Clinical features and response to treatment of infradiaphragmatic Hodgkin's disease

Outcome of Patients With Early-Stage Infradiaphragmatic Hodgkin Lymphoma: A Comprehensive Analysis From the German Hodgkin Study Group

Purpose The prognostic effect of isolated infradiaphragmatic involvement in Hodgkin lymphoma (HL) is controversial, and there are little data about patients treated with current therapies. Therefore, we performed a risk factor analysis to focus on isolated nodal infradiaphragmatic disease in patients treated within the German Hodgkin Study Group trials HD13 (clinical trial information: ISRCTN63474366) and HD14 (clinical trial information: ISRCTN04761296) for early-stage HL. Patients and Methods Characteristics and outcomes of patients who had infradiaphragmatic HL were compared with patients who had supradiaphragmatic disease. Progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS) were estimated according to Kaplan-Meier methods and were compared between groups using the log-rank test and Cox proportional hazards regression, which was also applied for multivariable analyses that adjusted for relevant baseline characteristics. Results Of 2,903 qualified patients, 223 (7.7%) were diagnosed with isolated nodal infradiaphragmatic disease. In general, these patients were older, had a poorer performance status, were more often male, and had the nodular sclerosis subtype less often than those with supradiaphragmatic disease. After a median follow-up time of 51 months, PFS and OS were significantly worse in patients with infradiaphragmatic disease (5-year PFS and OS, 80.1% and 91.5% v 91.2% and 97.6% in patients with supradiaphragmatic disease; each P < .001). In multivariable analyses, infradiaphragmatic HL remained a significant risk factor in terms of PFS (hazard ratio [HR], 1.5; 95% CI, 1.04 to 2.2; P = .03) and OS (HR, 2.0; 95% CI, 1.2 to 3.5; P = .01). However, inferior PFS and OS could not be observed among those patients treated with the more intensive chemotherapy (two cycles of doxorubicin, bleomycin, vinblastine, and dacarbazine [ABVD] in HD13, and two cycles of escalated bleomycin, etoposide, doxorubicin, cyclophosphamide, vincristine, procarbazine, and prednisone [BEACOPP_escalated] plus two cycles of ABVD in HD14; all patients received 30 Gy of involved-field radiotherapy). Conclusion Early-stage HL that presents with infradiaphragmatic disease only represents a distinct patient group with an inferior outcome. However, this adverse outcome can be outweighed by appropriate combined modality treatment.

Hodgkin's Disease Stage I and II with Exclusive Subdiaphragmatic Presentation. The Experience of the Departments of Radiation Oncology and Hematology, University “La Sapienza” of Rome

During the period 1978 to 1994, 1054 patients with Hodgkin's disease were evaluated and treated at the Departments of Radiation Oncology and Hematology, University “La Sapienza”, Rome. A total of 549 patients presented with clinical or pathological stage I and II; 37 of these had Hodgkin's disease below the diaphragm (BDHD), and 512 above the diaphragm (ADHD). A comparison of patients with BDHD versus those with ADHD showed that the first group had a higher male to female ratio. A comparison of cases with stage II BDHD versus those with stage II ADHD showed that patients with BDHD were older (48 years vs 28 years), had different histologic features and a higher incidence of systemic symptoms (67% vs 33%). Stage II BDHD patients had a worse prognosis; in fact, there were significant differences in the overall survival and relapse-free-survival rates for cases with stage II BDHD versus those with stage II ADHD (overall survival, 46% vs 80%, P<0.001; relapse-free survival, 44% vs 69%, P<0.005). Stage was found to be the most important prognostic factor for BDHD cases without systemic symptoms treated with radiation therapy alone. The type of infradiaphragmatic presentation (intra-abdominal vs peripheral disease) did not influence outcome, probably due to the more aggressive therapy received by the intra-adbominal group. Treatment recommendations for BDHD cases should be tailored to the stage and the presence or absence of intra-abdominal localization. For patients with stage IA extended fields, irradiation (inverted Y) is sufficent. However, combined modality therapy should be the treatment of choice for stage II cases, particularly in the presence of intra-abdominal disease. Patients with systemic symptoms also require combined modalities.

Infradiaphragmatic Hodgkin lymphoma: a large series of patients staged with PET-CT

Introduction

Infradiaphragmatic Hodgkin Lymphoma (IDHL) accounts for 3-11% of adult cases of stage I-II Hodgkin Lymphoma and the treatment strategy in IDHL is still heterogeneous. All previous published studies were conducted before the PET-CT era. PET may provide a more accurate evaluation of IDHL stage. The aim of this study was to analyze the clinical and biological characteristics of IDHL patients staged by CT scan or PET-CT in eight French hematology departments and their impact on outcomes in these patients.

Methods

Baseline clinical and biological data and outcomes in patients with a first diagnosis of stage I-II IDHL treated with ABVD +/- radiotherapy were retrospectively collected.

Results

Among the 99 patients included, 65 (66%) were staged with PET-CT. These patients were older (53 years vs 46 years, p=0.043), had lower ESR (27 vs 58mm, p=0.022), higher hemoglobin level (13.6 vs 12.8g/dL, p=0.015), less frequent Ann Arbor stage II (74% vs 91%) and less central adenopathy involvement (60% vs 82%, p=0.024). Treatment was chemotherapy alone in 55% of patients and the remaining patients received chemo-radiotherapy (CRT). Five-year PFS and OS rates in PET-CT-staged patients were 78% (95% CI 64-87) and 88% (95% CI 73-95), respectively, compared with 65% (p=0.225) and 82% (p=0.352) in CT-staged patients. The CRT strategy was associated with fewer relapses (p=0.027).

Conclusion

This study showed that the characteristics of CT-staged IDHL patients were less favorable than those of PET-CT-staged patients and indicated that CRT provided better PFS than did chemotherapy alone.

Hodgkin's disease: correlation between causes of death at autopsy and clinical diagnosis

PURPOSE

The causes of mortality in Hodgkin's disease patients are insufficiently known. Autopsy study is the fundamental procedure in the investigation of these causes. The present study analyzes the autopsies performed in a series of patients diagnosed as having Hodgkin's disease, determining the cause of death in each case and comparing the premortem clinical data and the postmortem findings.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A total of 486 patients diagnosed as having Hodgkin's disease between 1967 and 1996 were assessed. Autopsy was performed in 40 of the 144 deceased patients (28%). We reviewed the pathological findings, effects of treatment, discordance between the clinical diagnosis and the outcome of autopsy, and cause of death in each case.

RESULTS

The most common clinical causes of death in those patients with autopsy study were tumor progression (37%) and infections (43%) in those patients with autopsy study. The rate of discordance between the clinical and autopsy diagnoses in this study was 43%. The most frequent location of residual Hodgkin's disease was in the lymph nodes.

CONCLUSIONS

Autopsy study in Hodgkin's disease confirms a high rate of discrepancy between final clinical diagnosis and postmortem lesions despite advances in diagnostic methods. Autopsy revealed causes of death directly related to the treatment, as well as some lesions directly related to patient death and secondary to treatment. Infectious processes are likely to remain undetected and their symptoms can mimic tumor progression.

Subdiaphragmatic stage I & II Hodgkin's disease: long-term follow-up and prognostic factors

PURPOSE

To report long-term follow-up results and to analyze prognostic factors for overall and disease-free survival in patients with subdiaphragmatic Stage I & II Hodgkin's disease.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

From September 1962 to April 1995, 109 patients presented at the M. D. Anderson Cancer Center with subdiaphragmatic Hodgkin's disease. The medical records of these patients were retrospectively reviewed; 22 patients who received no treatment at the M. D. Anderson Cancer Center or who had radiation therapy at other institutions were excluded. The remaining 87 patients formed the basis of this study. The median age of our group was 33 years with a male: female ratio of 3.3:1. The histological subtypes were nodular sclerosis in 21 (24.1%) patients, mixed cellularity in 31 (35.6%), lymphocyte predominance in 33 (37.9%), lymphocyte depletion in 1 (1.1%) and unclassified histology in 1 (1.1%). Of the patients, 32 (36.8%) underwent laparotomy for diagnosis or staging purpose, 74 (85.1%) had lymphangiography, and 35 (40.2%) had computerized tomography of the abdomen and pelvis. Among the patients, 22 (25%) had more than three sites of nodal involvement at presentation, 56 (64.4%) had pelvic or abdominal disease, and 14 (18.4%) had bulky disease that was defined as disease with the largest dimension > or = 7 cm. Stage distribution was IA in 33.3%, IIA in 39.1%, and IIB in 27.6%. Treatment was radiotherapy alone in 60 (69%) patients, chemotherapy and radiation in 23 (26.4%), and chemotherapy alone in 4 (4.6%).

RESULTS

The 10- and 20-year actuarial overall survival rates for all patients were 74.6% and 55.3%, and the corresponding disease-free survival rates were 72.4% and 67.5%, respectively. On univariate analysis, age > 40 years, B symptoms, nodular sclerosis or mixed cellularity histology, and decreased albumin or hemoglobin levels were statistically significant adverse pretreatment factors for overall survival. B symptoms, decreased albumin level, more than 3 sites of disease at presentation, and Stage II were statistically significant negative pretreatment prognostic factors for disease-free survival. Only B symptoms and decreased albumin level predicted worse outcome in both overall and disease-free survivals. On multivariate analysis, age > 40 years, nodular sclerosis and mixed cellularity histology, and decreased hemoglobin levels were three independent risk factors for overall survival. An analysis of the pattern of failure revealed that the majority of the patients with central Stage II disease who did not receive mantle radiation failed in the supradiaphragmatic area. Late complications of radiation were infrequent.

CONCLUSIONS

Long-term follow-up of this group of patients revealed similar overall and disease-free long-term survival, as would be expected from supradiaphragmatic Hodgkin's disease. For patients with central Stage II disease, it is anticipated that supradiaphragmatic radiation therapy would improve the disease-free survival.

Infradiaphragmatic Hodgkin's disease: the Swedish National Care Programme experience. The Swedish Lymphoma Study Group

A Swedish national care programme has provided guidelines for staging, treatment and follow-up of all patients with Hodgkin's disease (HD) since 1985. Between January 1985 and December 1992, 920 patients were reported and followed prospectively. Of a total of 533 patients with stage I and II disease, 484 presented with supradiaphragmatic HD and 49 (9%) with infradiaphragmatic HD. The median follow-up time was 4.3 yr (3.3-10 yr). Significant differences in average age (45 +/- 21 yr and 55 +/- 19 yr), male:female ratio (1.1:1 and 2.8:1) and B-symptoms (25% and 47%) were observed in patients with supra- and infradiaphragmatic HD, respectively. Forty-six patients with infradiaphragmatic HD were treated with a curative intention and 40 (87%) achieved a complete response. Eleven (28%) of the 40 patients have recurred and 8 patients have died of HD. Complete response rates and recurrence frequencies did not differ from those observed in patients with supradiaphragmatic HD. Mortality was, however, significantly higher (p = 0.001) in the infradiaphragmatic group; this was due mainly to poorer effects of salvage treatment in a elderly population. In this population-based study, patients with peripheral disease in stage IA respond well to inverted Y irradiation alone, whereas it appears to be important to give stage II patients chemotherapy or a combined modality treatment in order to avoid unacceptably high recurrence rates.

Treatment of subdiaphragmatic Hodgkin's disease: is radiotherapy alone appropriate only for inguino-femoral presentations?

PURPOSE

Evaluate the role of staging laparotomy, and the impact of disease subsites on treatment outcome, for sub-diaphragmatic Hodgkin's Disease.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between 1966 and 1989, 23 patients with Hodgkin's disease limited to sites below the diaphragm were treated at the Royal Adelaide Hospital. The high male:female ratio (2:8), low proportion of nodular sclerosis subtype (26%), and older age (mean = 40) relative to supra-diaphragmatic Hodgkin's disease is consistent with most other series. Thirteen patients underwent staging laparotomy. Initial treatment consisted of radiation therapy alone in 11, chemotherapy alone in 7, and combined modality therapy in 4 patients. This data was then combined with other published series over the last decade, to analyse relapse patterns and treatment results in relation to initial site(s) of disease.

RESULTS

The overall, disease specific, and progression free 5 (and 10) year survival rates were 69%, 81%, and 58% respectively. There was no statistically significant effect of staging laparotomy on any of these parameters. Combining these results with those in the literature revealed an unacceptable relapse rate for patients with disease outside of the inguino-femoral region treated with inverted-Y radiation therapy alone.

CONCLUSIONS

For the majority of patients with sub-diaphragmatic Hodgkin's disease, staging laparotomy can be avoided. Inverted-Y radiation therapy should only be used for inguino-femoral presentations.

Serum lactate dehydrogenase level as a prognostic factor in Hodgkin's disease

The efficacy of currently available treatments for Hodgkin's disease (HD) has led to a substantial modification in the prognosis of this disease; nevertheless there is still a group of patients that cannot be cured with conventional treatments and who will be candidates for alternative therapy. In the present work we analysed the prognostic influence of the most relevant clinico-biological characteristics of HD in a consecutive series of 137 patients diagnosed and treated in a single institution. Univariate analyses identified six variables with significant prognostic influence, both on achieving complete remission (CR) and overall survival (OS); LDH > 320 U ml-1, age > 45 years, stages IIB, III and IV, extranodal involvement, alkaline phosphatase > 190 UI dl and ESR > 40 mm h. In addition, Hb < 12.5 gr dl-1 and abdominal disease were statistically relevant for CR while a poor performance score (ECOG > or = 2) affected a lower survival. In the multivariate analysis only LDH, age and the clinical stage retained a significant prognostic influence for achieving CR, while the two first factors above, together with performance status were the variables with independent prognostic value with respect to OS. Moreover, only LDH > 320 U ml-1 had prognostic influence in the probability of relapse and disease free survival (DFS), both in the univariate and multivariate analyses. According to the three independent factors obtained in the multivariate analysis for CR (LDH, age and stage) a predictive model was established that allows the stratification of patients into two prognostic groups: one with poor prognosis that includes patients with the three adverse prognostic factors, or two if one of them was elevated LDH, and the other with good prognosis that includes the remaining patients. This model was also able to separate two independent groups of patients with respect to OS and to DFS. In conclusion, the present study shows that LDH is one of the most important prognostic factors in HD.

Hodgkin's disease and the malignant lymphomas

The unanticipated finding of a subcutaneous swelling, typically an enlarged lymph node in the neck, is legitimate cause for concern. After excluding benign or reactive conditions, this sign should initiate a series of investigations to characterize the neoplasm and, in the case of a lymphoma, lead to prompt treatment aimed at cure. The classic description of such cervical adenopathy is that by Thomas Hodgkin, who clearly recorded both the clinical behavior and the macroscopic findings evident at dissection. Subsequent histologic study revealed the multinucleate giant cells that characterize the tumor that now bears his name and linked it to those of Greenfield, Sternberg, and Reed. Initial debate centered on whether this entity was inflammatory or malignant, with the issue further clouded by the frequent coexistence of tuberculosis. Although a number of features exist in favor of both concepts, current consensus places it among the neoplastic processes. Hodgkin's disease was separated from other malignant lymphomas as agreement on diagnostic criteria emerged. The next major step forward was the demonstration, first by Vera Peters and then by Henry Kaplan, that adequate doses of radiotherapy were curative when delivered to treatment fields that encompassed the tumor. A further milestone was the introduction by Vincent DeVita, Jr., and his colleagues of combination chemotherapy that was effective in late stage of disseminated disease. The established cornerstones of managing these patients are accurate diagnosis; precise anatomic staging, modified as appropriate by associated factors known to have prognostic value; and selection of irradiation, chemotherapy, or whatever combination will result in the best possible patient survival. However, success is not universal, and death due to resistant or relapsing disease is encountered all too frequently. It is here that the benefits of a multidisciplinary approach are evident, because a substantial level of expertise coupled with sound judgment is needed to salvage these individuals, often by means of investigational programs. Some of the latter are limited by profound myelosuppression, and safety may center on the use of cytokines in the form of interleukins and growth factors, with or without bone marrow transplantation. In such situations, benefit must be balanced against risks in well-structured clinical trials that embody informed consent. Herein lies one of the major goals for the next decade. The non-Hodgkin's lymphomas can conveniently be considered in two broad categories. Some follow an indolent clinical course, in which the lymph node retains a follicular pattern with small component cells, and others are aggressive tumors, in which primitive blasts have diffusely effaced the glandular architecture.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Hodgkin's disease diagnosed post mortem: a population based study

All cases of Hodgkin's disease (HD) notified to the Danish Cancer Registry from 1976 through 1987 in patients less than 70 years old were reviewed in order to identify patients in whom a correct diagnosis was established only post mortem. The case records of such patients were reviewed in a search for clinical features that could have ensured a correct pre mortem diagnosis. HD was diagnosed after death in 31 patients in this unselected population based study and thus constituting only 2.4% of all patients less than 70 years with HD, but 14.1% of the group aged 65-69 years. Most patients were identified during the first part of the study period, which may reflect a decreasing autopsy rate. HD was considered to be a coincidental finding in four patients and the primary cause of death in 27 patients. Among the later 27 patients a number of unfavourable prognostic factors were a common finding: persistent unexplained fever and weight loss, pancytopenia, hepatic involvement, bone marrow involvement, advanced stage disease, and lymphocytic depletion histology. However, most of the patients had no concurrent diseases and may have benefitted from a correct diagnosis and a potentially curative treatment. The many uncommon features of HD together with the frequent findings of falsely negative chest X-ray, bone marrow examination, liver biopsy, and ultrasound contributed to the difficulty in diagnosis. In about 1/3 of the patients clinical findings suggestive of lymphoma did not result in relevant diagnostic procedures.