Pathogenesis of lumbosacral lipoma: a test of the "premature dysjunction" theory

Disorders of Secondary Neurulation: Suggestion of a New Classification According to Pathoembryogenesis

Recently, advanced knowledge on secondary neurulation and its application to the clinical experience have led to the deeper insight into the pathoembryogenesis of secondary neurulation with new classifications of the caudal spinal dysraphic entities. Here, we summarize the dynamic changes in the concepts of disordered secondary neurulation over the last two decades. In addition, we suggest our new pathoembryogenetic explanations for a few entities based on the literature and the data from our previous animal research. Disordered secondary neurulation at each phase may cause various corresponding lesions, such as (1) failed junction with the primary neural tube (junctional neural tube defect and segmental spinal dysgenesis), (2) dysgenesis or duplication of the caudal cell mass associated with disturbed activity of caudal mesenchymal tissue (caudal agenesis and caudal duplication syndrome), (3) abnormal continuity of medullary cord to the surrounding layers, namely, failed ingression of the primitive streak to the caudal cell mass (myelomeningocele), focal limited dorsal neurocutaneous nondisjunction (limited dorsal myeloschisis and congenital dermal sinus), and neuro-mesenchymal adhesion (lumbosacral lipomatous malformation), and (4) regression failure spectrum of the medullary cord (thickened filum and filar cyst, retained medullary cord and low-lying conus, terminal myelocele, and terminal myelocystocele). It seems that almost every anomalous entity of the primary neural tube may occur in the area of secondary neurulation. Furthermore, the close association of the caudal cell mass with the activity of caudal mesenchymal tissue involves a wider range of surrounding structures in secondary neurulation than in primary neurulation. Although the majority of the data are from animals and many theories are still conjectural, these changing concepts of normal and disordered secondary neurulation will provoke further advancements in our management strategies as well as in the pathoembryogenetic understanding of anomalous lesions in this area.

Disorders of Secondary Neurulation : Mainly Focused on Pathoembryogenesis

Recent advancements in basic research on the process of secondary neurulation and increased clinical experience with caudal spinal anomalies with associated abnormalities in the surrounding and distal structures shed light on further understanding of the pathoembryogenesis of the lesions and led to the new classification of these dysraphic entities. We summarized the changing concepts of lesions developed from the disordered secondary neurulation shown during the last decade. In addition, we suggested our new pathoembryogenetic explanations for a few entities based on the literature and the data from our previous animal research. Disordered secondary neurulation at each phase of development may cause corresponding lesions, such as failed junction with the primary neural tube (junctional neural tube defect and segmental spinal dysgenesis), dysgenesis or duplication of the caudal cell mass associated with disturbed activity of caudal mesenchymal tissue (caudal agenesis and caudal duplication syndrome), failed ingression of the primitive streak to the caudal cell mass (myelomeningocele), focal limited dorsal neuro-cutaneous nondisjunction (limited dorsal myeloschisis and congenital dermal sinus), neuro-mesenchymal adhesion (lumbosacral lipomatous malformation), and regression failure spectrum of the medullary cord (thickened filum and filar cyst, low-lying conus, retained medullary cord, terminal myelocele and terminal myelocystocele). It seems that almost every anomalous entity of the primary neural tube may occur in the area of secondary neurulation. Furthermore, the close association with the activity of caudal mesenchymal tissue in secondary neurulation involves a wider range of surrounding structures than in primary neurulation. Although the majority of the data are from animals, not from humans and many theories are still conjectural, these changing concepts of normal and disordered secondary neurulation will provoke further advancements in our management strategies as well as in the pathoembryogenetic understanding of anomalous lesions in this area.

Congenital Spinal Lipomatous Malformations. Part 2. Differentiation from Selected Closed Spinal Malformations

BACKGROUND

Congenital spinal lipomatous malformations (spinal lipomas, lipomyeloceles, and lipomyelomeningoceles) are closed neural tube defects over the lower back. Differentiation from some other closed neural tube defects in this region can be problematic for pathologists.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This review is based on PubMed searches of the embryology, gross and histopathologic findings, and laboratory reporting requisites for retained medullary spinal cords, coccygeal medullary vestiges and cysts, myelocystoceles, true human vestigial tails, and pseudotails for comparison with congenital spinal lipomatous malformations.

RESULTS

Embryology, imaging, gross and histopathology of these closed neural tube lesions have different but overlapping features compared to congenital spinal lipomatous malformations, requiring context for diagnosis.

CONCLUSION

The lipomyelocele spectrum and to some degree all of the malformations discussed, even though they may not share gross appearance, anatomic site, surgical approach, or prognosis, require clinical and histopathologic correlation for final diagnosis.

Congenital Spinal Lipomatous Malformations. Part 1. Spinal Lipomas, Lipomyeloceles, and Lipomyelomeningoceles

Background: Lumbosacral spinal lipomas and lipomyeloceles are usually identified in early childhood. Terminology, histopathology, and diagnosis for these malformations can be confusing. Materials and Methods: This is a PubMed review with comparison of embryology, gross, and histopathology, and reporting requisites for these and related closed spinal malformations. Results: The spinal lipoma group (congenital spinal lipomatous malformations) includes subcutaneous, transdural, intradural, and noncontiguous malformations stretching through the entire lower spinal region. This lipomyelocele trajectory overlaps the embryonic tail's caudal eminence. Histopathologically, the lipomyelocele spectrum is a heterogeneous, stereotypical set of findings encountered from dermis to spinal cord. Diagnosis requires detailed correlation of images, intraoperative inspection, and histopathology. Conclusions: Appropriate terminology and clinicopathologic correlation to arrive at a diagnosis is a critical activity shared by pathologist and clinician. Prognostic and management differences depend on specific diagnoses. Familial and genetic influences play little if any role in patient management in closed spinal malformations.

Spinal Dysraphism in the Last Two Decades : What I Have Seen during the Era of Dynamic Advancement

Compared to any other decade, the last two decades have been the most dynamic period in terms of advances in the knowledge on spinal dysraphism. Among the several factors of rapid advancement, such as embryology during secondary neurulation and intraoperative neurophysiological monitoring, there is no doubt that Professor Dachling Pang stood high amidst the period. I review here the last two decades from my personal point of view on what has been achieved in the field of spinal dysraphism, focusing on occult tethered cord syndrome, lumbosacral lipomatous malformation, terminal myelocystocele, retained medullary cord, limited dorsal myeloschisis and junctional neural tube defect. There are still many issues to revise, add and extend. Profound knowledge of basic science is critical, as well as refined clinical analysis. I expect that young scholars who follow the footsteps of precedent giants will shed bright light on this topic in the future.

Split Cord Malformation Type 2 with Double Dorsal Lipoma: A Sequela or a Chance

An 11-month-old baby girl, with normal perinatal history, presented with a congenital lumbosacral swelling and a sacral dimple. Imaging revealed a split cord malformation (SCM) type 2 at L1–L3 with a lipomeningocoele extending intradurally and tethering both the hemicords, the conus was noted to be at L4. She underwent excision of the lipoma and detethering of the hemicords. Intraoperatively, the split cord was seen from L1 to L3 with an aberrant median vessel passing between the hemicords. Two lipomas were seen separately attached to each of the hemicords, the lipomas were dissected off the hemicords, and the hemicords were neurulated. The case helps revisit the unified theory proposed by Pang for SCM as well as the theory of premature disjunction in the pathogenesis of lipomeningocoele. Formation of the endomesenchymal tract splits the developing cord into two, whereas the premature detachment of neuroectoderm from the cutaneous ectoderm can lead to lipomeningocoeles. The present case is only the fourth case ever reported of an SCM type 2 with double lipoma. In the case report, we discuss the embryological basis of this condition and surgical nuances of management.

Placode rotation in transitional lumbosacral lipomas: are there implications for origin and mechanism of deterioration?

PURPOSE

Rotation of the lipoma-neural placode has been noted in transitional lumbosacral lipomas. The purpose of this study was to confirm this rotation; that this rotation occurs with a preference to the left, and correlates with clinical symptoms. In addition, this study tests the hypothesis that this rotation occurs through local mechanical forces rather than intrinsic congenital malformation.

METHODS

Lipomas were classified as per the Chapman classification. Degree of rotation of the placode from the coronal plane was recorded along with the presence of herniation outside of the vertebral canal. Abnormalities on urodynamic testing were recorded, along with neuro-orthopaedic signs picked up on formal neuro-physiotherapy assessment.

RESULTS

Placode rotation occurs more frequently in the transitional group. Regardless of lipoma classification, rotation was much more common to the left. Furthermore, when lateralisation of symptoms was present, this strongly correlated with the direct of rotation. There was no difference in rotation of the placode whether it was within (lipomyelocoele) or without the vertebral canal (lipomyelomeningocoele).

CONCLUSIONS

Placode rotation is a feature of transitional lumbosacral lipomas and may account for the increase in symptoms amongst this subgroup. Herniation of the placode outside the vertebral canal does not increase the risk of rotation suggesting a congenital cause for this finding rather than a purely mechanical explanation.

Noncontiguous Double Spinal Lipoma with Tethered Cord and Polydactyly: Two Different Embryological Events in One Patient

Lumbosacral lipoma is reported to occur in 4–8 of 100,000 patients. Sixty-six percent of lipomyelomeningocele in young patients have accompanied by hypertrophic filum terminale. It is rare to find two isolated spinal lipomas simultaneously. Embryological origin of dorsal and filar lipomas is different from each other and hence rarer to find them together. Radical resection is now being preferred for better long-term progression-free survival. We report an interesting case of spinal dysraphism in a 4-month-old female child with protruding, nontender, soft, subcutaneous 5 cm × 7 cm mass of the lumbosacral area that had been present since birth. Other anomalies included polydactyly of left hand. Magnetic resonance imaging demonstrated two isolated spinal lipomas, a transitional type and a terminal type filum lipoma with an interval of normal filum between the two. The findings were confirmed at surgery and detethering done along the white plane with neural placode reconstruction as described by Dachling Pang. The child had an uneventful postoperative recovery.

Experimental models of spinal open neural tube defect and Chiari type II malformation

INTRODUCTION

Experimental animal models are essential for investigation of the pathoembryogenesis, pathophysiology, and management strategy of spinal open neural tube defect (ONTD) and its associated anomalies including Chiari type II malformation. Genetic, chemical/nutrient, and surgical models have been widely used for a variety of purposes. The aim of this article is to review the representative animal models of spinal ONTD and associated Chiari type II malformation with respect to their advantages and disadvantages.

DISCUSSION

Among them, the surgical model was described in detail because it is familiar to neurosurgeons and it is used for evaluations of prenatal repair of spinal ONTDs. The surgical model also has advantages because it allows quantitative analysis of the lesions. A description of our previous studies on spinal ONTDs using a chick surgical model is presented as an example.

Spinal cord malformations

Malformations of the spinal cord are one of the most frequent malformations. They should be clearly divided into two completely different families of malformations: open dysraphisms and occult dysraphisms. Open dysraphism mostly consists in myelomeningocele (MMC). Its incidence is 1/1000 live births with a wide variation. Folic acid supplementation has been shown to reduce its risk. In most cases, the diagnosis is done prenatally by serum screening and ultrasound and may lead to termination of pregnancy. In case of decision to continue pregnancy, surgical treatment must be achieved during the first days of life, and in 50 to 90% of cases, a ventricular shunt must be installed. The follow-up of these children must be continued throughout life looking for late complications (Chiari II and syringomyelia, vertebral problems, neuropathic bladder, tethered cord). Occult dysraphisms are a heterogeneous group of malformations. Lipomas (filum and conus) are the most frequent and their treatment remains controversial. Diastematomyelia, neurenteric cysts, dermal sinus, and more complex forms (Currarino syndrome) belong to this group. Most of them can and must be diagnosed prenatally or at birth by careful examination of the lower back for the cutaneous stigmata of the disease to decrease the risk of neurological, urological, or orthopedic permanent handicap.

Orthopaedic deformities associated with lumbosacral spinal lipomas

BACKGROUND

Lipomeningocele is the most common cause of occult spinal dysraphism and spinal cord tethering. Children with this condition seem normal at birth except for cutaneous signs, and the initial complaints are usually musculoskeletal. We studied the orthopaedic deformities observed in this condition.

METHODS

We reviewed the medical charts of 159 patients with a diagnosis of lipoma of the lumbosacral spine that were examined in the Myelodysplasia Clinic over 25 years. Of these patients, 122 were treated by a single orthopaedic surgeon (L.D.) and were studied in detail. Of these 122 patients, 45 were over 15 years of age at the time of the final follow-up.

RESULTS

Most patients had cutaneous stigmata. Foot deformities were the most common orthopaedic problems, followed by scoliosis. In patients over 15 years of age, the incidence of foot deformities was 44.2% (36 feet), with 20 feet requiring surgical treatment. The most common foot deformities were cavovarus, cavus, and equinocavovarus. In 70% of the surgical cases, good correction was achieved with only one procedure. Foot surgeries in patients under the age of 8 years were usually soft tissue procedures, and bony procedures were performed primarily in patients over the age of 11 years.

CONCLUSIONS

Orthopaedic deformities are common at the initial presentation in patients with occult spinal dysraphism. A careful clinical examination with a high index of suspicion for spinal cord anomalies is indicated in all cases of spinal and lower extremity deformities. Foot deformities are very common and surgical treatment is usually successful. A thorough follow-up evaluation, including manual muscle strength testing, should be performed routinely to detect tethering of the cord in the early stages and to prevent worsening of the orthopaedic deformities.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

This was a retrospective case study. Level 4.

Congenital spinal lipomatous malformations: part I--Classification

BACKGROUND

Congenital spinal lipomatous malformations constitute a diverse group of lesions. There is considerable confusion in the literature regarding their terminology and a proper classification is long overdue. The first part of this two part report sets out a proposed classification scheme.

METHODS

On the basis of this author's experience with 80 patients with a congenital spinal lipomatous malformation treated over a 10 year period, a new classification is proposed. The proposed classification divides congenital spinal lipomatous malformations into two broad groups: 1. Lipomas without dural defect and, 2. Lipomas with dural defect. Within each group, there are several subtypes. These two broad groups differ from one another in their embryology, clinical presentation, operative findings, complications and prognosis

FINDINGS

Group I consists of Lipomas without dural defect. Included in this group are: Filum lipoma, caudal lipoma without dural defect, and intramedullary lipoma. Group II consists of lipomas with dural defect. Included in this group are: dorsal lipoma, caudal lipoma with dural defect, transitional lipoma, lipomyelocele, and lipomyelomeningocele. The definitions of the various subtypes and radiological and operative findings of all these lesions are described.

CONCLUSIONS

Congenital spinal lipomatous malformations constitute a wide spectrum of lesions ranging from relatively simple lipomas of the filum terminale to complex malformations. These lesions differ from one another in their embryology, clinical presentation, operative strategies, complications and prognosis. Failure to differentiate between the different forms of congenital spinal lipomatous malformations may lead to inaccurate assumptions regarding prognosis and inappropriate management. The proposed classification seeks to address these issues.

Surgery for spinal cord lipomas

OBJECTIVES

To analyze the results after surgery for spinal cord lipomas.

METHODS

The authors report their results of management of 63 non consecutive random children with spinal cord lipomas treated over a period from 2001 to 2005, at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India, a tertiary care neurosurgical centre.

RESULTS

There were 63 cases consisting of 32 (52%) conus lipomas, 14 (22%) filum lipomas, 14 (22%) lipomeningomyelocele (lipoMMC), 2 (2.5%) cases of lipomyelocystocele and one (1.5%) case of mixed lipoma. None of the patients who were asymptomatic before surgery deteriorated neurologically, irrespective of the type of lipoma till the last follow up. In those patients with preexisting neurological deficits, the improvement in motor, sensory and bladder abnormalities was only to an extent of 15 %, 16 % and 21 % respectively. None of the children with preexisting neurological deficit regained overall normal function. Nevertheless, the improvement in symptoms after surgery made the patients lead a better social life. Only 6 % of patients developed deterioration in neurological function after surgery, all of them occurring in patients already having pre-operative deficits.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors recommend prophylactic surgery which is safe and effective in preventing neurological deficits, irrespective of the type of lipoma. Most of the patients benefit only to some extent even after surgery, once they develop neurological dysfunction. A close long term follow up is recommended in order to detect neurological deterioration even in children operated prophylactically.

Tethered spinal cord with double spinal lipomas

Although lumbosacral lipoma is reported to occur in 4-8 of 100,000 patients, and 66% of lipomyelomeningoceles in young patients are accompanied by hypertrophic filum terminale, it is very rare to find two isolated spinal lipomas simultaneously. A 3 month-old baby girl was admitted to the hospital for a protruding, non-tender, soft, subcutaneous 2.5 cm mass of the lumbosacral area that had been present since birth. Simple radiography showed a spinal posterior arch defect from L3 to L5, and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) demonstrated two isolated spinal lipomas, a transitional type from L3 to L5, and a terminal type below S1 without dural defect. The cornus medullaris was severely tethered descending to the S1, but there was no cerebellar or brain stem herniation on the MRI. We suggest that the presence of a combined spinal lipoma should be a point for careful differentiation in an infant with spinal lipoma.

Spinal hamartoma associated with spinal dysraphism

OBJECTS

The aims of the study were (1) to review the pathological findings of spinal lipomatous masses associated with congenital spinal dysraphism and (2) to discuss the pathological diagnosis.

METHODS

The pathological records of 47 patients at our institution were reviewed, and three illustrative cases were presented.

CONCLUSION

Spinal tumorous lesions associated with spinal dysraphism have been traditionally described as lipoma since they are composed mostly of fatty tissue. However, they are different from lipomas arising in other part of the body in that they often contain various tissues of ecto- and mesodermal origin. In our study, we detected such heterotopic components in 24 out of 47 cases. Although they are also similar to teratoma, it is generally accepted that they are malformative lesions which lack neoplastic potential. We therefore should diagnose them as hamartoma rather than lipoma or teratoma.

Teratoma in human tail lipoma

We report a case of a rare congenital teratoma that developed in a lipoma attached to a remnant human tail. A male newborn baby presented with a large, 3-cm mass with an open margin, which pedunculated from a tail attached to the midline skin of the coccygeal area. Magnetic resonance images demonstrated multiple sacral spinal bifida without cord tethering, and also showed neural roots and a lipoma and teratoma with peripheral homogeneous high density and internal low density on T(2)-weighted images. Intraoperatively, we found and dissected two nerve roots from the filum terminale which extended into the mass. Pathologic examination of the mass revealed abnormal differentiation of respiratory epithelium and squamous cell metaplasia along the open margin of the mass, and mainly lipoma in the rest of the mass. We suggest that this case could support the hypothesis of transient teratomatous cells in the pathogenesis of the spina bifida with lumbosacral lipoma.

Enhancement of re-closure capacity by the intra-amniotic injection of human embryonic stem cells in surgically induced spinal open neural tube defects in chick embryos

To evaluate the re-closure promoting capacity of human embryonic stem (hES) cells injected into the amniotic cavity on spinal open neural tube defects (ONTDs) of chick embryos, neural tubes were opened at Hamburger and Hamilton stage 18 or 19 and the embryos were divided into three groups: a control group (no injection), a vehicle group, and a hES cell group (injection of 20,000 hES cells immediately after neural tube incision). On postoperative days 3, 5, and 7, ONTDs were significantly more re-closed in the hES cell group than in the other two groups. hES cells were present at the area in the process of re-closure, and covered ONTDs, but were not found in the re-closed area, suggesting indirect effects rather than cell replacement on the neural tissue.

Spinal intramedullary lipoma: report of three cases

STUDY DESIGN

Case report.

OBJECTIVE

To report three cases of spinal intramedullary lipoma seen in the last 10 years and present the clinical characteristics and surgical outcome of these cases.

METHOD

Two patients were boys aged 12 years and 7 months, respectively. The other was a female patient aged 6 months. Chief complaints were hemiparesis, back swelling and thoracic scoliosis. All patients were diagnosed with magnetic resonance images. The lesion was located in the cervico-thoracic spine (foramen magnum to T1) in one case, thoracic spine (T9-T12) with the back swelling at L2-4 level in the second, and in the third, one mass extended from C6 to T11 and the other mass was located in the L1-2 level, separately.

RESULT

All masses were removed subtotally and dysraphism was absent. Postoperatively, neurological status of the first and the second patient were unchanged, but in the third case weakness was transiently aggravated.

CONCLUSION

Intramedullary lipoma is a rare spinal lesion and multiple intramedullary lipoma is extremely rare. Treatment principle is surgical decompression before symptom progression. Laminoplastic laminotomy is an appropriate approach for decompression of an intramedullary lipoma.

Skin graft on the surgically induced spinal open neural tube defects does not induce lipomatous malformation but enhances re-closure to the normal state in chick embryos

To determine the effect of skin allograft on open neural tube defects (ONTDs), the neural tube was incised open using Hamburger and Hamilton stage 18 or 19 chick embryos for a length of six somites. Embryos were divided into two groups: graft and control (with and without skin allograft). On postoperative day 5, closure of ONTDs was more frequent in the graft group than in the control group (9/15 versus 0/15), and healing was nearly complete. However, typical lipomatous features were not observed. These results suggest that simple mechanical attachment of skin allograft on ONTDs does not lead to lipomatous malformation in chick embryos. On the other hand, our results support a potential role of skin allograft in the management of prenatal spinal ONTDs.