Human Evolution and Dietary Ethanol

The "drunken monkey" hypothesis posits that attraction to ethanol derives from an evolutionary linkage among the sugars of ripe fruit, associated alcoholic fermentation by yeast, and ensuing consumption by human ancestors. First proposed in 2000, this concept has received increasing attention from the fields of animal sensory biology, primate foraging behavior, and molecular evolution. We undertook a review of English language citations subsequent to publication of the original paper and assessed research trends and future directions relative to natural dietary ethanol exposure in primates and other animals. Two major empirical themes emerge: attraction to and consumption of fermenting fruits (and nectar) by numerous vertebrates and invertebrates (e.g., Drosophila flies), and genomic evidence for natural selection consistent with sustained exposure to dietary ethanol in diverse taxa (including hominids and the genus Homo) over tens of millions of years. We also describe our current field studies in Uganda of ethanol content within fruits consumed by free-ranging chimpanzees, which suggest chronic low-level exposure to this psychoactive molecule in our closest living relatives.

Male sexual behaviour and ethanol consumption from an evolutionary perspective: A comment on "Sexual Deprivation Increases Ethanol Intake in Drosophila"

Shohat-Ophir et al. (1) demonstrate a connection between sexual behaviour and ethanol consumption in male Drosophila flies, and how the neuropeptide F system regulates ethanol preference. Their results are rightly discussed only in a physiological context, but this has facilitated erroneous anthropomorphic interpretations by the media. Here we discuss the link between male sexual behaviour and ethanol consumption from an evolutionary perspective, providing a broader context to interpret their results.

Acetaldehyde burst protection of ADH1B*2 against alcoholism: an additional hormesis protection against esophageal cancers following alcohol consumption?

This account of recent work presented at the 4th International Symposium on Alcohol Pancreatitis and Cirrhosis reports animal studies aimed at determining the role of the "acetaldehyde burst," generated shortly upon ethanol intake, as the mechanism of protection against alcoholism conferred by the ADH1B*2 polymorphism. Literature studies discussed suggest an additional role of the acetaldehyde burst on the paradoxical (hormesis) protection of the ADH1B*2 polymorphism against esophageal cancers in alcoholics.

Mechanism of protection against alcoholism by an alcohol dehydrogenase polymorphism: development of an animal model

Humans who carry a point mutation in the gene coding for alcohol dehydrogenase-1B (ADH1B*2; Arg47His) are markedly protected against alcoholism. Although this mutation results in a 100-fold increase in enzyme activity, it has not been reported to cause higher levels of acetaldehyde, a metabolite of ethanol known to deter alcohol intake. Hence, the mechanism by which this mutation confers protection against alcoholism is unknown. To study this protective effect, the wild-type rat cDNA encoding rADH-47Arg was mutated to encode rADH-47His, mimicking the human mutation. The mutated cDNA was incorporated into an adenoviral vector and administered to genetically selected alcohol-preferring rats. The V(max) of rADH-47His was 6-fold higher (P<0.001) than that of the wild-type rADH-47Arg. Animals transduced with rAdh-47His showed a 90% (P<0.01) increase in liver ADH activity and a 50% reduction (P<0.001) in voluntary ethanol intake. In animals transduced with rAdh-47His, administration of ethanol (1g/kg) produced a short-lived increase of arterial blood acetaldehyde concentration to levels that were 3.5- to 5-fold greater than those in animals transduced with the wild-type rAdh-47Arg vector or with a noncoding vector. This brief increase (burst) in arterial acetaldehyde concentration after ethanol ingestion may constitute the mechanism by which humans carrying the ADH1B*2 allele are protected against alcoholism.

Aging: the fitness-stress continuum and genetic variability

Assuming the stress theory of aging, longevity depends upon primary selection for stress resistance and metabolic efficiency. Predominantly based upon experimental studies in the insect Drosophila melanogaster, high genetic variability for fitness, especially mortality, occurs under extreme stress. Isofemale strains derived from the progeny of recently collected single inseminated Drosophila females from the wild should provide useful biological material for extrapolating to quantitative genetic studies in man. Furthermore, environments from the benign (hormetic) to the extreme can be incorporated. Survival to old age may depend upon genes for metabolic efficiency that respond to the environmental challenges of living as limits to adaptation are approached. Under this scenario the survival of longevity mutants in man to ages analogous to the extreme life spans found in some experimental organisms under benign or protected laboratory conditions is unlikely. More future emphasis is needed on genetic variation of longevity in natural populations of experimental organisms under an array of realistically stressful environments to act as an evolutionary model for longevity in our own species.

Hormesis and high-risk groups

The concept of hormesis (i.e., biological phenomena characterized by dose-response relationships displaying low-dose stimulation and high-dose inhibition) has important implications for current risk assessment practices because of its generalizability with respect to experimental model, agent, and endpoint measured. This paper addresses the question of whether hormesis is present in high-risk subpopulations and highly susceptible species. Evaluation of published data revealed that hormetic dose-response relationships occur with similar quantitative characteristics among species and individuals that display widely differing susceptibility to various toxicants. This observation suggests that the cause of the differential susceptibility in the more susceptible organisms is not due to the absence of the hormetic response but to some other factor(s). However, despite the recognition that hormetic responses are common and similar in susceptible and resistant organisms there are sufficient examples indicating that some strains/individuals may lack the capacity to produce the low-dose stimulatory response. Thus, the capacity to display hormetic effects is one of a variety of factors affecting differential susceptibility to xenobiotics and needs to be addressed within the hazard assessment process.

Fermenting fruit and the historical ecology of ethanol ingestion: is alcoholism in modern humans an evolutionary hangover?

In the field of addiction research, the possibility of ancestral exposure to psychoactive compounds has generally been excluded. A paleobiological approach to the human diet, however, illustrates the potential utility of historical data in interpreting modern-day addictive behaviors. Low-level dietary exposure to ethanol via ingestion of fermenting fruit has probably characterized the predominantly frugivorous anthropoid lineage for about 40 million years. Potentially adaptive primate behaviors associated with the natural occurrence of ethanol include the olfactory use of ethanol plumes to localize fruit crops, the use of ethanol as an appetitive stimulant to facilitate rapid consumption of transient nutritional resources, and the physiological exploitation of the caloric benefits of ethanol. Such behavioral and energetic advantages probably pertain to all animal taxa that consume fermenting fruit, and may have been retained in modern humans in spite of considerable dietary diversification over the last several million years. In contemporary human environments, excessive consumption of ethanol would then represent maladaptive cooption of ancestrally advantageous behaviors given essentially ad libitum access to a compound otherwise found only within scarce nutritional substrates. Epidemiologically demonstrated health benefits of low-level alcohol consumption are consistent with an ancient and potentially adaptive exposure of primate frugivores to this most common of the psychoactive substances.

Hormesis: an adaptive expectation with emphasis on ionizing radiation

Non-linear fitness gradients with maxima between extremes are expected for any environmental variable to which free-living populations are exposed. For exceedingly toxic agents, including ionizing radiation, such deviations from linearity are close to zero exposure and are conventionally called hormesis. Accordingly, hormesis is an extreme version of the non-linear fitness gradients for general environmental stresses such as temperature fluctuations, for which maximum fitness occurs at the moderate temperature fluctuations to which free-living populations are most commonly exposed. Some metabolic reserves should occur under moderate temperature stresses because of the need for pre-adaptation enabling survival during exposure to occasional periods of more extreme stress, especially at species borders where selection for stress resistance is likely to be most intense. Because heat shock proteins are induced by all stresses, adaptation to extreme temperatures should translate into adaptation to other stresses. Consequently, metabolic reserves from adaptation to extreme temperatures in the past should translate into protection from correlated abiotic stresses, especially in human populations where modern cultural processes are now ameliorating exposure to extreme stresses. Ambient and man-made radiations of non-catastrophic dimensions should therefore lead to stress-derived radiation hormesis. Other stresses can, in principle, be incorporated into this model. Accordingly, evolutionary and ecological considerations suggest two components of hormesis in relation to ionizing radiation: background radiation hormesis based upon the background exposure to which all organisms on earth are subjected; and stress-derived radiation hormesis. Exposure under stress-derived radiation hormesis is considerably larger than under background radiation hormesis, so significant deleterious effects from non-catastrophic radiation normally may be impossible to detect. Suggestions are provided for testing such postulated deviations from the commonly assumed linear no-threshold (LNT) hypothesis for the biological consequences of exposure to radiation.

Pesticide uptake and locomotor behaviour in the woodlouse: an experimental study employing video tracking and (14)C-labelling

: The toxicity of soil pesticide residues to target and non-target organisms depends on the amount of chemical absorbed by the organism. One of the principle factors governing chemical uptake is the amount of chemical encountered by the animal and, hence, the area of soil contacted. This in turn, depends on the locomotor behaviour of the animal. In the present study, the relationship between the uptake of soil residues of an organophosphate insecticide and locomotor behaviour was examined, employing (14)C-labelled dimethoate and computer-aided video tracking. Groups of male woodlice, Porcellio scaber (Isopoda), walked freely for 22 h on a soil substrate treated with three application rates of the pesticide. A strong correlation was found between pesticide uptake and path length, mean velocity and time spent in locomotor acivity, which is consistent with previously reported modelling studies. Our data suggest a linear relationship for all locomotor parameters except for path length at the highest application rate, where uptake was best described by an inverse exponential relationship. All doses induced hyperactivity in terms of time spent in locomotor activity. However, when compared with a untreated control group, the most pronounced effects were displayed at the lowest dose where path length, mean velocity and turning rate were also significantly different. The number of shifts between locomotor active and inactive periods in the experimental period increased with increasing application rate.

Radiation hormesis: an evolutionary expectation and the evidence

Fundamental to evolutionary biology is the tendency for organisms to become progressively adapted to those environments to which they are most frequently exposed. Since background radiation is a universal component of our environment, radiation hormesis is an evolutionary expectation. Whole-of-life experiments and more numerous (and evolutionarily more artificial) shorter duration and higher dose-rate experiments are consistent with this expectation. Additional research is needed especially at the molecular level to search for underlying mechanisms, and implications for radiation protection guidelines need to be analyzed.