Properties of the Mls system: a revised formulation of Mls genetics and an analysis of T-cell recognition of Mls determinants

Evidence for a thymus-dependent form of tolerance that is not based on elimination or anergy of reactive T cells

The avian embryo has provided an appropriate model to study the ontogeny of the primary lymphoid organs, thymus and bursa of Fabricius. By using the quail-chick marker system the embryonic origin of the highly intricate cell components which form these organs could be traced back to the initial endodermal, mesodermal and ectodermal germ layers. The timing and dynamics of the incoming and outcoming flows of hemopoietic cells which characterize their lymphopoietic activity could be revealed in both quail and chick embryos. This knowledge served as a basis for an investigation on the role of the epithelial component of the thymus (derived from the pharyngeal endoderm) on tolerance to tissue graft and, by extension, tolerance to self. When this work was undertaken, the prevailing view was that exposure of the developing immune system to foreign antigens in the embryo allows them to be assimilated to self components in the mature animal. In fact, this was found to be true for allogeneic grafts between MHC-distinct chickens, of certain tissues, such as for instance wing tissues. However, in heterospecific transplantations, i.e. when a limb bud was grafted from quail to chick embryos, the chick host acutely rejected the foreign limb soon after birth. In contrast, grafts of the quail thymic epithelial (TE) rudiment resulted in the development of a chimeric thymus in which the foreign epithelial component was not only tolerated but able to induce full tolerance of the grafted wing from the same donor. By monitoring the amount of quail TE implanted we showed in addition that only part of the peripheral T-cell population had to differentiate in the context of the quail epithelial cells to induce tolerance to quail tissues. This pointed to the generation in the thymus of regulatory T cells, coexisting with specific anti-quail reactive T cells, but able to inhibit them from reacting against the quail wing antigenic determinants. A mammalian model was then devised to further study this mechanism of tolerance that we have qualified as "dominant" by opposition to the current model based on either clonal elimination or anergy which can be considered as recessive or passive. Nude mice of MHC type A were grafted with TE of E10 type B embryos. They became reconstituted for T-cell function but tolerant for B skin allografts. Spleen cells from such tolerant animals injected to naive A nude mice reconstituted T cell function in the recipient and transferred the tolerance to B skin grafts. Reducing the number of donor cells resulted in the segregation of the two phenomena. For low numbers the recipients were restored but not tolerant, thus showing the coexistence in the tolerant donor of anti-B reactive T cells together with regulatory cells able to abolish their reactivity against B determinants. Other experiments demonstrated that TE-induced tolerance does not rely on clonal deletion or anergy. This was shown on systems where elimination of cells directed toward superantigens was screened. It turned out that tolerance to skin grafts and superantigen T-cell deletion are unrelated phenomena. These observations strongly suggest that tolerance to self results at least in part from the interplay between cells potentially harmful for self component and others which exert a strong control on their reactivity. The latter cell type depends upon interactions of thymocytes with the endodermal component of the thymus.

Direct evidence for the role of COOH terminus of mouse mammary tumor virus superantigen in determining T cell receptor V beta specificity

It has recently been shown that open reading frames in the 3' long terminal repeats of mouse mammary tumor viruses encode superantigens. These viral superantigens (vSAGs) stimulate most T cells expressing appropriate V beta s almost regardless of the rest of the variable components of the T cell receptors (TCR) expressed by those cells. vSAGs produce a type II integral membrane protein with a nonessential short cytoplasmic domain and a large glycosylated extracellular COOH-terminal domain, which is predicted to interact with major histocompatibility complex class II molecules and the TCR. The transmembrane region of vSAG also has an internal positively charged lysine residue of unknown significance. A set of chimeric and mutant vSAG genes has been used in transfection experiments to show that only the extreme COOH-terminal portion of vSAGs determine their TCR V beta specificities, and to show that the lysine residue in the transmembrane domain is not essential for the function of vSAG.

H-2 I-E molecules isolated from Mls1a stimulatory cells do not activate Mls1a-responsive T cells but do present exogenous staphylococcal enterotoxins

The T cell response to allogeneic murine Mls determinants is not H-2 restricted but is dependent on H-2 class II molecules on the Mls-expressing stimulator cells. We have tested planar membranes containing H-2 class II I-E molecules alone or with I-A molecules for their ability to activate a panel of Mls1a-specific T hybrids. Despite the ability of the planar membranes to activate an alloreactive T hybrid and to present staphylococcal enterotoxins or an antigenic peptide to appropriately responsive T hybrids, they failed to stimulate the Mls1a-specific T hybrids. These findings, in the light of the various controls demonstrating sufficiency of the I-E molecules in the planar membranes, indicate that Mls1a determinants are not covalently bound to I-E molecules; the two molecular species are thus either not physically associated or are linked by a relatively weak interaction. In addition, our experiments show that isolated I-E molecules but not I-A molecules present staphylococcal enterotoxins A and B to two independently derived T hybrids expressing T cell receptor V beta 1, V beta 2 and V beta 6 elements.

Effect of isotypic and allotypic variations of MHC class II molecules on staphylococcal enterotoxin presentation to murine T cells

Staphylococcal enterotoxins (SE) are known to be potent T cell activators, stimulating +/- proliferation and lymphokine production. These toxins have recently have been termed "superantigens" because of their ability to bind directly to class II molecules forming a ligand that interacts with particular V beta gene elements within the TCR complex. This interaction between SE and MHC class II molecules plays a central role in toxin-induced mitogenesis. In the present study we have examined the effect of polymorphism on the ability of MHC class II molecules to bind and present SE. Through the use of H-2 congenic mouse strains, it was possible to look directly at haplotype differences within the MHC and their effect on SE presentation to a panel of responsive V beta-bearing T cells. The results demonstrate that toxin presentation by class II-bearing accessory cells to murine T cells is greatly affected by polymorphisms within the H-2 complex. Toxin-pulsed accessory cells obtained from mice of an H-2k and H-2u haplotype were found to be less efficient in activating a variety of T cell clones and hybridomas. However, one T cell clone responded similarly to the enterotoxins presented on all H-2 haplotypes, suggesting that differences in responses of T cells are not simply a function of the degree of binding of these toxins to various class II molecules. Neutralization analysis with monoclonal anti-class II antibodies demonstrates that both I-A and I-E molecules play a significant role in SEA and SEB presentation to murine T cells. These results suggest that the differential activation of T cells by a particular enterotoxin may reflect a difference in recognition of an SE:class II ligand by a surface T cell receptor complex.

V beta 17 T-cell deletion by endogenous mammary tumor virus in wild-type-derived mouse strain

The wild-type-derived mouse strain PWK possesses a beta-chain variable region V beta 17a2 allele, which is expressed on mature T cells as part of the T-cell receptor of most mice expressing I-E, whereas V beta 17 T cells are deleted in all I-E+ laboratory mice bearing a V beta 17a1 allele. However, (PWK x CBA/J)F1 progeny and the wild-type-derived mouse strain MAI, which possesses the V beta 17a2 allele, display deletion of V beta 17 T cells. Analysis of (PWK x CBA/J) x PWK and of (PWK x MAI) x PWK backcrosses demonstrates that endogenous mouse mammary tumor virus MTV-6 from CBA/J and a MTV from strain MAI control the clonal deletion of V beta 17a2 as well as V beta 3 T cells. Furthermore, among I-E- progeny of a (MAI x C57BL/6) x C57BL/6 backcross, we observed that mice inheriting MTV of MAI have a reduced level of V beta 17 T cells, suggesting that the clonal deletion of V beta 17a2 T cells can be mediated in the absence of the I-E molecule. The 3' long terminal repeat of MTV MAI was cloned and translation of the open reading frame was compared to those of MTV known to encode superantigens. Comparisons indicate that MTV MAI has significantly diverged from the other MTVs. However, MTV MAI and MTV-6 share a stretch of 11 identical amino acids at the C terminus, which is divergent in MTV reacting with other V beta s. This suggests that this region is involved in determining the specificity toward V beta s and has been selectively conserved through evolution of the Mus species.

Direct activation of murine T cells by staphylococcal enterotoxins

The capacity of staphylococcal enterotoxins to stimulate all T cells bearing certain TCR variable region alleles has generated a great deal of interest. This stimulation appears to involve specific binding of the toxin to class II molecules and subsequent stimulation of the T cell via the TCR V beta elements. Recent studies from our laboratory have focused on the ability of staphylococcal enterotoxins to directly activate purified lymph node T cells and a panel of T cell clones and hybridomas. A T cell costimulation assay was performed to assess cellular activation requirements and cytokine receptor expression. Activation of highly purified lymph node T cells by staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB) required costimulatory signals which could be provided by IL-1, IL-2, IL-4, or IL-6, whereas SEB alone demonstrated no significant proliferative response. Using a panel of TH1 and TH2 cell clones and T cell hybridomas possessing various responsive and nonresponsive V beta alleles, it was possible to demonstrate that SEA and SEB costimulate T cells via the TCR complex. Additionally, enterotoxin-pretreated T cells demonstrated a significant proliferative response upon exposure to class II-bearing accessory cells, suggesting that these toxins bind directly to T cells. Highly purified T cells cultured with both SEB and IL-1 exhibit significantly increased levels of IL-2 receptor, whereas cells cultured with SEB or IL-1 alone demonstrated low levels of this receptor. These results do not exclude an association of the staphylococcal enterotoxins with class II molecules in a manner which results in a high avidity binding to the TCR required for transduction of the appropriate activation signals. In the absence of class II molecules, however, these superantigens can still bind to T cells, and the activation signal is delivered in the presence of cytokines that trigger T cell growth and lymphokine production.

Identification of a T cell receptor beta chain variable region, V beta 20, that is differentially expressed in various strains of mice

A cDNA library of TCR beta chain transcripts from BALB/c thymocytes was constructed using anchored polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Screening of this library led to the identification of a V beta gene segment, V beta 20, structurally related to V beta 3 and V beta 17. Genomic analysis of mice displaying deletions in their V beta loci, together with mapping of cosmid clones, situated V beta 20 2.5 kb beside V beta 17. The expression of V beta 20 was estimated by PCR in mice of different H-2 and Mls types. Peripheral T cells from H-2k and H-2d mice did not express V beta 20, whereas in I-E-negative mice (C57Bl/6 and SJL), V beta 20 transcripts were detected. The lack of V beta 20 transcripts in (C57Bl/6 x CBA/J)F1, (C57Bl/6 x BALB/c)F1, and in congenic B6.H-2k mice suggests that the differential use of V beta 20 is due to an I-E-mediated clonal deletion process. The involvement of the Mls super antigens was excluded by analysis of all Mls type combinations. The nature of the V beta 20-deleting element(s) is discussed in the context of the I-E/superantigen systems controlling the expression of V beta 11 and V beta 17.

Mechanisms of autoimmunity in the context of T-cell tolerance: insights from natural and transgenic animal model systems

There are a number of mechanisms which cooperate to produce and maintain T-cell tolerance. First, and perhaps most important, is the clonal deletion in the thymus of T cells with high affinity for self antigens. However, to ensure that a wide repertoire of T cells is available in the periphery to combat foreign antigens, the threshold of clonal deletion may be set low enough so that T cells whose TCR's have sub-threshold affinity for self antigens mature and migrate to the periphery. T cells which recognize self antigen-derived peptides not expressed or presented in the thymus will also fail to be deleted. For those self-reactive T cells which are not deleted in the thymus, other mechanisms may produce tolerance, including an undefined alteration of signalling pathways which produces clonal anergy, and lowering the avidity of the TCR for its ligand by downregulating coreceptor and accessory molecules. Active suppression of T-cell responses in another well-described phenomenon whose mechanism is undefined. From our observations with the model systems discussed here, we have observed three distinct mechanisms by which T-cell tolerance can be circumvented, allowing autoimmune phenomena to occur. These mechanisms may have relevance for different types of autoimmune diseases seen in humans. In gld mice, the autoimmune disease seems to be related to a global defect in T-cell differentiation and function, which allows for the expansion of autoimmune B cells. While we showed that clonal deletion of V beta-bearing T cells is appropriate in certain cases, aberrant lymphokine secretion by the abnormal T cells or disruption of immune system regulation are most probably responsible for allowing autoantibody production. While human lupus erythematosis shares much of the pathology of lpr and gld mice, there is no expansion of T cells with a similar phenotype in human lupus. There are environmental factors which must play a role in the development of human lupus, since the incidence of the disease does not follow an absolute genetic pattern. The escape from clonal deletion and subsequent reactivation of autoimmune T cells which we observed in V beta 8.1 TCR-transgenic mice can be a model for human autoimmune diseases such as multiple sclerosis and type I diabetes, in which T cells are directed against a specific autoantigen. According to this model, susceptibility loci for autoimmune disease such as the MHC would function by producing different repertoires of T cells which in some cases could gain autoreactivity following activation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

V beta 17 gene polymorphism in wild-derived mouse strains: two amino acid substitutions in the V beta 17 region greatly alter T cell receptor specificity

Of 41 wild-derived mouse strains analyzed, 14 contained T cells bearing V beta 17 receptors in spite of the concomitant expression of I-E antigens. Reciprocal F1 and F2 hybrids of one of these strains, PWK, with laboratory strains revealed different patterns of V beta 17 T cell deletions from those observed with V beta 17 T cells from SJL, implying that the two V beta 17 regions are associated with recognition of distinct superantigens. The structures of the V beta 17 alleles differ by two amino acid substitutions, which lie together in an area distant from the predicted site of T cell receptor interaction with peptide-MHC complexes but overlapping with that implicated in V beta 8.2 recognition of Mls-1 superantigen. This demonstrates that the self-superantigen leading to V beta 17 T cell deletion varies with the allele of the receptor gene and confirms that T cell deletions by such ligands involve interactions with a region of the V beta domain that is distinct from the conventional combining site.

Characterization of the ligand(s) responsible for negative selection of V beta 11- and V beta 12-expressing T cells: effects of a new Mls determinant

During T cell development, events occur that result in the generation of a T cell population capable of recognizing foreign antigens in association with self major histocompatibility complex (MHC) gene products. However, selective events also occur during thymic education that result in the deletion of T cells expressing alpha/beta T cell receptors with high affinity for self determinants alone, i.e., potentially self-reactive T cells. Both MHC- and non-MHC-encoded self antigens appear to play critical roles in this negative selection of self-reactive T cells. We recently observed that T cells expressing V beta 5, V beta 11, V beta 12, or V beta 16 products are deleted in most strains of H-2k type, but not in congenic H-2b strains. In contrast, the H-2k strain C58/J deleted V beta 5+ and V beta 16+ T cells, but failed to delete T cells expressing V beta 11 or V beta 12. Based upon this observation, in the present study we have analyzed the genetic regulation of the ligands responsible for deletion of V beta 11- and V beta 12-expressing T cells, and have tested the possibility that these ligands can function as strong alloantigens analogous to the known minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mls)- and MHC-encoded antigens. Two major findings have resulted from these studies. First, the ligands recognized by V beta 11+ and V beta 12+ T cells were regulated by both MHC- and multiple non-MHC-encoded genes. Correlation between expression of these two V beta s in backcross animals suggested that shared, though not necessarily identical, ligands mediate deletion of V beta 11- and V beta 12-expressing T cells. Second, the ligand for deletion of V beta 11- and V beta 12-expressing T cells functions as a newly defined Mls alloantigen that stimulates primary proliferative responses in T cell populations from mice that express V beta 11+ and V beta 12+ T cells.

Ontogenic characterization of thymic B lymphocytes. Analysis in different mouse strains

We have characterized a population of murine B lymphocytes present in the thymus (TBL). They are a minor subset (0.2%-1% of total thymocytes), present from perinatal periods onwards and constituted by activated cells with a high proportion of Ig-secreting cells. They represent the first B lymphocytes detected that secrete IgG after birth. Functional analysis reveals that the frequency of lipopolysaccharide-responding cells in TBL is 5- to 10-fold lower than in the spleen. TBL from adult mice did not show any significant difference in their VH repertoire expression when compared to peripheral B lymphocytes. Furthermore, we have been able to isolate a subpopulation of B220+IgM-CD3- thymocytes whose putative B cell precursor potential needs to be directly analyzed. These and other findings support the intrathymic resident characteristics of TBL and suggest new ways of elucidating its physiological role in the complex selective processes occurring inside the thymus.

Cessation of autonomous proliferation of mouse lymphoma EL4 by fusion with a T cell line

Benzanthracene-induced C57BL/6 (H-2b) mouse T-cell lymphoma EL4 (a thymidine kinase-deficient cell line) was fused by using polyethylene glycol with an Mlsa (Mls for minor lymphocyte stimulatory) antigen-dependent T cell line, which was designated G4 and had been derived from a C3H/He mouse (H-2k), and the fused cells were cultured in HAT medium. Although no growing cells appeared in most of these fusions, we consistently obtained growth-arrested H-2Kb-positive cells from the fused cell populations by the panning method. The cells were tetraploid and were able to proliferate in response to Mlsa antigen. Three H-2Kb-positive clones, isolated by limiting dilution from three different fusions, were shown to be EL4 x G4 hybrids, because (1) they had both H-2k and H-2b antigens; (2) each of the clones had one submetacentric chromosome which was a marker chromosome of EL4, and they were tetraploid with modal chromosome numbers of 74, 78, and 79, respectively; (3) they had 4 isozymes of both parental cells. These results indicate that EL4 lymphoma cells cease to proliferate when fused with T cell line G4. The malignant phenotype of lymphoma EL4 is thus suppressed at the level of cell transformation by the introduction of the G4 cell genome.

Intrathymic clonal deletion of V beta 6+ T cells in cyclophosphamide-induced tolerance to H-2-compatible, Mls-disparate antigens

When C3H (H-2k, Mls-1b) mice were primed intravenously with 10(8) viable spleen cells from AKR (H-2k, Mls-1a) and treated intraperitoneally with 200 mg/kg of cyclophosphamide (CP) 2 d later, not only a long-lasting skin allograft tolerance but also a tolerance in mixed lymphocyte reaction to Mls-1a-encoded antigens was established. The cellular mechanisms of CP-induced tolerance were examined by assessing the V beta 6-bearing T cells that are strongly correlated with reactivity to Mls-1a-encoded antigens bound to MHC class II molecules. At the relatively early stage (2 or 5 wk) after the CP treatment, CD4+-V beta 6+ T cells of C3H origin were preferentially eliminated in the lymph nodes of the tolerant mice, whereas CD8+-V beta 6+ T cells remained. On the other hand, neither CD4+CD8- nor CD4-CD8+ thymocytes bearing a high density of V beta 6 was detected in the chimeric thymus. Namely, in the thymus of the tolerant C3H mice, neither mixed chimerism nor the clonal deletion of the V beta 6-bearing T cells was observed on day 14, whereas both of them were observed on day 35. The clonal deletion and mixed chimerism in the thymus were lasting for greater than 10 wk after the CP treatment. Expression of V beta 6 on the peripheral T cells in the tolerant C3H mice gradually reduced in the process of time. These results strongly suggested that the clonal deletion in the thymus was one of the essential mechanisms in the CP-induced tolerance system.

Neonatal thymectomy results in a repertoire enriched in T cells deleted in adult thymus

In B6AF1 mice, T lymphocytes that use the V beta 11-positive (and not V beta 6-positive or V beta 8-positive) segment in their receptor for antigen are greatly reduced in the thymus and peripheral lymphoid tissues, most likely as a result of clonal deletion. The relative number of V beta 11-positive cells in adult lymph nodes was ten times as high in B6AF1 mice thymectomized 1 to 4 days after birth as in normal mice. Moreover, for the first 10 days of life of B6AF1 mice, mature V beta 11-positive T cells were readily detected in the thymus and spleen. Thus neonatal thymectomy results in the maintenance of the receptor repertoire of early postnatal life, and this correlates with the subsequent development of organ-specific autoimmune diseases.