Influence on Response to Therapy and Overall Survival of Mediastinal Involvement by Hodgkin's Disease

The role of radiation therapy in Hodgkin disease: experience and controversy. The 54th annual Janeway Lecture: 1989

BACKGROUND

Beginning in 1970, a series of patients with Hodgkin disease were treated at the University of Minnesota, after staging laparotomy, with radiation therapy (RT) for Stage I, II, and IIIA Hodgkin disease. This report is an analysis of the results of the treatment and of treatment modifications.

METHODS

From 1970 to 1974, all patients were treated with standard RT. In 1975, an analysis of these patients indicated that patients with large mediastinal mass (LMM) and patients with Stage IIIA spleen-positive (IIIAS+) disease had a higher recurrence rates than patients without these factors. Subsequently, a schema of radical radiation therapy (RRT) was devised, which included low-dose lung RT for patients with LMM and low-dose liver RT for patients with IIIAS+ disease.

RESULTS

Analysis of the results of the two treatments indicates that the use of low-dose lung RT in patients with LMM and low-dose liver RT in patients with IIIAS+ Hodgkin disease produced survival and recurrence-free survival results equivalent to those achieved by use of combined modality treatment (CMT) or chemotherapy (CT) alone.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of RT with whole lung and liver irradiation for patients with LMM and IIIAS+ Hodgkin disease, respectively, produces results that are equivalent to those of CMT or CT alone with the advantage of a decreased incidence of second malignant neoplasms. In addition, patients who do not respond to initial RT have a greater chance of being saved with chemotherapy than do patients initially treated with CMT of being saved with RT. The authors suggest that radical RT is the treatment of choice for patients with LMM and/or IIIAS+ Hodgkin disease.

Therapeutic implications of mediastinal involvement in advanced Hodgkin's disease

47 patients with advanced Hodgkin's disease (stage IIIB or IV) and mediastinal involvement, treated during the period 1969-78 and followed till death or from 36 to 126 months after initiation of therapy, were analysed. All 47 patients had received combination chemotherapy (MOPP or equivalent regimens). 20 had also received additional radiotherapy to mediastinum (and in some cases to other involved areas as well). The 2 treatment groups did not differ significantly with regard to the more important prognostic factors. Both in the case of stages IV and IIIB patients in the group treated with combination chemotherapy alone, remissions were significantly more often only partial, the frequency of relapse and of treatment failure was significantly higher, and relapse-free survival was significantly poorer than in the group treated with additional radiotherapy. Furthermore, survival from Hodgkin's disease and crude survival including all causes of death were significantly better for patients treated with combination chemotherapy plus mediastinal irradiation. Consequently, for patients with advanced Hodgkin's disease and mediastinal involvement a combined approach including radiotherapy as well as combination chemotherapy would seem advisable.