Effects of hyperventilation length on muscle sympathetic nerve activity in healthy humans simulating periodic breathing

Background: Periodic breathing (PB) is a cyclical breathing pattern composed of alternating periods of hyperventilation (hyperpnea, HP) and central apnea (CA). Differences in PB phenotypes mainly reside in HP length. Given that respiration modulates muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA), which decreases during HP and increases during CA, the net effects of PB on MSNA may critically depend on HP length.

Objectives: We hypothesized that PB with shorter periods of HP is associated with increased MSNA and decreased heart rate variability.

Methods: 10 healthy participants underwent microelectrode recordings of MSNA from the common peroneal nerve along with non-invasive recording of HRV, blood pressure and respiration. Following a 10-min period of tidal breathing, participants were asked to simulate PB for 3 min following a computed respiratory waveform that emulated two PB patterns, comprising a constant CA of 20 s duration and HP of two different lengths: short (20 s) vs long (40 s). Results: Compared to (3 min of) normal breathing, simulated PB with short HP resulted in a marked increase in mean and maximum MSNA amplitude (from 3.2 ± 0.8 to 3.4 ± 0.8 µV, p = 0.04; from 3.8 ± 0.9 to 4.3 ± 1.1 µV, p = 0.04, respectively). This was paralleled by an increase in LF/HF ratio of heart rate variability (from 0.9 ± 0.5 to 2.0 ± 1.3; p = 0.04). In contrast, MSNA response to simulated PB with long HP did not change as compared to normal breathing. Single CA events consistently resulted in markedly increased MSNA (all p < 0.01) when compared to the preceding HPs, while periods of HP, regardless of duration, decreased MSNA (p < 0.05) when compared to normal breathing.

Conclusion: Overall, the net effects of PB in healthy subjects over time on MSNA are dependent on the relative duration of HP: increased sympathetic outflow is seen during PB with a short but not with a long period of HP.

Interactive effects of apneic and baroreflex stress on neural coding strategies in human muscle sympathetic nerve activity

The sympathetic nervous system exhibits patterns of action potential (AP) discharge in human muscle sympathetic nerve activity that suggest coding strategies express reflex specificity. This study explored the interactive effects of baroreceptor unloading using lower body negative pressure (LBNP) and volitional end-expiratory apnea (APN) on sympathetic postganglionic neuronal discharge patterns inferred from the firing patterns of differently sized sympathetic AP clusters. Seven individuals were studied using multi-unit microneurography (fibular) and a continuous wavelet approach to quantify AP discharge probability, recruitment, and latency during APN performed under ambient conditions, -10 and -40 mmHg LBNP. Compared to the ambient condition, LBNP increased AP discharge rate at -10 and -40 mmHg and recruited larger previously-silent sympathetic neurons at -40 mmHg. Compared to spontaneous breathing, APN increased AP discharge when performed during the ambient condition (∆351±132 AP/min), -10 mmHg (∆423±184 AP/min), and -40 mmHg (∆355±278 AP/min; main effect APN: P<0.01; LBNP-by-APN interaction: P=0.55). APN recruited larger previously-silent AP clusters during the ambient condition (∆4±3; P<0.02) and -10 mmHg (∆4±3; P<0.01), but not -40 mmHg (∆0±2; P=0.53; LBNP-by-APN: P<0.01). LBNP did not affect AP latency. However, APN reduced AP latency similarly during all conditions (ambient pressure: ∆-0.04±0.04s, -10 mmHg: ∆-0.03±0.03s, -40 mmHg: ∆-0.03±0.04s; main effect APN: P<0.01; LBNP-by-APN: P=0.48). These data indicate that apneic and baroreflex mechanisms appear to additively modify the axonal discharge rate of previously active sympathetic postganglionic neurons and interact to affect recruitment of previously-silent sympathetic neurons. Reductions in AP latency due to apneic stress were not impacted by baroreflex unloading.

Influence of sympathetic activation on myocardial contractility measured with ballistocardiography and seismocardiography during sustained end-expiratory apnea

Ballistocardiography (BCG) and seismocardiography (SCG) assess vibrations produced by cardiac contraction and blood flow, respectively, through micro-accelerometers and micro-gyroscopes. BCG and SCG kinetic energies (KE) and their temporal integrals (iK) during a single heartbeat are computed in linear and rotational dimensions. Our aim was to test the hypothesis that iK from BCG and SCG are related to sympathetic activation during maximal voluntary end-expiratory apnea. Multiunit muscle sympathetic nerve traffic [burst frequency (BF), total muscular sympathetic nerve activity (tMSNA)] was measured by microneurography during normal breathing and apnea (n = 28, healthy men). iK of BCG and SCG were simultaneously recorded in the linear and rotational dimension, along with oxygen saturation ([Formula: see text]) and systolic blood pressure (SBP). The mean duration of apneas was 25.4 ± 9.4 s. SBP, BF, and tMSNA increased during the apnea compared with baseline (P = 0.01, P = 0.002,and P = 0.001, respectively), whereas [Formula: see text] decreased (P = 0.02). At the end of the apnea compared with normal breathing, changes in iK computed from BCG were related to changes of tMSNA and BF only in the linear dimension (r = 0.85, P < 0.0001; and r = 0.72, P = 0.002, respectively), whereas changes in linear iK of SCG were related only to changes of tMSNA (r = 0.62, P = 0.01). We conclude that maximal end expiratory apnea increases cardiac kinetic energy computed from BCG and SCG, along with sympathetic activity. The novelty of the present investigation is that linear iK of BCG is directly and more strongly related to the rise in sympathetic activity than the SCG, mainly at the end of a sustained apnea, likely because the BCG is more affected by the sympathetic and hemodynamic effects of breathing cessation. BCG and SCG may prove useful to assess sympathetic nerve changes in patients with sleep disturbances.NEW & NOTEWORTHY Ballistocardiography (BCG) and seismocardiography (SCG) assess vibrations produced by cardiac contraction and blood flow, respectively, through micro-accelerometers and micro-gyroscopes. Kinetic energies (KE) and their temporal integrals (iK) during a single heartbeat are computed from the BCG and SCG waveforms in a linear and a rotational dimension. When compared with normal breathing, during an end-expiratory voluntary apnea, iK increased and was positively related to sympathetic nerve traffic rise assessed by microneurography. Further studies are needed to determine whether BCG and SCG can probe sympathetic nerve changes in patients with sleep disturbances.

Inspiratory muscle strength training lowers blood pressure and sympathetic activity in older adults with OSA: a randomized controlled pilot trial

Previous work has shown lowered casual blood pressure after just 6 wk of inspiratory muscle strength training (IMST), suggesting IMST as a potential therapeutic in the prevention/treatment of hypertension. In this study, we assessed the effects of IMST on cardiovascular parameters in older, overweight adults diagnosed with moderate and severe obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). Subjects were randomly assigned to one of two interventions 1) high-intensity IMST (n = 15, 75% maximal inspiratory pressure), or 2) a control intervention (n = 10, 15% maximum inspiratory pressure). Subjects in both groups trained at home completing 30 training breaths/day, 5 days/wk for 6 wk. Pre- and posttraining measures included maximal inspiratory pressure, casual and ambulatory blood pressures, spontaneous cardiac baroreflex sensitivity, and muscle sympathetic nerve activity. Men and women in the high-intensity IMST group exhibited reductions in casual systolic (SBP), diastolic (DBP), and mean arterial blood pressures (MAP) [SBP: -8.82 ± 4.98 mmHg; DBP: -4.69 ± 2.81 mmHg; and MAP: -6.06 ± 1.03 mmHg; P < 0.002] and nighttime SBP (pre: -12.00 ± 8.20 mmHg; P < 0.01). Muscle sympathetic nerve activities also were lower (-6.97 ± 2.29 bursts/min^-1; P = 0.01 and -9.55 ± 2.42 bursts/100 heartbeats; P = 0.002) by week 6. Conversely, subjects allocated to the control group showed no change in casual blood pressure or muscle sympathetic nerve activity and a trend toward higher overnight blood pressures. A short course of high-intensity IMST may offer significant respiratory and cardiovascular benefits for older, overweight adults with OSA. For Clinical Trial Registration, see https://www.clinicaltrials.gov (Identifier: NCT02709941).NEW & NOTEWORTHY Older, obese adults with moderate-severe obstructive sleep apnea who perform 5 min/day high-intensity inspiratory muscle strength training (IMST) exhibit lowered casual and nighttime systolic blood pressure and sympathetic nervous outflow. In contrast, adults assigned to a control (low-intensity) intervention exhibit no change in casual blood pressure or muscle sympathetic nerve activity and a trend toward increased overnight blood pressure. Remarkably, adherence to IMST even among sleep-deprived and exercise-intolerant adults is high (96%).

Mechanisms of sympathetic regulation during Apnea

Volitional Apnea produces a robust peak sympathetic response through several interacting mechanisms. However, the specific contribution of each mechanism has not been elucidated. Muscle sympathetic activity was collected in participants (n = 10; 24 ± 3 years) that performed four maximal volitional apneas aimed at isolating lung-stretch (mechanical) and chemoreflex drive: (Ainslie and Duffin ) end-expiratory breath-hold, (Ainslie et al. ) end-inspiratory breath-hold, (Alpher et al. ) prehyperventilation breath-hold, and (Andersson and Schagatay ) prehyperoxia breath-hold. A final repeated rebreathe breath-hold protocol was performed to measure the peak sympathetic response during successive breath-holds at increasing chemoreflex stress. Finally, the influence of dynamic ventilation was assessed through asphyxic rebreathe. Muscle sympathetic activity was calculated as the change in burst frequency (burst/min), burst incidence (burst/100 heart-beats), and amplitude (au) between baseline and prevolitional breakpoint. Rebreathe was analyzed at similar chemoreflex stress as inspiratory breath-hold. All maneuvers increased muscle sympathetic activity compared to baseline (P < 0.01). However, prehyperoxia exhibited a smaller increase (+22.18 ± 9.13 burst/min; +25.52 ± 11.7 burst/100 heart-beats) compared to inspiratory, expiratory, and prehyperventilation breath-holds. At similar chemoreflex strain, rebreathe sympathetic activity was blunted compared to inspiratory breath-hold (P < 0.01). Finally, muscle sympathetic activity was not different between the repeated rebreathe trials, despite elevated chemoreflex stress and lower breath-hold duration with each subsequent breath-hold. We have demonstrated an obligatory role of the peripheral, but not central, chemoreflex (prehyperventilation vs. prehyperoxia) in producing peak sympathetic responses. At similar chemoreflex stresses the act of dynamic ventilation, but not static lung stretch per se, blunts muscle sympathetic activity. Finally, similar peak sympathetic responses during successive repeated breath-holds suggest a sympathetic ceiling may exist.

Ventilation inhibits sympathetic action potential recruitment even during severe chemoreflex stress

This study investigated the influence of ventilation on sympathetic action potential (AP) discharge patterns during varying levels of high chemoreflex stress. In seven trained breath-hold divers (age 33 ± 12 yr), we measured muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA) at baseline, during preparatory rebreathing (RBR), and during 1) functional residual capacity apnea (FRC_Apnea) and 2) continued RBR. Data from RBR were analyzed at matched (i.e., to FRC_Apnea) hemoglobin saturation (HbSat) levels (RBR_Matched) or more severe levels (RBR_End). A third protocol compared alternating periods (30 s) of FRC and RBR (FRC-RBR_ALT). Subjects continued each protocol until 85% volitional tolerance. AP patterns in MSNA (i.e., providing the true neural content of each sympathetic burst) were studied using wavelet-based methodology. First, for similar levels of chemoreflex stress (both HbSat: 71 ± 6%; P = NS), RBR_Matched was associated with reduced AP frequency and APs per burst compared with FRC_Apnea (both P < 0.001). When APs were binned according to peak-to-peak amplitude (i.e., into clusters), total AP clusters increased during FRC_Apnea (+10 ± 2; P < 0.001) but not during RBR_Matched (+1 ± 2; P = NS). Second, despite more severe chemoreflex stress during RBR_End (HbSat: 56 ± 13 vs. 71 ± 6%; P < 0.001), RBR_End was associated with a restrained increase in the APs per burst (FRC_Apnea: +18 ± 7; RBR_End: +11 ± 5) and total AP clusters (FRC_Apnea: +10 ± 2; RBR_End: +6 ± 4) (both P < 0.01). During FRC-RBR_ALT, all periods of FRC elicited sympathetic AP recruitment (all P < 0.001), whereas all periods of RBR were associated with complete withdrawal of AP recruitment (all P = NS). Presently, we demonstrate that ventilation per se restrains and/or inhibits sympathetic axonal recruitment during high, and even extreme, chemoreflex stress.NEW & NOTEWORTHY The current study demonstrates that the sympathetic neural recruitment patterns observed during chemoreflex activation induced by rebreathing or apnea are restrained and/or inhibited by the act of ventilation per se, despite similar, or even greater, levels of severe chemoreflex stress. Therefore, ventilation modulates not only the timing of sympathetic bursts but also the within-burst axonal recruitment normally observed during progressive chemoreflex stress.

Respiratory modulation of human autonomic function on Earth

KEY POINTS

We studied healthy supine astronauts on Earth with electrocardiogram, non-invasive arterial pressure, respiratory carbon dioxide concentrations, breathing depth and sympathetic nerve recordings. The null hypotheses were that heart beat interval fluctuations at usual breathing frequencies are baroreflex mediated, that they persist during apnoea, and that autonomic responses to apnoea result from changes of chemoreceptor, baroreceptor or lung stretch receptor inputs. R-R interval fluctuations at usual breathing frequencies are unlikely to be baroreflex mediated, and disappear during apnoea. The subjects' responses to apnoea could not be attributed to changes of central chemoreceptor activity (hypocapnia prevailed); altered arterial baroreceptor input (vagal baroreflex gain declined and muscle sympathetic nerve burst areas, frequencies and probabilities increased, even as arterial pressure climbed to new levels); or altered pulmonary stretch receptor activity (major breathing frequency and tidal volume changes did not alter vagal tone or sympathetic activity). Apnoea responses of healthy subjects may result from changes of central respiratory motoneurone activity.

ABSTRACT

We studied eight healthy, supine astronauts on Earth, who followed a simple protocol: they breathed at fixed or random frequencies, hyperventilated and then stopped breathing, as a means to modulate and expose to view important, but obscure central neurophysiological mechanisms. Our recordings included the electrocardiogram, finger photoplethysmographic arterial pressure, tidal volume, respiratory carbon dioxide concentrations and peroneal nerve muscle sympathetic activity. Arterial pressure, vagal tone and muscle sympathetic outflow were comparable during spontaneous and controlled-frequency breathing. Compared with spontaneous, 0.1 and 0.05 Hz breathing, however, breathing at usual frequencies (∼0.25 Hz) lowered arterial baroreflex gain, and provoked smaller arterial pressure and R-R interval fluctuations, which were separated by intervals that were likely to be too short and variable to be attributed to baroreflex physiology. R-R interval fluctuations at usual breathing frequencies disappear during apnoea, and thus cannot provide evidence for the existence of a central respiratory oscillation. Apnoea sets in motion a continuous and ever changing reorganization of the relations among stimulatory and inhibitory inputs and autonomic outputs, which, in our study, could not be attributed to altered chemoreceptor, baroreceptor, or pulmonary stretch receptor activity. We suggest that responses of healthy subjects to apnoea are driven importantly, and possibly prepotently, by changes of central respiratory motoneurone activity. The companion article extends these observations and asks the question, Might terrestrial responses to our 20 min breathing protocol find expression as long-term neuroplasticity in serial measurements made over 20 days during and following space travel?

Do peripheral and/or central chemoreflexes influence skin blood flow in humans?

Voluntary apnea activates the central and peripheral chemoreceptors, leading to a rise in sympathetic nerve activity and limb vasoconstriction (i.e., brachial blood flow velocity and forearm cutaneous vascular conductance decrease to a similar extent). Whether peripheral and/or central chemoreceptors contribute to the cutaneous vasoconstrictor response remains unknown. We performed three separate experiments in healthy young men to test the following three hypotheses. First, inhibition of peripheral chemoreceptors with brief hyperoxia inhalation (100% O2) would attenuate the cutaneous vasoconstrictor response to voluntary apnea. Second, activation of the peripheral chemoreceptors with 5 min of hypoxia (10% O2, 90% N2) would augment the cutaneous vasoconstrictor response to voluntary apnea. Third, activation of the central chemoreceptors with 5 min of hypercapnia (7% CO2, 30% O2, 63% N2) would have no influence on cutaneous responses to voluntary apnea. Studies were performed in the supine posture with skin temperature maintained at thermoneutral levels. Beat-by-beat blood pressure, heart rate, brachial blood flow velocity, and cutaneous vascular conductance were measured and changes from baseline were compared between treatments. Relative to room air, hyperoxia attenuated the vasoconstrictor response to voluntary apnea in both muscle (-16 ± 10 vs. -40 ± 12%, P = 0.023) and skin (-14 ± 6 vs. -24 ± 5%, P = 0.033). Neither hypoxia nor hypercapnia had significant effects on cutaneous responses to apnea. These data indicate that skin blood flow is controlled by the peripheral chemoreceptors but not the central chemoreceptors.

Cardiovascular responses induced by obstructive apnea are enhanced in hypertensive rats due to enhanced chemoreceptor responsivity

Spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR), like patients with sleep apnea, have hypertension, increased sympathetic activity, and increased chemoreceptor drive. We investigated the role of carotid chemoreceptors in cardiovascular responses induced by obstructive apnea in awake SHR. A tracheal balloon and vascular cannulas were implanted, and a week later, apneas of 15 s each were induced. The effects of apnea were more pronounced in SHR than in control rats (Wistar Kyoto; WKY). Blood pressure increased by 57±3 mmHg during apnea in SHR and by 28±3 mmHg in WKY (p<0.05, n = 14/13). The respiratory effort increased by 53±6 mmHg in SHR and by 34±5 mmHg in WKY. The heart rate fell by 209±19 bpm in SHR and by 155±16 bpm in WKY. The carotid chemoreceptors were then inactivated by the ligation of the carotid body artery, and apneas were induced two days later. The inactivation of chemoreceptors reduced the responses to apnea and abolished the difference between SHR and controls. The apnea-induced hypertension was 11±4 mmHg in SHR and 8±4 mmHg in WKY. The respiratory effort was 15±2 mmHg in SHR and 15±2 mmHg in WKY. The heart rate fell 63±18 bpm in SHR and 52±14 bpm in WKY. Similarly, when the chemoreceptors were unloaded by the administration of 100% oxygen, the responses to apnea were reduced. In conclusion, arterial chemoreceptors contribute to the responses induced by apnea in both strains, but they are more important in SHR and account for the exaggerated responses of this strain to apnea.

Sex differences in forearm vasoconstrictor response to voluntary apnea

Clinical evidence indicates that obstructive sleep apnea is more common and more severe in men compared with women. Sex differences in the vasoconstrictor response to hypoxemia-induced sympathetic activation might contribute to this clinical observation. In the current laboratory study, we determined sex differences in the acute physiological responses to maximal voluntary end-expiratory apnea (MVEEA) during wakefulness in healthy young men and women (26 ± 1 yr) as well as healthy older men and women (64 ± 2 yr). Mean arterial pressure (MAP), heart rate (HR), brachial artery blood flow velocity (BBFV, Doppler ultrasound), and cutaneous vascular conductance (CVC, laser Doppler flowmetry) were measured, and changes in physiological parameters from baseline were compared between groups. The breath-hold duration and oxygen-saturation nadir were similar between groups. In response to MVEEA, young women had significantly less forearm vasoconstriction compared with young men (ΔBBFV: 2 ± 7 vs. -25 ± 6% and ΔCVC: -5 ± 4 vs. -31 ± 4%), whereas ΔMAP (12 ± 2 vs. 16 ± 3 mmHg) and ΔHR (4 ± 2 vs. 6 ± 3 bpm) were comparable between groups. The attenuated forearm vasoconstriction in young women was not observed in postmenopausal women (ΔBBFV -21 ± 5%). We concluded that young women have blunted forearm vasoconstriction in response to MVEEA compared with young men, and this effect is not evident in older postmenopausal women. These data suggest that female sex hormones dampen neurogenic vasoconstriction in response to apnea-induced hypoxemia.