Mechanical performance of a dental composite: probabilistic failure prediction

Effect of blood contamination on the compressive strength of three calcium silicate-based cements

The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of human blood exposure on the compressive strength of various calcium silicate-based cements. Two hundred and eighty-eight customised cylindrical moulds were randomly divided into three groups according to material used: ProRoot MTA, Biodentine or CEM cement (n = 96). Each group was divided into two subgroups according to exposure conditions: PBS or blood. Then, the compressive strength of the specimens was measured after 6 h, 24 h, 72 h and 7 days. The compressive strength of CEM cement could not be measured after 6 and 24‏ h regardless of the exposure conditions nor could the compressive strength of 6 h blood-exposed ProRoot MTA. The compressive strength of blood-exposed ProRoot MTA was only significantly lower after 6 h, but no difference was seen at other time intervals. Blood exposed did adversely affected the compressive strength of Biodentine. The compressive strength of all groups significantly increased over time (P < 0.005).

Experimental and computational approach for evaluating the mechanical characteristics of dental composite resins with various filler sizes

This study aimed to investigate the influence of particle size of fillers on flexural properties of dental composite resins by laboratory testing with computational analysis validation. Four kinds of silica fillers with mean particle sizes of 3.3, 4.3, 7.9, and 15.5 microm were used. Filler content was kept constant at 70 mass% (or 53.8 vol.%). The three-point bending test was performed with a constant loading speed of 1.0mm/min, and a span length of 20mm using an Instron machine, in order to measure flexural strength and modulus of composite resins with various particle sizes. Test specimens were 2-mm wide, 2-mm thick, and 25-mm long rectangular bars. Furthermore, a numerical simulation using three-dimensional finite element (FE) analysis was performed to investigate stress distribution in composite resins under loading. As a result, flexural strength decreased with increasing particle size of the filler of the composite resins (p<0.05). On the other hand, there was no significant difference in Young's modulus among composite resins with various filler sizes (p>0.05). Moreover, FE analysis indicated that stress concentration increased with increasing particle size in agreement with experimental results of flexural strength. In conclusion, within the limitations of this investigation, we confirmed that flexural strength of composite resins decreased with increasing filler particle size. In addition, FE analysis was effective for evaluating stress distributions of dental composite resins with various filler sizes.

Effect of filler content on bending properties of dental composites: Numerical simulation with the use of the finite-element method

The purpose of this work is to investigate the influence of filler content on the bending properties of dental composites by use of the finite-element method (FEM). The proposed numerical model was constructed from isotropic shell elements representing silica filler, and isotropic beam elements representing the remaining matrix resin. The proposed model was applied to failure analysis under three-point bending conditions. The validity of applying the numerical model to the failure progression analysis of composites was checked through comparison with experimental results. The results show that, in both the analytical and experimental results, the bending properties, such as maximum bending stress and bending modulus, increase with filler content. Also, the proposed method of failure progression analysis could better simulate the failure process of composites under three-point bending conditions. In addition, close agreement between the analytical and experimental results was confirmed. The above results indicate that the proposed numerical model is effective for evaluating the bending properties of dental filler composites of any content range.

Numerical failure analysis of glass-fiber-reinforced composites

The purpose of this work was to propose a new numerical model for glass-fiber-reinforced composites. The proposed numerical model was constructed with orthotropic shell, isotropic shell, and beam elements representing glass fiber cloth, silica filler, and the remaining matrix resin, respectively. The proposed model was applied to failure analysis under three-point bending conditions. The validity of the numerical model was checked through comparisons with experimental results. Four types of specimens were used: composite resin, and composite resin with neutral, upper, and lower glass-fiber cloth reinforcement insertions. For all types, close agreement between the analytical and experimental results was confirmed. This indicates that the proposed numerical model is effective for evaluating the mechanical behaviors of glass-fiber-reinforced composites.

Fatigue of restorative materials

Failure due to fatigue manifests itself in dental prostheses and restorations as wear, fractured margins, delaminated coatings, and bulk fracture. Mechanisms responsible for fatigue-induced failure depend on material ductility: Brittle materials are susceptible to catastrophic failure, while ductile materials utilize their plasticity to reduce stress concentrations at the crack tip. Because of the expense associated with the replacement of failed restorations, there is a strong desire on the part of basic scientists and clinicians to evaluate the resistance of materials to fatigue in laboratory tests. Test variables include fatigue-loading mode and test environment, such as soaking in water. The outcome variable is typically fracture strength, and these data typically fit the Weibull distribution. Analysis of fatigue data permits predictive inferences to be made concerning the survival of structures fabricated from restorative materials under specified loading conditions. Although many dental-restorative materials are routinely evaluated, only limited use has been made of fatigue data collected in vitro: Wear of materials and the survival of porcelain restorations has been modeled by both fracture mechanics and probabilistic approaches. A need still exists for a clinical failure database and for the development of valid test methods for the evaluation of composite materials.

Weibull models of fracture strengths and fatigue behavior of dental resins in flexure and shear

In estimating lifetimes of dental restorative materials, it is useful to have available data on the fatigue behavior of these materials. Current efforts at estimation include several untested assumptions related to the equivalence of flaw distributions sampled by shear, tensile, and compressive stresses. Environmental influences on material properties are not accounted for, and it is unclear if fatigue limits exist. In this study, the shear and flexural strengths of three resins used as matrices in dental restorative composite materials were characterized by Weibull parameters. It was found that shear strengths were lower than flexural strengths, liquid sorption had a profound effect on characteristic strengths, and the Weibull shape parameter obtained from shear data differed for some materials from that obtained in flexure. In shear and flexural fatigue, a power law relationship applied for up to 250,000 cycles; no fatigue limits were found, and the data thus imply only one flaw population is responsible for failure. Again, liquid sorption adversely affected strength levels in most materials (decreasing shear strengths and flexural strengths by factors of 2-3) and to a greater extent than did the degree of cure or material chemistry.

Crack propagation directions in unfilled resins

Posterior composite restorative materials undergo accelerated wear in the occlusal contact area, primarily through a fatigue mechanism. To facilitate the timely development of new and improved materials, a predictive wear model is desirable. The objective of this study was to develop a finite element model enabling investigators to predict crack propagation directions in resins used as the matrix material in composites, and to verify these predictions by observing cracks formed during the pin-on-disc wear of a 60:40 BISGMA:TEGDMA resin and an EBPADMA resin. Laser confocal scanning microscopy was used to measure crack locations. Finite element studies were done by means of ABAQUS software, modeling a cylinder sliding on a material with pre-existing surface-breaking cracks. Variables included modulus, cylinder/material friction coefficient, crack face friction, and yield behavior. Experimental results were surprising, since most crack directions were opposite previously published observations. The majority of surface cracks, though initially orthogonal to the surface, changed direction to run 20 to 30 degrees from the horizontal in the direction of indenter movement. Finite element modeling established the importance of subsurface shear stresses, since calculations provided evidence that cracks propagate in the direction of maximum K(II)(theta), in the same direction as the motion of the indenter, and at an angle of approximately 20 degrees. These findings provide the foundation for a predictive model of sliding wear in unfilled glassy resins.

The influence of simulated clinical handling on the flexural and compressive strength of posterior composite restorative materials

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to investigate the influence of clinical handling on the flexural and compressive strengths of two commercially available posterior composites.

METHODS

Since the manufacturing of test specimens in a truly clinical situation presents many problems, an in vitro model was developed, consisting of a phantom-head set-up in a clinical operatory. Two composite materials, recommended for use in posterior teeth, were used: P50 APC (3M Dental Products) and Herculite XRV (Kerr, Dental Manufacturing). Beam specimens for 3-point bending tests of both materials and cylindrical specimens for compression test of P50 were made both under ideal laboratory circumstances and under simulated clinical circumstances.

RESULTS

The difference in mean flexural strength between laboratory prepared and the quasi-clinically prepared specimens was highly significant for both the specimens handled in a clinical manner was 15% of the flexural strength of the P50 specimens made under laboratory conditions, and the difference for Herculite XRV was 29%. No difference in compressive strength could be shown between the laboratory-fabricated and the quasi-clinically made specimens of P50.

SIGNIFICANCE

The relative flexural strength of composite materials in a clinical situation may differ significantly from that predicted from mechanical properties measured in vitro.