papillomas and carcinomas on cottontail and domestic rabbits and provides an excellent animal model of HPV infection and vaccine development. CRPV encodes three transforming proteins; LE6, SE6, and E7. Each of these proteins is required for papilloma formation. Like HPV E7, the CRPV E7 protein binds to the tumor suppressor pRB. In contrast, unlike HPV E6, the CRPV E6 proteins do not bind the tumor suppressor p53. Although more than a dozen cellular proteins have been identified as HPV E6 interacting proteins, nothing is known about the cellular interacting proteins of CRPV E6s. Here we describe the association of CRPV E6s with hDlg/SAP97, the mammalian homolog of the Drosophila discs large tumor suppressor protein. HPV E6 has previously shown to bind and target hDlg/SAP97 for degradation. Our results demonstrate that both LE6 and SE6 interact with hDlg/SAP97, although their association does not lead to the degradation of hDlg/SAP97. The PDZ domains of hDlg were shown to be sufficient for interaction with CRPV E6 proteins while the C-terminus of CRPV E6 is essential for the interaction with hDlg. The association of hDlg with SE6 may be important but not sufficient for the transformation of NIH 3T3 cells by SE6. Importantly, a CRPV SE6 mutant defective for papilloma formation did not interact with hDlg. These results suggest that interaction with hDlg/SAP97 plays a role in the biological function of CRPV E6s.

A cottontail rabbit papillomavirus strain (CRPVb) with strikingly divergent E6 and E7 oncoproteins: An insight in the evolution of papillomaviruses

We previously observed that warts induced by an isolate of cottontail rabbit papillomavirus (CRPV) showed incomplete instead of systemic regression in some domestic rabbits. We report that the viral isolate contained, as a major component, a CRPV strain (CRPVb) showing an unexpectedly high divergence in the E6 and E7 open reading frames (ORFs), compared to the prototype CRPVa present in the isolate as a minor component. The E6 and E7 oncoproteins of CRPVa and -b disclosed only 87.5% identical amino acids and differed in size by three and two amino acids, respectively. This divergence involved (i) a great number (4.4%) of nucleotide substitutions and a high rate (83.3%) of nonsynonymous mutations; (ii) mutations changing the E6 and E7 stop codons; and (iii) in-frame sequence insertions in the E6 ORF (18 nucleotides) and downstream of the mutated E7 stop codon (6 nucleotides), both likely to result from a duplication of adjacent sequences. These extensive differences could account for distinct biological and antigenic properties. Strikingly, only four (0.8%) amino acids of the L1 major capsid protein were variable. Thus, it seems likely that sequence duplications and mutations affecting stop codons exert a strong selection pressure on the fixation of nonsynonymous mutations and that phylogenetic calculations based only on point mutations may misevaluate the time scale of the evolution of papillomaviruses.

Transforming properties of the cottontail rabbit papillomavirus oncoproteins Le6 and SE6 and of the E8 protein

Cottontail rabbit papillomavirus induces on cottontail and domestic rabbits papillomas which progress at a high frequency to carcinoma. The virus encodes three transforming proteins; one is translated from open reading frame (ORF) E7 and binds the retinoblastoma protein, and two, LE6 and SE6, are translated from the first and second ATGs of ORF E6, respectively. Here we show that neither of the E6 proteins coprecipitated with p53 in vitro, nor did they bind to a recently identified E6-binding protein (J. J. Chen, C. E. Reid, V. Band, and E. Androphy, Science 269:529-531, 1995). This protein was shown to bind to the E6 proteins of the high-risk human papillomairus types 16 and 18 but not to the low-risk human papillomavirus types VI and II. In-frame deletions cloned into the pZipNeo vector were used to identify structural features of SE6 and LE6 important for transformation of NIH 3T3 cells. Three deletions covering the amino-terminal half of SE6 did not transform cells. In two of the three deletions, two Cys-X-X-Cys motifs were deleted, each deletion preventing the formation of one of the potential small Zn fingers of SE6. Among the LE6 deletions, only one had a reduced transformation efficiency, while seven transformed cells at least as efficiently as wild-type LE6. In each of three of these seven mutants, two Cys-X-X-Cys motifs were deleted. None of the three amino acid deletions which abolished transformation by SE6 reduced transformation by LE6. Furthermore, transformation did not correlate with the level of SE6 or LE6 proteins detectable. ORF E8 colinear with ORF E6, which could generate a 50-amino-acid protein with a hydrophobic segment, did not transform cells when cloned into the pZipNeo vector. However, mutation of the E8 ATG, which did not alter the amino acid sequence of LE6, increased transformation by LE6 without affecting the level of LE6 expression. The data suggest that transformation by the E6 proteins is not mediated by interfering with p53 function or through binding to the E6-binding protein. Furthermore, different structural features are important to maintain transformation functions and protein stability of LE6 and SE6. Finally, E8 seems not to be a transforming protein but rather appears to modulate transformation bv LE6.

Rapid, efficient, large-scale purification of unfused, non-denatured E7 protein of cottontail rabbit papillomavirus

Cottontail rabbit papillomavirus (CRPV) E7 protein is one of the :high risk' papillomavirus E7 oncoproteins that are partially insoluble in aqueous solution. An Escherichia coli expression system was used for purification of CRPV E7 protein in quantities sufficient for immunologic studies and structural analysis. A glutathione S-transferase (GST)-CRPV E7 fusion protein was solubilized in the presence of non-ionic and ionic detergents, and isolated on an affinity column of glutathione Sepharose beads. The CRPV E7 portion was cleaved from the column with thrombin at a thrombin cleavage site between the fused partners. Thrombin was removed subsequently by adsorption to benzamidine. This method is rapid, requiring just one week, and efficient, yielding 3 mg of pure CRPV E7 protein per liter of bacterial culture. It produced a protein product that was about 95% pure. High-titered polyclonal antisera generated to the product recognized CRPV E7 but not GST. Purified CRPV E7 protein exhibited the ability to bind pRB, making it the first unfused, non-denatured CRPV E7 product reported to do so. This attribute could facilitate structure-function studies of CRPV E7-pRB interactions.

Comparison of the properties of the E6 and E7 genes of low- and high-risk cutaneous papillomaviruses reveals strongly transforming and high Rb-binding activity for the E7 protein of the low-risk human papillomavirus type 1

A comparative analysis of different properties of the E6 and E7 proteins of high-risk and low-risk cutaneous papillomaviruses was performed. The corresponding genomic regions of human papillomavirus types 1 and 8 (HPV1 and HPV8) and of the cottontail rabbit papillomavirus (CRPV) were cloned into the eucaryotic expression vector pZipNeo-SV(X)-1 and into vectors for in vitro transcription and translation. With the help of these vectors, the individual proteins were investigated for their ability to transform C127 and NIH 3T3 rodent fibroblasts, bind the Rb protein in vitro, transactivate the adenovirus E2 promoter, and cooperate in the immortalization of primary human keratinocytes. Expression vectors for HPV16 E6 and E7 were used as a positive control. A highly transformed phenotype could be observed with rodent cell lines expressing HPV8 E6, HPV16 E6 and E7, and, surprisingly, HPV1 E7. In contrast, no transformation was detected with CRPV long E6 and HPV8 E7, whereas cells expressing HPV1 E6 and CRPV short E6 exhibited a weakly transformed phenotype. Although neither CRPV E6 nor CRPV E7 caused morphological transformation of C127 cells, CRPV E6 was able to induce anchorage-independent growth in both rodent cell lines, whereas CRPV E7 led to high cloning efficiencies only in NIH 3T3 cells. The in vitro Rb-binding affinities relative to that of HPV 16 E7 were 66% for HPV1 E7, 34% for HPV8 E7, and 11% for CRPV E7. In spite of its high Rb-binding affinity, HPV1 E7 did not trans activate the adenovirus E2 promoter, whereas HPV8 E7 and CRPV E7 showed low activities. Complementation studies in primary human keratinocytes revealed a weak immortalizing potential for HPV8 E7 and indicated a low degree of cooperativity between CRPV E7 and CRPV or HPV16 E6.

Papilloma formation by cottontail rabbit papillomavirus requires E1 and E2 regulatory genes in addition to E6 and E7 transforming genes

The present study used the cottontail rabbit papillomavirus DNA-rabbit system to evaluate whether the regulatory genes E1 and E2 and the transforming gene E6 are required for papilloma formation. Frameshift mutations were generated in the individual genes in the context of a full-length cottontail rabbit papillomavirus genome, and the mutant DNAs were intradermally inoculated into domestic rabbits. None of the mutants induced papillomas. Marker rescue experiments confirmed that the defects were due to mutations that we deliberately introduced. Marker rescue also confirmed our previous report that the upstream region of E7 around position 9 was critical for papilloma induction. These results demonstrate that the E1 and E2 regulatory genes as well as the E6 and E7 transforming genes are each required for papilloma formation. Each gene may provide molecular targets for therapeutic intervention.