Efficacy and spatial distribution of ultrasound-mediated clot lysis in the absence of thrombolytics

Beyond silence: evolving ultrasound strategies in the battle against cardiovascular thrombotic challenges

Cardiovascular thrombotic events have long been a perplexing factor in clinical settings, influencing patient prognoses significantly. Ultrasound-mediated acoustic therapy, an innovative thrombolytic treatment method known for its high efficiency, non-invasiveness, safety, and convenience, has demonstrated promising potential for clinical applications and has gradually become a focal point in cardiovascular thrombotic disease research. The current challenge lies in the technical complexities of preparing ultrasound-responsive carriers with thrombus-targeting capabilities and high thrombolytic efficiency. Additionally, optimizing the corresponding acoustic treatment mode is crucial to markedly enhance the thrombolytic effectiveness of ultrasound-mediated acoustic therapy. In light of the current status, this article provides a comprehensive review of the research progress in innovative ultrasound-mediated acoustic therapy for cardiovascular thrombotic diseases. It explores the impact of technical methods, therapeutic mechanisms, and influencing factors on the thrombolytic efficiency and clinical potential of ultrasound-mediated acoustic therapy. The review places particular emphasis on identifying solutions and key considerations in addressing the challenges associated with this cutting-edge therapeutic approach.

Ultrasound Trigger Ce-Based MOF Nanoenzyme For Efficient Thrombolytic Therapy

The inflammatory damage caused by thrombus formation and dissolution can increase the risk of thrombotic complications on top of cell death and organ dysfunction caused by thrombus itself. Therefore, a rapid and precise thrombolytic therapy strategy is in urgent need to effectively dissolve thrombus and resist oxidation simultaneously. In this study, Ce-UiO-66, a cerium-based metal-organic framework (Ce-MOF) with reactive oxygen species (ROS) scavenging properties, encapsulated by low-immunogenic mesenchymal stem cell membrane with inflammation-targeting properties, is used to construct a targeted nanomedicine Ce-UiO-CM. Ce-UiO-CM is applied in combination with external ultrasound stimulation for thrombolytic therapy in rat femoral artery. Ce-UiO-66 has abundant Ce (III)/Ce (IV) coupling sites that react with hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) to produce oxygen, exhibiting catalase (CAT) activity. The multi-cavity structure of Ce-UiO-66 can generate electron holes, and its pore channels can act as micro-reactors to further enhance its ROS scavenging capacity. Additionally, the porous structure of Ce-UiO-66 and the oxygen produced by its reaction with H2O2 may enhance the cavitation effects of ultrasound, thereby improving thrombolysis efficacy.

Sonothrombolysis: State-of-the-Art and Potential Applications in Children

In recent years, advances in ultrasound therapeutics have been implemented into treatment algorithms for the adult population; however, the use of therapeutic ultrasound in the pediatric population still needs to be further elucidated. In order to better characterize the utilization and practicality of sonothrombolysis in the juvenile population, the authors conducted a literature review of current pediatric research in therapeutic ultrasound. The PubMed database was used to search for all clinical and preclinical studies detailing the use and applications of sonothrombolysis, with a focus on the pediatric population. As illustrated by various review articles, case studies, and original research, sonothrombolysis demonstrates efficacy and safety in clot dissolution in vitro and in animal studies, particularly when combined with microbubbles, with potential applications in conditions such as deep venous thrombosis, peripheral vascular disease, ischemic stroke, myocardial infarction, and pulmonary embolism. Although there is limited literature on the use of therapeutic ultrasound in children, mainly due to the lower prevalence of thrombotic events, sonothrombolysis shows potential as a noninvasive thrombolytic treatment. However, more pediatric sonothrombolysis research needs to be conducted to quantify the safety and ethical considerations specific to this vulnerable population.

Low-Intensity Ultrasound Reduces Brain Infarct Size by Upregulating Phosphorylated Endothelial Nitric Oxide in Mouse Model of Middle Cerebral Artery Occlusion

OBJECTIVE

There have been attempts to use therapeutic ultrasound (US) for the treatment of both experimental and clinical stroke. We hypothesized that low-intensity US has direct beneficial effects on the brain independent of cerebral blood flow (CBF) during middle cerebral artery occlusion (MCAO).

METHODS

Three groups of mice were studied. Group I included 84 mice with MCAO undergoing US treatment/no treatment at two US frequencies (0.25 and 1.05 MHz) with three different acoustic pressures at each frequency in which infarct size (IS) was measured 24 h later. Group II included 11 mice undergoing treatment based on best US results from group I animals in which the IS/risk area (RA) ratio was measured 24 h later. Group III included 38 normal mice undergoing US treatment/no treatment for assessment of CBF, tissue metabolite and protein expression and histopathology.

DISCUSSION

Ultrasound at both frequencies and most acoustic pressures resulted in reduction in IS in group I animals, with the best results obtained with 0.25 MHz at 2.0 MPa: IS was reduced 4-fold in the cerebral cortex, 1.5-fold in the caudate putamen and 3.5-fold in the cerebral hemisphere compared with control. US application in group III animals elicited only a marginal increase in CBF despite a 2.6-fold increase in phosphorylated endothelial nitric oxide synthase (p-eNOS)-S1177 and a corresponding decrease in p-eNOS-T494. Histopathology revealed no evidence of hemorrhage, inflammation or necrosis.

CONCLUSION

Low-intensity US at specific frequencies and acoustic pressures results in marked neuroprotection in a mouse model of stroke by modulation of p-eNOS independent of its effect on CBF.

Effect of Recombinant Tissue Plasminogen Activator and 120-kHz Ultrasound on Porcine Intracranial Thrombus Density

Surgical intervention for the treatment of intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH) has been limited by inadequate lysis of the target thrombus. Adjuvant transcranial ultrasound exposure is hypothesized to improve thrombolysis, expedite hematoma evacuation and improve clinical outcomes. A juvenile porcine intracerebral hemorrhage model was established by direct infusion of autologous blood into the porcine white matter. Thrombi were either not treated (sham) or treated with recombinant tissue plasminogen activator alone (rt-PA only) or in combination with pulsed transcranial 120-kHz ultrasound (sonothrombolysis). After treatment, pigs were euthanized, the heads frozen and sectioned and the thrombi extracted. D-Dimer and thrombus density assays were used to assess degree of lysis. Both porcine and human D-dimer assays tested did not have sufficient sensitivity to detect porcine D-dimer. Thrombi treated with rt-PA with or without 120-kHz ultrasound had a significantly lower density compared with sham-treated thrombi. No enhancement of rt-PA-mediated thrombolysis was noted with the addition of 120-kHz ultrasound (sonothrombolysis). The thrombus density assay revealed thrombolytic efficacy caused by rt-PA in an in vivo juvenile porcine model of intracerebral hemorrhage. Transcranial sonothrombolysis did not enhance rt-PA-induced thrombolysis, likely because of the lack of exogenous cavitation nuclei.

Enhanced thrombolysis by endovascular low-frequency ultrasound with bifunctional microbubbles in venous thrombosis: in vitro and in vivo study

There is a need to improve the efficacy and safety of endovascular techniques in venous thrombotic diseases, and microbubble enhanced sonothrombolysis is a promising approach. However, whether endovascular low-frequency ultrasound (LFUS) can be utilized in microbubble enhanced sonothrombolysis is unclear. Here, we present a catheter-based thrombolytic system that combines unfocused low-frequency low-intensity ultrasound with novel fibrin-targeted drug-loaded bifunctional microbubbles. We develop an in vitro flow model and an in vivo rabbit inferior vena cava (IVC) thrombosis model to evaluate the safety and efficacy of the thrombolytic system. The results indicate that microbubble enhanced sonothrombolysis with endovascular LFUS treatment for 30 min is equally effective compared to pure pharmacologic treatment. Furthermore, the thrombolytic efficacy of this system is safely and substantially improved by the introduction of a fibrin-targeted drug-loaded bifunctional microbubble with a reduction of the fibrinolytic agent dosage by 60%. The microbubble enhanced endovascular LFUS sonothrombolysis system with excellent thrombolytic efficacy may serve as a new therapeutic approach for venous thrombotic diseases.

Advances in Biological Application of and Research on Low-Frequency Ultrasound

In recent years, the in-depth study of low-frequency sonophoresis (LFS) has greatly elucidated its biological effects in various therapeutic applications, including drug delivery, enhanced healing, thrombolytic technology, anti-inflammatory effects and tumor treatment. Specifically, numerous studies have reported its use in drug delivery and synergistic antitumor activity, indicating a new treatment direction for cancer. However, there are significant gaps in the understanding of LFS in terms of frequency and sound intensity safety; these issues are becoming increasingly important in understanding the biological effects of LFS ultrasound. This article reviews the treatment mechanism and current applications of LFS technology and discusses and summarizes its safety and application prospects.

Ultrasound and Magnetic Responsive Drug Delivery Systems for Cardiovascular Application

With the increasing insight into molecular mechanisms of cardiovascular disease, a promising solution involves directly delivering genes, cells, and chemicals to the infarcted myocardium or impaired endothelium. However, the limited delivery efficiency after administration fails to reach the therapeutic dose and the adverse off-target effect even causes serious safety concerns. Controlled drug release via external stimuli seems to be a promising method to overcome the drawbacks of conventional drug delivery systems (DDSs). Microbubbles and magnetic nanoparticles responding to ultrasound and magnetic fields respectively have been developed as an important component of novel DDSs. In particular, several attempts have also been made for the design and fabrication of dual-responsive DDS. This review presents the recent advances in the ultrasound and magnetic fields responsive DDSs in cardiovascular application, followed by their current problems and future reformation.

Quantification of microbubble-induced sonothrombolysis in an ex vivo non-human primate model

BACKGROUND

In vitro studies with ultrasound (US) and microbubbles (MB) have reported that sono-thrombolysis can be achieved at high peak rarefactional acoustic pressure amplitudes (PRAPAs) using 0.25 and 1.05 MHz US frequencies.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of the current study was to determine if these parameters work on an ex vivo physiological model of thrombosis.

METHODS

A thrombogenic device was placed in an ex vivo chronic arteriovenous shunt in juvenile baboons. Platelet accumulation was measured by dynamic imaging of the device and the 10 cm thrombus tail with 111 In-labeled platelets. After 15 minutes of thrombus formation, treatment with either low-dose recombinant tissue plasminogen activator (rtPA) or low-dose rtPA + MB+US was performed for 20 minutes. Four US settings at 0.25% duty cycle were used: 0.25 MHz at PRAPAs of 1.20 and 2.20 MPa, and 1.05 MHz at 1.75 and 4.75 MPa.

RESULTS

Platelet accumulation was not inhibited by low-dose rtPA or MB with US alone. Platelet accumulation was significantly reduced with 0.25 MHz US at 2.20 PRAPA (P < .001) and with 1.05 MHz at 1.75 MPa and 4.75 MPa (P < .05) when used with MB and low-dose rtPA. Although this approach prevented platelet accumulation it did not cause thrombolysis on the device.

CONCLUSIONS

rtPA + MB + US (0.25 and 1.05 MHz) resulted in inhibition of platelet accumulation on the thrombogenic device when moderately high PRAPAs (≥1.75 MPa) were used. These results taken in context with lytic effects of US on myocardial microthrombi and direct effect on myocardial blood flow and function provide direction for the use of therapeutic US in acute coronary syndromes.

Regional and Conducted Vascular Effects of Endovascular Ultrasound Catheters

Intra-vascular ultrasound catheters are used clinically to facilitate clot lysis. We hypothesized that these devices could also directly lower microvascular resistance and increase tissue perfusion through established shear-dependent pathways. In mice, either the proximal hind-limb muscles or the upstream femoral artery alone was exposed to an endovascular ultrasound catheter (2.3 MHz, 0.5-1.1 MPa) for 10 min. Quantitative microvascular perfusion imaging in the hind limbs exposed to the endovascular ultrasound system exhibited a more-than-twofold increase in flow (p < 0.01) compared with the contralateral control limb after exposure of either the muscle or the femoral artery alone. Using an in vivo optical imaging reporting system, an eight- to ninefold increase in tissue adenosine triphosphate (ATP) was detected in the region of insonification (p = 0.006). Ultrasound was found to produce an immediate release of ATP from ex vivo erythrocytes (p = 0.03). In situ electrochemical sensing revealed an immediate increase in nitric oxide with initiation of ultrasound which returned to baseline within 5 min of termination, as well as ultrasound-triggered nitric oxide (NO) release from erythrocytes. These data indicate that non-cavitating ultrasound produced by endovascular catheters can reduce vascular resistance and increase flow through recognized shear-dependent vasodilator pathways involving purinergic signaling and NO.

Therapeutic Ultrasound Improves Myocardial Blood Flow and Reduces Infarct Size in a Canine Model of Coronary Microthromboembolism

BACKGROUND

Therapeutic ultrasound (TUS) has been used to lyse infarct-related coronary artery thrombus. There has been no study examining the effect of TUS specifically on myocardial microthromboemboli seen in acute myocardial infarction and acute coronary syndromes. The aim of this study was to test the hypothesis that TUS improves myocardial blood flow (MBF) and reduces infarct size (IS) in this situation by dissolving myocardial microthrombi.

METHODS

An open-chest canine model of myocardial microthromboembolism was created by disrupting a thrombus in the left anterior descending coronary artery, and 1.05- and 0.25-MHz TUS (n = 7 each) delivered epicardially for 30 min was compared with control (n = 6). MBF and IS (as a percentage of left anterior descending coronary artery perfusion bed size) were measured 60 min after treatment. In addition, immunohistochemistry was performed to assess microthrombi, and histopathology was performed to define inflammation.

RESULTS

Transmural, epicardial, and endocardial myocardial blood volume and MBF (measured using myocardial contrast echocardiography) and percentage wall thickening were significantly higher 60 min after receiving TUS compared with control. The ratio of IS to left anterior descending coronary artery perfusion bed size was significantly smaller (P = .03) in the 1.05-MHz TUS group (0.14 ± 0.04) compared with the control (0.31 ± 0.06, P = .04) and 0.25-MHz (0.36 ± 0.08) groups. MBF versus percentage wall thickening exhibited a linear relation (r = 0.65) in the control and 1.05-MHz TUS groups but not in the 0.25-MHz TUS group (r = 0.29). The presence of myocardial microemboli in vessels >10 μm in diameter was significantly reduced in the 1.05-MHz TUS group compared with the other two groups. The distribution and intensity of inflammation was higher in the 0.25-MHz TUS group compared with the other groups.

CONCLUSIONS

TUS at 1.05 MHz is effective in restoring myocardial blood volume and MBF, thus reducing IS by clearing the microcirculation of microthrombi. IS reduction is not seen at 0.25 MHz, despite improvement in MBF, which may be related to the increased inflammation noted at this frequency. Because both acute myocardial infarction and acute coronary syndromes are associated with microthromboembolism, these results suggest that TUS could have a potential adjunctive role in the treatment of both conditions.

Augmentation of Tissue Perfusion in Patients With Peripheral Artery Disease Using Microbubble Cavitation

OBJECTIVES

The authors investigated ideal acoustic conditions on a clinical scanner custom-programmed for ultrasound (US) cavitation-mediated flow augmentation in preclinical models. We then applied these conditions in a first-in-human study to test the hypothesis that contrast US can increase limb perfusion in normal subjects and patients with peripheral artery disease (PAD).

BACKGROUND

US-induced cavitation of microbubble contrast agents augments tissue perfusion by convective shear and secondary purinergic signaling that mediates release of endogenous vasodilators.

METHODS

In mice, unilateral exposure of the proximal hindlimb to therapeutic US (1.3 MHz, mechanical index 1.3) was performed for 10 min after intravenous injection of lipid microbubbles. US varied according to line density (17, 37, 65 lines) and pulse duration. Microvascular perfusion was evaluated by US perfusion imaging, and in vivo adenosine triphosphate (ATP) release was assessed using in vivo optical imaging. Optimal parameters were then used in healthy volunteers and patients with PAD where calf US alone or in combination with intravenous microbubble contrast infusion was performed for 10 min.

RESULTS

In mice, flow was augmented in the US-exposed limb for all acoustic conditions. Only at the lowest line density was there a stepwise increase in perfusion for longer (40-cycle) versus shorter (5-cycle) pulse duration. For higher line densities, blood flow consistently increased by 3-fold to 4-fold in the US-exposed limb irrespective of pulse duration. High line density and long pulse duration resulted in the greatest release of ATP in the cavitation zone. Application of these optimized conditions in humans together with intravenous contrast increased calf muscle blood flow by >2-fold in both healthy subjects and patients with PAD, whereas US alone had no effect.

CONCLUSIONS

US of microbubbles when using optimized acoustic environments can increase perfusion in limb skeletal muscle, raising the possibility of a therapy for patients with PAD. (Augmentation of Limb Perfusion With Contrast Ultrasound; NCT03195556).

Therapeutic Ultrasound Increases Myocardial Blood Flow in Ischemic Myocardium and Cardiac Endothelial Cells: Results of In Vivo and In Vitro Experiments

BACKGROUND

Therapeutic ultrasound can reduce infarct size in a model of coronary thrombosis even when sonothrombolysis is ineffective. The aim of this study was to test the hypothesis that ultrasound-induced cardioprotection is mediated by molecules released from the vascular endothelium that increase myocardial blood flow (MBF) and also have direct tissue-salvaging effects.

METHODS

In vivo and in vitro experiments were performed using a 1.05-MHz transducer. For the in vivo experiments 10 control and 10 ultrasound-treated dogs undergoing occlusion of the left anterior descending coronary artery were studied. MBF was measured using myocardial contrast echocardiography. For the in vitro experiments, primary mouse cardiac endothelial cells were exposed to ultrasound at baseline or following oxygen-glucose deprivation and endothelial nitric oxide synthase phosphorylation as well as adenosine and the eicosanoids epoxyeicosatrienoic acids, dihydroxyeicosatrienoic acids, and hydroxyl-eicosatetraenoic acids were measured.

RESULTS

In vivo, ultrasound treatment caused higher MBF (20 ± 10 vs 10 ± 8, P = .03) and higher wall thickening (3 ± 3% vs 1 ± 0.4%, P = .01) in the collateral-derived border zone compared with control. Epicardial MBF in the left anterior descending coronary artery bed also tended to be higher (17 ± 17 vs 5 ± 4, P = .05) in ultrasound-treated versus control animals; however, endocardial MBF in this region was similar to that in controls (13 ± 14 vs 14 ± 7). In vitro, phosphorylated endothelial nitric oxide synthase and adenosine increased (by 129 ± 11% and 286 ± 63%, respectively, P < .01) with ultrasound compared with unstimulated cells. Similar results were obtained with epoxyeicosatrienoic acids. After oxygen-glucose deprivation, phosphorylated endothelial nitric oxide synthase decreased and was restored with application of ultrasound. Similar changes were noted with epoxyeicosatrienoic acids. Cell viability decreased with oxygen-glucose deprivation and returned to near baseline with ultrasound.

CONCLUSIONS

Ultrasound increases MBF in ischemic tissue in vivo. This effect is likely mediated by the release of a plethora of coronary vasodilators during ultrasound treatment that also have direct tissue-salvaging effects. Therapeutic ultrasound, therefore, has potential for treatment of acute and chronic myocardial ischemia independent of its effect on thrombolysis.

Spatially Specific Liposomal Cancer Therapy Triggered by Clinical External Sources of Energy

This review explores the use of energy sources, including ultrasound, magnetic fields, and external beam radiation, to trigger the delivery of drugs from liposomes in a tumor in a spatially-specific manner. Each section explores the mechanism(s) of drug release that can be achieved using liposomes in conjunction with the external trigger. Subsequently, the treatment's formulation factors are discussed, highlighting the parameters of both the therapy and the medical device. Additionally, the pre-clinical and clinical trials of each triggered release method are explored. Lastly, the advantages and disadvantages, as well as the feasibility and future outlook of each triggered release method, are discussed.

Recent strategies on targeted delivery of thrombolytics

Thrombus formed in blood vessel is a progressive process, which would lead to life-threatening thrombotic diseases such as ischemic stroke. Unlike other diseases, the recognition of thrombus is usually in the late stage where blood vessels are largely blocked. So acute thrombotic diseases have a narrow therapeutic window, and remain leading causes of morbidity and mortality, whereas current thrombolysis therapy has limited therapeutic effects and bleeding complications. Thrombolytic agents in unwanted sites would cause hemorrhage due to the activation of plasminogen. Moreover, untargeted thrombolysis therapy require large amounts of thrombolytic agents, which in return would enhance hemorrhage risk. To improve the efficiency while minimizing the adverse effects of traditional thrombolysis therapy, novel drug delivery systems have been investigated. Various targeting strategies including ultrasound and magnetic field directed targeting, and specific binding, have been designed to deliver thrombolytic drugs to the thrombotic sites. These strategies demonstrate promising results in reducing bleeding risk as well as allowing less dosage of thrombolytic drugs with lowered clot lysis time. In this review, we discuss recent progress on targeted delivery of thrombolytics, and summarize treatment advantages and shortcomings, potentially helping to further promote the development of targeted thrombolysis.

Stable cavitation using acoustic phase-change dodecafluoropentane nanoparticles for coronary micro-circulation thrombolysis

BACKGROUND

The thrombolysis in micro-circulation after acute myocardial infarction has been an unsolved issue, as elimination effect of acute thrombolysis and primary intervention were unsatisfied. Stable cavitation using acoustic phase-change nanoparticles may have potential for thrombolysis. Therefore, we sought to investigate a novel treatment method with dodecafluoropentane (DDFP) nanoparticles for rapid and effective thrombolysis in an in-vitro artificial vascular system, as a mimicking preparation of coronary circulation.

METHODS

To simulate thrombus embolism in coronary circulation, an in-vitro artificial vascular system was established with cavitation effect using DDFP nanoparticles. For PBS blank control (group A), SonoVue microbubbles (group B) and DDFP nanoparticles (group C), the durations for cavitation effect were recorded and the thrombolysis efficiency with low intensity focused ultrasound irradiation in the in-vitro vascular system were analyzed with weight loss and pathological changes of thrombus before and after thrombolysis.

RESULTS

The optimal conditions for acoustic cavitation effect were power of 6 W for 20 min by ultrasound irradiation at 37 °C. The weight loss and weight loss rates of thrombus in group C (189.4 ± 30.2 mg and 34.2 ± 5.7%) were higher than those in group A (30.2 ± 16.0 mg and 5.2 ± 2.1%) and group B (84.0 ± 20.4 mg and 14.6 ± 1.5%) (P < 0.01, all). The duration for cavitation effect in group C (32.8 ± 3.9 min) was also longer than those in group A (0.0 ± 0.0 min) and group B (5.3 ± 0.3 min) (P < 0.01, all).

CONCLUSIONS

By stable and sustaining cavitation in targeted area, DDFP nanoparticles with ultrasound irradiation have significantly increased the thrombolysis efficiency, which has provided a powerful experimental foundation for potential coronary thrombolysis.