T-cell tolerance in transgenic mice expressing major histocompatibility class I molecules in defined tissues

A blood-borne antigen induces rapid T-B cell contact: a potential mechanism for tolerance induction

Understanding the difference between the development of a productive T-cell response and tolerance is central to discerning how the immune system functions. Intravenous injection of soluble protein is thought to mimic the presentation of self-serum and orally introduced antigens. It is generally toleragenic. The current view is that this outcome reflects the failure of 'immunogenic' dendritic cells to relocate to the T-cell zone of the secondary lymphoid tissues. Here, using a peptide/I-Ek tetramer and antibodies to stain splenic sections, we showed that antigen-specific T cells were activated in the spleen within hours of injection or feeding of protein. The activated T cells were found to be located at the T-B junction, the bridging zone and the B-cell area, interacting directly with B cells. In addition, B cells gain the ability to present antigen. Our results suggest a way for T cells to be stimulated by blood-borne antigen presented by naïve B cells, a potential mechanism of tolerance induction.

B cell-deficient (mu MT) mice have alterations in the cytokine microenvironment of the gut-associated lymphoid tissue (GALT) and a defect in the low dose mechanism of oral tolerance

Peripheral immune tolerance following i.v. administration of Ag has been shown to occur in the absence of B cells. Because different mechanisms have been identified for i.v. vs low dose oral tolerance and B cells are a predominant component of the gut-associated lymphoid tissue (GALT) they may play a role in tolerance induction following oral Ag. To examine the role of B cells in oral tolerance we fed low doses of OVA or myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein to B cell-deficient ( microMT) and wild-type C57BL/6 mice. Results showed that the GALT of naive wild-type and microMT mice was characterized by major differences in the cytokine microenvironment. Feeding low doses of 0.5 mg OVA or 250 microg myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein resulted in up-regulation of IL-4, IL-10, and TGF-beta in the GALT of wild-type but not microMT mice. Upon stimulation of popliteal node cells, in vitro induction of regulatory cytokines TGF-beta and IL-10 was observed in wild-type but not microMT mice. Greater protection against experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis was found in wild-type mice. Oral tolerance in microMT and wild-type mice was found to proceed by different mechanisms. Anergy was observed from 0.5 mg to 250 ng in microMT mice but not in wild-type mice. Increased Ag was detected in the lymph of microMT mice. No cytokine-mediated suppression was found following lower doses from 100 ng to 500 pg in either group. These results demonstrate the importance of the B cell for the induction of cytokine-mediated suppression associated with low doses of Ag.

Regulation of T cell function in mucosal tolerance

Administering antigens through mucosal surfaces leads to the induction of antigen-specific T cell unresponsiveness. This property of the mucosal immune system is now beginning to be exploited in the design of immunotherapeutic strategies aimed at targeting disease-inducing T cell populations. The induction of high dose mucosal tolerance leads to the induction of T cell anergy. Recent studies have suggested that the induction of anergy in vivo may not necessarily be due to a lack of costimulation by APC. Instead, recognition of mucosal antigen leads to transient T cell activation which eventually gives rise to a population of regulatory T cells whose function is to modulate, rather than promote antigen-specific immune responses. These regulatory T cells mediate linked suppression in vivo thus enabling T cell responses directed to a multideterminant protein to be effectively controlled. The manner in which T cell responses to mucosally delivered antigens are regulated are examined herein.

CD4+ T cell activation and tolerance induction in B cell knockout mice

B cell knockout mice microMT/microMT were used to examine the requirement for B cell antigen (Ag) presentation in the establishment of CD4+ T cell tolerance. CD4+T cells from microMT mice injected with exogenous protein Ag in adjuvant responded to in vitro challenge by transcription of cytokine mRNA, cytokine secretion, and proliferation. Peripheral tolerance could be established in microMT mice with a single dose of deaggragated protein. This tolerance was manifested by a loss of T cell proliferation and cytokine production (including both T helper cell type 1 [Th1]- and Th2-related cytokines), indicating that B cells are not required for the induction of peripheral T cell tolerance and suggesting that the dual zone tolerance theory is not applicable to all protein Ags and is not mediated through Ag presentation by B cells.

Proopiomelanocortin production by epidermal cells: evidence for an immune neuroendocrine network in the epidermis

Proopiomelanocortin (POMC) is known to be synthesized in the pituitary gland and is subsequently cleaved by specific prohormone convertases into biologically active peptide hormones such as melanocyte stimulating hormones (MSH), adrenocorticotropin (ACTH) and endorphins (EP). Guanine nucleotide-binding protein (G-protein)-coupled receptors, which have only recently been discovered, are involved in the transmission of their message. There is also evidence indicating that POMC is not only produced by pituitary cells but is an ubiquitous molecule, that is cleaved cell- and tissue-specific. It has also been shown that the epidermis keratinocytes as well as melanocytes express POMC upon stimulation and release alpha MSH and ACTH. In addition to their function as hormones, POMC peptides have been shown to exert a variety of immunoregulatory effects by modulating the function of immunocompetent cells as well as cytokines. These findings provide further evidence for the immunoneuroendocrine network playing a crucial role during the pathogenesis of immune and inflammatory skin disease.

The role of thymic epithelium in the establishment of transplantation tolerance

From experimental observations on induction of transplantation tolerance, we discuss a model that accounts for tissue-specific tolerance to antigens not expressed inside the thymus. It is postulated that antigens presented to differentiating T cells by thymic epithelium (or at large within the thymic environment) positively select and activate self-reactive T cells. A developmental program and/or prevalent conditions in the thymic environment restrict the proliferative potential and the class of effector functions that can be exerted by differentiating T cells activated in the thymus. These do not mediate inflammatory or cytolytic activities, but instead will produce the appropriate mediators to inhibit aggressive effector activities by other T cells activated in their proximity. Such "regulatory" functions will be locally expressed at the periphery upon recognition of tissue antigens shared with the thymus, towards newly formed thymic emigrants directed at tissue-specific antigens expressed by the same "target" cells. This mechanism imposes "dominant tolerance", based on specific self-recognition and predominantly established in the embryonic and neonatal period. Throughout life, the process of thymic positive selection results in all newly-formed T cells being susceptible to such suppressive mechanisms, but becoming increasingly refractory with time in the resting, post-differentiative stage. Absence of antigen (nonself) in the embryonic and neonatal life therefore allows for the accumulation of such "suppression-resistant" antigen-reactive T cells that will mount aggressive responses upon antigenic exposure. Tolerance or immunity thus represent two classes of specific immune responses, the relative predominance of which is determined by the frequency of each type of effector T cell, representing the antigenic overlap between thymic and peripheral tissues, as well as the frequency of tissue-specific T-cell generation, and the kinetics of peripheral antigenic exposure. Tolerance induced by hemopoietic cells to all other tissues is also "dominant" and based on thymic colonization and persistence of antigenic cells, with the consequent positive selection of regulatory T cells and peripheral conditions for the establishment of suppression. Upon this simple model, that ensures "interclonal class regulation" by "bridging" regulatory and effector T cells through the recognition of different antigens on the same target cell, other mechanisms which are based on V-region interactions among T cells (Ben-Nun et al. 1981, Pereira et al. 1989, Webb & Sprent 1990, Gaur et al. 1993) might well operate to ensure "dominant tolerance" by self-reactivity and class regulation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Self-nonself discrimination and tolerance in T and B lymphocytes

The immune system must not only fight off infections, but also ensure that it does not react against its own body tissues. Since clones of lymphocytes have predetermined reactivities, some will be self-reactive and have the potential to cause damage. They should therefore be neutralized in some way. In a system as complex and important as that governing self-tolerance, many mechanisms must exist to neutralize autoaggressive lymphocytes. They may be classified under two main groups. In one the tolerant state arises from the physical or functional silencing of potentially autoaggressive lymphocytes after antigen encounter. This may involve clonal deletion, clonal abortion or clonal anergy. In the second, regulatory mechanisms of the immune system itself may hold autoreactive lymphocytes in check, for example through the operation of idiotypic network interactions and the action of specialized suppressor cells. Much evidence has accumulated for the physical deletion of autoreactive T cells as they mature in the thymus. The fate of any that escape thymus censorship has been the subject of recent research and is discussed here. Under certain conditions, self-tolerance must also be imposed at the B-cell level to prevent the production of potentially damaging autoantibodies. Although the mechanisms which silence self-reactive lymphocytes are very efficient, self-tolerance can break down, and autoimmunity will thus ensue. The main factors responsible for this are briefly described here.

Post-thymic tolerance to self antigens

There is now convincing evidence for the imposition of self-tolerance by means of the clonal deletion of self-reactive T cells operating within the thymus. Since not all self components may be encountered there, the question must be asked whether tolerance can occur post-thymically. To test this, we have used transgenic technology to direct expression of a known 'non-self' gene, H-2Kb, to the insulin producing beta cells of the pancreas of mice. H-2Kb-bearing skin, but not skin from other mouse strains, failed to be rejected by the 'RIP-Kb' transgenic mice indicating specific tolerance. Following in vitro stimulation, their spleen cells could not kill H-2Kb-bearing targets, but could respond to third party targets. Their reactivity to H-2Kb was restored by providing them with IL-2. Two hypotheses could account for the above: tolerance results either from the deletion or functional silencing of high affinity effector cytotoxic cells or of regulatory, IL-2-producing helper T cells. Since it is difficult to distinguish between these, we have produced a second series of transgenic mice with rearranged T cell receptor (TCR) genes encoding an anti-H-2Kb TCR, and obtained 'double transgenic' offspring by mating these mice with RIP-Kb mice. The TCR utilized the V beta 11 segment which can be detected by a monoclonal antibody. Although the double transgenic mice were tolerant of H-2Kb, there was no evidence of deletion of anti-H-2Kb T cells. It seems, therefore, that a non-deletional mechanism operates to induce post-thymic tolerance.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Cellular and molecular mechanisms of B lymphocyte tolerance

A paradox of immunology is that the immune system is distributed so widely in the body, as a large number of cells that discharge most of their effector functions as single cells; but, at the same time, the elements of the system are so very interdependent, not only via specialized cell clusters and microenvironments, but also by mobile feedback loops, cellular and molecular. The end result is that one cannot really understand one element of the system without understanding every other, at least to a degree. Certainly, tolerance cannot be isolated from immune activation, nor B cell from T cell tolerance, rendering the task of the reviewer somewhat thankless. This being said, the last few years have seen wonderful progress in our grasp of B cell tolerance, to which the transgenic revolution has contributed a great deal. The fact that B cell tolerance exists as an important component of self-tolerance has been firmly established, as have the limits of the process in terms of both the survival of low-affinity antiself clonotypes and the question of location and concentration of antigen required for tolerance induction. Two processes have been identified as key alternatives: clonal abortion/maturation arrest/deletion and induction of clonal anergy. The latter requires a less strong Ig receptor crosslinking signal, may be partial, and is reversible. Recognition of these facts has prompted both experimentation and speculation on possible functions of the anergic cell. One unsatisfactory area, which we have not addressed because nothing like a consensus has been reached, is T cell-mediated suppression and its possible effects on tolerant states, including anergy induction in B cells. The phenomenology of suppression is too striking to sweep under the carpet, and suppressor T cell memory in particular (Adelstein et al., 1990) requires much more investigation; however, suppression has not been shown to play a major role in any of the best-studied transgenic models. These can readily be explained on the basis of direct interactions between the B cell target for abortion or anergy and the self antigen in question. The biochemical basis of discrimination between immunity and tolerance has also progressed, but not as fast. This is understandable, as so many signaling pathways have to come together for full immune induction, and as immaturity of the signal transduction pathway plays a profound role that must be studied in normal cells, with all the attendant difficulties of cell separation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Molecular and cellular aspects of immunologic tolerance

This review seeks to explain the most exciting recent data concerning the nature of self/non-self discrimination by the immune system in a manner accessible to a biochemical readership. The nature of recognition in the two great lymphocyte families, B cells and T cells, is described with special emphasis on the nature of the ligands recognized by each. The history of the field of immunologic tolerance is surveyed, as are the key experiments on conventional mice which provided a conceptual framework. This suggested that tolerance was essentially due to 'holes' in the recognition repertoires of both the T and B cell populations so that lymphocytes competent to react to self antigens were not part of the immunologic dictionary. There were essentially two ways to achieve this situation. On the one hand, self antigens might 'catch' developing lymphocytes early in their ontogeny and delete the cell, a process of clonal abortion. On the other hand, self antigens might signal lymphocytes (particularly immature cells) in a negative manner, reducing or abolishing their capacity for later responses, without causing death. This process is referred to as clonal anergy. Evidence for both processes exists. Special emphasis is placed on a wave of experimentation beginning in 1988 which imaginatively uses transgenic mouse technology to study tolerance. Transgenic manipulations can produce mice which synthesize foreign antigens in a constitutive and/or inducible manner, sometimes only in specific locations; mice which possess T or B lymphocytes almost all expressing a given receptor of known specificity; and mice which are an immunologic time bomb in that the antigen is present and so too are lymphocytes all endowed with receptors for that antigen. These experiments have vindicated the possibility of both clonal abortion and clonal anergy in both T and B cell populations, the choice of which phenomenon occurs depending on a number of operational circumstances. For T cell tolerance, clonal abortion occurs if the self antigenic determinant concerned is present within the thymus; if not, clonal anergy is more likely. For B cell tolerance, the strength of the negative signal and therefore the choice between abortion and anergy depends on the molar concentration of the self antigen, the capacity for multivalent presentation to a B cell, and the affinity of the B cell's receptor for the antigen in question. Some B cells with low affinity for self antigens certainly escape censorship and remain capable of secreting low affinity anti-self antibodies, which however do no harm.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

The use of transgenic animals to study the role of growth factors in endocrinology

Transgenesis is identified as being of special interest in the study of growth factors where their multicellular origins and complex interactions make them particularly difficult to characterize using classical experimental approaches developed to investigate hormones originating in specialized cells in discrete glands. Through allowing molecular 'tinkering' in intact animals, transgenesis enables specific growth factors to be 'ablated or replaced' from specific tissues and organs and target cell response and impact of modulatory factors such as binding proteins to be explored in the intact animal. To the endocrinologist, the potential applications of such technology are legend. This chapter provides a brief overview of the technique and provides linkages to the rapidly developing body of literature in establishing transgenesis in growth factor research.

A transgenic approach to the study of peripheral T-cell tolerance

There is now convincing evidence for the imposition of self tolerance by means of the clonal deletion of self-reactive T cells operating within the thymus. Since not all self components may be encountered there, the question must be asked whether tolerance can occur post-thymically. To test this, we and other investigators have used transgenic technology to direct expression of a known "nonself" gene to a given extrathymic tissue. No lymphocytic infiltration was ever seen in transgene-expressing tissues, even if the mice were given normal syngeneic (nontransgenic) spleen cells intravenously or were stimulated with H-2Kb spleen cells. Infiltration did, however, occur in irradiated transgenic recipients of H-2Kb immune spleen cells. In MET-Kb mice, this infiltrate diminished with time, raising the possibility that peripheral tolerance may even have been induced in immune cells. H-2Kb-bearing skin was accepted in young RIP-Kb mice but rejected in older mice, which had lost more than 75% of their beta cells as a result of the overexpression of H-2Kb. This loss of tolerance thus occurred when the concentration of the tolerogen, H-2Kb, fell below some critical threshold. Following in vitro stimulation, spleen cells from young RIP-Kb mice could not kill H-2Kb-bearing targets, but could respond to third party targets. Thymus cells, on the other hand, could be stimulated to kill both targets, clearly indicating that tolerance was not imposed intrathymically. Spleen cells from older RIP-Kb mice (those that had lost most of their beta cells) killed both targets, which is in agreement with the in vivo data. Reactivity to H-2Kb was restored to young spleen cells by providing them with IL-2. Two hypotheses were proposed to account for the above findings: tolerance results either from the deletion or functional silencing of high-affinity effector cells or of regulatory, IL-2-producing helper T cells. As it is difficult to distinguish between these, we have produced a second series of transgenic mice (F3+) with rearranged TCR genes encoding an anti-H-2Kb TCR and derived "double-transgenic" (F3+RIP+) offspring by mating these mice with RIP-Kb mice. The transgenic TCR utilized the V beta 11 segment which can be detected by a monoclonal antibody. There were in the thymus very few CD4+ and very few CD4+8+ cells in both F3+ and F3+RIP+ mice and, in the double-transgenic mice, there was no evidence of deletion of CD8+V beta 11+ cells in the periphery although they showed tolerance to H-2Kb-bearing skin.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Non-deletional mechanisms of peripheral and central tolerance: studies with transgenic mice with tissue-specific expression of a foreign MHC class I antigen

The studies described here reveal a surprising variety of non-deletional manifestations of tolerance (anergy and unresponsiveness) in both the thymus and peripheral lymphoid organs. This can be observed in anti-Kb TCR transgenic mice crossed with normal Kb positive mice, and in TCR mice crossed with transgenic mice expressing Kb in restricted tissues, such as liver, epithelial cells, cells of neuroectodermal origin etc. Thymic induction of unresponsiveness: Transgenic mice were prepared with the a, beta TCR genes from a CD8-dependent and Kb-specific CTL clone. In homozygous H-2b mice clonotype+ cells were found in the thymus but none or few in the periphery, suggesting that deletion occurs in the thymus although lack of migration to the periphery has not been ruled out. In H-2 heterozygous mice (TCR.H-2kxb) deletion was incomplete in the thymus and clonotype+ cells accumulated substantially in the periphery. Most of them had downregulated their CD8 molecules. The clonotype+ cells in both the thymus and periphery were unresponsive to the Kb antigen in vitro, suggesting the induction of anergy in the thymus. The inefficient negative selection in H-hkxb heterozygous mice is probably due to the lower Kb expression in comparison to H-2b homozygous mice. We then further reduced the amount of Kb expression in the thymus by constructing Kb transgenic mice using the 0.8 Kb fragment of the keratin IV promoter. In the thymus expression was only observed on a subset of medullary epithelial cells. When these mice were crossed with the TCR transgenic mice than no deletion was observed in the thymus. However, the clonotype+ CD8+ thymocytes could not respond to Kb in vitro, indicating that they had been rendered anergic in the thymus. These data show that unresponsiveness can be induced in the thymus, that the extent of clonal deletion can vary greatly owing to a change in antigen expression by a factor of two as in H-2 heterozygous versus homozygous mice, and that expression of Kb on a few medullary thymic epithelial cells is sufficient to induce anergy. Peripheral induction of unresponsiveness: To study the consequence of tissue-specific tolerogen expression we have generated transgenic mice expressing Kb exclusively in cells of neuroectodermal origin (GFAP.Kb mice) in the liver (alumin.Kb mice), or in certain epithelial cells outside the thymus (2.4 keratin IV.Kb mice). Consistent with the absence of Kb expression in the thymus there was no deletion of clonotype+ CD8+ cells in the thymus, and the thymocytes were fully functional.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Induction of self-tolerance in T cells but not B cells of transgenic mice expressing little self antigen

Self-tolerance to a transgene-encoded protein, hen egg lysozyme, was examined in the T and B cell repertoires of a series of lines of transgenic mice that expressed different serum concentrations of soluble lysozyme. T cells were tolerant in all lines in which lysozyme was expressed irrespective of the antigen concentration, whereas B cell tolerance did not occur when the serum lysozyme concentration was less than 1.5 nanograms per milliliter (0.1 nM). Induction of elevated transgene expression could restore B cell tolerance. These findings support the hypothesis that autoimmune disease may in some instances arise through a bypass of T cell tolerance.

Transgenic models of T-cell self tolerance and autoimmunity

Self-tolerance is generally induced by intrathymic clonal deletion of T cells with reactivity directed to antigens synthesized within the thymus (Kappler et al. 1987, Kisielow et al. 1988). It may also be induced in peripheral T cells when these encounter antigens unique to extra-thymic tissues. Two transgenic models have been particularly useful in the study of peripheral self tolerance: in one model, a known antigen is expressed in a particular extra-thymic site; in the other, the T-cell repertoire is predominantly reactive to this antigen. We, and others, have shown that expression of class I or II MHC molecules in defined extra-thymic sites leads to a state of T-cell tolerance. To account for this, we have proposed two hypotheses which have different implications for autoimmune disease. According to one, tolerance is imposed by deletion or functional silencing of specific high-affinity cytolytic T cells; alternatively, the target cell for tolerance induction may be a regulatory IL-2-producing T-cell, rather than the effector cell itself. To distinguish between these hypotheses it is essential to examine the fate of T cells which have the potential to react to the transgene product. Since the frequency of such T cells is low and there is no dominant clonotype for H-2Kb, which is the class I molecule we used, it was necessary to create double transgenic mice by mating class I transgenic mice with transgenic mice whose T-cell pool was compared of cells reactive to H-2Kb and could be detected by an antibody directed to the TCR. Initial studies showed that such T cells did persist despite the presence of antigen to which they may be reactive. If these double transgenic mice can be shown to be tolerant, they will offer a rich source of tolerant T cells for detailed investigation of their phenotype and fate, and they will be most useful in enabling us to probe the mechanisms responsible for the induction of peripheral self tolerance. Transgenic mouse technology has also been used successfully to unravel the genetic influences which may lead to or prevent autoimmunity. In particular, we have prevented autoimmune diabetes in the nonobese diabetic mouse by introducing a non-NOD MHC class II gene and further work is implicating the failure of intrathymic positive selection of a protective cell as one step in the pathogenesis of diabetes in NOD mice.

Tolerance in transgenic mice expressing major histocompatibility molecules extrathymically on pancreatic cells

Transgenic mice with defined expression of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) proteins provide novel systems for understanding the fundamental question of T cell tolerance to nonlymphoid self components. The MHC class II I-E and I-A and class I H-2K molecules expressed specifically on pancreatic islet or acinar cells serve as model self antigens. In these systems, transgenic proteins are not detected in the thymus or other lymphoid tissues. Yet mice are tolerant to the pancreatic MHC products in vivo; this tolerance is not induced by clonal deletion. These studies have been aided by monoclonal antibodies specific for I-E-reactive T cells and indicate that clonal anergy may be an important mechanism of tolerance to peripheral proteins.

Clonalism--the myth?

Two regulatory mechanisms, based on the contrasting concepts of imprinting (clonal theories and idiotypic networks) and of ongoing regulation of immune responses (by antigen and end products with specificity for antigen), give rise to different predictions and approaches to the question of autoimmunity and autoimmune disease. Both concepts have legitimacy, however, if a ranking in terms of explicative power must be given, ongoing regulation is more plausible since it accounts more fully for basic events in immune responses and in autoimmune phenomena. Many instructive findings have emerged from experiments based on this latter concept, furthermore, the approach has only received limited notice and, thus, has not yet been exhausted.

The Florey lecture, 1989. Self-tolerance: the key to autoimmunity

'Horor autotoxicus', as it was termed by Erhlich, is a rare clinical event despite the genetic potential of every individual to mount immune responses to self-antigens. This can be explained by the fact that the developing immune system learns to recognize self-antigens and to tolerate them. The key to autoimmunity therefore lies in unravelling the mechanisms of self-tolerance. Studies of conventional models of unresponsiveness have failed to provide a definitive answer owing to the difficulty in controlling for the large number of antigen-related variables associated with self-tolerance and in following the fate of individual clones of self-reactive lymphocytes which emerge in very low numbers from the pre-immune repertoire. These problems have now been overcome by creation of transgenic mice tolerant to endogenous antigens and containing high frequencies of autoreactive T or B lymphocytes. According to the results obtained to date, different mechanisms of tolerance induction operate for self-reactive T lymphocytes compared with B lymphocytes. Thus self-tolerance in T lymphocytes appears to depend largely on clonal deletion within the thymus. By contrast, self-reactive B lymphocytes are functionally silenced without undergoing deletion provided that the transgenic B lymphocytes express both IgM and IgD on their surfaces. This dichotomy makes good sense given that the T-lymphocyte repertoire once shaped within the thymus is not subject to further mutation whereas antigen receptors on mature B lymphocytes undergo hypermutation in the periphery.