MR Imaging– versus Conventional X-ray Fluoroscopy–guided Renal Angioplasty in Swine: Prospective Randomized Comparison

Current State of MRI-Guided Endovascular Arterial Interventions: A Systematic Review of Preclinical and Clinical Studies

BACKGROUND

MRI guidance of arterial endovascular interventions could be beneficial as it does not require radiation exposure, allows intrinsic blood-tissue contrast, and enables three-dimensional and functional imaging, however, clinical applications are still limited.

PURPOSE

To review the current state of MRI-guided arterial endovascular interventions and to identify the most commonly reported challenges.

STUDY TYPE

Systematic review.

POPULATION

Pubmed, Embase, Web of Science, and The Cochrane Library were systematically searched to find relevant articles. The search strategy combined synonyms for vascular pathology, endovascular therapy, and real-time MRI guidance.

FIELD STRENGTH/SEQUENCE

No field strength or sequence restrictions were applied.

ASSESSMENT

Two reviewers independently identified and reviewed the original articles and extracted relevant data.

STATISTICAL TESTS

Results of the included original articles are reported.

RESULTS

A total of 24,809 studies were identified for screening. Eighty-eight studies were assessed for eligibility, after which data were extracted from 43 articles (6 phantom, 33 animal, and 4 human studies). Reported technical success rates for animal and human studies ranged between 42% to 100%, and the average complication rate was 5.8% (animal studies) and 8.8% (human studies). Main identified challenges were related to spatial and temporal resolution as well as safety, design, and scarcity of current MRI-compatible endovascular devices.

DATA CONCLUSION

MRI guidance of endovascular arterial interventions seems feasible, however, included articles included mostly small single-center case series. Several hurdles remain to be overcome before larger trials can be undertaken. Main areas of research should focus on adequate imaging protocols with integrated tracking of dedicated endovascular devices.

MRI-guided endovascular intervention: current methods and future potential

INTRODUCTION

Image-guided endovascular interventions, performed using the insertion and navigation of catheters through the vasculature, have been increasing in number over the years, as minimally invasive procedures continue to replace invasive surgical procedures. Such endovascular interventions are almost exclusively performed under x-ray fluoroscopy, which has the best spatial and temporal resolution of all clinical imaging modalities. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) offers unique advantages and could be an attractive alternative to conventional x-ray guidance, but also brings with it distinctive challenges.

AREAS COVERED

In this review, the benefits and limitations of MRI-guided endovascular interventions are addressed, systems and devices for guiding such interventions are summarized, and clinical applications are discussed.

EXPERT OPINION

MRI-guided endovascular interventions are still relatively new to the interventional radiology field, since significant technical hurdles remain to justify significant costs and demonstrate safety, design, and robustness. Clinical applications of MRI-guided interventions are promising but their full potential may not be realized until proper tools designed to function in the MRI environment are available. Translational research and further preclinical studies are needed before MRI-guided interventions will be practical in a clinical interventional setting.

Metabolic flux between organs measured by arteriovenous metabolite gradients

Mammalian organs convert dietary nutrients into circulating metabolites and share them to maintain whole-body metabolic homeostasis. While the concentrations of circulating metabolites have been frequently measured in a variety of pathophysiological conditions, the exchange flux of circulating metabolites between organs is not easily measurable due to technical difficulties. Isotope tracing is useful for measuring such fluxes for a metabolite of interest, but the shuffling of isotopic atoms between metabolites requires mathematical modeling. Arteriovenous metabolite gradient measurements can complement isotope tracing to infer organ-specific net fluxes of many metabolites simultaneously. Here, we review the historical development of arteriovenous measurements and discuss their advantages and limitations with key example studies that have revealed metabolite exchange flux between organs in diverse pathophysiological contexts.

Magnetic Resonance-Guided Passive Catheter Tracking for Endovascular Therapy

The use of MR guidance for endovascular intervention is appealing because of its lack of ionizing radiation, high-contrast visualization of vessel walls and adjacent soft tissues, multiplanar capabilities, and potential to incorporate functional information such as flow, fluid dynamics, perfusion, and cardiac motion. This review highlights state-of-the-art imaging techniques and hardware used for passive tracking of endovascular devices in interventional MR imaging, including negative contrast, passive contrast, nonproton multispectral, and direct current techniques. The advantages and disadvantages of passive tracking relative to active tracking are also summarized.

Magnetic Resonance-guided Active Catheter Tracking

Several advantages of MR imaging compared with other imaging modalities have provided the rationale for increased attention to MR-guided interventions, including its excellent soft tissue contrast, its capability to show both anatomic and functional information, and no use of ionizing radiation. An important aspect of MR-guided intervention is to provide visualization and navigation of interventional devices relative to the surrounding tissues. This article focuses on the methods for MR-guided active tracking in catheter-based interventions. Practical issues about implementation of active catheter tracking in a clinical setting are discussed and several current application examples are highlighted.

Torsional dynamics of steerable needles: modeling and fluoroscopic guidance

Needle insertions underlie a diversity of medical interventions. Steerable needles provide a means by which to enhance existing needle-based interventions and facilitate new ones. Tip-steerable needles follow a curved path and can be steered by twisting the needle base during insertion, but this twisting excites torsional dynamics that introduce a discrepancy between the base and tip twist angles. Here, we model the torsional dynamics of a flexible rod-such as a tip-steerable needle-during subsurface insertion and develop a new controller based on the model. The torsional model incorporates time-varying mode shapes to capture the changing boundary conditions inherent during insertion. Numerical simulations and physical experiments using two distinct setups-stereo camera feedback in semitransparent artificial tissue and feedback control with real-time X-ray imaging in optically opaque artificial tissue-demonstrate the need to account for torsional dynamics in control of the needle tip.

Electromagnetic navigation for thoracic aortic stent-graft deployment: a pilot study in swine

PURPOSE

To determine the feasibility of electromagnetic tracking as a method to augment conventional imaging guidance for the safe delivery, precise positioning, and accurate deployment of thoracic aortic endografts.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Custom guide wires were fabricated, and the delivery catheters for thoracic aortic endoprostheses were retrofitted with integrated electromagnetic coil sensors to enable real-time endovascular tracking. Preprocedure thoracic computed tomographic (CT) angiograms were obtained after the placement of fiducial skin patches on the chest wall of three anesthetized swine, enabling automatic registration. The stent-graft deployment location target near the subclavian artery was selected on the preprocedure CT angiogram. Two steps were analyzed: advancing a tracked glidewire to the aortic arch and positioning the tracked stent-graft assembly by using electromagnetic guidance alone. Multiple CT scans were obtained to evaluate the accuracy of the electromagnetic tracking system by measuring the target registration error, which compared the actual position of the tracked devices to the displayed "virtual" electromagnetic-tracked position. Postdeployment CT angiography and necropsy helped confirm stent-graft position and subclavian artery patency.

RESULTS

A stent-graft was successfully delivered and deployed in each of the three animals by using real-time electromagnetic tracking alone. The mean fiducial registration error with autoregistration was 1.5 mm. Sixteen comparative scans were obtained to determine the target registration error, which was 4.3 mm +/- 0.97 (range, 3.0-6.0 mm) for the glidewire sensor coil. The mean target registration error for the stent-graft delivery catheter sensor coil was 2.6 mm +/- 0.7 (range, 1.9-3.8 mm). The mean deployment error for the stent-graft, defined as deployment deviation from the target, was 2.6 mm +/- 3.0.

CONCLUSIONS

Delivery and deployment of customized thoracic stent-grafts with use of electromagnetic tracking alone is feasible and accurate in swine. Combining endovascular electromagnetic tracking with conventional fluoroscopy may further improve accuracy and be a more realistic multimodality approach.

Whole shaft visibility and mechanical performance for active MR catheters using copper-nitinol braided polymer tubes

BACKGROUND

Catheter visualization and tracking remains a challenge in interventional MR.Active guidewires can be made conspicuous in "profile" along their whole shaft exploiting metallic core wire and hypotube components that are intrinsic to their mechanical performance. Polymer-based catheters, on the other hand, offer no conductive medium to carry radio frequency waves. We developed a new "active" catheter design for interventional MR with mechanical performance resembling braided X-ray devices. Our 75 cm long hybrid catheter shaft incorporates a wire lattice in a polymer matrix, and contains three distal loop coils in a flexible and torquable 7Fr device. We explored the impact of braid material designs on radiofrequency and mechanical performance.

RESULTS

The incorporation of copper wire into in a superelastic nitinol braided loopless antenna allowed good visualization of the whole shaft (70 cm) in vitro and in vivo in swine during real-time MR with 1.5 T scanner. Additional distal tip coils enhanced tip visibility. Increasing the copper:nitinol ratio in braiding configurations improved flexibility at the expense of torquability. We found a 16-wire braid of 1:1 copper:nitinol to have the optimum balance of mechanical (trackability, flexibility, torquability) and antenna (signal attenuation) properties. With this configuration, the temperature increase remained less than 2 degrees C during real-time MR within 10 cm horizontal from the isocenter. The design was conspicuous in vitro and in vivo.

CONCLUSION

We have engineered a new loopless antenna configuration that imparts interventional MR catheters with satisfactory mechanical and imaging characteristics. This compact loopless antenna design can be generalized to visualize the whole shaft of any general-purpose polymer catheter to perform safe interventional procedures.

Comparative evaluation of the geometrical accuracy of intravascular magnetic resonance imaging: a phantom study

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

To evaluate and compare the accuracy of cross-sectional imaging using an intravascular antenna in the context of vascular morphological measurements performed during a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-guided vascular intervention.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Cross-sectional imaging of a multimodality vascular phantom was performed using intravascular and surface MRI, multidetector computed tomography, and intravascular ultrasound (IVUS). Using a balanced steady-state free-precession sequence, 18 sequences parameters sets were investigated (12 for intravascular MRI and 6 for surface MRI). Vessel diameters for all images and modalities were computed using an automated vessel segmentation algorithm.

RESULTS

Using IVUS as a gold standard, imaging using an intravascular antenna leads to an increase in geometrical accuracy in comparison to traditional surface MRI. This level of accuracy appears to follow a significant inverse proportionality relation in respect to vessel wall signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). Taking into account the rapid decrease in SNR as a function of the distance to the intravascular antenna, these results imply that, for a given level of geometrical accuracy, faster sequences can be used for the imaging of smaller vessels.

CONCLUSION

Imaging using an intravascular antenna appears as a valuable assistance to increase the accuracy of vascular morphological measurements. This increase in geometrical accuracy would be beneficial during the realization of an MRI-guided intervention, either to perform pretreatment measurements or to assess the outcome of the procedure. Acquisition parameters should be tailored to vessel size and procedural time constraints.

First magnetic resonance imaging-guided aortic stenting and cava filter placement using a polyetheretherketone-based magnetic resonance imaging-compatible guidewire in swine: proof of concept

The purpose of this study was to demonstrate feasibility of percutaneous transluminal aortic stenting and cava filter placement under magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) guidance exclusively using a polyetheretherketone (PEEK)-based MRI-compatible guidewire. Percutaneous transluminal aortic stenting and cava filter placement were performed in 3 domestic swine. Procedures were performed under MRI-guidance in an open-bore 1.5-T scanner. The applied 0.035-inch guidewire has a PEEK core reinforced by fibres, floppy tip, hydrophilic coating, and paramagnetic markings for passive visualization. Through an 11F sheath, the guidewire was advanced into the abdominal (swine 1) or thoracic aorta (swine 2), and the stents were deployed. The guidewire was advanced into the inferior vena cava (swine 3), and the cava filter was deployed. Postmortem autopsy was performed. Procedural success, guidewire visibility, pushability, and stent support were qualitatively assessed by consensus. Procedure times were documented. Guidewire guidance into the abdominal and thoracic aortas and the inferior vena cava was successful. Stent deployments were successful in the abdominal (swine 1) and thoracic (swine 2) segments of the descending aorta. Cava filter positioning and deployment was successful. Autopsy documented good stent and filter positioning. Guidewire visibility through applied markers was rated acceptable for aortic stenting and good for venous filter placement. Steerability, pushability, and device support were good. The PEEK-based guidewire allows either percutaneous MRI-guided aortic stenting in the thoracic and abdominal segments of the descending aorta and filter placement in the inferior vena cava with acceptable to good device visibility and offers good steerability, pushability, and device support.

Interventional cardiovascular magnetic resonance: still tantalizing

The often touted advantages of MR guidance remain largely unrealized for cardiovascular interventional procedures in patients. Many procedures have been simulated in animal models. We argue these opportunities for clinical interventional MR will be met in the near future. This paper reviews technical and clinical considerations and offers advice on how to implement a clinical-grade interventional cardiovascular MR (iCMR) laboratory. We caution that this reflects our personal view of the "state of the art."

MR-guided intravascular interventions: techniques and applications

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) offers several advantages over other imaging modalities that make it an attractive imaging tool for diagnostic and therapeutic procedures. This tremendous potential of MRI has provided the rationale for increased attention toward MR-guided endovascular interventions. MR guidance has been used recently to navigate endovascular catheters and deliver stents, vena cava filters, embolization materials, and septum closure devices. However, its potential goes beyond just copying existing procedures toward the development of new minimally invasive techniques that cannot be performed with conventional guiding techniques. Because of technical limitations and safety issues associated with some of the currently available devices, a limited number of clinical studies have been performed so far. The overall success for this developing field requires considerable interdisciplinary research within both the interventional and the MR community. Only through a combined effort can this complex technology find its way into clinical practice. This review discusses the hardware and software improvements that have helped to advance endovascular interventions under MR imaging guidance from a pure research tool to become a clinical reality. In addition, technical and safety issues specific to endovascular MR image guidance will be described and practical applications will be shown that take advantage of the benefits of MR for endovascular interventions.

MR-guided endovascular interventions: a comprehensive review on techniques and applications

The magnetic resonance (MR) guidance of endovascular interventions is probably one of the greatest challenges of clinical MR research. MR angiography is not only an imaging tool for the vasculature but can also simultaneously depict high tissue contrast, including the differentiation of the vascular wall and perivascular tissues, as well as vascular function. Several hurdles had to be overcome to allow MR guidance for endovascular interventions. MR hardware and sequence design had to be developed to achieve acceptable patient access and to allow real-time or near real-time imaging. The development of interventional devices, both applicable and safe for MR imaging (MRI), was also mandatory. The subject of this review is to summarize the latest developments in real-time MRI hardware, MRI, visualization tools, interventional devices, endovascular tracking techniques, actual applications and safety issues.

Development of an auxiliary system for the execution of vascular catheter interventions with a reduced radiological risk; system description and first experimental results

Vascular catheterization is a common procedure in clinical medicine. It is normally performed by a specialist using an X-ray fluoroscopic guide and contrast-media. In the present paper, an image-guided navigation system which indicates a path providing guidance to the desired target inside the vascular tree is described with the aim of reducing the exposure of personnel and patients to X-rays during the catheterization procedure. A 3D model of the patient vascular tree, reconstructed with data collected by an angiography before starting the intervention, is used as a guide map instead of fluoroscopic scans. An accurate spatial correspondence between the body of the patient and the 3D reconstructed vascular model is established and, by means of a position indicator installed over the catheter tip, the real-time position/orientation of the tip is indicated correctly. This paper describes the system and the operational procedures necessary to use the proposed method efficiently during a catheter intervention. Preliminary experimental results on a phantom are also reported.

Renal Artery Stenosis in Swine: Feasibility of MR Assessment of Renal Function during Percutaneous Transluminal Angioplasty

PURPOSE

To prospectively test--in a swine model of renal artery stenosis (RAS)--the hypothesis that magnetic resonance (MR) imaging can reveal changes in renal function at the time of percutaneous transluminal angioplasty (PTA).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this animal care and use committee-approved study, high-grade unilateral RAS was surgically induced in six pigs. MR imaging at 3.0 T was used for intraprocedural assessment of the anatomic and physiologic changes induced by x-ray-guided PTA. With use of MR imaging, changes in single-kidney glomerular filtration rate, extraction fraction, and renal blood flow were assessed during PTA. The arterial diameter of stenosis before and after PTA was assessed by using conventional digital subtraction angiography. Mean changes in functional and anatomic parameters were compared by using the Wilcoxon signed rank test (alpha = .05).

RESULTS

At digital subtraction angiography, the mean percentage of stenosis was 69% +/- 10 (standard deviation) before PTA and 26% +/- 10 after PTA (P<.03). Mean pre- and post-PTA extraction fraction values were 0.11 +/- 0.03 and 0.19 +/- 0.06, respectively (P<.03). The mean single-kidney glomerular filtration rate before PTA, 19 mL/min +/- 13, increased to 41 mL/min +/- 33 after PTA (P<.03). There was no significant change in mean renal blood flow after PTA (P=.44).

CONCLUSION

In swine, MR imaging can reveal changes in renal function after x-ray-guided PTA for unilateral RAS.

Comparison of intraarterial MR angiography at 3.0 T with X-ray digital subtraction angiography for detection of renal artery stenosis in swine

PURPOSE

To compare the accuracy of catheter-directed intraarterial (IA) magnetic resonance (MR) angiography at 3.0 T with that of x-ray digital subtraction angiography (DSA) for the measurement of renal artery stenosis (RAS) in swine.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Unilateral hemodynamically significant RAS (>50%) was induced surgically in six pigs with use of reverse cable ties. One to two weeks after surgery, each pig underwent x-ray DSA and MR angiography before and after percutaneous transluminal balloon angioplasty (PTA). X-ray DSA was performed before and after PTA of RAS by injection of iodinated contrast agent through a 5-F multiple-side hole angiographic catheter placed in the abdominal aorta under fluoroscopic guidance. MR angiography of RAS was performed before and after PTA of RAS on a 3.0-T clinical MR imager with use of gadolinium-based contrast agent. MR angiography and DSA images were analyzed with the full width at half maximum method. Percent stenosis measurements between x-ray DSA and MR angiography were compared with a paired t test and were correlated with linear regression and Bland Altman analysis (alpha = 0.05).

RESULTS

Six cases of RAS were induced and imaged successfully with DSA and MR angiography techniques before and after PTA. On x-ray DSA, median stenoses was 64% (95% CI 57%-80%) before PTA and 20% (95% CI 5%-32%) after PTA. Corresponding MR angiography median stenosis measurement was 69% (95% CI 58%-80%) before PTA and 26% (95% CI 16%-36%) after PTA. A paired t test comparison did not show a difference between DSA and MR angiography (P = .16). RAS measurements on MR angiography correlated closely (P < .01) with DSA measurements (r(2) = 0.92).

CONCLUSION

In swine, the accuracy of catheter-directed IA MR angiography with use of a clinical 3.0-T MR imaging unit for the measurement of RAS was similar to that of conventional x-ray DSA.

Magnetic resonance imaging-guided vascular interventions

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), which provides superior soft-tissue imaging and no known harmful effects, has the potential as an alternative modality to guide various medical interventions. This review will focus on MR-guided endovascular interventions and present its current state and future outlook. In the first technical part, enabling technologies such as developments in fast imaging, catheter devices, and visualization techniques are examined. This is followed by a clinical survey that includes proof-of-concept procedures in animals and initial experience in human subjects. In preclinical experiments, MRI has already proven to be valuable. For example, MRI has been used to guide and track targeted cell delivery into or around myocardial infarctions, to guide atrial septal puncture, and to guide the connection of portal and systemic venous circulations. Several investigational MR-guided procedures have already been reported in patients, such as MR-guided cardiac catheterization, invasive imaging of peripheral artery atheromata, selective intraarterial MR angiography, and preliminary angioplasty and stent placement. In addition, MR-assisted transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt procedures in patients have been shown in a novel hybrid double-doughnut x-ray/MRI system. Numerous additional investigational human MR-guided endovascular procedures are now underway in several medical centers around the world. There are also significant hurdles: availability of clinical-grade devices, device-related safety issues, challenges to patient monitoring, and acoustic noise during imaging. The potential of endovascular interventional MRI is great because as a single modality, it combines 3-dimensional anatomic imaging, device localization, hemodynamics, tissue composition, and function.