Losses of temporal modulation sensitivity in retinal degenerations

Perifoveal Cone- and Rod-Mediated Temporal Contrast Sensitivities in Stargardt Disease/Fundus Flavimaculatus

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to compare L-cone-driven, S-cone-driven, and rod-driven temporal contrast sensitivities (tCSs) in patients with Stargardt disease 1/fundus flavimaculatus (STGD1/FF).

Methods

Fourteen patients (eight male, six female; mean age, 43.21 ± 13.18 years) with genetically confirmed STGD1/FF participated in this study. A dedicated light-emitting diode stimulator was used to measure perifoveal tCSs in an annular test field (1°-6° of visual eccentricity) at temporal frequencies between 1 and 20 Hz. Photoreceptor classes were isolated with the triple silent substitution technique. To compare functional damage among photoreceptor classes, sensitivity deviations (decibels) were calculated based on age-related normal values and then averaged across those frequencies where perception is mediated by the same post-receptoral pathway (L-cone red-green opponent pathway: 1, 2, 4 Hz; luminance pathway: 12, 16, 20 Hz; S-cone pathway: 1, 2, 4 Hz; fast rod pathway: 8, 10, 12 Hz). Sensitivity deviations were compared with infrared scanning laser ophthalmoscopy (IR-SLO) and standard automated perimetry (SAP).

Results

Photoreceptor-driven tCSs were generally lower in patients with STGD1/FF than in normal subjects but were without systematic differences among photoreceptors. Although sensitivity deviations were significantly correlated between each other, only luminance-driven L-cone sensitivity deviations were significantly correlated with the IR-SLO area of hyporeflectance (AoH) and SAP central mean deviation within 6° eccentricity (MD6deg).

Conclusions

No systematic differences between photoreceptor classes were detected; however, our data suggest that temporal contrasts detected by the luminance pathway were closely correlated with other clinical parameters (AoH and MD6deg) and might be most useful as functional biomarkers in clinical trials.

Evaluation of photoreceptor function in inherited retinal diseases using rod- and cone-enhanced flicker stimuli

PURPOSE

Clinical assessment of rod and cone photoreceptor sensitivity often involves the use of extended dark adaptation times to minimise cone involvement or the use of bright adapting backgrounds to saturate rods. In this study we examine a new rod/cone sensitivity test, which requires minimal dark adaptation. The aim was to establish whether rod/cone sensitivity losses could be measured reliably in patients with retinal diseases that selectively affect rods or cones when compared to age-matched subjects with normal vision.

METHODS

Flicker modulation thresholds (FMTs) were measured psychophysically, using cone- and rod-enhanced stimuli located centrally, and in four quadrants, at 5° retinal eccentricity in 20 patients (age range: 10-41 years) with cone-dominated (Stargardt's disease or macular dystrophy; n = 13) and rod-dominated (retinitis pigmentosa; n = 7) disease. These data were compared against age-matched normals tested with identical stimuli.

RESULTS

Across all retinal locations, cone FMTs in cone-dominated diseases (Median ± IQR: 32.32 ± 28.15% for central location) were greater than a majority (83%; 49/59) of corresponding rod FMTs (18.7 ± 3.29%; p = 0.05) and cone FMTs of controls (4.24 ± 2.00%). Similarly, rod FMTs in rod-dominant disease (14.99 ± 22.58%) were greater than a majority (88%; 29/39) of the corresponding cone FMTs (9.09 ± 10.33%) (p = 0.13) and rod FMT of controls (6.80 ± 2.60 %).

CONCLUSIONS

Cone-specific deficits were larger than rod-specific deficits in cone-dominated diseases, and vice versa in rod-dominated disease. These results suggest that the new method of assessing photoreceptor sensitivity has potential application in detecting specific rod/cone losses without the need for dark adaptation.

Perifoveal L- and M-cone-driven temporal contrast sensitivities at different retinal illuminances

We established a protocol using a well-established LED stimulator to measure temporal contrast sensitivities driven by sine-wave modulation of L- and M-cones in the perifovea using triple silent substitution. The stimulus was presented in an annular field (2° inner diameter, 13° outer diameter). We validated this technique by studying the contrast sensitivity of three color normal observers at 10 different temporal frequencies (between 1 and 28 Hz) over a large range of retinal illuminances (between 0.07 and 587 phot Td), spanning the complete mesopic range. In one subject, sensitivities to counterphase modulation of L- and M-cones and in-phase modulation of L, M, and S-cones were additionally measured, which putatively reflected the parvo- and magnocellular retinogeniculate pathways, respectively. Furthermore, we performed measurements of temporal contrast sensitivities as a function of frequency at 294 phot Td in two protanopes, in two deuteranopes, and in one subject with S-cone monochromacy. Quality of isolation was satisfactory and we were able to reproduce known physiological patterns of temporal vision, such as the typical temporal contrast sensitivity functions of the L- and M-cone, the parvo- and magnocellular retinogeniculate pathways, as well as the light adaptation curves. These results will help determine optimal stimulus conditions in future studies. Results from the dichromats and the S-cone monochromat also support the quality of isolation of our protocol and underpin its potential clinical value.

Psychophysics, reliability, and norm values for temporal contrast sensitivity implemented on the two alternative forced choice C-Quant device

The current paper describes the design and population testing of a flicker sensitivity assessment technique corresponding to the psychophysical approach for straylight measurement. The purpose is twofold: to check the subjects' capability to perform the straylight test and as a test for retinal integrity for other purposes. The test was implemented in the Oculus C-Quant straylight meter, using homemade software (MATLAB). The geometry of the visual field lay-out was identical, as was the subjects' 2AFC task. A comparable reliability criterion ("unc") was developed. Outcome measure was logTCS (temporal contrast sensitivity). The population test was performed in science fair settings on about 400 subjects. Moreover, 2 subjects underwent extensive tests to check whether optical defects, mimicked with trial lenses and scatter filters, affected the TCS outcome. Repeated measures standard deviation was 0.11 log units for the reference population. Normal values for logTCS were around 2 (threshold 1%) with some dependence on age (range 6 to 85 years). The test outcome did not change upon a tenfold (optical) deterioration in visual acuity or straylight. The test has adequate precision for checking a subject's capability to perform straylight assessment. The unc reliability criterion ensures sufficient precision, also for assessment of retinal sensitivity loss.

A practical method of measuring the human temporal contrast sensitivity function

One of the more significant indicators of neural age-related loss and disease is reduced temporal processing speed. It would, therefore, be useful to have an accurate and practical device that measures the full range of an individual's temporal processing abilities (characterized as the temporal contrast sensitivity function, TCSF). 70 subjects (15-84 yrs) were tested. A small tabletop device utilizing electronic control of light-emitting diodes (LEDs) was constructed that delivered a 1-degree, 660 nm test (the modulation depth of which could be adjusted directly by the subject) centered within a 10-degree 660 nm surround. The method provided a TCSF that had a shape consistent with past studies (peaking around 8 Hz). Also consistent with past work, the largest age-decline was found at the highest frequencies and for the central fovea (r = 0.47, p<0.0001, ~2 Hz per decade). Psychophysical assessment of temporal vision offers an easy and dynamic measure of central visual function.

The fundamental and second harmonic of the photopic flicker electroretinogram: temporal frequency-dependent abnormalities in retinitis pigmentosa

OBJECTIVES

The flicker electroretinogram (FERG) consists mainly of a linear (fundamental, 1F) and a non linear (second harmonic, 2F) component. Previous results indicate that 2F originates more proximally in the retina than 1F, and that retinitis pigmentosa (RP) may affect 2F to a greater extent than 1F. The aim of this study was to evaluate FERG 1F and 2F abnormalities in RP as a function of the stimulus temporal frequency (TF).

METHODS

Twelve patients with typical RP and 10 age-matched controls were examined. FERGs were recorded in response to uniform fields (18 degrees) presented in the macula on a light-adapting background. Stimuli were flickered sinusoidally at different, closely spaced TFs between 3.7 and 52 Hz. Amplitudes and phases of the Fourier analysed 1F and 2F components were measured. Components' apparent latencies were estimated from the rate at which phase lagged with TF.

RESULTS

When compared to controls, mean 1F amplitudes of patients were reduced at both low (3.7-12.6 Hz) and high (14-52 Hz) TFs, with greatest losses (0.5 log units) around the peaks (3.7 and 41 Hz) of the normal TF function. Mean 2F amplitudes were reduced mainly at low TFs, with greatest losses (0.5 log units) at 5-8 Hz. On average, the shape of the 2F, but not 1F amplitude versus TF function, differed between patients and controls, showing a selective attenuation at low TFs. Mean 1F apparent latencies were delayed at both low and high TFs, with greater delays at low (85 ms) than at high (33 ms) TFs. Mean 2F apparent latencies were delayed only at low TFs (58 ms).

CONCLUSIONS

In RP, 1F and 2F phase delays as well as 2F amplitude losses are dependent on TF, suggesting that FERG generators' subpopulations in both distal and proximal retina are differentially affected. Analysis of the FERG TF response is potentially useful to characterize cone system dysfunction in different genetic subtypes of RP.

Abnormalities of the retinal cone system in retinitis pigmentosa

Patients with retinitis pigmentosa (RP) show delayed inner retinal responses as measured by the cone ERG response to a 30 Hz stimulus. To determine the extent to which this delay results from abnormalities of cone phototransduction, cone ERGs to single flashes were obtained from 21 patients with RP and a model of cone phototransduction was fitted to the leading edge of the a-waves of these ERGs. Nearly all patients showed an abnormally low sensitivity of cone phototransduction consistent with a reduction in the amplification of transduction. This abnormality can account for part of the delayed 30 Hz response. Analysis of post-receptoral potentials indicated that RP also slows the responses of the inner retina. A combination of these two factors, a sensitivity change at the receptor and a delay in the response of the inner retina, produces the delayed response of the cone flicker ERG in patients with RP.