Frameshift mutations in the v-src gene of avian sarcoma virus act in cis to specifically reduce v-src mRNA levels

Organizing principles of mammalian nonsense-mediated mRNA decay

Cells use messenger RNAs (mRNAs) to ensure the accurate dissemination of genetic information encoded by DNA. Given that mRNAs largely direct the synthesis of a critical effector of cellular phenotype, i.e., proteins, tight regulation of both the quality and quantity of mRNA is a prerequisite for effective cellular homeostasis. Here, we review nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD), which is the best-characterized posttranscriptional quality control mechanism that cells have evolved in their cytoplasm to ensure transcriptome fidelity. We use protein quality control as a conceptual framework to organize what is known about NMD, highlighting overarching similarities between these two polymer quality control pathways, where the protein quality control and NMD pathways intersect, and how protein quality control can suggest new avenues for research into mRNA quality control.

Structural features in the Rous sarcoma virus RNA stability element are necessary for sensing the correct termination codon

Background

Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) is an mRNA quality control mechanism that selectively recognizes and targets for degradation mRNAs containing premature termination codons. Retroviral full-length RNA is presented to the host translation machinery with characteristics rarely observed among host cell mRNAs: a long 3' UTR, retained introns, and multiple open reading frames. As a result, the viral RNA is predicted to be recognized by the host NMD machinery and degraded. In the case of the Rous sarcoma virus (RSV), we identified a stability element (RSE), which resides immediately downstream of the gag termination codon and facilitates NMD evasion.

Results

We defined key RNA features of the RSE through directed mutagenesis of the virus. These data suggest that the minimal RSE is 155 nucleotides (nts) and functions independently of the nucleotide sequence of the stop codon or the first nucleotide following the stop codon. Further data suggested that the 3'UTRs of the RSV pol and src may also function as stability elements.

Conclusions

We propose that these stability elements in RSV may be acting as NMD insulators to mask the preceding stop codon from the NMD machinery.

RNAi and RNA-based regulation of immune system function

Gene regulation by short RNAs is a ubiquitous and important mode of control. MicroRNAs are short, single-strand RNAs that bind with partial complementarity to the 3' untranslated region of several genes to silence their expression. This expanding class of endogenous short RNAs are evolutionarily conserved and participate in control of development and cell-specific gene function. Several of these microRNAs have been cloned uniquely from mammalian lymphocytes suggesting specialized roles in lymphocyte development and function. In addition, several genes linked to RNAi in lower eukaryotes have mammalian homologs with specialized roles in adaptive immunity. For example, in worms, the nonsense-mediated decay (NMD) and RNAi pathways appear to be intricately linked. NMD plays a key role in regulating antigen-receptor expression in lymphocytes and there are mammalian homologs for factors identified in worms that appear to be common in both RNAi and NMD pathways. On the other hand, RNA editing and RNAi have an inverse relationship and RNA editing has an important role in viral immunity. These observations indicate unique roles for dsRNAs in the mammalian immune system.

Premature termination codons do not affect the rate of splicing of neighboring introns

Introduction of a premature termination codon (PTC) into an exon of a gene can lead to nonsense-mediated decay of the mRNA, which is best characterized as a cytoplasmic event. However, increasing evidence has suggested that PTCs may also influence the nuclear processing of an RNA transcript, leading to models of nuclear surveillance perhaps involving translating nuclear ribosomes. We used quantitative RT-PCR to measure the in vivo steady-state levels of every exon-intron junction in wild-type, PTC-containing, and missense-containing precursor mRNAs of both the nonrearranging dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) and the somatically rearranging Ig- micro genes. We find that each exon-intron junction's abundance and, therefore, the rate of intron removal, is not significantly affected by the presence of a PTC in a neighboring exon in either the DHFR or Ig- micro pre-mRNA. Similarly, the abundance of the uncleaved Ig- micro polyadenylation sites does not differ between wild-type and PTC-containing Ig- micro pre-mRNAs. Our Ig- micro data were confirmed by RNase protection analyses, and multiple cell isolates were examined to resolve differences with previously published data on steady-state pre-mRNA levels. We conclude that the presence of a PTC affects the rate of neither splicing nor the cleavage step of 3' end formation during pre-mRNA processing in the nucleus. Our results are discussed with respect to existing evidence for nuclear surveillance mechanisms.

Functional analysis of three genetic polymorphisms in the glucocorticoid receptor gene

Glucocorticoids are widely used as potent anti-inflammatory drugs. Glucocorticoids exert their pharmacological effects by binding to a glucocorticoid receptor (GR), which promotes expression of its target genes or suppresses transcription mediated by other transcriptional factors, such as nuclear factor-kappaB (NF-kappaB). To identify genetic polymorphisms affecting glucocorticoid responses, the GR gene was sequenced, and two novel single nucleotide alterations, 1510A>T (T504S) and 1952C>T (S651F), were identified in addition to an adenine base insertion at nucleotide 2314 (2314insA). mRNA expression levels of T504S and S651F were comparable with that of the wild type (WT), whereas the mRNA level of 2314insA was reduced to approximately 36% of the WT level. Protein expression was reduced to approximately 66% of WT levels in S651F and to approximately 6% in 2314insA. No significant change was seen in the T504S variant levels. The instability of the 2314insA mRNA, S651F protein, and 2314insA protein was confirmed by time course experiments. The transcriptional activity of S651F and 2314insA was also reduced to approximately 63 and 2% of the WT levels, respectively, in the luciferase reporter assay. Moreover, the inhibitory effect of GR on NF-kappaB transactivation was reduced to approximately 81 and 12% of the WT levels for S651F and 2314insA, respectively. These results indicated that the overall transcriptional activity and inhibitory effect on NF-kappaB transactivation of S651F and 2314insA have partially reduced and almost abrogated, respectively, almost paralleling their reduced protein expression levels caused by mRNA and/or protein instabilities. Thus, these two variations were suggested to influence the response to glucocorticoid treatment.

Precursor RNAs harboring nonsense codons accumulate near the site of transcription

Messenger RNAs containing premature termination codons (PTCs) are selectively eliminated by nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD). Paradoxically, although cytoplasmic ribosomes are the only known species capable of PTC recognition, in mammals many PTC-containing mRNAs are apparently eliminated prior to release from the nucleus. To determine whether PTCs can influence events within the nucleus proper, we studied the immunoglobulin (Ig)-mu and T cell receptor (TCR)-beta genes using fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH). Alleles containing PTCs, but not those containing a missense mutation or a frameshift followed by frame-correcting mutations, exhibited elevated levels of pre-mRNA, which accumulated at or near the site of transcription. Our data indicate that mRNA reading frame can influence events at or near the site of gene transcription.

Mechanisms of mRNA surveillance in eukaryotes

A conserved mRNA degradation system, referred to as mRNA surveillance, exists in eukaryotic cells to degrade aberrant mRNAs. A defining aspect of aberrant transcripts is that the spatial relationship between the termination codon and specific downstream sequence information has been altered. A key, yet unknown, feature of the mRNA surveillance system is how this spatial relationship is assessed in individual transcripts. Two views have emerged to describe how discrimination between proper and improper termination might occur. In the first view, a surveillance complex assembles onto the mRNA after translation termination, and scans the mRNA in a 3' to 5' direction for a limited distance. If specific downstream sequence information is encountered during this scanning, then the surveillance complex targets the transcript for rapid decay. An alternate view suggests that the downstream sequence information influences how translation termination occurs. This view encompasses several ideas including: (a) The architecture of the mRNP can alter the rate of key steps in translation termination; (b) the discrimination between a proper and improper termination occurs via an internal, Upf1-dependent, timing mechanism; and (c) proper termination results in the restructuring of the mRNP to a form that promotes mRNA stability. This proposed model for mRNA surveillance is similar to other systems of kinetic proofreading that monitor the accuracy of other biogenic processes such as translation and spliceosome assembly.

mRNA surveillance in eukaryotes: kinetic proofreading of proper translation termination as assessed by mRNP domain organization?

In the last few years it has become clear that a conserved mRNA degradation system, referred to as mRNA surveillance, exists in eukaryotic cells to degrade aberrant mRNAs. This process plays an important role in checking that mRNAs have been properly synthesized and functions, at least in part, to increase the fidelity of gene expression by degrading aberrant mRNAs that, if translated, would produce truncated proteins. A critical issue is how normal and aberrant mRNAs are distinguished and how that distinction leads to differences in mRNA stability. Recent results suggest a model with three main points. First, mRNPs have a domain organization that is, in part, a reflection of the completion of nuclear pre-mRNA processing events. Second, the critical aspect of distinguishing a normal from an aberrant mRNA is the environment of the translation termination codon as determined by the organization of the mRNP domains. Third, the cell distinguishes proper from improper termination through an internal clock that is the rate of ATP hydrolysis by Upf1p. If termination is completed before ATP hydrolysis, the mRNA is protected from mRNA degradation. Conversely, if termination is slow, then ATP hydrolysis and a structural rearrangement occurs before termination is completed, which affects the fate of the terminating ribosome in a manner that fails to stabilize the mRNA. This proposed system of distinguishing normal from aberrant transcripts is similar to, but distinct from other systems of kinetic proofreading that affect the accuracy of other biogenic processes such as translation accuracy and spliceosome assembly.

The upstream, direct repeat sequence of Prague A Rous sarcoma virus is deficient in mediating efficient Gag assembly and particle release

Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) contains two approximately 135-nt imperfect direct repeats composed of smaller repeats, dr1 (approximately 100 nt) and dr2 (approximately 36 nt), that are between the env and src genes and downstream of src in the 3' untranslated region, respectively. It has previously been shown that a Prague A RSV mutant in which both dr1 sequences are deleted is defective at several points in the virus life cycle, including unspliced RNA and env mRNA stability, unspliced RNA transport, and virus particle assembly. A defect in unspliced RNA transport occurs because a cytoplasmic transport element is present within the dr1. We have suggested that the defect of particle production may arise from the failure of the unspliced RNA to be targeted to sites in the cytoplasm where its translation is favorable for Gag protein assembly. In this report, we have further investigated the function of the direct repeats by comparing virus mutants containing either a single upstream or downstream dr1 sequence. Both mutants were delayed in replication compared to the wild-type; the mutant with a single upstream dr1 (delta DDR) is significantly more defective than the mutant with a single downstream dr1 (delta UDR). While both mutants appear capable of efficiently transporting unspliced RNA to the cytoplasm, the delta DDR mutant with only the upstream dr1 is defective in its ability to support Gag assembly and particle release. The replication defect cannot be repaired by placing the upstream dr1 at the location of the downstream dr1 in the 3' untranslated region. A single point mutation in the upstream dr1 (U to C) restored replication and particle production to near normal levels. The results suggest that unspliced RNA transport and Gag assembly functions may be mediated by different elements within the dr1 and that the Prague A upstream dr1 is defective in the latter but not the former function.

T cell receptor (TCR) mini-gene mRNA expression regulated by nonsense codons: a nuclear-associated translation-like mechanism

Premature termination codons (PTCs) are known to decrease mRNA levels. Here, we report our investigation of the mechanism for this downregulation using the TCR-beta gene, which acquires PTCs as a result of programmed rearrangements that occur during normal thymic development. We found that a mini-gene version of this gene, which contains only three TCR-beta exons, exhibited efficient downregulation in response to PTCs. This demonstrates that the full coding sequence is not necessary for appropriate regulation. Mutation of the translation start AUG and a downstream in-frame AUG that displayed similarity to the Kozak consensus sequence reversed the downregulatory response to PTCs. Thus, an AUG start codon is required to define the reading frame of a PTC. Specific suppressor tRNAs also reversed the downregulatory response, strongly implicating the involvement of a translation-like process. Remarkably, the addition of suppressor tRNAs or the inactivation of the start AUGs caused a dramatic rise in the levels of PTC-bearing transcripts in the nuclear fraction prepared by two independent methods. Collectively, our results provide evidence for a codon-based surveillance mechanism associated with the nucleus that downregulates aberrant transcripts encoding potentially toxic polypeptides from nonproductively rearranged genes.

Molecular genetic analysis of plastocyanin biosynthesis in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Five plastocyanin-deficient mutants were identified from a population of UV-mutagenized Chlamydomonas reinhardtii cells. Genetic complementation experiments indicated that four mutants represented alleles at the PCY1 locus (pcy1-2, pcy1-3, pcy1-4, and pcy1-5). Sequence analysis confirmed that two strains, pcy1-2 and pcy1-3, carry a frameshift (-1) and a nonsense mutation, respectively, while strains pcy1-4 and pcy1-5 synthesize an extended protein as a result of read-through mutations at the stop codon. The C-terminal extension does not affect synthesis or processing of the pre-proteins, but the polypeptides are rapidly degraded after the second (lumenal) processing event. The frameshift mutation in pcy1-2 results in loss of Pcy1 mRNA, as noted previously for strain ac208 (pcy1-1), but the abundance of Pcy1 mRNA in strain pcy1-3, which carries a nonsense mutation at codon 26, is unaffected relative to wild-type cells. The decreased abundance of frameshifted Pcy1 mRNA is attributed to increased degradation rather than decreased synthesis, since the mRNAs can be stabilized by treatment of cells with cycloheximide or anisomycin. The fifth strain has a wild-type plastocyanin-encoding gene, but the strain accumulates apoplastocyanin at the expense of holoplastocyanin. We suggest that the mutation identifies a new locus (PCY2) whose function is required for normal holoplastocyanin accumulation. Like ac208 (pcy1-1), several of the new mutants were suppressed spontaneously owing to accumulation of cytochrome c6 (a functional substitute for plastocyanin). The suppressor mutation(s) displayed Mendelian inheritance and segregated independently from the PCY1 locus, which confirms that regulation of Cyc6 expression is not tightly linked to plastocyanin function.

A splicing-dependent regulatory mechanism that detects translation signals

Premature termination codons (PTCs) can cause the decay of mRNAs in the nuclear fraction of mammalian cells. This enigmatic nuclear response is of interest because it suggests that translation signals do not restrict their effect to the cytoplasm, where fully assembled ribosomes reside. Here we examined the molecular mechanism for this putative nuclear response by using the T-cell receptor-beta (TCR-beta) gene, which acquires PTCs as a result of programmed rearrangements that occur during normal thymic ontogeny. We found that PTCs had little or no measurable effect on TCR-beta pre-mRNA levels, but they sharply depressed TCR-beta mature mRNA levels in the nuclear fraction of stably transfected cells. A PTC split by an intron was able to trigger the down-regulatory response, implying that PTC recognition occurs after an mRNA is at least partially spliced. However, intron deletion and addition studies demonstrated that a PTC must be followed by at least one functional (spliceable) intron to depress mRNA levels. One explanation for this downstream intron-dependence is that cytoplasmic ribosomes adjacent to nuclear pores scan mRNAs still undergoing splicing as they emerge from the nucleus. We found this explanation to be unlikely because PTCs only 8 or 10 nt upstream of a terminal intron down-regulated mRNA levels, even though this distance is too short to permit PTC recognition in the cytoplasm prior to the splicing of the downstream intron in the nucleus. Collectively, the results suggest that nonsense codon recognition may occur in the nucleus.

Nonsense mutations inhibit RNA splicing in a cell-free system: recognition of mutant codon is independent of protein synthesis

Mutations resulting in premature termination codons reduce the corresponding mRNA levels. We describe a cell-free system in which depletion of the mutant immunoglobulin kappa mRNA pool correlates with inefficient splicing and not with RNA decay. Splicing deficiency does not depend on the sequence surrounding the in-frame nonsense codon and can be partially corrected by mutating the methionine initiation codon. Despite the apparent link between translation and low mutant mRNA levels, inefficient splicing is not dependent on protein synthesis. Abnormal splicing of mutant immunoglobulin RNA is observed with B-cell but not with HeLa or T-cell extracts. A nonsense mutant beta-globin RNA is normally spliced by B-cell extract. We propose that the phenomenon exhibits tissue and gene specificity.

A UV-induced mutation in neurospora that affects translational regulation in response to arginine

The Neurospora crassa arg-2 gene encodes the small subunit of arginine-specific carbamoyl phosphate synthetase. The levels of arg-2 mRNA and mRNA translation are negatively regulated by arginine. An upstream open reading frame (uORF) in the transcript's 5' region has been implicated in arginine-specific control. An arg-2-hph fusion gene encoding hygromycin phosphotransferase conferred arginine-regulated resistance to hygromycin when introduced into N. crassa. We used an arg-2-hph strain to select for UV-induced mutants that grew in the presence of hygromycin and arginine, and we isolated 46 mutants that had either of two phenotypes. One phenotype indicated altered expression of both arg-2-hph and arg-2 genes; the other, altered expression of arg-2-hph but not arg-2. One of the latter mutations, which was genetically closely linked to arg-2-hph, was recovered from the 5' region of the arg-2-hph gene using PCR. Sequence analyses and transformation experiments revealed a mutation at uORF codon 12 (Asp to Asn) that abrogated negative regulation. Examination of the distribution of ribosomes on arg-2-hph transcripts showed that loss of regulation had a translational component, indicating the uORF sequence was important for Arg-specific translational control. Comparisons with other uORF5 suggest common elements in translational control mechanisms.

A regulatory mechanism that detects premature nonsense codons in T-cell receptor transcripts in vivo is reversed by protein synthesis inhibitors in vitro

Gene rearrangement during the ontogeny of T- and B-cells generates an enormous repertoire of T-cell receptor (TCR) and immunoglobulin (Ig) genes. Because of the error-prone nature of this rearrangement process, two-thirds of rearranged TCR and Ig genes are expected to be out-of-frame and thus contain premature terminations codons (ptcs). We performed sequence analysis of reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction products from fetal and adult thymus and found that newly transcribed TCR-beta pre-mRNAs (intron-bearing) are frequently derived from ptc-bearing genes but such transcripts rarely accumulate as mature (fully spliced) TCR-beta transcripts. Transfection studies in the SL12.4 T-cell line showed that the presence of a ptc in any of several TCR-beta exons triggered a decrease in mRNA levels. Ptc-bearing TCR-beta transcripts were selectively depressed in levels in a cell clone that contained both an in-frame and an out-of-frame gene, thus demonstrating the allelic specificity of this down-regulatory response. Protein synthesis inhibitors with different mechanism of action (anisomysin, cycloheximide, emetine, pactamycin, puromycin, and polio virus) all reversed the down-regulatory response. Ptc-bearing transcripts were induced within 0.5 h after cycloheximide treatment. The reversal by protein synthesis inhibitors was not restricted to lymphoid cells, as shown with TCR-beta and beta-globin constructs transfected in HeLa cells. Collectively, the data suggest that the ptc-mediated mRNA decay pathway requires an unstable protein, a ribosome, or a ribosome-like entity. Protein synthesis inhibitors may be useful tools toward elucidating the molecular mechanism of ptc-mediated mRNA decay, an enigmatic response that can occur in the nuclear fraction of mammalian cells.

When cells stop making sense: effects of nonsense codons on RNA metabolism in vertebrate cells

It appears that no organism is immune to the effects of nonsense codons on mRNA abundance. The study of how nonsense codons alter RNA metabolism is still at an early stage, and our current understanding derives more from incidental vignettes than from experimental undertakings that address molecular mechanisms. Challenges for the future include identifying the gene products and RNA sequences that function in nonsense mediated RNA loss, resolving the cause and consequences of there apparently being more than one cellular site and mechanism for nonsense-mediated RNA loss, and understanding how these sites and mechanisms are related to both constitutive and specialized pathways of pre-mRNA processing and mRNA decay.

Isolation of a novel gene mutated in Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome

Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome (WAS) is an X-linked recessive immunodeficiency characterized by eczema, thrombocytopenia, and recurrent infections. Linkage studies have placed the gene at Xp11.22-p11.23. We have isolated from this interval a novel gene, WASP, which is expressed in lymphocytes, spleen, and thymus. The gene is not expressed in two unrelated WAS patients, one of whom has a single base deletion that produces a frame shift and premature termination of translation. Two additional patients have been identified with point mutations that change the same arginine residue to either a histidine or a leucine. WASP encodes a 501 amino acid proline-rich protein that is likely to be a key regulator of lymphocyte and platelet function.