Hypothermic perfusion preservation of liver: the role of phosphate in stimulating ATP synthesis studied by31P NMR

Hypothermic Machine Preservation of the Liver: State of the Art

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

In this review, we highlight which livers may benefit from additional treatment before implantation and describe the concept of hypothermic machine liver perfusion. Furthermore, we explain why cold oxygenated perfusion concepts could potentially lead to a breakthrough in this challenging field of transplantation. Accordingly, we summarize recent clinical applications of different hypothermic perfusion approaches.

RECENT FINDINGS

The impact of end-ischemic, hypothermic liver perfusion in liver transplantation is currently assessed by two multicenter, randomized controlled trials. Recently, new applications of hypothermic perfusion showed promising results and recipients were protected from severe intrahepatic biliary complications, despite the use of very extended criteria grafts including donation after circulatory death livers.

SUMMARY

Hypothermic machine liver perfusion is beneficial for high-risk livers and protects recipients from most feared complications. Importantly, such easy approach is currently implemented in several European centers and new markers obtained from perfusate may improve the prediction of liver function in the future.

Machine perfusion versus cold storage of livers: a meta-analysis

Different organ preservation methods are key factors influencing the results of liver transplantation. In this study, the outcomes of experimental models receiving donation after cardiac death (DCD) livers preserved through machine perfusion (MP) or static cold storage (CS) were compared by conducting a meta-analysis. Standardized mean difference (SMD) and 95% confidence interval (CI) were calculated to compare pooled data from two animal species. Twenty-four studies involving MP preservation were included in the meta-analysis. Compared with CS preservation, MP can reduce the levels of aspartate aminotransferase (AST), alanine aminotransferase (ALT), lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), and hyaluronic acid (HA) and the changes in liver weight. By contrast, MP can enhance bile production and portal vein flow (PVF). Alkaline phosphatase (ALP) levels and histological changes significantly differed between the two preservation methods. In conclusion, MP of DCD livers is superior to CS in experimental animals.

Hypothermic machine perfusion versus cold storage in the rescuing of livers from non-heart-beating donor rats

The aim of this work was to compare the efficiency of cold storage (CS) and hypothermic machine perfusion (HMP) methods of preserving grafts excised from non-heart-beating donors that had suffered 45 minutes of warm ischemia. We developed a new solution for HMP to use in liver transplantation, based on BES, gluconate, and polyethylene glycol (BGP-HMP solution). After 24 h of HMP or CS, livers were reperfused at 37°C with Krebs-Henseleit solution with added dextran. For both procedures, portal pressure and flow were measured and the intrahepatic resistance (IR) was calculated. The pH oscillations and enzyme activities (LDH, AST, and ALT) were evaluated for the perfusion buffer during normothermic reperfusion. O2 consumption of the liver, glycogen production, and bile flow were also measured during the normothermic reperfusion period. Portal flow and IR showed statistical differences (P < 0.05) between the two groups (n = 5). HMP with BGP-HMP solution resulted in higher values of portal flow and lower IR than CS with HTK solution. Enzyme release after 90 min of reperfusion did not show statistical differences between groups. With regard to bile flow and O2 consumption, livers preserved by both processes were able to produce bile, but livers preserved with HMP were able to take up more O2 than livers preserved by CS.

Current state of hypothermic machine perfusion preservation of organs: The clinical perspective

This review focuses on the application of hypothermic perfusion technology as a topic of current interest with the potential to have a salutary impact on the mounting clinical challenges to improve the quantity and quality of donor organs and the outcome of transplantation. The ex vivo perfusion of donor organs on a machine prior to transplant, as opposed to static cold storage on ice, is not a new idea but is being re-visited because of the prospects of making available more and better organs for transplantation. The rationale for pursuing perfusion technology will be discussed in relation to emerging data on clinical outcomes and economic benefits for kidney transplantation. Reference will also be made to on-going research using other organs with special emphasis on the pancreas for both segmental pancreas and isolated islet transplantation. Anticipated and emerging benefits of hypothermic machine perfusion of organs are: (i) maintaining the patency of the vascular bed, (ii) providing nutrients and low demand oxygen to support reduced energy demands, (iii) removal of metabolic by-products and toxins, (iv) provision of access for administration of cytoprotective agents and/or immunomodulatory drugs, (v) increase of available assays for organ viability assessment and tissue matching, (vi) facilitation of a change from emergency to elective scheduled surgery with reduced costs and improved outcomes, (vii) improved clinical outcomes as demonstrated by reduced PNF and DGF parameters, (viii) improved stabilization or rescue of ECD kidneys or organs from NHBD that increase the size of the donor pool, (ix) significant economic benefit for the transplant centers and reduced health care costs, and (x) provision of a technology for ex vivo use of non-transplanted human organs for pharmaceutical development research.

Normothermic versus hypothermic ex vivo flush using a novel phosphate-free preservation solution (AQIX) in porcine kidneys

BACKGROUND

The initial flush of an organ is important to remove any cellular components from the microcirculation before storage. The aim of this study was to assess graft function after an ex vivo warm flush with a novel non-phosphate buffered preservation solution AQIX RS-I (AQIX) compared with a traditional cold flush.

METHODS

Porcine kidneys were either warm-flushed with AQIX RS-I at 30°C, or cold-flushed at 4°C with University of Wisconsin solution (UW) or hyperosmolar citrate (HOC) preservation solution at a pressure of 100 cmH2O (n = 6). Renal function was measured ex vivo by perfusing the organs with autologous blood at 37°C on an isolated organ perfusion system.

RESULTS

The AQIX group flushed significantly quicker than the cold stored groups (22 ± 1.8 versus UW 4.9 ± 1.6 versus HOC 10 ± 1.6 mL/min/100g; P = 0.001) and gained less weight than the UW group (19 ± 2.9 versus UW 30 ± 3.4 versus HOC 21% ± 7.7%; P = 0.025). The AQIX group also had superior acid-base homeostasis. Functional results, histologic analysis, and ADP: ATP levels were comparable between the groups.

CONCLUSION

Flushing kidneys with AQIX at 30°C cleared the renal microcirculation of blood more rapidly without any detrimental effects when compared to traditional cold flushing with UW or HOC at 4°C. Warm initial flushing has potential to be developed as part of normothermic renal preservation techniques.

Hypothermic perfusion preservation: the future of organ preservation revisited?

Hypothermic perfusion preservation (HPP) was an integral step in the development of early clinical transplantation programmes, and considerable progress was made in understanding the basic principles underlying the technique. In subsequent years, the development of better preservation solutions for cold hypoxic storage, along with pragmatic choices made on grounds of costs and logistics, saw a fall in the application of HPP. More recently, the acute shortage of suitable organ donors and the inevitable pressure to use organs from sub-optimal (or expanded criteria) donors, has forced a re-evaluation of HPP, and the development of a new generation of HPP machines and associated perfusion solutions. This review sets out the historical development of HPP across the range of organs in which the method was originally investigated, describes the biological benefits and drawbacks associated with HPP, and sets out the most recent literature on the topic (including comments on the interest in use of higher temperatures in organ perfusion).

Improved machine perfusion preservation of the non-heart-beating donor rat liver using Polysol: a new machine perfusion preservation solution

Waiting lists for transplantation have stimulated interest in the use of non-heart-beating donor (NHBD) organs. Recent studies on organ preservation have shown advantages of machine perfusion (MP) over cold storage (CS). To supply the liver with specific nutrients during MP, the preservation solution Polysol was developed. The aim of our study was to compare CS in University of Wisconsin solution (UW) with MP using UW-gluconate (UW-G) or Polysol in an NHBD model. After 30 minutes of warm ischemia, livers were harvested from rats for preservation by either CS, MP-UW-G, or MP-Polysol. After 24 hours of preservation, livers were reperfused with Krebs-Henseleit buffer (KHB). Perfusate samples were analyzed for liver damage and function. Biopsies were examined by hematoxylin and eosin staining and transmission electron microscopy. Liver damage was highest after CS compared with the MP groups. MP using Polysol compared with UW-G resulted in less aspartate aminotransferase (AST) and alanine aminotransferase (ALT) release. Perfusate flow, bile production, and ammonia clearance were highest after MP-Polysol compared with CS and MP-UW-G. Tissue edema was least after MP-Polysol compared with CS and MP-UW-G. In conclusion, preservation of the NHBD rat liver by hypothermic MP is superior to CS. Furthermore, MP using Polysol results in better-quality liver preservation compared with using UW-G.

Hepatic function in hypothermically stored porcine livers: Comparison of hypothermic machine perfusion vs cold storage

Hypothermic machine perfusion (HMP) has a potential to relieve the current donor liver crisis by providing an improved and extended preservation method. This study examined the effect of HMP on hepatocellular functions, using a prototype liver transporter capable of preserving livers for 24 hours. Livers obtained from adult farm pigs (28 to 32 kg body weight) were divided into three groups: fresh control, HMP, and simple cold storage (n = 4 each). A 4-hour normothermic reperfusion of livers was conducted to assess hepato-metabolic and cellular functions. The hepatic transport function, as indicated by canalicular excretion of indocyanine green, was improved in the HMP group than in the SCS group. The overall tissue viability, as indicated by oxygen consumption levels, was notably improved in HMP and control livers as compared to the SCS group. Higher bile production in both the preserved groups as compared to the fresh control livers could be a result of biliary edema and leakage of plasma into the canaliculus. The hepato-cellular injury, measured by ALT, release was significantly greater in the SCS group as compared to the HMP and control groups. These findings suggest that HMP could be a better method to preserve hepatic function and overall tissue viability as compared to SCS. Improved hepatic functions are indirect indicators of superior microcirculation and sinusoidal endothelial cell functions. Further studies in progress will evaluate these functions to confirm the significance of these observations.

Survival transplantation of preserved non-heart-beating donor rat livers: preservation by hypothermic machine perfusion

BACKGROUND

Non-heart-beating donor (NHBD) livers are an untapped source with the potential to provide relief to the current donor shortage problem. Hypothermic machine perfusion (MP) has the potential to reclaim and preserve these marginal donor organs.

METHODS

This study compared 5-day survival in a rat NHBD liver transplantation model with simple cold storage (SCS) and MP-preserved tissues that had experienced 30 min of warm ischemia followed by a 5-hr preservation period with the University of Wisconsin solution. Total release of lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) and alanine aminotransferase (ALT) were determined at major time points. Bilirubin levels and histology were examined after 5-day survival.

RESULTS

Six of seven control livers and five of six MP livers survived, whereas SCS tissues had survival in zero of seven. The results showed that MP livers had reduced release of LDH and ALT after 5 hr of storage, 5.07+/-1.42 and 2.02+/-0.69 U (mean+/-SE), respectively, compared with SCS, 15.54+/-0.81 and 3.41.3+/-0.73 U, respectively. Bilirubin values after 5-day survival of MP livers (1.17+/-0.49 mg/dL) were comparable to controls (0.91+/-0.36 mg/dL). Histology confirms that SCS displayed increased necrosis and MP tissue showed regions of near normal hepatic structure.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that MP for 5 hr improves survival and reduces cellular damage of liver tissue that has experienced 30 min of warm ischemia when compared with SCS tissues. Further studies need to be conducted, but this study suggests that MP preservation has the potential to reclaim and preserve NHBD liver tissues.

Oxygenated machine perfusion mitigates surface antigen expression and improves preservation of predamaged donor livers

The aim of the present study was to evaluate the potential benefit of machine preservation with the Belzer MPS or HTK solution, compared to standard cold storage, after procurement of marginal livers from non-heart beating donors in an experimental pilot study. Livers from male Wistar rats (250-300 g bw) were harvested after 60 min of cardiac arrest, flushed via the portal vein and cold stored submerged in HTK for 24 h at 4 degrees C while other organs were subjected to oxygenated machine perfusion with HTK or Belzer's MPS at 5 ml/min at 4 degrees C. Cold perfusion of livers with the non-colloidal HTK was not compromised by the lack of oncotic agents and there was no rise in vascular resistance during the 24 h of machine preservation with HTK or the colloidal Belzer MPS. Viability of the livers was assessed after the cold preservation period by warm reperfusion in vitro. Oxygenated machine perfusion was found to significantly increase viability of the livers vs simple cold storage with respect to portal vascular resistance upon reperfusion, enzyme release as well as functional recovery of oxygen utilization or bile production. Moreover, tissue antigen expression of ICAM-1 or histocompatibility antigen class II could be markedly reduced by oxygenated perfusion preservation as compared to cold storage. It is concluded that predamaged organs should preferably be preserved by oxygenated machine perfusion thus minimizing functional alterations and immunogenicity of the graft. In this setup HTK appeared equally effective as Belzer's MPS for machine preservation.

Liver and kidney preservation by perfusion

The clinical boundaries of transplantation have been set in an era of simple cold storage. Research in organ preservation has led to the development of flush solutions that buffer the harsh molecular conditions which develop during ischaemia, and provide stored organs that are fit to sustain life after transplantation. Although simple and efficient, this method might be reaching its limit with respect to the duration, preservation, and the quality of organs that can be preserved. In addition, flush preservation does not allow for adequate viability assessment. There is good evidence that preservation times will be extended by the provision of continuous cellular substrate. Stimulation of in-vivo conditions by ex-vivo perfusion could also mean that marginal organs will be salvaged for transplantation. Perfusion will also allow for assessing the viability of organs before transplantation in a continuous fashion. The cumulative effect of these benefits would include expansion of the donor pool, less risk of primary non-function, and extension of the safe preservation period. Use of non-heart-beating donors, international organ sharing, and precise calculation of the risk of primary organ failure could become standard.

A comparison of the metabolic effects of continuous hypothermic perfusion or oxygenated persufflation during hypothermic storage of rat liver

The metabolic consequences of supplying oxygen by two different modes were investigated. The effects of hypothermic liver preservation after cold hypoxic flush (Group I), oxygenated vascular persufflation (Group II), and continuous oxygenated perfusion (Group III) were compared. Adenine nucleotides were measured to assess energetics, and 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy was employed to investigate other metabolic pathways. Energetics were maintained by both modes of oxygenation at 24 h. The mitochondrial redox state is indicated by the ratio of acetoacetate (Ace) and beta-hydroxybutyrate (betaHb). The detection of only betaHb or Ace in the hypoxic flush and perfused livers, respectively, suggested that the mitochondria of these livers were hyperreduced and hyperoxidized, respectively. In contrast, both components of the redox couple were detected in the persufflated livers, suggesting that persufflation may be a simple and effective method of maintaining hepatic energetics long-term while maintaining a more normal mitochondrial redox state.

Role of hepatocytes and bile duct cells in preservation-reperfusion injury of liver grafts

In liver transplantation, it is currently hypothesized that nonparenchymal cell damage and/or activation is the major cause of preservation-related graft injury. Because parenchymal cells (hepatocytes) appear morphologically well preserved even after extended cold preservation, their injury after warm reperfusion is ascribed to the consequences of nonparenchymal cell damage and/or activation. However, accumulating evidence over the past decade indicated that the current hypothesis cannot fully explain preservation-related liver graft injury. We review data obtained in animal and human liver transplantation and isolated perfused animal livers, as well as isolated cell models to highlight growing evidence of the importance of hepatocyte disturbances in the pathogenesis of normal and fatty graft injury. Particular attention is given to preservation time-dependent decreases in high-energy adenine nucleotide levels in liver cells, a circumstance that (1) sensitizes hepatocytes to various stimuli and insults, (2) correlates well with graft function after liver transplantation, and (3) may also underlie the preservation time-dependent increase in endothelial cell damage. We also review damage to bile duct cells, which is increasingly being recognized as important in the long-lasting phase of reperfusion injury. The role of hydrophobic bile salts in that context is particularly assessed. Finally, a number of avenues aimed at preserving hepatocyte and bile duct cell integrity are discussed in the context of liver transplantation therapy as a complement to reducing nonparenchymal cell damage and/or activation.

Energy metabolism following prolonged hepatic cold preservation: benefits of interrupted hypoxia on the adenine nucleotide pool in rat liver

The ability of brief hypothermic reperfusion (HtR) to restore hepatic energy metabolism following periods of cold hypoxic preservation was studied in isolated rat livers after storage times of 5, 10, and 24 h. In addition, investigations were performed on the effects of HtR used to restore liver oxidative metabolism in the middle of a prolonged (24 h) hypoxic preservation period. A histidine-lactobionate-raffinose solution was used for the initial cold portal flush in all groups. Results showed that cold hypoxia for either 5 or 10 h yielded livers capable of similar recoveries of ATP, energy charge, and total adenine nucleotides, but that HtR after 24 h cold preservation resulted in reduced regeneration of ATP, a lower energy charge, and a fall in tissue adenine nucleotides. When livers were stored for 24 h but subjected to brief HtR after either 5 or 10 h before return to hypoxic storage, improved recoveries of the energy metabolites were seen over those recorded after 24 h hypoxia alone. The fact that these improvements were not due to an improved supply of adenine nucleotide precursors was demonstrated by studying groups which were given HtR with perfusate containing precursors of adenine nucleotides (adenosine, adenine, and inosine) after 24 h cold hypoxia. These data are consistent with the hypothesis that poor metabolic recovery after long-term hepatic cold preservation results more from decreased mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation than from a lack of precursors for adenine nucleotide resynthesis. In addition, restoring oxidative metabolism at hypothermia for brief periods can to some extent protect final metabolic status after prolonged storage.

Reduced oxidative stress during acellular reperfusion of the rat liver after hypothermic oscillating perfusion

BACKGROUND

ATP resynthesis during reperfusion after liver preservation has been shown to be well correlated with the function of transplanted grafts. Nevertheless, the advantages of a cellular energy charge loading during the preservation period are yet not fully understood. This study evaluates the effects of different nucleotide levels at the end of preservation on metabolic changes and oxidative stress during reperfusion.

METHODS

Two experimental groups were chosen reflecting different energy charge states after preservation: static cold storage for 10 hr and hypothermic oxygenated oscillating perfusion for 10 hr. In both experimental groups, normothermic ex vivo acellular reperfusion over 40 min was performed. A third group consisted of nonpreserved livers similarly reperfused for 40 min. Superoxide formation was detected by the superoxide dismutase inhibitable reduction of ferricytochrome c added to the normothermic perfusate.

RESULTS

Superoxide formation and lipid peroxidation malondialdehyde were significantly lower during reperfusion after the energy charge loading before reperfusion by the hypothermic oscillating perfusion technique. However, oxygen radical formation, liver cell injury (lactate dehydrogenase [LDH] release), and TNFalpha release were significantly higher in energy charge-depleted groups (nonpreserved and cold stored livers).

CONCLUSIONS

Hypothermic oscillating oxygenated perfusion led to the elevated energy charge during preservation and led to reduced oxygen radical formation as well as less lipid peroxidation during reperfusion, in contrast to cold stored livers and nonpreserved livers. This suggests a correlation between the energy charge before reperfusion and oxygen radical formation as well as liver injury at reperfusion.

Hypothermic oscillating liver perfusion stimulates ATP synthesis prior to transplantation

BACKGROUND

ATP and glycogen depletion often have been demonstrated during cold storage of the liver prior to transplantation. Suppression of events that lead to metabolic depression and to lipid peroxidation could contribute to improvement of liver preservation. A new method of liver preservation for transplantation is therefore suggested, an oscillating oxygenated hypothermic liver perfusion.

METHODS

Biochemical analysis of liver tissue samples and perfusate after 10 h of perfusion by the presented oscillating perfusion model were compared with results after continuous liver perfusion for 10 h as well as with data derived from cold-stored livers over a period of 10 h. Particular reference was made to nucleotide metabolites, glycogen content, lipid peroxidation, glutathione content, glycolytic metabolites, and enzyme release before and after preservation.

RESULTS

Glycogen depletion occurred to the same degree in hypothermic storage and machine perfusion (oscillating as well as continuous perfusion), but the energy charge was significantly increased after oxygenated perfusion, whereas cold storage resulted in a significant energy charge depletion. In addition, perfusion by an oscillating technique yielded superior energy charge loading compared to the continuous perfusion technique and diminished the other hand lipid peroxidation.

CONCLUSIONS

Hypothermic oscillating oxygenated perfusion could be important for the improvement of the quality of energy-depleted organs prior to transplantation.

Rat liver preservation by hypothermic oscillating liver perfusion compared to simple cold storage

Rat livers were preserved hypothermically for 10 or 24 h in vitro as if for transplantation. Two methods of preservation were compared using physiological and biochemical parameters: simple storage and oscillating perfusion. By measuring the nucleotides after preservation the calculated energy charge was significantly higher after 10 and 24 h of oscillating perfusion compared to the simple storage group. In addition, a significant energy charge loading was demonstrated by 10 h oscillating perfusion compared to the initial value prior to perfusion. The oscillating, computer-controlled perfusion permits continuous monitoring of perfusate temperature, O2 consumption, pCO2, portal vein pressure, and pH and also automatic sample collection and pH compensation. In addition, the perfusate can be easily exchanged by using two different pumps or be rewarmed by a heat exchanger. For measuring of short-lived metabolites (interleukins, oxygen radicals, prostaglandins) sampling can be performed directly out of the vena cava outflow. pH and temperature stability was maintained by a data acquisition and controlling system. Because of a special designed liver chamber a combination of storage and perfusion with or without substrates was possible. The demonstrated standardized perfusion technique was achieved by a combination of special equipment and computer-aided monitoring and allows further experiments to improve understanding of ischemic and reperfusion injury.

On the correlation between tissue hydration state and proton NMR relaxation rates in experimental liver transplantation

As the tissue hydration state is one of the most important parameters to predict viability cold stored livers before transplantation, we investigated the correlation between the tissue inverse total water fraction, reflecting the hydration state, and proton relaxation times in cold stored rat liver and orthotopic liver transplantation in a pig model. In cold stored rat liver excellent linear correlations between relaxation rates R1 (= 1/T1) and R2 (= 1/T2) and inverse total water fraction 1/Pw were obtained. In pig liver transplants, the slope and intercept obtained from a linear regression model are twice as high for R1 and almost identical for R2; however, correlation coefficients are lower due to increased biological variation and a smaller range in storage conditions, reflected by the range of water content. Proton nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation times measured during the cold storage on the whole organ non-invasively show also linear correlation with the inverse total water fraction, but the method is presently not accurate enough to estimate the hydration state of the liver tissue with sufficient precision. NMR relaxation times obtained from liver biopsies have the potential to predict tissue viability in experimental liver transplantation independent of species, strain and gender, and thus may be useful in estimating the viability of human donor livers (or at least add a new complementary information to the information gained by standard liver selection and function test before and after transplantation).

Involvement of reactive oxygen species in the preservation injury to cultured liver endothelial cells

We have previously demonstrated an energy-dependent injury to cultured liver endothelial cells during cold incubation in University of Wisconsin (UW) solution. In the present study, we report experimental evidence for the involvement of reactive oxygen species in this injury: LDH release during 48 h of cold incubation in UW solution was decreased from 40-55% under aerobic conditions to less than 20% under hypoxic conditions or by the presence of KCN (1 mM). Similar protection was achieved by the addition of the spin trap 5,5-dimethyl-1-pyrroline N-oxide, the hydroxyl radical scavenger dimethyl sulfoxide, or the flavonoid silibinin to UW solution under aerobic conditions. Preincubating the cells with the iron chelator deferoxamine even decreased the injury to less than 5%. The residual injury (as observed after longer incubation times) under hypoxic conditions or in cells preincubated with deferoxamine was no longer energy dependent. The amount of thiobarbituric acid-reactive substances markedly increased during cold incubation of the cells in UW solution. This increase was not observed in UW solution to which KCN had been added, i.e., under the conditions of energy depletion. These results suggest that an iron-dependent generation of reactive oxygen species with subsequent lipid peroxidation is involved in the pathogenesis of the injury to cultured liver endothelial cells in cold UW solution.