Rebuttal to Ajioka and Kushner

Iron homeostasis

Iron is needed by all mammalian cells but is toxic in excess. Specialized transport mechanisms conduct iron across cellular membranes. These are regulated to ensure homeostasis both systemically in living organisms and within individual cells. Over the past decade, major advances have been made in identifying and characterizing the proteins involved in the transport, handling, and homeostatic regulation of iron. Molecular understanding of these processes has provided important insights into the pathophysiology of human iron disorders.

Inherited iron loading: genetic testing in diagnosis and management

Elucidation of the molecular pathways of iron transport through cells and its control is leading to an understanding of genetic iron loading conditions. The general phenotype of haemochromatosis is iron accumulation in liver parenchymal cells, a raised serum transferrin saturation and ferritin concentration. Four types have been identified: type 1 is the common form and is an autosomal recessive disorder of low penetrance strongly associated with mutations in the HFE gene on chromosome 6(p21.3); type 2 (juvenile haemochromatosis) is autosomal recessive, of high penetrance with causative mutations identified in the HFE2 gene on chromosome 1 (q21) and the HAMP gene on chromosome 19 (q13); type 3 is also autosomal recessive with mutations in the TfR2 gene on chromosome 3 (7q22); type 4 is an autosomal dominant condition with heterozygous mutations in the ferroportin 1 gene. In type 4, iron accumulates in both parenchymal and reticuloendothelial cells and the transferrin saturation may be normal. There are also inherited neurodegenerative conditions associated with iron accumulation. The current research challenges include understanding the central role of the HAMP gene (hepcidin) in controlling iron absorption and the reasons for the variable penetrance in HFE type 1.

Clinical expression of haemochromatosis in Irish C282Y homozygotes identified through family screening

BACKGROUND

In Ireland, the homozygote frequency of the C282Y mutation in the HFE gene is 1/83. The biochemical expression of this mutation is high in haemochromatosis (HH) individuals identified through family screening, but the clinical expression of the mutation in Irish HH subjects to date has not been investigated fully.

OBJECTIVES

To determine the clinical, biochemical and histological penetrance of the C282Y mutation in Irish C282Y homozygotes identified through family screening.

METHOD

Two hundred and nine C282Y homozygous individuals comprising of 172 first-degree relatives, 31 second-degree relatives and four unrelated individuals were identified following HFE mutation analysis of 167 families. The following variables were analysed: age at identification, gender, fasting transferrin saturation, fasting serum ferritin, liver enzymes, clinical symptomatology, liver histopathology and histochemical iron staining.

RESULTS

An elevated transferrin saturation in combination with an elevated ferritin was present in 43.4% of males and 23.3% of females. Abnormal liver enzymes were found in 32.3% of males. Diabetes, a haemochromatosis-specific association, was noted in 2.8% of males. Of those individuals requiring liver histopathology evaluation, 38% had moderate-to-severe iron staining, and 42% had fibrosis; 2.8% of the biopsied cohort had cirrhosis. Thus, HH cirrhotics were identified in less than 1% of the screened population.

CONCLUSION

Although the homozygote frequency in Ireland is very high, the prevalence of advanced liver disease was less than 1% of the family members screened. Nevertheless, 42% of biopsied patients had histological evidence of iron overload-related architectural change and 2.8% had cirrhosis. This cohort of young people had previously unrecognized biochemical iron overload and histopathological change. This emphasizes the importance and value of both genetic and biochemical screening in first-degree relatives of identified homozygotes.

Hemochromatosis subjects as allogeneic blood donors: a prospective study

BACKGROUND

Persons with hemochromatosis constitute a plentiful and willing source of blood for transfusion. A program was established and evaluated for treating persons with hemochromatosis in a donor center and making their blood available for transfusion.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Phlebotomy therapy was performed free of charge regardless of whether subjects met criteria for allogeneic donation. A Hb level of 12.5 g per dL was used as the threshold for performing phlebotomy, and decreases in the MCV were used to guide the endpoints of therapy.

RESULTS

A total of 130 subjects were consecutively enrolled: 74 percent were homozygous for the C282Y mutation in the HFE gene, 76 percent met eligibility criteria for allogeneic donation, and 55 percent were previous blood donors. A median of 20 weekly or biweekly phlebotomies (range, 7-99) were performed before the MCV reached the targeted endpoint of 3 percent below baseline, at which time the ferritin level was less than 30 microg per L and the transferrin saturation was less than 30 percent. The median phlebotomy interval necessary to keep the MCV at this level during maintenance therapy was 10 weeks. No incident seroconversions for agents of transfusion-transmissible disease occurred during 1402 donations. All subjects testing positive for viral agents gave a prior history of deferrable risk. Twenty-seven months after starting the program, hemochromatosis donors were contributing 14 percent of the RBC units collected for allogeneic use.

CONCLUSIONS

Hemochromatosis subjects can safely and significantly augment the allogeneic blood supply. Provision of phlebotomy therapy unrestricted by considerations of cost or suitability for donation can improve access to care and remove incentives for incomplete risk disclosure.

Iron Deficiency and Overload

In the past seven years numerous genes that influence iron homeostasis have been discovered. Dr. Beutler provides a brief overview of these genes, genes that encode HFE, DMT-1, ferroportin, transferrin receptor 2, hephaestin, and hepcidin to lay the groundwork for a discussion of the various clinical forms of iron storage disease and how they differ from one another.

In Section I, Dr. Beutler also discusses the types of hemochromatosis that exist as acquired and as hereditary forms. Acquired hemochromatosis occurs in patients with marrow failure, particularly when there is active ineffective erythropoiesis. Hereditary hemochromatosis is most commonly due to mutations in the HLA-linked HFE gene, and hemochromatosis clinically indistinguishable from HFE hemochromatosis is the consequence of mutations in three transferrin receptor-2 gene. A more severe, juvenile form of iron storage disease results from mutations of the gene encoding hepcidin or of a not-yet-identified gene on chromosome 1q. Autosomal dominant iron storage disease is a consequence of ferroportin mutations, and a polymorphism in the ferroportin gene appears to be involved in the African iron overload syndrome.

Evidence regarding the biochemical and clinical penetrance of hemochromatosis due to mutations of the HFE gene is rapidly accumulating. These studies, emanating from several centers in Europe and the United States, all agree that the penetrance of hemochromatosis is much lower than had previously been thought. Probably only 1% of homozygotes develop clinical findings. The implications of these new findings for the management of hemochromatosis will be discussed.

In Section II, Dr. Victor Hoffbrand discusses the management of iron storage disease by chelation therapy, treatment that is usually reserved for patients with secondary hemochromatosis such as occurs in the thalassemias and in patients with transfusion requirements due to myelodysplasia and other marrow failure states. Tissue iron can be estimated by determining serum ferritin levels, measuring liver iron, and by measuring cardiac iron using the MRI-T2* technique. The standard form of chelation therapy is the slow intravenous or subcutaneous infusion of desferoxamine. An orally active bidentate iron chelator, deferiprone, is now licensed in 25 countries for treatment of patients with thalassemia major. Possibly because of the ability of this compound to cross membranes, it appears to have superior cardioprotective properties. Agranulocytosis is the most serious complication of deferiprone therapy and occurs in about 1% of treated patients. Deferiprone and desferoxamine can be given together or on alternating schedules. A new orally active chelating agent ICL 670 seems promising in early clinical studies.

In Section III, Dr. James Cook discusses the most common disorder of iron homeostasis, iron deficiency. He will compare some of the standard methods for identifying iron deficiency, the hemoglobin level, transferrin saturation, and mean corpuscular hemoglobin and compare these with some of the newer methods that have been introduced, specifically the percentage of hypochromic erythrocytes and reticulocyte hemoglobin content. The measurement of storage iron is achieved by measuring serum ferritin levels. The soluble transferrin receptor is a truncated form of the cellular transferrin receptor and the possible value of this measurement in the diagnosis of iron deficiency will be discussed. Until recently iron dextran was the only parental iron preparation available in the US. Sodium ferric gluconate, which has been used extensively in Europe for many years, is now available in the United States. It seems to have a distinct advantage over iron dextran in that anaphylactic reactions are much less common with the latter preparation.