The histological diagnosis of cutaneous graft versus host disease: relationship of skin changes to marrow purging and other clinical variables

In Vivo Reflectance Confocal Microscopy of Cutaneous Acute Graft-Versus-Host Disease: Concordance with Histopathology and Interobserver Reproducibility of a Glossary with Representative Images

BACKGROUND

The reliability to noninvasively identify features of inflammatory dermatoses by reflectance confocal microscopy (RCM) remains unknown. Lack of formal training among RCM readers can result in inconsistent assessments, limiting clinical utility. Specific consensus terminology with representative images is necessary to ensure consistent feature-level interpretation among RCM readers.

OBJECTIVES

(1) Develop a glossary with representative images of RCM features of cutaneous acute graft-versus-host disease (aGVHD) for consistent interpretation among observers, (2) assess the interobserver reproducibility among RCM readers using the glossary, and (3) determine the concordance between RCM and histopathology for aGVHD features.

METHODS

Through an iterative process of refinement and discussion among five international RCM experts, we developed a glossary with representative images of RCM features of aGVHD. From April to November 2018, patients suspected of aGVHD were imaged with RCM and subsequently biopsied. 17 lesions from 12 patients had clinically and pathologically confirmed cutaneous aGVHD. For each of these lesions, four dermatopathologists and four RCM readers independently evaluated the presence of aGVHD features in scanned histopathology slides and 1.5x1.5 mm RCM submosaics at 4 depths (blockstacks), respectively. RCM cases were adjudicated by a fifth RCM expert. Interobserver reproducibility was calculated by U statistic. Concordance between modalities was determined by fraction agreement.

RESULTS

We present a glossary with representative images of 18 aGVHD features by RCM. The average interobserver reproducibility among RCM readers (75%, confidence interval, CI: 71%-79%) did not differ significantly from dermatopathologists (80%, 76%-85%). The concordance between RCM and histopathology was 59%.

CONCLUSIONS

By using the glossary, the interobserver reproducibility among RCM readers was similar to the interobserver reproducibility among dermatopathologists. There was good concordance between RCM and histopathology to visualize aGVHD features. The implementation of RCM can now be advanced in a variety of inflammatory conditions with a validated glossary and representative image set.

Clinical versus histological grading in the assessment of cutaneous graft versus host disease

BACKGROUND

Skin biopsies are often used in daily practice for the diagnosis of acute (aGvHD) or chronic graft versus host disease (cGvHD). With the latest understanding in pathogenesis and new National Institute of Health (NIH) classifications for aGvHD and cGvHD, there is a need to evaluate the current prognostic value of histological grading cutaneous GvHD and its correlation to the clinical grade.

METHODS

In a retrospective study with 120 skin biopsies (all taken for suspected GvHD) from 110 patients (all classified according to the NIH), biopsies were revised and graded, blinded for clinical information, for either acute of chronic features. Morphological grades were compared for concordance with the clinical grade and survival analyses were done for clinical and histological grading.

RESULTS

Correlation for histologic vs. clinical grading was (very) poor for aGvHD and cGvHD (weighted κ - 0.038 and 0.0009, respectively). Patients with clinical aGvHD had worse prognosis compared to cGvHD. However, at time of biopsy neither clinical nor histological grading predicted the eventual survival for either aGvHD (p = 0.9739 and p = 0.0744, respectively) or cGvHD (p = 0.2149 and p = 0.4465, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

Confirming the diagnosis of GvHD is still a valuable reason for taking a skin biopsy, but this study shows that histologic grading of GvHD in the skin biopsy has no additional value for clinicians in current practice.

Genital manifestation of graft-vs.-host disease: a series of case reports

INTRODUCTION

After hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT), many patients present genital graft-vs.-host disease (GVHD) that can culminate with sexual problems, which are poorly dimensioned.

AIM

We hope to draw attention to the need to perform genital biopsy to diagnose genital GVHD, and thus to call attention to the need to incorporate careful attention to sexual health in the treatment of these patients.

METHODS

Five allogeneic stem cell transplant recipients complaining of coital pain after HSCT were clinically diagnosed for genital GVHD. Genital biopsies were given for histological analysis, and microphotographs of the corresponding marked field in the slide were taken. Specimens were evaluated by the site pathologist and then sent to a reference pathologist, each blinded to the histological findings. A literature search was performed in PubMed/MEDLINE (1966-2009) for cross-sectional and cohort studies or trials related to genital GVHD. Expert opinions peer reviews and case reports were also considered.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

HSCT, genital GVHD, genital biopsy.

RESULTS

The biopsy showed evidence of dilated apoptotic cells in the basal layer and detachment of the epithelial lining of the mucosa, hyalinization and thickening of collagen fibers, capillary ectasia, and mononuclear inflammatory infiltrate of the submucosa. Three patients presented vulval lesion such as leucoplasia and ulcer on the large lip. Histological analyses showed evidence of epithelial hyperplasia and influx of inflammatory cells to the epithelial surface, intercellular edema and spongiosis, apoptotic bodies on the basal layer of the epithelium, spongiosis, and nuclear vacuolization. A common treatment based on corticotherapy resulted in complete remission of coetaneous or mucous genital lesions in all five patients.

CONCLUSION

Genital biopsy is important to differentially diagnose GVHD and secondary symptoms due to hypoestrogenism. Prevention is the most important step in controlling the evolution GVHD in the vagina to prevent vaginal obstruction and sexual dysfunction.

Manifestações tegumentares da doença enxerto contra hospedeiro em pacientes transplantados de medula óssea

A doença enxerto contra hospedeiro (DECH) é uma síndrome sistêmica que ocorre em pacientes que recebem linfócitos imunocompetentes. A fisiopatologia envolve uma reação imunológica entre linfócitos transplantados e tecidos do hospedeiro, e ocorre por ataque imune das células T do doador às células do hospedeiro, as quais diferem daquelas pelos antígenos de histocompatibilidade. É, assim, uma complicação primária do transplante de medula óssea (TMO) alogênico. O envolvimento cutâneo é freqüente na DECH e contribui para a morbidade e mortalidade do TMO. O dermatologista tem papel importante na avaliação dos pacientes auxiliando no reconhecimento precoce da DECH e suas complicações e no acompanhamento clínico desses pacientes. Nesta revisão os autores enfatizam as manifestações cutâneas da DECH, tendo como base sua experiência pessoal no acompanhamento de pacientes portadores de DECH transplantados de medula óssea no Centro Nacional de Transplante de Medula Óssea/Inca/MS, no Rio de Janeiro, nos últimos 14 anos.

"Rush" skin biopsy specimens in a tertiary medical center: diagnostic yield and clinical utility

BACKGROUND

Skin biopsy specimens are submitted for "rush" or "stat" processing, thereby indicating a sense of urgency about the clinical situation.

OBJECTIVE

Our purpose was to determine the patient population who underwent biopsy on a "rush" basis and assess the way in which interpretation of the skin biopsy specimen influences clinical management.

METHODS

A retrospective study was performed on the "rush" biopsy specimens sequentially requested during 1 year. Histologic findings, the clinical situation, and the effect of the biopsy result on clinical management were determined.

RESULTS

A total of 90 adult patients, many critically ill, were identified. The majority of patients were admitted to hematology-oncology services (58%). The other 42% were admitted to a variety of clinical services. The chief clinical concerns in hematology-oncology patients were graft-versus-host disease and cutaneous infection. Only 5.5% of biopsy specimens taken to exclude graft-versus-host disease were used in immediate clinical decision-making compared with 45% of biopsy specimens for oncology patients with suspected infection and 42% for all other services.

CONCLUSION

Many urgent skin biopsy specimens were not used for immediate clinical decision-making. The usefulness of skin biopsy varies with the clinical situation, and some situations are more prone to yield equivocal histologic data. Knowledge of these situations may reduce the number of unhelpful biopsy specimens. Therapy based on clinical findings had often been initiated before receiving the biopsy results, but biopsy findings are often helpful as confirmatory data. Diagnostic findings were not necessary for a biopsy specimen to provide useful data and nonspecific findings interpreted in light of clinical findings were also useful.

Value of skin biopsies in assessing prognosis and progression of acute graft-versus-host disease

Skin biopsies are commonly performed after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT) to help establish the origin of a new skin rash in a transplant recipient. Histologic criteria and a grading system for acute graft-versus-host reaction of the skin are well established. Histologic diagnosis, however, can be difficult and is based on interpretation of subtle changes that show significant overlap with features seen in other entities that can be responsible for a skin rash in the posttransplantation period such as drug reactions, viral exanthems, and the effects of chemotherapy. We retrospectively reviewed 179 skin biopsies from 137 patients who had undergone allogeneic BMT. We compared 98 skin biopsies from 71 patients with acute graft-versus-host disease (GvHD) with 81 biopsies from 66 patients who underwent biopsy to exclude GvHD but did not go on to develop the disease on clinical grounds. Two observers reviewed each slide without knowledge of the clinical situation and graded 16 histologic parameters. No single parameter (e.g., dyskeratotic keratinocytes, basal vacuolization, satellitosis, necrotic cells in appendages) achieved statistical significance on univariate analysis. A search for factors to separate GvHD biopsies from non-GvHD biopsies using logistic regression failed to reveal a single best predictor or a combination of predictors. We conclude that skin biopsies after allogeneic BMT are of limited use in predicting the progression of a skin rash to clinical grade II or higher GvHD.

Apoptosis is the mode of keratinocyte death in cutaneous graft-versus-host disease

BACKGROUND

Satellite cell necrosis is a histopathologic hallmark of cutaneous graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation. Although this interaction of lymphocytes with keratinocytes has features of immune cytolytic destruction, the details of the process are not known.

OBJECTIVE

Our purpose was to investigate whether apoptosis is involved in the process of GVHD.

METHODS

We used TdT-mediated dUTP-biotin nick end labeling (TUNEL) technique with biotinylated nucleotides. Formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded sections from skin biopsy specimens of patients with GVHD and normal skin were studied.

RESULTS

Labeling of scattered individual keratinocytes in the epidermis and adnexal epithelium undergoing cytolytic degeneration and a proportion of the adjacent lymphocytes was noted in all specimens of GVHD.

CONCLUSION

The positive staining of keratinocytes by the TUNEL method indicates that cell destruction in cutaneous GVHD involves apoptosis.

Reciprocal expression of CD34 and cell adhesion molecule ELAM-1 on vascular endothelium in acute cutaneous graft-versus-host disease

The expression of CD34 and endothelial leucocyte adhesion molecule-1 (ELAM-1) on endothelial cells was studied in skin biopsies from normal human donors and recipients of allogeneic bone marrow. Both molecules were demonstrable on a variable number of cells in normals with no significant change after marrow transplantation in patients with no clinical evidence of skin disease. In patients with graft-versus-host disease (GvHD), however, there was a striking decrease in CD34-positive cells with a corresponding increase in ELAM-1 positivity. These changes were similar to those occurring in cultured endothelial cells after the addition of certain cytokines. They were seen only in the presence of a lymphocytic infiltrate and were not observed in the early stages of GvHD before lymphocytic infiltration was discernible. The reciprocal expression of these molecules may thus be important in the adhesion of lymphocytes to endothelium and their entry into the skin in GvHD and may be modulated by local cytokine release.

Cytokine gene expression in skin and lymphoid organs in graft versus host disease

AIM

To determine if human graft versus host disease (GvHD) is associated with any detectable change in cytokine gene expression in the skin and lymphoid organs.

METHODS

Reverse transcriptase and the polymerase chain reaction were used to amplify mRNA for interleukins-1 (IL-1), -2 (IL-2), -4 (IL-4) and -6 (IL-6), IL-2 receptor (IL-2R), tumour necrosis factors alpha (TNF-alpha) and beta (TNF-beta), gamma interferon (IFN gamma) and granulocyte macrophage colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF) in frozen punch biopsy specimens of skin and necropsy samples of skin, lymph node, and spleen.

RESULTS

No cytokine mRNA was detected in the punch biopsy specimens except weak signals for IL-6 and IL-1 and GM-CSF in two normal donors and IL2-R in one patient with GvHD. In samples of skin taken at necropsy, however, significant quantities of mRNA for TNF-alpha, TNF-beta, and IL-4 were detected in patients who had or had had GvHD in contrast to those without the disease whose skin lacked mRNA for these products but contained detectable quantities of IL-1, IL2-R, IL-6 and GM-CSF. There seemed to be a reciprocal relation between TNF-alpha and IL-4. In necropsy samples of lymph node and spleen a pattern of cytokine production similar to that in the skin was observed with a preponderance of TNF-alpha, TNF-beta and IL-4 in patients with GvHD and GM-CSF and IL-6 in those without the disease.

CONCLUSIONS

The local synthesis of these molecules would explain many of the morphological and immunohistological features of GvHD. The failure to detect TNF-alpha, TNF-beta, and IL-4 in skin biopsy specimens exhibiting GvHD is probably due to their small size but further investigations are required.

The pathology of bone marrow transplantation

The pathological complications of bone marrow transplantation are complex and may affect any organ in the body. The causes are often multifactorial and include the effects of chemotherapy, the conditioning regimen, drugs used in the post-transplant period such as immunosuppressants and antibiotics, graft-versus-host disease (GvHD) and the effects of the primary disease itself. Infections are common and result from the immunosuppressive effects of cytotoxic drugs and irradiation, GvHD and marrow failure. Haemorrhage is not infrequent. Graft-versus-host disease remains a significant problem and can be difficult to diagnose. Some of its histological features simulate the effects of chemoradiation and the diagnostic lesions may not be present early in the disease, when treatment is most effective. Evidence has accumulated that inflammatory cytokines have a key role in the pathogenesis of GvHD. It can be prevented by eliminating T-cells from the donor marrow but this procedure adversely affects marrow engraftment, increases the changes of rejection and results in a higher incidence of leukaemic relapse. Immunohistochemical staining for various cytokine-inducible molecules has led to some improvement in early diagnosis.

Immunohistology of skin and rectum biopsies in bone marrow transplant recipients

We have studied histological and immunohistological specimens of 39 skin biopsies from 21, and 30 rectal biopsies from 17 bone marrow transplant recipients. The biopsies were taken before transplantation, during acute and chronic graft-versus-host disease (GVHD), and at times with no GVHD. In biopsies taken during cutaneous aGVHD grade I to III, epithelial changes were seen in 16/23 biopsies. The cutaneous infiltrates during aGVHD consisted of CD2-, CD4-, CD8- and FMC-33-positive cells both in the epithelium and in the dermis. CD57-positive NK cells were also detected in most biopsies. During chronic GVHD the cutaneous cellular infiltrates were similar to those seen in moderate aGVHD, i.e. both CD4- and CD8-positive lymphoid cells were present. When the biopsy was taken after the beginning of corticosteroid treatment for aGVHD, or at times when the patient did not have GVHD symptoms, the cellular infiltrates were considerably smaller in the dermis. During clinical intestinal aGVHD mucosal epithelial changes were relatively uncommon; instead, increased numbers of both CD4- and CD8-positive lymphocytes in the lamina propria (LP) were seen in 11/13 samples. During chronic GVHD the number of CD4-positive cells exceeded that of CD8-positive cells in the LP, and the large lymphoid infiltrates also reached the muscularis mucosae. In rectal biopsies the differences were not so prominent because most of the pretransplant biopsies showed CD2-, CD4-, CD8- and CD57-positive lymphocytes both in the lamina propria and epithelium.

Epidermal damage in skin of allogeneic marrow recipients: relative importance of chemotherapy, conditioning and graft v. host disease

The relative importance of previous chemotherapy, conditioning and graft v. host disease in producing the epidermal damage associated with allogeneic bone marrow transplantation was investigated by enumerating individually necrotic cells. A small number was seen in many pre-transplant biopsies and was related to the time interval between biopsy and the last dose of chemotherapy. Their presence did not predispose patients to develop graft v. host disease in the post-transplant period. In post-transplant patients without rashes the degree of epidermal damage at 14 days was similar to that seen in the pre-transplant period indicating that the effects of the conditioning regime were insignificant. In patients with rashes clinically classical of graft v. host disease, necrotic cells were increased above the pre-transplant levels even in the absence of a lymphocytic infiltrate. Lymphocytic infiltration was seen more frequently in biopsies taken later after transplantation and after the onset of the rash and was associated with the maximal amount of epidermal damage. Comparison of the degree of epidermal damage in pre- and post-transplantation specimens lacking a lymphocytic infiltrate resulted in the correct identification of the majority of patients with clinical evidence of graft v. host disease. This approach may, thus, be useful in diagnosing early graft v. host disease especially if combined with keratinocyte HLA-DR staining.

Clinical, laboratory, and histopathologic indicators of the development of progressive acute graft-versus-host disease

Graft-versus-host disease (GvHD) is the major cause of morbidity and mortality following bone marrow transplantation (BMT). The goal of this study of 69 cyclosporin-treated, allogeneic BMT patients was to identify early clinical, laboratory, or histopathologic indicators of the development of progressive, fatal GvHD. Peak values within 100 d of allogeneic BMT for total bilirubin, stool volume in a day, clinical stage of cutaneous GvHD (based on extent of rash), and overall clinical stage of GvHD (based on a combination of graft-versus-host reactions in the skin, liver, and gastrointestinal tract) were most useful (p less than 0.05, by logistic regression) in identifying those patients with clinically progressive and fatal GvHD. Peak values for each of these parameters were reached an average of 40 d or less after BMT. Each unit increase in peak clinical stage of rash (e.g., stage 2 versus stage 3) was associated with an odds ratio incremental risk of 5.8 for clinical progression of GvHD, and each tenfold increase in peak total bilirubin (e.g., 2 mg/dl versus 20 mg/dl) or stool output in a day (e.g., 100 cm3/d versus 1000 cm3/d) was associated with an incremental risk of 8.4 and 10.6, respectively, for a fatal outcome from GvHD. Number of exocytosed lymphocytes and dyskeratotic epidermal keratinocytes (DEK) per linear millimeter of epidermis, the presence of follicular involvement, and the degree of dermal perivascular lymphocytic infiltration in 121 skin biopsy specimens were not associated with the development of progressive or fatal GvHD. Pretransplant total body irradiation was associated (p = 0.03, by Mann-Whitney U testing) with an increased number of DEK in skin biopsy specimens taken less than 20 d after BMT. This study demonstrates that monitoring of total bilirubin, stool output, extent of rash, and overall clinical stage of GvHD is most useful during the first 40 d after BMT in formulating the prognosis of early acute GvHD in allogeneic BMT patients receiving cyclosporin.

Vessel associated adhesion molecules in normal skin and acute graft-versus-host disease

Immunohistological staining of skin from normal donors and bone marrow transplant recipients was undertaken using antibodies to two vessel associated adhesion molecules, endothelial leucocyte adhesion molecule-1 (ELAM-1). In normal skin ELAM-1 staining was restricted to a variable but generally small number of endothelial cells which were significantly increased in graft-versus-host disease (GvHD), but only when the fully developed histological picture of epidermal basal damage and leucocytic infiltration was present. All other biopsy specimens from marrow recipients taken before or after transplantation were similar to those of normal controls even in the presence of a clinical rash consistent with early GvHD. Although VCAM-1 positivity was seen on a few endothelial cells in normal skin, staining was mainly observed on dermal dendritic cells surrounding blood vessels and adnexal structures. In specimens with histological evidence of GvHD, positive perivascular dendritic cells were increased and were accompanied by the appearance of large numbers of similar cells dispersed throughout the upper dermis. Biopsy specimens from marrow recipients before and after transplantation resembled those from normal donors except for the presence of a rash after transplantation when some specimens, which lacked the leucocytic infiltrate diagnostic of GvHD, showed an increase in VCAM-1 positive cells, particularly in the upper dermis. The identification of these cells may therefore be useful in diagnosing early GvHD.

Cyclosporine-induced graft-versus-host disease after autologous bone marrow transplantation in hematological malignancies

In the attempt to induce graft-vs-host disease (GVHD) in patients undergoing autologous bone marrow transplantation (ABMT) or blood stem cell transplantation (BSCT), 12 consecutive patients received cyclosporin A (CyA) post transplant. CyA was given at a dose of 1.5 mg/kg/day intravenously for 28 days, starting on the day of transplant. Histologically proven acute GVHD of the skin occurred in seven patients 9-14 days after ABMT and lasted 7-11 days. CyA-induced GVHD after ABMT resembles mild GVHD after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT). Although the preliminary data reported here show that it is possible to induce GVHD in patients undergoing ABMT, it is not yet known whether GVHD after ABMT will have an antitumor activity.

Clinical, histological, and immunohistological studies of postoperative erythroderma

We report 7 cases of acute fatal illness characterized by fever, diffuse erythematous rash, and progressive leukopenia occurring 10 days after surgical operation. The outcome was uniformly fatal. The biopsy findings consisted of eosinophilic individual necrosis of epidermal cells, satellite cell necrosis, basal liquefaction degeneration, and scanty cell infiltration into the dermis. T lymphocytes were found in the epidermis but Langerhans cells disappeared. These findings are compatible with acute graft-vs-host disease following blood transfusion. Explanations based upon drug allergy, infection, toxic shock syndrome, or toxic epidermal necrolysis seem less reasonable.

Histological features of skin and rectal biopsy specimens after autologous and allogeneic bone marrow transplantation

The histological appearances of skin and rectal biopsy specimens were studied in 31 bone marrow transplant recipients (13 autologous, 18 allogeneic) before transplant, at 28 days, at six months, and as soon as graft versus host disease (GVHD) was clinically suspected. Grades I and II skin changes were commonly seen in patients before transplant and in the autologous group after transplant, as well as in most of the allogeneic recipients with suspected GVHD. Epidermal lymphocytic infiltration was seen only in allogeneic recipients, with clinical GVHD following transplant, but this was not a consistent finding and no other histological features were seen which would distinguish early GVHD from changes caused by cytotoxic agents. Rectal biopsy specimens, however, were normal in patients before transplant and in autologous recipients at 28 days; single cell necrosis of crypt cells was seen only in six of 13 allogeneic recipients studied after transplant with clinical skin GVHD but no gastrointestinal symptoms. Skin changes greater than I and II are required for the histological diagnosis of GVHD. Rectal changes are more specific and may be present despite a lack of intestinal symptoms.

Cutaneous leucocyte composition after human allogeneic bone marrow transplantation: relationship to marrow purging, histology and clinical rash

Immunohistological and morphometric techniques were used to study the skin after marrow transplantation with particular reference to the relationship of marrow purging, the presence of a clinical rash and histological changes to leucocyte numbers and phenotype. Recipients of T-cell-depleted marrow showed significant reductions in CD2+, CD4+ and CD8+ T-lymphocytes in the first 22 d after transplantation but not after this time. T-cell numbers in recipients of unpurged marrow were similar to those of normal donors, indicating a rapid repopulation by cells from the graft. Langerhans cells (CD1+ dendritic cells) and macrophages, on the other hand, were present in similar numbers in both groups of patients within the first 22 d; the former in low and the latter in normal numbers. Biopsies exhibiting graft versus host disease showed increases in CD2+, CD4+ and CD8+ T-lymphocytes with significant lowering of the CD4:CD8 ratio. A proportion expressed markers of activation and HNK1+ cells and macrophages were also increased. Biopsies exhibiting epidermal basal abnormalities only (changes identical to graft versus host disease but without detectable leucocyte infiltration on conventional microscopy) showed a minor increase in macrophages and HNK1+ cells but no other leucocyte alterations to suggest a pathogenetic link with graft versus host disease. Langerhans cells were reduced in these biopsies, however, when taken more than 22 d post-transplant, suggesting that the epidermal changes are associated with Langerhans cell damage or repopulation. We were unable to identify any significant alteration in leucocytes in patients with strong clinical evidence of graft versus host disease but with histologically unremarkable biopsies. Although it is possible that perivascular increases in T-cells and expression of activation markers precede the characteristic histological picture of graft versus host disease the time scale is probably too short to allow diagnostic value.