False positive cases in thyroid cytopathology - the experience of a single laboratory and a systematic review

Thyroid Fine-Needle Aspiration: The Current and Future Landscape of Cytopathology

Thyroid cytology is a rapidly evolving field that has seen significant advances in recent years. Its main goal is to accurately diagnose thyroid nodules, differentiate between benign and malignant lesions, and risk stratify nodules when a definitive diagnosis is not possible. The current landscape of thyroid cytology includes the use of fine-needle aspiration for the diagnosis of thyroid nodules with the use of uniform, tiered reporting systems such as the Bethesda System for Reporting Thyroid Cytopathology. In recent years, molecular testing has emerged as a reliable preoperative diagnostic tool that stratifies patients into different risk categories (low, intermediate, or high) with varying probabilities of malignancy and helps guide patient treatment.

Diagnostic Accuracy of the Bethesda System for Reporting Thyroid Cytopathology (TBSRTC): An Institution Experience

The Bethesda System for Reporting Thyroid Cytopathology (TBSRTC) is a standardized system which is used to classify results of thyroid fine-needle aspiration (FNA). This system is used to evaluate and determine which patients should get thyroid surgery. It was created in order to reduce the number of patients requiring surgery. The question remains as to whether this reporting system is accurate in determining those nodules that have malignant potential and those that do not. This study is a retrospective analysis of patients in one institution who have undergone FNA and then thyroid surgery based on TBSRTC. The outcome of the pathology reports after surgery was analyzed to determine the accuracy of TBSRTC in our institution (Lourdes Hospital, Binghamton, NY). The results from our institution were compared with similar studies in other institutions to determine accuracy and reproducibility. Our results indicated that the risk of malignancy in each Bethesda category was similar to the risk percentages described for most categories in the 2017 TBSRTC update.

Diagnostic Value and Challenges of BRAF V600E Molecular Testing and Thyroid Fine-Needle Aspiration Cytology: A Retrospective Study from a Tertiary Institution in Southern Hunan Province, China

INTRODUCTION

Combined thyroid fine-needle aspiration (FNA) cytology and valine-to-glutamate substitution at codon 600 of B-Raf proto-oncogene, serine/threonine kinase (BRAF V600E) mutation detection are procedures used for diagnosing thyroid nodules in many Chinese tertiary institutions. This retrospective study at our institution aimed to explore the effectiveness and challenges of the combined approach in diagnosing thyroid nodules and the correlation between BRAF V600E mutation status and behavior of papillary thyroid carcinoma.

METHODS

Thyroid FNA cytology and BRAF V600E mutation detection results were reviewed between November 2020 and July 2022. A total of 623 patients, each of whom underwent thyroidectomy and final pathological examination after FNA cytology diagnosis, were included in the study. The relationship between the BRAF V600E mutational status and pathological parameters was analyzed using the χ2 test. The effectiveness and challenges of FNA cytology alone and the combined procedure were also evaluated based on the final pathology.

RESULTS

Of 623 patients, 591 were diagnosed with papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC), of which 456 were positive for the BRAF V600E mutation. It demonstrated near-perfect specificity for identifying PTC, and its incidence rate showed an age-specific curve with an inverted U-shaped distribution. The final pathological examination showed that the combined procedure had a higher sensitivity (83.91%) than FNA cytology alone (63.45%) for distinguishing PTC from other lesions (p < 0.001). Mutational status was associated with a larger maximum tumor diameter (p = 0.003) and a tendency of capsular invasion (p = 0.0542) but possibly unrelated to central lymph node metastasis (p = 0.1846). Nodular goiters accounted for most benign entities initially designated as Bethesda categories III-V.

CONCLUSION

BRAF V600E mutational analysis complements cytopathology and improves the PTC detection rate in FNA cytology samples due to the high prevalence of the mutation in China. BRAF V600E mutation does not show a statistical correlation with tumor aggressiveness. Morphological pitfalls such as histocyte aggregation, cystic-lining cells in nodular goiters, and oncocytes in Hashimoto's thyroiditis, were overwhelmingly found in BRAF V600E-negative specimens.

Degenerative atypia in benign thyroid nodules: a potential diagnostic pitfall on fine-needle aspiration

INTRODUCTION

Benign (B) follicular lesions of the thyroid are among the most encountered specimens on fine needle aspiration (FNA). Although FNA and The Bethesda System for Reporting Thyroid Cytopathology (TBSRTC) remain highly accurate, minimally invasive and robust tools in triaging thyroid nodules, false positive (FP) diagnoses may still occur. Endocrine-type degenerative atypia can cause diagnoses of suspicious for malignancy (SFM) or malignant (M), resulting in overtreatment and exposure to undue surgical risk in patients.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We performed a multi-institutional retrospective clinicopathologic correlation of benign thyroid nodules with degenerative atypia on FNA. Review of cytologic material was conducted to identify potential cytomorphologic features which may have prompted these diagnoses.

RESULTS

Among 342 patients with benign thyroid nodules harboring degenerative atypia, 123 had available preceding FNA cytopathology. TBSRTC nondiagnostic, B, atypia of undetermined significance, follicular neoplasm, SFM, and M, comprised 3.3%, 49.6%, 30.1%, 13.0%, 2.4%, and 1.6% of cases. Among patients with FP diagnoses (SFM and M), 100% underwent total thyroidectomy, and 40.0% underwent additional neck lymph node dissections. Among remaining patients, 61.0%, 39.0%, and 0% underwent lobectomy, thyroidectomy, and lymph node dissection. The number of patients who underwent total thyroidectomy was significantly different (P = 0.03) between those with FP nodules and those without.

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrate that 4.1% of nodules harboring endocrine-type degenerative atypia may be given FP diagnoses on initial FNA. Such atypia may be indistinguishable from that of Graves' Disease, dyshormonogenic goiter, and radiation therapy. FP diagnoses of degenerative atypia can expose patients to undue surgical procedures and risks.