Screening a chemically defined extracellular matrix mimetic substrate library to identify substrates that enhance substrate-mediated transfection

Nonviral gene delivery, though limited by inefficiency, has extensive utility in cell therapy, tissue engineering, and diagnostics. Substrate-mediated gene delivery (SMD) increases efficiency and allows transfection at a cell-biomaterial interface, by immobilizing and concentrating nucleic acid complexes on a surface. Efficient SMD generally requires substrates to be coated with serum or other protein coatings to mediate nucleic acid complex immobilization, as well as cell adhesion and growth; however, this strategy limits reproducibility and may be difficult to translate for clinical applications. As an alternative, we screened a chemically defined combinatorial library of 20 different extracellular matrix mimetic substrates containing combinations of (1) different sulfated polysaccharides that are essential extracellular matrix glycosaminoglycans (GAGs), with (2) mimetic peptides derived from adhesion proteins, growth factors, and cell-penetrating domains, for use as SMD coatings. We identified optimal substrates for DNA lipoplex and polyplex SMD transfection of fibroblasts and human mesenchymal stem cells. Optimal extracellular matrix mimetic substrates varied between cell type, donor source, and transfection reagent, but typically contained Heparin GAG and an adhesion peptide. Multiple substrates significantly increased transgene expression (i.e. 2- to 20-fold) over standard protein coatings. Considering previous research of similar ligands, we hypothesize extracellular matrix mimetic substrates modulate cell adhesion, proliferation, and survival, as well as plasmid internalization and trafficking. Our results demonstrate the utility of screening combinatorial extracellular matrix mimetic substrates for optimal SMD transfection towards application- and patient-specific technologies.

Impact statement

Substrate-mediated gene delivery (SMD) approaches have potential for modification of cells in applications where a cell-material interface exists. Conventional SMD uses ill-defined serum or protein coatings to facilitate immobilization of nucleic acid complexes, cell attachment, and subsequent transfection, which limits reproducibility and clinical utility. As an alternative, we screened a defined library of extracellular matrix mimetic substrates containing combinations of different glycosaminoglycans and bioactive peptides to identify optimal substrates for SMD transfection of fibroblasts and human mesenchymal stem cells. This strategy could be utilized to develop substrates for specific SMD applications in which variability exists between different cell types and patient samples.

Targeted Drug Delivery via the Use of ECM-Mimetic Materials

The use of drug delivery vehicles to improve the efficacy of drugs and to target their action at effective concentrations over desired periods of time has been an active topic of research and clinical investigation for decades. Both synthetic and natural drug delivery materials have facilitated locally controlled as well as targeted drug delivery. Extracellular matrix (ECM) molecules have generated widespread interest as drug delivery materials owing to the various biological functions of ECM. Hydrogels created using ECM molecules can provide not only biochemical and structural support to cells, but also spatial and temporal control over the release of therapeutic agents, including small molecules, biomacromolecules, and cells. In addition, the modification of drug delivery carriers with ECM fragments used as cell-binding ligands has facilitated cell-targeted delivery and improved the therapeutic efficiency of drugs through interaction with highly expressed cellular receptors for ECM. The combination of ECM-derived hydrogels and ECM-derived ligand approaches shows synergistic effects, leading to a great promise for the delivery of intracellular drugs, which require specific endocytic pathways for maximal effectiveness. In this review, we provide an overview of cellular receptors that interact with ECM molecules and discuss examples of selected ECM components that have been applied for drug delivery in both local and systemic platforms. Finally, we highlight the potential impacts of utilizing the interaction between ECM components and cellular receptors for intracellular delivery, particularly in tissue regeneration applications.

Growth factors with enhanced syndecan binding generate tonic signalling and promote tissue healing

Growth factors can stimulate tissue regeneration, but the side effects and low effectiveness associated with suboptimal delivery systems have impeded their use in translational regenerative medicine. Physiologically, growth factor interactions with the extracellular matrix control their bioavailability and spatiotemporal cellular signalling. Growth factor signalling is also controlled at the cell surface level via binding to heparan sulfate proteoglycans, such as syndecans. Here we show that vascular endothelial growth factor-A (VEGF-A) and platelet-derived growth factor-BB (PDGF-BB) that were engineered to have a syndecan-binding sequence trigger sustained low-intensity signalling (tonic signalling) and reduce the desensitization of growth factor receptors. We also show in mouse models that tonic signalling leads to superior morphogenetic activity, with syndecan-binding growth factors inducing greater bone regeneration and wound repair than wild-type growth factors, as well as reduced tumour growth (associated with PDGF-BB delivery) and vascular permeability (triggered by VEGF-A). Tonic signalling via syndecan binding may also enhance the regenerative capacity of other growth factors.

Laminin-derived peptides: Applications in drug delivery systems for targeting

Recently, the development of drug delivery systems (DDSs) for clinical application of anticancer drugs and gene therapy has rapidly progressed. In particular, DDS carriers used for chemotherapy and gene therapy are required to selectively deliver drugs and genes to cancer cells. Both the carrier and the molecule must in combination be highly selective in most cases. Possible candidate targeting molecules are the laminins, major basement membrane proteins that interact with various cells through their multiple constituent active peptide sequences. Laminin-derived peptides bind to various cellular receptors and have been used for DDSs as a targeting moiety. Here, we review the progress in laminin-derived peptide-conjugated DDSs. Drug and gene carriers as well as ultrasound diagnostic contrast agents utilizing laminin-derived peptides for selective targeting are useful components of DDSs and play important roles in cancer and in the neovasculature.

Engineering liposomal nanoparticles for targeted gene therapy

Recent mechanistic studies have attempted to deepen our understanding of the process by which liposome-mediated delivery of genetic material occurs. Understanding the interactions between lipid nanoparticles and cells is still largely elusive. Liposome-mediated delivery of genetic material faces systemic obstacles alongside entry into the cell, endosomal escape, lysosomal degradation and nuclear uptake. Rational design approaches for targeted delivery have been developed to reduce off-target effects and enhance transfection. These strategies, which have included the modification of lipid nanoparticles with target-specific ligands to enhance intracellular uptake, have shown significant promise at the proof-of-concept stage. Control of physical and chemical specifications of liposome composition, which includes lipid-to-DNA charge, size, presence of ester bonds, chain length and nature of ligand complexation, is integral to the performance of targeted liposomes as genetic delivery agents. Clinical advances are expected to rely on such systems in the therapeutic application of liposome nanoparticle-based gene therapy. Here, we discuss the latest breakthroughs in the development of targeted liposome-based agents for the delivery of genetic material, paying particular attention to new ligand and cationic lipid design as well as recent in vivo advances.

Ultrasound-mediated gene delivery systems by AG73-modified Bubble liposomes

Targeted gene delivery to neovascular vessels in tumors is considered a promising strategy for cancer therapy. We previously reported that "Bubble liposomes" (BLs), which are ultrasound (US) imaging gas-encapsulating liposomes, were suitable for US imaging and gene delivery. When BLs are exposed to US, the bubble is destroyed, creating a jet stream by cavitation, and resulting in the instantaneous ejection of extracellular plasmid DNA (pDNA) or other nucleic acids into the cytosol. We developed AG73 peptide-modified Bubble liposomes (AG73-BL) as a targeted US contrast agent, which was designed to attach to neovascular tumor vessels and to allow specific US detection of angiogenesis (Negishi et al., Biomaterials 2013, 34, 501-507). In this study, to evaluate the effectiveness of AG73-BL as a gene delivery tool for neovascular vessels, we examined the gene transfection efficiency of AG73-BL with US exposure in primary human endothelial cells (HUVEC). The transfection efficiency was significantly enhanced if the AG73-BL attached to the HUVEC was exposed to US compared to the BL-modified with no peptide or scrambled peptide. In addition, the cell viability was greater than 80% after transfection with AG73-BL. These results suggested that after the destruction of the AG73-BL with US exposure, a cavitation could be effectively induced by the US exposure against AG73-BL binding to the cell surface of the HUVEC, and the subsequent gene delivery into cells could be enhanced. Thus, AG73-BL may be useful for gene delivery as well as for US imaging of neovascular vessels.

Nonviral gene delivery systems by the combination of bubble liposomes and ultrasound

The combination of therapeutic ultrasound (US) and nano/microbubbles is an important system for establishing a novel and noninvasive gene delivery system. Genes are delivered more efficiently using this system compared with a conventional nonviral vector system such as the lipofection method, resulting in higher gene expression. This higher efficiency is due to the gene being delivered into the cytosol and bypassing the endocytosis pathway. Many in vivo studies have demonstrated US-mediated gene delivery with nano/microbubbles, and several gene therapy feasibility studies for various diseases have been reported. In addition, nano/microbubbles can deliver genes site specifically by the control of US exposure site. In the present review, we summarize the gene delivery systems by the combination of nano/microbubbles and US, describe their properties, and assess applications and challenges of US theranostics.

Ultrasonically triggered drug delivery: breaking the barrier

The adverse side-effects of chemotherapy can be minimized by delivering the therapeutics in time and space to only the desired target site. Ultrasound offers one fairly non-invasive method of accomplishing such precise delivery because its energy can disrupt nanosized containers that are designed to sequester the drug until the ultrasonic event. Such containers include micelles, liposomes and solid nanoparticles. Conventional micelles and liposomes are less acoustically sensitive to ultrasound because the strongest forces associated with ultrasound are generated by gas-liquid interfaces, which both of these conventional constructs lack. Acoustically activated carriers often incorporate a gas phase, either actively as preformed bubbles, or passively such as taking advantage of dissolved gasses that form bubbles upon insonation. Newer concepts include using liquids that form gas when insonated. This review focuses on the ultrasonically activated delivery of therapeutics from micelles, liposomes and solid particles. In vitro and in vivo results are summarized and discussed. Novel structural concepts from micelles and liposomes are presented. Mechanisms of ultrasonically activated release are discussed. The future of ultrasound in drug delivery is envisioned.

Contribution of syndecans to lipoplex-mediated gene delivery

The long awaited breakthrough of gene therapy significantly depends on the in vivo efficiency of targeted intracellular delivery. Hidden details of cellular uptake present a great hurdle for non-viral gene delivery with liposomes. Growing scientific evidence supports the involvement of polyanionic cell surface carbohydrates in cellular internalization of cationic liposomes. Syndecans, a highly conserved family of transmembrane heparan sulfate proteoglycans serve attachment sites for great variety of cationic ligands including growth factors, cytokines and even parasites. In the present study we quantitatively measured the contribution of various syndecan isoforms to liposome-mediated gene transfer. The obtained data show the superiority of syndecan-4, the ubiquitously expressed isoform of the syndecan family, in cellular uptake of liposomes. Applied mutational analysis demonstrated that gene delivery could be abolished by mutating the glycosaminoglycan attachment site of syndecans, highlighting the importance of polyanionic heparan sulfate side chains in the attachment of cationic liposomes. Blocking sulfation of syndecans also diminished gene delivery, a finding that confirms the essential role of polyanionic charges in binding cationic liposomes. Mutating other parts of the syndecan extracellular domain, including the cell-binding domain, had clearly smaller effect on liposome internalization. Mutational analyses also revealed that superiority of syndecan-4 in liposome-mediated gene delivery is significantly influenced by its cytoplasmic domain that orchestrates signaling pathways leading to macropinocytosis. In summary our study present a mechanistic insight into syndecan-mediated macropinocytic uptake of lipoplexes and highlights syndecan-4 as a superior target for cationic liposomes.

Laminin-111-derived peptides and cancer

Laminin-111 is a large trimeric basement membrane glycoprotein with many active sites. In particular, four peptides active in tumor malignancy studies have been identified in laminin-111 using a systematic peptide screening method followed by various assays. Two of the peptides (IKVAV and AG73) are found on the α1 chain, one (YIGSR) of the β1 chain and one (C16) on the γ1 chain. The four peptides have distinct activities and receptors. Since three of the peptides (IKVAV, AG73 and C16) strongly promote tumor growth, this may explain the potent effects laminin-111 has on malignant cells. The peptide, YIGSR, decreases tumor growth and experimental metastasis via a 32/67 kD receptor while IKVAV increases tumor growth, angiogenesis and protease activity via integrin receptors. AG73 increases tumor growth and metastases via syndecan receptors. C16 increases tumor growth and angiogenesis via integrins. Identification of such sites on laminin-111 will have use in defining strategies to develop therapeutics for cancer.

Involvement of Ca²⁺ and ATP in enhanced gene delivery by bubble liposomes and ultrasound exposure

Recently, we reported the accelerated gene transfection efficiency of laminin-derived AG73-peptide-labeled polyethylene glycol-modified liposomes (AG73-PEG liposomes) and cell penetrating TAT-peptide labeled PEG liposomes using PEG-modified liposomes, which trap echo-contrast gas, "Bubble liposomes" (BLs), and ultrasound (US) exposure. BLs and US exposure were reported to enhance the endosomal escape of AG73-PEG liposomes, thereby leading to increased gene expression. However, the mechanism behind the effect of BLs and US exposure on endosomes is not well understood. US exposure was reported to induce an influx of calcium ions (Ca²⁺) by enhancing permeability of the cell membrane. Therefore, we examined the effect of Ca²⁺ on the endosomal escape and transfection efficiency of AG73-PEG liposomes, which were previously enhanced by BLs and US exposure. For cells treated with EGTA, the endosomal escape and gene expression of AG73-PEG liposomes were not enhanced by BLs and US exposure. Similarly, transfection efficiency of the AG73-PEG liposomes in ATP-depleted cells was not enhanced. Our results suggest that Ca²⁺ and ATP are necessary for the enhanced endosomal escape and gene expression of AG73-PEG liposomes by BLs and US exposure. These findings may contribute to the development of useful techniques to improve endosomal escape and achieve efficient gene transfection.

Probing the interaction between heparan sulfate proteoglycan with biologically relevant molecules in mimetic models for cell membranes: a Langmuir film study

Investigating the role of proteoglycans associated to cell membranes is fundamental to comprehend biochemical process that occurs at the level of membrane surfaces. In this paper, we exploit syndecan-4, a heparan sulfate proteoglycan obtained from cell cultures, in lipid Langmuir monolayers at the air-water interface. The monolayer served as a model for half a membrane, and the molecular interactions involved could be evaluated with tensiometry and vibrational spectroscopy techniques. Polarization-modulation infrared reflection-absorption spectroscopy (PM-IRRAS) employed in a constant surface pressure regime showed that the main chemical groups for syndecan-4 were present at the air-water interface. Subsequent monolayer decompression and compression showed surface pressure-area isotherms with a large expansion for the lipid monolayers interacting with the cell culture reported to over-express syndecan-4, which was also an indication that the proteoglycan was inserted in the lipid monolayer. The introduction of biological molecules with affinity for syndecam-4, such as growth factors, which present a key role in biochemical process of cell signaling, changed the surface properties of the hybrid film, leading to a model, by which the growth factor binds to the sulfate groups present in the heparan sulfate chains. The polypeptide moiety of syndecan-4 responds to this interaction changing its conformation, which leads to lipid film relaxation and further monolayer condensation.

Local gene delivery system by bubble liposomes and ultrasound exposure into joint synovium

Recently, we have developed novel polyethylene glycol modified liposomes (bubble liposomes; BL) entrapping an ultrasound (US) imaging gas, which can work as a gene delivery tool with US exposure. In this study, we investigated the usefulness of US-mediated gene transfer systems with BL into synoviocytes in vitro and joint synovium in vivo. Highly efficient gene transfer could be achieved in the cultured primary synoviocytes transfected with the combination of BL and US exposure, compared to treatment with plasmid DNA (pDNA) alone, pDNA plus BL, or pDNA plus US. When BL was injected into the knee joints of mice, and US exposure was applied transcutaneously to the injection site, highly efficient gene expression could be observed in the knee joint transfected with the combination of BL and US exposure, compared to treatment with pDNA alone, pDNA plus BL, or pDNA plus US. The localized and prolonged gene expression was also shown by an in vivo luciferase imaging system. Thus, this local gene delivery system into joint synovium using the combination of BL and US exposure may be an effective means for gene therapy in joint disorders.