H3K9 tri-methylation at Nanog times differentiation commitment and enables the acquisition of primitive endoderm fate

The impact of the embryonic DNA methylation program on CTCF-mediated genome regulation

During mammalian embryogenesis, both the 5-cytosine DNA methylation (5meC) landscape and three dimensional (3D) chromatin architecture are profoundly remodeled during a process known as 'epigenetic reprogramming.' An understudied aspect of epigenetic reprogramming is how the 5meC flux, per se, affects the 3D genome. This is pertinent given the 5meC-sensitivity of DNA binding for a key regulator of chromosome folding: CTCF. We profiled the CTCF binding landscape using a mouse embryonic stem cell (ESC) differentiation protocol that models embryonic 5meC dynamics. Mouse ESCs lacking DNA methylation machinery are able to exit naive pluripotency, thus allowing for dissection of subtle effects of CTCF on gene expression. We performed CTCF HiChIP in both wild-type and mutant conditions to assess gained CTCF-CTCF contacts in the absence of 5meC. We performed H3K27ac HiChIP to determine the impact that ectopic CTCF binding has on cis-regulatory contacts. Using 5meC epigenome editing, we demonstrated that the methyl-mark is able to impair CTCF binding at select loci. Finally, a detailed dissection of the imprinted Zdbf2 locus showed how 5meC-antagonism of CTCF allows for proper gene regulation during differentiation. This work provides a comprehensive overview of how 5meC impacts the 3D genome in a relevant model for early embryonic events.

Heterochromatin protein ERH represses alternative cell fates during early mammalian differentiation

During development, H3K9me3 heterochromatin is dynamically rearranged, silencing repeat elements and protein coding genes to restrict cell identity. Enhancer of Rudimentary Homolog (ERH) is an evolutionarily conserved protein originally characterized in fission yeast and recently shown to be required for H3K9me3 maintenance in human fibroblasts, but its function during development remains unknown. Here, we show that ERH is required for proper segregation of the inner cell mass and trophectoderm cell lineages during mouse development by repressing totipotent and alternative lineage programs. During human embryonic stem cell (hESC) differentiation into germ layer lineages, ERH is crucial for silencing naïve and pluripotency genes, transposable elements, and alternative lineage genes. Strikingly, ERH depletion in somatic cells reverts the H3K9me3 landscape to an hESC state and enables naïve and pluripotency gene and transposable element activation during iPSC reprogramming. Our findings reveal a role for ERH in initiation and maintenance of developmentally established gene repression.

Mitotic bookmarking redundancy by nuclear receptors in pluripotent cells

Mitotic bookmarking transcription factors (TFs) are thought to mediate rapid and accurate reactivation after mitotic gene silencing. However, the loss of individual bookmarking TFs often leads to the deregulation of only a small proportion of their mitotic targets, raising doubts on the biological significance and importance of their bookmarking function. Here we used targeted proteomics of the mitotic bookmarking TF ESRRB, an orphan nuclear receptor, to discover a large redundancy in mitotic binding among members of the protein super-family of nuclear receptors. Focusing on the nuclear receptor NR5A2, which together with ESRRB is essential in maintaining pluripotency in mouse embryonic stem cells, we demonstrate conjoint bookmarking activity of both factors on promoters and enhancers of a large fraction of active genes, particularly those most efficiently reactivated in G1. Upon fast and simultaneous degradation of both factors during mitotic exit, hundreds of mitotic targets of ESRRB/NR5A2, including key players of the pluripotency network, display attenuated transcriptional reactivation. We propose that redundancy in mitotic bookmarking TFs, especially nuclear receptors, confers robustness to the reestablishment of gene regulatory networks after mitosis.

DNA methylation restricts coordinated germline and neural fates in embryonic stem cell differentiation

As embryonic stem cells (ESCs) transition from naive to primed pluripotency during early mammalian development, they acquire high DNA methylation levels. During this transition, the germline is specified and undergoes genome-wide DNA demethylation, while emergence of the three somatic germ layers is preceded by acquisition of somatic DNA methylation levels in the primed epiblast. DNA methylation is essential for embryogenesis, but the point at which it becomes critical during differentiation and whether all lineages equally depend on it is unclear. Here, using culture modeling of cellular transitions, we found that DNA methylation-free mouse ESCs with triple DNA methyltransferase knockout (TKO) progressed through the continuum of pluripotency states but demonstrated skewed differentiation abilities toward neural versus other somatic lineages. More saliently, TKO ESCs were fully competent for establishing primordial germ cell-like cells, even showing temporally extended and self-sustained capacity for the germline fate. By mapping chromatin states, we found that neural and germline lineages are linked by a similar enhancer dynamic upon exit from the naive state, defined by common sets of transcription factors, including methyl-sensitive ones, that fail to be decommissioned in the absence of DNA methylation. We propose that DNA methylation controls the temporality of a coordinated neural-germline axis of the preferred differentiation route during early development.

Single-cell chromatin state transitions during epigenetic memory formation

Repressive chromatin modifications are thought to compact chromatin to silence transcription. However, it is unclear how chromatin structure changes during silencing and epigenetic memory formation. We measured gene expression and chromatin structure in single cells after recruitment and release of repressors at a reporter gene. Chromatin structure is heterogeneous, with open and compact conformations present in both active and silent states. Recruitment of repressors associated with epigenetic memory produces chromatin compaction across 10-20 kilobases, while reversible silencing does not cause compaction at this scale. Chromatin compaction is inherited, but changes molecularly over time from histone methylation (H3K9me3) to DNA methylation. The level of compaction at the end of silencing quantitatively predicts epigenetic memory weeks later. Similarly, chromatin compaction at the Nanog locus predicts the degree of stem-cell fate commitment. These findings suggest that the chromatin state across tens of kilobases, beyond the gene itself, is important for epigenetic memory formation.

DAXX safeguards heterochromatin formation in embryonic stem cells

Genomes comprise a large fraction of repetitive sequences folded into constitutive heterochromatin, which protect genome integrity and cell identity. De novo formation of heterochromatin during preimplantation development is an essential step for preserving the ground-state of pluripotency and the self-renewal capacity of embryonic stem cells (ESCs). However, the molecular mechanisms responsible for the remodeling of constitutive heterochromatin are largely unknown. Here, we identify that DAXX, an H3.3 chaperone essential for the maintenance of mouse ESCs in the ground state, accumulates in pericentromeric regions independently of DNA methylation. DAXX recruits PML and SETDB1 to promote the formation of heterochromatin, forming foci that are hallmarks of ground-state ESCs. In the absence of DAXX or PML, the three-dimensional (3D) architecture and physical properties of pericentric and peripheral heterochromatin are disrupted, resulting in de-repression of major satellite DNA, transposable elements and genes associated with the nuclear lamina. Using epigenome editing tools, we observe that H3.3, and specifically H3.3K9 modification, directly contribute to maintaining pericentromeric chromatin conformation. Altogether, our data reveal that DAXX is crucial for the maintenance and 3D organization of the heterochromatin compartment and protects ESC viability.