Simian virus 40 DNA replication: characterization of gaps in the termination region

A Decade of Discovery-Eukaryotic Replisome Disassembly at Replication Termination

The eukaryotic replicative helicase (CMG complex) is assembled during DNA replication initiation in a highly regulated manner, which is described in depth by other manuscripts in this Issue. During DNA replication, the replicative helicase moves through the chromatin, unwinding DNA and facilitating nascent DNA synthesis by polymerases. Once the duplication of a replicon is complete, the CMG helicase and the remaining components of the replisome need to be removed from the chromatin. Research carried out over the last ten years has produced a breakthrough in our understanding, revealing that replication termination, and more specifically replisome disassembly, is indeed a highly regulated process. This review brings together our current understanding of these processes and highlights elements of the mechanism that are conserved or have undergone divergence throughout evolution. Finally, we discuss events beyond the classic termination of DNA replication in S-phase and go over the known mechanisms of replicative helicase removal from chromatin in these particular situations.

Roles for DNA polymerase δ in initiating and terminating leading strand DNA replication

Most current evidence indicates that DNA polymerases ε and δ, respectively, perform the bulk of leading and lagging strand replication of the eukaryotic nuclear genome. Given that ribonucleotide and mismatch incorporation rates by these replicases influence somatic and germline patterns of variation, it is important to understand the details and exceptions to this overall division of labor. Using an improved method to map where these replicases incorporate ribonucleotides during replication, here we present evidence that DNA polymerase δ universally participates in initiating leading strand synthesis and that nascent leading strand synthesis switches from Pol ε to Pol δ during replication termination. Ribonucleotide maps from both the budding and fission yeast reveal conservation of these processes. These observations of replisome dynamics provide important insight into the mechanisms of eukaryotic replication and genome maintenance.

Mechanisms of DNA replication termination

Genome duplication is carried out by pairs of replication forks that assemble at origins of replication and then move in opposite directions. DNA replication ends when converging replication forks meet. During this process, which is known as replication termination, DNA synthesis is completed, the replication machinery is disassembled and daughter molecules are resolved. In this Review, we outline the steps that are likely to be common to replication termination in most organisms, namely, fork convergence, synthesis completion, replisome disassembly and decatenation. We briefly review the mechanism of termination in the bacterium Escherichia coli and in simian virus 40 (SV40) and also focus on recent advances in eukaryotic replication termination. In particular, we discuss the recently discovered E3 ubiquitin ligases that control replisome disassembly in yeast and higher eukaryotes, and how their activity is regulated to avoid genome instability.

The mechanism of DNA replication termination in vertebrates

Eukaryotic DNA replication terminates when replisomes from adjacent replication origins converge. Termination involves local completion of DNA synthesis, decatenation of daughter molecules, and replisome disassembly. Termination has been difficult to study because termination events are generally asynchronous and sequence non-specific. To overcome these challenges, we paused converging replisomes with a site-specific barrier in Xenopus egg extracts. Upon removal of the barrier, forks underwent synchronous and site-specific termination, allowing mechanistic dissection of this process. We show that DNA synthesis does not slow detectably as forks approach each other and that leading strands pass each other unhindered before undergoing ligation to downstream lagging strands. Dissociation of CMG helicases occurs only after the final ligation step, and is not required for completion of DNA synthesis, strongly suggesting that converging CMGs pass one another and dissociate from double-stranded DNA. This termination mechanism allows rapid completion of DNA synthesis while avoiding premature replisome disassembly

Structural state of newly replicated closed circular simian virus 40 DNA

We have studied the early transition of newly replicated, segregated daughter molecules of simian virus 40 (SV40) into their mature, fully supercoiled state. The DNA of SV40 replicating in African green monkey kidney CV1 cells was chronically labeled with [14C]thymidine and pulse-labeled with [3H]thymidine. The cells were lysed and the viral DNA was isolated. Density gradient centrifugation of viral DNA in cesium chloride revealed that the pulse-labeled, newly synthesized, closed circular supercoiled DNA molecules banded at a slightly higher density (delta sigma = 0.0025) than the chronically labeled DNA, suggesting that the newly completed molecules were in a different structural state. Electrophoresis of DNA in agarose gels at appropriate chloroquine concentrations demonstrated that the mobility of the pulse-labeled closed, superhelical DNA was retarded relative to that of the chronically labeled DNA. These observations indicated that the newly completed SV40 DNA molecules existed in a structural state more relaxed than that of mature DNA by one or two linking numbers.

Structure of replicating simian virus 40 minichromosomes. The replication fork, core histone segregation and terminal structures

The structure of replicating simian virus 40 (SV40) minichromosomes was studied by DNA crosslinking with trimethyl-psoralen. The procedure was used both in vitro with extracted SV40 minichromosomes as well as in vivo with SV40-infected cells. Both procedures gave essentially the same results. Mature SV40 minichromosomes are estimated to contain about 27 nucleosomes (error +/- 2), except for those molecules with a nucleosome-free gap, which are interpreted to contain 25 nucleosomes (error +/- 2). In replicative intermediates, nucleosomes are present in the unreplicated parental stem with the replication fork possibly penetrating into the nucleosomal DNA before the histone octamer is removed. Nucleosomes reassociate on the newly replicated DNA branches at distances from the branch point of 225 ( +/- 145) nucleotides on the leading strand and of 285( +/- 120) nucleotides on the lagging strand. In the presence of cycloheximide, daughter duplexes contained unequal numbers of nucleosomes, supporting dispersive and random segregation of parental nucleosomes. These were arranged in clusters with normal nucleosome spacing. We detected a novel type of interlocked dimer comprising two fully replicated molecules connected by a single-stranded DNA bridge. We cannot decide whether these dimers represent hemicatenanes or whether the two circles are joined by a Holliday-type structure. The joining site maps within the replication terminus. We propose that these dimers represent molecules engaged in strand segregation.

Replicative intermediates in UV-irradiated simian virus 40

We have used Simian virus 40 (SV40) as a probe to study the replication of UV-damaged DNA in mammalian cells. Viral DNA replication in infected monkey kidney cells was synchronized by incubating a mutant of SV40 (tsA58) temperature-sensitive for the initiation of DNA synthesis at the restrictive temperature and then adding aphidicolin to temporarily inhibit DNA synthesis at the permissive temperature while permitting pre-replicative events to occur. After removal of the drug, the infected cells were irradiated at 100 J/m2 (254 nm) to produce 6-7 pyrimidine dimers per SV40 genome, and returned to the restrictive temperature to prevent reinitiation of replication from the SV40 origin. Replicative intermediates (RI) were labeled with [3H]thymidine, and isolated by centrifugation in CsCl/ethidium bromide gradients followed by BND-cellulose chromatography. The size distribution of daughter DNA strands in RI isolated shortly after irradiation was skewed towards lengths less than the interdimer spacing in parental DNA; this bias persisted for at least 1 h after irradiation, but disappeared within 3 h, by which time the size of the newly-synthesized DNA exceeded the interdimer distance. No significant excision of dimers from parental strands in either replicative intermediates or Form I (closed circular) DNA molecules was detected. These data are consistent with the hypothesis that replication forks are temporarily blocked by dimers encountered on the leading strand side of the fork, but that daughter strand continuity opposite dimers is eventually established. Evidence was obtained for the generation at late times after irradiation, of Form I molecules in which the daughter DNA strands contain dimers. Thus DNA strand exchange as well as trans-dimer synthesis may be involved in the generation of supercoiled Form I DNA from UV-damaged SV40 replicative intermediates.

Analysis of simian virus 40 chromosome-T-antigen complexes: T-antigen is preferentially associated with early replicating DNA intermediates

The fraction and DNA composition of simian virus 40 chromosomes that were complexed with large T-antigens (T-Ag) were determined at the peak of viral DNA replication. Simian virus 40 chromatin containing radiolabeled DNA was extracted by the hypotonic method of Su and DePamphilis (Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 73:3466-3470, 1976) and then fractionated by sucrose gradient sedimentation into replicating (90S) and mature (70S) chromosomes. Viral chromosomes containing T-Ag were isolated by immunoprecipitation with saturating amounts of either an anti-T-Ag monoclonal antibody or an anti-T-Ag hamster serum under conditions that specifically precipitated T-Ag protein from cytosol extracts. An average of 10% of the uniformly labeled DNA in the 90S pool and 7.5% in the 70S pool was specifically precipitated, demonstrating that under these conditions immunologically reactive T-Ag was tightly bound to only 8% of the total viral chromosomes. In contrast, simian virus 40 replicating intermediates (RI) represented only 1.2% of the viral DNA, but most of these molecules were associated with T-Ag. At the shortest pulse-labeling periods, an average of 72 +/- 18% of the radiolabeled DNA in 90S chromosomes could be immunoprecipitated, and this value rapidly decreased as the labeling period was increased. Electron microscopic analysis of the DNA before and after precipitation revealed that about 55% of the 90S chromosomal RI and 72% of the total RI from both pools were specifically bound to T-Ag. Comparison of the extent of replication with the fraction of RI precipitated revealed a strong selection for early replicating DNA intermediates. Essentially all of the RI in the 70S chromosomes were less than 30% replicated and were precipitated with anti-T-Ag monoclonal antibody or hamster antiserum. An average of 88% of the 90S chromosomal RI which were from 5 to 75% replicated were immunoprecipitated, but the proportion of RI associated with T-Ag rapidly decreased as replication proceeded beyond 70% completion. By the time sibling chromosomes had separated, only 3% of the newly replicated catenated dimers in the 90S pool (<1% of the dimers in both pools) were associated with T-Ag. Measurements of the fraction of radiolabeled DNA in each quarter of the genome confirmed that T-Ag was preferentially associated with newly initiated molecules in which the nascent DNA was nearest the origin of replication. These results are consistent with a specific requirement for the binding of T-Ag to viral chromosomes to initiate DNA replication, and they also demonstrate that T-Ag does not immediately dissociate from chromosomes once replication begins. The biphasic relationship between the fraction of T-Ag-containing RI and the extent of DNA replication suggests either that 1 or 2 molecules of T-Ag remain stably bound until replication is about 70% completed or that 4 to 6 molecules of T-Ag are randomly released from each RI at a uniform rate throughout replication.

Distribution of replicating simian virus 40 DNA in intact cells and its maturation in isolated nuclei

The maturation of replicating simian virus 40 (SV40) chromosomes into superhelical viral DNA monomers [SV40(I) DNA] was analyzed in both intact cells and isolated nuclei to investigate further the role of soluble cytosol factors in subcellular systems. Replicating intermediates [SV40(RI) DNA] were purified to avoid contamination by molecules broken at their replication forks, and the distribution of SV40(RI) DNA as a function of its extent of replication was analyzed by gel electrophoresis and electron microscopy. With virus-infected CV-1 cells, SV40(RI) DNA accumulated only when replication was 85 to 95% completed. These molecules [SV40(RI(*)) DNA] were two to three times more prevalent than an equivalent sample of early replicating DNA, consistent with a rate-limiting step in the separation of sibling chromosomes. Nuclei isolated from infected cells permitted normal maturation of SV40(RI) DNA into SV40(I) DNA when the preparation was supplemented with cytosol. However, in the absence of cytosol, the extent of DNA synthesis was diminished three- to fivefold (regardless of the addition of ribonucleotide triphosphates), with little change in the rate of synthesis during the first minute; also, the joining of Okazaki fragments to long nascent DNA was inhibited, and SV40(I) DNA was not formed. The fraction of short-nascent DNA chains that may have resulted from dUTP incorporation was insignificant in nuclei with or without cytosol. Pulse-chase experiments revealed that joining, but not initiation, of Okazaki fragments required cytosol. Cessation of DNA synthesis in nuclei without cytosol could be explained by an increased probability for cleavage of replication forks. These broken molecules masqueraded during gel electrophoresis of replicating DNA as a peak of 80% completed SV40(RI) DNA. Failure to convert SV40(RI(*)) DNA into SV40(I) DNA under these conditions could be explained by the requirement for cytosol to complete the gap-filling step in Okazaki fragment metabolism: circular monomers with their nascent DNA strands interrupted in the termination region [SV40(II(*)) DNA] accumulated with unjoined Okazaki fragments. Thus, separation of sibling chromosomes still occurred, but gaps remained in the terminal portions of their daughter DNA strands. These and other data support a central role for SV40(RI(*)) and SV40(II(*)) DNAs in the completion of viral DNA replication.

Arrest of chain growth of replicon-sized intermediates by aphidicolin during rat fibroblast cell chromosome replication

The effect of aphidicolin, a specific inhibitor of DNA polymerase alpha, on size maturation of nascent DNA intermediates was studied in cultured rat fibroblast cells. Results provided the first evidence of DNA synthesis associated with merging of intermediates of larger than replicon size. Aphidicolin at a concentration (1.4 micrograms/ml) causing 90-95% inhibition of [3H]thymidine incorporation, resulted in accumulation of intermediates of nearly the same size as the replicon (2-5 x 10(-7) Da); although the synthesis of short nascent fragments (referred to as Okazaki fragments) continued in the presence of aphidicolin, the rate of their elongation to the replicon size was greatly decreased. On removal of aphidicolin, these accumulated intermediates merged into high-molecular-weight DNA. This merging of the intermediates was associated with DNA synthesis in gaps between adjacent intermediates, as revealed by photolysis of bromodeoxyuridine-DNA leader with long-wave ultraviolet light; when the cells had been pulse-labeled for 5 min with bromodeoxyuridine immediately after removal of the drug, the large DNA arising from aphidicolin-arrested intermediates was cut into fragments of the original size by long-wave ultraviolet light irradiation. The arrest of chain elongation at the replicon-size by aphidicolin might be due to inhibition of this DNA synthesis in gaps, because aphidicolin did not cause degradation of nascent DNAs.

Nascent replicons are synchronously joined at the end of S phase or during G2 phase in peas

In synchronized meristematic cells of Pisum sativum replicon-size DNA-fragments ((14--27) . 10(6) daltons) are not joined until the cells achieve a 4C DNA content. The combined use of a pulse-chase labeling protocol, single-cell autoradiography, cytophotometry, and velocity sedimentation in alkaline sucrose gradients showed that, unlike low molecular weight DNA (i.e., Okazaki fragments) which is ligated soon after replication starts, the joining of nascent replicon-size DNA is delayed until G2. In addition, this observation argues for the existence of replicon termini, although the data are insufficient to determine the true nature of these termini, i.e., whether they are coded in the DNA itself or simply arise as a consequence of the convergence of two replicating forks.

Preferred DNA sites are involved in the arrest and initiation of DNA synthesis during replication of SV40 DNA

Previous analysis of simian virus 40 (SV40) DNA replication revealed a 2-4 fold excess of DNA molecules that were 90 +/- 2% replicated, demonstrating that replication forks accumulate near the termination site. To determine whether replication is arrested at specific DNA sites, forks were located on the SV40 genome by specifically 32P labelling 3' ends of nascent DNA on purified replicating SV40 DNA, isolating the longest 32P-DNA chains, annealing them to SV40 DNA and then digesting them with a restriction endonuclease that cut near the terminatin site. 32P-DNA fragments of several discrete lengths were released, demonstrating that replication forks on native chromosomes were arrested at preferred sites on the DNA. Most forks were arrested when bidirectional DNA replication was 91% completed, and the two forks were separated by about 470 bp of unreplicated DNA centered at the expected termination site. Forks were also arrested at other locations such that the center of the termination region defined by DNA arrest sites varied by +/- 450 bp. Electron microscopic analysis of replicating DNA suggested that such variation may result from asynchronous arrival of some replication forks. Analysis of 5' end-labeled nascent DNA demonstrated that initiation of Okazaki fragments was also promoted at preferred DNA sites (about 100-120 per genome). Thus specific DNA sequences appear to be utilized throughout DNA replication, not just at the origin.

Terminal stages of SV40 DNA replication proceed via multiply intertwined catenated dimers

We have identified a new class of SV40 replicative intermediates which consists of a least 20 discrete DNA species. All members of this class are catenated dimers, two circular molecules of SV40 duplex DNA linked topologically by one or more intertwining events. Most of these molecules are linked by several intertwining events, and the range of linkage states observed runs from L = 1 to L = 10. A catenated dimer with a given linkage state is assigned to one of three distinct families (A, B or C) depending on the open or covalently closed nature of its two circular components: in form A catenated dimers, both circles are nicked or gapped; in form B, one of the circles is supercoiled; and in form C, both circles are supercoiled. Members of all three of these families are found in SV40 chromatin pulse-labeled with 3H-thymidine, and together they comprise 10-20% of the total replicative form SV40 DNA, appearing as a discrete series of electrophoretically resolved bands superimposed upon a continuous smear of growing cairns structures. The distribution of linkage states varies between the families, A being the most intertwined and C the least intertwined. Upon a chase with cold thymidine, label is lost rapidly from all these catenated DNA species. We suggest that the sequence A leads to B leads to C leads to mature monomeric supercoiled SV40 DNA represents the final stages of SV40 replication, and that a special enzyme activity exists in vivo to uncatenate the SV40 daughter chromosomes.

Maturation of replicating simian virus 40 DNA molecules in isolated nuclei by continued bidirectional replication to the normal termination region

Mature SV40 DNA synthesized for different periods of time either in isolated nuclei or in intact cells was highly purified and then digested with restriction endonucleases in order to relate the time of synthesis of newly replicated viral DNA to its location in the genome. Replication in nuclei supplemented with a cytosol fraction from uninfected cells was a faithful continuation of the bidirectional process observed in intact cells, but did not exhibit significant initiation of new replicons. SV40 DNA replication in cells at 37 degrees C proceeded at about 145 nucleotides/min per replication fork. In the absence of cytosol, when DNA synthesis was limited and joining of Okazaki fragments was retarded, bidirectional SV40 DNA replication continued into the normal region where separation yeilded circular duplex DNA molecules containing one or more interruptions in the nascent DNA strands. In the presence of cytosol, this type of viral DNA was shown to be a precursor of covalently closed, superhelical SV40 DNA, the mature from of viral DNA.

Late replicative intermediates are accumulated during simian virus 40 DNA replication in vivo and in vitro

Simian virus 40 (SV40) replicating chromosomes were extracted from nuclei of infected cells. The chromosomes in the extract were resolved on neutral sucrose gradients, and the extent of replication of the DNA in the chromosome peaks was determined. The extract, in combination with cytosol factors and the appropriate precursors, supports the continued replication of viral DNA. The products of the incubation were mature form I DNA and molecules (after deproteinization) with sedimentation coefficients, in neutral sucrose, of 22S and 29S. The results of our analysis of this system indicate the following. (i) The 22S molecule, which has been described by previous workers, is a relaxed, replicating molecule and is an artifact of the in vitro system. (ii) When the in vitro synthesis is performed at optimal ionic strength (150 mM potassium acetate), the artifactual 22S molecule does not appear. (iii) Late replicative intermediates do accumulate in vivo and in vitro. The major late form accumulated is 91% completed. (iv) The replicating chromosomes can be resolved into two distinct peaks on neutral sucrose gradients. The molecules in these peaks differ in extent of replication. (v) The nuclear extraction procedure preferentially extracts early replicating chromosomes. The relevance of these data to the problem of SV40 and cellular chromosome replication and termination is described.

Simian virus 40 DNA replication in isolated replicating viral chromosomes

Three subnuclear systems capable of continuing many aspects of simian virus 40 (SV40) DNA replication were characterized in an effort to define the minimum requirements for "normal" DNA replication in vitro. Nuclear extracts, prepared by incubating nuclei isolated from SV40-infected CV-1 cells in a hypotonic buffer to release both SV40 replicating and mature chromosomes, were either centrifuged to separate the total SV40 nucleoprotein complexes from the soluble nucleosol or fractionated on sucrose gradients to provide purified SV40 replicating chromosomes. With nuclear extracts, CV-1 cell cytosol stimulated total DNA synthesis, elongation of nascent DNA chains, maturation and joining of "Okazaki pieces," and the conversion of replicating viral DNA into covalently closed, superhelical DNA. Nucleoprotein complexes responded similarly, but frequently the response was reduced by 10 to 30%. In contrast, isolated replicating chromosomes in the presence of cytosol appeared only to complete and join Okazaki pieces already present on the template; without cytosol, Okazaki pieces incorporated alpha-(32)P-labeled deoxynucleoside triphosphates but failed to join. Consequently, replicating chromosomes failed to extensively continue nascent DNA chain growth, and the conversion of viral replicating DNA into mature DNA was seven to eight times less than that observed in nuclear extracts. Addition of neither cytosol nor nucleosol corrected this problem. In the presence of cytosol, nonspecific endonuclease activity was not a problem in any of the three in vitro systems. Extensive purification of replicating chromosomes was limited by three as yet irreversible phenomena. First, replicating chromosomes isolated in a low-ionic-strength medium had a limited capability to continue DNA synthesis. Second, diluting either nuclear extracts or replicating chromosomes before incubation in vitro stimulated total DNA synthesis but was accompanied by the simultaneous appearance of small-molecular-weight nascent DNA not associated with intact viral DNA templates and a decrease in the synthesis of covalently closed viral DNA. Although this second phenomenon appeared similar to the first, template concentration alone could not account for the failure of purified replicating chromosomes to yield covalently closed DNA. Finally, preparation of nucleoprotein complexes in increasing concentrations of NaCl progressively decreased their ability to continue DNA replication. Exposure to 0.3 M NaCl removed one or more factors required for DNA synthesis which could be replaced by addition of cytosol. However, higher NaCl concentrations yielded nucleoprotein complexes that had relatively no endogenous DNA synthesis activity and that no longer responded to cytosol. These data demonstrate that continuation of endogenous DNA replication in vitro requires both the soluble cytosol fraction and a complex nucleoprotein template whose ability to continue DNA synthesis depends on its concentration and ionic environment during its preparation.

The relationship of SV40 replicating chromosomes to two forms of the non-replicating SV40

SV40 replicating chromosomes were extracted from infected cells using a detergent free extraction method. This procedure also extracts 2 forms of the non-replicating chromosome, one of which corresponds to the well characterized 50-55S SV40 minichromosome. The other is a more compact structure which has a sedimentation coefficient of 80-85S. The replicating chromosomes sediment between the 2 conformations of the mature chromosome. Electron microscopy of the replicating chromosomes suggests an overall conformation that resembles the 50-55S form of the mature chromosome rather than that of the 80-85S structure. Nucleosomes are present on both sides of the replication forks. When the replicating chromosomes were incubated in an in vitro DNA synthesis assay all regions of the SV40 genome were synthesized and a significant fraction of the replicating chromosomes completed replication. The progeny chromosomes co-sedimented with the 50-55S chromosomes which were present prior to the incubation. The sedimentation coefficients and relative amounts of the two forms of the mature chromosome were unaffected by the incubation.

Initiation and termination mutants of Bacillus subtilis bacteriophage SPO1

Mutants affected in cistrons 21 and 32 of bacteriophage SPO1 are defective specifically in the initiation of DNA replication. Mutations in cistron 32 also specifically affect the termination of replication.

Simian virus 40 DNA replication in nuclear monolayers

Simian virus 40 DNA replication has been studied in nuclear monolayers prepared by treatment of monolayers of BSC-1 monkey kidney cells with Nonidet P-40. These nuclear monolayers incorporated [3H]TTP into two types of viral replicative intermediates that sediment as 25-26S and 22-23S species, respectively, in neutral sucrose gradients. The 22-23S species behaves, in dye buoyant density equilibrium gradients, as a late replicative intermediate. Examination of both species in alkaline sucrose gradients revealed the presence of two types of newly synthesized strands: (i) 4-7S strands and (ii) full-length, or nearly full-length, 10-16S strands. At low TTP concentrations (less than 0.5 muM), the two size classes were found in approximately equal amounts. However, at 10 to 50 muM TTP, the proportion of the longer strands increased, with a corresponding decrease in the relative amount of the 4-7S species. Thus, the joining of small, Okazaki-like fragments to the growing chain appears to require a much higher concentration of TTP than the synthesis of the fragments themselves. Replicating simian virus 40 DNA synthesized in the nuclear monolayers is is associated with "M bands", as previously demonstrated for replicating simian virus 40 DNA in cultured whole cells.